Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 Northwestern Affirmative
Off › States CP › AT: ERISA Preemption---General

States have historical supremacy over health insurance regulation---the Court will defer towards the states on ERISA questions

Elizabeth McCuskey 16, Associate Professor of Law, University of Toledo College of Law, “Body of Preemption: Health Law Traditions and the Presumption Against Preemption,” 2016, Temple Law Review, 89 Temp. L. Rev. 89

Commercial health insurance. Since the 1850s, states have been the primary regulators of insurance; therefore, they have supplied most laws governing private health insurance.343 Insurers did not cover health care, however, until after 1908.344 The first two categories of true health insurance sprung up in the early 1930s: Groups of hospitals offered prepaid services (known as “Blue Cross” model plans), and groups of physicians offered similar arrangements (known as “Blue Shield” plans).345 Health insurance policies were rare until after World War II, when they became ubiquitous and largely employer-sponsored because insurance offered as an employee fringe benefit was exempt from the wartime wage and price controls.346

Over their roughly 150 years of insurance regulation, states have both exercised licensing authority over insurers and have regulated issuance of policies.347 Since 1945 with the passage of the McCarran-Ferguson Act,348 some state insurance regulation has enjoyed a form of reverse preemption in which state insurance law is supreme to federal law.349 The Health Maintenance Organization Act of 1973350 “marked the first time that Congress created a direct federal role in the regulation of health insurance;” the legislation was “designed to supplement, rather than replace . . . state functions” through federal funding and qualifications.351

2023 Northwestern Affirmative
Off › States CP › AT: ERISA Preemption---General

Financing and taxes are areas of state authority---CP doesn’t get preempted

William C. Hsiao 11, K.T. Li Professor of Economics at the School of Public Health at Harvard University, “What Other States Can Learn From Vermont’s Bold Experiment: Embracing A Single-Payer Health Care Financing System,” Health Affairs, Volume 30, Number 7, 2011, pp. 1232-1241

State reforms must also contend with the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA). In practice, ERISA preempts state laws that would regulate benefit plans offered by selfinsured employers—that is, employers that assume the full financial risk of their employees’ health care, instead of contracting with an insurer or health plan to effectively assume that risk.

Because of the vague language in ERISA, much of what is known about the limitations imposed by the law comes from court decisions. There have been no cases regarding a tax-financed universal health system at the state level, so case law does not provide a sure guide to any legal challenges.

2023 Northwestern Affirmative
Off › States CP › AT: Free Riding/Race to the Bottom

Migration isn’t significant enough to cause a race to the bottom

Nicholas Bagley 17, Professor Nicholas Bagley teaches and writes in the areas of administrative law, regulatory theory, and health law, former attorney with the appellate staff in the Civil Division at the U.S. Department of Justice where he argued before the U.S. Courts of Appeals and acted as lead counsel, 4/24/17, "Federalism and the End of Obamacare," University of Michigan Law School, repository.law.umich.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi? article=2847&context=articles

To the extent that the states cannot be excluded from the enjoyment of collective goods, they will be tempted to contribute little or nothing to the production of those goods. They will prefer, instead, to free ride on the contributions of other states. Since every state has the same incentives, contributions toward that collective good will fall short of what the states, acting in concert, would prefer. Federal action may be necessary to avoid a race to the bottom.

When it comes to health reform, a race to the bottom might develop if a state’s adoption of a coverage expansion led sick people to flock to the state.12 To avoid becoming a “welfare magnet,” individual states might decline to expand coverage, even if they would happily expand coverage if they could con- fine that coverage to their own residents.

2023 Northwestern Affirmative
Off › States CP › AT: Free Riding/Race to the Bottom

States can successfully manage single payer systems---previous examples failed because they were added onto the existing federal structure

PPG 8/5, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette editorial board, 8/5/17, "Healthy devolution: For the next round of health care reform, look to states," www.post-gazette.com/opinion/editorials/2017/08/06/Healthy-devolution-For-the-next-round-of-health-care-reform-look-to-states/stories/201708310015

The conservative principle of federalism and the liberal cause of a single-payer option could, for example, be combined.

Both sides understand that the source of ballooning health care costs lies in the system’s vast complexity, which makes government and insurance companies alike unaccountable in keeping costs under control. Liberals recognize that simplifying the health insurance market on free enterprise principles would make insurance utterly unaffordable or simply inaccessible for millions of Americans. But conservatives fear that a health care service based in Washington would be too far removed from patient needs. They also bridle against the rationing and wait times such a system would require to control costs and equalize access. Canadians in need of a hip or knee replacement wait an average of six months for the procedure. With a much larger population than Canada — or any of the other countries with single-payer health care and comparable governments — America under an equivalent system could see substantially worse waiting periods.

2023 Northwestern Affirmative
Off › States CP › AT: Funding---Balanced-Budget Amendments

States don’t actually have balanced-budget amendments---it’s worse to increase federal spending rather than state spending

Jason Sorens 17, lecturer in the Government Department at Dartmouth College and received his Ph.D. in political science from Yale University, 4/28/17, "The health care shell game: Why not leave health care policy to the states?," www.learnliberty.org/blog/the-health-care-shell-game-why-not-leave-health-care-policy-to-the-states/

What’s more, most states don’t have strong constitutional requirements that they actually run balanced budgets at the end of the fiscal year. More often, they just have statutory requirements that balanced budgets must be enacted — or even merely proposed — at the beginning of the fiscal year. Most states run balanced budgets because they want to, not because they are required to by law.

Federal and State Spending Constraints

2023 Northwestern Affirmative
Off › States CP › 2NC---Follow-On

The counterplan causes learning and national adoption

Henry Aaron 8, Bruce and Virginia MacLaury Senior Fellow at the Brookings Institution, Economic Studies, written with Stuart Butler, vice president, Domestic and Economic Policy Studies, at the Heritage Foundation, May 2008, "A Federalist Approach To Health Reform: The Worst Way, Except For All The Others," Health Affairs, Volume 27, Number 3, May 2008, pp. 725-735

The second reason is that the U.S. health care sector is remarkably complex, and knowledge about what will work best in the diverse political and health system environments of the fifty states is remarkably incomplete. So whether one believes that the ideal reform would be national or federalist, the ability to move ahead in the near future will be advanced by learning from state initiatives now—and from initiatives that are not marginal refinements, where the results are minor and the lessons open to dispute, but bold initiatives that test very different approaches. Moreover, any national reform will be enhanced by allowing states to improve it at the margin, both to adjust the reform to local circumstances and to adapt it to new knowledge. It should also be kept in mind that other federalist nations—notably Canada and Switzerland—extended health insurance to all while allowing provinces and cantons some flexibility in how to do it.

The third reason for encouraging state action is the abundant evidence that states are eager and poised to take the lead in health system reform.3 The Massachusetts plan is the most widely known. It mandates that every person have insurance or pay a tax penalty, and it subsidizes low- and moderate-income families to help them buy health insurance. It also creates a state-operated insurance exchange, known as the “Connector,” that enables individuals and employees of small businesses—indeed, anyone—to buy insurance at regulated rates and take it from job to job.

2023 Northwestern Affirmative
Off › States CP

State action is key even if federal reforms are preferable---key to solve geographic coverage gaps and leads to federal follow on

Henry Aaron 8, Bruce and Virginia MacLaury Senior Fellow at the Brookings Institution, Economic Studies, written with Stuart Butler, vice president, Domestic and Economic Policy Studies, at the Heritage Foundation, May 2008, "A Federalist Approach To Health Reform: The Worst Way, Except For All The Others," Health Affairs, Volume 27, Number 3, May 2008, pp. 725-735

Support for state action should be part of any strategy to expand health insurance coverage. Decades-long political deadlock in Washington has frustrated national efforts to expand coverage. Some states have already undertaken to do this; others show a determination to do so. Regulatory and legislative flexibility would trigger widespread state action. Whether one thinks that ensuring coverage requires a unified national approach or that diverse conditions require different methods in different states, the likelihood of progress will be advanced if states test out various ways to expand coverage. We describe a practical way by which the federal government can promote state action to expand health insurance coverage.

Federal encouragement of state health reform will advance both the state and national reform agendas.

2023 Northwestern Affirmative
Off › Topicality › 2NC---XT: Interpretation

“Social Security” is a term of art that refers to the Old-Age, Survivors, and Disability Insurance program.

Investopedia - https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/socialsecurity.asp

“Social Security” is the term used for the Old-Age, Survivors, and Disability Insurance (OASDI) program in the United States. It's run by the Social Security Administration (SSA), a federal agency. It's best known for retirement benefits, but it also provides survivor benefits and income for workers who become disabled.

1

2023 Northwestern Affirmative
Off › AT: Cap K

The aff is a non-reformist reform—spurs more radical change

Keith Brower Brown 17, Democratic Socialists of America member and MS Candidate in Geography at UC Berkeley, Meagan Day, 8/2/2017, How Socialists Can Fight for Single Payer, Jacobin,

The challenge now is to hone its political vision and build a durable and democratic organizations that can affect real change. A focus on winning single-payer health care can help us do that.¶ The growing demand for single payer rankles establishment Democrats, who insist that the Affordable Care Act — with its labyrinthine subsidies program meant to provide coverage without undermining the private insurance industry — is the best deal on offer, and to demand anything more is pie-in-the-sky and politically counterproductive. But with Obamacare given reprieve for the moment (albeit unsafe from future attacks), and our still-broken health care system on everyone’s mind, socialists have an opportunity to organize ordinary people toward a better common goal: genuine universal coverage, managed and dispersed by democratic, transparent, and efficient institutions that are accountable to us, not corporate shareholders.¶ California has the unique potential to become the first state to pass single payer. A grassroots movement for the cause, spearheaded by the California Nurses Association, goes back decades. This movement twice passed single-payer bills through both houses of the state legislature in the 2000s, but both were vetoed by then-Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger.¶ Out of this legacy of popular action, 70 percent of California voters now support single payer in polls. To appeal to that active grassroots and public support, California Democrats have made single payer an official plank of their party platform. Democrats hold the Governor’s seat and an exact two-thirds supermajority in both houses of the legislature, so the time has come to deliver on promises.¶ We are two organizers with the East Bay chapter of DSA, which has made a strategic decision to focus on a single campaign: organizing around single-payer health care legislation, SB562, in California. The lessons from our campaign aren’t universal (no one’s are), but in explaining the strategic thinking behind our mass canvassing program and sharing the lessons we’ve learned from implementing it, we want to show how a focus on Medicare for All can increase socialist organizations’ organizing capacity and build working-class power for long-term struggle.¶ Zeroing in on Single Payer¶ In recent months, socialists — many of them newcomers to the movement — have flocked to DSA, seeking opportunities to continue pushing for left political-economic reforms after the Sanders campaign. Both the national DSA organization and local chapters have begun a program of political education to introduce these members to socialist history, theory, and strategy — some for the first time in their lives. The East Bay chapter has been no exception: over five hundred people joined after Trump’s election.¶ At East Bay DSA’s chapter elections in January — our first following the membership explosion — many candidates running for a leadership role pledged to focus our organizing on the California single-payer effort. The members who won election were nearly unanimous in their interest in pursuing this campaign.¶ Based on that mandate, the leadership voted to officially join the campaign for Healthy California in February and started canvassing almost immediately.¶ Two generations of our elected leadership have now committed to single payer as the core focus for our organizing work. Importantly, this hasn’t prevented ongoing chapter actions on other issues: our direct action committee helped blockade an ICE office and held the line to protect an elderly renter from eviction; we were at the airport protests, the Women’s Strike, and May Day; we have a housing caucus, a prison abolition caucus, and a socialist feminist caucus.¶ But we’ve found that focusing the bulk of our organizing effort on single payer comes with major benefits: we concentrate and replicate our capacity for training members, we stress-test our organizing against the clear benchmarks of a single campaign, and we build internal unity and transparency by working together on a common cause.¶ The singular focus helps convey to our coalition partners and members alike that we’re in this for the long haul, and we’re in it to win. As a result of our recent growth in both size and legitimacy, coalition partners have asked to table with us at events for increased visibility, and local candidates have sought our endorsement.¶ East Bay DSA’s commitment to campaigning for SB562 is a tactic in service of a larger strategy to build good internal structures in our burgeoning group and effective organizing skills among a new generation of grassroots leftist activists. We also seek to strengthen ties between socialists and the labor movement — in this case the women-led and substantially non-white nurses’ union — and win reforms that will strengthen the power of the working class.¶ The Ground Game¶ Our focus on winning single payer has driven the evolution of our organizing process¶ Our canvassing strategy began with a focus on large canvasses that gathered members from across our entire chapter as well as non-members interested in joining in.¶ Before these canvasses, a select team of canvass captains received training from the union and community organizers in the chapter. On the day of the large canvasses, these captains trained and facilitated practice sessions for teams of about a dozen people each. To date, five hundred people have received training from team captains, then pounded the pavement together to knock on doors.¶ In a frightening national political moment, door-to-door organizing has been heartening for many members, showing us we’re not as alone as we think. One of our members, who originally described herself as shy, remarked that her canvassing experiences with our chapter had convinced her there are only two kinds of people in the Bay Area: socialists, and people who aren’t home.¶ Across all of our canvassing, we’ve focused on empowering neighbors to see their experiences with medical fees and debt in terms of class conflict, explained the mechanics and upsides of single payer, and gathered thousands of pledges to support DSA and our coalition partners in the fight for public universal coverage. In the process, our organizers have also developed as leaders. In a testament to the skill- and commitment-building potential of this tactic, about half of the chapter’s newly elected Local Council started out as single-payer canvassers.¶ The large, chapter-wide canvasses provided a good way to kick start training across our membership but weren’t well suited to build steady teams of organizers consistently working the same neighborhoods. To address this issue, our organizing tactic has shifted since May to focus on district canvasses, where our members develop dedicated teams for their own neighborhoods. The point is for socialist organizers to talk to their own neighbors and build lasting political relationships.¶ We live in an atomized, alienating society where most of us don’t know our neighbors’ names, and don’t see any reason to learn them. These district canvasses break our own members out of their isolation, while simultaneously building stronger community ties between our organization and existing neighborhood networks.¶ In early July, one of our canvassers, after a particularly successful round of door-knocking, was invited to speak at a block party. The person then found themselves literally organizing their neighborhood. Another district canvasser was invited to give a talk for a second block party just last week.¶ A third stage in the evolution of our organizing is just beginning. Our canvassing program has done well at training our members for the initial conversations with neighbors, but we’ve found we need more structure and shared skills for follow-up to keep our neighbors consistently involved. As our chapter grows, the most involved members have largely had their workload expand just as fast; this has made it clear that helping members develop into leaders needs to become a central part of our organizing system.¶ To clarify who should take on our member development efforts, we passed new bylaws in April which created distinct positions (both elected and appointed) for internal organizers and external organizers. The internal organizers, who were elected in June, are now focused on developing a member steward system based on the model used in many unions and the New York City and Philadelphia DSA chapters. This will build a trained network of stewards among our membership, with each responsible for supporting and catalyzing a set of less-active members and interested neighbors to become regular participants.¶ Strong local relationships like these are invaluable to socialist organizers and can be tapped in future campaigns for fights around housing justice or workers’ rights. Democratic elites have all but abandoned field organizing, especially in down-ballot races, in favor of exorbitant, consultant-led media strategies. In many places, by training even a few dozen regular canvassers through the single-payer cause, socialists can quickly develop one of the strongest ground games in town.¶ By building ongoing relationships with our neighbors, this emphasis on field organizing will put us in a position to be helpful, in-demand allies for local unions and other Left campaigns, and lay the foundation for real impacts on electoral politics. And while we should only organize for what we are committed to winning, we should also organize so that, whether we win or lose one round in a fight, we are building the skills and relationships for power in the long term.¶ The focused campaign gives us an opportunity to troubleshoot our organizational structure and its challenges, which makes our chapter increasingly resilient, responsive, and effective, and will serve us well beyond the fight for single payer. Already, our work has rippled outward; we’ve shared our training guides, canvassing scripts, and leave-behind literature to be put to use in chapters across California and as far afield as Ohio.¶ Advancing the Program¶ The advantages for our organization are only part of the equation. Any unifying campaign will be beneficial to an organization finding its footing, but single payer is a strategic central focus. In fighting for it, we can build solidarity across lines of difference and continue to build power for the working class.¶ Everybody needs health care. Nearly everybody in the working class has been hurt by private insurance greed, or has seen a friend or family member denied care so that a rich few can profit. When we organize in the East Bay, we share our own personal stories and ask our neighbors about what they could personally gain from single payer.¶ We work to show how our direct self-interest intersects with that of all working people: we can only win single payer for ourselves if we win it for each other. Political education that fosters this sense of shared self-interest — rather than charity for a distant other — is the foundation of a sense of solidarity built to last.¶ The fight for single payer is an urgent anti-racist struggle. Currently in the United States, the uninsured rate is 60 percent higher for black people than for white people. The Movement for Black Lives platform demands a universal, guaranteed health care system, with particular focus on equitable access for currently excluded communities of color. In committing to the fight for single payer, socialists can take up that call to action.¶ Meanwhile, across the US, Latinos have an uninsured rate 300 percent higher than white people. Undocumented immigrants — and many documented ones — are not covered by Medicare, nearly all Medicaid programs, and many subsidized private plans. This cruel exclusion is despite the fact that immigrants pay into the public system through taxes, and worse, is in spite of the fact that they are members of our communities who need care like everybody else.¶ By providing coverage to all state residents regardless of documentation status, California and New York’s single-payer bills not only directly help millions, but could point a socialist path out of the current dead end around immigration politics in the US and Europe. Over the past decade, most parties of the center and many on the left have shifted towards far-right positions on refugees and migrants as a supposedly necessary concession to white-working-class xenophobia. This is morally and strategically wrong.¶ When socialists win truly universal social programs that cover migrants, we can demonstrate that social care is not a zero-sum game. Instead, building social systems for everyone who lives here makes for stronger public institutions and a healthier society for all. If we are to push further towards building a powerful multiracial working-class movement, then a proud politics of inclusion for immigrants is not only right — it’s essential.¶ Single payer is also a critical feminist fight. Public health coverage for all would be transformational to a society in which most unpaid and underpaid care work falls to women. When people can’t get the care they need, someone is usually compelled to pick up the slack — and, especially in the realm of home care for family members, those people are disproportionately women. (“The best long-term care insurance in our country,” concluded a recent study about home care for older adults, “is a conscientious daughter.”)¶ Women are more likely to receive health insurance as dependents, which means that losing a spouse through death or divorce puts them at greater risk for being uninsured. Single mothers are nearly twice as likely to be uninsured as mothers in two-parent households. Meanwhile, women who are insured also suffer disproportionately from confusing and predatory private insurance industry practices. Care costs more for women, is harder to obtain, and employers can refuse to cover contraception on religious grounds, meaning a woman’s reproductive health is in many cases dependent on the conditions of her employment. California’s Medicaid program covers abortion, contraception, and prenatal care. To universalize that comprehensive and inclusive care is an urgent and crucial feminist reform.¶ The California Nurses Association, which is leading the charge on the state single-payer effort, has eighty thousand members across both unionized and non-unionized workplaces in the state. These workers are overwhelmingly women, and about half are people of color. Women fill nearly all of the top leadership roles at CNA.¶ Who better to lead the fight to bring care into the public sphere than women care workers, who disproportionately shoulder the burden of undervalued care? Organizing in close alliance with care workers is an essential way we can put our principles into practice and expand socialist-feminist understanding within our ranks.¶ Working with organized nurses is also strategic for building solidarity between socialists, the labor movement, and the broad working class. CNA has led the drafting of legislation and steered the inside game while coordinating and supporting grassroots allies across the state. Nurses at the helm makes this not just a “consumer movement,” made up of health-care users, but a workers’ movement. The nurse-led campaign sets up a clear dynamic of workers, both inside and outside the industry, against our common adversaries at the very top: health insurance executives, shareholders, and the 1 percent.¶ Over the last half-century, the relationship between socialists and the labor movement has grown tenuous, as both groups have been diminished and devitalized by state repression and capitalist advancement. As socialists, we know that acting in concert with organized labor is fundamental, and that it’s necessary to rebuild our role, both as socialist organizers and workers ourselves, in the labor movement. By uniting with nurses against CEOs, we’re committing to working-class solidarity in practice, not just in theory.¶ Socialists must continue to build our own independent organizations steered by the democratic power of our members, but the nurses are a strategic ally to learn from and fight alongside in this moment.¶ Finally, single payer would win power for the working class like no other reform popularly on the table in the US today. When socialists consider fighting for a reform, we should ask if it builds working-class power towards future struggles. Some left organizers and scholars call this “building the crisis”: by winning reforms that strengthen the material conditions and class consciousness of working people, we advance the fight for more radical victories.¶ Many union workers, who have seen spiraling private health insurance costs undermine their position for wage and benefit increases, have rallied behind single payer as a bulwark for future battles with management. For non-union workers, too, single payer would strengthen both their actual health and their bargaining position for raises and other benefits. A push for single payer, in this political moment, is uniquely able to draw clear lines of class conflict: it’s capitalists versus all of us who work.¶ Single payer is already a concession on the part of socialists. We want fully socialized medicine, which would function on the same principles but extend to hospitals and doctors themselves, and which already exists in many nations. We envision single payer as a first step in a long struggle to implement full universal social programs. We see it as a non-reformist reform: that is, a structural modification of power relations that elevates the ability of working-class people to fight against capital while radically shifting the window of political possibility. We’re interested in using SB562 as a political education opportunity for our membership and neighbors, and publicly advancing the idea that universal social programs are better than means-tested ones. According to the neoliberal logic of means-testing, some people need public assistance to attain things like health insurance, but only those in the direst of straits. Socialists, on the other hand, believe in the decommodification of essential goods and services for all, for both moral and politically strategic reasons. Universal programs are essential to eliminating wealth inequality. They decrease disparities in the here and now, creating a stronger working class that is less fearful and insecure, and therefore less easily exploited by capital. They also build powerful new constituencies dedicated to defending public goods against privatization. In this way, universal programs can function as “engines of solidarity.” To make health insurance universally guaranteed and public is to both assert that coverage is a right, and to build a stronger body politic that can mobilize to protect that right. In our discussions at peoples’ doors, we hear our neighbors’ indignation that the wealthy are able to receive medical care when necessary without fear of ruinous financial consequences, while everybody else is faced with hard choices about whether to go into massive amounts of debt to seek necessary treatment. In those conversations, we hear the raw material for a mass oppositional class politics. That’s why we ask for commitments from those people to join the campaign, instead of just signing a petition or donating once. For example, behind one door was a twenty-six year old with a bandage wrapped around his hand. He had just lost his job, where he was paid poorly to work with dogs, one of which had bitten him badly. He was a few months too old to be listed as a dependent, and suddenly found himself uninsured. He talked to our neighborhood canvassers for twenty minutes. At the next neighborhood canvass there he was, DSA clipboard in his healing hand, knocking on doors with the rest of us. California’s Single-Payer Melee Pressured by a growing movement and a single-payer bill that has passed the State Senate, elite Democrats have been forced to show their true loyalties. In late June, Assembly Speaker Anthony Rendon froze the bill in committee, halting any formal legislative progress in his chamber until next year. We knew this opposition was coming. Contrary to recent allegations of unpreparedness and deception, from the start of the campaign, CNA leaders have been clear on statewide conference calls with coalition activists that we are building strength for a multiple-year effort — which could require a ballot campaign as a costly last resort. That’s only necessary if the legislature can’t be pushed to deliver single payer past the state’s tax and spending constraints. The coalition’s current effort to turn up pressure on Rendon and other resistant Democrats is essential to build that necessary legislative will. At doorsteps, DSA organizers have been talking with our neighbors about what it will take to win this protracted and difficult fight. After fifty years of conservatives and centrists passing severe restrictions on taxes and spending, California’s political playing field is badly rigged. That’s why our victory requires building a powerful movement off that field. Democratic elites — steered by donors from real estate, insurance, dirty energy, and tech, and backed up by the management of huge non-profits and major unions — treat the handcuffs on state power as “sacred doctrine that should never be questioned.” Even if they wanted to overturn suffocating restrictions on the state, Democratic leaders can’t imagine building the popular power needed to do it. If Democrats bury the legislation now, they will be opposing the idea that politics ought to involve imagination, mass effort, and the will to fight uphill battles so that people’s lives might be freer and better. In this context, socialists have a critical role to play in the movement for single payer: unlike the Democrats, we can build broad working-class power while expanding the public imagination of what politics could be. East Bay DSA regards SB562 as an opportunity to build, mobilize, and grow our organizations and movement. While the bill is frozen in committee, we’re going to continue educating, coordinating, and taking full advantage of the swelling interest in both single payer and socialism. In those respects we’re already winning, and no legislative defeat can undo our victories. But this isn’t a trap, or a trick question meant to expose neoliberal hypocrisy. Single payer is a real policy demand, and we want it to pass. If it does, there will be several subsequent obstacles to actually implementing a functional single-payer health care system in our state. If we proceed to a ballot measure, the health insurance lobby will wage a media war to scare Californians out of it. (Of course, the best way to combat a propaganda campaign that well-funded is to organize and educate people on the ground, grassroots-style — which we’re currently doing.) In the meantime, socialists around the country must start thinking critically about building and wielding organizational power. Not every socialist group has the opportunity to rally behind state single-payer legislation like we have. But given our national moment of historic upheaval for health care and the broadening popularity of Medicare for All, we think socialists throughout the nation can build alliances and open political imagination by being a loud voice — and given the refusal of the Democratic Party to champion it, perhaps the loudest voice — for single payer in their specific political climate. A nationwide single-payer campaign that embraces a diversity of location-specific tactics can help socialists replicate a skill-building, infrastructure-honing strategy across cities and states. This shouldn’t preclude simultaneous local and regional campaigns on other issues, but we believe a primary nationwide focus on single payer, more than any other issue, will build power for socialists and the working class.

2023 Northwestern Affirmative
Off › AT: Medicare Part E › 1AR---XT: Solvency Deficit

Private insurance uses big data to force more limited data pools and worse coverage through aggressive network management

Thomas G. McGuire et al 14, PhD, is a professor of health economics in the Department of Health Care Policy at Harvard Medical School and a research associate at the National Bureau of Economic Research; Joseph Newhouse, PhD, is the John D. MacArthur Professor of Health Policy and Management at Harvard University, director of the Division of Health Policy Research and Education, chair of the Committee on Higher Degrees in Health Policy, and director of the Interfaculty Initiative in Health Policy; Sharon-Lise T. Normand, PhD, is a professor of health care policy (biostatistics) in the Department of Health Care Policy at Harvard Medical School and in the Department of Biostatistics at the Harvard School of Public Health; Julie Shi Post-Doctoral Fellow Department of Health Care Policy Harvard Medical School; Samuel H. Zuvekas- Ph.D., Economics, University of Wisconsin-Madison (2014). Assessing incentives for service-level selection in private health insurance exchanges. Journal of Health Economics 35, 47–63.

Several provisions of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act of 2010 (ACA) are designed to minimize adverse selection in Exchanges (also referred to as Marketplaces).1 Exchange plans may condition premiums only on age (with restricted rate bands), family size, smoking status, and geography, but not preexisting conditions or other factors. Coverage is regulated. The ACA also mandates that Exchanges engage in risk adjustment and implement temporary risk corridors and reinsurance programs.2 Risk adjustment is budget neutral: health plans drawing enrollees with lower than average health risk transfer funds to plans with higher than average health risks.3

These regulations may not fully address selection problems, however, because Exchange plans may engage in the difficult-to-regulate practice of distorting service offerings to attract “winners” and deter “losers.” For example, news stories already contain reports that plans are engaging in aggressive network management, possibly discouraging enrollees requiring more costly treatment.4 Aggressive network management will also generally lower premiums, making insurance purchase more attractive to good risks.

2023 Northwestern Affirmative
Off › AT: Medicare Part E › 2AC---Medicare Part E

Even extremely low copays deter use of care

Samantha Artiga 17, Senior Policy Analyst with the Kaiser Family Foundation “The Effects of Premiums and Cost Sharing on Low-Income Populations: Updated Review of Research Findings” https://www.kff.org/medicaid/issue-brief/the-effects-of-premiums-and-cost-sharing-on-low-income-populations-updated-review-of-research-findings/

Recently, there has been increased interest at the federal and state level to expand the use of premiums and cost sharing in Medicaid as a way to promote personal responsibility, prepare beneficiaries to transition to commercial and private insurance, and support consumers in making value-conscious health decisions. This brief reviews research from 65 papers published between 2000 and March 2017 on the effects of premiums and cost sharing on low-income populations in Medicaid and CHIP. This research has primarily focused on how premiums and cost sharing affect coverage and access to and use of care; some studies also have examined effects on safety net providers and state savings. The effects on individuals, providers, and state costs reflect varied implementation of premiums and cost sharing across states as well as differing premium and cost sharing amounts. Together, the research finds: Premiums serve as a barrier to obtaining and maintaining Medicaid and CHIP coverage among low-income individuals. These effects are largest among those with the lowest incomes, particularly among individuals with incomes below poverty. Some individuals losing Medicaid or CHIP coverage move to other coverage, but others become uninsured, especially those with lower incomes. Individuals who become uninsured face increased barriers to accessing care, greater unmet health needs, and increased financial burdens. Even relatively small levels of cost sharing in the range of $1 to $5 are associated with reduced use of care, including necessary services. Research also finds that cost sharing can result in unintended consequences, such as increased use of the emergency room, and that cost sharing negatively affects access to care and health outcomes. For example, studies find that increases in cost sharing are associated with increased rates of uncontrolled hypertension and hypercholesterolemia and reduced treatment for children with asthma. Additionally, research finds that cost sharing increases financial burdens for families, causing some to cut back on necessities or borrow money to pay for care.

2023 Northwestern Affirmative
Off › AT: Medicare Part E › 2AC---Medicare Part E

CP locks in fragmentation AND multiple risk pools

Margaret Flowers 18, Maryland pediatrician with experience as a hospitalist at a rural hospital and in private practice, 1-5-2018, "Jacob Hacker Rises Again to Stop Single Payer," Health Over Profit, http://healthoverprofit.org/2018/01/05/jacob-hacker-rises-again-to-stop-single-payer/

In the article linked below, The Road to Medicare for Everyone, Jacob Hacker is once again working to dissuade single payer healthcare supporters from demanding National Improved Medicare for All and is using our language to send us down a false path. Once again, he comes up with a scheme to convince people to ask for less and calls those who disagree “purists”. Hacker calls his “Medicare Part E” “daring and doable,” I call it dumb and dumber. Here’s why. Hacker makes the same assertions we witnessed in August of 2017 when other progressives tried to dissuade single payer supporters. He starts with “risk aversion,” although he doesn’t use the term in his article. Hacker asserts that those who have health insurance through their employers won’t want to give it up for the new system. Our responses to this are: there is already widespread dislike for the current healthcare system; people don’t like private insurance while there is widespread support across the political spectrum for Medicare and Medicaid; there is also widespread support for single payer; and those with health insurance can be reassured that they will be better off under a single payer system. It is also important to note that employers don’t want to be in the middle of health insurance. Healthcare costs are the biggest complaint by small and medium sized businesses and keep businesses that operate internationally less competitive. Next, Hacker brings up the costs of the new system and complains that it will create new federal spending. He points to the failures to pass ‘single payer’ in Vermont and California. First, it must be recognized that the state bills were not true single payer bills, and second, states face barriers that the federal government does not, they must balance their budgets. Hacker ignores the numerous studies at the national level, some by the General Accounting Office and the Congressional Budget Office that demonstrate single payer is the best way to save money. Of course there would be an increase in federal spending, the system would be financed through taxes, but the taxes would replace premiums, co-pays and deductibles, which are rising as fast as health insurers can get away with. Hacker proposes a more complex system that will fail to provide the savings needed to cover everyone, the savings that can only exist under a true single payer system. Hacker also confuses “Medicare for All” with simply expanding Medicare to everyone, including the wasteful private plans under Medicare Advantage. This is not what National Improved Medicare for All (NIMA) advocates support. NIMA would take the national infrastructure created by Medicare and use it for a new system that is comprehensive in coverage, including long term care, and doesn’t require co-pays or deductibles. The system would negotiate reasonable pharmaceutical prices and set prices for services. It would also provide operating budgets for hospitals and other health facilities and use separate capital budgets to make sure that health resources are available where they are needed. And the new system would create a mechanism for negotiation of payment to providers. Finally, Hacker tries to convince his readers that the opposition to NIMA will be too strong, so we should demand less. We know that the opposition to our lesser demands will also be strong. That was the case in 2009 when people advocated for the ‘public option’ gimmick. If we are going to fight for something, if we are going to take on this opposition, we must fight for something worthwhile, something that will actually solve the healthcare crisis. That something is NIMA. We are well aware that the opposition will be strong, but we also know that when people organize and mobilize, they can win. Every fight for social transformation has been a difficult struggle. We know how to wage these struggles. We have decades of history of successful struggles to guide us. One gaping hole in Hacker’s approach is that it prevents the social solidarity required to win the fight and to make the solution succeed. Hacker promotes a “Medicare Part E” that some people can buy into. Not only will this forego most of the savings of a single payer system, but it also leaves the public divided. Some people will be in the system and others will be out. This creates vulnerabilities for the opposition to exploit and further divide us. Any difficulties of the new system will be blown out of proportion and those in the system may worry that they are in the wrong place. When we are united in the same system, not only does that create a higher quality system (a lesson we’ve learned from other countries), but it also unites us in fighting to protect and improve that system.

2023 Northwestern Affirmative
Off › AT: Medicare Part E › 2AC---Medicare Part E

Only eliminating private insurance can solve. A profit-driven patchwork of companies increases administrative costs and fraud.

Richard A. Damon 17, M.D., 3/28/17, “Medicare for all key to stopping unjust inequalities,”

The complex multi-payer insurance finance system, comprised of hundreds of different insurance companies is and has been the major flaw in U.S. health care for decades. Multiple insurers operate with overwhelming administrative costs, large CEO salaries and bonuses, seek ways to insure only the healthiest people, avoid the sickest, and restrict coverage for costly illnesses. The corporate mandate that insurance premiums must cover enrollee benefits, profits, CEO bonuses, stockholder profits, and massive administrative costs, calls forth perverse and fraudulent practices by insurance companies to do whatever is necessary to preserve the all mighty bottom line.

2023 Northwestern Affirmative
Off › AT: States CP › 1AR---XT: ERISA Preemption Deficit

Numerous aspects of the counterplan violate ERISA

Marea Tumber 15 [Candidate for Juris Doctor, December 2015, University of Massachusetts School of Law; MPH, Brown University; B.A., St. Lawrence University, "The ACA's 2017 State Innovation Waiver: Is ERISA a Roadblock to Meaningful Healthcare Reform? 10 U. MASS. L. REV. 388, accessed 1-14-2018]

In order to create a single-payer system, states would need to institute a payroll or income tax to pay for it. The Vermont plan incorporated a payroll tax as the preferred means to raise revenue to pay for a single-payer system. 193 A payroll tax can raise ERISA preemption problems because such taxes create incentives for employers who are sponsoring health coverage plans to terminate or modify their plans.194

The amount of payroll tax that would be required to fund a single payer system is not known, but the Hsiao report estimated it would be approximately 12.8 to 18.2 percent. 195 The Court in Travelers recognized that a state law might impose cost burdens so “exorbitant” that they removed any real choice and therefore could be preempted.196 A 12.8 to 18.2 percent tax is significant and a court would likely find this “exorbitant” 197 under Travelers. Under RILA, the Court found that the eight percent payroll tax in that case left employers with a lack of “meaningful alternatives by which an employer can increase its healthcare spending to comply with the [law] without affecting its ERISA plan.” 198 A law that compels plan administrators to structure their benefits in a particular way, especially by forgoing their ERISA plans, would be preempted under Travelers. 199 This restructuring of employee plans also directly conflicts with ERISA’s goal of permitting uniform nationwide administration of these plans.” 200

2023 Northwestern Affirmative
Off › AT: States CP › 1AR---XT: ERISA Preemption Deficit

Empirics prove strike down

Avik Roy 17, President, The Foundation for Research on Equal Opportunity (@FREOPP). Editor @ForbesOpinion. Author of “Transcending Obamacare,” “How Medicaid Fails the Poor.”, 3-2-2017, "How State-Based Single-Payer Initiatives Crush Economic Opportunity," FREOPP.org, https://freopp.org/how-state-based-single-payer-initiatives-crush-economic-opportunity-604ac9ac17c9

Core elements of the New York Health Act violate federal law The New York Health Act envisions abolishing private health insurance and replacing it with a single, state-run insurance program. However, the Act ignores the fact that federal law prohibits states from doing so. ERISA protects self-insured plans from state regulation. The Employee Retirement Income Security Act, enacted by Congress in 1974, provides employers with the ability to preempt state health insurance laws if they choose to provide health insurance directly, instead of through a third-party insurer. In third-party, or group insurance, the insurance company takes on the financial risks of paying health care claims, even if those claims exceed the revenues that the insurer has received in premiums. If a company decides to self-insure, it takes on those financial risks directly. Most large companies self-insure because there are economies of scale in doing so; in New York state in 2015, 83.2 percent of workers covered at firms with more than 1,000 employees were enrolled in self-insured plans, according to the U.S. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. All in all, in 2015, 53.5 percent of New York state residents with employer-sponsored health insurance were enrolled in self-insured plans protected from state interference by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA). With 10.2 million New Yorkers covered by employer-sponsored plans — 52 percent of the population — self-insured plans cover 5.1 million New Yorkers, or 26 percent of the state population. In other words, ERISA prevents New York State from abolishing private health coverage sponsored by companies that self-insure their workers. This principle of preemption was upheld by the U.S. Supreme Court on March 1, 2016 in Gobeille v. Liberty Mutual. The State of Vermont had sought to require self-insured employer plans in that state to report data on health care utilization, pricing, and quality to the state government. The Supreme Court ruled that ERISA prohibited states from regulating self-insured employer plans, even with something as minor as data disclosure. Indeed, the text of the New York Health Act partially anticipates this problem, declaring that a provision related to out-of-state residents working in New York “shall be null and void” if it is found “to violate federal ERISA.” Hence, an analytically accurate assessment of the New York Health Act must take into account that it cannot apply to the one-third of New Yorkers who receive their coverage from self-insured employers.

2023 Northwestern Affirmative
Off › AT: Topicality › 1AR---AT: US is Different

Social Security in the US is not limited to retirement security

MHLW – Japanese Ministry of Health, Labor, and Welfare, “Section 2. Definitnio of Social Security,” https://www.mhlw.go.jp/english/wp/wp-hw/vol1/p1c1s2.html

Also in the United States, "social security" is often defined as income security such as pensions. The welfare services provided in Japan are called "human services." In the United States, "welfare" usually points to services that are funded by tax revenues and provided after the status inquiry, especially to the temporary assistance to needy families (TANF). The U.S. Social Security Act, however, is a comprehensive law, which provides for unemployment insurance, health services for fatherless families, human services for people with disabilities, medical services for the elderly and medical assistance in addition to pension insurance for ensuring income.

2023 Northwestern Affirmative
Off › AT: Topicality › 2AC---Yes-Medicare

Legal Predictability---Legislative intent supports our interp

BIA No Date – Brain Injury Association of America, “Medicare (Title XVIII of the Social Security Act),” https://www.biausa.org/public-affairs/public-policy/medicare-title-xviii-of-the-social-security-act#:~:text=Medicare%20was%20established%20in%201965,when%20they%20reach%20age%2065.

Medicare was established in 1965 under Title XVIII of the Social Security Act as a federal health insurance program for individuals age 65 and older, regardless of income or health status. Individuals pay taxes throughout their working lives and generally become eligible for Medicare when they reach age 65. More than 55 million people rely on Medicare for their health insurance. About 17 percent of these individuals are under age 65. The program is administered by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), an agency of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.

2023 Northwestern Affirmative
Off › AT: Topicality › 2AC---Yes-Medicare

Social Security involves legislative efforts to solve catastrophic income disruption---that includes Medicare for all---International consensus

Brian Abel-Smith 23, Professor of Social Administration, London School of Economics and Political Science, University of London, 5/3/23, “social security,” https://www.britannica.com/money/topic/social-security-government-program

social security, any of the measures established by legislation to maintain individual or family income or to provide income when some or all sources of income are disrupted or terminated or when exceptionally heavy expenditures have to be incurred (e.g., in bringing up children or paying for health care). Thus social security may provide cash benefits to persons faced with sickness and disability, unemployment, crop failure, loss of the marital partner, maternity, responsibility for the care of young children, or retirement from work. Social security benefits may be provided in cash or kind for medical need, rehabilitation, domestic help during illness at home, legal aid, or funeral expenses. Social security may be provided by court order (e.g., to compensate accident victims), by employers (sometimes using insurance companies), by central or local government departments, or by semipublic or autonomous agencies.

The International Labour Organisation (ILO) uses three criteria to define a social security system. First, the objective of the system must be to grant curative or preventive medical care, to maintain income in case of involuntary loss of earnings or of an important part of earnings, or to grant a supplementary income to persons having family responsibilities. Second, the system must have been set up by legislation that attributes specified individual rights to, or that imposes specified obligations on, a public, semipublic, or autonomous body. And third, the system should be administered by a public, semipublic, or autonomous body.

2023 Northwestern Affirmative
Off › AT: Topicality › 2AC---Yes-Medicare

We Meet---Medicare is part of “Social Security”

Dr. Sanjay Gupta 19, CNNhealth, 7/2/19, “What ‘Medicare for All’ means, politically and practically,” https://www.cnn.com/2019/02/25/health/what-does-medicare-for-all-mean/index.html

Medicare, which has been around since 1965, is the government-run health insurance program that covers all Americans 65 and older and is funded by taxpayers. A portion taken out of our paychecks for Social Security goes toward Medicare to cover most services like hospital stays and doctors’ visits.

2023 Northwestern Affirmative
Case › Coverage Advantage › AT: Doctor Shortages

Single payer does not cause doctor shortages

Aaron Carrol 19, MD, 2019, “The myth of a physician exodus under Medicare for All,” https://pnhp.org/news/the-myth-of-a-physician-exodus-under-medicare-for-all/

There are plenty of reasons to be concerned about a transition to a Medicare-for-all type of system in the United States. Any big transition, even if it wound up being better than what we had before, would likely cause major disruption. But a mass exodus of doctors from Medicare is unlikely. Physicians need to see patients, and in such a system, all the patients would be covered by one carrier.

Even in a “Medicare for more” system, evidence from the past shows us that the vast majority of physicians are likely to remain. The ones who won’t may be more vocal, but they’ll be the exception, not the norm.