Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Kritik
Universalism Aff › Universalism Good- Solves Paternalism and Exclusion

UBI and FJG are examples of universalism that lessen racial inequality by benefiting all, and avoid paternalism and exclusions associated with past policies.

Klein, ANU Canberra Public Policy Lecturer & Fouksman, King’s College Social Justice Lecturer, 22 [Edward & Elizaveta, 11/21/2021, Development and Change, Volume 53, Issue 1, January “Reparations as a Rightful Share: From Universalism to Redress in Distributive Justice] https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/dech.12695 Accessed 7/2/2023, PE]

REDISTRIBUTORY UNIVERSALISM AND REPARATIONS FOR SLAVERY IN THE UNITED STATES

Calls for reparations for slavery and racially based dispossession and discrimination have a long history in the United States, dating back to the early years of European colonization and the triangular trade (Brooks, 2004), and encompass a broad variety of proposals, justifications and forms.5 Many of the arguments for race-based reparations in the US focus not only on the two and a half centuries of slavery in the US, but also on the economic ramifications of racial discrimination in the centuries after the formal end of slavery, which range from Jim Crow segregation laws to discriminatory housing policy, as well as the current racialized mass incarceration system (see for instance Darity, 2008). Advocates of targeted reparations based on race in the US point out that the roots of the US's current wealth lie not only in White democracy and institutions making up what Mills (1997) calls ‘the racial contract’, but also in ‘black plunder’ (Coates, 2014).6

2023 GDI Kritik
Universalism Aff › AT: Global Reparations Alt

There are massive logistical hurdles for global reparations, and it risks reinforcing Western-centric forms of global governance.

Klein, ANU Canberra Public Policy Lecturer & Fouksman, King’s College Social Justice Lecturer, 22 [Edward & Elizaveta, 11/21/2021, Development and Change, Volume 53, Issue 1, January “Reparations as a Rightful Share: From Universalism to Redress in Distributive Justice] https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/dech.12695 Accessed 7/2/2023, PE]

All these points of resistance to reparations underscore a deep discomfort about the underlying challenges to the West's own myths about modernization and Western progress, which have justified inequality, power and domination (Biondi, 2003). However, problems remain around the concrete ways reparations would function in post-independence contexts. For example, if not development assistance and aid, then what mechanisms could be used to facilitate material redress to people? Would this material redress be made available to individuals via something like a global UBI, or as payments to nation states? If payments were made directly to individuals via a global UBI, would this be focused exclusively around former empire economies paying dividends to individuals in the majority world? Would more recently wealthy countries, such as South Korea, also contribute to this reparative global UBI? And how would such a mechanism connect with people that are stateless, or diaspora dispersed because of colonialism and slavery? Finally, how can the ‘transfer effect’ outlined by Darity et al. (2010) be avoided: that is, how can the majority world avoid reinvesting reparations payments back into structures that benefit its former colonizers?

Some scholars have proposed the idea of a redistributive fund administered by a global organization such as the United Nations, to act in part as a form of reparative justice (Blackburn, 2011; Pogge, 2008). Yet cosmopolitan mechanisms such as the UN system have themselves been critiqued for their risk of becoming supra-global mechanisms that reproduce coloniality via Western-centric and top-down designs of development, democracy and economic growth (inclusive or otherwise). Walter Mignolo (2000: 742) argues that the problem for cosmopolitanism models is how to ‘focus on the coloniality of power and the colonial difference produced, reproduced, and maintained by global designs’. But these challenges are not insurmountable, and considerations as to what decolonial options are available for administering direct reparations beyond the nation state boundaries could be pursed further. Claims for reparations for colonialism continue to be important. They offer pathways not only towards redress for the past, but also for radically altering global distribution in the present. In the words of Tan (2007: 284):

2023 GDI Kritik
Universalism Aff › AT: Immigration Links

Basic income would be available to everyone in the U.S. including undocumented immigrants – welfare precedent proves availability, but basic income is more efficient boosting solvency – states bridge any remaining gap

James Davis ’16, September 21, “Reconciling UBI with Immigration Concerns,” BIEN, https://basicincome.org/news/2016/09/reconciling-ubi-immigration-concerns/#:~:text=Depending%20on%20implementation%2C%20a%20UBI,stamps%20on%20their%20children%27s%20behalf

Depending on implementation, a UBI policy may slightly increase or decrease aid to the families of illegal immigrants. Although immigrants illegally residing in the U.S. are generally ineligible to receive welfare, illegal immigrants are permitted to apply to receive food stamps on their children’s behalf. A UBI equal to the value of the food stamps the family would have otherwise received should be the preferred policy. Various states already have their own forms of supplementary assistance for illegal immigrants in addition to food stamps: these states could bridge any perceived gaps by offering the same assistance they do now.

Lawful, non-citizen residents, such as students, exchange visitors and foreign workers, are eligible for certain welfare transfers depending on their circumstances. Current laws also require waiting periods and point systems for noncitizens to become eligible for Supplemental Security Income (SSI) transfers. These rules could be maintained to alleviate concerns that noncitizens would take advantage of the UBI: as it stands now, non-citizens receive substantially less welfare transfers than their citizen counterparts. Essentially, a UBI would end up looking very similar to the SSI – the general idea would be to have fewer onerous requirements on how welfare dollars are spent.

2023 GDI Kritik
Universalism Aff › Permutation- Targeted Universalism

UBI Plus would provide reparations for those in disadvantaged communities.

Warren, Fellow at the Roosevelt Institute, 2017 [Dorian, 5/3/17, Boston Review, “Reparations and Basic Income,” https://www.bostonreview.net/forum_response/dorian-t-warren-reparations-and-basic-income/, 7/3/23, PE]

Brishen Rogers is right that a basic income will not solve all of the problems created by the political economy of American capitalism. It will not magically solve the collective action problem among workers and the powerless vis-à-vis corporate power. But most proponents do not see it as a magic bullet. Many of us see it as one of several elements in a reimagined twenty-first-century social contract that provides economic security for all. And we get there via different political and strategic routes. Futurists and technologists come to the basic income idea via technology and automation. Libertarians come to basic income from arguments around efficiency and reducing the size of the state. Progressives come to basic income from a concern around non-domination, freedom, and redistributive justice. Universal PLUS Basic Income would function as reparations in a grand bargain with white America. I come to basic income from a very different political tradition: black politics with a focus on race and political economy. It is this tradition that led both Martin Luther King, Jr., and the Black Panther Party to argue for full employment and a “guaranteed income” fifty years ago. Though they wanted these specifically for African Americans, they hoped they would be made available to all Americans. Five decades later it is about time the rest of us caught up to their vision. Black workers today face the exact same dual crisis of high unemployment and low-wage work that they did fifty years ago. The black unemployment rate is twice that of white workers at nearly every level of education. Thus one need not be only concerned with future trends to speculate that a basic income would help black Americans today, especially those who continue to be locked out of access to labor markets. Rogers is spot on to warn us that basic income could be “designed to serve white nationalist ends.” We know this from our own historical experience. Seemingly “universal” social policies, from the New Deal to the Great Society, have had intended and unintended consequences of maintaining or exacerbating existing racial and gender inequalities. Many supposedly “universal” policies ultimately were not. But Rogers’s rightful skepticism and warning about a white nationalist basic income comes down to a question of political power. President Franklin D. Roosevelt compromised on his New Deal programs because southern Democrats insisted on it. The race-based occupational exclusions of agricultural and domestic workers were ultimately included in Social Security, the National Labor Relations Act, and the Fair Labor Standards Act to appease political elites protecting the southern Jim Crow racial and economic regime over the protests of racial justice organizations. Black workers were excluded as a result of this previous iteration of white nationalism and populism. But advocates for a truly universal social policy did not give up, eventually winning racial inclusion in Social Security but not the other two major New Deal policies. Similarly we should not limit our political imaginations about the promise of a basic income because of the very perilous questions around race, immigration, and exclusion. Quite the opposite. We should imagine a robust basic income that advances racial and gender justice while simultaneously addressing the ills of twenty-first-century capitalism. I have argued that a basic income in all but a few forms—those that exclude the incarcerated or result in a net decrease in benefits—would benefit African American communities for the following reasons. First, it would provide an individual-sustaining basic floor for returning citizens caught up in the criminal justice system. Second, even an equal income could disproportionately benefit black Americans. White Americans earn more overall, so a greater percentage of their basic income would be taxed back. More importantly today’s wealthiest Americans benefit either directly from African Americans’ disadvantaged position in our political economy, or indirectly as a result of the cumulative benefits to our nation from centuries of exploiting black bodies. Black Americans either helped build the co-owned wealth of our nation (our infrastructure and banking, legal, and patent systems) or were denied access to our share of it (land, sky, and other natural resources). Even if African Americans receive an income equal to whites, tapping wealth hoarded by racist means and distributing it universally effectively amounts to targeted redistribution. Third, a basic income would be an improvement on portions of today’s current safety net. Some benefits, such as food stamps, are replete with paternalistic restrictions that rest on racist tropes about recipients and their consumption habits. Others, such as the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC), are significantly tied to work, which is problematic when structural racism continues to create so many barriers to black employment. A basic income lacks these flaws. A campaign around U+BI could create political will within black communities and across racial and ethnic divides in America. The underlying assumption around welfare and entitlement reform has been that racial minorities do not want to work and that existing social policies provide “disincentives” to work. Basic income fundamentally decouples work from the economic right to basic needs and arguably bolsters individual-level bargaining power in the labor market. It also, by virtue of its universality, is less likely to be viewed as a program solely to benefit one racial or ethnic group. For sure, racialized attacks on cash grants will continue, but progressives are in a stronger position arguing for a universal program, knowing that it will in fact benefit African Americans greatly. There is, in fact, a model of basic income which is not only acceptable but preferable to common proposals: the Universal PLUS Basic Income. It is identical to most basic income proposals but includes a pro-rated additional amount for black Americans over a specified period of time. The Universal PLUS Basic Income draws on the concept of “targeted universalism” in designing social policies. Such a proposal would take into account the historical and cumulative disadvantages of income, wealth, and inheritance afflicting black communities, and it would recognize that potential changes in the nature of work will disproportionately hurt black Americans. It would effectively function as reparations in a grand bargain with white America: all would benefit, but those who suffered through slavery and continuing racism in the economy would benefit slightly more. Most importantly a campaign around a racially inclusive basic income is a potential opportunity for creating the political will within black communities and across racial and ethnic divides in American politics. Rogers, after all, suffers from the same limited theory of change with which he charges libertarian basic income supporters. How and under what conditions will the political will for his broad public sector program to advance economic security and human flourishing be created? Yes, there have been incredible victories by fast food, retail, and farm workers over the past decade to advance worker power, and these efforts are necessary but not yet sufficient to win national labor law reform. But public opinion around economic redistribution has always been higher among black Americans relative to the rest of the population, and initial polling and focus groups around support for a basic income in the United States suggests this pattern still holds. Thus a U+BI proposal could become a bridge to the increasingly salient demand for reparations and reinvestment emerging from the Movement for Black Lives. And, if nothing else, it serves as a stronger starting progressive bargaining position in political fights over basic income. We are not yet at a moment to argue beyond basic income. We have to build the campaign to win it first.

2023 GDI Kritik
Universalism Aff › Permutation- Targeted Universalism

Demands for UBI framed in the context of reparations has transformative potential

Oliver, Pitzer college President, & Shapiro, Brandeis U Institute of Assets and Social Policy Director, 2019 [Melvin & Thomas, 3/7/19, Contexts, Volume 18, Issue 1, Winter, Pages 16-21, https://doi.org/10.1177/1536504219830672, “Disrupting the Racial Wealth Gap,” Accessed 7/8/23, EP]

Universal Basic Income (UBI) has been receiving renewed interest, funding, pilots, organizational support, and media attention (see Calnitsky, this issue). In theory, at least, individuals would receive one-quarter of the national domestic product per capita, which in the United States translates to about $1,200 a month. This is marginally above the official poverty line for one person. Currently in the United States, Canada, and other countries, various UBI designs are being tested, typically none at the full UBI level. Stockton, California’s UBI has received the most coverage. That pilot program involves a small group of families receiving $500 a month for 18 months, with no strings attached. Advocates from various perspectives are enthusiastic about UBI’s impact on work narratives, poverty alleviation, remedy for automation and artificial intelligence, gender equality, and framing public wealth as its prime funding source. Sovereign wealth funds such as the Alaska Permanent Fund, which utilizes a slim part of the common wealth of oil revenues, are exemplars of common and public wealth. Skeptics focus on UBI’s drag on work and employment, inflationary impact, meager redistributive potential, and removing financial incentives to work.

A brief examination of potentially disruptive, transformative policy ideas moves us closer on how to link economic equality and racial justice to social mobility and poverty alleviation.

2023 GDI Kritik
Universalism Aff › Permutation- Targeted Universalism

Cash transfers that combine universal basic income and additional targeted reparations is an effective demand that disrupts patterns of accumulation and social advantages.

Táíwò, Georgetown University Assistant Philosophy professor, 2022 [Olúfẹ́mi, 1/10/22, Boston Review, “The Fight for Reparations Cannot Ignore Climate Change, “, , 7/3/23, EP]

Contemporary demands for reparations have rightly kept focus on this tactic. In stark contrast to the byzantine social support systems that have come to characterize modern social democracies, social scientists are beginning to embrace “unconditional cash transfers”—simply giving people money directly. These kinds of transfers will intervene directly in the patterns of accumulation, one of our most adaptable forms of social advantages. It also avoids the problems with other welfare programs: the sprawling (and questionably efficacious) overhead, the paternalistic attempts to further shape people’s incentives, and the “poverty traps” caused by aid withdrawal once a recipient crosses some threshold of income or welfare. Furthermore, the ethos of the unconditional cash transfer matches self-determination as a goal for reparations policies, which is part and parcel of the constructive view.

In their recent book From Here to Equality: Reparations for Black Americans in the Twenty-First Century (2020), economist William A. Darity, Jr., and scholar A. Kirsten Mullen endorse a strategy rooted in direct payments to African Americans descended from those enslaved in the United States, disbursed over time rather than all at once (to prevent inflation) and via trust funds and endowments. Moreover, it would be governed by a National Reparations Board that enlists its recipients in research about and decisions over the funds, further bolstering a commitment to an outcome of self-determination. Scholar and organizer Dorian Warren of the Economic Security Project has suggested that we adopt a strategy rooted in “targeted universalism”—a universal basic income for all, plus an additional amount for African Americans to account for the owed reparations. These proposals have been discussed in the context of U.S. politics, but others have suggested a global universal basic income, which could be weighted in the targeted way that Warren suggests. Both of these are exactly the kind of demands we should want to win.

2023 GDI Kritik
Universalism Aff › Permutation- Targeted Universalism

Targeted Universalism is an effective strategy to resist racial capitalism’s race AND class based dispossession.

Klein, ANU Canberra Public Policy Lecturer & Fouksman, King’s College Social Justice Lecturer, 22 [Edward & Elizaveta, 11/21/2021, Development and Change, Volume 53, Issue 1, January “Reparations as a Rightful Share: From Universalism to Redress in Distributive Justice] https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/dech.12695 Accessed 7/2/2023, PE]

However, the issue of targeting on the basis of race in order to repair the damage done by slavery and post-slavery racial discrimination still remains. Warren's proposed solution is to establish what he terms U+BI (universal plus basic income). This is a form of targeted universalism, where a basic income is both universal, and there is an additional top up which is targeted towards racial minorities, and explicitly framed as reparations for slavery and racism. Warren's proposal for a U+BI as reparations, and his explicit tying together of UBI and reparations, raises a number of questions. Why adopt an explicitly universal policy such as UBI as part of the case for reparations, which are meant to explicitly target communities damaged by specific historical occurrences? Warren never directly addresses this question, but perhaps the inclusion (with modifications) of UBI within the Movement for Black Lives agenda points to unstated support for other advantages of a universal rightful share, in particular the justice-based arguments for universal ownership of collective wealth (see for instance Birnbaum, 2016; Sloman, 2018; Van Parijs, 1992). The proposal of U+BI also raises the question of whether this would be a true UBI, and if the ‘plus’ would undermine some of the advantages of universalism. In particular, if historically benefits targeted at disadvantaged groups have frequently been inferior to universal benefits and enjoyed lower levels of support, a U+BI might have the same disadvantage, which a UBI would avoid. Ultimately, this case asks: can a distributory policy framed as a rightful share be both reparative and universal at the same time?

A conceptual framework that provides some fruitful avenues into reconciling these tensions is the writing around racial capitalism. The study of racial capitalism underscores the ways in which race and capitalism have been historically — and continue to be currently — co-created and intertwined (Robinson, 1983), with slavery and ongoing racial dispossession as a key example.10 In the words of Jodi Melamed, capitalist ‘accumulation requires loss, disposability, and the unequal differentiation of human value, and racism enshrines the inequalities that capitalism requires’ (Melamed, 2015: 77). As such, scholars of racial capitalism point out that a focus on class, race or colonialism alone is insufficient to understand both the way capitalism has been constituted and the way it continues to operate today. Instead, race and racialization emerged both out of slavery and colonialism and also out of dispossession and proletarianization, and in turn racialized conceptions of social hierarchies enabled class-based exploitation and dispossession. This was not simply imposed by the ‘West onto the Rest’ (Hall, 1992: 275) in a ‘singular axis of power of colonized/colonizer’ (Virdee, 2019: 6), but also occurred within the West itself. An example of this is the way the Catholic Irish were racialized in industrial England in order to subdivide the working class and channel workers’ disaffection into racialized hierarchies (Robinson, 1983). Thus, alongside the racialization of non-European and colonized populations, which was used to justify both colonial conquests and slavery, came the racialization of parts of Europe, which was used to justify further exploitation.

2023 GDI Kritik
Universalism Aff › Permutation- Targeted Universalism

A racially inclusive UBI plus reparations policy advances justice while also securing a stronger political bargaining position.

Warren, Roosevelt Institute Fellow, 2017 [Dorian, December 10 2017, Economic Security Project, “A Universal Basic Income +,” https://economicsecurityproject.org/news/a-universal-basic-income/, July 3 2023, ah]

Yet just 5 miles from here, either west or south, 2 out of 3 black kids are born into, and grow up in poverty. I believe that is wrong and Un-American.

Two of the most unpopular ideas in American political discourse: UBI and reparations.

2023 GDI Kritik
Universalism Neg › Impacts › Impacts- Reject Racism

Reject racism as an implicit ethical contract- violence and destruction is inevitable if any degree of racism is accepted.

Memmi, 2k [2000, Albert is a Professor Emeritus of Sociology @ Unv. Of Paris, Albert-; RACISM, translated by Steve Martinot, pp.163-165]

The struggle against racism will be long, difficult, without intermission, without remission, probably never achieved, yet for this very reason, it is a struggle to be undertaken without surcease and without concessions. One cannot be indulgent toward racism. One cannot even let the monster in the house, especially not in a mask. To give it merely a foothold means to augment the bestial part in us and in other people which is to diminish what is human. To accept the racist universe to the slightest degree is to endorse fear, injustice, and violence. It is to accept the persistence of the dark history in which we still largely live. It is to agree that the outsider will always be a possible victim [and which [person] man is not [themself] himself an outsider relative to someone else?]. Racism illustrates in sum, the inevitable negativity of the condition of the dominated; that is it illuminates in a certain sense the entire human condition. The anti-racist struggle, difficult though it is, and always in question, is nevertheless one of the prologues to the ultimate passage from animality to humanity. In that sense, we cannot fail to rise to the racist challenge. However, it remains true that one’s moral conduct only emerges from a choice: one has to want it. It is a choice among other choices, and always debatable in its foundations and its consequences. Let us say, broadly speaking, that the choice to conduct oneself morally is the condition for the establishment of a human order for which racism is the very negation. This is almost a redundancy. One cannot found a moral order, let alone a legislative order, on racism because racism signifies the exclusion of the other and his or her subjection to violence and domination. From an ethical point of view, if one can deploy a little religious language, racism is “the truly capital sin.”fn22 It is not an accident that almost all of humanity’s spiritual traditions counsel respect for the weak, for orphans, widows, or strangers. It is not just a question of theoretical counsel respect for the weak, for orphans, widows or strangers. It is not just a question of theoretical morality and disinterested commandments. Such unanimity in the safeguarding of the other suggests the real utility of such sentiments. All things considered, we have an interest in banishing injustice, because injustice engenders violence and death. Of course, this is debatable. There are those who think that if one is strong enough, the assault on and oppression of others is permissible. But no one is ever sure of remaining the strongest. One day, perhaps, the roles will be reversed. All unjust society contains within itself the seeds of its own death. It is probably smarter to treat others with respect so that they treat you with respect. “Recall,” says the bible, “that you were once a stranger in Egypt,” which means both that you ought to respect the stranger because you were a stranger yourself and that you risk becoming once again someday. It is an ethical and a practical appeal – indeed, it is a contract, however implicit it might be. In short, the refusal of racism is the condition for all theoretical and practical morality. Because, in the end, the ethical choice commands the political choice. A just society must be a society accepted by all. If this contractual principle is not accepted, then only conflict, violence, and destruction will be our lot. If it is accepted, we can hope someday to live in peace. True, it is a wager, but the stakes are irresistible.

2023 GDI Kritik
Universalism Neg › Impacts › Impacts- Prioritize Fighting White Supremacy

Center white supremacy over other impacts – its is the root cause of environment, climate, economic crisis

Dyer 12

(Herbert Dyer Jr. is an African American writer in Chicago with a masters degree from Governors State University in Political & Justice Studies, April 28, “Redemption of the White Liberal”, Dissident Voice, http://dissidentvoice.org/2012/04/redemption-of-the-white-liberal/)

The foremost reality that white liberals must understand and then deal with is that every square inch of land, every lake, river and stream, every mountain, field, every blade of grass or grain of desert sand that they proudly refer to as the “United States of America” is stolen property – stolen from a people who rarely, if ever, warrant even a back-handed mention in today’s socio-economic and political discourse. This terrible reality lies at the bottom of a continent-wide and unimaginably deep sea of red blood which separates the two blue eastern and western oceans. By now they must be aware of the magnitude and meaning of such an unconscionable atrocity. Hell, at some level they’ve always known; but do they care? White liberals must go further, though. They must understand that the reason Chicago, New York City, Philadelphia, Houston, San Francisco, New Orleans, St. Louis, etc., ad infinitum, sport such high and gleaming alters to capitalism is because the raw materials and laborers used in their construction were ripped from the soil and souls of Black, Brown, Red and Yellow peoples not only here but from throughout the world. The white liberal must understand that those villages, countries, nations and nation-states are labeled and defined by them as “Third World”, “underdeveloped”, “developing” because it was and remains white supremacy and their embrace thereof that put and keep them there. Appalling numbers of white liberals are in deep denial of the unfathomable pain, suffering, and death that the pursuit of white supremacy has wrought. Yes, their denial is appalling but completely understandable. They labor under a grand form of “cognitive dissonance” which exquisitely defines the term. I have wondered often that had I been born “white”, how utterly impossible it would be, must be, to simply look into a mirror knowing how much innocent blood lay behind my reflection, my history. Absolute denial and rejection of that blood, of that reflection and history would be the only means of maintaining even a semblance of sanity. On another level, though, many, perhaps a majority, of white liberals appreciate quite clearly what they have done. Indeed, they celebrate and gleefully swim in that bloody sea of denial, ever thankful for their whiteness and their conscientious and well-meaning liberalism. This set of white liberals eagerly embraces their unearned privileges and power and protect themselves and their whiteness behind world-destroying weapons, multi-million-man armies – or “gated” enclaves. Their fear is understandable as well for they have much to fear, going all the way back to, and starting with, Indian attack and slave revolt. Black folks know very well that all white people are not knowingly white supremacist in their worldview and daily lives. That is, there are now and always have been some “good” white folks – those few who fought and died alongside Blacks at various stages of history against white supremacy. The problem is, however, that the good have never outnumbered the bad. The “good” white people have never constituted the majority of white people. And, somehow it seems that when it comes to Black folks, some sort of “compromise” must always be made in order that white supremacy remains supreme. Finally, what can and must white liberals do to redeem themselves, their people? The time has long passed for any more perfunctory “national discussion of race” between whites and Blacks. There is nothing more to talk about. White people, including white liberals, invented “race”, racism and white supremacy. They must begin the redemption process by disavowing and denouncing the validity, legitimacy of each of these self-serving and pernicious concepts and ideologies. They must first acknowledge, recognize and accept their guilt. Then repent. Repentance can take many forms, but it must be holistic, all encompassing, just as holistic and encompassing as the past 500 years of white supremacy have been. White liberals must teach each other and their children the unvarnished history of this nation-state. They must begin and see through to the end the hard work of dismantling all of the covert and overt institutional structures and scaffolds which have framed and perpetuated a white racial consciousness and its attendant white supremacist practices for the last 25 generations. They must teach themselves and their children that the number one problem in the world has been, is, and remains Europe’s and America’s Original Sin: white supremacy – not global warming nor environmental degradation, not the national debt/deficit, not gay rights, not the energy crisis, and not women’s liberation – but white supremacy. In doing so, they will discover that these other “issues” are but symptoms and byproducts of the most debilitating disease that has afflicted the whole of mankind since those first Europeans began rampaging across the seas circa 1444.

2023 GDI Kritik
Universalism Neg › Alternative › Alt Solvency- Reparations Movement Good

STATUS QUO reparation movements are stuck in liberal schemes like redemption. But the alt doesn’t assume reparations is something to be materially achieved but uses reparations as a weapon to precipitate a crisis in American institutionalist can transforms the social order.

Hartman and Wilderson 3 (THE POSITION OF THE UNTHOUGHT. Author(s): Saidiya V. Hartman, Prof of Comp Lit @ Columbia, Frank B. Wilderson, Prof at UC Irvine, Source: Qui Parle, Vol. 13, No. 2 (Spring/Summer 2003), pp. 183-201. Published by: University of Nebraska Press)

S. VH. - And I think the underlying question is, "Where do we go from here?" F. W - Is that leading us to reparations? S.VH. - Yes. I've been thinking about the notion of focusing one's appeal to the very state that has inflicted the injury. The reparations movement puts itself in this contradictory or impossible position, because reparations are not going to solve the systemic ongoing production of racial inequality, in material or any other terms. And like inequality, racial domination and racial abjection are produced across generations. In that sense, reparations seem like a very limited reform: a liberal scheme based upon certain notions of commensurability that reinscribe the power of the law and of the state to make right a certain situation, when, clearly, it cannot. I think too that such thinking reveals an idealist trap; it's as if once Americans know how the wealth of the country was acquired, they'll decide that black people are owed something. My God! Why would you assume that? Like housing segregation is an accident! I think that logic of "if they only knew otherwise" is about the disavowal of political will. Why is the welfare state dismantled, even though it's actually going to affect more white women and children than black people? Because it has to do with that political will and an antipathy to blackness that structures .. . FW. - That structures institutions. And your work on empathy shows that; it helps us to understand how important blackness is to the libidinal economy of white institutionality. Now, I think I'm fair in generally characterizing the reparations debate and those who've renewed it - Randall Robinson and company - by saying that they got a tiger by the tail, and then didn't want the tiger to do its thing.29 The reparations people present the issue to blacks as though slavery is an essentially historical phenomenon that ended, but the effects of which put blacks at what they call, you know, "an unfair disadvantage" to those in other positions who are also chasing the American dream. Through such a move the reparations folks literally waste a political weapon, they dull the knife, they keep the tiger in the cage, because here is a weapon which could spew forth in untold directions: I'm thinking here of Nat Turner's greatest night. Instead, that weapon is a denuded or, maybe a policed method of conveyance. They're trying to simultaneously mobilize and manage black rage. If reparations were thought of not as something to be achieved, but as a weapon that could precipitate a crisis in American institutionality, then it could be worked out a lot differently from the way it's presented. One could present a reparations agenda in the way in which you present your book, dealing with the despotism of black positionality as it moves from generation to generation, from historical moment to historical moment - with despotism being the almost ahistorical constant. Unleash the tiger and let it do its thing. S. VH. -- At the very least that would entail a transformation of the social order.

2023 GDI Kritik
Universalism Neg › Alternative › Alt Solvency- Reparations Movement Good

Reparations are more than a “handout”—it is the start to the reimagination of a new country that leads to a spiritual renewal of past injustices

TA-NEHISI COATES, June 2014, Ta-Nehisi Coates is a national correspondent for The Atlantic, where he writes about culture, politics, and social issues., “The Case for Reparations”, The Atlantic,

And so we must imagine a new country. Reparations—by which I mean the full acceptance of our collective biography and its consequences—is the price we must pay to see ourselves squarely. The recovering alcoholic may well have to live with his illness for the rest of his life. But at least he is not living a drunken lie. Reparations beckons us to reject the intoxication of hubris and see America as it is—the work of fallible humans. Won’t reparations divide us? Not any more than we are already divided. The wealth gap merely puts a number on something we feel but cannot say—that American prosperity was ill-gotten and selective in its distribution. What is needed is an airing of family secrets, a settling with old ghosts. What is needed is a healing of the American psyche and the banishment of white guilt. What I’m talking about is more than recompense for past injustices—more than a handout, a payoff, hush money, or a reluctant bribe. What I’m talking about is a national reckoning that would lead to spiritual renewal. Reparations would mean the end of scarfing hot dogs on the Fourth of July while denying the facts of our heritage. Reparations would mean the end of yelling “patriotism” while waving a Confederate flag. Reparations would mean a revolution of the American consciousness, a reconciling of our self-image as the great democratizer with the facts of our history.

2023 GDI Kritik
Universalism Neg › Alternative › Alt Solvency- Reparations Movement Good

Reparations are a radical transformation and reimagining of society. Only the act of dreaming and being involved in the fight for reparations can attempt to eliminate violence such as rampant poverty from black communities

Robin D. G. Kelley, Published in 2002, Robin is a frequent contributor to The New York Times, is a professor of history and Africana studies at New York University. “Freedom Dreams”, pg 129-134

If we think of reparations as part of a broad strategy to radically transform society—redistributing wealth, creating a democratic and caring public culture, exposing the ways capitalism and slavery produced massive inequality—then the ongoing struggle for reparations holds enormous promise for revitalizing movements for social justice. Consider the context: For at least the last quarter century we have witnessed a general backlash against the black community. As I argued in Yo’ Mama’s Disfunktional! (1997), Republican and Democratic administrations dismantled most state protections for poor people of color, expanded the urban police state, virtually eliminated affirmative action and welfare as we knew it, and significantly weakened institutions and laws created to protect civil rights. All these cutbacks were justified by a discourse that blamed black behavior for contemporary urban poverty and turned what were once called “rights” (i.e., welfare) into “privileges.” The argument for reparations not only recasts these measures as rights but as payback. It shows how more than two centuries of U.S. policy facilitated accumulation among white property owners while further impoverishing African Americans. Thus federal assistance to black people in any form is not a gift but a down payment for centuries of unpaid labor, violence, and exploitation. We need not go all the way back to slavery to make the case. We can point to more than a century of discrimination to explain the myriad ways U.S. policies have enriched upper- and middle-class whites at the expense of black people and other people of color (and we’ve already looked at housing policies). Let us take just one example: education. During Reconstruction, African Americans led the fight for free universal public education in the United States, not just for themselves but for everyone. After being barred from reading and writing while in bondage, newly freed people regarded education as one of the most basic rights and privileges of citizenship. Education was so important, in fact, that they were willing to pay for public schools or start their own. In South Carolina, for example, freed people contributed nearly thirteen thousand dollars to keep twenty-three schools running, schools that had been established by the Freedmen’s Bureau. Indeed, between 1866 and 1870, newly freed people contributed more than three-quarters of a million dollars in cash to sustain their own schools. Once African Americans won the franchise, they made it possible for universal compulsory education to be written into state constitutions throughout the South. They also elected black legislators who succeeded in establishing boards of education and requiring compulsory education with “no distinction to be made in favor of any class of persons.” In South Carolina in 1868, black and progressive white legislators made sure textbooks were provided free of charge, and within two years close to sixteen thousand black children and eleven thousand white children attended public schools. As soon as the federal government withdrew its support for Reconstruction and the Southern planter class and New South industrialists imposed formal segregation, black students were relegated to inferior schools and denied full attendance. Rural schools for blacks, for example, often operated only a few weeks out of the year. And yet black wage earners continued to pay taxes to support public education. In the Jim Crow South it was not unusual for African Americans to contribute 40 percent of the school budget but attend schools that received 10 percent of the expenditures. One study conducted by researchers at Atlanta University in 1901 concluded that black taxpayers were actually subsidizing white schools. More recently, two years after the Supreme Court ordered desegregation of schools in 1954, the state of Virginia introduced publicly funded school vouchers to help white families send their children to private schools rather than endure integration. The vouchers were eventually deemed unconstitutional, but during that short period of time African American taxes were being used to help pay for white children’s private-school tuition. In light of how our separate and unequal education has benefited whites and cost African Americans, claims that affirmative action is “reverse discrimination” or a “special privilege” ring hollow at best. The reparations movement exposes the history of white privilege and helps us all understand how wealth and poverty are made under capitalism—particularly a capitalism shaped immeasurably by slavery and racism. It stresses the fact that labor— not CEOs, not scientists and technicians, not the magic of the socalled free market—creates wealth. The reparations movement provides an analysis of our situation that challenges victim-blaming explanations, explaining that exploitation and regressive policies create poverty, not bad behavior. It ought to compel us to pay attention to the centrality of racism in the U.S. political economy, because one of the consequences of racial differentials in income and economic opportunity is downward pressure on wages for all working people, irrespective of color. It should also make us look at gender, because men and women did not experience exploitation in the same manner. We need to consider things like women’s unpaid labor (see chapter 5), reproduction, sexual abuse, and ways to make restitution for these distinctive forms of exploitation. At the very least, the reparations movement ought to clarify issues like what constitutes a “family” if payments are to be made to such units, or how we might imagine remaking relationships between men and women, boys and girls, adults and children. If radical transformation of society is one of the goals of the reparations movement, then these questions cannot be ignored. Unfortunately, most arguments in support of reparations scarcely mention gender. In the end, a successful reparations campaign has the potential to benefit the entire nation, not just the black community. Since most plans emphasize investments in institutions rather than individual payments, the result would bring a massive infusion of capital for infrastructure, housing, schools, and related institutions in communities with large black populations. Monies would also be made available to support civic organizations and help establish a strong civil society among people of African descent, which in turn would strengthen civil society as a whole. Presumably, social ills such as crime, drug use, and violence would be reduced considerably and thus alter the world’s image of black people. Furthermore, the historically black ghetto communities to which substantial investments would be made also house other poor people of color: Latinos, Afro-Caribbeans, Native Americans, Asian Americans (namely Filipinos, Samoans, South Asians, Koreans, etc.). They, too, would benefit from improved schools, homes, public life, and a politically strengthened black community. Given the relationship of slavery and racism to the global economy, this outcome makes perfect sense. Many of these poor immigrant groups are themselves products of centuries of imperialism—slavery’s handmaiden, if you will—or descendants of slaves, as in the case of many Caribbean and Latin American immigrants. Finally, it should be stressed that reparations for one group will not harm working-class whites. As Robert Westley argued in a recent Boston College Law Review article on reparations: Racist exploitation has contributed to the persistence of poverty among Blacks and the unjust privilege of whites. Redressing these harms through Black reparations would help to alleviate part of the problem of persistent poverty. To the extent that poverty remains a problem among nonBlacks and Blacks alike, it is both just and consistent with the equality principle to demand adequate social welfare, equal educational opportunity and access to jobs. Other national goals, like space exploration or defense, may need to be downsized in order to fulfill the moral obligation of social justice. Of course, we do not yet live in a society where social justice takes precedence over national defense. This is why the reparations campaign, despite its potential contribution to eliminating racism and remaking the world, can never be an end in itself. Movement leaders have known this all along. The hard work of changing our values and reorganizing social life requires political engagement, community involvement, education, debate and discussion, and dreaming. Money and resources are always important, but a new vision and new values cannot be bought. And without at least a rudimentary critique of the capitalist culture that consumes us, even reparations can have disastrous consequences. Imagine if reparations were treated as start-up capital for black entrepreneurs who merely want to mirror the dominant society. What would really change? Again, we have to return to Detroit, this time to veteran radical Grace Lee Boggs. For decades she has been making this very point, insisting that we stop begging for inclusion in a corrupt system, take responsibility for transforming our culture, and remake ourselves as human beings. I hope that all of us who believe freedom is worth pursuing will heed her words and recognize the power we already possess: What we need to do . . . is encourage groups of all kinds and all ages to participate in creating a vision of the future that will enlarge the humanity of all of us and then, in devising concrete programs on which they can work together, if only in a small way, to move toward their vision. In this unique interim time between historical epochs, this is how we can elicit the hope that is essential to the building of a movement and unleash the energies that in the absence of hope are turned against other people or even against oneself. . . . When people come together voluntarily to create their own vision, they begin wishing it to come into being with such passion that they begin creating an active path leading to it from the present. The spirit and the way to make the spirit live coalesce. Instead of seeing ourselves only as victims, we begin to see ourselves as part of a continuing struggle of human beings, not only to survive but to evolve into more human human beings.

2023 GDI Kritik
Universalism Neg › Alternative › Alt Solvency- Reparations Movement Good

Questioning the wrong doings of America through the movement for reparations is more important than the specific answers that are produced

TA-NEHISI COATES, June 2014, Ta-Nehisi Coates is a national correspondent for The Atlantic, where he writes about culture, politics, and social issues., “The Case for Reparations”, The Atlantic,

Something more than moral pressure calls America to reparations. We cannot escape our history. All of our solutions to the great problems of health care, education, housing, and economic inequality are troubled by what must go unspoken. “The reason black people are so far behind now is not because of now,” Clyde Ross told me. “It’s because of then.” In the early 2000s, Charles Ogletree went to Tulsa, Oklahoma, to meet with the survivors of the 1921 race riot that had devastated “Black Wall Street.” The past was not the past to them. “It was amazing seeing these black women and men who were crippled, blind, in wheelchairs,” Ogletree told me. “I had no idea who they were and why they wanted to see me. They said, ‘We want you to represent us in this lawsuit.’ ” A commission authorized by the Oklahoma legislature produced a report affirming that the riot, the knowledge of which had been suppressed for years, had happened. But the lawsuit ultimately failed, in 2004. Similar suits pushed against corporations such as Aetna (which insured slaves) and Lehman Brothers (whose co-founding partner owned them) also have thus far failed. These results are dispiriting, but the crime with which reparations activists charge the country implicates more than just a few towns or corporations. The crime indicts the American people themselves, at every level, and in nearly every configuration. A crime that implicates the entire American people deserves its hearing in the legislative body that represents them. John Conyers’s HR 40 is the vehicle for that hearing. No one can know what would come out of such a debate. Perhaps no number can fully capture the multi-century plunder of black people in America. Perhaps the number is so large that it can’t be imagined, let alone calculated and dispensed. But I believe that wrestling publicly with these questions matters as much as—if not more than—the specific answers that might be produced. An America that asks what it owes its most vulnerable citizens is improved and humane. An America that looks away is ignoring not just the sins of the past but the sins of the present and the certain sins of the future. More important than any single check cut to any African American, the payment of reparations would represent America’s maturation out of the childhood myth of its innocence into a wisdom worthy of its founders.

2023 GDI Kritik
Universalism Neg › Alternative › Alternative- Global Reparations Activism

State based universalism sidelines more radical reparations demands. The alternative is to demand global distributive justice via reparations for slavery and colonialism.

Klein, ANU Canberra Public Policy Lecturer & Fouksman, King’s College Social Justice Lecturer, 22 [Edward & Elizaveta, 11/21/2021, Development and Change, Volume 53, Issue 1, January “Reparations as a Rightful Share: From Universalism to Redress in Distributive Justice] https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/dech.12695 Accessed 7/2/2023, PE]

REPARATIONS FOR COLONIALISM AND THE WORLD CONFERENCE AGAINST RACISM

In considering a rightful global (re)distribution of wealth, it is hard not to reflect on the foundational violence, oppression and disruption that has played a large role in creating contemporary structures of global political, economic and military order. European colonization of the Americas, Asia, Oceania and Africa continues to be a key aspect of global inequality today. Reparations could right some of the wrongs of not only slavery and the slave trade but also colonization by European empires. In Inglorious Empire: What the British Did to India, Shashi Tharoor (2017) draws on Minhaz Merchant's computation which demonstrates that, in return for profits made over 200 years of imperial rule, Britain could owe India up to US$ 3 trillion (as of 2015). Yet Tharoor argues for atonement over the actual payment of funds. He calls for a ‘symbolic reparation of one pound a year, payable for 200 years to atone for 200 years of imperial rule’ (Tharoor, 2017: 79). Tharoor's preference for atonement over financial settlement or fiscal compensation underscores the importance of the British recognizing the role of colonialism in their own and India's history — a recognition that is largely lacking. This preference can be critiqued for emphasizing recognition at the expense of redistribution (Fraser, 2005). However, Tharoor's point does draw attention to one of the major challenges for universalist notions of a rightful share such as a UBI: as discussed above, it does not necessarily provide recognition of historically specific forms of dispossession, such as colonization and related violence. Recognition can thus be conceptualized as an important part of distributive justice, because it not only acknowledges historical wrongs as a key consideration in making justice-based claims, but also provides pathways to address structural inequalities that were set up under colonial rule and continue today.

2023 GDI Kritik
Universalism Neg › Alternative › AT: Plan Decreases Racial Wealth Gap

Reparations must include explicit recognition and acknowledgment of wrongdoing- some material redress isn’t enough.

Klein, ANU Canberra Public Policy Lecturer & Fouksman, King’s College Social Justice Lecturer, 22 [Edward & Elizaveta, 11/21/2021, Development and Change, Volume 53, Issue 1, January “Reparations as a Rightful Share: From Universalism to Redress in Distributive Justice] https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/dech.12695 Accessed 7/2/2023, PE]

Yet at the same time, this economically reparative function could be undermined by a lack of recognition of specific historic wrongs (such as enslavement, expropriation and racial discrimination). As will be discussed in greater detail in the case studies that follow, reparations are not simply about economic compensation, but equally about recognition of such historical wrongs. Roy Brooks (2004) distinguishes between the settlement or tort model of reparations, a legal approach in which specific individuals compensate victims for their demonstrable losses, and the atonement model, which emphasizes reparative justice through collective apology together with material reparations that give weight to the apology. A UBI fits well into the collective nature of the atonement model of reparations. Yet, while a UBI might be able to fulfil some material redress through its redistributory function, it has rarely been framed as a collective apology from one group to another. Darity and Mullen (2020) advocate for a model of reparations that must include acknowledgement, redress and closure. While the intersectionality of class and race enable a more just redistribution of wealth to provide some amount of race-based economic restitution, it lacks concrete acknowledgement for racially based injustice, and thus cannot provide closure.

In short, if a key way in which UBI can serve as a rightful share of collectively generated wealth is precisely its universalism, how can both its universalism and its reparative functions be simultaneously acknowledged? How can a universal policy provide recognition of specific historical acts of injustice? As discussed in the sections to follow, the importance of recognition becomes a particular challenge when considerations of a rightful share move beyond the nation state, as in the case of post-independence reparations, and in contestation over sovereignty within settler colonial contexts.

2023 GDI Kritik
Universalism Neg › Alternative › Race Targeted Redistribution Good

Race is an effective redistributive proxy- it’s efficient, distributively just, and doesn’t distort work incentives.

Logue, UMich Law Professor, 4 [Kyle D., associate dean for faculty and research and the Douglas A. Kahn Collegiate Professor of Law at the University of Michigan Law School, “Reparations as Redistribution,” Boston University Law Review, 84, No. 5, 1319-74. https://repository.law.umich.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2737&context=articles]

This tension - the efficiency-fairness tradeoff - is impossible for a tax-and transfer regime to avoid entirely. On the one hand, when policymakers try to make the system more progressive or more distributively just, they end up sacrificing efficiency. That is what happens, for example, when marginal tax rates are increased on the highest levels of income, or when special deductions are phased out as income rises. On the other hand, when policymakers try to improve the efficiency of a tax, it is often at the expense of distributive justice. The paradigmatic example of the efficient but distributively unjust tax is the head tax, a type of lump-sum tax that imposes the same tax liability on every individual in the society. Such a tax is perfectly efficient, in the sense that it produces no substitution effect (after all, there is no way to avoid the tax other than to leave the country), but it is obviously unjust, as the poorest person in society pays the same tax as the richest person. This injustice, in fact, is why we use an income tax rather than a head tax, because the income tax, for all its flaws, at least allows us to allocate tax burdens roughly on the basis of relative well-being.

In sum, real-world redistributive programs must find reliable proxies for well-being that are relatively observable. Such redistributive regimes typically have a serious problem with distorting work incentives, because most good proxies for well-being are functions of work effort; therefore, it is generally understood that tradeoffs or compromises must be made between distributive justice concerns and efficiency concerns. These are practical facts about redistributive programs that must be taken into account, and alternative systems of redistribution must be compared with one another in terms of how well they deal with these issues.

2023 GDI Kritik
Universalism Neg › Alternative › Redistribution ≠ Reparations

Reparations are distinct from redistribution- only a reparations framework foregrounds the intergenerational harm inflicted on Black and Indigenous communities.

Resource Generation, Philanthropic Organization, 21 [Resource Generation Organizing team, Social Justice and Wealth Inequality Philanthropic Group, “Reparations and Redistribution” , Accessed 7/16/23]-grh

Within the U.S context, the term reparations is used predominantly as an acknowledgment of the immense intergenerational harm inflicted upon Indigenous and Black communities, and thus the repair that is due. Reparations might look like local governments investing in affordable housing, education and transportation, while divesting from policing. An aspect of reparations might look like the national government passing the Breathe Act, which would put in place four different commissions for reparations for slavery, the war on drugs and mass criminalization, police violence, and immigration enforcement. Reparations might look like #Landback with national public lands being given back to Indigenous stewardship. All of these examples are things that must be won, and that people who have benefited from exploitation should play roles in advocating for.

Differences between reparations and redistribution

2023 GDI Kritik
Universalism Neg › Links › Universalism Bad- Health Care

False universalism like the plan treats populations as homogenous- can’t account for social difference

Carrey, PhD in public health, and Crammond, RMIT health researcher, 17

[Gemma and Brad, March 2017, Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, “A glossary of policy frameworks: the many forms of 'universalism' and policy 'targeting'”, https://www.jstor.org/stable/44363653, Accessed July 12 2023, ah]

However, welfare scholars argue that many states which have been described as 'universal' exclude certain groups by virtue of viewing populations as homogenous.20 This means that they are either not really universal at all, or in practice have been found to incorporate various degrees of targeting.10 The universalist approaches of postwar Britain and the Nordic states have come under attack from scholars concerned with social diversity.10 20-22 Labelled as 'false universalism', they are seen as insufficient for dealing with social difference.20 For example, universalism in the postwar era overlooked the needs of women and minority groups and catered predominately to white men.20 Meanwhile, significant gaps have been found in the 'universalist' programmes of the Nordic states, particularly in benefits for immigrants and guest workers.21 Here, proponents of universalism are accused of confusing 'impartiality' with uniformity and 'equality of treatment' with 'sameness of treatment' regardless of the different needs or ability to access services.8 These ideas have their roots in the work of Ronald Dworkin23, who argued that equal treatment of all individuals is insufficient. Giving equal treatment to all people would mean, for example, providing the same resources to someone with a disability and someone without a disability. To be sensitive to differences in need, Dworkin's theory of equality argued that individuals must be treated differently. Hence, while universalism is regarded as a precondition of equality, it does little to promote redistribution and ignores existing inequalities.23

2023 GDI Kritik
Universalism Neg › Links › Universalism Bad- Health Care

Universal healthcare forfeits helping the marginalised

Carrey, PhD in public health, and Crammond, RMIT health researcher, 17

[Gemma and Brad, March 2017, Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, “A glossary of policy frameworks: the many forms of 'universalism' and policy 'targeting'”, https://www.jstor.org/stable/44363653, Accessed July 12 2023, ah]

Actions taken for the benefit of public health require a balancing of the universal and the particular. All individuals are biologically susceptible to disease and all will experience ill health during their lives, making some universal services appropriate. However, many conditions do not strike evenly and certain characteristics can make individuals more susceptible, such as poverty, disadvantage or belonging to marginalised social or cultural groups.1 As a result, it is argued that those who are more at risk, or at the greatest vulnerability to succumbing to ill health, should be treated differently by, for example, being given additional resources or assistance.2^ While straightforward in principle, achieving the right balance between 'universal' and 'targeted' programmes in practice is more difficult, requiring decisions to be made about what groups deserve what level and kind of support. As a result, how to combine universal and targeted policies, programmes and services remains a point of much discussion and debate.1 3-6 This debate is likely to intensify as public health becomes increasingly concerned with issues of inequality.7