Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Affirmative
DA Answers › Econ › 2AC/1AR: A2 Offshoring

Aff solves for the service sector – living-wage incentive reigns in private sector,

Tcherneva, Bard Economics Associate professor, ‘20

[Pavlina R. Tcherneva, Associate Professor, Economics, Bard College, THE CASE FOR A JOB GUARANTEE, Polity Press, Medford MA, 2020, epub]

This new labor standard would be especially beneficial to service sector workers. The vast majority of workers who would transition to private sector employment from the Job Guarantee would take up service sector jobs, as manufacturing today employs less than 8 percent of the total labor force in the US. The decline in manufacturing employment is a global trend, and even manufacturing giants like China and South Korea cannot count on this sector to maintain previous levels of employment. We often think with nostalgia about manufacturing jobs, longing for the family security they provided and the communities they engendered. But it is easy to forget that manufacturing jobs were precarious and underpaid until organized labor unionized them and governments legislated for workplace safety, working hour limits, and minimum wages. Those changes were far-reaching but still inadequate. They depended on the mutual expectations and obligations between workers and employers over labor conditions. The social contract, which ushered in family wages for men (but only “pin money” for women), is now long gone, and service sector work does not provide comparable wage support and living standards.

2023 GDI Affirmative
DA Answers › Econ › 2AC/1AR: Stabilization

Green New Deal reduces economic volatility – jobs and socialized investment

Tcherneva, Bard Economics Associate professor, ‘20

[Pavlina R. Tcherneva, Associate Professor, Economics, Bard College, THE CASE FOR A JOB GUARANTEE, Polity Press, Medford MA, 2020, epub]

The Green New Deal is another such watershed moment. The scale of the response needed is comparable to what was required to tackle the Great Depression and a second devastating world war. The policies we design today would usher in a new economy. In the big battle to save the planet, implementing the Job Guarantee is a comparatively small but critical component. If the Green New Deal brings a broader socialization of investment in essential public goods – transportation, housing, electricity, healthcare and childcare – economic volatility would decline much the same way it did after WWII. (Prior to the New Deal of the 1930s, the US economy had experienced a depression every twenty years, and many smaller downturns in between.) The Green New Deal holds the promise of stabilizing the economy in comparable ways. However, it will not end the business cycle. While cyclical fluctuations will hardly be expunged, the fact that they are smaller would mean that the size of the Job Guarantee would also be smaller. As a permanent part of the policy landscape, it would continue to provide an employment safety net and a macroeconomic stabilization mechanism, even as we transition to a cleaner, more stable and more just economy.

2023 GDI Affirmative
DA Answers › Econ › 2AC/1AR: Stabilization

Critiques ignore private sector is already cyclical – aff provides more stability

Tcherneva, Bard Economics Associate professor, ‘20

[Pavlina R. Tcherneva, Associate Professor, Economics, Bard College, THE CASE FOR A JOB GUARANTEE, Polity Press, Medford MA, 2020, epub]

Critics also worry that the Job Guarantee cannot function as an effective automatic stabilizer. Can we really create jobs on demand? If they are so useful, why let Job Guarantee workers go when the economy recovers?

2023 GDI Affirmative
DA Answers › Econ › 2AC/1AR: Stabilization

JG checks inflation and price stability – worker benefits outweigh

Whalen, visiting legal scholar at SUNY Buffalo, ’19 (Charles J. Whalen, visiting scholar in the Baldy Center for Law and Social Policy, SUNY Buffalo School of Law., 4-1-2019, "Jobs for All: Reclaiming the Right to Work," Taylor & Francis, https://doi.org/10.1080/05775132.2019.1581005)

What about inflation? To be sure, there would be a one-time adjustment of the wage structure as low-wage employers respond to the new wage floor set by government as employer of last resort, but current jobs-for-all proposals don’t call for wages out of line with where they would have been had the minimum wage kept up with inflation and productivity increases since the 1960s (Paul et al. Citation2018, 51, n.17). Moreover, the Federal Reserve would still be empowered to keep inflation in check by using monetary policy to restrain the growth of private investment when necessary—workers would just face less economic vulnerability with a jobs program in place (Paul, Darity, and Hamilton Citation2018, 8).

2023 GDI Affirmative
DA Answers › Econ › 2AC/1AR: Budget

We can afford it—pandemic proves

Tcherneva, Bard Economics Associate professor, ‘20

[Pavlina R. Tcherneva, Associate Professor, Economics, Bard College, THE CASE FOR A JOB GUARANTEE, Polity Press, Medford MA, 2020, epub]

We need a Job Guarantee now more than ever. The following pages present the case for its overwhelming benefits and a blueprint for its implementation. Its design is inspired precisely by the way policy is supposed to respond to pandemics, by prioritizing preparedness and prevention. Decades of austerity have led to the erosion of essential public sector programs, services, and institutional capacities, leaving us woefully unprepared to respond to this pandemic and the social crisis that will follow. The public was baited into accepting austerity with the myth that the federal government could run out of funding. And yet, almost overnight, the US government passed an unprecedented $2.2 trillion package to tackle the pandemic, with additional spending on the way according to bipartisan consensus. Many countries around the world are doing the same. Finding the money was never the problem. Finding the political will to rally behind key policies always was.

2023 GDI Affirmative
DA Answers › Econ › 2AC/1AR: Budget

JG helps pay for itself via economic stimulus – new taxes are too small to link

LNS ’19

[Labor Network for Sustainability, CLIMATE JOBS FOR ALL: BUILDING BLOCK FOR THE GREEN NEW DEAL, 12—18, p. 17]

Many advocates of a JG see one of its principal benefits as countercyclical economic stimulus. To play this role requires periodic governmental deficit spending. Public borrowing can take place through bond sales or by the Fed buying infrastructure bonds, just as it bought Treasury securities in 1940 to financed the World War II. Public-purpose banks, credit unions, and investment and loan funds can provide more decentralized financial resources, especially for smaller-scale and community-based projects. The economic growth generated by the CJG, along with the sources listed above, is likely to provide a substantial part of the funds required for it. New taxes will need to provide only a small part, if any, of the cost of the CJG.

2023 GDI Affirmative
DA Answers › Econ › 2AC/1AR: Budget

Job Guarantee results in GDP increases, and the costs of unemployment outweigh.

Tcherneva, Bard Economcis Associate professor, ‘18

[Pavlina R. Tcherneva, Associate Professor, Economics, Bard College and Levy Economics Institute, “The Job Guarantee: Design, Jobs, and Implementation,” WORKING PAPER n. 902, Levy Economics Institute of Bard College, 4—18, p. 34-36]

3. How much will the program cost?

2023 GDI Affirmative
DA Answers › Econ › 1AR Uniqueness: Inflation

Too soon to predict inflation decline

Milden- staff writer for CNET, 23

Dashia Milden- staff writer for CNET. Peter Butler- writer and editor for the CNET. CNET/ Inflation Eased to 4.9% in April. What Experts Predict Is Next and How to Prepare. . May 12, 2023. DOA: 06/19/23. AR

Inflation has been falling for the past few months, but it's still high. And there's no guarantee that it will continue to trend downward. "The thing that still worries me and keeps me up at night is what if we have a month where it pops back up?" said Young. "Although it's tempting to sort of declare victory and say we're headed in the right direction, and things are going well, I think it's too soon to do so." Instead, now's the time for you to stay the course and continue to closely manage your finances -- including debt, spending, saving and investing -- until there's a clear sign that we're closer to the 2% inflation target.

2023 GDI Affirmative
DA Answers › Econ › 1AR Uniqueness: Inflation

Inflation increases inevitable due to fuel cost increases

Bhattarai, economics correspondent for the Washington Post, 23

Abha Bhattarai-economics correspondent for The Washington Post. Jeff Stein- the White House economics reporter for The Washington Post. The Washington Post.. Inflation is falling. Why aren’t people noticing? . April 12, 2023. DOA: 06/18/23. AR.

Americans’ views on inflation are closely tied to the whims of fuel costs, which have edged up after months of decline. After hitting an all-time high of $5 a gallon in June, average national gas prices dropped to $3 a gallon in December but have since bounced back up to $3.60 a gallon, according to AAA. There are also growing fears that prices could spike even more in coming months, following last week’s announcement that a number of major oil exporters, including Saudi Arabia, will significantly cut production this year. Higher fuel prices — which also drive up the cost of making and transporting goods — could threaten the progress that has already been made in bringing down inflation. “When it comes to inflation, I haven’t seen any spikes, but I don’t see any improvement either,” said Juan Soto, president of IT Impact, a custom software developer in Chicago that has raised prices by 20 percent in the past year. “My insurance costs are going up, labor costs are going up. This recent price hike in gasoline isn’t helping anybody. Just when you think it’s easing up a little bit, things get worse again.” Surging oil prices could again frustrate inflation fight Stubborn inflation reinforces a lingering concern for officials at the Federal Reserve: The longer price growth stays elevated, the greater the risk that consumers and businesses will begin expecting such increases to persist, creating a self-fulfilling cycle that would present a more lasting challenge for central bankers.

2023 GDI Affirmative
DA Answers › Econ › 1AR Uniqueness: Worker Productivity

Key states report low productivity- California, NY, Texas, Washington

Henderson, Stateline staff, 23

TIM HENDERSON- staff at Stateline. Stateline. Workers are less productive in key US states; here’s what that means for economy, WFH. . Jun 13, 2023. DOA: 06/20/23. AR.

U.S. worker productivity has dropped significantly, including in key large states, leaving some economists alarmed by the decrease in a measure that could mean trillions of dollars to the economy. Labor productivity — the value of the goods and services produced on average by an hour’s work — ranged from $58.80 in Mississippi to $120.67 in New York last year, according to a Stateline analysis of federal Bureau of Labor Statistics data released in May. Thirty-seven states and the District of Columbia saw worker productivity drop from 2021 to 2022 after adjustment for inflation. So far this year, productivity nationwide dropped through the first quarter. Even states that have led productivity in recent years had decreases between 2021 and 2022 — California, New York, Texas and Washington. From 2007 to 2019, those states contributed more than half the country’s productivity growth. Some economists see the unprecedented drop in national productivity numbers as an alarm bell, though others see it as an expected reset from pandemic highs, when tech industries in California and Washington soared along with the financial industry in New York. Only nine states had productivity drops when comparing 2019 with 2022. Gregory Daco, a chief economist for Ernst & Young, called the recent decrease a “recessionary signal” in a May 4 tweet, noting that the five consecutive year-to-year quarterly declines through early 2023 had never happened since the BLS began calculating the statistic in 1948. “The economy remains in a productivity slump at the moment,” Daco wrote in an executive briefing for clients. Likely reasons, Daco wrote, are labor market churn causing businesses to lose skilled employees as well as unequal access to technology that could speed up work.

2023 GDI Affirmative
DA Answers › Econ › 1AR Uniqueness: Worker Productivity

Worker productivity is at a 75 year low

Their, reporter at Fortune, 23

JANE THEIR- reporter at Fortune on the Success team. Fortune. American worker productivity is declining at the fastest rate in 75 years—and it could see CEOs go to war against WFH. . May 5, 2023. DOA: 06/20/23. AR.

It’s been a rough three years. The globe effectively shut down as a once-per-century pandemic claimed millions of lives, while on the business front, the U.S. saw a layoff wave incomparable in modern history. Working our way back to a relative baseline has come with hiccups, like a huge shift to remote work, and then a semi-return to normal. As a mark of what a long journey it’s been, the World Health Organization just today declared COVID is no longer an emergency, after more than three years. But for a while there, amid the panic and tragedy, workers were somehow more productive than ever. Not anymore. The U.S. has now had five consecutive quarters of year-over-year declines in productivity, according to research from EY-Parthenon, using data from the federal Bureau of Labor Statistics. That has never happened before, in data going back to 1948. To figure out why this is happening, Fortune spoke with Gregory Daco, chief economist at EY-Parthenon, the global strategy consulting arm of one of the “Big Four” accounting and consulting firms. Daco has written and spoken extensively about remote work and the pandemic’s effect on the labor market. He said the low productivity reflects our current environment, defined by high inflation. Remote work is a real thing to consider, Daco said, but it’s not the only factor. The drop in productivity, Daco tweeted Thursday, is exacerbating compensation pressures and pushing up unit labor costs. “The difficulty is that there is no magic productivity wand,” he wrote. “And cost-cutting via layoffs and wage growth compression is often ‘easier’ and faster to execute.” Breaking down the numbers U.S. productivity plunged 2.7% in the first quarter of this year compared to last year, EY found. That’s a 0.9% year-over-year drop. Concurrently, quarter-over-quarter output grew slightly (0.2%), and hours worked grew 3%. That means people are working longer hours and barely putting out more products, because they just aren’t as productive as they used to be. “When you have an environment in which output is outpacing labor growth, that’s an environment of stronger productivity,” he explains to Fortune. “When you have the opposite, when output growth is sluggish but labor growth is strong, you have a weak productivity environment.” A rebound in productivity will be key to solving many of the economy’s current issues, Daco said, as that would lift supply and thereby reduce inflationary pressures. Over the past five or six quarters, he says, economic activity has been sluggish, even as the country has seen a resilient labor market and continued job gains. People are working longer hours, he adds, so labor utilization has also been higher. Unit labor costs grew 6.3% this quarter, while compensation grew 3.4%. That combination has created conditions for the perfect storm: Weak productivity for five quarters straight, for the first time since post-World War II. Daco acknowledged hearing from clients that remote work could be making employees, well, work less hard. “From our clients across sectors, we hear similar stories of reduced productivity because of the new work environment,” Daco says. He acknowledged that imperfect hybrid arrangements could be a possible cause of the productivity plummet. CEOs such as JPMorgan’s Jamie Dimon and Salesforce’s Marc Benioff have argued that in-person workers are simply doing more work, better than their remote colleagues. Dimon says long-term remote work just doesn’t work for most employees; while Benioff says workers in the office consistently perform better. Both the bank and the tech giant have waffled on return-to-office mandates, but both have yielded to a hybrid plan—at least for now. Daco, however, highlighted another factor, which he says economists often underestimate, is that, over the past 18 months, the churn of labor has been “tremendous.” He points to recent BLS and JOLTS reports, which have found that the number of job openings, hire rates and quit rates have all reached record highs. “That tells you it’s been very difficult for employers to, essentially, train their employees and bring them up to par with the productivity levels that would have been deemed normal pre-pandemic,” he says. When the pandemic hit, it brought a combination of early retirement, a mass exit from the workforce, and an avalanche of job-switchers, a phenomenon alternately called “the great resignation” and “the labor shortage.” Taken together, it created a dearth of productivity. “Because people were job-hopping so regularly, there wasn’t really a chance to bring them up to the speed, or productivity, that a former worker would’ve had,” he says. In other words: the outsize rate of churn has been a key, if under-appreciated, factor in sluggish productivity.

2023 GDI Affirmative
DA Answers › Econ › Starter 2AC Block – Economy DA

No impact - Economic decline doesn’t cause war.

Walt ’20 [Stephen; 5/13/20; Professor of International Relations at Harvard University; " Will a Global Depression Trigger Another World War?" https://foreignpolicy.com/2020/05/13/coronavirus-pandemic-depression-economy-world-war/]

On balance, however, I do not think that even the extraordinary economic conditions we are witnessing today are going to have much impact on the likelihood of war. Why? First of all, if depressions were a powerful cause of war, there would be a lot more of the latter. To take one example, the United States has suffered 40 or more recessions since the country was founded, yet it has fought perhaps 20 interstate wars, most of them unrelated to the state of the economy. To paraphrase the economist Paul Samuelson’s famous quip about the stock market, if recessions were a powerful cause of war, they would have predicted “nine out of the last five (or fewer).”

Second, states do not start wars unless they believe they will win a quick and relatively cheap victory. As John Mearsheimer showed in his classic book Conventional Deterrence, national leaders avoid war when they are convinced it will be long, bloody, costly, and uncertain. To choose war, political leaders have to convince themselves they can either win a quick, cheap, and decisive victory or achieve some limited objective at low cost. Europe went to war in 1914 with each side believing it would win a rapid and easy victory, and Nazi Germany developed the strategy of blitzkrieg in order to subdue its foes as quickly and cheaply as possible. Iraq attacked Iran in 1980 because Saddam believed the Islamic Republic was in disarray and would be easy to defeat, and George W. Bush invaded Iraq in 2003 convinced the war would be short, successful, and pay for itself.

2023 GDI Affirmative
DA Answers › Econ › Starter 2AC Block – Economy DA

The DA is backwards – growing the economy to create jobs increases violent consumption patterns

Hickel, anthropologist, ’21

(Jason Hickel, anthropologist, author, and a fellow of the Royal Society of Arts, 2-23-2021, "Stimulus Is an Environmental Disaster Waiting to Happen," Foreign Policy, https://foreignpolicy.com/2021/02/23/stimulus-is-an-environmental-disaster-waiting-to-happen/)

This is a much more rational, ecologically coherent way to address the present economic crisis. Trying to grow the economy to create jobs is effectively busywork. Almost by definition, jobs created this way are in industries we don’t really need to expand, and expanding them, in turn, creates pressures for needless consumption. A job guarantee program does the opposite: It mobilizes labor and resources around things that our communities—and ecology—actually need and which the private sector is unlikely or unable to provide.

2023 GDI Affirmative
DA Answers › Econ › Starter 2AC Block – Economy DA

No link to crowd-out -- job guarantees are countercyclical buffers that support private sector activity.

Tcherneva, Bard Economcis Associate professor, ‘18

[Pavlina R. Tcherneva, Associate Professor, Economics, Bard College and Levy Economics Institute, “The Job Guarantee: Design, Jobs, and Implementation,” WORKING PAPER n. 902, Levy Economics Institute of Bard College, 4—18, p. 40]

13. Why do you say that this program is a better countercyclical stabilizer?

2023 GDI Affirmative
DA Answers › Econ › Starter 2AC Block – Economy DA

Turn - Job guarantee automatically stabilizes the economy through recessions and empowers the private sector during growth periods

Barrantes-Fernández et al. 2023 (Telma Barrantes-Fernández , Esteban Cruz-Hidalgo, José Francisco Rangel-Preciado, and Francisco Manuel Parejo-Moruno, Decommodify the 2030 Agenda: Why and How to Finance What Is Not Profitable?, Sustainability 2023, 15, 3966. https://doi.org/10.3390/su15053966)

The job guarantee is, in general terms, an automatic stabilizer that works by employing workers who cannot find a job in the private sector. During economic recessions, the program will expand in size, whereas during economic booms its size will decrease due to increased demand for private sector employment [100,101]. Participation in the program is voluntary. The state sets the wage it pays for activating the workforce, and individuals choose whether to participate. In other words, the total expenditure for this mechanism is not determined by the state, unlike other programs regardless of their objectives. Mitchell and Muysken [102] (pp. 141–142) point out that the size and direction of the public budget is an endogenous result. This can be understood through a basic understanding of how automatic stabilizers work: a sharp drop in demand reduces tax revenue and increases spending on, for example, unemployment benefits, automatically increasing the public deficit. Attempting to limit the effect of automatic stabilizers or even suppress them to conform to a budgetary balance rule only deepens the recession. This is because households and companies rely on others’ spending, and if the state is forced to cut spending, the monetary gains that it generates by maintaining purchasing power to soften the fall in demand will disappear, resulting in more job losses and company failures. The aim is that these programs are mainly temporary and do not require specialized training. They can be designed in a flexible manner to include groups that are frequently excluded from the labor market: the chronically ill, ex-convicts, disabled workers, young people entering the labor market for the first time, ethnic minorities, or people who have been out of the labor market for a long time for any reason [103]. In regard to the topic at hand, artists also fall under the category of people who are frequently excluded from the labor market, with high unemployment rates, low wages, and chronic insecurity [104–106]. This is due to the nature of artistic activity and its incompatibility with capitalist values, as explained in Section 2 of this article. These jobs do not compete with the need for public employment and the traditional welfare state, but rather should be considered as a beneficial job for society that provides a bridge to the private sector, although this transition may not always be necessary, especially for artists, due to their unique characteristics. According to the labor preference model, the artist values emotional income over monetary income, resulting in a higher level of satisfaction compared to what they would obtain from engaging in another activity [107,108].

In this way, market forces determine the size and direction of the public budget automatically. The job guarantee operates as an anchor for prices and wages, effectively replacing the traditional method of controlling inflation by maintaining a reserve army of the unemployed with a reserve of employees. In times of economic recession, when companies lay off workers, those who become unemployed will have the option to take part in these last resort jobs, which help to balance swings in private spending and investment. During economic growth, private employers will be able to hire workers from the pool, by offering better working conditions. The maintenance and improvement of individual skills and abilities compensates for any increase in wages, preventing an inflationary spiral. Mitchell and Mosler [109] referred to this reserve of employees that maintains stable inflation as the non-accelerating inflation buffer employment ratio (NAIBER), as an alternative to the natural unemployment rate used by mainstream economics to control inflation.

2023 GDI Affirmative
DA Answers › Econ › Starter 2AC Block – Economy DA

Recession coming and inevitable.

Lee, Money and Personal Finance reporter, ‘6/15/23

[Medora, USA Today, 6-15-2023, "Recession or no recession? Why Deutsche Bank says an economic downturn is 100% inevitable," https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/economy/2023/06/15/recession-inevitable-deutsche-bank/70327467007/]

Odds of a U.S. recession have been hotly debated with the labor market and consumer spending showing resiliency even after some of the most aggressive interest rate hikes in history. But Deutsche Bank sees a 100% probability the U.S. will have one. The short-term benchmark fed funds rate stands at the highest level since 2006, but inflation’s still twice the Fed’s goal. Fed Chairman Jerome Powell warned after the Fed’s policy committee meeting on Wednesday more rate hikes will likely be necessary to further cool inflation. “Looking ahead, nearly all Committee participants view it as likely that some further rate increases will be appropriate this year to bring inflation down to 2% over time,” Powell said. The Fed’s median forecast for the fed funds rate this year is 5.6%, up from 5.1% in March and above the current fed funds target of 5% to 5.25%. While more rate increases could bring inflation down to 2%, at what price? Recession, says David Folkerts-Landau, Deutsche Bank chief economist. “The U.S. is heading for its first genuine policy-led boom-bust cycle in at least four decades,” he writes. “The inflation we see was induced largely by expansive fiscal and monetary policy, and the aggressive rate hikes needed to tame that have now materialized. Avoiding a hard landing would be historically unprecedented.”

2023 GDI Affirmative
DA Answers › Econ › Starter 2AC Block – Economy DA

Non-unique: Inflation high now- decreases are on a two-year stack

Bhattarai, economics correspondent for the Washington Post, 23

Abha Bhattarai-economics correspondent for The Washington Post. Jeff Stein- the White House economics reporter for The Washington Post. The Washington Post.. Inflation is falling. Why aren’t people noticing? . April 12, 2023. DOA: 06/18/23. AR.

“You’ll probably hear inflation numbers that start to sound lower, but you’ll have to remember that’s on a two-year stack,” Doug McMillon, Walmart’s chief executive, said in an earnings call in February. “So if inflation in dry grocery and consumables is only 3 percent or 5 percent, that’s on top of 15 percent. And that’s still a problem for the customer and still will pressure their wallet.”