2023
GDI
Counterplan
States CP › 2NC Solvency O/V › Wages
Neumark, Chancellor’s Professor of Economics and Director of the Center for Economics & Public Policy, University of California, Irvine, Muz, Ph.D. candidate, University of California, Irvine., ‘13
[David, Jennifer, April 15, 2013, FRBSF Economic Letter, “Job Growth and Economic Growth in California,” https://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=a9h&AN=87063358&site=ehost-live&scope=site., Accessed 07/08/2023, BS]
Economic growth at the state level is commonly measured using overall state economic output, or gross state product (GSP). We look at inflation-adjusted, or real, GSP to avoid the effects of rising prices. And we consider real GSP on a per capita basis to measure the growth in economic resources per person, rather than growth that comes from a rising population. In assessing whether a single state’s economic performance is strong or weak, it makes sense to compare performance across states because business cycles affect the whole nation. We compare California’s performance with the rest of the United States, and with other western states, including Alaska, Arizona, Colorado, Hawaii, Idaho, Montana, Nevada, New Mexico, Oregon, Utah, Washington, and Wyoming. Figure 1 shows growth in real per capita GSP for California, the western states excluding California, and the United States, excluding California but including the District of Columbia. Since the early 1990s, real GSP growth in California has followed a more distinct cyclical pattern than in the western region or the rest of the United States. Overall, California’s economic growth was only slightly lower than that of other states. Of course, economic output in all three areas fell during the Great Recession from 2007–09. For the whole sample period 1990 to 2011, California ranked 29th in output growth, meaning that 22 states had lower growth and 28 had higher growth. If we exclude the Great Recession and consider data only through 2007, California’s growth compares more favorably with that of other states, ranking 19th. Thus, excluding the Great Recession, California’s economic growth outpaced about 60% of states in the nation. Still, each of the three recessions of the past 20 years—for different reasons—have been more severe in California than in the rest of the nation.Our second measure of a state’s economic health is job growth. To measure it, we use data collected from employers through the Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages (QCEW) conducted by the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. The QCEW data provide a reliable measure of job growth over the long term because they capture nearly all employment in the U.S. economy, not just a sample. Figure 2 shows California employment growth relative to that in the rest of the United States and the western region. Comparing it with Figure 1, it is evident that job growth largely mirrors output growth. However, the figures also show that, unlike output growth, job growth in California lagged behind the United States and the rest of the western region during the mid-2000s boom. This implies that, to some extent, overall economic output spurted ahead in California during this period without the usual accompanying increase in jobs. A similar pattern is also apparent in the late 1990s when California’s output boom was much more pronounced than its jobs boom.
Looking at job growth over the entire 1990 to 2011 period provides more evidence for this pattern. In contrast to GSP growth, California’s job growth was relatively anemic compared with that in other states. For the whole period, only 11 states had slower job growth. This pattern holds even if we look at the data only through 2007. Only 12 states reported slower job growth. Thus, California was in the bottom quarter of states for job growth, but near the median for output growth.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
States CP › 2NC Solvency O/V › Wages
VerBruggen, Editor for National Review and fellow at Manhattan Institute , ‘21
[Robert, 3/8/2021, National Review,, “Minimum-Wage Complexities,” https://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=a9h&AN=148761436&site=ehost-live&scope=site , Accessed 07/07/2023, BS]
DEMOCRATS are moving fast to advance some of their biggest policy goals under the guise of COVID-19 relief. One of their most contentious proposals is to increase the minimum wage to $15 an hour by 2025, with the phase-in beginning this year.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
States CP › 2NC Solvency O/V › Bargaining Power
Hays, Professor of Law, Columbia University School of Law, 1954
[Paul R., Jun. 1954, University of Pennsylvania Law Review, “Federalism and Labor Relations in the United States,” https://www.jstor.org/stable/3309892, Accessed 07/09/2023, BS]
There are also basic problems which may be called sociological.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
States CP › 2NC Solvency O/V › Bargaining Power
Inman, Professor, Finance, Economic and Public Policy, Wharton School, Univerwity of Pennsylvania, Rubinfeld, Professor of Law, NYU, ‘14
[[Robert P., Daniel L., 2014, Oxford Handbook of Law and Economics, forthcoming, “ECONOMICS OF FEDERALISM,” , Accessed 06/09/2023, BS]
Cooperative Federalism
2023
GDI
Counterplan
States CP › 2NC Solvency O/V › Inflation
Karabell, TIME author, investor and commentator, Expada, reporter at TIME. Kohli, reporter at TIME, ‘22
[Zachary, Mariah and Anisha name, 11/7/2022,, TIME Magazine, “A PAINLESS INFLATION FIX,” https://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=a9h&AN=159888949&site=ehost-live&scope=site., Accessed 07/3/2023, BS]
The Fed's moves represent a broad consensus that high inflation imperils the stability of the system, erodes living standards, and must be brought down even at the risk of squashing growth and triggering a recession., The lack of doubt by the Fed, most economists, and many businesses about what the problem is and what to do about it is a troubling sign of economic group think. In short, the Fed is making an epic mistake. It should not have done what it has done, should not be doing what it's doing, and should not do what it plans to do. Past mistakes can't be undone, but future ones can be avoided. Group think is standing in the way. There is, of course, inflation right now, in the U.S. and in most countries throughout the world. There's also broad agreement about what caused this inflation: too much government spending as the pandemic began subsiding in the spring of 2021; too much pent-up demand from pandemic lockdowns exploding in the summer of 2021 onward, which created massive supply- chain bottlenecks and demand for labor; too much easy money from global central banks that kept assets such as stocks and homes elevated; too little action from the Fed until it was too late; and Russia's invasion of Ukraine leading to a doubling or more of the price of oil and gas.The belief that this period of inflation is so dangerous that it is worth the price of squashing the strongest job and wage market in a generation has taken hold in almost every central bank and every government in the developed worldBUT THAT LEAVES one rather crucial question: is it true? Must central banks take aggressive measures to cool the labor market, dampen financial markets, and likely cause a recession? Is it a fact that waiting longer would lead to elevated levels of inflation becoming intractable and entrenched? If you listened to what the Fed and many economists are saying, you'd hardly be aware that this has been a two-year period unlike any other. You'd think today is a normal and regrettable bout of too much money, too much demand, and high wages. That is not the case. This time it's different. Inflation as a statistic measures year-over-year price increases, which means that until October, all the high inflation was relative to depressed economic activity caused by pandemic shutdowns. Inflation started to rise in May 2021, with a reading of 5%, rose to 7.5% as markets began anticipating the disruptive energy effects of the Ukraine war, then accelerated to 9.1% before moderating over the past months to 8.2%.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
States CP › 2NC Solvency O/V › Labor/Unemployment
Haim, MS Economic Theory and Policy., 2021
[Daniel, January 2021, Levy Economics Institute, “What Jobs Should a Public Job Guarantee Provide?Lessons from Hyman P. Minsky,” , Accesed 07/02/23, BS]
INTRODUCTION Instability and with it what Orwell called “the haunting terror of unemployment” is the damning weakness of capitalism. (Minsky 2008b, 329) Following the COVID-19 pandemic, governments around the world have started to implement far-reaching social policies to alleviate the effects of what is set to become the largest economic recession since World War II (World Bank 2020). A public job guarantee is among the ideas that have garnered renewed interest in the United States and abroad. India’s Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme has helped push rural joblessness down to 7.3 percent in June 2020, with 33 million households benefitting from the scheme in May 2020 (Times of India 2020). In the United States, Congresswomen Bonnie Watson Coleman (D-NJ) and Ilhan Omar (D-MN) have announced the introduction of the Workforce Promotion and Access Act (WPA Act 2020). Their proposal calls for the US Department of Labor to establish a job guarantee for states, localities, and tribal entities where the unemployment rate is greater than 10 percent or double the national unemployment rate. Public support for a job guarantee has been high, even before the current crisis, with approval ratings of up to 78 percent among US voters (The Hill 2019).
2023
GDI
Counterplan
States CP › 1NC EITC UBI Module
Downey, Legal Impact Network at the Shiver Center, Staff Attorney, et al., 22
(Nolan, Jeremy Rosen, Shiver Center staff, Marie Claire Tran-Leung, Shiver Center staff, Michelle Nicolet, Shiver Center staff, Emily Coffey, Shiver Center staff, Marcus Samuel, Shiver Center staff, Dina Kostrow, Shiver Center staff, Gabriela Camargo Martins, Economic Security Project staff, Michael Conti, Economic Security Project staff, Andrea Diaz, Economic Security Project staff, Pedro Morillas, Economic Security Project staff, Madeline Neighly, Economic Security Project staff, April 2022, Shiver Center on Poverty Law, and Economic Security Project, “States Lead the Way in Reimagining the Social Safety Net”, , Accessed 7-2-23, ED)
State Considerations:
2023
GDI
Counterplan
States CP › 1NC FJG Half Guarantee Module
Newman, writer and professor who teaches criminal justice and sociology at CUNY. , 2021 (Nathan, Reset Labor Markets With a Local Half-Time Job Guarantee, 09-21-21 accessed 07-13-23)-TL
In the wake of the Covid recession, state and local governments have the chance to remake local labor markets—and public assistance—by adopting a policy guaranteeing half-time employment at $15 an hour for every resident.
Despite the hype of supposed proliferating job openings, long experience shows that even if we approach rates of nominal “full employment” again, such statistics will inevitably ignore higher unemployment rates for Black, Latino, formerly incarcerated, and many other workers. In a Covid-based recession where women in particular have struggled to return to previous levels of employment, a job guarantee may be critical to restore real employment alternatives for everyone who wants a job.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
States CP › 1NC Shell - Generic
McNichol, Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, Senior Fellow, 16
(Elizabeth, 12-15-16, Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, “How State Tax Policies Can Stop Increasing Inequality and Start Reducing It”, , Accessed 7-2-23, ED)
The income tax is the one major state revenue source that typically reduces inequality, but many states have weak income tax systems that do too little in this regard. A graduated-rate income tax, which taxes higher incomes at higher rates, affects high-income families more than low-income families, and in a few states this balances out the effects of sales and property taxes. But many state income taxes are flat (meaning all income is taxed at the same rate) or nearly flat, and a few states don’t have an income tax. As a result, some states do much more than others to reduce inequality through their tax codes.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
AFF Answers › Links 2 PTX DA
Glaser, mechanical engineer and former president of the International Solar Energy Society, 8 [Interview with Dr. Peter Glaser, by William Ledbetter, past president of the NSS of North Texas, Spring 08, Ad Astra, “Space Based Solar Power” , accessed 7-4-11]
AD ASTRA: In light of the growing demand for dwindling hydrocarbons and the dangerous increases of greenhouse gases, do you think that the world is now primed to seriously consider space-based power systems? GLASER: No, because people can still get gas for their cars too easily. Those in the top levels of science and government know what is coming, but the average man on the street will not care unless it impacts his wallet. That is the biggest problem. The basic approach is unchanged from my initial concept. We could have built this system 30 years ago. The technology just keeps getting better. The design and implementation is a small problem compared to the much larger obstacle of getting people to understand the potential benefits. Building such a system could provide cheap and limitless power for the entire planet, yet instead of trying to find a way to make it work, most people shrug it off as being too expensive or too difficult. Of course existing energy providers will fight, too. It only makes sense that coal and oil lobbies will continue to find plenty of reasons for our representatives in Congress to reject limitless energy from the sun.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
AFF Answers › Links 2 Econ DA
Cyranoski 9 (David, Asia-Pacific Correspondent, Nature, Vol. 462, Iss. 7272, pg 398-99, ProQuest)JFS
The goal is to make satellites for under ¥1 trillion (US$11 billion) each; it currently costs 100 times that. "It's exciting, but there are many problems to overcome," says Naoki Shinohara of Kyoto University. For one thing, transmission efficiency must rise to 75%, he says; the airship experiment achieved just 40% efficiency, although the technology it uses differs from what a satellite would use. Rocket launches will also need to be cut to a hundredth of their current cost; options such as reusable rockets are being considered, according to Susumu Sasaki of the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA). At this month's meeting, Tokyo University's Kimiya Komurasaki discussed how a remote microwave source could power rockets. That would reduce the amount of propellant they need to carry and, in theory, mean that rockets used to build a solar-power satellite could carry more antennas and solar cells. Matsumoto estimates that it will take ¥2 billion to ¥3 billion to demonstrate solar-power satellite technology on the ground, and ¥10 billion to ¥50 billion to demonstrate it in orbit.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
AFF Answers › Links 2 Econ DA
Hall 8 (David, Director @ Public Services International Research Unit, Business Scholl @ U of Greenwich, www.psiru.org/reports/2008-11-PPPs-crit.doc)JFS [note: PPP is public private partnership]
But the construction element of PPP projects is much more expensive. An EIB report compared the cost of PPP road projects across Europe with conventionally procured road projects, and found that the PPPs were on average 24% more expensive than the public sector roads. 72 In 2007 the Polish government cancelled a motorway PPP for exactly this reason: they realised that the A1 Motorway from Grudziadz-Torun could be built for about €5.6m. per kilometre using conventional procurement, compared with €7.4m. per km. using the PPP. 73 The EIB report also notes that this premium of 24% is about the same as estimates of cost overruns on public procurement projects, and so the extra cost of PPP projects reflects the payment required by the contractor to accept construction risk.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
AFF Answers › Energy Beaming Fails
Vasile 9 (Massimilanto, engineering@U of Glasgow, October 21, , accessed: 26 June 2011, JT)
All structures larger than the internal dimension of launcher fairings need to follow some sort of deployment or assembly process in space. This can range form the most common and probably best studied process of deploying solar panels, to formation flying and docking and human/robotic assisted assembly of separately launched modules. For very large, in-homogenous and very complex structures such as the space stations MIR and ISS, astronauts have proven to still be unrivalled due to human flexibility and ingenuity. Human presence however requires much higher safety standards and mission complexity. Due to the limited and costly access of humans to space, the construction of space stations lasts usually many years. The construction of space station MIR lasted over ten years: The construction of the International Space Station has started in 1998, is currently about 80% completed but will be fully assembled only in 2011 according to current plans. It will then have a mass in excel of 400 metric tons, compared to the 125 tons of space station MIR. Even if augmented by the use of robotic assistants, this approach is tedious, expensive and lengthy and represents a serious barrier to space applications that require or would benefit from very large structures.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
AFF Answers › Energy Beaming Fails
Collins & Matsuoko 4 (Patrick and Hideo, co-founder of Space Future Consulting and Prof Teikyo Heisei University, Int. Conf. on Solar Power From Space, Dec, http://articles.adsabs.harvard.edu//full/2004ESASP.567..213M/0000213.000.html accessed 6-26-11, CH)
Work by the engineers designing the SPS 2000 system has led to the assessment that the project's largest risk is the technical risk arising from relying on 100% automatic deployment of the satellite. Since it is not uncommon even today for satellites to suffer a failure in the deployment of an antenna or solar panel, the probability of a problem arising with the automatic deployment of a 200 ton satellite some 300 metres in dimensions, and comprising several different payloads which are to dock autonomously, must be assessed as much higher. Indeed, unless this risk can be reduced very substantially, it seems unlikely that this project could be selected for funding as such.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
AFF Answers › Energy Beaming Fails
Day, American space historian and policy analyst and served as an investigator for the Columbia Accident Investigation Board, 8 [Dwayne A., 6-9-8, Space Review, “Knights in Shining Armor” , accessed 6-30-11]
The NSSO study is remarkably sensible and even-handed and states that we are nowhere near developing practical SSP and that it is not a viable solution for even the military’s limited requirements. It states that the technology to implement space solar power does not currently exist… and is unlikely to exist for the next forty years. Substantial technology development must occur before it is even feasible. Furthermore, the report makes clear that the key technology requirement is cheap access to space, which no longer seems as achievable as it did three decades ago (perhaps why SSP advocates tend to skip this part of the discussion and hope others solve it for them). The activists have ignored the message and fallen in love with the messenger
2023
GDI
Counterplan
AFF Answers › Can’t Solve Warming
Collins et al 4 (Patrick, co-founder of Space Future Consulting, 4th International Conference on Solar Power, Space, July, , accessed 6-26-11, CH)
Even when assuming that the development and installation of space-based solar power systems proceeds as planned, there is still the time risk. SPS may - aside others - well be a solution to ease the burden of human energy consumption on the environment. Yet. potential benefits from SPS require a long lead-time at inherently higher risks due to its technical state-of-the-art. There are two resulting risk pathways: the risk of omission and the risk of misdirected investment. Either society decides to proceed on a business-as-usual basis until 2030 when SPS is finally up and running - then there is the risk of facilitating climate change, air pollution etc.; or society decides to facilitate investments in terrestrial renewable energies and energy savings in order to environmentally benefit as fast as possible - then the risk is that there is no longer a market demand for SPS.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
AFF Answers › Readiness DA
Sherman 99 (Robert, Federation of American Scientists, http://www.fas.org/spp/military/docops/afwa/U2.htm AQB)
The desire to go to higher frequencies was caused by the need for longer range, higher capacity circuits. Until HF came about, transatlantic communication was by cable or mail. Cable systems were very limited in capacity and sending messages was extremely expensive; mail was rather slow. With HF radio, transatlantic communication became faster, had greater capacity, and was less expensive. From this point in history to the present, radio technology increased dramatically. World War II had a profound impact on the use of the radio-frequency spectrum. Military leaders realized higher capacity communications were needed. Naturally, the solution was to go to even higher frequency bands. During the early part of the war, a system called radar was developed. The development of components and equipment to operate at the higher radar frequencies led to the development of higher frequency radio systems. Developments during the war led to the development of very high frequency (VHF) and ultrahigh frequency (UHF) radio systems. Along with these systems came the idea of line-of-sight (LOS) microwave and tropospheric (TROPO) scatter systems. Unfortunately, it was found that using these higher frequency bands caused the distance range to be shorter than with HF. So until the late 1950s, long-range radio communication had to remain in the HF band, even with its limitations. With the advent of the space program, radio engineers realized they could now get long-range communications at the higher frequencies by using satellites as radio relay stations. Thus came the development of satellite communications systems. Today, practically all of our long-range communication goes through satellite links. Since the first communications satellite was placed in orbit, satellites have been thought of as "the" communications system. However, as seen from a military viewpoint, satellite systems and most other radio systems have some weaknesses. Because higher frequency systems have weaknesses associated with their method of radio-wave propagation, lower frequency systems are taking on more importance. Studies and experiments have indicated that if there is a nuclear blast, most if not all of our higher frequency systems would be adversely affected. Since the military always requires communications, low frequency (LF), very low frequency (VLF), and extremely low frequency (ELF) communications systems have been undergoing development since the early 1960s.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
AFF Answers › Readiness DA
Laracy et al. 7 (Joseph, Complex Systems Research Laboratory MIT, Damien Baldor, Lean Aerospace Initiative MIT, Danielle Adams, Aeronautics/Astronautics & Technology & Policy Program MIT, & Annalisa Weigel Asst. Prof @ MIT, http://lean.mit.edu/docman/view-document-details/1702-solar-power-satellites-historical-perspectives-with-a-look-to-the-future.html AQB)
Atmospheric side effects were a large concern. The most sensitive issues dealt with the ionosphere, a layer between 50 and 400 km from the Earth’s surface. Concerns arose regarding the ability of the microwave power beam from the SPS to heat the ionosphere sufficiently to alter its electron density. This would harm communication systems that depend on dense electron regions. This could also lead to undesirable scattering in the microwave beam path. The rocket effluents from the SPS launches could also interact with the ionosphere to reduce electron density. Another fear was that weather could be altered in the troposphere due to the exhaust of frequent launches. This is an area of large uncertainty.30 A major concern about the SPS design was its potential for interference with other electronic systems. As mentioned in the CDEP Final Program review, “Electromagnetic systems likely to experience SPS interference would include military systems, public communications, radar, aircraft communications, public utility and transportation system communications, other satellites, and radio and optical astronomy.”31 Such a long and varied list clearly puts this issue into the realm of a serious social problem. In particular, military systems close to the transmitter or receiver would be threatened. Also, radio and optical astronomy would be very difficult with an SPS system in place. For radio astronomy, Earth based systems close to receiving antenna sites would be affected by interference. Meanwhile, optical astronomy would be limited because the SPS would create light pollution.32
2023
GDI
Counterplan
AFF Answers › Launches DA
Goodwin et al 1 (Anna, University of Bristol, http://www.priweb.org/ed/ICTHOL/ICTHOLrp /82rp.htm, 6-25-11, AH)
The Permian-Triassic boundary extinction was the largest extinction the world has ever experienced. About 90 percent of all species vanished in this mass extinction 250 million years ago. Approximately 85% of all marine species and 70% of all terrestrial species went extinct in less than one million years. By studying the species which became extinct at this time, the rate at which they became extinct, and the regions of the Earth in which the greatest extinction occurred ,hypotheses about possible methods for the cause of extinction have been devised. There are many theories which have been developed to understand this historic mass extinction. One theory is the formation of a super-continent which caused a reduction of shallow continental shelves. Such a reduction in oceanic continental shelves would result in ecological competition for space, perhaps acting as an agent for extinction. However, although this is a viable theory, the formation of Pangaea and the ensuing destruction of the continental shelves occurred in the early and middle Permian, and mass extinction did not occur until the late Permian Impact from an extraterrestrial object is a common theory for the explanation of this extinction. The collision wasn't directly responsible for the extinction but rather triggered a series of events, such as massive volcanism and changes in ocean oxygen, sea level and climate. Those in turn led to species extinction on a wholesale level. The collision would either weaken or kill much of the life that thrived during this time. Dust clouds and CO2 in the atmosphere would have caused major climate changes for the species and make it unsuitable for them to thrive. Evidence of increased levels of atmospheric levels of CO2 exists in the fossil record. Glaciation is also a viable theory. Simultaneous glaciation events on the north and south poles could have caused rapid warming and severe climatic fluctuations. Intemperate zones, there is evidence of significant cooling and drying in the sedimentological record, shown by thick sequences of dune sands and evaporites, while in the polar zones, glaciation was prominent. This caused severe climatic fluctuations around the globe, and is found by sediment record to be representative of when the Permian mass extinction occurred. Another theory is volcanism. Basaltic lava eruptions in Siberia were large and sent a quantity of sulphates into the atmosphere. Evidence in China supports that these volcanic eruptions may have been silica-rich, and thus explosive, a factor that would have produced large ash clouds around the world. The combination of sulphates in the atmosphere and the ejection of ash clouds may have lowered global climatic conditions. The age of the lava flows has also been dated to the interval in which the Permian mass extinction occurred. Other than changes in atmospheric carbon, No other evidence exists for this theory. Scientists are working to precisely date volcanic ash from Permian fossil reefs in Texas and China. This will provide a kind of timeline for the extinction to build a global database of extinction for the Permian Age, which species died, where they died and when they died. This too will help him determine the timing of the extinction in more detail and highlight gaps in the fossil record that may be distorting palaeontologists' understanding of when various organisms went extinct and how rapidly they did so. Lastly , a new theory has been proposed - the Supernova explosion. A supernova occurring 30 light years away from earth would release enough gamma radiation to destroy the ozone layer for several years. Subsequent exposure to direct ultra-violet radiation would weaken or kill nearly all existing species. Only those living deep in the ocean will be secured . Sediments contain records or short-term ozone destruction-largeamounts of NOx gasses and C14 plus “global and atmospheric cooling.” With sufficient destruction of the ozone layer, these problems could cause widespread destruction of life.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
AFF Answers › Launches DA
UCSUSA 2 (Union of Concerned Scientists, 10-24, http://www.ucsusa.org/global_environment /archive/page.cfm?pageID=551, 6-25-11, AH)
The solid rocket strap-on motors used in the most powerful space launch systems -- the US space shuttle and the Titan IV, as well as the European Ariane V -- produce copious amounts of HCl and possibly other reactive chlorine-containing exhaust products. Since these strap-on motors burn well into the stratosphere, a significant fraction of their exhaust gases is deposited there. The plume from each launch causes a temporary "mini" ozone hole, although since space launch trajectories are slant paths, the ozone depletion is not stacked up over a single surface point. Current launch levels are so low that the stratospheric chlorine injected by space launches is only a few tenths of a percent of that due to halocarbon decomposition. But if more frequent space launches occur in the future, care should be taken to design more stratospherically benign rocket propulsion systems for both US and foreign launch systems.