Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Affirmative
***UBI Negative Supplement*** › UBI minus bad › * turn – UBI replacement bad

Turn - UBI trades off better systems and exacerbates marginalization

Iyahen et al , UN Women’s Headquarters, 21 [ Isiuwa, “Universal Basic Income as a means of Gender-Responsive Social Protection”, Joint SGD Fund, 9/22/2021, access info , date accessed 7/13/2023, GDI-AL]

Some caution however that if a UBI is considered only as a minimal safety net, it could be used to justify the roll back of state responsibility and funding of social security systems that provide comparatively higher levels of protection including care services, housing, education and health care.

Other limitations of introducing a UBI that were considered were:

2023 GDI Affirmative
***UBI Negative Supplement*** › Inequality debate › Alt causes

Alt causes to inequality the plan doesn’t solve

Siripurapu, Council on Foreign Relations, 2022

[Anshu, “The U.S. Inequality Debate”, Council on Foreign Relations, 4/20/22, https://www.cfr.org/backgrounder/us-inequality-debate, 7/11/23 GDI- SC]

* Figure omitted

2023 GDI Affirmative
***UBI Negative Supplement*** › Inequality debate › Overestimated

Inequality overstated – multiple metrics

Siripurapu, Council on Foreign Relations, 2022

[Anshu, “The U.S. Inequality Debate”, Council on Foreign Relations, 4/20/22, https://www.cfr.org/backgrounder/us-inequality-debate, 7/11/23 GDI- SC]

* Figure omitted

2023 GDI Affirmative
K answers › Cap k

UBI + reframes societal treatment of labor and its racialized marginalization

The Undercommons, 2017

[The Undercommons is a freedom school in Los Angeles that was started at UCLA. It works to provide oppressed peoples' social movements with the resources housed at universities, “No Racial Justice Without Basic Income” Boston Review May 3, 2017 accessed 6.23.23 GDI-TM]

More radical challenges to racial capitalism are possible. UBI+, by guaranteeing everyone an income sufficient to live on, reframes the way society treats labor and provides security to its citizens. For example, this kind of guarantee recognizes that the labor of raising children and caring for the elderly—work done disproportionately by women—is valued as work. Currently much of this work is uncompensated, and as a result we economically and socially marginalize those who do it. In a capitalist system where economic value and overall value are often conflated, this reinforces the idea that caregiving is not an important contribution to society and penalizes people who try to do this work alongside paid work (e.g., child-unfriendly work policies, expensive child care, lack of clear leave policies for caring for children or elders). UBI- would provide a guaranteed income but eliminate programs that respond to these specific concerns, such as those provided by Social Security that target the needs of elderly and disabled people. This would effectively offer security with one hand while taking it with the other.

2023 GDI Affirmative
K answers › Cap k

Perm solvency and alt alone fails -- Limitations in ecosocialism mean a UBI can bridge the gap and sustain workers in a green economy

Lawhon, Assistant Professor of Geography and Environmental Sustainability at the University of Oklahoma, and McCreary, Assistant Professor at the Department of Geography at Florida State University, 2020

[Mary and Tyler, “Beyond Jobs vs Environment: On the Potential of Universal Basic Income to Reconfigure Environmental Politics” Antipode, 28 January 2020, https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/anti.12604, Accessed 7/13/2023 GDI-HB]

Green Marxism

2023 GDI Affirmative
CP Answers › Temporary UBI › *AT temporary/counter-cyclical UBI

Prabhakar, senior lecturer in personal finance, 22

[Rajiv Prabhakar, “Are Temporary or Permanent Income Payments Better Placed to Boost Demand during Covid-19?,” Basic Income Studies 17(1) p. 15-27 Gonzaga – Ebsco accessed 7-11-2023 GDI–AL]

Evidence to date on both vouchers and emergency payments suggest that these policies only have a modest role in raising demand. One might still support a universal basic income as a way of guaranteeing social protection or social justice. However, the case for income payments as a demand stimulus might be stronger if these were permanent, as with a universal basic income, rather than temporary. One reason for this is that a universal basic income might perform as an automatic stabilizer to smooth consumption over the economic cycle. Much of the existing literature on automatic stabilizers does not focus specifically on a universal basic income but rather on other taxes or benefits (Maravalle & Rawdanowicz, 2020; Sahm, 2019). But there may be a case for extending automatic stabilisers to cover policies such as a universal basic income. Moffitt and Ziliak (2020) say that there is a patchwork of policies providing social assistance in the US. The most important of these are unemployment insurance (which varies by state) and the Federal Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) or ‘food stamps’. Moffitt and Ziliak (2020) propose extra Federal cash for low-income families with young children as a way to cut income volatility during economic shocks. These researchers do not consider the role of a universal basic income, but this might nevertheless act as an automatic stabilizer to smooth demand over the economic cycle. Sahm (2019) is more explicit about the role of direct stimulus payments as an automatic stabiliser. Her proposal was shaped before the onset of Covid-19 and drew on research on the effects of stimulus payments around the time of the global financial crisis of 2008–2009. Based on her analysis of stimulus payments made after the global financial crisis of 2009–09, she calls for: ‘direct payments to individuals as an automatic stabilizer. The lump-sum annual payments would be made to individuals, regardless of their income level, when the national unemployment rate rises by at least 0.50% points’ (Sahm, 2019, 67). Sahm’s idea is not a universal basic income as the trigger for the payments is the unemployment rate. But this proposal highlights the ways that the discussion of automatic stabilizers could extend to cover income payments besides policies such as unemployment benefit. A case for permanent over temporary payments need not be tied only to an argument about automatic stabilizers. Other economic traditions also provide an argument for permanent over temporary payments. Friedman’s Permanent Income Hypothesis suggests that people base their consumer spending upon a notion of permanent income that stretches across their lifetime. Theory and empirical tests of the Permanent Income Hypothesis suggest that a change in permanent income will have a bigger effect on consumer spending than a change in temporary income (Aguiar & Hurst, 2008; Friedman, 1957; Lugilde, Bande, & Riveiro, 2019; Meghir, 2004). A universal basic income would add to a permanent income and so could be expected to have a bigger impact than temporary payments.

2023 GDI Affirmative
CP Answers › Carbon Tax › Carbon tax funding bad

Carbon Taxing BI fails – it’s self-defeating

Pinto, Universidade do Minho, ‘20

[Jorge, “Environmentalism, Ecologism, and Basic Income”, Basic Income Studies Vol 15.1 https://doi.org/10.1515/bis-2019-0026accessed 7-11-2023 GDI-FLC]

The balance between the total value collected through taxing polluting activities and the amount at which a BI can be set is an extremely complex one. The risk of financing a BI based exclusively on fees on polluting activities is that it may fall victim to its own policy: success in reducing polluting activities can mean the failure of economic sustainability of the BI. This could lead to a scenario whereby in order to maintain the financing source of a BI, the continuation of the polluting activities would be accepted or even encouraged.

2023 GDI Affirmative
CP Answers › PIC redistribution › No solvency

In order to challenge consumption patterns, redistributive taxes necessary for EBI

Pinto, Universidade do Minho, ‘20

[Jorge, “Environmentalism, Ecologism, and Basic Income”, Basic Income Studies Vol 15.1 https://doi.org/10.1515/bis-2019-0026accessed 7-11-2023 GDI-FLC]

We are now confronted with two scenarios: the first, endogenous, in which funding of a BI through polluting activities would lead people to a radical change of their behaviours and habits, opting for a more sustainable way of life and, the second, exogenous, in which in addition to these measures of taxing polluting activities other complementary activities would promote such behavioural change. As Howard et al. (2019) argue, a green BI, by itself, can hardly ensure the positive ecological consequences that it proposes, which is why additional mea- sures, such as reducing the number of working hours, introducing educational programmes aimed at ecological preservation, and defining a maximum income are necessary. In this way, advocates of an ecological BI would also have to insist on the need for these measures.

2023 GDI Affirmative
CP Answers › FJG › UBI better than FJG

Prefer UBI over jobs guarantee, training programs fall apart with certain types of work

Lawhon, Assistant Professor of Geography and Environmental Sustainability at the University of Oklahoma, and McCreary, Assistant Professor at the Department of Geography at Florida State University, 2020

[Mary and Tyler, “Beyond Jobs vs Environment: On the Potential of Universal Basic Income to Reconfigure Environmental Politics” Antipode, 28 January 2020, https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/anti.12604, Accessed 7/13/2023 GDI-HB]

Recent public discussions about a Green New Deal (GND) in the US explicitly draw on ideas of a Just Transition and form a useful example for us here. While as yet a nascent platform, the GND broadly proposes that jobs will be created through investments in green infrastructure and includes provisions for worker training and a “Jobs Guarantee”.1 Our concern with a Jobs Guarantee is that it is disconnected from changes occurring to employment in North America and globally. As noted above, technological disemployment will change the types of jobs associated with new employment possibilities and many activities may well be done more safely and cheaply by robots. Those trained to work in high automated facilities are highly skilled; few can conceivably transfer into this type of work with a few months or even years of state-supported training programs (for a wider analysis of the limited success of retraining programs, see Selingo 2018). In this context, it is likely to be cheaper, safer, greener, and more socially beneficial to provide incomes rather than jobs for many workers (see Schuppert 2019).

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – solvency › UBI – targeted populations › BIG Solves Immigrant Exclusion

Immigrant families are denied access to critical social programs in the status quo – BIG solves

Bogle et al, principal research associate at MHCPC, 2022

[Mary, “Guaranteed Income as a Mechanism for Promoting Housing Stability”, Urban Institute, December 30, https://www.urban.org/research/publication/guaranteed-income-mechanism-promoting-housing-stability, 7-11-2023 GDI- SPB] 

A hallmark of most guaranteed income efforts is their inclusiveness. Although eligibility criteria are often applied (boxes 2 to 4) to ensure access for those who need the funds most, municipal and state implementers often lean into the equity and cost-benefit implications of aiming cash infusion specifically at “excluded workers” who, because of their immigration, tax, or formerly incarcerated status, are typically excluded from accessing housing and other federally funded public benefits, including even short-term emergency rental assistance. Exclusionary federal eligibility policies are common for these populations, whether or not a national emergency is occurring. For example, because of the reality of and confusion over public charge rules, many immigrant families are prevented from accessing public benefits, housing or otherwise, even though millions of undocumented workers in the US pay federal income taxes. This exclusion was particularly harsh at the onset of the pandemic, when relief efforts, including stimulus payments and pandemic unemployment assistance provided through the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act, excluded undocumented individuals or US citizens and legal immigrants in mixed-status families. About 5.1 million US citizens and legal immigrants were excluded because they were children or spouses of unauthorized immigrants.32 In an effort to right this inequity, jurisdictions like the District of Columbia, Houston, and New York State used their general funds and philanthropic contributions to provide immediate cash assistance to these and other workers who were excluded from reaping their share of relief from an economic system they contribute to regularly. A frequently applied design standard found in guaranteed income programs, including the three pilots featured in this brief, is to explicitly include and even seek out participant populations who are excluded from federal cash transfers. In fact, some cash infusion programs are purpose-built to include the excluded. A recently launched guaranteed basic income pilot in New Mexico focuses solely on giving 330 undocumented or mixed-immigration status families $500 a month for 12 months. This decision was based in part on data from a survey of 1,000 Hispanic adults, including nearly 250 immigrants, in which more than half the respondents said they have $1,000 or less saved for financial emergencies, and more than a quarter had gone through that savings, or acquired debt, during the pandemic. Hispanic New Mexican parents were more than twice as likely as white parents in the state to have lost wages since the pandemic began, and more than three times as likely to be unsure about whether they could make their next housing payment.33

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – solvency › UBI [general] Solvency – automation driven displacement › Answer to work incentives decline under UBI

Empirics disprove income effect – and do not support reduction in labor incentives

Fleischer University of San Diego School of Law Professor of Law, and Hemel, University of Chicago Law School Assistant Professor of Law, 2020

[Miranda Perry Fleischer and Daniel Hemel “The Architecture of a Basic Income” The University of Chicago Law Review , Vol. 87, No. 3 (May 2020), pp. 625-710 JSTOR – pre-jcp-tm accessed 4.4.23]

The third and final component of the case for a UBI is the claim that redistributive cash transfers should be uncondi- tional—not limited to individuals of a particular age (for example, the young and the elderly), or to individuals with a demonstrable disability, or to individuals who participate in the workforce. This is probably the most controversial component of the case for a UBI and the point on which welfarism and resource egalitarianism are most equivocal in their support. (Libertarians may find the claim less problematic.) Again, we consider each theory in turn, high- lighting the ways in which lack of conditionality can be justified and evaluating potential counterarguments.

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – solvency › UBI [general] Solvency – automation driven displacement › BIG Solves Circumvention

Biased agency administrators deny access to welfare programs in the status quo. BIG overcomes mistrust and solves circumvention

Bogle et al, principal research associate at MHCPC, 2022

[Mary, “Guaranteed Income as a Mechanism for Promoting Housing Stability”, Urban Institute, December 30, https://www.urban.org/research/publication/guaranteed-income-mechanism-promoting-housing-stability, 7-11-2023 GDI- SPB] 

Guaranteed income, which aims to fill safety net gaps in critical needs like affordable housing, can help challenge the tendency of the American polity and its representatives to mistrust people who use the safety net, especially people who are heavily stigmatized by living in substandard housing or who have experienced homelessness. This mistrust lies at the heart of a commonly held belief that some people are more deserving of assistance than others, in which deservingness is measured by perceptions of how responsible the recipients are and how willing they are to work (Steinberger 2020). This mistrust does not affect just housing safety net users. It is baked into the workings of most policies and institutions meant to serve low-income people. For example, in one study, researchers observed that staff in benefits-administering agencies expressed much unease with “giving people money” if they felt those people did not deserve those funds. Not only that, administrators can act on this unease by withholding cash transfers from those eligible to receive them (Steinberger 2020). A recent World Bank and Stanford University study, “Cash Transfers and Temptation Goods,” corroborates behavioral economics research that finds when money is given for a specific purpose, such as housing, people and organizations tend to use it for that purpose, even when no one is monitoring them (Evans and Popova 2017). In addition, other studies show that people with low incomes are not inclined to consume temptation goods with extra cash any more than people with higher incomes (Evans and Popova 2017). A pilot leader from Austin questioned the equity of common societal expectations when he said, “[Should] we monitor or audit what [participants in the pilot] are spending the money on? I think that we have some soul searching to do around that.”

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – solvency › UBI [general] Solvency – automation driven displacement › BI solves structural unemployment

Basic income solves for threat of massive poverty in an automated future

Malmaeus, et al,  IVL Swedish Environmental Research Institute, 2019

[Mikael, “Basic Income and Social Sustainability in Post-Growth Economies”, Basic Income Studies, August 19, De Gruyter, 7/11/23 GDI- JY]

The automation scenario has a different emphasis, focusing on how the pro- duction of goods and services may be carried out with a minimum of human labor. The Automation scenario is based on the trend of dramatic improvements in and application of information and communication technologies and AI which comes with a number of opportunities such as boosting labor productivity, improved health care, job flexibility, and entirely new goods and services. The radical pro- ductivity growth associated with robotization and digital innovations could enable an economy with a much shorter average working week. According to some commentators the benefits of this increasing production efficiency can thus be traded in for more free time and a more meaningful life (e. g., Gorz, 1999; Max-Neef, 1995). However, these same advances could also lead to growing inequalities and decreased job-stability along with major changes in business organization. Such considerations explain why the idea of basic income as a potential response to automation has been a staple in recent popular discussions on the future of work (Brynjolfsson & McAfee, 2014; Ford, 2015). Utilizing the technological advances to the maximum in combination with reduced material consumption and reduced physical labor is also widely invoked as a political strategy in support of ecological sustainability (see, e. g., An Ecomodernist Manifesto by Asafu-Adjaye et al., 2015). In this context, a UBI may be an indispensable policy tool for the transformation to a high-tech post-growth economy to be associated with emancipation and social progress for all rather than involuntary unemployment, poverty, and exclusion. In the automation scenario basic income is thus mainly perceived as an instrument to enable voluntary job sharing and to ensure that everyone can satisfy their basic needs and share in the profits of automation even though there are many fewer full- time jobs around.

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – solvency › UBI + › UBI+ solves racial wealth gap

UBI solves racial inequality – multiple warrants for redressing racial discrimination

Warren,  Fellow at the Roosevelt Institute, 2017

[Dorian T., “Reparations and Basic Income”, Boston Review, May 3, access info [https://www.bostonreview.net/forum_response/dorian-t-warren-reparations-and-basic-income/] accessed 7/13/23 GDI- JY] 

I have argued that a basic income in all but a few forms—those that exclude the incarcerated or result in a net decrease in benefits—would benefit African American communities for the following reasons.

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – solvency › UBI + › UBI+ solves racial wealth gap

UBI+ solves best for racial wealth inequality

Bhattacharya, vice president of programs and strategy at the Insight Center for Community Economic Development, 19

[Jhumpa, “EXPLORING GUARANTEED INCOME THROUGH A RACIAL AND GENDER JUSTICE LENS”, Roosevelt Institute, 6/19/2019, https://rooseveltinstitute.org/publications/exploring-guaranteed-income-through-a-racial-and-gender-justice-lens) , accessed 7/13/23 GDI- JY]

The universal + basic income model is a tiered guaranteed income proposal, which accounts for the fact that Black people have faced systematic barriers to economic prosperity throughout US history. Conceived by Community Change President Dorian Warren, this model calls for an additional payment to be dispersed to Black families on top of the standard benefit given to all families over a period of time (Warren 2017b). The “plus model” acknowledges that the wealth created in the US is inextricably linked to Black labor, sweat, and tears, and this community has never received the benefits created from that labor. Due to persistent racial discrimination, Black unemployment consistently remains double that of white unemployment, and, as noted before, Black people are dramatically over represented in our criminal justice system due to over-policing and surveillance in Black neighborhoods. It is clear that the UBI + model is the closest implementation we currently have that could make a dent in racial wealth inequities. Given that Black families would receive more money than other communities, it begins to account for the centuries of disinvestment and discrimination Black communities faced, and continue to face, in the US. The plus model does not account for gender wealth inequities, but we can build on the premise of this model when assessing the implementation of a guaranteed income. We will also need to ensure that other wealth-stripping policies through the criminal justice system and other municipal debts that are racialized are eliminated.

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – solvency › EBI [BI solves environment] › Solvency – consumption behavior

BI solves climate – decreases worker commitment to GDP and stimulates non-consumption activities

Pinto, Universidade do Minho, ‘20

[Jorge, “Environmentalism, Ecologism, and Basic Income”, Basic Income Studies Vol 15.1 https://doi.org/10.1515/bis-2019-0026accessed 7-11-2023 GDI-FLC]

The compatibility between a BI and ecological sustainability is not, however, obvious (Andersson, 2010). One question immediately comes to mind: if one of the causes of the current ecological crisis is the productivist model of the economy, based on the ever-increasing extraction of natural resources, over-consumption, and the search for permanent economic growth, will not an extra income contribute even further to the promotion of such a system? Questioning the existence of an environmental justification for the BI, Van Parijs presents two possible reasons why the Greens would support the implementation of a BI, concluding that there is a fundamental, albeit indirect, relationship between BI and ecological issues.

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – solvency › EBI [BI solves environment] › Solvency – food add-on

Current food production and consumption contributes to environmental damages – only a BIG stimulates pro-environment food practices through expanded resources for farmers and consumers

Macneill 19 (Tim - Doctor of Philosophy, Senior Teaching Professor at Ontario Tech University. “Universal Basic Income and the Natural Environment: Theory and Policy.” Basic Income Studies, 14(1), June 2019, , Accessed 7.16.23 gdi-flc]

Irrespective of its impact on health, food production and consumption have direct environmental impacts that could be augmented via a BIG. The food system is one of the largest contributors to greenhouse gas emissions, deforestation, desertification, eutrophication, and biodiversity loss (Goggins & Rau, 2016). These impacts relate to an increased reliance on environmentally damaging international transport, refrigeration, and industrial petro-chemical-based production techniques (Clark & Tilman, 2017). Although there are controversies regarding the accounting of sectoral impacts (Jones et al., 2016), some analyses have shown that the livestock industry alone may have the largest ecological impact of any human sector (Herrero et al., 2013). Accordingly, solutions to environmental crises often include the support of local production, fairly traded goods, sustainable farming practices, and reduced meat consumption (Goggins & Rau, 2016). Many experts argued that a BIG could stimulate such pro-environment food practices by increasing the money and time resources of individuals.

Some have also claimed that environmentally sustainable production could be directly stimulated by providing a basic income for farmers. Aric McBay (2018), of the National Farmers Union of Ontario (NFUO), proposes a BIG pilot that is specifically allocated to farmers in order to study this relationship. Urgency the NFUO has for this pilot proposal is driven by the increasing challenges facing the population of farmers. These include the rising price of farmland which deters young people from farming, an aging farm population with no succession plans, extreme weather conditions, and corporate control of the food system.

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – solvency › EBI [BI solves environment] › Solvency/answer to degrowth bad

BI aids in degrowth – it provides a safety net that solves recession impacts while shaping movements towards resource consumption decline

Pinto, Universidade do Minho, ‘20

[Jorge, “Environmentalism, Ecologism, and Basic Income”, Basic Income Studies Vol 15.1 https://doi.org/10.1515/bis-2019-0026accessed 7-11-2023 GDI-FLC]

It is not surprising that ecologists look to this approach reluctantly. Even if technological solutions to com- pensate for the environmental impact of human activities are created and the separation between economic growth and consumption is achieved, should this happen after the loss of biodiversity (including the extinc- tion of animals and plants) or after passing the planetary boundaries beyond the point of no return – that is, the critical point after which the consequences for the planet are unpredictable – then it may be too late. Instead of taking a defeatist attitude toward the possibility of changing the economic system, advocates of ecologism will, in a proactive way, try to promote these changes, defending a model of prosperity that does not depend on economic growth (Jackson, 2017). For the sake of clarity, it is this vision of ecologism I subscribe to.

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – solvency › EBI [BI solves environment] › BIG solves degrowth

Degrowth possible through slow reform – fast transition causes economic disaster and collapse

Frenzel 21 [Max (PhD), "Universal Basic Income, Degrowth, and the Future of Work," Medium, 7-27-2021 , GDI, TS]

“Degrowth,” writes Kallis, “refers to a trajectory where the ’throughput’ (energy, materials and waste flows) of an economy decrease while welfare, or well-being improves.” Crucially, this is not the same as negative growth or recession. The focus is on reducing throughput, the use of resources, while improving living conditions. Whether output and GDP decrease in the process is a different but rather irrelevant matter. “The problem is not only that the economy cannot or should not grow. Our very ideas of what an economy is are wrong.” We are simply measuring the wrong thing. The problem is, we have been measuring growth in this way for a long time and built a system that relies on the continuation of this kind of growth. Kallis admits that directly switching our current economy to the degrowth mindset would lead to economic disaster and collapse. Instead, we need small steps to rebuild a new economy from the ground up. The push for this comes from two directions. From the outside, as a criticism of economic thinking itself, but also from inside economics, considering the risk and cost of growth, which can outweigh the benefits. The agenda of the degrowth research program is to find out how and under what conditions such a transition can happen without disaster. Even if such conditions can be found, everyone involved knows that achieving political change will still be difficult. “Unlike ecological laws, however, political systems can change. It was hard to end slavery, but it was not impossible. It is impossible, though, to change the law of entropy.” Overall, the degrowth proposition looks positive, according to Kallis: “A transformation of society with a concomitant reduction in economic activity and throughput is not only necessary, and desirable, but also possible.” If we achieve a transition to degrowth, we might find ourselves once again in a society that values time off as one of its highest virtues. French economics professor Serge Latouche, one founder of the degrowth movement, has a concept called the “eight Rs” of degrowth. One of the Rs he describes as “reevaluating, that is, valuing the ‘pleasure of leisure,’ for example, or the ‘ethos of play’ instead of material possessions.” Similarly, Ph.D. researcher Aaron Vansintjan at Birbeck, University of London, imagines a society after degrowth with, among other things, “surpluses expended in popular feasts, philosophy or leisure, instead of invested for more growth; and conviviality and caring for one another, and for non-human living beings.” It sounds a lot like the positive aspects of ancient Rome or Greece, bringing us full circle to a culture of noble leisure that Aristotle advocated for. Previous civilizations have flourished under this kind of model, and potentially we can do so once again.

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – solvency › EBI [BI solves environment] › BIG solves degrowth

BIG aids in degrowth and transitions away from Capitalism.

Cabana 19 [Gabriela (PhD Candidate in Anthropology at the London School of Economics ) " The radical combination of degrowth and basic income," openDemocracy, 10-2-2019, https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/beyond-trafficking-and-slavery/radical-combination-degrowth-and-basic-income/, GDI, TS]

Basic income goes well with the ideas of slowing down the economy, of becoming less dependent, and of stopping the increasing and continuous production of stuff that we don't really need. A UBI would precisely allow individuals the freedom to work less and to say no to negative jobs, for instance in the fossil fuels industry. It would also allow them to have more free time to take care of the people they care about. You’ve mentioned care and freedom a couple times now. They seem central to your vision of a degrowth future. Could you say a little more about those? In the economies that we have now, many of the policies that we have towards care are implicitly instrumental. Conditional cash transfers, for instance, revolve around the idea of building human capital. You give money to mothers to take care of their children, to send them to school, to send them to health check-ups, etc. This is not completely altruistic. It’s also about creating able citizens that will participate in economy. Policies that truly care for others have freedom at their centre, and basic income seeks to enhance or maintain other people’s freedom. It gives them something, some livelihood, and a base from which to do something that might not necessarily contribute to GDP. It allows them to work if they want, but they might also chose to write poetry, take care of their garden, or do something else. This is the ultimate act of freedom – choosing what you do without anyone judging if you're actually contributing to the economy or to society.