All of these three moments--the Langdellian systematizations, the realist revolt, the "law and . . ." enlightenment--were reinventions of the discipline. They failed in the sense that they failed to reproduce themselves as vital intellectual enterprises. But they did not fail in making people think. Now, we live amidst their ruins. We are in need of another re-invention. That does not seem to be happening. Instead what we have is: A. CASE-LAW JOURNALISM Case-law journalism is a legacy of Langdellianism. As an intellectual enter-prise, Langdellianism came to an end when the work of taxonomic organization was completed. Now, as mentioned above, Langdellianism did leave some [*822] academics in each field to do the useful work of entering the new cases into the old taxonomies and to make modest modifications of the latter whenever it seemed advisable. This took care of keeping six or seven legal academics in each field busy (for a lifetime). n45 As for the other what--ninety-eight percent?--they would have to do something else. The legal academy clearly did not need five hundred contracts teachers to write treatises on contracts (six would do). How then to keep the other 494 duly employed? A three-pronged answer: (1) heighten the intricacy of analysis, (2) let the academics issue lots of normative recommendations, and (3) have them argue incessantly amongst themselves. The possibility of outdoing the courts in terms of intricacy was a natural for the legal academy. Courts have dockets. Legal academics have time. Given this asymmetry, the academics could always outdo the courts in the intricacy of their analysis. For legal academics, more searching, more precise, more detailed analyses were always possible. And it was also possible along the way to chastise the courts for their analytical shallowness. Indeed, one legal-process wag in the 1950s once complained very soberly that the essential work of the Supreme Court was suffering because the Justices clearly did not have sufficient time to give proper attention to writing their opinions. n46 The second possibility--to issue lots of normative recommendations--was also a successful full-employment strategy. To the extent that legal academics could make recommendations to the courts as to what should be done, the work would never dry up. Indeed, normative prescription pretty much opened up the world of legal scholarship to the future--in fact, to all kinds of futures, ranging from the modestly improved to the wildly utopian. The third prong--to let the academics argue among themselves--was also well suited for the legal academy. Surely if Professor X had a better solution than the courts, then, of course, it should be published. And surely if Professor Y found that Professor X's proposed solution was somehow flawed, it would be useful to publish that too. And surely, further responses might also add to the storehouse of knowledge. And surely too there would be value-added for [*823] Professor Z to show that while both Professor X and Professor Y had made valuable contributions, neither of them understood the problem quite as well as Professor Z. And so on. The possibilities were endless (in a kind of mock common law sort of way). And because all the legal materials (as had been demonstrated over and over again) were fraught with contradictory values and imperatives, the game could keep going forever. These three prongs are very much a part of case-law journalism. But they are too formal to capture the ethos of the practice--for this is a practice, not a set of rules to follow, not a model, but a well-settled, fully socialized, thoroughly internalized way of thinking and writing. By way of analogy to this practice, consider the mythical reporter covering the police beat. Think 1950's film noir here. In the opening scene, the reporter waits at the police station (today, by his pager) for the suspects to trickle in. The action starts. He interviews the cops, then reads the arrest report, calls the wife or husband or girlfriend, as appropriate. Then, should zeal strike, he might visit the crime scene. In the end, he writes and files his report, which is then published in the morning paper. Case-law journalism is much the same except for three things. First, the case-law journalist is a professor of law. And she writes law review articles, not newspaper articles. Second, she does not wait by the police desk. She is by her PC looking at Lexis or Findlaw or the SCOTUS website. n47 Third, unlike the journalist who is supposed to stick to the facts, the case-law journalist inserts the cases into some sort of normative narrative. Almost invariably, the case-law journalist ends on a cheery normative prescription for betterment of law, nation, or world. (Indeed, when was the last time you saw a law review article end on the note, "Oh my god, there's nothing we can do. We're ruined."?) B. LCM The most critical aspect of case-law journalism and its variations is the submission of issues, problems, artifacts, methods, or whatever else might come over the transom to the logic of judicial discourse in a way that produces legally cognizable material ("LCM"). There is a great deal of LCM produced in the legal academy. One gets the sense here of a great machine composed of many legal academics--each one ready and able to process the materials through the logic of judicial discourse. In the early days, up until the late 1960's say, it was mainly cases that were crunched. Today, the field has opened up. We will crunch anything. No matter what comes up--O.J., thick description, postmodernism, blogs, Bush v. Gore, the anniversary of Brown v. Board, anything at all--we will turn it into LCM. [*824] When the thing really needs a lot of crunching, we will hold a symposium and get a small group to crunch the thing together. We are ready, willing, and able to crunch the stuff (any stuff) and turn it into LCM. The consumption metaphor is also apt here. Anything that comes to us, we legal academics will chew on and ultimately digest. Our job is to be there--ready to process the cases, to answer the call from CNN or NPR or 9NEWS, to provide a pithy quote for the morning paper, to argue importantly at the law review symposium, and then to go back to our offices and do it again the next day (for life). This is not nothing, of course. If you do this, it allows you to display knowledge-mastery. In turn, this will please your dean and get you lots of lines in the alumni magazine. Like this, for instance: Professor Brancroft spoke on at NPR on July 20. He published three articles on the Bankruptcy Act and Putative Spouses--and a sequel to his earlier . . . . He also presented a talk at to the State Commission on special courts and appeared on CNN to discuss . . . . And so on. Or more candidly: Professor Brancroft has not become a world-class party animal (surprise--that one) and is not visibly suffering from jungle rot. What's more, he shows evidence of working on the kinds of things that the mental giants at CNN believe is worth air time. So the upshot is that he's doing something and the rest of us at the law school are doing something. We are all doing something. The future looks bright. So give us your money please. Legal thought is a lot like that these days. Notice that if this is the job description--producing lots of LCM--it's kind of hard to have ideas. It is a lot like trying to have a truly creative idea in the middle of taking a law school exam--(which, as we all know, is seldom a good idea). C. THE PERPETUAL LAW SCHOOL EXAM And there's a thought: the state of the art really is like a perpetual law school exam. The prototype of the contemporary legal academic is someone who is constantly either preparing to take or is in fact taking a law school exam. In one sense, of course, it's not quite a law school exam because the law professor is talking about things that are actually happening: court proceedings, legislative deliberations, etc. On the other hand, it has that same sort of form--answering stock questions in terms of stock issues by deploying stock arguments. Go to the blogs: I speak truth. This is a weird job description. It is even weirder that people (besides the six who are very helpfully writing the treatises in each field) would choose to make this their job description when they could clearly choose to make their job [*825] description something else. I strongly suspect, though I cannot prove, that this has a lot to do with the kinds of people we hire. By and large, we vet people very seriously for doing really well on exam-like tasks, writing law review kinds of things, while hardly vetting them at all on anything else. Not surprisingly, when they set about writing, many of them take up the familiar spot and crunch of the perpetual law school exam. What else would they do? What else could we reasonably expect? Even much of the recent flurry of interdisciplinary activity seems to have come down to a highly academicized case of LCM production. Earlier, in the introduction, we encountered James Boyd White looking at the pile of reprints on his desk with dread and ennui. n48 I ask you now to imagine something different--namely, a stack of interdisciplinary university press monographs on your desk. The first thing to notice is their covers--beautiful colors, awesome designs. But then you imagine actually reading one of them. Do you not, gentle reader, dread the dryness of the prose, the lumbering lurch of the argument, and the deadening thuds of the footnotes? n49 For apart from the striking cover, is there not this uncanny sense that what you see before you is simply a very, very, very long law review article? Still, we should take heart. There may be something highly functional about all this. As intellectually pointless as the perpetual law school exam may be, it serves to display mastery--namely, mastery of the law by the individual legal thinker. To be really good at the perpetual law school exam is to confirm that one is really well-prepared to be a really good case-law journalist. Also it means putting out lots of LCM. The exercises also show mastery at a higher level of abstraction. They show the mastery of "the law" over current cultural trends, intellectual currents, and social events. This is an important task because it demonstrates performatively that law and its authorized agents are still dominant. n50 LCM. Moreover, case-law journalism is the way in which we confirm to each other and to outside parties (lawyers, judges, the press, tenure committees, other departments in the university) that we really are in possession of some kind of expertise. And we are. LCM does not just happen. It takes years of effort and hard work [*826] to be really good at putting out first-rate LCM. <Schlag continues> G. WHY THINGS WILL GET WORSE Two things: Personnel and Institutionalization. Personnel. Well, enough on that subject. Institutionalization. Ironically, it is at this very moment--the moment when legal scholarship seems so thoroughly compromised--that law schools have decided, seemingly en masse, to intensify the monitoring of scholarly quality and quantity as well as to enforce scholarly output maximization strategies. Law faculties and administration are all increasingly heavily invested in mentoring, career positioning, SSRN download rates, citation indices, article placement strategies, blog announcements, and glossy scholarship advertising. It's all a kind of massive "no law professor left behind" scheme. All these techniques and strategies are ways in which law professors and law schools can all watch each other with great ease and in great detail. The important part is not so much the watching, but rather that we all know we are being watched. It's as if we, who are responsible for all this (and this would seem to be nearly all of us), had read Foucault's account of the panopticon and [*831] decided it was way cool and that we should institute our own version as soon as possible. The upshot sadly is that, at the very moment (1) that some terribly unenlightening paradigms are holding sway over legal scholarship, we also have (2) a radical intensification of quantity and quality control mechanisms. For my part, I believe it would vastly improve matters if at least one of those two things were not happening. Things will get worse. On the cheery side, one can always count on (1) the contributions of exogenous forces and (2) the fact that Malthus was and still is wrong. I'm a reasonable person (as well as a law professor) so all I came back with was one really tiny insight. Not only is it tiny, but it's not even very original. And it begins like this: There is something pervasively neurotic about the structures of contemporary life. The excruciating intricacies of everyday demands, the symbolic overinvestment of meaning in the trivial, the obsessive monitoring of everything to within an inch of its life, the constant piling on of little local meta- and infra-layers of thought--all these things are, from the [*832] perspective of the river, pervasively neurotic. n64 Contemporary life ensnares us in all sorts of little maze-games that seem to matter tremendously and yet ultimately do not--except in the negative sense that they distract our attention from what does or at least could matter. Now, lots of people have had this sort of insight--the most famous perhaps being Heidegger (the "fallenness" thing). n65 But my insight, and it really isn't much of an insight at all, is about legal scholarship. I think the practices and institutions of contemporary legal scholarship (spam jurisprudence, case law journalism, rank anxiety, nothing happening, etc.) are extremely intense versions of this generalized neurotic structure. It's as if we were all working really hard on an imaginary bus schedule. Someone writes an article saying we need to optimize the number of buses. Another person can't resist pointing out that it might be preferable to start by optimizing the number of bus stops instead. Soon someone writes that we should reconstruct the entire schedule. Someone else will suggest that we should split the schedule along eight different parts. Someone says, the eight parts are really sixteen. Some truly original thinker says there are ten. And then, some ranker comes along and starts ranking whose law school has the best bus scheduling program going. And somebody else decides to hold a symposium on bus schedule rankings. (Remember the traveling show on Bush v. Gore?) n66 And then fifty years from now, someone will write a book: How Should the Bus Schedules of 2000-Whatever Have Been Decided? n67 Pretty soon, we've got a collective imaginary going and we're pushing buses and bus stops all across pages of the Yale Law Journal and it all feels kind of real and pretty important. And it's not hard to believe that it's important. For one thing people are getting real rewards--prestige jobs, chairs, program funding--for [*833] imaginary bus schedule breakthroughs. And adding to the increasing reality of the thing is the undeniable fact that we can't just dismiss buses or bus schedules as unreal. (If everything else fails, by the way, this is your takeaway: Buses are real.) But the thing of it is, our legal academic bus schedule remains imaginary. Even if it looks a lot like the real thing, it's still imaginary. When we put out our bus schedule, no buses run. Word. And no Rapid Transit District (RTD) that I know of is going to change its schedule just because some new bus stop entries have been introduced in the pages of the Yale Law Journal or wherever. Not going to happen. So here we are, legal academics working on our collective imaginary bus schedule. And one of the things that troubles me about this is that the imaginary bus schedule is in some important ways not at all like the RTD's bus schedule. The RTD faces real stakes. We legal academics don't. Our reality principle--to the extent we have one at all--is decidedly indeterminate: get tenure/avoid showing cause. So if we want to construct a bus schedule with stops every ten yards (all in the name of rigor or precision) then we can have at it. And realize, please, that I'm not being extreme here. It's not like this hasn't been done. Over and over again. n68 And then there's the normativity thing. I once read an article that purported to elaborate about what the Constitution should be. Now what struck me as odd was that the author really did want to free himself (and his reader) from any official pronouncements of what the Constitution is. This struck me as incredibly weird. What an odd thing to do. If the question "What should the Constitution be?" is not anchored in what the Constitution is (whatever that might be), then why not go for broke: I say let's have a constitution that guarantees universal health care, tastes a lot like Ben & Jerry's ice cream, and is laugh-out-loud funny. You leave it to me? I say: Go big. Is this flip? Well, of course, it is. But hey, I'm not the one who invented this practice of normative legal thought. I'm just pointing it out. In fact, that's what I do these days. Check that: It's what I used to do. I used to have a pretty good job as a satirist. Good working conditions. Not much competition. I'm out of business now: Legal thought satirizes itself. For me now, it's all just point and shoot. There's something gratuitous about legal scholarship. No one, of course, writes that the constitution should be like Ben & Jerry's ice cream. But just what is it that precludes anyone from suggesting that the Constitution should guarantee universal health care. (I'd be in favor--I really would.) The answer: [*834] there are constraints on what we argue. Sure there are. n69 And who generates . . . the constraints? Well, in part, we do: n70 So what we have is an imaginary legal thought shaped by imaginary collective constraints, one of which is the injunction that we should follow those constraints with great rigor. My question: Is this a neurotic structure? Yes, it is. Straight out--full-flower. It has to be because without the neurosis, [obsession], there would be nothing there. No constraints at all. Now please understand: As a matter of form, I have nothing against collective imaginaries. My only problem is this: if we law professors have to work so hard (and so painfully) on our collective imaginaries, couldn't we pick something more interesting, or important, or aesthetically enlivening, or morally salient, or politically relevant than bus schedules? I mean, couldn't we? Uh, no. Which raises perhaps my final point. It's not very nice, but someone's got to say it, and apparently it's going to be me. As mentioned earlier, our people are not cognitively challenged. They are, bell curve and all, very intelligent. It is easy then for people like you and I, when we look at the extreme intricacy of the work produced by these very intelligent people, to associate the intricacy of their work with their manifest intelligence. Indeed, we are likely to think of the relation in reciprocal terms: Because they are intelligent, their work is intricate, and because their work is intricate, it shows great intelligence. n71 But the thing I want to suggest as a possibility here is that all this intricacy of legal scholarship is less a function of intelligence than it is a manifestation of neurosis in the face of intractable conflicts. What conflicts? Consider the prototypical needs of the legal academic: A need to display great intelligence in a discourse (law) that will ultimately not bear it. A need to contribute to disciplinary knowledge in a discourse which is not really about knowledge or truth in any profound sense of those terms. A need to say something intellectually respectable within a disciplinary paradigm that we know, on some level, is intellectually compromised. [*835] A need to display control over social, political, and economic transactions that are in important senses not subject to control. A need to activate moral and political virtue in a discourse that uses both largely as window dressing. A need to make one's thought seem real and consequential in a discourse that is neither. I want to suggest then, and this is perhaps the unkindest cut of all, that within the dominant paradigm of legal scholarship, it may be that there is very little of enduring value to be said. In the main it's the rehearsal of a form, a genre--and not a self-evidently good one. n72 I have a cheery ending and a not so cheery ending The cheery ending is that it has not always been like this. And, maybe it doesn't have to be like this now. The non-cheery ending goes like this: It's going to get worse in many ways. The forces are in play--the rankings, the administrators who want to enhance the reps of their schools, the status insecurities of young (and old) faculty members, the pervasive triumph of porno (ahem, ahem, told you so) n73--all these forces will converge to produce ever more spam jurisprudence. And then something else will happen. <Schlag continues> In terms of social organization then, there may be something to be said for creating a professional corps (lawyers) whose modes of communication are widely shared and relatively standardized. Notice that if this is the objective, then the only place where that sort of standardized communication can be widely shared is somewhere close to the middle of the bell curve. Both intellectual sloth and intellectual excellence are, by definition, aberrant and thus detract from our efforts at standardization. Thus, training for mediocrity does serve a social function (within limits, of course). Mediocrity is not the only aim here. One would like this mediocrity to be the best it can be. We would like legal professionals to share a language and a mode of thought and, at the same time, for that language and mode of thought to be as perspicuous and intelligent as possible. Given the omnipresence of the bell curve, these desiderata are obviously in tension. The economists would likely talk about achieving "the optimal degree" of intelligence and mediocrity at the margin, but my sense is this will only get us so far. For law professors, the tension is bound to be somewhat frustrating. What many law professors would like--because many of them are intellectually inclined--is to bring intelligence to bear within legal discourse. This is bound to be a somewhat frustrating venture. Legal discourse is not designed to produce intelligence and, frankly, the materials and the discourse can only bear so much. Good judgment, groundedness, reasonableness--any of these virtues is often enough to snuff out real thinking. Indeed, whatever appeal good judgment, groundedness, and reasonableness may have for a judge or a lawyer (and I am prepared to say the appeal is considerable), such virtues are not particularly helpful to intellectual achievement. On the contrary, intellectual achievement requires the abandonment of received understandings. In fact, I would go so far as to say that intellectual vitality (at least in the context of a discipline like law) [*829] requires some degree of defamiliarization, some reach for the exotic. The thing is, those sorts of efforts are not going to get very far if they constantly have to answer to good judgment, groundedness, reasonableness, and the like. And at this point, I would like to flip the argument made earlier in the paper. Here, I would like us to think of appeals to good judgment, groundedness, and reasonableness in legal thought as appeals to mediocrity. Making people see things involves things far different from good judgment, groundedness, or reasonableness. It involves a kind of artistry--a reorientation of the gaze, a disruption of complacency, a sabotage of habitual forms of thought, a derailing of cognitive defaults. This is part of what a really good education is about. Constant obeisance to good judgment or groundedness or reasonableness, by contrast, will systematically frustrate such efforts. n57 This is all rather vexing. Legal academics--with aspirations to intellectual excellence--are thus destined to play out the myth of Sisyphus. The main difference, of course, is that Sisyphus had a real rock to push up a real hill. The law professors' rock and hill, by contrast are symbolic--imaginative constructions of their own making. Arguably, pushing a symbolic rock up a symbolic hill is substantially easier than doing it for real. At the very least, it is easier to fake it and to claim success. At the same time, though, the symbolic nature of the exercise perhaps makes it more transparently pointless. As between these two points, there is a certain dissonance. On the one hand, we are dealing with pushing rocks up hills--and that is surely hard work. On the other hand, the rocks and hills are of our own imagination--so it should be easy. This is very confusing. n58 My best guess (and I offer this only as a preliminary hypothesis) is that the dissonance here might yield a certain degree of neurosis. n59 Still the question pops up again: "So what?" So what--so you have maybe seven thousand-something law professors in the nation and you know, maybe ninety-six percent are engaged in a kind of vaguely neurotic scholarship. So what? Maybe it's borderline tragic. Maybe, these people could have done so much better. None of this, by the way, is clearly established. But let's just assume, it's true. Who cares? Seven thousand people--that's not a lot of people. Plus, it's hard to feel for them. I know that nearly all of them would be us (but still). It's an extraordinarily privileged life. So why care about this? Here's why. The thing about legal scholarship is that it plays--through the mediation of the professorial mind--an important role in shaping the ways, the [*830] forms, in which law students think with and about law. n60 If they are taught to think in essentially mediocre ways, they will reproduce those ways of thinking as they practice law and politics. If they are incurious, if they are lacking in political and legal imagination, if they are simply repeating the standard moves (even if with impressive virtuosity) they will, as a group, be wielding power in essentially mediocre ways. And the thing is: when mediocrity is endowed with power, it yields violence. And when mediocrity is endowed with great power, it yields massive violence. n61 All of which is to say that in making the negotiation between the imprinting of standard forms of legal thought and the imparting of an imaginative intelligence, we err too much on the side of the former. (Purely my subjective call here--but so is everybody else's.) Another way to put it is that while there is something to be said for the standardization point made earlier, generally, standardization is overdone. n62