Disarticulating the Biopolitical Aporia Through Wonder As the Earth is reframed as a vulnerable body in the Anthropocene, power shifts focus, modalities of interventions and goals, in order to reconstruct its legitimacy (challenged in the Anthropocene where all modern political certainties have been ‘irrevocably disturbed’) and to remain productive (Matthews 2019, p. 3). From a sovereign mode that appropriates and exploits the Earth and its resources, law, through biopolitics, must enter into a protective mode, caring for vulnerable bodies, fostering their capacity, enhancing their productivity. Yet biopolitics remains inevitably underpinned by an epistemology of mastery and often needs, to be operationalized, the sovereign command. Sovereignty in fact, while diminished or even dormant in a legal framework that focuses on the biopolitical notions of conservation and sustainability (De Lucia 2017a), rather than on exploitation, stands ready to be re-activated when a forceful intervention is needed to discipline recalcitrant nature. This continuous risk of transformation from a biopolitics of care to a biopolitics of death, with all its attendant sovereign choices as to who can live and who must die, is the core dilemma of this biopolitical shift. Esposito speaks in this respect of a constitutive dilemma of biopolitics, a ‘never-released tension’, a ‘lacerating effect’ (Esposito 2008, p. 32) that accompanies it, as the two poles of its articulation—life and politics—are engaged in an inevitable and insoluble struggle. The effects of this struggle are that life is caught in what Agamben calls the ‘zone of irreducible indistinction’; that is, a site where inclusion and exclusion, law and violence, life and death, the political form of life endowed with rights and the bare life which can be killed with impunity, are inextricably linked (Agamben 1998, p. 12). And it is here, in this zone of indistinction, that the protection and enhancement of life is continuously at risk of becoming, or perhaps always already is, the subjection and subjugation of life. It is here, in this zone of indistinction, that biopolitics and sovereignty find their most intimate connection. How can we then escape this dilemma, this continuous transformation of a politics of life into a politics of death? How can we resist the biopolitical enframing of the vulnerable Earth? How can we resist the total subsumption of nature under a legal power that cares? How can we break out from the continuous biopolitical oscillations between care and subjugation? Is it possible to retain the positive inflection of biopolitics without the subjugating elements? Is encaring (that is, a single gesture that simultaneously cares and enframes) inevitable in a biopolitical regime? One way is perhaps to recognize how the complexities of the Anthropocene elude ‘the possibility of “solving” it’ (Petersmann 2020). In this respect, biopolitics reflects precisely a non-negotiable entanglement of all life with death. It is not a problem that can be solved. However, the distribution of life and death, in all its complexity, can and should be problematized. Aesthetics may offer in this regard a way forward that remains attuned to such complexity. As Matthews has observed, in fact ‘one of the greatest challenges that the Anthropocene thesis poses is an aesthetic one’ (Matthews 2019, p. 3). The Anthropocene urges us to problematize how we sense the world around us, through what sensibilities (Petersmann 2020), and through what ‘modes of perception’ (Matthews 2019, p. 3). And here it is important to recover the broad semantic field of aesthetics (De Lucia 2016; Matthews 2019), which Matthews evokes, with a contrasting purpose, through the term aesthesis (Matthews 2019). This reactivated semantic field speaks of intellect and discernment as well as, importantly, of awareness and perception—a sort of ‘non-cognitive porosity’ of the body, in the words of Anna Grear (De Lucia 2016). Sensing, in this broad meaning, thus becomes a crucial dimension for thinking differently about/beyond the Anthropocene. Sensing, perception, awareness: these all require something to sense, to perceive, to be aware of; they require a relation. Although the mode of relation that is required to disarticulate the biopolitical aporia is of a special kind. Here Tolkien, as mediated and elaborated by Patrick Curry, may be of help, through the concept of wonder. Tolkien distinguishes between two ways of entertaining a relationship with the world: magic and wonder (or, better, enchantment, though I prefer the term wonder as it does not resonate with a Weberian discourse). Magic entails the wilful exercise of power with the purpose of domination; it enacts a singular relational stance to the world; and is firmly anchored in a centre from which, and for whose benefit, the world can be controlled and manipulated (Curry 2012, p. 76). Tolkien describes magic as a ‘technique’ that ‘produces, or pretends to produce, an alteration in the [world]’ in order to ‘dominat[e] things and wills’ (Tolkien 2001, p. 53). Magic coerces. Magic is thus aligned with the modern epistemology of mastery and facilities its continuous and relentless transformation into domination (Leiss 1994). In this respect, it is easy to see the continuity between magic and science, as observed by Curry: As a matter of philosophical, practical and historical fact, these two [magic and science] share extensive common ground—much more than what divides them. The principal goal of both is to engineer changes in the […] world, and both try to amass knowledge in order to predict and control that world; both adhere to the idea of laws of nature which can be manipulated for human gain. That those laws are spiritual or occult in the case of magic and material in the case of science is a point of ultimately secondary importance. (Curry 1999, p. 402) Further, as Curry still emphasizes, ‘science never rejected the occult – literally what is hidden’, but rather ‘redefined it’ (Curry 2019, p. 21). Magic is thus central to the project of modernity; is central to the exploitation of nature and the epistemology of mastery. However, magic remains also crucial once nature has been discursively reframed as vulnerable, for the biopolitical project of Earth-care, though it now underpins and enables an epistemology of care. Biopolitics in fact must know before it can regulate and ultimately care, and as such, it needs to engulf the planet, as we have seen, in its panopticist frameworks of surveillance and control. It needs to envelop the world with magic. And law is utterly dependent on this knowledge for its regulatory web to be laid on the world for its protection (De Lucia 2017b, 2018, 2019a). And this is precisely one of the mechanics through which biopolitics and sovereignty jointly operate, and through which the positive inflection of biopolitics inevitably becomes a subjugating framework of control: in order to care you need to know, and to know you need to engulf, surveil, predict. In this way, care is continuously transformed into subjugation, and only through subjugation is it possible to care. However, just as much as biopolitics is inevitably caught in the continuous process of transformation of care into subjugation, an inner tension exists between the mode of knowing we have described as magic—epistemology—and what can be described, by contrast, as the mode of knowing of wonder—which is rather an aesthetics, in the sense explained just above. Wonder, as a mode of encountering the world, is premised on relational diversity. Indeed, wonder requires a gap between each party of the relationship, over which they can meet (Curry 2019, p. 13). This encounter, in turn, ‘creates a “third thing”, something new in the world: a metaphorical you-and-me, or a this-but-also-that’ (Curry 2019, p. 13). This is crucial: wonder eschews equally hyper-separation and total unity, it is a mobile, tentative and oscillating relation that does not settle once and for all, but negotiates the tension aesthetically, through what Curry, following Keats, calls ‘negative capability’ (ibid, p. 16). Wonder thus requires the capability of ‘being in uncertainties, mysteries, doubts’ (ibid, p. 16). Additionally, and this is a crucial aspect of the relational world of wonder, there is no centre in wonder, or, rather, the centre exists between the ‘two or more parties, and thus cannot simply be occupied by any one of them’ (Curry 2019, p. 15). As Curry observes, when it comes to wonder, ‘no one is in charge’ (ibid). Wonder, unlike magic, is a way to enter into a relationship in a non-coercive fashion (Curry 2012, p. 76). Wonder, thus, is ‘distinct from will’ (ibid). Finally, the parties of the wonder-full relation need not be humans—wonder puts into relation all sort of beings, things, places and even ideas (Curry 2019, p. 24), thanks to their diversity. Wonder, through its centre-less relational modality, through its way of knowing which is an entering-into-relation, may help chart a novel trajectory that does not take sides but remains, firmly, in the middle (as urged by Philippopoulos-Mihalopoulos 2011), navigates on the cusp, on the edge of the threshold, balancing without falling, yet without certainty. But what does this mean for law? How does this wonder-full, as it were, relational aesthetics help rethink the encounter between law and nature? My argument, which will be articulated in the next section, is that thinking through wonder may help chart a novel trajectory for the classical tradition of natural law. Through wonder, once again though differently, law is in the nature of things (Villey 1969), that is, in the middle of this relational world. Here it is however important to note the crucial distinction between the classical framework of natural law, which I am connecting with and re-activating, and the modern, rationalist school of natural law. In the classical school of natural law, which finds its roots in the pragmatic legal consciousness of ancient Rome, and further links with Aristotle’s notion of particular justice (Villey 2003, p. 78ff), there is no eternal, fixed law proceeding from the will of god or from the dictates of reason. Indeed, natural law is one of a multiplicity of co-existing legal orders. This natural law returns to law as an art (rather than a technique) and does not have a centre—there is no privileged subject, will, or god. As a relation, it is a measure, and is tensive, historically situated, alive, uncertain, negotiable and contestable. It is, indeed, somewhat ‘wild and unbiddable’ (Curry 2019, p. 15) like wonder, and requires, like classical natural law, a prudential and flexible approach to contingency (Villey 2001, p. 160). It is a law that, perhaps best denoted as jus, is sensed.