Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Kritik
K—Racial IR—FMPS › ALT › Alt---Post-Racist Critical IR

Vote negative for post-racist critical IR scholarship – revealing the Westphilian epistemologies present in the aff is critical to holding them accountable for their double standards and working towards decolonization

Hobson 07(John, Professor of Politics and International Relations at the University of Sheffield, “Is critical theory always for the white West and for Western imperialism? Beyond Westphilian towards a post-racist critical IR”, CS)

If Eurocentrism portrays the West as bringing the world to heel, post-racist emancipatory politics seeks to bring the world to heal. How, then, might we begin to imagine this? Post-racist IR singles out analyses of identity-formation and civilisational dialogues/dialectics as the first port of call for a global emancipatory politics. The centre-piece of racism as it has been constructed in the West is a repressing of the Other in the Self. It is precisely this that underpins the Eurocentric construction of a line of civilisational apartheid, which creates the illusion of a pure, self-generating, supremacist White Western Self. Accepting the Other in the Self and recognising that the Self is therefore hybrid must be central to the process of global reconciliation. The second step is, however, much more fraught but all the more pressing nevertheless – namely the creation of a political dialogue between East and West.100 This can take the form of a counter-hegemonic bloc comprising a rainbow coalition of groups from the West though mainly from the East, which can articulate an alternative discourse to challenge Eurocentric post-racism. Still, there are undoubtedly many hurdles that stand in its way. These include the not inconsiderable spiritual capital that Westerners have invested in their Eurocentric identity; the economic interests of capital in maintaining post-racist neo-colonialism; and, ironically, those Eastern political elites who embrace Eurocentrism in order to hold on to power. But global reconciliation need not be portrayed as an impossible dawn, for there is historical precedent here in the shape of the Eastern nationalist movements that successfully challenged the discourse of empire. And while decolonisation has been succeeded by the imposition of post-racist policies this should not detract from the success of Eastern resistance agency in terminating formal empire. Decolonisation also provides a crucial precedent given that ‘the setting of the sun on the British empire’ was always portrayed by the British elites as an impossible dusk. Salutary too is that Nelson Mandela’s long walk to freedom would also have appeared prior to its success as a feat too far. Naeem Inayatullah and David Blaney argue that this political dialogue needs to work on an empathic approach in which both sides appeal to their own experiences of suffering.101 This needs to be coupled with a major injection of humility in the West, which can be enabled by revealing, and facing up to, the massive moral debt that it owes the East (given that the East did so much to enable the West’s rise through both dialogue and sacrifice). In any case, failure to do this is to be complicit with that which went on not just in the past but also in the last fifty years. But alongside these rhetorical manoeuvres, the Eastern and Western spokespersons need to emphasise the contradictions and double standards that underpin contemporary post-racist Western foreign policy. Here they need to engage not simply in dialogue but a dialogical dialectic wherein the East prosecutes the unfair and hypocritical practices of the post-racist West in what might be called the ‘global court of social justice’. This is not a legal entity, though it is governed like any (formal) court by a certain set of (social) norms that adjudicate over what is right and wrong. The nationalist movements effectively prosecuted the West in the global court of social justice through ‘mimetic challenge’,102 or ‘rhetorical entrapment’,103 where they rendered empire illegitimate by appealing to Western social norms of justice, since there was no other way of revealing the racist double standards that the West committed in its imperial policies (much as the Black Jacobins had done in the earlier Haitian revolution).104 Crucially, if revealing the racism of empire had such powerful import in effecting decolonisation, then why cannot the strategy of revealing post-racism today equally be used to decolonise contemporary neo-colonialism? Thus a counter-hegemonic bloc needs to work within the interstices of Western discourse to reveal the postracist contradictions and double standards that it consciously and subconsciously smoothes over, in order to demonstrate how the West currently fails to uphold its own self-referential norms of human justice. Appealing only to Eastern norms would most likely be rejected out of hand by the West with no progress forward possible. Indeed, ‘[f]or the oppressed it is a strategic necessity to address the oppressor in its own language, the language which it knows and understands: indeed the point is to manipulate the self-understanding of the oppressor’.105 Besides, no court can operate according to conflicting norms. And it is to the West that the East must turn if only because it currently holds disproportionate (though not anthropomorphic) power. Still, this dialogical project is one that can simultaneously benefit the West.106 For as noted, Eurocentrism leads to the repression and sublimation of the Other in the Self. Thus doing away with Eurocentrism can end the sociopsychological angst and alienation that necessarily occurs through such sublimation. Indeed, the ultimate irony is that racist/post-racist Western imperialism has underdeveloped the Western Self. And so, hopes for Western emancipation must to an important extent lie with the ‘Eastern civilising mission’ and the associated ‘Black Human’s Burden’, which can launch the Western peoples on an ethnographic maiden Voyage of Self-discovery that, with humility, empathy and above all sincerity, steers around the icebergs of tragic self-deception to return fully humanised. In the process, we take one giant leap towards a global dream that exorcises the global nightmare of cycles of war and Western civilising missions – a dream in which the dusk of post-racism brings in its wake the dawn of a new era wherein the peoples of the world can finally sit down at the table of global humanity and communicate together as equal partners.

2022 Michigan Kritik
K—Racial IR—FMPS › Framework › AT: Evaluating Scholarship Bad

Their evidence is the product of the system that encouraged it---methodological whiteness is unquestionably accepted as the true logic of security studies, creating a never-ending cycle of securitization and threat construction

Gani and Marshal 22(Jasmine, PhD in International Relations from the London School of Economics, Jenna, PhD Political Science, Queen Mary University of London, “The impact of colonialism on policy and knowledge production in International Relations”, CS)

If academia has had a long history of supplying imperial policy through its knowledge production, the reverse has also been true—it is not a unidirectional process. Thus, imperial policies and those that embed racial injustices have often provided the starting-point for academic enquiry, with imperialist and racist constructions taken as the material reality from which to launch any research, without historicization or interrogation of whether that is how it has to be. The risk of academia being a mule for unjust and oppressive assumptions generated through colonial and racist practice looms even larger with the increased emphasis in academia on the necessity of applying for and obtaining research grants. Many funding bodies are dependent on state subsidies, or are financed by the corporate sector or by benefactors from the business and political elite.27 When it comes to selecting prize-winners, the committees are often made up of members from the business community to assess the potential ‘real world’ (and presumably monetary) impact of the proposed research. Thus academia is not a bastion of intellectual autonomy, but is increasingly allowing the parameters and goals of research to be delineated by practitioners and their priorities. Where those practitioners have vested interests (as is often likely, even if not always the case) in a social, economic and political status quo that upholds systemic discrimination against marginalized communities, the potential for deep-rooted long-term change becomes muted. This special issue accordingly demonstrates how academic knowledge production risks reifying colonial and racial injustices. Like so-called impartial reporting in journalism, which indirectly becomes a convenient and efficient means for political elites to distribute their messages, IR as a discipline can end up being a disseminator of the rationales and motives of policy-makers. Thus the supposed neutrality of analytical theorizing and empiricism,28 which claim merely to observe and predict impartially the way the world is and will be without problematization, can be seen as complicit in normalizing what should in fact be treated as abnormal, even unacceptable. Several contributions apply this argument to particular regions and debates where the inherent absorption of unjust practices and erasures within knowledge production is particularly egregious. The articles by Kwaku Danso and Kwesi Aning, and by Somdeep Sen, both call for greater challenges to the centrality of the state in IR, and criticize the way it has mirrored an (often colonial) international practice of delegitimizing non-state actors. In their article, Danso and Aning complicate Weberian notions of the state monopoly on violence, extending validity and recognition to non-state actors in their ability to act as authoritative avenues for dispute resolution.29 They further make the case for the unsettling of knowledge within security studies, especially when engaging with the African continent, arguing that methodological whiteness has been unquestioningly accepted as the logic that underpins much of security studies discourse. This lack of problematization racializes Africa as ungovernable, and flattens or often entirely negates any substantive understandings of the complexities of lived experiences.30 Their article also makes visible the ways in which academic eagerness to supply regional case-studies for the sake of policy relevance and proof of ‘universal theories’ impact people’s lived realities. They make their point explicit through an illustration of the ‘war on terror’ discourses within the Sahel region. Providing an alternative example, Sen argues that academic scholarship has contributed to the concretization of the state and its violence as ‘normal politics’, while insurgency (or, in other words, anti-colonial resistance) is thereby rendered ‘unnatural’ and existentially dangerous for global order.31 In failing to question the sanctity of the state, scholars have been complicit in upholding colonial practice and the outlawing of resistance, consigning it beyond the realm of acceptable politics, as seen in contexts such as Palestine. Sharri Plonski and Nivi Manchanda extend these arguments about unsettling the fixity of the state and its borders, but also expand where we look to first to identify the producers of knowledge.32 Thus, they argue knowledge is not necessarily always produced within the academy, but often is first made (and indeed exchanged and concretized) through (colonial) practice and, in turn, via normalization that converts the practice into ‘fact’ that goes unchallenged by academic knowledge producers. Their article demonstrates the way colonial and racist knowledges are nourished, upheld and validated by silences within broader epistemic communities—communities in which the boundaries between academics, policy-makers and corporations are much more fluid than a strict binary between academics and practitioners. Recognizing this fluidity also serves to disrupt the ‘bridge the gap’ debate discussed at the outset of this article.

2022 Michigan Kritik
K—Racial IR—FMPS › Framework › Being DA

Their framework is a form of liberalism that pacifies violence and legitimizes military action creating zones of being and nonbeing

Van Milders and Toros 20(Lucas, Assistant Professor in Critical Security Studies at the University of Groningen, Harmonie, Deputy Director of Institute of Cyber Security for Society (iCSS) at University of Kent, “Violent International Relations”, CS)

Indeed, the ‘international’ nature of IR and of its scholars make the discipline a ‘frontline’ discipline that often resides in practices along the abyssal lines between the zones of being and nonbeing. This is caused by the object of enquiry of the discipline – formally the power relations between states but, as is increasingly recognised, the power relations between people. It is also caused by the practices of the discipline – the need to perform the role and lifestyle of the international expert for research, dissemination and increasingly impact. There are many ways in which this is distributed across the discipline, yet what the iterations of disciplinary violence in IR tend to have in common is a further proliferation of the limits of IR as essentially an abyssal line. This concerns, for instance, the decadent or disciplinary nature of mainstream IR, widely critiqued elsewhere (such as in Ashley and Walker, 1990 and Weber, 2014 to name but two separated by decades). However, critical strands of IR theory might have, despite their efficacy at exposing the violence performed by mainstream IR, implicitly (and presumably undeliberately) contributed to the image of the critical theorist as an expert or intellectual, characterised by the privilege to withdraw politically and theorise both systemically as well as globally (Linklater, 1996). This image subsequently solicits and naturalises a range of theoretical inquiries that not only stem from the zone of being but also, as mentioned above, continue to demarcate an abyssal line around the discipline. This has, in recent years, allowed for the continued support for Western military violence in post-colonial states, even when such instances have had disastrous effects (see debate between Dunne and Gelber, 2014, Hehir, 2015, and again Dunne and Gelber, 2015 as well as the critique of feminist support for war in Afghanistan in Wibben, 2011). The violent nature of IR is also evident from its inclusion of non-Western forms of theory (typically presented as reactionary and anti-Western) on the premise that they do not challenge the discipline’s inherently Western epistemology (Buzan, 2018). The violence of IR theory is then characterised by its capacity and often willingness to maintain relations of both material as well as epistemic coloniality. This article is not about pointing accusatory fingers at specific instances of disciplinary and epistemic violence, which would indeed aid to exceptionalise said violence. Yet the question remains: what marks the violence of IR that cannot be solely attributed to the fact that it is a discipline like any other, and can we study IR without reproducing said violence? To clarify, the type of violence we are talking about is not merely the direct violence of physical and material force or the indirect violence of the aggregate actions of social groups or institutions, such as a refugee crisis or the concentration of wealth. Rather, it is the violence of pacification: a form of domination that (re)structures the political order and ensures that violent resistance against it is infrequent (Baron et al., 2019: 203). The violence of pacification is often inconspicuous, yet it operates through means of coercion that are rendered visible whenever they are resisted. As such, it is similar to Slavoj Žižek’s discussion of the maintaining function of objective violence in capitalist ideology that incites the eruption of subjective violence of anti-capitalist struggles and riots (2009). In IR, this pacification is distributed through the so-called liberal world order, often celebrated for bestowing the world with liberal peace and a decline of violence (Ikenberry, 2009; Pinker, 2012). Yet liberal pacification is still violent, as ‘it coerces a specific type of liberal docility, while also preventing types of resistance that might be understood as violent, including riots, insurrections, civil wars, and inter-state wars. Pacification reveals the ongoing violence at the heart of a political project that imagines itself to be against violence’ (Baron et al., 2019: 207). As it concerns the shaping and maintaining of a political order that seeks to hide its apparatus of violent coercion, the violence of pacification also intersects with the epistemic violence that is distributed through a colonial epistemology. It is indeed the epistemic violence that seeks to silence marginalised groups such as the subaltern nonspecialists, the illiterate peasantry, and the urban subproletariat (Spivak, 1994). Through IR’s violence, the international is reconfigured into a discipline that silences these voices in a seemingly non-violent way by subjugating their experiences as in need of translation or assimilation into expert knowledge that can be evaluated against disciplining/disciplinary criteria, that is, impact. So as opposed to trivilialising IR’s violence by exceptionalising it, we rather seek to highlight the deeply embedded nature of this violence across the discipline, although of course distributed to varying degrees.

2022 Michigan Kritik
K—Racial IR—FMPS › Framework › Privilege DA

Their evidence comes from a position of privilege---their authors ignore the complex racialization of great power relations compromising the quality of their theorizing and the field of IR itself

Peterson 21(V Spike, professor of international relations in the School of Government and Public Policy at the University of Arizona, “Critical privilege studies: Making visible the reproduction of racism in the everyday and international relations”, CS)

Familiar structural inequalities – of race, gender, class, nationality – and corresponding systems of privilege constitute relations of domination and subordination that figure centrally in the social violence and multiple crises that international relations and security scholars struggle to address. These scholars, however, rarely engage a critique of privilege when interpreting these processes, which effectively perpetuates the invisibility (naturalization) of power relations and precludes more adequate critical theorizing. Privilege refers to socially conferred unearned advantages available to some by being constitutively denied to others. Two implications of this structural relationship: the privilege enjoyed by dominant groups is literally at the expense of subordinated groups, and systemic inequalities do not only harm those who are dominated but significantly benefit – every day and over time, intentionally and unintentionally, directly and indirectly – those who are privileged. Failing to ‘see’ this crucial, consequential and structural relationship – and its affective consequences – has enormous implications for how adequately we understand the reproduction of, and responses to, entrenched inequalities and the social violence they generate. Not least, we need to ‘see’ that conditions generating internalized inferiority in those who are subordinated have the effect of naturalizing internalized superiority in those who can, and typically do, assume that the advantages of privilege and their practices of domination are ‘just the way things are’. Given the global expanse of harms, resentments, and violences that we confront, I argue that critical theorists – in security studies, international relations, and elsewhere – cannot afford to persist in neglecting privilege. This neglect perpetuates ignore-ance of consequential power relations and obscures how practices of privilege, every day and everywhere, operate to reinforce, normalize, and reproduce structural inequalities. I assume that critical security studies seeks to further a reduction in emotional and embodied harms produced by, and productive of, structural inequalities, and I argue that doing so requires accurately understanding and actively dismantling the power relations of privilege. Accordingly, I contend that failure to critically engage how privilege operates severely compromises both the quality of current theorizing and the future field of critical security studies. My contribution, then, situates racism in the intersectional matrix of structural inequalities, foregrounds how systems of privilege operate to reproduce this matrix and its many harms, and examines the role of white privilege in reproducing the invisibility and normalization of racism (and its related inequalities). I present a condensed overview of what I call ‘critical privilege studies’2 and indicate how this analytical framing contributes to ‘a radically different, anti- or nonracist [international relations] and everyday’ (Rutazibwa, 2016: 199). I argue that the systematic study of privilege shifts our attention, illuminates unfamiliar patterns, and enriches critical theorizing within and beyond international relations. Critical privilege studies makes distinctive contributions, primarily by examining how those who benefit the most – every day and everywhere – participate in reproducing inequalities, sometimes intentionally but also – most often and most problematically – when not ‘consciously’ intending to do so (but doing so all the same). The specific orientation of critical privilege studies reveals how normalization reproduces – while concealing – the power relations and structural logics of dominant–subordinate relations, and how behaving ‘normally’ in unequal systems reinforces and reproduces their hierarchies, whether intentionally or not. Critical privilege studies clarifies how privilege works to entrench and amplify systemic inequalities, while enabling those with privilege to be unaware of, habitually ignore, and also deny how privilege tilts the playing field in their favor – a reality that fosters feelings of superiority for some and inferiority for others. And by recognizing that everyone occupies multiple social categories, critical privilege studies uniquely engages the complex dynamics of theorizing intersectionality and points to the inadequacy of critical projects that focus exclusively on a single vector of oppression.

2022 Michigan Kritik
K—Racial IR—FMPS › Framework › Epistemology First

Epistemology comes first---the Kritik is a moment of invasion as we enter into IR centric spaces and introduce radical ideas---that shapes those spaces.

Gani and Marshal 22(Jasmine, PhD in International Relations from the London School of Economics, Jenna, PhD Political Science, Queen Mary University of London, “The impact of colonialism on policy and knowledge production in International Relations”, CS)

Thus far, a lot of responsibility for challenging the racial and colonial dynamics of the academic–practitioner nexus has been placed with knowledge producers, whether within or outside academia. But it is necessary to emphasize that efforts have already been under way, not only to ‘decolonize’ our academic disciplines, but to bring that discourse into the public realm. At that point practitioners need to carry their share of responsibility in listening to and applying the expertise (whether academic or community-based) that can foster more just policies. Instead, the attention policy-makers give to expertise is often selective and politicized, based not on what can actually improve people’s lives but on what helps to justify the existing approaches adopted by governments. The current denigration and growing securitization of critical race theory, especially in the United States but increasingly elsewhere, is an example of attacks on emancipatory knowledges that challenge power and oppression. Offering another stark example of this, Amal Abu-Bakare explores in her article the lack of any serious attempts to confront Islamophobia in society, despite the wealth of research and expert advice from scholars and community-based practitioners available to policy-makers.55 Focusing on the cases of the UK and Canada, she highlights the way in which practitioner intervention, in this case that of security and police officials, has actively prevented the adoption of expert guidelines on tackling Islamophobia on the grounds that they might interfere with their counterterrorism strategies. In many ways this is a blatant acknowledgement from policy-makers that their counterterrorism strategy is inherently built upon racial tropes and discrimination. In contrast, so-called ‘neutral’ research on terrorism and/or counterterrorism is embraced by practitioners, precisely because such research might not ask uncomfortable questions about the racial foundations or assumptions that are necessary to enact their policies. Abu-Bakare’s article offers an example of the limitations of academic–practitioner knowledge exchange. Exhorting scholars to make their research policy relevant does not address the unequal receptivity towards critical research that may challenge policy. Nor does it sufficiently take into account the implicit disciplining that can take place in that process of knowledge exchange. Those very spaces or channels that are created to facilitate sharing, listening and negotiation between knowledge producers and practitioners (through all the blurred boundaries between them) may reproduce and reify hierarchies through unequal interactions. Is real dialogue possible if power dynamics render the interlocutors unequal?56 Or, in their efforts to be heard, taken seriously, and make their presence worthwhile, academics and other knowledge producers may find themselves being subtly socialized into the very modes of speech and thought that they sought to criticize. This can also happen in reverse when grassroots practitioners share spaces with scholars and elite institutions. The path-breaking and radical ideas needed to initiate change on some of the most deep-seated problems in politics and society may be diluted in such spaces for the sake of pragmatism and communication, undermining the ability to imagine real alternatives to the status quo. This is not to say that knowledge producers, whether academic or community-based, should not engage with policy-makers, but rather that they should be clear in what they seek to achieve—if, for example, constructive dialogue or receptivity to expertise is unlikely, it is at times necessary and an ethical responsibility simply to register alternative ideas or contestation. Returning to the point made at the start of this piece, this cautions us in how we champion ‘impact’ and knowledge–policy engagement, especially if we only recognize engagements that supplement and are ‘useful’ to systems of power rather than those that hold them to account.

2022 Michigan Kritik
K—Racial IR—FMPS › Impact › AT: Realism True

Scholars critiquing realism are forced to make their theories fit within constraining models of conceptualization – it isn’t that realism is true, rather it is built to subvert critique

Henderson 13(Errol, Associate Professor of Political Science at Pennsylvania State University, “Hidden in plain sight: racism in international relations theory”, CS)

The centrality of race and racism in the foundations of IR and their enduring impact on world affairs towards the end of the millennium contrasts with the relative dearth of mainstream scholarship on the subject in IR. For example, Doty’s (1998, 136) survey of mainstream journals in IR for the period of 1945 –1993 (World Politics, International Studies Quarterly, International Organization, Journal of Conflict Resolution, Review of International Studies) ‘revealed only one article with the word race in the title, four with the term minorities and 13 with the term ethnicity’. Given that at its inception IR focused heavily on issues of race and racism, the marginalization of race and racism in mainstream IR journals (and textbooks) begs the question of what accounts for the apparent disparity? Doty (1998, 145) argues that ‘the dominant understandings of theory and explanation in International Relations’ preclude conceptualizations of ‘complex issues/concepts such as race’ and result in their marginalization or force them ‘into constraining modes of conceptualization and explanation’. For Krishna (2001, 401), the complexity is related less to the issue of racism than to the methodological orientations that often privilege abstract theorizing over historical analyses, which allows IR theorists to whitewash the historical content of global affairs, especially ‘the violence, genocide, and theft that marked the encounter between the rest and the West in the post-Columbian era’. Ignoring the role of racism facilitates this whitewash. He adds that ‘abstraction, usually presented as the desire of the discipline to engage in theory-building rather than in descriptive or historical analysis, is a screen that simultaneously rationalizes and elides the details of these encounters. By encouraging students to display their virtuosity in abstraction the discipline brackets questions of theft of land, violence, and slavery—the three processes that have historically underlain the unequal global order we now find ourselves in’ (Krishna 2001, 401– 402). Further, ‘overattention’ on the part of scholars to issues related to racism in IR ‘is disciplined by professional practices that work as taboo’ and may label such orientations as ‘too historical or descriptive’ and label such students as ‘not adequately theoretical’ and ‘lacking in intellectual rigor’ (Krishna 2001, 402). Moreover, where the impact of race and racism is analysed, insufficient attention is paid to the relevance of struggles related to race and racism to basic conceptions of fundamental issues in world politics such as power, war, freedom or democracy. For example, Persaud (2001, 116) maintains that ‘what needs to be underlined is that the struggle for racial equality has been fundamental to the emergence of democracy as a whole, not just for the colored world’ (2001, 116). Persaud and Walker (2001, 374) claim that race has not been ignored in IR as much as it ‘has been given the epistemological status of silence’. This silence is linked by Maclean (1981, 110) to ‘invisibility’, which ‘refers to the removal (not necessarily through conscious action) from a field of enquiry, either concrete aspects of social relations, or of certain forms of thought about them’. Vitalis (2000) also acknowledges a ‘norm against noticing’ white racism throughout mainstream IR discourse (also see Depelchin 2005). Each of these processes perpetuates the racist assumptions embedded in the foundations of IR theory where they serve as the ‘priors’ of the main propositions. These assumptions may be exposed by tracing the racist claims that inform IR theory. This approach is different from that undertaken in most studies of racism in IR, which usually focus on one of four approaches: (1) examinations of the impact of non-racial factors on racial outcomes, such as the geographical studies of Linneaus and the physical anthropological works of Blumenbach and Kant, which attempted to determine the extent to which environmental and climatic factors led to the creation of different races;3 (2) examinations of the impact of racial outcomes on non-racial factors, such as studies of the effects of racial stratification on domestic outcomes (for example, development or democracy), or the impact of racial differences on the likelihood of violence within or between states (for example, Deutsch 1970; Shepherd and LeMelle 1970); (3) examinations of the impact of racist practices on the IR of states and non-state actors, such as studies of diplomatic historians on racist practices such as international slavery, imperial conquest, colonialism, genocide, apartheid, occupation, or racial discrimination, among single states, several states, or international organizations (for example, Elkins 2004; Hochschild 1998; Tinker 1977; Vincent 1982; Winant 2001); and (4) examinations of the impact of racist ideology on the IR of states and nonstate actors, such as studies on the impact of racism on foreign policy (for example, Hunt 1987; Lauren 1988; Anderson 2003), imperialism (for example, Rodney 1974), state-making (for example, Cell 1982; Fredrickson 1982; Mamdani 1996; Marx 1998), diasporization (Harris 1982; Walters 1993) or international war (Dower 1986). While studies utilizing each of these approaches have contributed to our understanding of the role of racism in world politics, they have largely ignored the issue of primary concern to us here: how racism informs the major paradigms of IR theory such as realism and liberalism.4 Racism informs IR theory mainly through its influence on the empirical, ethical and epistemological assumptions that undergird its paradigms. These assumptions operate individually and in combination. For example, racist empirical assumptions bifurcate humanity on the basis of race and determine our view of what/whom we study and how we study it/them—privileging the experiences of ‘superior’ peoples and their societies and institutions. These assumptions also lead us to privilege ethical orientations of the ‘superior’ peoples which justify their privileged status. In such a context, epistemological assumptions that reflect and reinforce the racist dualism are more likely to become ascendant, and ‘knowledge’ that supports the racist dichotomy—both the privileged position of the racial hegemon and the underprivileged position of the racial subaltern—is more likely to be viewed as valid. Such knowledge drawn from the empirical domain becomes legitimized through ethical justifications that ‘naturalize’ the racial hierarchy. In this way, the separate dimensions often reinforce each other. Whether or not the empirical, ethical and epistemological assumptions operate singly or in combination, it is important to demonstrate the role of these assumptions in IR theory today, especially given that mainstream IR also provides prominent critiques of racism. Ignoring these critiques would misrepresent the degree of racism in the field and disregard the challenge to racist discourse within IR from IR theorists themselves. For example, few IR scholars openly embrace a racist ontology that assumes for whites a higher order of being than for nonwhites.5 Moreover, racist ethical assumptions usually receive the opprobrium they deserve in present IR discourse. Racist epistemological assumptions are largely challenged by the prevalence in IR theory of the view that our ‘knowledge’ of world politics usually requires us to have something approximating evidence to determine the accuracy of rival truth claims. Finally, racist empirical assumptions are checked by the dominant view in IR that our theses should be broadly applicable across states and societies and should be substantiated by crossnational and cross-temporal tests. But the sanguine view of the propensity of IR literature to check racist assumptions, or to generate non-racist theoretical discourse for the field, begs a fuller exploration of how ethical, epistemological and empirical assumptions underlie prominent theses in IR. The main sources of these racist assumptions that inform our present IR discourse are the primary theoretical constructs of most IR theory: the state of nature, the social contract and the conception of anarchy that derives from them.

2022 Michigan Kritik
K—Racial IR—FMPS › Impact › AT: Realism Good

Realism is bad, ensures racialization is cemented in all areas of IR.

Vitalis 2K(Robert, Professor of Political Science at the University of Pennsylvania, “The Graceful and Generous Liberal Gesture: Making Racism Invisible in American International Relations”, CS)

IR theorists have often hidden behind realism’s wings to face these kinds of criticism; they have argued that the distinctiveness of their subject matter sets them apart and makes the ‘norm against noticing’ irrelevant in this case. In relations among states, where material power and interest govern the behaviour of actors bent on survival in a violence-prone environment, an overarching logic of security and the national interest prevails. Even a ‘domestic politics’ of white supremacy, to use a familiar adage, stops at ‘the water’s edge’. Pursuit of this particular line of thought, however, would quickly take the naïve defender of an American-invented tradition down a slippery slope. The empirical quandary remains. ‘Until recently, race was a central category in international relations’ for statesmen, intellectuals, and the white working classes of the colonial powers and the industrialising colonial-settler states.17 More crucially still, realism’s own proximate indigenous roots in the US may be found in part in the ‘rising tide of colour’ theory in the 1920s and related strains of Anglo-Saxon declinism.18 Realism was not so much ‘founded’ in the 1940s by a wave of émigré continental European scholars, but recast in line with Cold War imperatives, which included the jettisoning of what was coming to be recognised as overt racist doctrines by whites who ruled the ‘kingdom of culture’ and the writing of a more useable past for their adopted discipline.19 What needs to be explained is not how a particular domain of intellectual life somehow escaped the bounds of ascriptive Americanism—it didn’t—but why the ‘norm against noticing’ appears to work so much more powerfully there than elsewhere inside the academy until now? The question, I believe, involves ‘domestic institutions’. Few signs remain of the academy’s insurgent moment inside professional IR in the US.20 The oppositional and anti-imperialist values that constituted the original identity of political economy in the 1960s and 1970s are reflected more powerfully today in parts of Anthropology, Cultural Studies, Gender Studies, Literature, and History than in Political Science, and more in British Political Science than in the American Political Science Association. This might be gauged by comparing the renaissance in the study of the culture of empire and American expansionism with the paucity of work by political scientists. One might look at the index of the New Left Review over the past two decades for a sense of what is ‘left’ in Political Science and who in American IR might be publishing there, aside from Richard Falk (answer: no one). Last, and undoubtedly most important, one might look around the room at the next seminar, conference plenary, or talk for insight into the culture of American IR and the operation of the ‘norm against noticing’. The absence of virtually any, let alone a critical mass of, black thinkers and writers in the field today goes a long way toward explaining why white supremacy remains an unexposed foundation of the field and why the Black Atlantic remains an unrecognised source (for mostly white IR scholars that is) of the emancipatory counter-currents that we know today as imperialism theory, ‘underdevelopment’ ‘postcolonial theory’, dependencia, world systems analysis, and so on.

2022 Michigan Kritik
K—Racial IR—FMPS › Impact › AT: Liberalism Good

Liberal peace is inseparable from the violent façade of liberal pacification which obscures the escalating cycle of phenomenological violence at the heart of the world order that kills value to life and ensures nuclear war

Baron, et al, 19—Associate Professor in the School of Government and International Affairs at Durham University (Ilan Zvi, with Jonathan Havercroft, Associate Professor in International Political Theory at the University of Southampton, Isaac Kamola, assistant professor of political science at Trinity College, Jonneke Koomen, Associate Professor of Politics, Sociology and Women’s and Gender Studies at Willamette University, Alex Prichard, senior lecturer in International Relations at the University of Exeter, and Justin Murphy, anticlimactically just an independent scholar, “Liberal Pacification and the Phenomenology of Violence,” International Studies Quarterly (2019) 63, 199–212, dml) [ableist language modifications denoted by brackets]

Phenomenology, as we are using it, is not about lived experience. It is the philosophical tradition of revealing different types of beings and things that contain meaning in our world, the structures and/or contexts in which they exist, and how these structures and contexts are meaningful. Understood in this way, violence is one of these structures and/or contexts. A phenomenological perspective does not approach violence from a particular normative position, although it does not preclude normative critique. A phenomenological approach does not treat violence as a discrete thing that one agent does to another, although it does not preclude such acts being described as violent. Instead, a phenomenological perspective adds to our intellectual and methodological toolbox by identifying violence as a condition or context in which people function. Phenomenology allows us to identify violence occurring in ways and in places that we otherwise would not be able to recognize. It does not change the meaning of violence (as harm, for example). Instead, it treats violence ontologically, enabling us to reveal more accurately the extent to which violence exists in the world.

From a phenomenological perspective, violence is often inconspicuous. Violence can function as a naturalized or internalized regime of compulsion or domination. Pacification reveals both the pervasiveness of violence and forms of violence that may otherwise remain inconspicuous. The erasing of tradition and the enforcement of particular legal codes at the expense of indigenous cultural norms is one example of an inconspicuous form of violence that involves conspicuous and inconspicous consequences (Cocks 2014). In understanding violence phenomenologically, as a structure of revealing across multiple worlds, we are better able to reveal the extent to which violence shapes our world and how we are then shaped by violence.

2022 Michigan Kritik
K—Racial IR—FMPS › Impact › AT: Our Threats are Real

Western epistemology will always present itself as indisputably true---subjecting the rest of the world to disempowerment and objectification

Van Milders and Toros 20(Lucas, Assistant Professor in Critical Security Studies at the University of Groningen, Harmonie, Deputy Director of Institute of Cyber Security for Society (iCSS) at University of Kent, “Violent International Relations”, CS)

We advance here a two-pronged conception of disciplinary violence. On the one hand, as is argued in this section, the epistemic violence of colonial disciplinarity shuts down debate and critique and leaves unhindered violent regimes of governmentality. On the other hand, as it will be argued in the next section, this form of violence is epitomised in the international expert. What moulds this all together is, apart from disciplinary fragmentation and hierarchy, the insulation of rational, objective and universal knowledge (typically associated with Western epistemology) from irrational, subjective and particular knowledge (although it is commonly referred to as experience or a perspective as opposed to knowledge). What this concerns is a colonial matrix of power that is based on a racist classification of the world (Quijano, 2007: 171). This is indeed one, as Kerem Nisancioglu argues in this issue, that still affects IR’s racialised account of one of its key elements of analysis: sovereignty (2020). The colonial infrastructure of knowledge production is thus part of a much broader matrix of colonial hierarchies that were imposed through European imperialism since 1492. This involved, among others, a racist hierarchy that privileged European whiteness and a sexist hierarchy that privileged the European masculinity (Grosfoguel, 2009). Indeed, the colonial framework is deeply racist and gendered, and we understand it as such in this article. It also includes a global epistemic hierarchy that privileges the Western mode of knowledge production as the only viable way of producing knowledge that is universal, objective, neutral and scientific. As mentioned above, this concerns ideas about organising, classifying and storing knowledge, yet it is specifically by hiding its locus of enunciation that its claims towards universality are facilitated. Indeed, similar to decadent disciplines, Western epistemology presents itself as coinciding with universality and is therefore capable of generating absolute knowledge by subjugating other modes of knowledge production as particular, subjective, biased and un-scientific. This epistemic subsequently operates through binary conceptions such as the West and the Rest that, on the one hand, consolidate a position of imperial hegemony while, on the other, cement other perspectives, knowledges and experiences into a subjugated position (Hall, 1996). The result of this is, in the words of Frantz Fanon, a dividing of the world in a zone of being and zone of nonbeing. For if it is only the Western mode of knowledge production that is capable of generating universal knowledge, then this means that the Western experience itself necessarily corresponds to the experience of humanity as such. Everything else is not a different type of knowledge – since this would affect the appeal to universality that marks Western epistemology – but is simply non-existent. What separates the zone of nonbeing from the zone of being is an unsurmountable line that strips the non-Western other of their ontological resistance. In the zone of nonbeing, colonial racialisation inescapably subjects one to disempowerment and objectification. For Fanon, the reasons behind this are plain and simple: ‘The white man wants the world; he wants it for himself alone. He finds himself predestined master of this world. He enslaves it. An acquisitive relation is established between the world and him’ (Fanon, 2008: 97).

2022 Michigan Kritik
K—Racial IR—FMPS › Impact › AT: Not the Root Cause

IR is rooted in racism and eurocentrism

Lake et al. 21(David, Distinguished Professor of Political Science at the University of California, San Diego, Bianca Freedman, PhD candidate in the Department of Political Science at UC San Diego, D.G. Kim, Ph.D. candidate in the Department of Political Science at the University of California, San Diego, “Race in International Relations: Beyond the “Norm Against Noticing””, CS)

In a parallel fashion, as suggested above, race is hidden behind international law and the principle of sovereign equality. Rooted in conceptions of natural law, international law is necessarily universal and based on principles of equality. Yet, race was implicated in the development of international law almost from its very origins (see, e.g., Pitts 2018). The vision of equality at its core was immediately challenged by Europe’s encounter with the rest of the world during the age of discovery. If international law applied universally to peoples, their territory, and their existing governance structures, then Europeans would have to recognize these unfamiliar polities as equal to their own, which in turn would have prevented them from expropriating the land and enslaving those who lived on it. To justify expropriation, international law thus required the creation or application of racialized hierarchies that considered non-European societies as less than human. The interpretation of race as a stable, self-evident difference became the marker from which more elaborate notions of difference, like “civilization,” were constructed (Anghie 2006). In one such justification, John Locke declared the territory occupied by Indigenous peoples in the Americas as forfeit for their failure to enclose and cultivate the land (see Arneil 1996). In short, international law required Europeans to assign a lesser status to others in order to reconcile the conception of equality under the law that governed their own relations with the desire to exploit the “new worlds” they “discovered.” Thus, race was tethered to the rationale for conquest undertaken by European powers. Race continued to animate international law and relations between Europe and the rest of the world well into the twentieth century. In negotiations over the League of Nations in 1919, for instance, Japan’s proposed language on racial equality was rejected. Although it received broad support, US President Woodrow Wilson, who himself had resegregated the US civil service, was in the Chair and summarily declared that such an important change required unanimity, which effectively killed the proposal. Following World War II, renewed calls for formal racial equality at the San Francisco Conference in 1945 and later the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination in 1969 led to the prohibition of racism, but subtly embedded it in the precept of sovereignty and the corresponding doctrine of domestic jurisdiction that allowed member countries to prohibit international oversight of their domestic racial regimes(Búzás 2021). As a shield against foreign interference, sovereignty became a way of preserving racial inequality at home. Its universal standard also gave rise to an international legal order that obscured racism from view. By the mid-twentieth century, non-European societies acquired the status of sovereign state-hood previously denied by international law. On its face, decolonization overcame the notion that racial others were somehow not ready for full sovereignty (Grovogui 1996). In practice, however, writing race out of law was necessary to conceal, and therefore maintain, the uneven application of international norms and rules along constructed racial difference. By implication, formal manifestations of race are no longer permissible. But at the same time, the projection of racial deficiency by White-majority countries onto especially Black-majority states is found in the practice and interpretation of contemporary international law. Although engagement varies across the movement of critical race theories and Third World Approaches to International Law (TWAIL), much of the work within these reconstructive traditions has sought to uncover the ongoing dynamics of racialized power that constitute international law and relations. The racialization of international law can be seen in several contemporary legal and political trends that are at least implicitly premised on a conception of non-White-majority countries as being deficient and in need of assistance or corrective action by North American or European states

2022 Michigan Kritik
K—Racial IR—FMPS › Impact › AT: Empirics

Modern IR frameworks selectively employ willful amnesia to justify their methodology – their theories aren’t supported by empirics by rather by the blatant omission of them

Zvobgo and Loken 20(Kelebogile, assistant professor of government at the College of William & Mary and founder and director of the International Justice Lab, Meredith, Assistant Professor in the Department of Political Science at the University of Amsterdam, “Why Race Matters in International Relations”, CS)

Take the “big three” IR paradigms: realism, liberalism, and constructivism. These dominant frames for understanding global politics are built on raced and racist intellectual foundations that limit the field’s ability to answer important questions about international security and organization. Core concepts, like anarchy and hierarchy, are raced: They are rooted in discourses that center and favor Europe and the West. These concepts implicitly and explicitly pit “developed” against “undeveloped,” “modern” against “primitive,” “civilized” against “uncivilized.” And their use is racist: These invented binaries are used to explain subjugation and exploitation around the globe While realism and liberalism were built on Eurocentrism and used to justify white imperialism, this fact is not widely acknowledged in the field. For instance, according to neorealists, there exists a “balance of power” between and among “great powers.” Most of these great powers are, not incidentally, white-majority states, and they sit atop the hierarchy, with small and notably less-white powers organized below them. In a similar vein, raced hierarchies and conceptions of control ground the concept of cooperation in neoliberal thought: Major powers own the proverbial table, set the chairs, and arrange the place settings. Constructivism, which rounds out the “big three” approaches, is perhaps best positioned to tackle race and racism. Constructivists reject the as-given condition of anarchy and maintain that anarchy, security, and other concerns are socially constructed based on shared ideas, histories, and experiences. Yet with few notable exceptions, constructivists rarely acknowledge how race shapes what is shared. Despite the dominance of the “big three” in the modern study of IR, many of the arguments they advance, such as the balance of power, are not actually supported by evidence outside of modern Europe. Consider the democratic peace theory. The theory makes two key propositions: that democracies are less likely to go to war than are nondemocracies, and that democracies are less likely to go to war with each other. The historical record shows that democracies have actually not been less likely to fight wars—if you include their colonial conquests. Meanwhile, in regions such as the Middle East and North Africa, democratizing states have experienced more internal conflicts than their less-democratic peers. Yet leaders in the West have invoked democratic peace theory to justify invading and occupying less-democratic, and notably less-white, countries. This is a key element of IR’s racial exclusion: The state system that IR seeks to explain arises from the 1648 Peace of Westphalia, which ended the Thirty Years’ War and established European principles of statehood and sovereignty. Far from 17th-century relics, these principles are enshrined in the United Nations Charter—the foundation for global governance since 1945. But non-European nations did not voluntarily adopt European understandings of statehood and sovereignty, as IR scholars often mythologize. Instead, Europe, justified by Westphalia, divided the world between the modern, “civilized” states and conquered those which they did not think belonged in the international system. IR scholar Sankaran Krishna has argued that, because IR privileges theorizing over historical description and analysis, the field enables this kind of whitewashing. Western concepts are prioritized at the expense of their applicability in the world. Krishna called this “a systematic politics of forgetting, a willful amnesia, on the question of race.”

2022 Michigan Kritik
K—Racial IR—FMPS › Impact › Impact---Racial Hierarchy

IR is utilized to establish a system of racial logics that overcodes the globe

Lake et al. 21(David, Distinguished Professor of Political Science at the University of California, San Diego, Bianca Freedman, PhD candidate in the Department of Political Science at UC San Diego, D.G. Kim, Ph.D. candidate in the Department of Political Science at the University of California, San Diego, “Race in International Relations: Beyond the “Norm Against Noticing””, CS)

As the Howard School knew, race is a social construct that categorizes or classifies humans ac-cording to contrived differences. Its categories—races—are always and everywhere contested, a product of social struggle. As such, race is nearly always vertically stratified, entitling members of the ranked categories different rights and privileges within society. Omi & Winant (1994, p. 60)center this idea of racial hierarchy in their theory of racial formation. They explain that hierarchy is established and sustained as a racial project such that “everybody learns...the rules of racial classification and of her racial identity...inserted in a comprehensively racialized social structure. Race becomes ‘common sense’—a way of comprehending, explaining, and acting in the world.” As Bonilla-Silva (1997) suggests, racialization—the process by which groups are attributed racial meaning—conditions how actors relate to the social structures and institutional systems they in-habit. As an organizing principle of super- and subordination, it orders race hierarchically and engenders behaviors and interests to fit the position of the groups in the racial regime. Fanon [2008 (1952)] perceived racial hierarchy and the process of racialization in the language of colonial domination. To internalize the norms of the colonizer was to participate in one’s own oppression, to reflect the very hierarchical structures of alienation. Once racial stratification is established and its “racial logics” are absorbed (Hobson & Sharman 2005), race becomes an in-dependent criterion for vertical hierarchy in a society, both domestic and international. And to be sure, race as a hierarchy is international. Wynter (2003) argues that a globally expanding West used race to define and order the human. The color line encoded deserving and undeserving status within Western imperial orders. Racial hierarchy becomes important in IR in at least two fundamental ways, explored in more detail below. Though the coin may eventually be revealed as multisided, we see perceived deficiency and hostility as the two faces of racism in world politics. In the first face, countries below the color line are perceived to be deficient in some essential attribute. Through the mid-twentieth century, this face of racism was manifested in the “standard of civilization” criteria for establishing sovereignty and acceptance into the family of nations. As the norm of juridical sovereignty took hold after the formation of the United Nations, conferring sovereignty on any recognized member of the international community regardless of their capacity to govern their territory effectively ( Jackson 1990), the same projection of deficiency onto countries with majorities of people of color continued in the practice and interpretation of international law. In the second face, non-White-majority countries are perceived by White-majority countries to be inherently aggressive or threatening. Within a racialized global order, dominant actors perceive racially “inferior” foreign countries as potentially destabilizing to the status quo. This is precisely how Du Bois [2005(1906), p. 34] construed the problem of the color line: the prospect of war and peace hinges upon how White-majority countries cope with perceived challenges from the “awakening of the brown and black races.” The integrated analytic framework in Figure 1 illustrates the intersections of racial hierarchy, international law, and foreign policy. First, norms, including the norm of racial hierarchy, are so deeply woven into the fabric of social life that they appear natural, effectively conditioning the design and enforcement of an international legal order (i). Once the embedded social norm(in this case, the norm of racial hierarchy) is codified, international law further authorizes and promotes it (ii), which is often the intended goal of norms entrepreneurs in international politics In other words, international law, racialized in its content and enforcement, helps consolidate what Reus-Smit (2017, p. 875) calls the “authorized forms of difference” along the color line. As discussed in more detail below, uneven application of law brace plagues international politics. Providing rules that order relations between states with different status, rights, and responsibilities, international law thus guides the practice of foreign policy making (Figure 1, iii), which in turn reproduces an unequal global order that is underwritten by the international legal system as well as the racial hierarchy embedded within it (iv). Racial hierarchy also implicates foreign policy and practice more directly. The racial norm shapes foreign policies by conditioning how actors perceive their interests, interpret the position and interests of racial others, and act accordingly. As emphasized by Jackson (2006, p. 16), racial hierarchy affects foreign policy making through the process of legitimation, defined as “the process of drawing and (re)establishing boundaries, ruling some courses of action acceptable and others unacceptable.” By supplying the language of legitimation that shapes predominant foreign policy discourses, racial hierarchy thus renders certain foreign policies acceptable and therefore possible (Figure 1, v). Similar to how international law facilitates the authorization of racial hierarchy (ii), foreign policy and practice in turn further reinforce the norm of racial hierarchy, reifying the contrived racial categories and differences (vi). Below, we provide a more in-depth discussion on how racial hierarchy shapes the formulation of foreign policy. Altogether, the interactions of racial hierarchy, international law, and foreign policy reaffirm one another and produce a racialized world that is taken for granted.

2022 Michigan Kritik
K—Racial IR—FMPS › Impact › Impact---Memmi

Don’t even let them into the house.

Memmi 2k. Albert Memmi, Professor Emeritus of Sociology at the University of Paris, Naiteire, Racism, Translated by Steve Martinot, pg. 163-165

The struggle against racism will be long, difficult, without intermission, without remission, probably never achieved.  Yet for this very reason, it is a struggle to be undertaken without surcease and without concessions.  One cannot be indulgent toward racism.  One cannot even let the monster in the house, especially not in a mask.  To give it merely a foothold means to augment the bestial part in us and in other people, which is to diminish what is human.  To accept the racist universe to the slightest degree is to endorse fear, injustice, and violence.   It is to accept the persistence of the dark history in which we still largely live. It is to agree that the outsider will always be a possible victim (and which [person] man is not [themself] himself an outsider relative to someone else?). Racism illustrates in sum, the inevitable negativity of the  condition of the dominated;  that is it illuminates in a certain sense the entire human condition. The anti-racist struggle, difficult though it is. and always in question, is nevertheless one of the prologues to the ultimate passage from animality to humanity. In that sense, we cannot fail to rise to the racist challenge. However, it remains true that one's moral conduct only emerges from a choice: one has to want it. It is a choice among other choices, and always debatable in its foundations and its consequences.  Let us say, broadly speaking, that the choice to conduct oneself morally is the condition for the establishment of a human order for which racism is  the very negation.  This is almost a redundancy.  One cannot found a moral order, let alone a legislative order, on racism because racism signifies the exclusion of the other and his or her subjection to violence and domination. From an ethical point of view, if one can deploy a little religious language, racism is "the truly capital sin."fn22 It is not an accident that almost all of humanity's spiritual traditions counsel respect for the weak, for orphans, widows, or strangers. It is not just a question of theoretical counsel respect for the weak, for orphans, widows, or strangers. It is not just a question of theoretical morality and disinterested commandments. Such unanimity in the safeguarding of the other suggests the real utility of such sentiments. All things considered, we have an interest in banishing injustice, because injustice engenders violence and death Of course, this is debatable. There are those who think that if one is strong enough, the assault on and oppression of others is permissible. But no one is ever sure of remaining the strongest. One day, perhaps, the roles will be reversed, All unjust society contains within itself the seeds of its own death. It is probably smarter to treat others with respect so that they treat you with respect. "Recall," says the Bible, "that you were once a stranger in Egypt," which means both that you ought to respect the stranger because you were a stranger yourself and that you risk becoming once again someday. It is an ethical and a practical appeal -- indeed, it is a contract, however implicit it might be. In short, the refusal of racism is the condition for all theoretical and practical morality. Because, in the end. The ethical choice commands the political choice. A just society must be a society accepted by all. If this contractual principle is not accepted, then only conflict, violence, and destruction will be our lot.  If it is accepted, we can hope someday to live in peace.  True, it is a wager, but the stakes are irresistible.

2022 Michigan Kritik
K—Racial IR—FMPS › Impact › Impact---Existential Threat

Treat white supremacy as an existential threat.

Preston, 17—Cass School of Education and Communities, University of East London (John, “Rethinking Existential Threats and Education,” Competence Based Education and Training (CBET) and the End of Human Learning pp 61-93, dml)

After Marxism, the second existential threat is one of negation and elimination of the subject and here I shall consider conceptions of this from CRT and black existentialism.

Various contemporary educational theories consider the equity and social justice implications of different forms of education with regard to race. The work of Sleeter and Grant (2007) makes the ethical and pragmatic case for multicultural social justice as a key value of education. This has been followed in contemporary work that attempts to consider the various dimensions of social justice. For example, Bhopal and Shain (2014), consider the twin axis of recognition and redistribution as goals of education. Other work examines the role of social distancing from the ‘Other’ by white students as a dynamic process in which Black, Asian and Minority Ethnic (BAME) and working-class students are disadvantaged. In many ways denial of social justice in terms of lack of resources, recognition or access to social space can be considered to be a form of dehumanisation. However, whilst work on social justice and education might consider the lack of humanity in these systems of oppression (applying concepts such as ‘bare life’, Lewis 2006; or ‘othering’ Lebowitz 2016) they do not consider directly existential threats. Threats to humanity on the basis of difference may arise from totalitarianism as much as through war and threats to the environment. The various genocides which have taken place throughout human history have often had a racial, or ethnic, cleansing purpose to them. They have been eugenic threats that are based upon spurious ideas of genetic and moral superiority. Writers on race from Fanon to Du Bois have considered that the threat posed to racial groups may be existential and that there is a short step from psychic, to real extermination. The negation of individuals through economic, social and psychological processes allows for their physical extermination. Du Bois (2014) deals explicitly with existential threat in his short story ‘The Comet’ where humanity is almost wiped out by a threat from space, leaving only a small number of people to carry on. As one of the survivors of the comet is an African American, this leads Du Bois to consider the state of race relations in the USA. The implication of the story is that the existential threat of the comet (which allows the African American character to live in a world entirely free of racial prejudice) allows release from the existential threat of eugenic attitudes. Building on Du Bois, in other work (Preston 2012), I have considered the ways in which preparation for threats, including existential threats such as pandemics and nuclear war, has been in many ways eugenic in that it prioritises the survival of some more than others based upon criteria which include race and ethnicity (Preston 2012). Preparing for disasters and emergencies often prioritises the interests of white people above those of other ethnic minorities. One reason for this is tacit intentionality which means that policymakers and practitioners do not consider human diversity in considering how people may respond to disaster. Policy is often biased as policymakers expect that people will be ‘like me’ which (at least in the UK and USA) means they will often be white, middle-class, educated, English-speaking men. In planning for threats, there will be various ways in which such biases are included. For example, they may not consider publishing advice in a number of languages, the resources necessary to survive a disaster, the mobility of people and the attitudes of emergency responders. This is unwitting prejudice in that by not considering diversity they are actually making it less likely for BAME people to survive, or protect themselves against, the disaster.

2022 Michigan Kritik
K—Racial IR—FMPS › Links › Link---Ukraine

Using Ukraine to justify militarization makes future conflict inevitable---NATO’s attempts to dominate and contain Russia and China put Ukraine directly in the line of fire

Kimberley 22(Margret, New York-based writer and activist for peace and justice issues, “Does Ukraine Expose White Supremacist Foreign Policy?”, CS)

The narrative that only white people deserve peace and security is all the more shameful because the global south suffers from war and privation as a direct result of US/NATO actions. It is NATO that destroyed the nation of Libya, NATO which attempted to do the same in Syria, NATO that occupied Afghanistan, NATO which wages war across  with US, French and British troops deployed across the continent. The white world causes suffering and then says that the people of the global south are “uncivilized” with no rights that need to be respected. A Watson Institute of Brown University  showed that more than 37 million people in North Africa, Western and Central Asia, and the Horn of Africa have been displaced by the US and its allies since 2001. The humanitarian disasters begun years ago are ongoing, as refugees use the Mediterranean and even the US border with Mexico as points of escape. After experiencing wars of aggression these nations are then subjected to punishment as the United States steals Afghanistan’s assets and keeps Syria under the thumb of Caesar Sanctions. These thefts cause more suffering and even death as nations are robbed of the ability to care for their people. Who is civilized and who is not? Ukraine has been pushed to the forefront of American thought in order to defend the imperialist foreign policy which led to the current conflict with Russia. If the blue eyed nation is suffering it is because of US and NATO arrogance and aggression. Ukraine’s current situation is a direct result of the 2014 coup engineered by the US and its EU partners. An elected president was dispatched and a civil war began that has killed some 14,000 people. Ukraine is a US colony with a puppet government now under military attack. Ukrainians are themselves refugees as they flee to neighboring Poland, Romania, Slovakia and other countries. It is the supposedly advanced, democratic, and supposedly civilized who have created their problems. Yet once again bare faced racism is evident. African migrants and students in Ukraine were prohibited from boarding trains and buses that could take them to safety. A group of  was forced to walk 20 kilometers when they were forced off of a bus enroute to Poland. Africans and Jamaicans live and study all over the world because the US and Europe underdeveloped their nations through a variety of means. Yet Ukrainians and Poles didn’t see people in need of help. They determined that the non-blondes were not deserving of assistance. Ironically, it is the white supremacist underpinnings of US/NATO foreign policy which has created all of Ukraine’s suffering. The need to dominate, to “contain” Russia and its ally China is not playing out the way they had hoped but the Ukrainians be damned. The MinskII agreement which was unanimously approved in the United Nations Security Council was a roadmap to peace. Ukraine should be a neutral nation but that is the exact opposite of what its lords and masters in Washington want. The good faith negotiations that could resolve the crisis are a non-starter because NATO is a very dishonest broker.

2022 Michigan Kritik
K—Racial IR—FMPS › Links › Link---Space Col

Space colonization is designed to by capitalist and exclusionary – White billionaires will monopolize resources and restrict the access of minorities

Haskins 18(Caroline, Business Insider, where covers artificial intelligence, data collection, and surveillance, “THE RACIST LANGUAGE OF SPACE EXPLORATION”, CS)

Earning money in space is an exciting prospect for a far-right, pro-business, anti-regulation politician like Cruz, and he explicitly associated it with European countries having colonized the Americas. Starting in the late 1400s, Great Britain, Spain, and Portugal funded missions to the Americas in order to gather natural resources that would power up their economies. By stealing the land that made this resource extraction possible, colonizers used genocide, enslavement, biological weaponry, and warfare and that resulted in the deaths of tens of millions of indigenous people living in the “New World.” The concept of race, and therefore racism, was invented as a way of justifying their violence and . Based off of what we know right now, the Moon and Mars are devoid of life, so this colonizing language is not actually putting other beings at risk. But, there is the risk that the same racist mythology used to justify violence and inequality on earth — such as the use of frontier, “cowboy” mythology to condone and promote the murder and displacement of indigenous people in the American West — will be used to justify missions to space. In a future where humans potentially do live on non-earth planets, that same racist mythology would carry through to who is allowed to exist on, and benefit from, extraterrestrial spaces. On Earth, and in the United States specifically, the ideal of a merit-based society has been used to justify race-blind hiring policies that fail to account for, say, the implicit bias against black or Asian-sounding names, or the legacy of segregation, which continues to make children of color more vulnerable to attending underfunded schools. Narratives of “law and order” have also been used to justify racial profiling and harsher prison sentences for people of color than for white people who commit the same crimes. Not nearly enough work has been done here on Earth to ensure that these structural inequalities wouldn’t carry through. “Those narratives do carry specific implications about how people living on other worlds might be structured,” Lucianne Walkowicz, the current Chair of Astrobiology at the Library of Congress, told The Outline. Walkowicz organized the Decolonizing Mars Conference that took place on June 27 as well as a public follow-up event planned for September, to discuss how colonial language is shaping our potential future in space. “Space is not just built for nothing, it’s built for people.” When we think about humanity’s potential to exist on other planets, it’s important to consider who won’t have access to space, in part due to a total lack of concern over these issues by people who are able to access it. Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos intends to make space a place for the rich to use for adventure leisure, and SpaceX/Tesla founder Elon Musk has proposed that a Martian “colony” can save a selection of humanity from the collapse of civilization in some World War III scenario. Granted, right now, these are just words from billionaires who want to excite the public about their business ventures. But they suggest that if the economically and socially vulnerable are priced out of a life-saving journey from Earth, it is a justifiable loss. “All of these things that are said off the cuff [by billionaires] have some implications that are concrete and count some people in, and some people out,” Walkowicz said. Part of that concern is fueled by the fact that Cruz and Pence have presented the path to settling space as one that will be privately funded, but lead by the U.S. government. In the Destination Mars subcommittee meeting, Cruz said, “At the end of the day, the commercial sector is going to be able to invest billions more in dollars in getting this job [of getting to Mars] done.” In his Thursday remarks regarding the Space Force, Pence also implied that celestial territories would be treated as private property (even though owning private property in space is explicitly illegal per the Outer Space Treaty, which the U.S. and dozens of other nations signed in 1967). “While other nations increasingly possess the capability to operate in space, not all of them share our commitment to freedom, to private property, and the rule of law,” Pence said. “So as we continue to carry American leadership in space, so also will we carry America’s commitment to freedom into this new frontier.” This approach to public-private partnerships directly mirrors colonist practices. For instance, the British East India Company violently colonized parts of India on behalf of the company, but over time, ownership of the stolen land shifted to Great Britain.

2022 Michigan Kritik
K—Racial IR—FMPS › Links › Link---Space

The 1AC forwards racist mythologies of white dominance over space. Their framing matters.

Haskins, 18—The Outline, citing Michael Ralph, professor of anthropology at NYU and Lucianne Walkowicz, Chair of Astrobiology at the Library of Congress (Caroline, “THE RACIST LANGUAGE OF SPACE EXPLORATION,” , dml)

“You could argue that the effort to colonize space is likely to involve new forms of inequality: shifts in tax revenues and administrative priorities devoted to that,” said Michael Ralph, a professor of anthropology at NYU. “As opposed to [supporting] other social institutions that benefit people like health care, education, infrastructure.”

Earning money in space is an exciting prospect for a far-right, pro-business, anti-regulation politician like Cruz, and he explicitly associated it with European countries having colonized the Americas. Starting in the late 1400s, Great Britain, Spain, and Portugal funded missions to the Americas in order to gather natural resources that would power up their economies. By stealing the land that made this resource extraction possible, colonizers used genocide, enslavement, biological weaponry, and warfare and that resulted in the deaths of tens of millions of indigenous people living in the “New World.” The concept of race, and therefore racism, was invented as a way of justifying their violence and legitimizing a hierarchy of race-divided labor.

2022 Michigan Kritik
K—Racial IR—FMPS › Links › Link---Security Policy

Security politics plays a key role in reinforcing a racialized lens of politics, enforcing scapegoating and denial from political spheres.

Lake et al. 21(David, Distinguished Professor of Political Science at the University of California, San Diego, Bianca Freedman, PhD candidate in the Department of Political Science at UC San Diego, D.G. Kim, Ph.D. candidate in the Department of Political Science at the University of California, San Diego, “Race in International Relations: Beyond the “Norm Against Noticing””, CS)

Foreign security policy. First, racial hierarchy, through “colored” perceptions of foreign threats and national interest, has direct implications for how countries conduct foreign policy on a wide range of security and military issues, including alliance politics, regional order building, and territorial expansion. A few exceptional works on race in IR have emphasized that racial identity can be an important factor in the formation, stability, and durability of alliances in international politics. Focusing on the case of the Anglo-Japanese alliance (1902–1923),Búzás (2013) proposes that racial prejudice inflates perceptions of threat and aggressive intentions from racially dissimilar countries. He finds through extensive archival research that racial difference came to inflate British threat perceptions of Japan, predisposing the two allies toward discord and eventually the termination of the alliance at the 1921 Washington Conference. At the same time, Anglo–American racial similarity saved the United States and Britain from such racialized fears, despite frequent military tensions including the Venezuela crisis of 1895–1896. The dominant racial discourse of the trans-Atlantic Anglo-Saxon brotherhood drew the two countries toward foreign policy cooperation to a greater extent “than any other comparable pairs of states” (Vucetic 2011a, p. 403). Bell (2013) further notes that this prevailing White supremacist vision undergirded the fin de siècle discussion of racial utopianism—the claim that an Anglo-Saxon security community would eliminate all forms of interstate conflict (see also Vucetic 2011b).Racialized beliefs can also have far-reaching effects on other types of foreign security and military policies such as regional institution-building and territorial expansion. Hemmer &Katzenstein (2002) argue that perceived racial identity, among other components of collective identity, played an important yet underappreciated role in shaping starkly different American approaches to regional orders in postwar Europe and Asia. Despite a huge disparity in material capabilities between the United States and its regional allies in both regions, American policymakers established multilateral security institutions in Europe while opting for a hub-and-spokes system of bilateral alliances in Asia. Postwar foreign policy elites viewed their potential Asian partners as part of an inferior race who were less trustworthy and thus ineligible for membership in a NATO-like multilateral security community. Maass (2020) shows that the perception of the native population as racially inferior, dangerous, and thus inherently unsuited for republican governance also explains the limited American territorial expansion in Mexico.

2022 Michigan Kritik
K—Racial IR—FMPS › Links › Link---Securitization

Their securitization narrative perpetuates the idea of the “West and the Rest”, non-Eurocentric civilizations are viewed as primitive, justifying the violent assertion of U.S. leadership

Howell and Richter-Montpetit 20(Alison, Associate Professor of Political Science at Rutgers University, Melanie, Senior Lecturer in International Relations and Director of the Centre for Advanced International Theory, “Is securitization theory racist? Civilizationism, methodological whiteness, and antiblack thought in the Copenhagen School”, CS)

Securitization theory similarly occludes the racial violence of normal (liberal) politics. This is not just a conceptual problem: it results in major empirical oversights. For example, though it contains the word ‘security’, securitization theory places social security outside of its frame of analysis, as part of ‘normal politics’: ‘Although it shares some qualities with “social security,” or security as applied to various civilian guard or police functions, international security has its own distinctive, more extreme meaning. Unlike social security, which has strong links to matters of entitlement and social justice, international security is more firmly rooted in the traditions of power politics’ (Buzan et al., 1998: 21). Securitization theory overlooks the power politics of social security and cannot see how Western welfare state social security systems support white (settler) heteropatriarchal forms of life, such as the nuclear family (Arvin et al., 2013; Cohen, 1997; Duggan, 2003; Kandaswamy, 2008), and disproportionately target racialized, indigenous, and poor communities for direct and violent interventions such as the removal of children from families through enslavement, the residential schools that formed part of the genocide of indigenous people, child welfare systems, migrant detention and removal, and so on. Closer to Copenhagen: Denmark now uses socialized daycare as a means for removing and assimilating Muslim children (Salem, 2018). Social and national security are imbricated. For example, current Islamophobic counter-terrorism programs often use social and health services to identify suspected ‘terrorists’ (Kundnani, 2014; Qurashi, 2018; Qureshi, 2015). Social security only entails ‘entitlement and social justice’ for those privileged by whiteness, heterosexuality, citizenship, and/or class status. Securitization theory’s civilizationist idealization of ‘normal politics’ occludes these dynamics. More strikingly still, Copenhagen School theorists view policing as a positive force: ‘In the West, the police are normally an institutionalized part of society that ensures continuous functioning’ (Buzan et al., 1998: 54). They praise the pacification role of the modern state (Greenwood and Wæver, 2013: 489) and ignore the longstanding use of police in defending class and racial inequality and (hetero)sexual mores (Amar, 2013; Browne, 2015; Davis, 2003; James, 2000; Kelley, 2000; Sexton, 2007; Singh, 2016), and violently occupying indigenous land (Bell and Schreiner, 2018; Byrd, 2011; Dhillon, 2015; Fanon, 1963; Nettelbeck and Smandych, 2010; Razack 2015). Securitization theory also repeatedly refers to the US War on Drugs as a ‘niche securitization’ (Buzan and Wæver, 2003: 327–331, 2009: 265). This minimizes the transnational history of antiblack violence perpetrated by the US state leading into the mass incarceration of black and Latinx people (Davis, 2003; James, 2000; Rodriguez, 2006) and ignores American covert and counterinsurgency action globally, especially in Latin America. Policing ensures ‘good’ order for those privileged by whiteness, property ownership, gender norms, and/or settler status. The constitutive role of policing and law in the racial, (settler-)colonial, sexual, and class violence of ‘normal politics’ is occluded as a direct result of securitization theory’s reliance on civilizationist oppositions between politics versus security and politicization versus securitization. Classic securitization theory is civilizationist in that it believes that there are more or less politically and morally developed civilizations. It identifies ‘normal politics’ with (European) civilization and ‘securitization’ with a return to (racialized) primal anarchy. As a result, it depicts ‘underdeveloped’ civilizations as threats to supposedly more advanced ones. This becomes especially clear when examining securitization theory’s ideas about ‘state failure’. Securitization theory claims that in ‘developed’ states (Buzan et al., 1998: 28) a civilized political sphere generally fends off securitization, except when ‘securitization is unavoidable, as when states are faced with an implacable or barbarian aggressor’ (Buzan et al., 1998: 29). By contrast, in ‘failed’ or ‘weak’ states securitization runs amok: ‘In well-developed states, armed forces and intelligence services are carefully separated from normal political life, and their use is subject to elaborate procedures of authorization. Where such separation is not in place, as in many weak states … much of normal politics is pushed into the security realm’ (Buzan et al., 1998: 28). This excessive securitization, in turn, leads to primal (or ‘Hobbesian’ or ‘Kaplanesque’) anarchy, wherein the state ‘fails to take root or spirals into disintegration. This situation can lead to prolonged periods of primal anarchy, as is currently the case in Afghanistan and various parts of Africa, in which the state is only a shadow and reality is one of rival warlords and gangs’ (Buzan et al., 1998: 50, emphasis added; for analysis of the colonial preoccupation with Afghan ‘tribes’, see Manchanda, 2018). Discourses of state failure are ‘irredeemably rooted in an imperial and racialized imagination’ (Gruffydd Jones, 2015: 65; see also Grovogui, 2001; Shilliam, 2013; Wai, 2012a, 2012b). While they may avoid overt reference to race, they operate within a lineage of racial discourse that emerged to justify colonialism and continuing trusteeship. This racial hierarchy is fully represented in securitization theory’s list of weak and failing states: Nigeria under Abacha, Sudan, Sierra Leone, Somalia, Liberia, and ‘various parts of Africa’, the USSR under Stalin, Bosnia, Colombia, Afghanistan, Tajikistan, and so on (see Buzan et al., 1998: 28, 50, 69, 146). This is a racial discourse: ‘primal anarchy’ is primarily located in ‘brown’ (‘Afghanistan’) and ‘black’ (‘parts of Africa’) regions.

2022 Michigan Kritik
K—Racial IR—FMPS › Links › Link---Revisionism

Their notions of a perceived revisionist get operationalized to enforce a new, violent understanding of international politics

Lake et al. 21(David, Distinguished Professor of Political Science at the University of California, San Diego, Bianca Freedman, PhD candidate in the Department of Political Science at UC San Diego, D.G. Kim, Ph.D. candidate in the Department of Political Science at the University of California, San Diego, “Race in International Relations: Beyond the “Norm Against Noticing””, CS)

The recent worldwide surge in anti-Asian hate at the height of the pandemic calls for renewed attention on how race and racism connect to international politics. Fueled by inflammatory elite rhetoric, deep-seated racial animus has far-reaching implications for not only domestic racial relations but also interstate, and most importantly, great power relations (Dionne 2020; Kim 2020,2021; Reny & Barreto 2020). As we shall see, race and racism can affect the way foreign threats are perceived, competing visions of national interest are deliberated, and foreign policy responses are selected. Having elucidated international law as a projection of racial deficiency, we now turn to the second face of racism, namely the perception of racial others as potential threats. Notions of deficiency and hostility, though seemingly contradictory, straddle a key feature of racial hierarchy. Subordinate racial groups are considered not only inferior but potentially threatening to the status quo. Dominant actors within a racialized international order, in other words, perceive racial others as a latent threat to their own interests, and by extension, their identity. Racial hierarchy thus directly conditions how state actors interpret the behavior of racial others, assess their own interests, and cope with felt challenges to their status. Understanding this element of racial hierarchy can help us reexamine the overlooked role of race and racism in shaping a wide range of foreign policy preferences and decision making. In the language of Reus-Smit (2017, p. 879), though he avoids explicit reference to race, an international order is a configuration of political authority in which the need for legitimacy requires complex heterogeneity to be converted into authorized forms of cultural—including racial—difference. Racial hierarchy, by extension, provides a key source of legitimacy for an unequal global order, engendering “intersubjective understandings about...the appropriateness of its constituent role identities” (Reus-Smit 2017, p. 879). Under such prevailing “diversity regimes,” subordinate groups are perceived as a latent existential threat with potentially revisionist intent and incompatible interests. Sociological and psychological understandings of racial hierarchy also suggest that it is through the effect of racial prejudice that dominant groups evaluate threats from racial others and formulate their behavioral responses. Building on Blumer’s (1958) group position theory of prejudice, Bobo (1999) posits that racial prejudice involves more than negative feelings or stereotypes and instead derives more fundamentally from a felt challenge to the sense of relative group position. The long tradition of social dominance theory also attributes the source of racial prejudice and violence to the human predisposition to maintain group-based social hierarchies(Sidanius & Pratto 1999). Conceived in this way, racism is related to but goes beyond social identity theory, which posits an innate human tendency toward in-group favoritism and out-group discrimination (Tajfel & Turner 1979). By socializing state actors into constituent identities and interests, racial hierarchy turns attention away from simple out-group tensions to threats to group status and, thus, shows how racism can play a deeper role in shaping perceived foreign threats, national interest, and ultimately foreign policy behaviors.