Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Art › Neg › 1NC

Eco Artists have the power to transform our models of economy

Ariunaa Jargalsaikhan 21 (Certified Public Accountant (Lifetime) MONICPA. Certified Tax Accountant. MACTA. Licensed Auditor. Mongolian Institute of Certified Public Accountants) “CAN ECO ART HELP MONGOLIA SOLVE THE CLIMATE CRISIS?” Jargal Defacto https://jargaldefacto.com/article/can-eco-art-help-mongolia-solve-the-climate-crisis?lang=en Access Date: 7/1/23—VS

One of the major dilemmas in resolving the climate crisis is the linear “take–make–consume–dispose” approach to natural resources.2 For this reason, countries have begun to recognize the fundamental rights of nature as part of their constitutions. Initiated by Ecuador in 2008, this principle accepts that humans are part and parcel of nature, and not its independent proprietors.3 The rights of nature can endorse a new model of circular economy where each economic sector receives from and provides for another. The resulting networks eliminate waste by continuing the use of resources and develop like ecosystems do.

Still, modes of operation adopted from the advent of industrialization are proving difficult to change. Rapid urbanization increases the sense of human detachment from the price it costs to make the energy, transport, food, and goods we consume. Eco artists are agents of transformation in attitudes toward the use of natural resources.

2023 UTNIF Counterplan
Art › Neg › 1NC

Connecting art to science increases human engagement—that’s key to addressing climate change

Mika Tosca and Adrian Galvin 19 (Mika is a trained climate scientist, having completed her Ph.D. work with Drs. Charlie Zender and James Randerson at the University of California, Irvine in 2012. While at Irvine, Dr. Tosca researched the interconnectivity of the climate with landscape fires and particulate (aerosol) emissions. Galvin went to graduate school at Carnegie Mellon University to study interaction design, and is now primarily a UX/UI designer with a specialization in data visualization for scientific research tools.) “Transcending Science: Can artists and designers help scientists solve the climate crisis?” ADS https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2019AGUFMED53B.05T/abstract Access Date: 7/1/23—VS

In recent decades, despite glaring and increasing evidence of climate change, much of this knowledge remains abstruse, cumbersomely documented, and opaquely presented, making engagement with it by "nonscientists" difficult. Perhaps this is the reason why a large segment of the general population remains convinced that human beings have not caused the observed 20th and 21st century climate change.

There exists, therefore, an exciting and necessary opportunity for scientists to collaborate with artists. In school, we learn that the scientific method begins with a hypothesis, progresses through research and analysis, and concludes with a result. The design process, in contrast, begins with human engagement and inquiry, progresses through ideation and prototyping, and concludes with a refined artifact. Perhaps the revolution we need to address climate change begins by making the human engagement of art-making an integral part of the scientific method. As a climate scientist teaching full time at an art university, I am uniquely positioned to explore these possibilities.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Aff Answers › 2AC – Perms › Perm – Power Reduction

Perm – the JGP is unique in being the threshold for transition away from growth – the net benefit is a necessary power-reduction in bad faith actors to organize a fully communist movement.

Klein 20 Klein, N. Naomi Klein is Senior Correspondent for The Intercept, a Puffin Writing Fellow at Type Media Center, and the inaugural Gloria Steinem Endowed Chair in Media, Culture and Feminist Studies at Rutgers University. She is the author, most recently, of On Fire: The (Burning) Case for a Green New Deal. (2020). Care and repair: Left politics in the age of climate change. Dissent, 67(1), 97-108. ut-ac

Drawing out these connections in ways that capture the public imagination will take a massive exercise in popular education and participatory democracy. A first step is for every sector touched by the Green New Deal—hospitals, schools, universities, and more—to make their own plans for how to rapidly decarbonize while furthering the Green New Deal’s mission to eliminate poverty, create good jobs, and close the racial and gender wealth divides.

My favorite example of what this could look like comes from the Canadian Union of Postal Workers, which has developed a bold plan to turn every post office in Canada into a hub for a just green transition. Think solar panels on the roof, charging stations out front, a fleet of domestically manufactured electric vehicles from which union members not only deliver mail, as well as local produce and medicine, but also check in on seniors—all supported by the proceeds of postal banking.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Aff Answers › 2AC – Perms › Perm do both

Perm do both – the aff remains integral to any form of “actualizing” communist organizing – the net benefit is reparative justice as the first step to intersect colonial histories and prioritize degrowth as an ongoing ethic and process outside of global North dominance.

Deivanayagam and Osborne 23 Deivanayagam, T. A., Institute for Global Health, University College London, Lancaster Medical School, Faculty of Health and Medicine, Lancaster University, & Osborne, R. E., School of Clinical Medicine, Addenbrooke’s Hospital, University of Cambridge (2023). Breaking free from tunnel vision for climate change and health. PLOS Global Public Health, 3(3), e0001684. pp. 9-10. ut-ac

A degrowth approach advocates a managed transition to an economy which maintains an ecological ceiling while prioritising health and social wellbeing. Many of the industries supported in the name of ‘economic growth’, such as the fossil fuel industry, the military and fast fashion, are based on social and environmental violence and need to be dismantled. However, rejecting GDP does not mean rejecting abundance. The goal of degrowth is to move away from an economy designed solely for material output and wealth accumulation. Degrowth advocates for an economy which does not demand endless resource use, but instead distributes resources equitably, and is designed for an abundance of public wellbeing, not private wealth [51]. As Jason Hickel states, “degrowth calls for abundance in order to render growth unnecessary. Degrowth, at its core, is a demand for radical abundance” [56]. Proposals to achieve this include public ownership and dismantling or transformation of harmful industries; wealth and corporate taxation; the implementation of a social foundation including universal public services; a universal basic income; large scale investment in a green transition; and a climate job guarantee [57].

Importantly, for any new economic paradigm to meet the joint goals of health and climate justice, it must implement reparations–this is explicitly part of degrowth. Reparations requires ending economic, social, and political dominance of the global North and returning wealth and land to the communities whose health has been most harmed by colonial capitalism. Reparations are not just a way to address past harm, but a world making project to build just and ecological futures [58].

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Aff Answers › 2AC stuff › Cap Good

Cap solves scarcity – asteroid mining alone solves – the estimates are conservative.

Pethokoukis and McAfee 19 Pethokoukis, James. Senior Fellow DeWitt Wallace Chair Editor, AEIdeas Blog, Podcast Host @ Political Economy Podcast. McAfee, Andrew. Andrew McAfee is the co-founder and co-director of the Initiative on the Digital Economy and a principal research scientist at the MIT Sloan School of Management. He studies how digital technologies are changing the world. He has also written The Second Machine Age and Machine, Platform, Crowd. Transcribed Podcast Episode 150 from: “Andrew McAfee on Capitalism, Tech Progress, and the Environment | Ep. 150 — Political Economy with James Pethokoukis” 2019 Oct. 15. https://www.aei.org/economics/how-can-innovation-and-capitalism-save-our-planet-a-long-read-qa-with-andrew-mcafee/.

Pethokoukis: I don’t know if you’ve been following the global voyages of the Swedish teen activist, Greta Thunberg, who’s very worried about global warming. When she came to America and was talking about climate change, she said one phrase that really stuck in my brain. She was very worried about these “fairy–tales of infinite economic growth.”

Your book actually gets at that issue. One reason that you have people who are concerned about economic growth is because they feel that we are running out of earth. That there’s no way that we can have a planet where everybody lives like Americans. It’s a very common criticism that I hear when I talk about economic growth: “We only have one earth, and unless you’re going to bring in asteroids full of resources, we will run out of earth.”

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Aff Answers › 2AC stuff › L/T – Degrowth

Turn – Growth is key to all your impacts – pointing the finger at capitalism builds hubris for the “next step taken” and preconditioned on surface-level engagement.

Terzi 22 Terzi, A. Alessio Terzi is Economist at the European Commission's Directorate-General for Economic and Financial Affairs. Prior to this, he was an Affiliate Fellow at the think tank Bruegel and a Fulbright Scholar at the Harvard Kennedy School. His research and commentaries have appeared in leading media outlets including BBC World News, Financial Times, and the Wall Street Journal. (2022). Growth for Good: Reshaping Capitalism to Save Humanity from Climate Catastrophe. United Kingdom: Harvard University Press. pp. 93—101. ut-ac

We started with a set of paradoxes, and we will conclude with one last one. Several of the current grievances against capitalism and the growth imperative identified by ecosocialists and others are actually problems that result from a slowdown (or, in Italy’s case, complete lack) of growth. Degrowth advocates got a first taste of this from one of their own prophets. Thomas Piketty’s argument for why wealth inequality is increasing and the rate of return on capital (r) is higher than economic growth (g) is actually that there has been a slowdown in the latter. As we learned from the Italian case, this same logic can be extended to a variety of dimensions. If you think your current society is already fractionalized, litigious, and gridlocked, having less or no economic growth will make the problem worse. In this respect, note that what matters is scarcity vis-à-vis your neighboring countries or your own past trend, not some absolute monetary (or moral) threshold. By absolute measures, Italy remains one of the largest economies in the world, and if we use the entire global distribution of income as a benchmark, its citizens are rich. But this simple fact does not protect the country from the toxic political and economic dynamics outlined above. The reasons for this will become more clear in Chapter 5.

This book’s Introduction laid out other grievances against the current economic order, including the plights of so many young people: they do not have enough opportunities, they are underemployed, and home ownership is nothing but an impossible dream to them. They are forced to seek help from their parents, and the government does not allocate enough resources to help them out. These are also problems that an absence of economic growth will make even worse. More broadly, if you think there should be more redistribution, then you should hope for the economic growth that makes that politically easier to achieve. When the economy enters into a steady state and faith in progress wanes, every group in society becomes highly risk averse, and assigns top priority to the defense of its present entitlements. It might very well be, as Galbraith remarked, that economic growth emerged as a powerful substitute to redistribution, as it eases social tensions. But at the same time, the relationship is not symmetric: redistribution is not a substitute for growth. Redistribution alone, in an environment of no growth, cannot serve the function of easing social tensions. It is instead bound to exacerbate them.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Aff Answers › 2AC stuff › L/T – Behavior

Turn – we’re predicated to always want more, which means capitalism is solely a natural consequence of our desires.

Terzi 22 Terzi, A. Alessio Terzi is Economist at the European Commission's Directorate-General for Economic and Financial Affairs. Prior to this, he was an Affiliate Fellow at the think tank Bruegel and a Fulbright Scholar at the Harvard Kennedy School. His research and commentaries have appeared in leading media outlets including BBC World News, Financial Times, and the Wall Street Journal. (2022). Growth for Good: Reshaping Capitalism to Save Humanity from Climate Catastrophe. United Kingdom: Harvard University Press. pp. 121—124. ut-ac

Harking back to the opening of this chapter, capitalism is blamed for many ills, but it is better understood as a great enabler. It is an efficient way to foster growth. It rewards ingenuity. It prods people to invent practical things and add to the store of useful knowledge. When firms compete for customers, they have an incentive to master the latest technology and learn how to produce it as cheaply as possible. This appeals to consumers, who display all the emulation and status-signaling behaviors we have discussed. In short, capitalism is efficient at delivering what people want, and people seem, due to cultural-evolutionary traits, to constantly want more. This did not start with the Industrial Revolution. The quest for more has characterized most of human history, both in periods when growth was achieved, and when it was not

Climate change and value systems

2023 UTNIF Kritik
Aff Answers › 2AC stuff › FW

Policy planning is pedagogically valuable and necessary to test arguments.

Gazzola 23 Gazzola, M. Ulster University, REAL – Research group “Economics, policy analysis, and language”, Grin, F. University of Geneva, REAL – Research group “Economics, policy analysis, and language”, Cardinal, L. Université de l’Ontario français / University of Ottawa, & Heugh, K. University of South Australia (2023). Language policy and planning: from theory to practice. In The Routledge Handbook of Language Policy and Planning. Routledge. pg. 17

Such diagnoses may of course result from very cogent arguments, although one might query the implicit reduction of the political process to interest-based politics that pit (often unduly essentialized) groups against each other. However, independently of whether the case made is compelling or not, a direct consequence of such an emphasis is that the discussion drifts towards ideological and political claims instead of the examination of actual policies (Cardinal & Sonntag 2015). These ideological and political dimensions, however (and as shown in Section 2) are only part of what LPP is about, and they are heavily focused on just one the phases of LPP, namely agenda-setting. Addressing the questions that actors face when they debate, advocate, campaign for, design, adopt, implement, appropriate, evaluate, or reform language policies, certainly requires analyses that embrace the political questions favoured by some strands of current research; but this does not, for that matter, foreclose the rigorous, systematic and comparative examination, assessment and evaluation of public policy plans and measures, whether when they are first designed or after they have been implemented. Such analyses are useful and even indispensable for civil servants, elected officials, professionals in various sectors, scholars, the media, and, ultimately, citizens at large, in order to engage in meaningful democratic debate. Alongside a focus on agenda-setting, significant tracts of current research devote much attention to discourses about language policies as distinct from language policies themselves (for an overview, see Reisigl, 2013). As Johnson aptly notes, “a lot of language policy analysis is, essentially, discourse analysis, since it involves looking at various texts (both spoken and written) and analyzing policy discourses that are instantiated within or engendered by the policy texts” (2013: 152). This, however, creates a risk of neglecting other forms of knowledge that actors also need. Providing such knowledge requires us to engage in the demanding task of identifying and measuring complex real-world processes, striving for a clear vision of the relationships between them, and using various types of hard data, ranging from the qualitative to the quantitative, to back up our accounts of such processes (see several chapters in Hult & Johnson, 2015). This is also a necessary condition for assessing the extent to which the claims made can be generalised.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
2NC – Cap K › 2NC – Alt › Alt Solves

The alternative empowers and produces energies for the party-form, which is vital to build affective infrastructure for the movement.

Bosworth 23 Bosworth, K. Ph.D. Geography, University of Minnesota, M.A. Geography, University of Minnesota, B.A. Environmental Studies, Macalester College. Bosworth is the author of "Pipeline Populism: Affective Infrastructures of Grassroots Environmentalism in the 21st Century," which examines the possibilities and limitations of pipeline opposition movements in the central United States in grounding the popular politics of climate justice. His ongoing research examines how environmental “protectors of the subsurface” intertwine data collection and environmental imaginaries in contesting the effects of oil and gas on underground spaces like aquifers and caves, thus inventing new cultures of conservation practice. (2023). What is ‘affective infrastructure’?. Dialogues in Human Geography, 13(1), 54-72. ut-ac

What sorts of organizational form might be sustained by an affective infrastructure? Dean’s retrospective on U.S. communist organizing in history and the present provides an analogous attention to the relationship between an affective infrastructure and political organization. Returning to crowd theory and group psychology, Dean’s goal is to reconstruct how the party form creates ‘practical optimism’ among its subjects, holding open not just collective endurance but also politics as a project of moving together in a certain direction (2016: 220). Building on this argument, Kamish (2021: 4) further analyzes the way that the Black Panther Party sought to become the vanguard ‘“affective infrastructure” for sustaining revolutionary feeling and political action’. Thus the ‘affective infrastructure’ that the party or the squat layers in and through its spaces augments the collective’s power of acting. It is the form which allows people to ‘become bigger, able to do more than they could have imagined’ (Dean, 2016: 209, emphasis added). Furthermore, it is through the organization of this infrastructure that such power coheres and is sustained, across time. The organizational form ‘provides an apparatus for this endurance’ (Dean, 2016: 217).2 Though in a politically divergent way from the analysis of anarchist organizing, Dean’s analysis of the party as a form still resonates: the point of an organizational infrastructure is to hold open space in which the energy of formative collective affects can be sustained rather than dissipate (as in crowd phenomenon) or become re-routed by the state.

Drawing attention to such affective infrastructures leads us to consider a fuller range of organizational forms which might sustain desiring subjects than the squat, commune, or party (Nunes, 2021: 230). Among these other forms might be the ‘infrastructures of feeling’ that Gilmore (2017: 237) suggests can be found in the long history of transnational abolitionist movements. For Gilmore, ‘infrastructure of feeling’ defines how ‘ideology becomes material as do the actions that feelings enable or constrain’ (2017: 237). Gilmore is concerned with understanding how abolition geographies and the Black Radical Tradition alike might build sustaining narrative arcs toward liberation, and further embed these arcs in spatial arrangements that reproduce and grow their power. Gilmore turns to infrastructure of feeling to elucidate the ‘consciousness-foundation’ which ‘underlies our capacity to select, to recognize possibility as we select and reselect liberatory lineages’ in a deliberately capacious manner (Gilmore 2017: 237, emphasis added). The practice of abolition geography, as a kind of organized historical materialism for liberation, mobilizes a movement ‘back in timespace’ to select and reselect ancestors as a kind of emotional sustenance, a way of finding ‘alternatives to the despairing sense that so much change, in retrospect, seems only ever to have been displacement and redistribution of human sacrifice’ (228). It is an open question what forces compose that which underlies our capacities to select, but it is clear again that these include ‘feelings [that] enable or constrain’ actions (237).

2023 UTNIF Kritik
2NC – Cap K › 2NC – Alt › Alt Solves

Only the alternative solves – centering neoliberalism is key to produce new transformative processes to research and politics. Our pedagogy invigorates action to disrupt flows that maintain “hope” and “normative structures” and reorient the meaning of “radical change” – this independently turns all DAs to the perm.

Fletcher 23 Fletcher, R. Robert Fletcher is Associate Professor of Sociology of Development and Change at Wageningen University. He is the author of Romancing the Wild: Cultural Dimensions of Ecotourism and a coauthor of The Conservation Revolution: Radical Ideas for Saving Nature beyond the Anthropocene. (2023). Failing Forward: The Rise and Fall of Neoliberal Conservation. Univ of California Press. pp. 210-220. ut-ac

This conclusion responds to a growing call within the social sciences for researchers to move beyond merely critiquing “things that they do not like” (Igoe and Brockington 2007: 445) and instead also contribute to formulating practical proposals for positive future directions. In the process, it also helps to advance discussion of the more intimate (both intra- and interpersonal) aspects of the transformation needed for degrowth to become possible. Thus far, growing discussions of the potential for degrowth have largely neglected in-depth attention to how this potential resonates at the level of (inter) personal subjectivity, notwithstanding notable exceptions pointing in this direction.1 Yet psychological perspectives, most prominently psychoanalysis, have long explored how a demand for infinite growth can be seen to inhere at both personal (Žižek 1989) and societal levels (Kapoor 2015; Bjerg 2016). The following discussion builds on these insights to explore how they might also help chart a path toward embrace of a post-capitalist transformation in pursuit of degrowth as well.

The Critique of Critique

2023 UTNIF Kritik
2NC – Cap K › Links › L - Universal Basic Income

Prescribing UBI as the “solution” to inequalities and inequities of capitalism is a demonstrative misunderstanding of responding to the root cause – UBI is a painkiller at best and a magnifier to continued financialization and disempowerment.

Szreter 22 Szreter, S. Simon Szreter is Professor of History and Public Policy at Cambridge University and co-founder and editor of History & Policy (2022). How Seriously Should we Take Universal Basic Income?. The Political Quarterly, 93(3), 517-523. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/1467-923X.13169. ut-ac

In light of all this, it is not possible to evaluate UBI's prioritisation of reducing absolute poverty simply on its own terms and without putting it in the context of the larger problem of runaway global inequality. This is because UBI is a large and expensive policy of fiscal transfers. To back it as the right national policy to deal with absolute poverty directly entails the opportunity cost of not implementing quite a range of alternative resource-using policies, which cannot be afforded at the same time. If it can be argued that those alternative policies would not only redress absolute poverty, but would also decelerate inequality, then advocates of UBI, though motivated by good intentions towards the world's poor, could in fact be viewed as unwitting handmaidens of the avaricious and of untaxed global capitalism's dynamic of ever-increasing inequality, as identified by Piketty and others.

The 1970s crisis of confidence in the capacity of the Keynesian managed economy to provide paid employment for the bulk of its population was the context which encouraged several leading left-wing European thinkers and politicians to engage initially with the neoliberal policy of negative income tax that was first propounded by Milton Friedman, and subsequently with UBI. This followed on from what is described by Andrew Sanchez as ‘the cybernation frenzy’ that gripped influential futurologists like Robert Theobald in 1960s USA.13 The menace of intelligent machines ‘taking over’ also elicited an immediate imaginative response in British popular culture (one thinks of Dr Who's Daleks in 1963 and the Cybermen in 1965). The left was already, since Hungary 1956 and Czechoslovakia 1968, disillusioned with what a communist state could do; and now it was beginning to doubt that the social democratic Keynesian welfare state had a future for worker-citizens, either.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
2NC – Cap K › Links › L – Social Security

The view of Social Security reform misses the larger neoliberal processes of globalization and increased consumption that has systematically produced a litany of impacts to welfare-entrapped populations.

Viana and Silva 18 Viana, A. L. D. Á., & Silva, H. P. D. | Ana Luiza d’Ávila Viana participated in the design of the article, review and systematization of the literature, writing of the manuscript, Departamento de Medicina Preventiva, Faculdade de Medicina, Universidade de São Paulo; Hudson Pacifico da Silva’s review and systematization of the literature, writing the manuscript, critical review, Institut de Recherche en Santé Publique, Université de Montréal. (2018). Neoliberal meritocracy and financial capitalism: consequences for social protection and health. Ciencia & saude coletiva, 23, pp. 2110-2111. ut-ac

The welfare state, neoliberalism and financialization of social protection

The creation and development of the welfare state – that is, a national system of decommodified social service provision, based on the creation of social funds maintained by the collection of taxes and social security contributions, where it falls upon the state to protect the population against the major risks that threaten individuals in contemporary societies (accidents, illness, aging, death, unemployment, social exclusion) – occurred in a specific moment in history (1945- 75) marked by the positive conjunction between economic growth and the reduction of social inequalities16. During this period, various countries adopted active political policies designed to promote economic growth, either through the implementation of monetary, fiscal and exchange rate policies, or direct public investment. At the same time, the role played by unions and adoption of labor protection policies also contributed to real wage growth and the introduction of various worker benefits. These factors made it possible to conciliate accelerated economic growth with a more equal distribution of the wealth generated.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
2NC – Cap K › Links › L – Social Security

Expanding social security legitimizes anti-labor governance and erodes worker’s rights. The 1AC entrenches social security in neoliberal institutions, where individual value is defined by labor production.

Devinatz 19 Devinatz, V. G. (2019). Left-Wing SPA-Led and CPUSA-Led Unions and Worker Organizations as the Vanguard of US Social Democracy’s Left-Wing, Circa 1935 to 1950. Labor Studies Journal, 44(1), 60-78. ut-ac

A lot of the core tenants of worker-based orgs (CPUSA, IWO, SPA, etc) started to fizzle out in the 1950s due to the growing nature to resist regulation

Certainly the CPUSA’s adoption of the Popular Front in 1935 encouraged the IWO to become an even stronger supporter of the New Deal. And it appears that after 1935, Roosevelt’s agenda became more acceptable to the IWO with the inauguration of FDR’s Second New Deal. While the First New Deal revolved around the National Recovery Administration, the Second New Deal involved the implementation of more substantial legislation including the National Labor Relations, Social Security, and the Fair Labor Standards Acts, which delivered more tangible benefits to the working class. Besides lobbying for the passage of the Social Security Act, the IWO also pushed for the enactment of universal health care, beginning in 1937 until its destruction in the early 1950s.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
2NC – Cap K › Links › L – Job Guarantee/MMT

The aff is no better than a “backstop” for the markets – upholding or aiming to “correct” capitalism via job guarantees is the pitch to buy snake oil.

Roberts 19 Roberts, M. Michael Roberts worked in the City of London as an economist for over 40 years. He has closely observed the machinations of global capitalism from within the dragon’s den. At the same time, he was a political activist in the labour movement for decades. (2019). Modern Monetary Theory: A Marxist Critique. Class, Race and Corporate Power, 7(1), 1-17. ut-ac

The answer to unemployment or the end of crises does not lie in the simple recourse of issuing money, as MMT claims. MMT relies on what Marx called “the tricks of circulation” – “the doctrine that proposes tricks of circulation as a way of, on the one hand, avoiding the violent character of these social changes and on the other, of making these changes appear not to be a presupposition but gradual result of these transformations in circulation”.

MMT claims that it has an endogenous theory of money, but in reality it has an exogenous one, based on state issuance of money. It claims that government spending can be expanded to any level necessary to achieve full employment through money issuance, without any reference to the productive activity of the non-state economy, in particular the profitability of the capitalist sector. Indeed, according to MMT, capitalism can be saved and achieve harmonious growth and full employment by ‘tricks of circulation’. MMT ignores or hides the social relations of exploitation of labor for profit. And by selling ‘snake oil’ (MMT) instead, it misleads the labor movement away from fundamental change.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
2NC – Cap K › Links › L – Job Guarantee/MMT

The guise of “Job Guarantee” solving impacts is rooted in maximizing full productivity and vitriol to welfare, which alienates and extracts labor from workers – that alone causes endless poverty.

King 20 King, A. D. Adam D. K. King is Postdoctoral Visitor in the Department of Politics at York University in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. (2020). Critical reflections on the job guarantee proposal. Studies in Political Economy, 101(3), 230-244. ut-ac

The myopic focus on paid employment is not confined to Minsky’s work, however. Contemporary JG advocates—while less explicit in their opposition to welfare—also privilege paid work in ways that complement capitalism’s structural dependence on, and lack of recognition of, social reproductive labour. Wray, for example, tends to lean more heavily on the political feasibility argument, claiming that the ease with which neoliberal politicians have cut or “reformed” welfare programs shows the latter’s weakness as a policy solution to poverty.52 Wray maintains that this is particularly evident in the way that the War on Poverty transformed into a “war on welfare” from Reagan onwards. This history of welfare retrenchment evinces the need to reorient social policy towards job creation and greater labour force participation. Such an approach is further substantiated, according to Wray, by Clinton’s “reform” to “end welfare as we know it” with the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Act, 1996, and replace Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC) with the Temporary Assistance to Needy Families program, both of which are widely recognized to encapsulate the “welfare-to-work” push of the 1990s’ workfare state.53 Wray contends that the lack of public support for AFDC, and thus its susceptibility to political attack, substantiates the need for a social policy geared towards public sector employment and a job guarantee (the political feasibility argument). Yet rather than develop a critique of what they believe to be the prevailing public consensus on “welfare,” Wray and Kelton use this public antipathy to buttress their argument for publicly guaranteed full employment. In this way, they reinforce a discourse that privileges waged “productive” labour and fails to recognize the structural dependence of capitalist market exchange on social reproductive work, which is often unpaid.

For Wray and others, social policy should bolster the centrality of waged labour and account for the ostensibly inelastic public disapproval of welfare. Yet JG advocates often neglect the ways that their advocacy of job creation and greater labour force participation might contribute to a politics of welfare retrenchment that does not lead to the kind of job program they envision, but instead to various forms of workfare pushing people into low-wage private sector employment. Indeed, it was no coincidence that paired alongside the Clinton administration’s reforms to AFDC was the Earned Income Tax Credit, which aimed to incentivize labour market entrance at the same time that welfare access was being limited and the general move towards “workfare” was intensifying.54 Clinton and his economic team drew approvingly on Minsky’s ideas about “welfare dependency” and the supposed poverty reduction potential of greater employment.55 Admittedly, Wray and other JG enthusiasts disapprove of the Clintonian approach. Building on Minsky’s criticisms of Johnson’s War on Poverty, they maintain that, likewise, the Clinton reforms were largely about forcing potential workers to be “employment ready” rather than creating public jobs, that is, they were labour market “supply side” reforms and not “demand” solutions. Yet by failing to account for how policy proposals might be taken up in an inhospitable political environment, JG advocates missed the ways that employment promotion fed the assault on social welfare.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
2NC – Cap K › Links › L – Job Guarantee/MMT

JGP is MMT in disguise. Federal jobs endlessly erodes worker’s rights, masks class conflict, and reproduces a neoliberal ethos of austerity.

Palley 19 Palley, Thomas I. (2019). Palley received his Bachelor of Arts degree from Oxford University in 1976. He earned a master's degree in international relations and a PhD in economics from Yale University. Palley founded the Economics for Democratic & Open Societies project. He states its purpose is to "stimulate public discussion about what kinds of economic arrangements and conditions are needed to promote democracy and open society."[1] Palley's previous positions include director of the Open Society Institute’s Globalization Reform Project, and Assistant Director of Public Policy for the AFL-CIO.[1] : What's wrong with modern money theory (MMT): A critical primer, FMM Working Paper, No. 44, Hans-Böckler-Stiftung, Macroeconomic Policy Institute (IMK), Forum for Macroeconomics and Macroeconomic Policies (FFM), Düsseldorf. https://www.econstor.eu/handle/10419/213401. pp. 22-32. **footnotes omitted ut-ac

3. Employer of last resort (ELR) or job guarantee program (JGP)22

The second leg of MMT’s triad of arguments in Figure 1 is the proposal for a JGP, whereby the central government would offer work to any who applied (i.e. act as employer of last resort). In principle, the JGP is completely separable from MMT and can be considered as a stand-alone program on the basis of its own merits. However, for MMT, the JGP is central because it is the way via which policy is supposed to harnesses the power to create money so as to deliver productive non-inflationary full employment.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
2NC – Cap K › Links › L – Green Infrastructure

Green infrastructure conflates the problem with the solution. The metaphor of the New Deal demonstrates the desire for the state to reestablish legitimacy and initiate a new cycle of accumulation.

McCollum 22 McCollum, J. (2022). John McCollum is an assistant professor of sociology at Minot State University. Avoiding the pitfalls of capitalism in the Green New Deal. In Routledge Handbook on the Green New Deal (pp. 78-83). Routledge. ut-ac

State capitalism and the problem of entrenched political power

Our next important area for critiquing the GND in Marxist perspective is the state. The question of whether the working class can advance its interests through the state remains a heated debate in Marxist political thought. Marxist political theorist Ralph Miliband held that the state could be turned toward working-class interests through parliamentary means. The state reflected capital’s interests because of the capitalist class’s occupation of decision-making power and influence over the parliamentary process. Miliband believed that the working class could capture some degree of political power in national politics and affect change in that manner. A case in point was the rise to power of the Labour Party after World War II in Miliband’s native United Kingdom. The social-democratic nature of the GND highlights the hopes of its supporters to advance the GND through national parliaments and congresses, rather than, say, through revolutionary means. Given that the state will remain intact, we should look further into what this means for the class nature of the GND and the problems this may create, socially and environmentally.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
2NC – Cap K › Links › L – Market Solution

The new age of Capitalocene predicates resource scarcity as an insular symptom of the market environment. The 1AC engages in a form of policy limitation to manage the environment that inevitably locks in global ramifications of overconsumption.

Spangenberg 22 Spangenberg, J. H. (2022). Dr. Joachim H. Spangenberg is research coordinator at the Sustainable Europe Research Institute SERI Germany in Cologne. With a PhD in economics, but an academic background biology and ecology, he is an inter- and transdisciplinary researcher by education and dedication. He works on sustainable development strategies, environmental conflicts, sustainable consumption, biodiversity conservation by pressure reduction, ecosystem services and their valuation incl. limits of economic growth. Inside the Anthropo-Populo-Consumo-Capitalocene. Anthropocene Science, 368-369. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s44177-022-00031-3. ut-ac

The first hypothesis to be questioned is that when the economy as a whole does not grow, credit will dry out and the economy will collapse. It assumes that if there is no chance for aggregate surplus, potential lenders (financial institutions and share buyers) would not see an opportunity for profitable investments and loans. As a consequence, they would keep their money, and the financial markets would dry out. However, this is only plausible as long as we analyse the economy as consisting of representative agents, one banker, one producer, one consumer. But if we take but one step closer to reality, the Fata Morgana disappears. Just imagine two banks A and B, and two corporations: a winner Wi and a loser Lo. Both apply for credit, and the banks must make a choice. Of course, they will check the risk even more carefully than today (and again will be wrong time and again), but in the end they will make a choice, hoping to make a fortune by picking the right from to lend to. Assuming bank A was right and bank B was wrong, what would be the result? Company Wi would make a profit, company Lo might go bust, bank A would make a profit and bank B would suffer from a loss. Both would continue lending as long as possible, A to continue success, B to make up for the losses. As soon we give up on conceptual oversimplifications, the risk of a financial system standstill turns out to be an artefact of economic theory, not a threat from economic reality. The same line of argumentation applies to shareholders and buyers, to the management (trying to make a profit would still be their objective and desire), to entrepreneurs and so forth: as long as some will grow, the situation is not structurally different from today, only the share of losers is higher and thus the competition fiercer. More companies would go bust, some more start-ups would falter while others could thrive – all not too new, at least in principle. The innovation dynamic and with it competition would increase. It would be a Schumpeterian economy of creative destruction, and incumbents would be forced to refocus their innovative capacities to enhance their resource productivity, the ¥€$ per ton and hectare of resources used. To risk-taking managers not only keen to grow but to enhance their market share, more frequent bankruptcy of competitors might even be appealing. Therefore, monopoly and cartel control would become more important than ever; no company should be permitted to become “too big to fail”. For corporate staff, this would imply a higher probability of losing their jobs due to employers’ bankruptcy more often in their lives, which in turn would require adjustments in the respective benefit and transfer systems, mirroring the transition from lifelong employment to patchwork labour biographies. Labour productivity increases could only be compensated by reducing working hours at constant gross salaries. From a management point of view (and partly also for the staff), this would be a pretty stressing situation: creative destruction at its best. However, the down side lies in the end of aggregate income growth (which brings distributional issues to the forefront), and the current crisis of care: both remunerated and unpaid care work are increasingly short in supply, and in an ageing society more unpaid care will probably be required (Spitzner and Spangenberg 2022; Spangenberg and Lorek 2022). The series of permanent bankruptcies is a form of rather steady capital destruction, unlike the simultaneous bust of many companies characterizing recessions and depressions of a growth bound economy. It is shedding of early what a capitalist market economy tends to produce above the level of activity set as a physical maximum (the size of the economy, Daly would call it). While standard economics considers this a major flaw of any external limitation to growth, it is necessary to inhibit the macroeconomic effect of corporate growth. At the same time, capital destruction of corporations and banks limits the growth impulse from the credit and interest mechanism. This way a resource cap addresses two of the key drivers of economic growth and keeps them in check. For citizens, small savers and many employees this is not necessarily bad news. It would be a different mode of regulation as compared to the more recent path: from of a series of booms, bubbles and bursts, of capital accumulation and large scale destruction, the economy would shift to a steadier process. Given the distribution effects associated with the bubble-burst based mode of regulation, the shift would provide more stability; the risk would be more distributed and thus more manageable. The result would be the end of capitalism as we know it – but not of capitalism as such (Altvater 2005). As this scenario narrative has shown, setting legally binding and enforced physical caps to the resource consumption of societies and economies will profoundly alter the inner working of a capitalist economy; they can be used as effective steering instruments in the Capitalocene. Another reason for the increased emphasis on non-market instruments is that the unfolding Anthropocene is a resource constrained era, regarding sources and sinks. Hence policies which are based on the possibility of unlimited increases of supply if only the prices provide the right incentives to provide them, are outdated and increasingly risky for environment, society and the economy itself. The pandemic with its repeated supply chain disruptions, and the Ukraine war with the blockade of some Ukrainian and the ban on most Russian exports provide first experiences with supply side crises and their economic impacts. If resources are not only scarce but limited – be it by natural conditions, by policy decisions anticipating them to give both society and the economy time to adapt, or by natural or political disasters – market mechanisms fail. The question to be answered is who should go without, and how the essential functions of society can be maintained irrespective of the purchasing power on the demand side – which is exactly what the German government prepares for in expectance of an end to Russian gas supply. An ordinance regulating the potential rationalising of gas in situations of scarcity (the GasNZV, Verordnung über den Zugang zu Gasversorgungsnetzen) has been adopted, stating that primary recipients of scarce gas resources will be households, health care institutions and emergency services from police to the fire brigade. A public agency will decide which industry sectors and individual producers will be closed down in the case of a termination of Russian gas supply – with preference given to those where production facilities, once shut down, cannot be restarted. However, remembering that essential sectors identifed in the pandemic included road transport, the retail sector, and waste management, it is obvious that cement production, chemical industry, automobile production and other sectors will suffer from resource limitations, despite their high purchasing power. As these are also sectors with a significant world market share, the crisis-borne new allocation system will have global repercussions if activated. While all restrictions are planned to be only temporarily, they provide the first hints at the allocation mechanisms required in a resource constrained economy, although neither politicians nor managers appear to understand this lesson yet.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
2NC – Cap K › 2NC – AT Perm › AT Perm do the aff then alt

The permutation is a prescription that alleviates some symptoms, but never treat the root cause – ONLY the alternative fosters the greatest chance for transition only through an invigorated understanding of colonial extraction and histories based on the imperial impulse of the 1AC.

Fernandes 20 Fernandes, S. Sabrina Fernandes is an ecosocialist activist based in Brazil. She is the lead editor for Jacobin Brasil, a postdoctoral fellow at the International Research Group on Authoritarianism and Counter-Strategies of the Rosa Luxemburg Stiftung and the University of Brasília, and she runs the radical left YouTube channel Tese Onze. (2020). Ecosocialism from the Margins. NACLA Report on the Americas, 52(2), 142-143. ut-ac

At some level, this requires ecosocialists to consider reform and revolution. Ecosocialism is a revolutionary perspective, yet it must be aware of the mediations required to guarantee the ecological conditions for a revolution. The urgency of climate change calls for decarbonization while still under capitalism. This does not mean, however, accepting such a plan on capitalist terms. The logic must be to decarbonize fast, with a focus on the public system, fighting privatization at all costs, and strengthening popular movements and organizations. A decarbonized mode of production is necessary to ensure that when workers are ready to overthrow capitalist structures, there is still a healthy planet on which to build socialism.

This is why projects aimed at outstripping the carbon economy, such as the Green New Deal, propose a transition from a carbon-based economy to renewables. This transition requires change in many areas, but it is not what socialists call a transitional program, let alone a socialist revolutionary endeavor. Decarbonization is both an immediate necessity and a material prerequisite for any transitional program and the very prospect of organizing to abolish private property. To be successful, decarbonization efforts need to be highly coordinated, but in a bottom-up fashion. Third-stage ecosocialism calls for mobilizing entire working-class sectors while also growing the Left by attracting those concerned about the viability of life into the next century.

2023 UTNIF Kritik
2NC – Cap K › 2NC stuff › Collapse Now - UQ

Collapse will be triggered – the current addiction to growth and compounding debt dooms us to collapse.

Sagin and Çaglar 23 Sagin, A., Çaglar, Ü. (2023). Great Reset. In: Ari, A. (eds) Capitalism at a Crossroads. Springer Studies in Alternative Economics. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-23257-2_14. pp. 259. ut-ac

There is a relationship between the need for growth and debt, another addiction to the economic system. The economic system accumulates huge debt stocks inherent in the monetary system. Since debt is a claim on the future income, the ability of the economic agencies to pay it back is dependent on the increase in income. If income does not grow, the increasing debt-to-income ratio will rise the danger of insolvency. This addiction to growth, which destroys the environment and exploits the world’s resources, has led to inequalities and violent conflicts, failing to bring prosperity to most human beings. Because growth rates are decreasing globally, the prosperity of the powerful minority is not sustainable. Crises have gained a global character, affecting wealthy nations, and a systemic collapse has appeared.

To understand the crisis-generating nature of the capitalist system, the relationship between money, credit, and banking needs to be analyzed. In the modern monetary system, banks are authorized to create credit out of nothing by lending deposits many times. Because credit functions as money, banks can create money that is not a physical entity but merely a number in a bank account. Considering that more than 90% of the money is supplied by banks in economies, it can be said that money emission was privatized in the modern economic system.