2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Fem IR updates › Neg › Fem lens – general
Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Gender(ed) Lenses on Global Politics, pgs 28-29 /// MF)
In simple terms, lenses focus our attention selectively. Selective attention is a necessary feature of making sense of any particular subject, practice, paradox, or social order. Because it is not physically possible for any human to see or comprehend everything at once, we rely on conceptual fi lters—lenses—that enable us to see some things in greater detail, with more accuracy, or in better relation to certain other things. Lenses simplify our thinking by focusing our attention on what seems most relevant. They “order” what we see and provide direction for subsequent actions. In this sense, lenses are like maps: they frame our choices, expectations, and explorations, enabling us to take advantage of knowledge already gained and, presumably, to move more eff ectively toward our objectives. Like maps, lenses enable us to make sense of where we are, what to expect next, and how to proceed. From the conceptual ordering systems available to us, we choose the lens we assume is most appropri-ate for a particular context—a lens that we expect will enable us to make sense of and act appropriately in that context.
Lenses are thus indispensable for ordering what we see and orienting our responses. But their fi ltering function is also problematic. Because we cannot focus on everything, any particular lens directs our attention to some features of a context, which unavoidably renders other features out of focus—fi ltered out—by that lens. In short, lenses both include and exclude, with important and often political implications.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Fem IR updates › Neg › Fem lens – general
Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Gender(ed) Lenses on Global Politics, pgs 32-33 /// MF)
Feminist IR lenses (see, for example, Tickner and Sjoberg 2011; Tickner 2014; Steans and Tepe-Belfrage 2016) focus on gender and its relation to other inequalities, and the political nature and eff ects of masculinist and other inequality-producing orders. As such, they are highly infl uenced by (neo)Marxist, poststructural, and postcolonial thinking in and outside of IR. More recently, queer and trans theorists in IR (see, for example, Weber 2016; Peterson 2014; Sjoberg 2012), many of whom are feminist, have directed greater attention to the implications of heteronormativity and gender conformity not only for sexual and gender minorities, but also for the further disruption of binaries in IR.
In general, gender analysts in IR operate from feminist perspectives, which, although varied (as discussed later in this chapter), share, minimally, a concern with the problem of gender inequality as a motivation for research. They have found in their examinations that individuals, institutions, and practices associated with masculinity (men, states, war-making, wealth production) remain highly valued (or valorized) in political and world political thought, whereas those individuals, institutions, and practices associated with femininity (women, local or international political formations, peacemaking, poverty reduction) have been more typically devalued (or devalorized) and even dismissed in such thinking until very recently. Again, this is key to what is meant in this text by the power of gender — the perva-siveness of gender as a fi ltering category, or meta-lens, that puts in motion the broad processes of masculinization and feminization. That is, gender-sensitive research does more than docu-ment the pattern of excluding or trivializing women and their experiences while infl ating men’s experiences and power. It documents how gender—characterizations of masculinity and femininity—can infl uence the very categories and frameworks within which scholars work.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Fem IR updates › Neg › Fem lens – general
Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Gender(ed) Lenses on Global Politics, pg 33 /// MF)
Gender inquiry in IR began with the question “Where are the women?” in international aff airs, as they appeared absent in typical accounts of the rise of great powers, their leaders, their weaponries, and their wars, as well as in dominant theories about the nature of and interactions among states and their economies. At fi rst glance, activities associated with masculinity (e.g., competitive sports, politics, militaries) appear simply as those in which men are present and women are absent and only the men engaging in these activities need be attended to. Gender analysis, however, reveals how women are in fact important to the picture (enabling men’s activities, such as providing reasons for men to fi ght), even though women and the roles they are expected to play are obscured when we focus only on men. Through a gender lens, we see how constructions of masculinity (agency, control, aggression) are not independent of, but rely upon, contrasting constructions of femininity (dependence, vulner-ability, passivity). In an important sense, the dominant presence of men and the overvaluing of masculinity depend on the absence of women and the devaluing of femininity. Because of this interdependence, using gender analysis in IR does not merely reveal heretofore-unseen conditions and roles of women in global politics, but “transforms” what we know about men and the activities they undertake in international aff airs. Hence, the study of gender alters our understandings of the conventional foci of IR—power politics, war, and economic control—by exposing what more deeply underpins them and why they are given such prominence over other ways of thinking about and acting in the world.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Fem IR updates › Neg › Fem lens – general
Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Gender(ed) Lenses on Global Politics, pgs 27-28 /// MF)
Feminist IR scholars, emerging in the discipline by the 1980s, generally do not subscribe to the conventional defi nition of IR as being the power struggles between sovereign states in an anarchic world in which there is no supranational government to control state behaviors through the rule of law. Rather, these scholars favor an alternative defi nition of IR: “the iden-tifi cation and explanation of social stratifi cations and of inequality as structured at the level of global relations” (Brown 1988: 461). In this sense, feminist perspectives on IR understand power in broader and more complex terms than more conventional IR scholars do, and have sought to put the relations of people, as agents and within social structures, back into IR. To do so, these IR scholars have relied on feminist sociopolitical theorizing in other disciplines, including the now well-developed (inter)discipline of women’s, gender, and sexuality studies.
They have also relied on, and contributed to, an array of other IR lenses, arising prior to and after the emergence of feminist IR, that critique conventional IR for such things as assuming reality is given rather than socially constructed, centering the state and state elites as the main actors in world aff airs to the exclusion of actors above and below the state, and failing to see or center how global power structures and relations immiserate the majority of the world’s people and the planet. What connects what are broadly referred to here as critical lenses or perspectives on IR is the view that conventional IR, as a result of its focus on political and economic elites and state power, and its relative blindness to the deleterious eff ects of dominant political, economic, and social arrangements upheld by elites and states, is oriented to serving elites to maintain global power structures. Thus, conventional IR is not value-free. Critical perspectives, which maintain no knowledge is value-free and that scholars should acknowledge their always present values or normative commitments that invariably shape the questions they ask, are, in contrast, oriented to producing more “emancipatory” knowledge, which confronts global power structures and relations and their eff ects on peoples and the planet. Critical perspectives, however, do diff er in terms of which global power struc-tures and relations they highlight, how those structures and relations are understood, and what to do about them. Feminist IR perspectives center gender as a global power relation and structure. But as presented in Chapter 1 and expanded upon in this chapter, feminist intersec-tional analysis in IR goes beyond a gender lens to encompass a gendered lens that highlights the interconnections among global power relations and structures.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Fem IR updates › Neg › Fem lens – general
Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Gender(ed) Lenses on Global Politics, pg 27 /// MF)
As argued in the introductory chapter, the power of gender is an especially resilient and adaptive fi ltering and organizing mechanism, a meta-lens that produces particular ways of seeing, thinking, and acting in the world. Gender may feature in policymaking, women and men may be repositioned, and ideal forms of masculinity may shift, but as long as the power of gender as a meta-lens continues to operate, it will produce and reproduce inequalities, injustices, and crises of global proportion. Here the central case made is that feminist lenses , and particularly intersectional ones, often in concert with other lenses critical of conventional IR approaches, are necessary to reveal the extent of the power of gender to produce and obscure inequalities and the global crises that ensue from and sustain inequalities.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Fem IR updates › Neg › Fem lens – general
Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Introduction, pgs 11-12 /// MF)
In IR, as in political science generally, power is usually defi ned as “power over,” specifi -cally, the ability to get someone to do what you want. It is usually measured by control of resources, especially those supporting physical coercion. The appropriate analogy might be power understood as tools: if you have them, you can use them to get certain things done if and when you choose, and some have more of these tools than others. This defi nition assumes measurable capacities, privileges instrumental rationality, and emphasizes separation and competition: those who have power use it (or its threat) to keep others from securing enough to threaten them. The emphasis on material resources and coercive ability defl ects attention from the fact that power reckoning is embedded in dominant conceptual orders, value systems, disciplinary practices, and institutional dynamics.
In IR, the concept of “political actor”—the legitimate wielder of society’s power—is derived from classical political theory. Common to constructions of “political man”—from Plato and Aristotle to Hobbes, Locke, and Rousseau—is the privileging of “man’s” capacity for reason. Rationality ostensibly distinguishes man from other animals and explains his pursuit of freedom—from nature and “necessity” as well as from tyranny. Feminist scholarship has exposed how models of human nature presupposed in constructions of political man are not in fact gender-neutral but are androcentric , based on exclusively male (especially elite male) experience and perspective. With reference to gender divisions of power, “woman” is excluded conceptually from political power by denying her the rationality that marks “man” as the highest animal. Substantively, women have historically been excluded from political power by states’ limiting citizenship to those who perform military duty and/or are property owners. Under these conditions, most women are structurally excluded from formal politics, even though individual women in exceptional circumstances have wielded considerable political power. Women worldwide have largely won the battle for the vote, though defi ni-tions of citizenship continue to limit women’s access to public power and women’s political power is circumscribed by a variety of indirect means (discussed more in Chapter 3 ). Most obvious are the continued eff ects of the dichotomy of public–private that privileges men’s productive and “political” activities over women’s reproductive and “personal/familial” activities. For example, sovereign man and sovereign states are defi ned not by connection or relationships but by (masculinist) autonomy in decision-making and putative freedom from interdependence and collective responsibilities. Although Aristotle acknowledged that the public sphere depends upon the (re)production of life’s necessities in the private sphere, he denied the interdependence that this implies in articulating political theory.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Fem IR updates › Neg › Fem lens – general
Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Introduction, pgs 11-12 /// MF)
In IR, as in political science generally, power is usually defi ned as “power over,” specifi -cally, the ability to get someone to do what you want. It is usually measured by control of resources, especially those supporting physical coercion. The appropriate analogy might be power understood as tools: if you have them, you can use them to get certain things done if and when you choose, and some have more of these tools than others. This defi nition assumes measurable capacities, privileges instrumental rationality, and emphasizes separation and competition: those who have power use it (or its threat) to keep others from securing enough to threaten them. The emphasis on material resources and coercive ability defl ects attention from the fact that power reckoning is embedded in dominant conceptual orders, value systems, disciplinary practices, and institutional dynamics.
In IR, the concept of “political actor”—the legitimate wielder of society’s power—is derived from classical political theory. Common to constructions of “political man”—from Plato and Aristotle to Hobbes, Locke, and Rousseau—is the privileging of “man’s” capacity for reason. Rationality ostensibly distinguishes man from other animals and explains his pursuit of freedom—from nature and “necessity” as well as from tyranny. Feminist scholarship has exposed how models of human nature presupposed in constructions of political man are not in fact gender-neutral but are androcentric , based on exclusively male (especially elite male) experience and perspective. With reference to gender divisions of power, “woman” is excluded conceptually from political power by denying her the rationality that marks “man” as the highest animal. Substantively, women have historically been excluded from political power by states’ limiting citizenship to those who perform military duty and/or are property owners. Under these conditions, most women are structurally excluded from formal politics, even though individual women in exceptional circumstances have wielded considerable political power. Women worldwide have largely won the battle for the vote, though defi ni-tions of citizenship continue to limit women’s access to public power and women’s political power is circumscribed by a variety of indirect means (discussed more in Chapter 3 ). Most obvious are the continued eff ects of the dichotomy of public–private that privileges men’s productive and “political” activities over women’s reproductive and “personal/familial” activities. For example, sovereign man and sovereign states are defi ned not by connection or relationships but by (masculinist) autonomy in decision-making and putative freedom from interdependence and collective responsibilities. Although Aristotle acknowledged that the public sphere depends upon the (re)production of life’s necessities in the private sphere, he denied the interdependence that this implies in articulating political theory.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Fem IR updates › Neg › Gendered lens alt
Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Gender(ed) Lenses on Global Politics, pgs 38-40/// MF)
On the other hand, feminists, queer, and trans critics of heteronormativity and gender normativity have exposed the assumption of binary sex diff erence as stunted (reducing “sex” to paired opposites, precluding alternatives and commonalities), static (neglecting historical shifts in how “sex” is “seen” and responded to), simplistic (obscuring the complexity of “sex” and its relationship to gender), and politically problematic (unrefl ectively essentializing what is historically situated and socially constructed). Feminist research has additionally docu-mented the deeply sedimented normalization of dichotomized gender (generated by essen-tializing sex as a binary) as a governing code valorizing what is privileged as masculine at the expense of what is stigmatized as feminine. Gendered socialization and social control mechanisms amplify individual and collective internalization of, and investments in, repro-ducing gendered orderings. Here it is argued that more adequate analyses of power require attending to and integrating the critical insights particularly of poststructuralist, postcolonial, feminist, queer, and trans lenses. In particular, to comprehend the resilience of hierarchical thinking and its reproduction of divisions and inequalities requires making sense of the power of gender as a hegemonic and pernicious but typically unacknowledged worldview.
Stated simply and based on the discussion of the power of gender in Chapter 1 , the “naturalness” of sex difference becomes indistinguishable from the “naturalness” of dichotomized and hierarchical gender differentiation that we reproduce, consciously and unconsciously, as we act out gender in all areas of social life. Because of this interaction, gendered stereotypes have political significance far beyond their role in male–female relations. First, gender normalizes dichotomized thought as a deeply embedded practice reproduced throughout social orders. Second, the gender dichotomy is so taken as given that it lends authority to the binary logic that “naturally” divides terms and identity groups into polarized opposites. The naturalness of dichotomized gender then becomes indistinguishable from—and lends credibility and authority to—the naturalness of dichotomized thinking. Third, the normaliza-tion of dichotomized thinking reproduces not only gender hierarchy but also other relations of inequality as dichotomies are taken for granted and eff ectively legitimate hierarchical ordering.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Fem IR updates › Neg › Gendered lens alt
Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Introduction, pg 24/// MF)
The gender(ed), or intersectional feminist, lenses that arise from feminist in combination with other critical perspectives on global politics are applied to the traditional categories of global politics inquiry: global governance ( Chapter 3 ), global security ( Chapter 4 ), and global political economy ( Chapter 5 ). It is within these chapters that historical and contemporary gender(ed) divisions of power, violence, and labor and resources and the global crises of representation, insecurity, and sustainability they spawn are fl eshed out empirically and ana-lytically. The employment of multiple feminist perspectives and the empirical research they are generating foregrounds the substantial body of work that now exists in feminist IR, 6which is contributing to, as well as based on, data now being produced by IGOs and NGOs on the gender(ed) eff ects of global political priorities, processes, and institutions and attempts to ameliorate them. The diversity of feminist IR thought and research also aff ords more com-plex and sometimes confl icting gender or gendered analyses of global politics. The benefi ts of this diversity are that it militates against resorts to “quick fi xes” that can do more harm than good and ensures no single or hegemonic analysis that forecloses debate and further investigation within feminist inquiry. At the same time, weaknesses in feminist inquiry and appropriations of gender analysis in policymaking are raised when they fail to address the gendered power relations among women and among men that forestall more comprehensive critiques and resistances to processes that widen and deepen global and local inequalities.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Fem IR updates › Neg › Gendered lens alt
Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Introduction, pgs 12-13 /// MF)
Gender divisions of power, which equate being political, acting in the public realm of reason, and exercising power-over with normative masculinity and being apolitical, power-less, and sequestered in the private realm of emotion and necessity with femininity, in combination with gendered divisions of power, which feminize or devalorize colonized, racialized, classed, and sexualized peoples in today’s global politics, are refl ective of and instrumental in producing a crisis of representation . This entails still gross inequalities in political representation, not only in formal power structures such as states and intergovern-mental organizations (IGOs), but also in nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) and social movements. While problematic in terms of constraining the political agency and voice of large swaths of people, even in “democracies,” without a range of perspectives from varying social locations, solutions proposed by the few (and most privileged) more often benefi t them while causing harm to those un- or under-represented. “Democracy” is strategically promoted while its radical promise is undermined by fraudulent elections, political machinations, imperial impositions, and gendered rule. As addressed in greater detail in Chapter 3 , “global governance” sounds good and is presumably desirable in some form, but its current form obscures the predominantly nondemocratic and unaccountable forms of international rule.
In these senses, analyzing gendered divisions of power requires greater attention to politi-cal, economic, and sociocultural forces below and above the level of the state, thereby revealing the greater complexity of global politics, which cannot be reduced to the actions of state elites and their international organizations or the top-down “problem-solving” orientation they advocate. Such a lens reveals inequalities as a source of confl ict in global politics and illuminates divisions within groups—as well as linkages among groups—not only along national lines but also along gender, race, class, sexuality, and culture lines. The corollary of this, addressed in the fi nal chapter, is that many people are resisting global-politics-as-usual by fi nding common cause with each other across national boundaries and “identity politics” and thus creating a diff erent kind of international relations from that of elite policymakers.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Fem IR updates › Neg › Gendered lens alt
Marysia Zalewski, 2018 (Zalewshi, author and professor of International Relations at Cardiff University. “Feminist Approaches to International Relations Theory in the Post-Cold War Period” part of The Age of Perplexity: Rethinking the World We Knew /// MF)
I opened with a somewhat provocative statement about the intent of feminist scholarship. It might be perceived that I ‘overstate’ the case to draw attention. Yet I maintain that the feminist critique of the underlying knowledge structures on which studies of international politics relies, and which are drawn from long standing philosophical, political and even mythical foundations, poses a very significant challenge. Beginning with the recognition that women and the traditionally ‘feminine’ have been rendered absent or irrelevant in the realm of international politics, it appears that the remedy is not simply to ‘add women in’ -as if they were men. The challenge to the study and practice of international politics demands much more rigorous and effective work in both theory and practice. There have been some notable changes on the global political landscape since 1989, but just a cursory glance will confirm hardly a dent in the realm of global violence, perhaps an increase. Of course, feminist scholarship cannot resolve all these violences, but the vast corpus of knowledge produced since 1989, knowledge which stems for questions drawn from the submerged work and activities of more than half the world’s population, bears much more serious and sustained attention.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Fem IR updates › Neg › Gendered lens alt
Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Introduction, pgs 10-11 /// MF)
The power of gender produces a common sense of privileging the masculine and devaluing the feminine that is culturally and collectively internalized to such an extent that we are all variously complicit in its reproduction. It is also implicitly and explicitly manipulated to reproduce inequalities as if they were natural and inevitable, thus undercutting critique and resistance. In these ways, devalorizing through feminizing produces even as it obscures vast inequalities of power, authority, and resource distribution.
Examples of how the power of gender, as an ordering system that valorizes or privileges what is deemed masculine and devalorizes or subordinates what is deemed feminine in order to naturalize inequalities and power relations, extends beyond hierarchically dividing women and men to hierarchically dividing peoples, places, cultures, practices, institutions, and even ideas and concepts in the global system can be seen in Table 1.1 . The processes of masculin-ization as valorization and feminization as devalorization powerfully organize our thinking as to what is valued and thus prioritized and what is not valued and thus denigrated in the study (explored more in Chapter 2 ) and practice (explored more in Chapters 3 , 4 , and 5 ) of global politics. To better see how gender as a power relation combines in complex ways with other structural power relations, such as colonialism, imperialism, militarism, racism, and economic and environmental exploitation, to normalize social, political, and economic divisions, inequalities, and injustices, a gendered lens is necessary. The term “gendered” is used in this text, unless otherwise specifi ed, as a shorthand to signal the application of an intersectional analysis to examine interlocking relations of inequality in global politics. The next section provides an overview of how hierarchical gender divisions that foreground the normative masculine–feminine dynamic are intertwined with gender ed hierarchical divi-sions that foreground how gender is never separate from and powerfully informs hierarchical divisions based on race, ethnicity, class, sexuality, nationality, age, ability, and so on. Adopting a gendered lens also more fully reveals how these divisions are productive of and reproduced by global crises, also introduced in the following section.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Fem IR updates › Neg › Gendered lens alt
Anne Runyan, 2019 (Runyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Interview – Anne Sisson Runyan” E-International Relations. March 8, 2019. /// MF)
In my work with V. Spike Peterson over several editions of Global Gender Issues between 1993 and 2014 and in my most recent , I came to make a distinction between a gender lens, which foregrounds masculine and feminine dynamics through which hierarchical dichotomies are naturalized and enforced in world politics, and a gendered lens, which attends to the ways in which race, class, sexual, and national power relations intersect with gender power relations to produce multiple, differing, and shifting femininities and masculinities. A gendered lens is necessary for seeing how gender combines in complex ways with other structural power relations, such as colonialism, imperialism, racism, and economic and environmental exploitation, to normalize a range of social, political, and economic divisions, inequalities, and injustices.
A gendered lens also resists the reduction of gender to “adding women” as is popular and problematic in policymaking circles. And it alerts us to the work that gender does, especially when deployed in this fashion, to cover up and smooth over what Spike and I termed global and systemic crises of representation, insecurity, and sustainability. An exemplar of how this works, which I address in the postscript of the second edition of , is in the case of the immediate aftermath of the Great Financial Crisis, when increasing the number of risk-averse women financial managers was briefly trumpeted as a panacea for avoiding such crises in future, relying on biologically determinist constructions of women saviors from testosterone-fueled men. This discursive move (which did not result in any serious material change in the gender make-up of financial services personnel) served to sidestep critical analysis of the systemic nature and costs of gendered financialization.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Fem IR updates › Neg › impact
Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Gender and Global Security, pgs. 86-87 /// MF)
Hence, feminists argue that to understand violence and insecurities, we must look not only within particular “levels” but also at the linkages among them. According to Ann Tickner,
Feminist perspectives on security would assume that violence, whether it be in the inter-national, national, or family realm, is interconnected. Family violence must be seen in the context of wider power relations; it occurs within a gendered society in which male power dominates at all levels . . .. Any feminist defi nition of security must therefore include the elimination of all types of violence, including violence produced by gender relations of domination and subordination.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Fem IR updates › Neg › impact
Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Gender and Global Security, pg. 86 /// MF)
War—its causes and eff ects—animated and has long dominated the study of IR. Since the Cold War period, war has been studied in IR under the rubric of “security” studies. In (neo)realist security studies, the maintenance of security is understood as controlling and contain-ing, but not eliminating, direct violence between state militaries through balances of military power and nuclear terror as well as collective security measures that rely on sustaining both credible threats to use force and the actual use of force. Ironically and problematically, this ensures the continued growth of militaries and the continuation of war to promote security—but only the security of the state, not necessarily of people within or across states, and certainly not of the planet.
The early post-Cold War period of the 1990s brought more interest within the discipline in wider defi nitions of security, ranging from economic to human, environmental, and even food security. These redefi nitions occurred in the face of new “threats” to state security (such as globalization and global warming, discussed in the next chapter), but also newly recognized notions of security arising from critical perspectives (including feminist ones) entering the fi eld, which pointed out that state security often compromised the welfare of people and the planet. Nevertheless, conventional security studies enjoyed somewhat of a resurgence in the post-9/11 period because decisions to engage in interstate and intrastate confl ict and the globalized “war on terror” once again spiked militarized violence. The resurgent interest in direct violence has once again been at the expense of attending to structural violence and the insecurities generated by structural inequalities. We must be mindful that direct and indirect (structural) violence are not separate but interdependent. The inequalities of the latter shape the expression of the former. As dire as are the eff ects of direct violence, indirect violence shapes the lives of all of us all of the time—and especially injures women and other subordi-nated and marginalized people.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Fem IR updates › Neg › impact
Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Gender(ed) Lenses on Global Politics, pg 46 /// MF)
Recent generations of feminist IR researchers (some of whom have worked in or with international agencies) also engage in a signifi cant amount of quantitative research to have a greater and more meaningful impact on international policymaking (Den Boer 2016). Although feminist IR scholars have long relied on governmental, non-governmental, and UN gender-diff erentiated data produced during and continuously since the UN Decade for Women (which are also used in this text), but knowing how incomplete and insuffi cient this most often statistical information can be, some are now producing extensive and continuously expanded and updated databases, such as WomanStats (see Box 2.1 ). Some have also engaged in large-scale studies, drawing upon existing, and creating new, databases, on the impact of international policymaking on women and the relationship between women’s status and global problems. For example, in the last decade, such research has showed that women’s literacy, access to reproductive health services, and employment have increased in states that have ratifi ed and observed CEDAW, most markedly in secular states with eff ective legal systems (Simmons 2009), and that the higher the level of violence against women within a state, the higher the likelihood it will engage in war, with violence against women rates being more signifi cant than levels of democracy, religion, wealth, and racial disparities as predictors of state peacefulness or bellicosity (Hudson et al. 2008/9). Such research is positivist to the degree that it treats gender (as well as race, class, nationality, and so on) as a variable, operationalizing it often as female sex and women’s rights in relation to a host of other variables. While this has yielded major fi ndings which tell us gender not only matters, but centrally matters in global politics, fem-inist IR researchers cannot control if and how policymakers make use of such fi ndings, nor does it particularly challenge the preference for positivist, quantitative measures in inter-national policymaking.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Fem IR updates › Neg › Intersectionality
Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Gender(ed) Lenses on Global Politics, pgs 39-40/// MF)
These points are crucial to the arguments of this text because the perpetuation of dichotomized thinking and its gendered normalizations reproduces hierarchical divisions and, hence, antagonistic relations between groups. But the power of gender also operates to obscure intersectionality, and, thus, the gendered power relations and divisions discussed in Chapter 1 . When the power of gender focuses attention on essentialized notions of gender—masculinity and femininity—we fail to see these as constructed and crosscutting dimensions operating within any particular group and across groups. This is among the problems with the way in which gender has been taken up by international policymakers, not as a matter of equality and social justice, but rather instrumentalizing women’s empowerment to try to “fi x” serial crises without addressing deeper ones that arise from not only gender but also gendered divisions. Similarly, when essentialized notions of group identities erase the diff erentiations within them, we fail to see the complexity of social orders and how inequalities are often sustained by pitting subordinated groups against each other. We are seeing this now in the rise of illiberal democracies resulting from the cultivation of ethno-nationalist and masculin-ist political backlash, associated with some (typically white, global North, working-class, and heterosexual) men falling down the economic ladder and “strong man” political rhetoric that places the blame for this on groups also in increasing and often greater precarity. Such blaming defl ects attention from the global crises that are producing and are the result of vast and intersecting inequalities, while undermining the equality struggles of all subordinated groups. This militates against the potential for coalitions and more comprehensive resistances to unjust social and global political orders. Deploying intersectional analysis facilitates a more comprehensive notion of gender equality that is indivisible from racial, class, and sex-ual equality and equality among nations. It encourages contemporary feminist IR scholars to ask not just “Where are the women?” but also “Which women?” and “Where are the men and which men?”
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Fem IR updates › Neg › Intersectionality
Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Introduction, pgs 5-6 /// MF)
Contemporary gender studies that partake of intersectional analysis, which holds that gender cannot be understood in isolation from other identity categories and relations of inequality, recognize that there are multiple genders, as well as sexes, in part because race/ethnicity, class, sexuality, and other cultural variations shape gender identities and performances. The concept of intersectional analysis emerged from the work of black US feminist theorists in the 1980s and beyond (Crenshaw 1991; Collins 1991) who recognized that the lives and experiences of women of color were underrepresented in dominant Western feminist theories about women’s subordination that were based on the experiences of largely white, Western, middle-class, and/or working-class women.
Because the particular characteristics associated with femininity and masculinity vary signifi cantly across cultures, races, classes, and age groups, there are no generic women and men, cis or trans. Our gender identities, loyalties, interests, and opportunities are intersected and crosscut by countless dimensions of “diff erence,” especially those associated with ethnicity/race, class, national, and sexual identities. “Acting like a man” (or a “woman”) means diff er-ent things to diff erent groups of people (e.g., trans people, heterosexual Catholics, Native Americans, British colonials, agriculturists versus corporate managers, athletes versus orchestra conductors, combat soldiers versus military strategists) and to the same group of people at diff erent points in time (e.g., nineteenth- versus twentieth-century Europeans, col-onized versus postcolonial Africans, pre-puberty versus elderly age sets, women during war versus women after war). Men may be characterized as feminine (e.g., Mahatma Gandhi, “fl amboyant” gay men) and women as “masculine” (e.g., Margaret Thatcher, “butch” lesbians). Gender is shaped by race (models of masculinity and femininity vary among Africans, Indians, Asians, Europeans), and race is gendered (gender stereotypes shape racial stereo-types of Africans, Indians, Asians, whites). Moreover, because masculinities and femininities vary (by class, race/ethnicity, sexuality, age), some expressions of gender (Hispanic in the US, Muslim in India, Turkana in Kenya) are subordinated to dominant constructions of ender (Anglo, Hindu, Kikuyu). There are thus multiple masculinities that not only vary across cultures but also confer diff erent levels of power. What is referred to as “hegemonic masculinity” (Connell 1987, 1995) is the ideal form of masculinity performed by men with the most power attributes, who not incidentally populate most global power positions. These are typically white, Western, upper-class, straight cismen who have conferred on them the complete range of gender, race, class, national, and sexuality privileges. “Subordinated masculinities” (Connell 1987, 1995) are embodied by those who lack one, some, or all these privileges and are consequently rendered feminized and thus devalorized (a process explored more in this chapter) on these scores. Although all femininities are subordinated to all mascu-linities, it is also the case that some femininities are subordinated more than or diff erently from others. The idealized image of Western femininity remains associated with Victorian notions of womanhood that celebrated the gentility, passivity, decorativeness, and asexuality imposed on white, middle- to upper-class women, who were the only ones who could enact such standards. Working-class women, women of color, and/or lesbians or trans women are either denied the (dubious) status of feminine because they cannot meet these standards or are feminized in other ways through processes of racialization and/or sexualization . For example, since the times of slavery and colonization, women of color have been labeled as naturally oversexual, thereby not only being unworthy of (white) male protection but also particularly open to (white) male sexual exploitation.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Fem IR updates › Neg › Intersectionality
Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Introduction, pg 7 /// MF)
Because models of appropriate gender behavior are diverse, we know that femininity and masculinity are not timeless or separable from the contexts in which they are embodied, acted out, and observed. This illustrates how gender rests not on biological sex differences but on interpretations or constructions of behavior that are culturally specific, that shift as contexts change, and that typically have little to do with biological differences, which themselves are not fixed as some bodies are born neither “male” nor “female” and gender and sex assignments can be altered. In short, there are multiple genders and gender orderings, but gender is always raced, classed, sexualized, and nationalized, just as race, class, sexuality, and nationality are always gendered. Hence, gender analysis must avoid stereotyping (or reducing people to unfounded caricatures), essentializing (or assuming “natural” and unchanging characteristics), and singling out any one identity as descriptive of a whole person. Instead, gender analysis must adopt intersectional analyses to make sense of our multiple, crosscutting, and differentially valorized identities. However, these variations still rest on concepts of gender differences and do not necessarily disrupt the power of gender as an oppositional dichotomy and as a relation of inequality.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Fem IR updates › Neg › Intersectionality
Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Introduction, pg 1/// MF)
In this introductory chapter, an overview is presented of the contemporary relationships between gender and global politics. It begins with a conceptual discussion of gender as a dichotomous power relation and normative ordering power, referred to as the power of gen-der , a meta-lens that fosters dichotomization, stratification, and depoliticization in thought and action through the processes of masculinization and feminization , thereby sustaining global power structures and crises that prevent, militate against, or reverse meaningful advances in social equality and justice. It then addresses why adopting not only a gender lens , but more importantly a gendered lens , informed by intersectional thinking, is important for understanding how the gender interacts with other power relations, such as race, class, sexuality, and nationality (including power relations among nations as well as those based on national origin) to produce both gender and gendered divisions of power , violence , and labor and resources in global governance, global security, and global political economy, the principal areas of inquiry in the study of International Relations (IR). These divisions, in turn, keep in place and exacerbate the crises of representation, insecurity, and sustainability in global politics, which are also introduced.
In the remainder of this introductory chapter, how gender politics became more salient in national and international policymaking in recent decades is raised. A host of international institutions have been adopting some understandings produced by gender-centered research in IR that make links between raising the status of women worldwide and addressing global crises, including democratic deficits, armed conflict and other violence, and poverty and environmental degradation. However, as also raised, the deepening of such crises has also led to a backlash not only against international institutions, but also with respect to nascent attention to women’s rights with the recent rise of ethnic, economic, and belligerent nationalisms in several parts of the world. This rise of such new authoritarianisms associated with “strong man” politics, as also pointed out, is also a feature of contemporary global gender politics. Thus, a gendered lens is required to better understand these conflicting responses to global crises and the insufficiencies and problematics of both to address them.