Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Kritik
AT: Baudrillard › AT: Specifics › AT: Fiat = Simulation

Fiat is good, makes us more focused on social relations and less militarized especially in the context of NATO.

Shearer 21 (Allan, School of Architecture Associate Dean for Research and Technology, Roleplaying to Improve Resilience, https://discovery.ucl.ac.uk/id/eprint/10121445/1/AMPS-18-6.pdf , 2021, ‘er’) *figure 2 omitted

Figure 2 presents a graphic comparison of the three assessments of critical uncertainties. Direct comparison is imperfect because each assessment was approached differently – again, in the first assessment, students worked in interdisciplinary groups, in the second, students worked alone while imagining the priorities of a fictional character, and in the third, students worked individually and from their own perspectives. While analytically messy, the results are a direct outcome of intentionally putting the students in positions where they had to think about the city from multiple perspectives. Nevertheless, observations can be made. It may be notable that in the first assessment (a group-based activity), the two PMESII factors that were used most commonly were Military and Infrastructure, both in terms of number of times cited and number of connections to different factors. The only relationship to receive more than one mention was Social-Infrastructure. The factors that were used least commonly were Political and Social. The initial identification of Military and Infrastructure factors might be expected given both that the base scenario was developed by NATO and that policy and planning programmes commonly emphasize infrastructure to support health, safety and welfare services. In the second (role-based) exercise, the results were reversed. Political and Social factors came to the forefront. Military and Infrastructure categories were still used, but not as dominantly. Also of note in the second assessment, all relationships are flagged by at least one person except the one between Economics and Information. In the third assessment, Infrastructure and Social are the most mentioned categories (19 and 12 respectively) and their connection is the most cited link pairwise. Perhaps curiously, in the third assessment, issues that relate to Information are not identified as of critical importance. This result suggests follow-up investigation given current conversations about ‘fake news’.46 Looking across the results it can be seen that between the first and third assessment more relationships are identified, and that can be recognized as supporting the primary goal of the exercise. Perhaps also, the connection to Political topics or concerns, which was prominent in the second assessment, was carried through into the third assessment. Referring to Table 1, the base political question is: ‘How is a member (typically a citizen) identified, what rights pertain to a member and how do those rights differ from non-members?’ As a set of exercises, participants were asked to play roles beyond their professional and sometimes educational experiences. Several of the students offered unsolicited comments that the experiment was unlike anything they had ever done in school or professional life. While each person was able to provide some level of analytical thinking (through the PMESII diagrams, maps and memo) that reflected the role s/he was asked to play, it must also be said that there were differing levels of comfort in trying to play these roles during the game. A sentiment expressed immediately following the exercise during a group discussion was that empathy may be the decisive criteria, but it will not be empathy with the person who delivers the news per se, but with the situation that is shared through real time Virtual Reality transmissions. The presentation of news would be replaced by experience (even if mediated experience) and without that experience, there would be no buy-in. David Chandler, who has written extensively on the role of resilience as a framing mechanism for governance in the Anthropocene, has commented, ‘For resilience-thinking, the type of knowledge that is possible is necessarily concrete rather than abstract; therefore, complexity- and resilience-thinking lends itself to action-research methods engaging with actors in the situation.’47 Wargames and role-playing may be simulations, but they do serve to ground our understanding of specific situations. To the degree that urban policy makers, planners and designers help create environments that allow strangers to live among one another, role-playing may bring in an aspect of professional practice that is otherwise absent or underdeveloped in the students’ training and education.

2022 Michigan Kritik
AT: Baudrillard › AT: Specifics › AT: Cyber Security = Simulation

Cyber-security research is based in sound research. Cold war threat inflation is a thing of the past.

Cavelty and Wegner 20 (Myriam Dunn and Andreas, PhDs from Zurich and lecturers, “Cyber security meets security politics: Complex technology, fragmented politics, and networked science”, 2019, Contemporary Security Policy, DOI: 10.1080/13523260.2019.1678855, )

Cluster 1: The reality of cyber conflict: Explaining state restraint and practices

In the beginning of this intellectual history, political aspects of cyber security were discussed almost exclusively in publications originating in U.S. think tanks and war colleges (for example: Arquilla & Ronfeldt, 1992). This literature had little ambition to contribute to an academic debate. The two main questions it tackled were “who (or what) is the biggest danger for an increasingly networked nation/society/military/business environment” and “how to best counter the new and evolving threat.”

2022 Michigan Kritik
AT: Baudrillard › AT: Specifics › AT: Charity Cannibalism

Multiple studies prove you’re wrong about people enjoying suffering and that images are necessary for action

Kyriakidou 21 (Maria, Senior Lecturer at the School of Journalism, Media and Culture, “The Audience of Human Communication”, 2021, ‘er’)

makes a psycho claim that baudrillard debaters unconsciously distance themselves from suffering through these args. probably the funniest card i’ve ever cut.

Researching the audience of suffering Limited but growing empirical research on audience responses to mediated suffering has been predominantly inspired by the reception paradigm of audience studies, whereby media viewers and users are approached as actively constructing meaning and interpreting media messages through various degrees of involvement and positioning in relation to the media (Livingstone, 1998; Morley, 1980, 1992). Given their qualitative nature, these studies have been small-scale, in-depth explorations of viewers’ reactions to mediated suffering. They have employed a variety of methods, such as focus groups, interviews and diaries. They have predominantly studied how audiences relate to news stories of suffering (Höijer, 2004; Huiberts & Joye, 2017; Kyriakidou, 2011) and, less often, to suffering witnessed through non-news programmes (Ong, 2015b; Scott, 2014); very few studies have explicitly studied audience engagement with humanitarian campaigns (Seu, 2003; 2010; von Engelhardt & Jansz, 2014). In her seminal work on the topic, Höijer explored audience reactions to the ‘discourse of global compassion’ constructed by the media through the reporting of humanitarian crises, wars and political conflicts and their innocent victims (Höijer, 2004). Her research, based on empirical material gathered through interviews and focus groups in Norway and Sweden, studied viewers’ reactions to media reports of war and violent news and concluded that compassion is most often directed to particular images of suffering and varies in its forms and expressions. Höijer concludes by describing the complexity of audience responses to suffering as ‘a twosided effect of global compassion on the one hand, and ignorance and compassion fatigue on the other’ expressed through ‘different forms of compassion as well as different forms of indifference’ (Höijer, 2004, p. 528). Indifference mostly reflected a critical stance and suspicion of media texts as either propagandistic or reflecting sensationalist, nationalistic mindsets, as well as overfamiliarity with images of suffering. Compassion, on the other hand, can be ‘tender-hearted’, ‘blamefilled’, ‘shame-filled’ and ‘powerlessness-filled’, according to Höijer. Interestingly, although the author acknowledges a variety of affective responses here, such as indignation or guilt, these are all described as being expressions of the same emotion, namely compassion. Focusing on the audience of humanitarian appeals, Seu also employed focus groups in a UK-based study of audience responses to NGO campaigns and news stories of human rights violations (Seu, 2003; 2010). Her analysis, focusing on the issue of audience (in)action and drawing upon the principles of psychology, psychoanalysis and rhetoric, illustrates the different ways people discursively distance themselves from the suffering of others and justify their unresponsiveness to human rights appeals. Scepticism about NGOs, their messages and international aid generally are given as reasons for such distancing. Cohen and Seu (2002, p. 189) describe such argumentative strategies as a ‘vocabulary of denial’ serving to avoid moral responsibility for witnessed suffering. Desensitisation, Seu argues, is a ‘defense’ mechanism against the realisation that ‘our social responsibility and human compassion, for whatever reason, do not stretch enough to getting us involved’ (Seu, 2003, p. 191). In a large-scale, UK-based study, Martin Scott (2014) combined focus group discussions with diaries, whereby participants were asked to log their daily media engagement. This research design allowed the author to move beyond the news genre and explore the mediation of distant suffering more broadly, including through other, factual television programmes. Influenced by Boltanski’s work, Scott analysed his material through the perspective of the options for action and emotion available to the viewers. He found substantial evidence of indifference to mediated encounters with distant suffering, particularly among young participants, as well as what he describes as ‘solitary enjoyment’, whereby research participants positioned themselves as observers of others’ suffering, devoid of any moral obligation to act (Scott, 2014, p. 13). An equally common type of engagement among participants was a tendency to evaluate media texts in terms of their accuracy and informational value (Scott, 2014, p. 10). Feelings of anger and indignation, per Boltanski’s topic of denunciation, were rather limited (Scott, 2014, p. 11). Given that participants seemed to be more emotionally involved with documentaries and current affairs programmes (Scott, 2014, p. 18), Scott’s study confirms Chouliaraki’s argument that media texts that represent suffering in its complexity and humanise the victims are necessary for constructing options for action and emotion on the part of the viewer (Chouliaraki, 2006).

2022 Michigan Kritik
AT: Baudrillard › AT: Specifics › AT: Charity Cannibalism

Images of suffering are key to compassion

Porter 6 (Prof & head of the School of International Studies at the University of South Australia, (Elisabeth, Hypatia 21.4, project muse)

I have explained what constitutes suffering and that attentiveness affirms dignity. I clarify further the nature of attentiveness. If morality is about our concerned responsiveness, attention is the prerequisite to intense regard. Iris Murdoch borrowed the concepdt of "attention" from Simone Weil "to express the idea of a just and loving gaze" (1985, 34) on the reality of particular persons. Part of the moral task is, as Murdoch reiterated, to see the world in its reality—to see people struggling in pain and despair. Weil, too, gave "attention" a prominent place, grounded in concrete matters of exploitation, economic injustice, and oppression. Her emphases were pragmatic in struggling against the debilitating nature of life—how "it humiliates, crushes, politicizes, demoralizes, and generally destroys the human spirit" (quoted in R. Bell 1998, 16)—and idealistic in striving to put ideals into practice. Too readily, we think about suffering in the height of media accounts of famine, suicide bombings, terrorist attacks, refugee camps, and war's destructive impact, and retreat quickly into our small world of self-pity. As Margaret Little explains, Murdoch's point was that "the seeing itself is a task—the task of being attentive to one's surroundings" (1995, 121). We need to "see" reality in order to imagine what it might be like for others, even when this includes horrific images from war violence. Yet despite the presence of embedded journalists, media reporting of such events as the invasion of Iraq has remained entirely typical in that "the experience of the people on the receiving end of this violence remains closed to us" (Manderson 2003, 4). Without political imagination, we will not have compassionate nations. "Without being tragic spectators, we will not have the insight required if we are to make life somewhat less tragic for those who . . . are hungry, and oppressed, and in pain" (Nussbaum 1996, 88). In order for political leaders to demonstrate [End Page 113] compassion, they should display the ability to imagine the lives led by members of the diverse groups that they themselves lead. Otherwise, dispassionate detachment predominates and acts like the 2003 invasion of Iraq lead to talk of freedom without seeing fear, assume liberation without replacing the losses, and abuse power without addressing people's pain. "The difference, for instance, between someone who discerns the painfulness of torture and someone who sees the evil of it is that the latter person has come to see the painfulness as a reason not to torture" (Little 1995, 126). Attentive ethics in international relations is about priorities and choices.

2022 Michigan Kritik
AT: Baudrillard › AT: Specifics › AT: Academy

Research in academic spaces can generate policy-relevant information necessary to navigate cyberspace. A focus on state-policy can be combined with critical approaches BUT abandoning statism makes relevant research impossible.

Cavelty and Wegner 20 - Cavelty is a senior lecturer for security studies and deputy for research and teaching at the Center for Security Studies (CSS) at ETH Zurich; Ph.D. from the University of Zurich; Visiting fellow at the Watson Institute for International Studies (Brown University) in 2007 and fellow at the stiftung neue verantwortung in Berlin, Germany 2010–2011. Wenger is professor of International and Swiss Security Policy at ETH Zurich; Ph.D. from the University of Zurich; visiting fellow at the Woodrow Wilson School of Public and International Affairs and the Center of International Studies, Princeton University.

Myriam Dunn Cavelty and Andreas Wenger, “Cyber security meets security politics: Complex technology, fragmented politics, and networked science”, 2019, Contemporary Security Policy, DOI: 10.1080/13523260.2019.1678855, https://doi.org/10.1080/13523260.2019.1678855

A second approach focuses on why cyber norms emerge only slowly, building on the existing IR norms literature (Finnemore & Hollis, 2016). Early works in this area focused on the debate among states, especially at the United Nations, followed by a growing number of proposal from the private and the civil sector (Hurwitz, 2014). However, cyber norms remain contested at the international level (Grisby, 2017). More recently, the interest of researchers shifted to the role of the creators (mostly private entities) and exploiters (sub-, semi-, and non-state actors) of digital technologies in shaping the behavioral standards that new regulation needs to take into account (Hurel & Lobato, 2018). States need to know how their intelligence services work in cyberspace, because through their tools and practices they set practical norms of acceptable (cyber) espionage with far-reaching effects on state behavior in cyberspace (Georgieva, 2019). The focus on the role of intelligence agencies in cyber conflict–as both the biggest threat and the most capable provider of safety–opens up interesting questions linked to the larger transformation of these agencies in the context of the digitization of society. Some authors argue that cyber conflict is primarily an intelligence game, because setting up cyber exploitation is much more expensive than countering released exploitation, which increases the incentive to keep the target at risk (Lindsay, 2017).

2022 Michigan Kritik
AT: Baudrillard › Alt Fails/Solvency Turns

Baudrillard theory of is extremely hostile towards minority struggles and over totalizes systems control.

Robinson 13(Andy Robinson, is a political theorist and activist based in the UK. He is the co-author (with Athina Karatzogianni) of Power, Resistance and Conflict in the Contemporary World: Social Movements, Networks and Hierarchies (Routledge, 2009). He has recently published a series of books on Homi Bhabha, February 7th 2013, Jean Baudrillard and Activism: a critique, Cease Fire, )

There are serious limits to Baudrillard’s work, in terms of his hostility to ‘minority’ struggles. Many of his formulations are inadvertently sexist and racist. There are also times when Baudrillard comes across as ableist in his critiques of the therapeutic. There are also times when Baudrillard attacks activism in strong terms: Hippies reproduce capitalist ideology; Feminists displaying images of porn are actually being seductive, against their will; The left is keeping capitalism alive with its moral critiques and its quests for meaning. There are times when it is hard to tell if Baudrillard is a reactionary, attacking the concerns of progressives, or an ultra-left, criticising every rebellion as insufficiently extreme. One limit to Baudrillard’s theory is his tendency to over-totalise. Baudrillard is talking about tendential processes, but he often talks as if they are totally effective. There are still, for instance, a lot of uncharted spaces, a lot of unexplained events, a lot of things the system can’t handle. While Baudrillard is describing dominant tendencies in the present, these tendencies coexist with older forms of capitalism, in a situation of uneven development. The persistence of the system’s violence is a problem for Baudrillard’s perspective: the smooth regime of neutralisation and inclusive regulation has not ended older modalities of brutality. At times, Baudrillard exaggerates greatly the extent to which the old authoritarian version of capitalism has been replaced by subtle regimes of control. He exaggerates the extent to which contemporary capitalism is tolerant, permissive and ‘maternal’. This may be because his works were mostly written in France in the 1970s-80s, when the dominant ethos was still largely social-democratic. What Baudrillard recognises as the retrograde version of capitalism associated with the right-wing was to return with a vengeance, especially after 911. Another problem is a lack of a Southern dimension. Like many Northern authors, Baudrillard’s approach mainly applies to the functioning of capitalism in the North. The penetration of the code is substantially less in countries where information technology is less widespread. In parts of Africa, even simple coding exercises such as counting votes or recording censuses are extremely difficult. This is for the very reasons of respondent reflexivity which Baudrillard highlights. People will under-record themselves to stay invisible, or over-record themselves to obtain benefits. And without massive resources to put into its bureaucracies, the system is unable to find enough people who will act as transmitters for the code. Instead, people use their power to extract what they can from the system. Explosions still happen regularly in the South. Furthermore, a contracting system ‘forcibly delinks’ large portions of the globe. Its power on the margins is lessened as its power at the core is intensified. As the system becomes ever more contracted and inward-looking, liberated zones may appear around the edges. Without an element of border thinking, Baudrillard tends to exaggerate the system’s completeness and effectiveness. Baudrillard assumes that any excess is everywhere absorbed into the code. He ignores the persistence of borderlands. And when he talks about the South, he admits that the old regime of production might still exist here: people still work seeking betterment; colonial wars are fought to destroy persisting symbolic exchange; Saddam was not playing the Gulf War by the rules of deterrence. The Arab masses are still able to become inflamed by war or non-war; Iran and Iraq can still fight a real war, not a simulated non-war. So perhaps only a minority, only the included layers within the North, are trapped within simulation and the ‘masses’. Perhaps reality has not died, but been displaced to the South.

2022 Michigan Kritik
AT: Baudrillard › Alt Fails/Solvency Turns

Baudrillard’s alternatives are ambiguous and overly conflated, and puts “liberation” at a huge cost.

Robinson 13(Andy Robinson, is a political theorist and activist based in the UK. He is the co-author (with Athina Karatzogianni) of Power, Resistance and Conflict in the Contemporary World: Social Movements, Networks and Hierarchies (Routledge, 2009). He has recently published a series of books on Homi Bhabha, February 7th 2013, Jean Baudrillard and Activism: a critique, Cease Fire, https://ceasefiremagazine.co.uk/in-theory-baudrillard-14/)

Baudrillard’s critique of Marx is interesting, and I think largely valid. What he puts in place of Marx’s theory is, however, contentious. His recent work gives the impression of a disillusioned Situationist seeking to find an alternative to revolution in a world where none is apparent. As a result, he finds ways to read conformist mass practices as unconscious resistances, irrational systemic functioning and implosion, and so on. Baudrillard is also too prone to conflate system collapse with liberation. There are scenarios of implosion which would not lead to liberation. One might, for instance, think of climate change due to overconsumption as a scenario of system-collapse. This would bring about the end of the code, but also possibly the end of humanity. In some ways, the idea of implosion echoes Sing Chew’s theory of world-system collapse. Based on previous episodes of collapse, Chew argues that the world-system will collapse when it reaches its ecological limits. It won’t explode; it will collapse inwards and break down as the processes which sustain it are reversed. Each ‘civilisation’ is followed by a ‘dark age’. Populations move outwards from cities, power is diffused, and local knowledge replaces global knowledge. This is not quite what Baudrillard has in mind, but similar enough to be suggested as an effect of continued implosion. Or maybe implosion should be compared to the ‘extraordinary communities’ of disaster, to the sudden collapse of the system’s management structures after which people take over their own self-management (as in Argentina), to the fraying round the edges of a system which can no longer secure the code at its more remote limits (as in Africa). Perhaps as the code burns itself up, we will be left occupying wastelands where we are finally free, but at great cost. Hence, an implosive collapse of the system might give rise to a hope for other social forms. It might, after all, be liberation in disguise. What of the crucial concept of ‘symbolic exchange’? Baudrillard’s discussion of symbolic exchange oscillates between three poles. Firstly, it refers to the experience of living in an embedded society, with rituals, exchanges and local knowledges. Secondly, it refers to the crisis-effects of the decomposition of the code, which create symbolic exchange as their effect. Thirdly, it refers to a kind of experience beyond the regime of simulation, through arbitrary connections. The political effects of the process Baudrillard advocates is thus rather ambiguous. Does the rise of symbolic exchange herald a return to embedded forms of social relations, to some kind of modern band or tribe which reproduces aspects of embedded forms, or something else entirely? The recovery of immediacy, connectedness, uncoded relations, ‘exchange’ between signs and the world, are important aspects of disalienation. However, I have issues with the Lacanian view of the subject which underpins Baudrillard’s theory of symbolic exchange. It is possible to endorse Baudrillard’s view of the death of value in capitalism and the creation of a self-reproducing code, without necessarily seeing the alternative in terms of symbolic exchange and death. A wide variety of other theories are attempting the same thing – from ‘anti-civilisation’ theories to Agamben’s ‘whatever-singularity’. It might be more useful to hitch Baudrillard’s critique to a more affirmative theory, than to attempt to follow his ‘fatal’ strategies.

2022 Michigan Kritik
AT: Baudrillard › Baudrillard Indicts

Yousuf Dhamee NO DATE

Yousuf Dhamee partner in the Private Investment Funds practice at Paul Hastings and based in the firm's Los Angeles office. A Critique of Baudrillard, cyberartsweb.org/cpace/theory/ydbaud.html. 🐸

In The Precession of Simulacra Jean Baudrillard attempts to disentangle the phenomenon that the Post-Structuralist movement simultaneously identified, decried and helped popularize: the disappearance of the real. In examining the cultural climate of the West following 1970 Baudrillard finds a world where representation through a surplus of images has obscured all former notions of truth. The annihilation of the real has become a manifestation of Marx's nightmare of the commodity fetish. He portrays the United States, in particular, as a grim militaristic state controlled by the media's manipulation of images. Baudrillard finds himself disempowered by the endlessly proliferating images which confound the real. His position becomes that of the male hysteric , due in part to the fact that intellect and reason cannot make sense of the post-modern "world of hallucinations" where image, reality, and surface representation blur into each other. Baudrillard in a sense writes himself out of his own text. In a world without truth the theorist/the semiotician/the intellectual (indeed the university itself) becomes irrelevant, if not totally impotent.

The idea of the loss of meaning is inherent in the concept of the simulacrum . Here the idea of an accurate copy becomes to a certain extent passé. Baudrillard states that we are removed from the binary which sets up copy and original; there are only copies of copies. In fact he takes the notion farther: the simulacra exists as a copy which has no original. According to Baudrillard the "imitation" can, in fact, precede the original. This results in a world without depth, a place where reality is only an endless interplay of surfaces. Simulations are produced in order to hide the fact that there is no original, no real. Baudrillard's intent is not to expose the falseness of the simulated real, but to lament the passing of the actual real. He seems to find the depthless world of images oppressive. He writes of the "murderous power of images," "the mirror of madness, and "the blackmail of the truth." His emotionally charged prose reflects a hysteria that derives from powerlessness. The loss of reference points, which results from the death of originality, contributes to the confusion that marks the modern world. As Baudrillard points out, the charm of a simulation lies in being able to distinguish copy from original. "Because it is difference that constitutes the poetry of the map and the charm of the territory, the magic of the concept and the charm of the real." The loss of distinction between the two leads to the loss of truth.

2022 Michigan Kritik
AT: Baudrillard › Baudrillard Indicts

Baudrillard’s defenders are mere propagandists that reduce their own scholarship to accumulation.

Horrocks 95(Christopher Horrocks, Senior Lecturer in the Faculty of Design at Kingston University, August 16th 1995, Baudrillard and the Millennium[Postmodern Encounters], Beyond the Millennium: Anti-Baudrillard, the Vital Illusion and the Return of the Mirror People, pf 78-80)

Beyond the Millennium: AntiBaudrillard, the Vital Illusion and the Return of the Mirror People It is beside the point to condemn Jean Baudrillard for either spurning the tasks of rational and ethical judgement set by philosophers, or for his 'failure' to account for real human injustice, misery and oppression. Christopher Norris, Douglas Kellner, Alex Callinicos and a host of other writers in the Kantian or Marxist tradition have taken 58 Baudrillard to task, accusing his 'trash-theory' of being part of a modernist sensibility that substitutes art for philosophy, value for truth, image for reality, or Baudelaire for Kant."? Yet people do support Baudrillard's right to comment on our condition. For example, sociologist Zygmunt Bauman has attacked those rationalist critics of Baudrillard who assume that criticism only carries weight if one's feet are set on the rock of absolute and universal truth. These critics are always the last to claim that their stance is part of historical, social and mundane transformations. 78 As Chris Rojek notes, Baudrillard's tone and style is hardly one of indifference or happy consumerism. Rather, Baudrillard writes like 'a man who is strapped to the mast of the pathological society, who sees everything without illusions and who accepts that there is no cure around the corner';" In fact, Baudrillard himself puts forward his critics' standard complaints. These apostles of reality and truth, he says, claim that he is monstrous for discrediting reality while there are so many in the world who find even existence difficult; that he fails to attack affluence on behalf of the poor; that he disparages class struggle when there are those who have not had their revolution; or that he insults feminism and human rights when many have not yet acquired those rights. Baudrillard sees, however, that these good intentions disguise a contempt. In phrasing reality as a version of life insurance or a human right and, worse, assuming that people place hope only in the visible proofs of their existence ('a plaster-saint realism'), such critics take them for naive and feeble-minded. This contempt simply reflects the desire of the propagandists of reality to reduce their own lives to an accumulation of facts, evidence, causes and effects. 'Well-ordered resentment always begins at home', Baudrillard concludes. 80

2022 Michigan Kritik
AT: Baudrillard › Baudrillard Indicts

Baudrillard’s theory is false, It misrepresents Simulacra and Simulation, It is a work of hypocrisy and The Matrix fails to represent his overall theoretical position.

Cussen, James. “Why Baudrillard Hated the Matrix.” Medium, The Living Philosophy, 30 Apr. 2022, medium.com/the-living-philosophy/why-baudrillard-hated-the-matrix-6052010375cd. 🐸

“The Matrix is surely the kind of film about the matrix that the matrix would have been able to produce.” These were the infamous words that Jean Baudrillard used to break his silence on The Matrix movies in a 2004 interview with . Baudrillard’s idea of simulation — which we explored in-depth  — was the primary inspiration behind the Wachowski siblings’ movie series. His 1981 book Simulacra and Simulation was not merely  but was the main inspiration for the movies and was required reading for the whole cast. After the release of the first movie the Wachowskis reached out to Baudrillard inviting him to work on the sequels but he turned down the offer and in this interview we learn why. As it turns out Baudrillard — the “high priest of postmodernism” — hated the movies. In this article we are going to look at the three reasons he gives for this disdain:1. It misrepresents Simulacra and Simulation, 2. It is a work of hypocrisy and 3. The Matrix fails to represent his overall theoretical position. And following that we are going to look at why Baudrillard is wrong. #1 The Misrepresentation of The Matrix In 2004, a year after the release of the third Matrix movie, Baudrillard finally broke his silence on the Wachowskis’ cinematic adaptation of his work. It was well known by now that his work was the main inspiration behind the movies but he had never spoken publicly about them until now. And he was not happy. His first criticism is the rather damning claim that the movies completely miss the point of his work and that it confuses the classical Platonic problem of illusion with the postmodern problem of simulation. The Problem of Illusion The classical formulations of the problem of illusion were given by Plato and Descartes. Plato’s version comes from his dialogue The Republic where we find his allegory of the cave in which the mass of humanity lives in an illusory state where they mistake the shadows cast by a fire on the cave wall for reality. The philosopher is the one who leaves the cave and emerges into the real light of the sun. A more condensed version of this classical problem is found in Descartes’ work Meditations on First Philosophy where in a line of investigation that culminates in his famous conclusion “I think there I am”, Descartes embarks on a quest for the foundations of knowledge. He begins to question how he knows whether what he is experiencing is real. It seems to be real, and yet, he writes: “How often my sleep at night has convinced me of all these familiar things — that I was here, wrapped in my gown, sitting by the fire — when in fact I was lying naked .” This is the classical problem of illusion. For Descartes this sitting here beside the fire is reality while dreaming is an illusion. With the problem of illusion there is a clear and absolute distinction between reality and illusion. We see this problem being directly referenced by Morpheus in the first movie: Morpheus: “Have you ever had a dream, Neo, that you were so sure was real? What if you were unable to wake from that dream? How would you know the difference between the dream world ?” The Simulation Hypothesis Baudrillard’s simulation hypothesis is a tough idea to fully grasp. For a deeper exploration check out  where you can read my futile attempts to wrap my brain around the nuances of Baudrillard’s brilliant simulation hypothesis. The bottom line is that with the emergence of simulation in the  we have entered, this distinction between the real and the illusory, to use Baudrillard’s term, ‘implodes’. The difference between reality and illusion becomes meaningless. With the emergence of the age of simulation, the real has become inaccessible. We can no longer speak of the real, it is no longer attainable. We only have a simulated reality that Baudrillard calls the ‘hyperreal’ in which reality and illusion have imploded into each other. In Simulacra and Simulation he writes: “The impossibility of rediscovering an absolute level of the real is of the same order as the impossibility of staging illusion. Illusion is no longer possible, because the real is .” It is this distinction between the problems of simulation and illusion that Baudrillard, in the 2004 interview, claims the Matrix movies missed entirely. The problem as he sees it is that the distinction between what is real and what is illusion is far too clear cut. There’s a red pill that takes you to the truth and there’s a blue pill that leaves you in illusion. In the interview he states that: “The actors are in the matrix, that is, in the digitized system of things; or, they are radically outside it, such as in Zion, the city of resistors. But what would be interesting is to show what happens when these two worlds collide. The most embarrassing part of the film is that the new problem posed by simulation is confused with its .” So for Baudrillard the Matrix movies have completely missed the point — they have the real in Zion and the illusion in the Matrix. The idea of the real is preserved. Of course any serious fan of the Matrix movies will be shouting at their screen right now saying that it is Baudrillard that has missed the point but we’ll come back to that in a minute. For now though we can say that Baudrillard’s first and his primary criticism of the movies is that they have missed the point of Simulacra and Simulation. They have misunderstood the idea of simulation and have set up an all-too-clear distinction between the real and the illusory. #2 The Matrix would love The Matrix Baudrillard’s second criticism of the Matrix series is what he sees as the hypocrisy of the movies. The Matrix is, on the surface of things, a criticism of technology and how technology is gaining more and more power over our lives. We learn that the humans in the real world had gone to war with their machines: Morpheus : We don’t know who struck first, us or them. But we do know it was us that scorched the sky. At the time, they were dependent on solar power. It was believed they would be unable to survive without an energy source as . However the machines find another power source — humans and so humanity become batteries that power the machine-run world. The entire setup and story of the Matrix is as a cautionary tale about the danger of technology and it is supposed to point us back to what really matters — our humanity, our freedom, our human love and connection. But Baudrillard remarks that “The Matrix is surely the kind of film about the matrix that the matrix would have been able to produce.” The interviewer picks up on this observation noting that it is: “a film that purports to denounce technicist alienation and, at the same time, plays entirely on the fascination exercised by the digital universe and .” Baudrillard expands on his point further saying that The Matrix movie is: “an instructive symptom, and the actual fetish of this universe of technologies of the screen in which there is no longer a distinction between the real . […] The Matrix paints the picture of a monopolistic superpower, like we see today, and then collaborates in its refraction. Basically, its dissemination on a world scale is complicit .” And when you think about it Baudrillard has a solid point here. The Matrix, for all its criticism of technology, utilises it to make a spectacle. The very thing that is so seductive about the Matrix movies is the dazzling technological spectacle — there’s Neo dodging bullets, learning kung-fu by downloading a computer program, there’s the gunfights running up walls, there’s the world of the robots and the sentinels, and then of course, there’s the Matrix itself — the movie is a monolithic fetishization of the exact thing it sets out to criticise. For Baudrillard this is part of the broader cultural landscape that is so overwhelming. He says that this: “is exactly what makes our times so oppressive. The system produces a negativity in trompe-l’oeil, [a trick of the eye] which is integrated into products of the spectacle just as obsolescence is built into industrial products. It is the most efficient way of incorporating all genuine alternatives. There are no longer external Omega points or any antagonistic means available in order to analyze the world; there is nothing more than .” And so in our postmodern world there is no solid ground from which to criticise the system. Che Guevara has been legitimised as an icon of rebellious adolescents and sells millions of t-shirts and posters every year. Critiques of the system on social media only further enshrine the power of those technological monopolies. Resistance is futile. The system is all-engulfing. #3 A Glimmer of Irony In his third criticism, Baudrillard moves from criticising The Matrix for misunderstanding the idea of simulation, to criticising the movies for failing to understand his philosophy in general. He says that: “The pseudo-Freud who speaks at the film’s conclusion puts it well: at a certain moment, we reprogrammed the matrix in order to integrate anomalies into the equation. And you the resistors, comprise a part of it. Thus we are, it seems, within a total virtual circuit .” Baudrillard is of course referring to the scene with the Architect at the end of the second movie The Matrix Reloaded  that the resistors in Zion are a part of the overall Matrix program. By giving rebellious outliers the illusion of autonomy and an escape into reality, they ensure the greater overall stability of the Matrix. But Baudrillard isn’t happy. His criticism is that the movies fail to enact his chosen form of rebellion which he summarises in the interview as: “a glimmer of irony that would allow viewers to turn this gigantic special effect .” This ties in with Baudrillard’s broader philosophy of what he calls  and his way of subverting this all-encompassing system within which we live. But when it comes to the Matrix, this criticism doesn’t make sense. The Wachowskis are being criticised for not being true to Baudrillard’s overall philosophy. He admits that they have created an all-encompassing system of oppression as he maps out in his works but criticises the movies for not also including his own chosen form of rebellion. But it’s an unfair criticism. The Wachowskis don’t reference Baudrillard’s entire corpus in The Matrix. They didn’t get the cast to read all of the French postmodernist’s books. They were primarily concerned with the problem of simulation as presented in the book Simulacra and Simulation. This third criticism then is to my eyes an unfair one because it criticises the movie for something it didn’t try to do. Baudrillard can dislike the film because it doesn’t agree with his philosophy but on this count he can’t knock the Matrix movies just because they aren’t exactly how he would have liked them to be. Why Baudrillard is Wrong. This brings us back to Baudrillard’s main criticism of The Matrix — it fails to portray the difference between simulation and reality — it makes the distinction too clear cut. This criticism might be applied to the first Matrix movie but remember this interview took place a year after the third movie had been released. Also Baudrillard referenced the conversation with the Architect at the end of the second movie in the interview so we know he has the second movie and so we can safely assume that he has also seen the third. And assuming that’s the case, Baudrillard has somehow dramatically missed the point because anyone who has seen the third movie or even just the end of the second movie would find it difficult to support Baudrillard’s critique. The third movie, The Matrix Revolutions, completes the fractalizing of epistemological doubts that had begun in the first movie. In the original movie we find out that the entire reality Neo is living in is a virtual reality universe. Neo escapes this Matrix and meets the other rebels who live in Zion — the underground city of humans in 2199. The second movie muddies the waters even more when we learn that even this rebel colony is part of the system. The Architect informs us that previous iterations of the Matrix had failed to account for the rebellious minority and so this rebellious anomaly had been incorporated into the design of this Matrix. The upshot is that yes Zion is the real world but the rebellion that Zion represents is not real. It is a simulated rebellion that serves the purpose of stabilising the Matrix. So already with the second movie we have the destabilisation of the neat dichotomy between reality and illusion. Already we have entered a blurred state of reality where even though Zion occurs in the real world it is a hyperreality — it is not a spontaneous utterance of nature but a crafted and predicted simulation of rebellion despite what its members may believe. This destabilisation of the reality principle reaches a new level at the end of the second movie which is picked up in the third as well. At the end of the second movie we see Neo destroying the sentinel robots — fighting them in the real world using the same sort of superpowers that we see him using inside the Matrix. Then, in the third movie we see his ability to see code when he goes blind and we also have the strange moment when a sentinel flies through him.These instances muddy the waters of reality more. We are now left questioning what is Matrix and what is reality and it seems that we can no longer truly tell one from the other.The “real” world of Zion and Machine City seems to be equally prey to the peculiar powers of Neo as the world of the Matrix. By the end of the series we can no longer say for certain what is real. Neo sues for peace with the machines but he does not know for sure what is reality. I’ve seen some people online argue that from the moment Neo leaves the room of the Architect he is in a new level of virtual reality. Others have argued that Zion was always a simulation. The bottom line is, the distinction between the real and the illusory has been muddied so much that we no longer know where one ends and the other begins. The distinction, has as Baudrillard would say, imploded.Final Thoughts In their introduction to the 2004 box set The Ultimate Matrix Collection, the Wachowski siblings say that“It was our sincerest hope that our movies might inspire or perhaps provoke a little Socratic interaction, something beyond, ‘Remember that one part? ”.There can be no doubt of their success. The Matrix movies are far from perfect and Baudrillard’s second criticism still stands. But that being said, I can’t think of any other movie except for maybe Kubrick’s 2001: A Space Odyssey that has inspired so much philosophical engagement — hundreds of articles that transcend the .The Wachowski siblings created a work of art that has sparked a philosophical conversation in a way that no other movie ever has. It is easy to get distracted by the criticisms of the Matrix movies, and to miss the greater success of the movies as attaining their initial goal. The Wachowskis set out to make a movie that got people thinking and they succeeded at a scale that outstripped all expectations.

2022 Michigan Kritik
AT: Baudrillard › Baudrillard Indicts

Hyperreality is itself postmodern, and fails to offer a critical understanding of culture other than explaining the obvious. Reality and meaning exists equally as it did in the past, the only thing that changed is the medium of exchange.

King 98(Anthony King, Department of Sociology at the University of Exeter, 1998, Philosophy and Social Criticism vol 24 no. 6, A critique of Baudrillard’s Hyperreality: towards a sociology of Postmodernism, pg 47-53, https://journals-sagepub-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/doi/pdf/10.1177/019145379802400603)

This article criticizes the concept of hyperreality which is central to Baudrillard’s later writings and, in doing so, intends to make a wider contribution to debates about postmodernism. In particular, I want to argue that Baudrillard’s hyperreality is an example of postmodern sociology, rather than a sociology of postmodernism. By that, I mean that the notion of hyperreality is not, in the end, a critical concept providing a means by which sociologists might analyse contemporary cultural change; rather, the notion of hyperreality is itself postmodern, 48 demonstrating those very features of nihilism, fragmentation and doubt, ’ which it highlights as central to recent social transformations. The examination of the concept of hyperreality is intended to show that such ’postmodern sociologies’ are limited and that they can be encompassed (and dialectically superseded) by a sociology of postmodernism. The critique of hyperreality (A) The sociological inadequacy of hyperreality Baudrillard is undoubtedly correct to point to the importance of the television as a central element in contemporary culture. It is a startling development that in the last 30 years practically every individual in capitalist countries is able to witness footage of events from almost anywhere around the globe. It is also true that this footage is invariably misleading, even though it is apparently so compelling and ’realistic’. Television is only tangentially connected with the realities it seeks to portray as well as contrasting dramatically with the social experience of the viewers; we 52 witness riots, wars and massacres as they occur from the comfort of our living-rooms. However, from these admittedly curious features, Baudrillard leaps suddenly and unjustifiably to the claim that there is no longer any reality. The television screen creates a ’false’ reality and it is in that reality that we now live. However, the television does not create a false reality either in its representation of the world or in its reception by viewers. Television coverage is determined by the cultural norms of the society to which it broadcasts and by those involved in the production of television. Thus any footage is an interpretation of the world and as such it is necessarily limited. It is certainly true that programme makers try to render this interpretation of the world as compelling as possible to attract viewers and to sustain their claims but those images are always and necessarily embedded in social discourse, which is itself related to the historic development of the society. The images are not then free-floating, mere simulacra but, on the contrary, concrete moves in a language game. They refer not so much to the reality of the situations they portray but rather to the society to which they communicate these images. Similarly the viewers of television programmes do not regard these images as empty, referenceless and fragmentary. On the contrary, just as the creation of these images was embedded in the interpretative practice of making sense of the world so do the viewers try to interpret these images in such a way that they will be able to make sense of their world. Whether the programme be a soap opera or news footage, the viewers interpret the images according to their cultural understandings (see, for instance, Fiske and Hartley, 1984; Hall, 1980; Featherstone, 1988: 220-1, 1991: 5, 11), although those understandings are under constant revision in order to make sense of new information. Thus rather than becoming the primary and prior cultural factor in contemporary society, the television is embedded in and dependent upon pre-existing and historically produced understandings and discourses.5 Furthermore, the footage does not exist above and beyond the lives of viewers but, as the briefest autobiographical consideration will reveal, the television is employed as a resource, where new interpretations derived from its footage are used in the renegotiation of social relations and understandings. Viewers discuss what they watch and make use of what they see to make sense of their own lives. The argument for the fundamentally interpretative nature of the television and, therefore, its fundamental unoriginality as a cultural form undercuts Baudrillard’s notion of hyperreality at an empirical level. In short, the television just does not represent the ontological transformation of culture which he envisages. The production and consumption of the television operates in the same interpretative manner as the production and consumption of literature, theatre and, indeed, oral 53 story-telling. All these methods of communication have to operate according to the same interpretative norms, typical of all human interaction, for the very reason that they are all primarily linguistic. Baudrillard’s failure to recognize the fundamentally interpretative nature of television suggests some deeper philosophical and, in particular, deeper epistemological shortcomings in his theories. The recognition of Baudrillard’s epistemological weakness brings us to the second, philo- sophical strand of the argument against the notion of hyperreality which will demonstrate that Baudrillard’s notion of hyperreality is founded in an unsustainable Cartesianism.

2022 Michigan Kritik
AT: Baudrillard › Baudrillard Indicts

Baudrillard more wrong than he is right and lacks empirical validity

Rojek and Turner 93(Chris Rojek is a Professor of Sociology at City University. He has held Professorships since 1994 at The University of Staffordshire; Nottingham Trent University and Brunel University, West London. He is the author of 14 solo authored books, 12 edited and co-edited books and over 50 refereed articles.

and Brian S. Turner is a British and Australian sociologist., 1992, Forget Baudrillard?, Introduction, https://monoskop.org/images/0/0a/Rojek_Chris_Turner_Bryan_Forget_Baudrillard_1993.pdf)

Should we the regret the dazzling ascent of this writer in the Anglo-American world over the last decade? Certainly if the quality of a writer in the social sciences is to be assessed only by the validity of his or her propositions there is reason for regretting Baudrillard’s success. Baudrillard has been wrong—spectacularly wrong—about a lot of things. One thinks of his prediction of the impossibility of the Gulf war; his assertion that America is already utopia; his reactionary thesis that the strength of the feminine is seduction; his eccentric defence of the concert against quadrophonic sound which is predicated in the argument that Mozart was never intended to be heard through electronic systems of reproduction; and his unsupported statement that the body has become a mere extension of network television. And one thinks of these things casually, without systematically sifting through the careening waves of Baudrillard’s prose for other hostages to fortune or bad prophecies. In short, Baudrillard fails the validity test. However, it is by no means clear that validity is the only or even the most important criterion to assess the significance of an author’s work. Other criteria such as courage and sympathy are also relevant. In these respects Baudrillard is on stronger ground. The success of his publications in the English-speaking world since the 1980s suggests that his main themes of simulation and the seductiveness of consumer culture have found sympathy with a large audience of readers. Baudrillard may be wrong more often than he is right, but he has unquestionably struck the appropriate mood with which to approach questions of consumer culture.

2022 Michigan Kritik
AT: Baudrillard › Baudrillard Indicts

Their theory of simulation is wrong and baseless nonsense - Reality exists

Schwabach 3 (Aaron Schwaback @ Jefferson School of Law - Professor of Law and Director of Center for Global Legal Studies, J.D., University of California at Berkeley Published : 2003, <jonah> <IKS> “Kosovo: Virtual War and International Law,” DOA: 7-8-16, pages 1-21)

Baudrillard presents fewer problems of interpretation; his word is simulacrum (simulacre), which he uses in more or less the same sense, albeit with more elaboration, that it is ordinarily used.10 Academics are often criticized for over-reliance on opaque jargon. In comparison to many of his compatriots and their American emulators, Baudrillard indulges in jargon only sparingly. For the most part, he writes the most arrant nonsense in a clear, readily accessible style. His basic point is that the Gulf War was not a war but the simulacrum of a war; it happened not on the battlefield but on television. All of the traditional trappings of the buildup to war were presented, even grotesquely exaggerated, on television; at the end, however, we (the audience) were deprived of the final battle, left with neither victory for the Allies nor defeat for Saddam Hussein. In light of the bold promise of the book’s title, this is rather disappointing. Rather than arguing unequivocally that the entire war was a fraud perpetrated upon the television-viewing public, Baudrillard is simply nattering on again about simulacra. (At one point, though, he does suggest that “[o]ne is reminded of Capricorn One,” a movie about a government conspiracy to fake a Mars landing in a film studio and present it to the public as news.)11 Baudrillard, after all, is a man who, like his compatriot and predecessor Descartes, spends an inordinate amount of time wondering whether he exists. Unlike Descartes, however, he is not convinced that he exists merely because he thinks that he does. His identity, and that of everything and everyone else, is lost in a kaleidoscope of endlessly precessing simulacra that ultimately preclude the existence of any baseline reality. The Gulf War is not then real or unreal in any absolute sense, because there is no ultimate “reality.” It is simply less real than some things and more real than others. (Baudrillard draws many comparisons between “events” in the war and television commercials, for example.) The Gulf War (or simulacrum of war) is thus at least as real as international law, and by extension so is the Kosovo war; I shall therefore have to continue writing about all three. Baudrillard begins by asserting that “It might have been supposed that the defection of the Eastern Bloc would have opened up new spaces of freedom for war by unlocking deterrence. Nothing of the sort[.]”12 Baudrillard, writing these words at the beginning of 1991,13 was simply too impatient. As the world has since learned to its dismay, the defection of the Eastern Bloc and subsequent breakup of the Soviet Union and Yugoslavia has opened up a great number of new spaces of freedom for war, most notably in the expression of the ethnic conflicts previously repressed by authoritarian Communist regimes. Baudrillard himself would undoubtedly deplore the idea that the facts of his life might be responsible for his opinions. But his reactions on such topics as America and superpower conflict (and, as we shall see later, Arabs and Islam) are often surprisingly conventional for a person of his age, gender and nationality. Baudrillard was born in Reims in 1929.14 He would thus have been three or four years old when Hitler came to power, fifteen during the liberation of France, and sixteen when World War II ended. The bilateral Allied/Axis conflict was almost immediately replaced with a similar conflict between the more or less free-market countries of the West and the communist countries of the Soviet bloc. As a result, it is perhaps natural that Baudrillard would see a world with two opposing ideological camps as a prerequisite for war, or at least for war of the sort to which he is accustomed. At the time of communism’s collapse, he found it difficult to believe in the possibility of war in a post-Soviet world. By the time Baudrillard opined that the collapse of the Eastern bloc had opened up no new spaces of freedom for war, in fact, Croatia and Slovenia had already begun to make secessionist noises; six months later the first of Yugoslavia’s ethnic cleansing wars would begin. The Romanian revolution (or its simulacrum) had already taken place, as Baudrillard repeatedly acknowledges, after his fashion. 15 Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait could have been designed as a test case for the role of the United States in the post-Cold War world, as the first major act of territorial aggression in which the response of the Soviet Union (which itself would not last out the year) was more or less insignificant. Thus, simulacrum or not, the Gulf War was important historically. Baudrillard himself says, somewhat inconsistently in light of his other conclusions, that “what is at stake in this one is war itself: its status, its meaning, its future.”16 Much of what strikes Baudrillard as different about the Gulf War, though, is actually not new at all. For example, he sees the role of hostages as one of the Gulf War’s novel qualities: “The hostage has taken the place of the warrior. He has become the principal actor, the simulacral protagonist, or rather, in his pure inaction, the protagoniser of non-war.”17 Later, in Kosovo, the Serbian government would make an entire civilian population hostage. Yet the use of hostages in war, even on this scale, is hardly new; warring parties have always viewed hostages “as exchange value and liquidity.”18 Using hostages as human shields and bargaining chips is as old as war itself. It is when Baudrillard likens the plight of the audience to the plight of the hostages, though, that he begins to exhibit the indifference to human suffering for which he has so often been criticized.19 He writes that “all of us [are] information hostages on the world media stage….20 We are already all strategic hostages in situ; our site is the screen on which we are virtually bombarded day by day, even while serving as exchange value.”21 It is this element of the concept of simulacral war that is most difficult to accept. The difference between the hostage and the viewer should be obvious even to one who affects to disbelieve in his own existence; the viewer can simply turn off the television and thus escape his or her predicament. Nor do the viewers have significant “exchange value,” unless the governments concerned would discontinue the charade of war if they thought no one was watching, or unless the simulacrum exists only to the degree it is perceived. Thus the claim that “[t]he complement of the unconditional simulacrum in the field is to train everyone in the unconditional reception of broadcast simulacra” makes sense only if one also accepts that the simulacrum experienced by the viewer is identical to that experienced by the viewed. Those who believe in the reality of human suffering are likely to react to this idea with a certain amount of hostility, however. This reaction can only be exacerbated by the assertion that “it is [the hostages’] virtual death that is at issue, not their real death.

2022 Michigan Kritik
AT: Baudrillard › Baudrillard Indicts

Baudrillard’s logic is faulty, it doesn’t take into account the thing to be simulated is equally affected by the real. War games and planning aren’t simulations, they’re the same as war, no meaning is lost.

Von Hilgers 12 (Phillip, Postdoctoral Fellow in the Department of the History of Science at Harvard University, Managing Director at Meetrics, “War Games: A History of War on Paper,” Chapter 4: Historiography in Real Time (2012), translated by Ross Benjamin, 6/23/22 - FI)

The Real of Simulations For a long time, media theories have burgeoned regarding how media seem to capture the world in simulations. The fact that media themselves are not based on virtualities but on realities — which even former radio officers occasionally find hard to master — is often overlooked. Thus sociologist Jean Baudrillard has elevated the simulacrum to the central concept for the description of the state of the Western world — without, however, asking about the historical development of the simulation. For Baudrillard, simulacra have, in an escalating fashion, first taken up the play with the real, then taken the place of its appearances, and finally themselves created a basis that is no longer dependent on the real. 32 In particular, the referential system of the image has thereby undergone a transformation that leads from reflection to self-referentiality. 33 The logic of this interpretation, however, implies that the real is excluded from the simulation media and their history is effaced. But it is precisely the development of war games that shows how much the real intrudes into the simulation media, which is the case whenever the simulation reaches its limit and suffers disturbances. The thing to be simulated is equally affected by the intrusion of the real, even if it sometimes takes on the technical forms of the simulation. In particular, effects of the real emerge at the communicative and mediatic level. In the military political war game, a Prussian legation councilor ’ s ability to empathize might underlie the position of the Polish foreign minister. However, the communication practices that are thereby tested could not be more real. It is in the war game that the difference between simulation and communication comes most clearly to light. Though infantry units in the war game that do not shoot with live ammunition — or if they do, then only at targets — and tank battalions that operate, in the absence of available tanks, with mockups or entirely on paper exclude a world of real pitfalls from the outset, their signal battalions do not proceed any differently in the war game than in war: “ The headquarters or the command post is set up in houses, in the open, in vehicles or tents. The signals personnel set up the required wire and radio connections so that during the exercise the entire communications operation including the messengers proceeds as in a war. ” 34 To make the situation appear to the remaining battalions “ as in a war, ” recourse could be had to an old alliance between the film industry and the military. It should be recalled that the chief of the supreme army command, Erich Ludendorff, had already founded Universal-Film AG (UFA) in 1917 for propaganda and psychological warfare. The war game, however, made use not of film ’ s contents but of its production methods — indeed, so much so that the general of the signal corps, Praun, would use the word “ film ” as a synonym for “ war game ” : “ Mostly the director [of the war game] will have assembled his ‘ insertions ’in a sort of ‘ screenplay, ’according to which the film then proceeds. ” 35 “ Insertions ”are measures undertaken by the war game director during meticulous plans in the run-up to the game or at the same point through the deployment of intercept companies so as to confront the war game participants with exceptional situations on the one hand and optimize one ’ s own signals intelligence on the other hand. 36 The borrowings from film thereby serve a form of psychological warfare that is not directed against opponents but subjects one ’ s own battalions to stress tests: The staff must be occupied constantly in a warlike form, thus to some extent put under pressure. It is therefore the main art of the director to generate realistically the numerous “ frictions ”that occur continuously in war. The director must have prepared these well in the form of “ insertions. ”Among these are the abundance of reports that amass, especially during critical situations, false reports, “ rumors, ”outof-date orders and reports, deceptive communications, wishes of the neighbors, inquiries of higher-ranking command posts — these should rain down on the staff and force the participants day and night to make swift evaluations and discern the essential. Among the countless individual events of war are wire faults, unintelligible telegraphs and radio reports, decoding missions, prisoner interrogations, evaluation of aerial images, assessments of the enemy demanded by superior posts, supplying missions. A captured enemy map with writing in a foreign language can also perplex the responsible specialists. Such specialists, or individual commanders or a whole section of the staff can be completely or temporarily lost in the decisive moment, while the staff operation must continue as in a case of emergency ( Ernstfall). Such losses, caused by direct hits, paratroopers or partisans, then force the remaining staff to instructive assistance. 37

2022 Michigan Kritik
AT: Baudrillard › Cyberian Islands Case Neg › Cyber War Games Good

Data from cyber conflict modeling can be useful in research and development of new cyber defense technologies

Granasen et al 19 (November 2019, Granåsen, Magdalena, Swedish Defense Research Agency, Huskaj, Gazmend, Swedish Defense University, Varga, Stefan, Royal Institute of Technology, “Data Collection and Research in CDXs: Command and Control, Cyber Situational Awareness and Intelligence Perspectives on Cyber Defense,” 24th International Command and Control Research and Technology Symposium)

The results showed that the data collected for the case study of the Swedish blue team during LS19 is meaningful and of sufficient quality for further analysis within the three research themes. Some issues concerning the quality of data were raised in the results section. These and other issues are further discussed in the current section. Concerning data quality, it can be concluded that data loss in the collected data will not impair the ability to conduct the analyses needed in order to explore the research themes C2 , CSA and intelligence. Analysis of different data sources in conjunction will be necessary in order to make sense of the data. The language in chat logs was sparse, and although the researcher is acquainted with the terminology used in these logs, it does not make sense until correlated with other information such as observations or published threat reports. As the exercise was organized by the CCDCOE, the research team only had part control of the data. This is the reason why data on the progress of threat reporting, score and network overview (available services) was collected through screenshots. It will be a time-consuming task to manually transfer these screenshots to a format that can be further analyzed. Still, the research team assessed that a screenshot of the information was better than not having access to this information at all. Using a well-established CDX such as Locked Shields for research is cost-efficient in that the scenario and scenario injects (including a 70-person red team), set-up, gamenet (including support personnel), communication infrastructure, participant invitation, scoring system, exercise control personnel and a lot of the administration already are in place. Furthermore, Locked Shields has gained a reputation that attracts very proficient cyber security experts, while it is likely that these people would not feel equally attracted to participate in a pure research experiment. From a Swedish perspective, one of the greatest benefits of participation in LS19 was the ability to meet and work with people from other organizations. Research within an international CDX clearly entails lack of experimental control and reduced access to data for the researchers, as well as continuous adjustments to fit the data collection to the exercise schedule. However, it also entails highly motivated, skilled and competitive participants, and a far more complex exercise environment than a normal research project would be able to finance. The initial results from the surveys indicated that the exercise as a whole seemed to have progressed smoothly, with positive ratings of teamwork, information sharing and strategy, as well as cyber situational awareness. The high performance score further emphasizes the success of the team. It is therefore clear that the case studied is well suited for analysis of how a successful team develops its strategy and what functional structures for coordination in a cyber defence team may look like. The participation of the research team can also be viewed as a success story. The team was engaged from the very beginning of the preparatory phase of the exercise. In this way, the researchers were able to learn contextual factors, such as the team leadership view on issues such as strategy and coordination, which may have affected the final outcome of the exercise, that were not necessarily written down or documented in any other way. The researchers were given the opportunity to describe their initial planning, which included the aim to be as non-intrusive as possible. This means that the data collection did not include any "freezes" in the exercise in order to collect data, neither were there any plans to collect excessive unnecessary amounts of data (video recordings, key-logging or screenshots). The research team explained their measures to preserve the participants’ anonymity (if this was requested). The nature of the meetings, e.g., personal interactions between exercise participants and the research team contributed to mutual trust and confidence building. The cordial relationship between the researchers and the participants probably contributed to the high survey response rates and a benevolent attitude to answering the questions. Having three persons in the research team meant a high workload, and an appreciation for that every team activity would not be observed. It should be noted that there could be a limit as to how many researchers are feasible for data collection to reduce the 16 risk of collecting too much data, duplicates of data, or disturbing the observed team. The inclusion of CSA-related questions in the team’s ordinary reporting procedure provided a less intrusive method for collecting SA-related data than if a traditional probing measure such as SAGAT or SART had been used. There was no indication of that the inference of SA-related questions in the internal reporting template disturbed the sub-teams. The internal reporting template was designed and administered by the reporting team, and the sub-teams were not aware of that some of the questions in the internal reporting template were induced by the research team. The research team may have positively affected the SA and even the performance in the team, in that they directed the team’s attention towards issues useful to include in the threat reports as well as for the understanding of the threats. This is, however, a risk with all data collection. For instance, the presence of observers may affect the behavior of the team, and the questions in the start-up survey may direct the team’s focus towards the issues mentioned in the survey. For integrity reasons as well as risk of data overload, the research team made a deliberate decision to not to capture network activity. It is assessed that network activity logs would produce a lot of data of which only a small part would be useful. Subsequently, a great deal of analysis would be required, and there would probably not be a great deal of added value for the research themes. For the current paper, a pluralist methodology [31] was employed, where different types of data were collected in order to address the research themes from several perspectives. It needs to be acknowledged that some data will almost always suffer from some data loss (for instance surveys), while other data is more complete, but requiring quite a lot of analytic effort and needing to be combined with other data in order to interpret it (i.e. communication logs). Some data is based on subjective assessment (surveys, observations). However who is best suited to assess the workload, if not those who are experiencing it? The pluralist approach finds answers in combinations and comparisons of data. The dataset will suit the analysis within all three research themes, and the same data items may be combined and analyzed in different ways to correspond to research questions within different themes. 6. Summary and Conclusions The objective of this paper was to explore the possibilities to collect meaningful data for research on Command and Control (C2 ) Cyber Situational Awareness (CSA), and Intelligence in conjunction with an interorganizational cyber defense team during a cyber defense exercise. The purpose of the data collection was to explore the possibilities to conduct research within these research areas. A variety of carefully selected data collection methods specifically tailored to suit the needs for relevant data for our research fields of interest was employed. Our research has shown that a CDX indeed provided a good opportunity to collect pertinent data to analyze Command and Control, Cyber Situational Awareness and Intelligence related research questions. The trove of collected data will be used to write papers according to our research themes. The working titles of some future papers in the works are: i) Exploring the development of coordination structures and strategy in a cyber defense team, ii) Acquiring Cyber Situational Awareness in a cyber defense team, and iii) Intelligence in support of a defensive cyberspace operation. The results obtained in this paper is further expected to be useful for refining data collection methods for CDXs.

2022 Michigan Kritik
AT: Baudrillard › Cyberian Islands Case Neg › Cyber War Games Good

Cyber Defense Exercises (CDX) are an effective tool to evaluate the effectiveness of defense systems and protect infrastructure

Seker & Seker 20 (Seker, Ensar, and Kamile Nur Seker, Nato Researcher and Cyber Security Expert. "Cyber Defense Exercises (CDXs) as a Testbed for Cyber Security Assessments. June 2020)

CDXs are suitable platforms to test the IT and OT systems to be able to create better cyber security and cyber defense solutions. In this chapter, we will take a closer look to Locked Shields CDX to analyze how cyber exercises can be used as testbed environments. Lesson learned sections and evaluation of the exercise by all participants, can give ideas to cyber experts to improve and strengthen their security. So, it’s fair to say that CDXs can serve as excellent testbeds. Cyber experts from different fields who participate CDX can share their knowledge and experience each other via these exercises. Figure 3 shows a model for CDXs as a testbed.Locked Shields (LS) cyber defense exercise is organized annually by the NATO Cooperative Cyber Defense Centre of Excellence (NATO CCD COE). It’s accepted by the authorities that Locked Shields is the world's largest, most complex and technologically advanced cyber defense exercise. In Locked Shields, blue teams are created by the NATO member nations or NATO allied nations. So, it is an international cyber exercise in state level. Locked Shields could be a good example to show how CDX can be used as testbed. Figure 4, 5, 6 shows some statistics about LS CDX. Based on Figure 4, while there were 9 blue teams in 2012 LS CDX, the number was increased to 22 in 2018. In Figure 6, the number of participants to LS CDX also growth (250, 250, 300, 400, 550, 800, 1000 respectively) in same period. This means LS CDX was able to attract more nations and more cyber experts every year. According to Figure 5, numbers of virtual machines were increased dramatically from 25 to 4000 in 6 years. It means LS CDX is getting more advance and complicated each year. More than 1000 cybersecurity experts from around the world have been involved in the 2018 Locked Shields exercise and the national teams of 21 countries have participated as blue teams. The exercise involved around 4000 virtualized systems and more than 2500 attacks by the red team. LS CDX follows a successful route to adopting information technology (IT) and operational technology (OT) systems. The organizers of LS CDX succeeded in providing an interesting and complex environment for the blue teams to defend these against an intensive attack campaign. While blue teams can put their skills to test, they can also analyze and test new technologies in a safe and secure environment. In the context of LS13, the following areas were most challenging for the blue teams: Defending web applications. Detecting custom malicious code. Mitigating BGP hijacking attacks. Initiating efficient information sharing. In LS14, the most challenging areas are for blue teams: Filtering and detecting malicious traffic over IPv6. Monitoring for malicious WAN route changes and preventing BGP hijacking/man-in-the-middle. Protecting custom web applications. Finding pre-planted malicious programs and coping with RT‟s Anti-Virus evasion techniques (publicly available free tools were in most cases enough to evade AV solutions). Sharing actionable information with other blue teams. In 2015, new attack vectors included ICS/SCADA systems and Windows 8 and 10 operating systems, as well as an element of active defense. In 2017 the blue teams were tasked to maintain the services and networks of a military air base of a fictional country, which, according to the exercise scenario, experienced severe attacks on its electric power grid system, unmanned aerial vehicles, military command and control systems, critical information infrastructure components and other operational infrastructure. The size and scope of technologies, networks and devices used in Locked Shields 2017 has increased considerably – leading to more attacks and specialized systems involved. Specialized systems enable teams to practice the defense of systems that they are not working with on a regular basis. However, in the modern threat landscape incidents with specialized systems may potentially have a profound effect on a military mission or the entire society. In 2018, the attacks cause severe disruptions in the operation of the electric power grid, 4G public safety networks, drone operation and other critical infrastructure components. While the aim of the tech game is to maintain the operation of various systems under intense pressure, the strategic part should serve as a forum to understand the impact of decisions made at the strategic and policy level. When we analyze LS CDX, based on the statistics and After Action Reports (ARR), it can be said that, the exercise improved itself during the years and created a suitable testbed platform for cyber experts. Via this platform, professionals and decision makers in cyber were able to share their knowledge and experience with each other and test their defense skills and strategies against new technologies and new attacks. For future studies, a technical tool will be developed on the scoring system, which is a problematic issue for CDXs, and on the standardization of this system and the development of a fairer system. The integration of new technologies such as power grid systems and drone control systems into CDXs is a critical issue. With the integration of these special systems into the exercises, the existing problems and the methods to be followed are another work to be done in the future. The importance of defense exercises is increasing day by day. It would be possible for countries to be involved in the global cyber defense exercises in the international arena, spreading the development and implementation of their own CDX platforms on a national basis, and allocating higher budget figures to the planning and development of these exercises could contribute to achieving beneficial outcomes in the future to create stronger cyber defense systems. The emphasis on these exercises on the national and 18 international scene will provide benefits in terms of uncovering the vulnerabilities in the area of the cyberspace, as well as the revitalization of the cyber defense awareness, and also the integrated technologies that can be followed in exercises related to the cyber defense.

2022 Michigan Kritik
AT: Baudrillard › Cyberian Islands Case Neg › Crimsonia = Russia and China

Crimsonia is intended as a stand in for Russia AND China.

Martin 21(Alexander Martin, Journalist of numerous journals focusing on technology based publications, April 13th 2021, Nato Prepares for world’s larget Cyber War game-with focus on grey zone, Sky News, https://news.sky.com/story/nato-prepares-for-worlds-largest-cyber-war-game-with-focus-on-grey-zone-12274488)

How does it work? Organised by the NATO Cooperative Cyber Defence Centre of Excellence (CCDCOE) based in Tallinn, Estonia, the Locked Shields exercise is an annual network defence drill using real-world skills. The scenario is based on an attack on the fictional country of Berylia - hypothetically situated in the northern Atlantic - and an adversary called Crimsonia that is creating some artificial islands. Although the adversary is not mapped to a specific NATO adversary, Crimsonia has traits of both Russia and China in its ambitions and conduct. The idea is to test multiple teams' skills just as they would be tested if they were forced to remotely come to the aid of NATO ally Berylia as it is targeted by "a sophisticated and intense series of cyber attacks".

2022 Michigan Kritik
AT: Baudrillard › Cyberian Islands Case Neg › Crimsonia = Russia

NATO’s cyberwar games clearly intend for Crimsonia to resemble Russia.

Senker 16(Cath Senker, Cath Senker is a writer of non-fiction for children on diverse subjects such as history, world religions, and the environment. In 2018, she won the Educational Writers' Award, 12 September 2016, Cyber Crime and the Dark Net: Revealing the hidden underworld of the internet)

The imaginary country Berylia (rather similar to Estonia) has been hit by a cyber assault on its drone manufacturer. The anonymous attackers are probably linked to Berylia’s enemy Crimsonia (very like Russia). They seek the laters cyber.

More evidence.

2022 Michigan Negative
The Digital Cyclops Negative --- BFHR › FW Supplement › at: neuro k

Prefer neuroscience---it refines social theories rather than rejecting them, but their dismissal forecloses causal analysis of biological variables

Serrat 10 [Olivier Serrat, Doctoral Student at The Chicago School of Professional Psychology at Washington DC. A Primer on Social Neuroscience. August 2010. https://www.adb.org/sites/default/files/publication/27625/primer-social-neuroscience.pdf]

Human history is not only social history but also neurobiological history. Throughout most of the 20th century, social and biological explanations were widely viewed as incompatible. However, from the 1990s, the emergence of social neuroscience6 vindicates Aristotle’s pioneering deductions. The young science accepts that the brain is a single, pivotal component of an undeniably social species and that it is orderly in its complexity. It treats the human brain as a social organ, whose physiological and neurological reactions are directly and profoundly shaped by social interaction. (To a mammal, being socially connected to caregivers is indispensable for survival: this, incidentally, suggests that Abraham Maslow’s hierarchy of needs might need to be revised to ascribe more weight to social needs, e.g., love and belonging, and esteem, in relation to self-actualization.) Nondualistic and nonreductionistic, social neuroscience, through a multilevel and integrative approach, aims to understand the role of the central nervous system in the formation and maintenance of social behaviors and processes. Spanning the social and biological domains, e.g., molecular, cellular, system, person, relational, collective, and societal, it exploits biological concepts and neurobiological techniques such as functional magnetic resonance imaging7 —which measures patterns of blood oxygenation responses in the brain as a subject engages in a particular task, to inform and refine theories of social behavior. In short, it focuses on how the brain mediates social interaction.8 (Brain scans captured through functional magnetic resonance imaging show that the same areas are associated with distress, be that caused by social rejection or by physical pain.) Arguably, the potential benefits of social neuroscience are that it can inform debates in social psychology, provide tools for measuring brain–body activity directly and unobtrusively and provide information that would be impossible to assess using other techniques, and permit the examination of social processes by pointing to the importance of social variables (from context to culture) in altering processes within the brain and body.

2022 Michigan Negative
The Digital Cyclops Negative --- BFHR › FW Supplement › at: science k

Our 1nc evidence is a defense of rigor and vetting ideas---science isn’t a search for capital T truths, but if it is, only our interp solves through humility

Hilton 14 [Elise Hilton, Communications Specialist at Acton Institute. M.A. in World Religions. ‘Science:’ You Use The Word, But It Doesn’t Mean What You Think It Means. September 23, 2014. https://blog.acton.org/archives/72707-science-use-word-doesnt-mean-think-means.html]

Pascal-Emmanuel Gobry wants to clear a few things up regarding “science.” First, he wants to make sure that we have the definition correct.

Science is the process through which we derive reliable predictive rules through controlled experimentation. That’s the science that gives us airplanes and flu vaccines and the Internet. But what almost everyone means when he or she says “science” is something different.