Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Evidence
Heg Bad › 1NC – Impact – Generic

Authoritarianism rises as a result of US hegemonic policies

Stephen M. Walt, 20 (4/21/20; Professor of international relations at Harvard University, PhD in Political Science; “There’s No Such Thing as Good Liberal Hegemony”; Foreign Policy ) //LVL

That the first attempt was a costly failure should be beyond dispute. Instead of advancing, democracy has been in retreat around the world for more than a decade—including in the United States itself—and U.S.-led efforts at regime change have led not to thriving democracies but to failed states and costly occupations. Hyperglobalization under U.S. auspices produced a grave financial crisis in 2008, politically painful job displacement in a number of sectors, and helped trigger a wide-ranging populist backlash. NATO enlargement helped poison relations with Russia, and policies such as dual containment in the Persian Gulf inspired anti-U.S. terrorism, including the 9/11 attacks and all the negative consequences that flowed from that event. The end result of these developments has been a partial retreat from globalization, the emergence of would-be autocrats in Hungary, Poland, and even in the United States, and revitalized authoritarianism in many other places. Given where we are today, does it matter whether a more sophisticated version of liberal hegemony might have succeeded? In fact, this issue is of paramount importance, because plenty of people are still convinced that trying to create a U.S.-led, liberal world order was the right goal and that the United States just needs to learn from past mistakes and do it better and smarter in the future. Defenders include unrepentant hawks such as Eric Edelman and Ray Takeyh, who think what the Middle East needs is even more U.S.-led regime change, but also liberal academics such as G. John Ikenberry and Daniel Deudney, who believe the liberal order remains surprisingly resilient. Other proponents of this view are dedicated policy wonks such as Jake Sullivan, who thinks the problem is not the United States’ basic strategy but rather the fact that Americans are increasingly skeptical of it, and one sees similar impulses in the writings of Hal Brands, Peter Feaver, and other defenders of an expansive U.S. role. If former U.S. Vice President Joe Biden wins the presidential election in November—and, to be clear, I hope he does—the apostles of U.S. primacy and its “indispensable” global role will be back in the saddle, and we are likely to see at least a partial attempt to turn the clock back to the halcyon days when the United States was actively trying to create a global liberal order.

2022 Michigan Evidence
Heg Good › 1AR – Sustainability – AT: Polarization/Domestic Divisions

Internal problems don’t preclude US leadership, and retrenching wouldn’t solve them.

Hal Brands 21, Bloomberg Opinion columnist, the Henry Kissinger Distinguished Professor at Johns Hopkins University’s School of Advanced International Studies, and a scholar at the American Enterprise Institute, 1/9/2021, "Turning Its Back on the World Won’t Help America Heal", Bloomberg, https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2021-01-09/trump-fueled-u-s-dysfunction-won-t-be-cured-by-isolationist-foreign-policy

The severity of the U.S. predicament has led some analysts to the conclusion that Washington must dial back its global ambitions until it conquers its internal demons. As Emma Ashford put it in Foreign Policy, “Ambitious foreign-policy goals are completely out of step with the realities of the country’s domestic political and economic dysfunction.”

That’s misguided. No true U.S. ally is advocating that Washington turn its back on the world (although many presumably worry about it), and for good reason. It’s not as though the need for American engagement has become any less pressing: As we have seen during Covid-19, the likely alternatives to constructive U.S. leadership are a breakdown of international cooperation on pandemics and other issues and a vacuum that less principled, less democratic actors such as China will fill.

2022 Michigan Evidence
Heg Good › 1AR – Sustainability – AT: Debt

Financial reasons for unsustainability are wrong.

Carla Norrlof 16, Ph.D. in IR, Discipline Representative of Political Science at the University of Toronto; and William Wohlforth, Ph.D. in Political Science, Daniel Webster Professor of Government in the Dartmouth College Department of Government, 2016, “Is US grand strategy self-defeating? Deep engagement, military spending and sovereign debt;” Conflict Management and Peace Science, Vol. 36, No. 3,

Retrenchment proponents see American military spending as contributing to the growth of public debt3 and the country’s relative economic decline, and they argue that as it approaches its credit limit, the US should cut military spending and act preemptively to forestall steeper decline and even bankruptcy. Some retrenchment supporters also fear that negative feedback between military overstretch and economic decline will eventually put America’s coercive hegemony at risk because economic might is the wellspring of military might (Calleo, 1982; Chace, 1981; Kennedy, 1987a, 1987b; MacDonald and Parent, 2011). In short, retrenchment proponents agree that reducing military spending is an economic necessity, although they disagree about the extent to which the US should reduce its spending and overseas presence as well as the desirability of sustaining military primacy.

This argument is noteworthy not only because of its centrality to the retrenchment argument, but also because academic defenders of deep engagement have as yet no direct response. Scholars and policymakers who oppose retrenchment maintain that American military dominance has produced significant economic benefits and warn that reductions in military spending will reduce these benefits (Brooks, et al., 2013; Brooks and Wohlforth, 2016; Gottlieb, 2012; Kagan, 2012; Sestanovich, 2014). Three main arguments point to such benefits. First, according to a research program closely connected with the work of Robert Gilpin and Stephen Krasner, military power underwrites an open economic order. In a series of books, Gilpin and Krasner explain the logic and evidence for hegemonic orders that rest in part on an outsized global military role (Gilpin, 1975; Gilpin, 1981, 1987, 2001; Krasner, 1978). A dominant military power that equates its own interest with expanding economic globalization benefits from providing a stable political context that makes economic exchange more secure and predictable (Brooks, et al., 2013; Brooks and Wohlforth, 2016; Norrlof, 2008, 2010).

2022 Michigan Evidence
Heg Good › 2AC – No Thucydides Trap

Mearsheimer agrees

Michael Mousseau, 19 (Professor in the School of Politics, Security, and International Affairs at the University of Central Florida, PhD from Binghamton University; “The End of War: How a Robust Marketplace and Liberal Hegemony Are Leading to perpetual World Peace”; International Security 2019; 44 (1): 160–196. doi: ) //LVL

Because economic power is central to military power, realist theory rejects the idea that states can be unconcerned with relative gains. Many influential scholars of power politics recognize, however, that factors other than relative power can inform states about whether another state is a threat. Arguably, the behavior of a state says more about whether it is a threat than do its economic and military capabilities. Even John Mearsheimer, considered to be the first theorist to postulate “offensive” realism, has asserted that “the prospects for cooperation among market democracies are ‘excellent.’

2022 Michigan Evidence
Heg Good › 2AC – No Thucydides Trap

No Thucydides Trap – Economic competition fosters peace

Michael Mousseau, 19 (Professor in the School of Politics, Security, and International Affairs at the University of Central Florida, PhD from Binghamton University; “The End of War: How a Robust Marketplace and Liberal Hegemony Are Leading to perpetual World Peace”; International Security 2019; 44 (1): 160–196. doi: ) //LVL

This article argues that there is no Thucydides Trap in international politics. Rather, the world is moving rapidly toward permanent peace, possibly in our lifetime. Drawing on economic norms theory, I show that what sometimes appears to be a Thucydides Trap may instead be a function of factors strictly internal to states and that these factors vary among them. In brief, leaders of states with advanced market-oriented economies have foremost interests in the principle of self-determination for all states, large and small, as the foundation for a robust global marketplace. War among these states, even making preparations for war, is not possible, because they are in a natural alliance to preserve and protect the global order. In contrast, leaders of states with weak internal markets have little interest in the global marketplace; they pursue wealth not through commerce, but through wars of expansion and demands for tribute. For these states, power equals threat, and therefore they tend to balance against the power of all states. Fearing stronger states, however, minor powers with weak internal markets tend to constrain their expansionist inclinations and, for security reasons, bandwagon with the relatively benign market-oriented powers. I argue that this liberal global hierarchy is unwittingly but systematically buttressing states’ embrace of market norms and values that, if left uninterrupted, is likely to culminate in permanent world peace, perhaps even something close to harmony. My argument challenges the realist assertion that great powers are engaged in a timeless competition over global leadership, because hegemony cannot exist among great powers with weak markets; these inherently expansionist states live in constant fear and therefore normally balance against the strongest state and its allies. Hegemony can exist only among market-oriented powers, because only they care about global order. Yet, there can be no competition for leadership among market powers, because they always agree with the goal of their strongest member (currently the United States) to preserve and protect the global order based on the principle of self-determination. If another commercial power, such as a rising China, were to overtake the United States, the world would take little notice, because the new leading power would largely agree with the global rules promoted and enforced by its predecessor. Vladimir Putin’s Russia, on the other hand, seeks to create chaos around the world. Most other powers, having market-oriented economies, continue to abide by the hegemony of the United States despite its relative economic decline since the end of World War II.

2022 Michigan Evidence
Heg Good › 2AC – Impact – Solves War

American hegemony can coordinate capabilities and protect security in the cyber domain

Joshua Rovner and Tyler Moore, 17 (8/14/17; Rovner is a Professor of International Politics and National Security at Southern Methodist University; Moore is a Professor of Cyber Security and Information Assurance in the School of Cyber Studies and the Tandy School of Computer Science at the University of Tulsa, PhD in Cyber Studies; “Does the Internet Need a Hegemon?”; Journal of Global Security Studies, Volume 2, Issue 3, July 2017, Pages 184–203, ) //LVL

The clash of national and global interests in cyberspace is particularly acute because there is no global government to resolve disputes. Sustaining cooperation under anarchy is an enduring puzzle for international relations theorists and animates some of the most enduring debates in political science. Realist scholars view the international system as prone to conflict because there is no higher authority that can enforce agreements among states (Waltz 1979). Liberal theorists, however, posit that international institutions can foster cooperation in part by reducing transaction costs (Keohane 1984). Extensions of this debate, including arguments about the value of institutions, are discussed below. But perhaps the most controversial argument focuses on the role of a hegemon, or a clearly dominant state, in the international system. Hegemonic stability theory (HST) posits that peace and prosperity are more likely when there is a clear hierarchy of states and one undisputed leader. A state with dominant capabilities can sustain cooperation by providing public goods and reducing collective action problems. Incentives to cheat on agreements or free ride are reduced when the hegemon picks up the tab. Hegemons also help coordinate action and deter challengers from threatening the global order.

2022 Michigan Evidence
Heg Good › 2AC – Impact – Solves War

Global economic interdependence stifles hegemonic war

Michael Mousseau, 19 (Professor in the School of Politics, Security, and International Affairs at the University of Central Florida, PhD from Binghamton University; “The End of War: How a Robust Marketplace and Liberal Hegemony Are Leading to perpetual World Peace”; International Security 2019; 44 (1): 160–196. doi: ) //LVL

Hegemonic realist theories largely predict never-ending cycles of global war and peace, caused principally by varying rates of economic growth among leading powers that trigger relative gains concerns and yield opportunities for rising powers to assert control and change the rules of the global order. This section identifies four core reasons why hegemonic war, defined as a clash over global leadership, is not only unlikely in the future, but probably never happened in the past. First, if internal factors determine national interests, as I argue, then hegemony cannot exist among status major powers. Preferring disorder wherever they lack control, status powers simply are unconcerned with global rules, and thus have no interest in fighting over them. Motivated foremost to make others their subordinates and avoid being the subordinate of others, status major powers have nothing to gain and everything to lose in acquiescing to stronger states, and therefore usually balance against them. Second, status states cannot reach the level of economic productivity per capita of contractualist states, and thus it is unlikely that any status power could overtake the combined might of the contractualist hegemony. Fortune may occasionally bestow wealth on a status or axial economy, as it did on the antebellum South, which sold cotton and tobacco in global markets, and as it does on oil-rich states today. But wealth is not economic productivity, so such states are ultimately dependent on the contractualist hegemony and can never seriously challenge it. This explains why the South lost the Civil War. The third reason why hegemonic war resulting from changes in relative economic power is unlikely follows from the second reason: in all likelihood, only another contractualist state can surpass the market leader in economic size; and as discussed, no rising contractualist power would ever challenge a declining one. Contractualist states are uninterested in relative power (unless a state is behaving in a threatening manner), and among them, there are no substantial changes in global rules to fight about. Fourth, even if one were to suppose that a rising contractualist power wanted to be dominant among all contractual states, such a power shift cannot happen, because these states’ economies cannot substantially rise and fall relative to one another. As a result of their shared economic type and preferences for normal trade, their economies have largely converged.

2022 Michigan Evidence
Heg Good › 2AC – Impact – LIO

US hegemony is strong now but shrinking US engagement outweighs the costs of sustaining it – rising authoritarian powers, economic collapse, LIO collapse

Daalder and Kagan, 16 (4/25/16; Ivo H. Daalder is President of the Chicago Council on Global Affairs, has a PhD in Political Science from Massachusetts Institute of Technology; Robert Kagan is a Senior Fellow with the Project on International Order and Strategy in the Foreign Policy program at Brookings, has a PhD in American History from American University; “The U.S. can’t afford to end its global leadership role”; Brookings ) //LVL

The economic, political and security strategy that the United States has pursued for more than seven decades, under Democratic and Republican administrations alike, is today widely questioned by large segments of the American public and is under attack by leading political candidates in both parties. Many Americans no longer seem to value the liberal international order that the United States created after World War II and sustained throughout the Cold War and beyond. Or perhaps they take it for granted and have lost sight of the essential role the United States plays in supporting the international environment from which they benefit greatly. The unprecedented prosperity made possible by free and open markets and thriving international trade; the spread of democracy; and the avoidance of major conflict among great powers: All these remarkable accomplishments have depended on sustained U.S. engagement around the world. Yet politicians in both parties dangle before the public the vision of an America freed from the burdens of leadership. What these politicians don’t say, perhaps because they don’t understand it themselves, is that the price of ending our engagement would far outweigh its costs. The international order created by the United States today faces challenges greater than at any time since the height of the Cold War. Rising authoritarian powers in Asia and Europe threaten to undermine the security structures that have kept the peace since World War II. Russia invaded Ukraine and has seized some of its territory. In East Asia, an increasingly aggressive China seeks to control the sea lanes through which a large share of global commerce flows. In the Middle East, Iran pursues hegemony by supporting Hezbollah and Hamas and the bloody tyranny in Syria. The Islamic State controls more territory than any terrorist group in history, brutally imposing its extreme vision of Islam and striking at targets throughout the Middle East, North Africa and Europe. None of these threats will simply go away. Nor will the United States be spared if the international order collapses, as it did twice in the 20th century. In the 21st century, oceans provide no security. Nor do walls along borders. Nor would cutting off the United States from the international economy by trashing trade agreements and erecting barriers to commerce. Instead of following the irresponsible counsel of demagogues, we need to restore a bipartisan foreign policy consensus around renewing U.S. global leadership. Despite predictions of a “post-American world,” U.S. capacities remain considerable. The U.S. economy remains the most dynamic in the world. The widely touted “rise of the rest”—the idea that the United States was being overtaken by the economies of Brazil, Russia, India and China—has proved to be a myth. The dollar remains the world’s reserve currency, and people across the globe seek U.S. investment and entrepreneurial skills to help their flagging economies. U.S. institutions of higher learning remain the world’s best and attract students from every corner of the globe. The political values that the United States stands for remain potent forces for change. Even at a time of resurgent autocracy, popular demands for greater freedom can be heard in Russia, China, Iran and elsewhere, and those peoples look to the United States for support, both moral and material. And our strategic position remains strong. The United States has more than 50 allies and partners around the world. Russia and China between them have no more than a handful.

2022 Michigan Evidence

RWG – AI Module Updates

We’re developing AI now and have passed the point of no return—extinction

Sean Martin, 11-3-2017, "Humanity’s days are NUMBERED and AI will cause mass extinction, warns Stephen Hawking," Express.co.uk, https://www.express.co.uk/news/science/875084/Stephen-Hawking-AI-destroy-humanity-end-of-the-world-artificial-intelligence

Professor Hawking has once again reiterated his claims manhumankind will inevitably fail, and says that our time on Earth is now numbered after we passed the point of “no return”. The theoretical physicist says that developments in AI have been so great that the machines will one day be more dominant than human beings. He told Wired Magazine: "I fear that AI may replace humans altogether. If people design computer viruses, someone will design AI that improves and replicates itself. “This will be a new form of life that outperforms humans.”

2022 Michigan Evidence

RWG – War inevitable

War is inevitable—-BUT, the longer we wait, the worse it gets.

Baum and Barrett ’18 (Seth D. Baum and Anthony M. Barrett, A Model For The Impacts Of Nuclear War. Global Catastrophic Risk Institute Working Paper 18-2) stowPCB

On the other end of the spectrum, the norm could be weaker. The Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombings provided a vivid and enduring image of the horrors of nuclear war—hence the norm can reasonably be described as a legacy of the bombings. Without this image, there would be less to motivate the norm. A weaker norm could in turn have led to a nuclear war occurring later, especially during a near-miss event like the Cuban missile crisis. A later nuclear war would likely be much more severe, assuming some significant buildup of nuclear arsenals and especially if “overkill” targeting was used. A new nuclear war could bring a similarly wide range of shifts in nuclear weapons norms. It could strengthen the norm, hastening nuclear disarmament. Already, there is a political initiative drawing attention to the humanitarian consequences of nuclear weapons use in order to promote a new treaty to ban nuclear weapons as a step towards complete nuclear disarmament (Borrie 2014). It is easy to imagine this initiative using any new nuclear attacks to advance their goals. Alternatively, it could weaken the norm, potentially leading to more and/or larger nuclear wars. This is a common concern, as seen for example in debates over low-yield bunker buster nuclear weapons (Nelson 2003). Given that the impacts of a large nuclear war could be extremely severe, a shift in nuclear weapons norms could easily be the single most consequential effect of a smaller nuclear war. Norms about nuclear power can also be highly consequential. Fear of ionizing radiation from nuclear power inflates public concern about nuclear power relative to the actual medical risk (e.g., Slovic 2012). Some of this fear appears to derive from perceptions of nuclear weapons, especially Hiroshima and Nagasaki (e.g., Cwikel 1997). A new nuclear attack could strengthen general fears of nuclear radiation, further reducing support for nuclear power. Reduced support for nuclear power can in turn have major consequences to energy systems and the environment. Energy analysts are divided on the details, with some warning that increased use of fossil fuels.

2022 Michigan Evidence

RWG – AT: Space Col

At best, colonization takes centuries – at worst, it causes conflict.

Deudney ’20 [Daniel; Associate Professor of Political Science at Johns Hopkins University, PhD in political science from Princeton University, MPA in science, technology, and public policy from George Washington University; March 2020; “Chapter 10: Solar Space, Island Earth, and the Ends of Humanity”; Dark Skies: Space Expansionism, Planetary Geopolitics, and the Ends of Humanity; Kindle; TV] *Edited in brackets for ableist language.

A crucial additional parameter of this scenario is temporal: How much time will be required to realize these steps? Optimistic expansion timetables presuppose large and sustained investments in space, which are unlikely. 5 But it seems plausible that these steps might be accomplished over several centuries. However, this schedule assumes that the Earth will be willing and able to provide significant initial support for colonization. The question of how rapidly self-sufficient colonies could be established has direct implications for their ability to serve as hedges to terrestrial catastrophic and existential threats.

2022 Michigan Evidence

RWG – Climate !

Climate change causes extinction and turns every impact---no defense other models lie and don’t begin to comprehend the threat

Wallace-Wells 17, 7-9-2017, David Wallace-Wells is an American journalist known for his writings on climate change. He wrote the 2017 essay "The Uninhabitable Earth;""When Will the Planet Be Too Hot for Humans? Much, Much Sooner Than You Imagine.," https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2017/07/climate-change-earth-too-hot-for-humans.html

I. ‘Doomsday’

2022 Michigan Evidence

RWG – Mindset Shift + no ext!

Nuclear war causes a mindset shift that causes the restructuring of society.

Madrigal 18 ( Alexis C; staff writer at The Atlantic and the author of Powering the Dream: The History and Promise of Green Technology; “The People Who Would Survive Nuclear War”; The Atlantic; Jan 25; ; Accessed 10/10/19, EB)

In the last scenario, the authors propose that there would be some structure to the days and months after the war. There’d be the first few days when people were seeking shelter and trying to deal with what had happened, however, the report predicts, “boredom will gradually replace panic, but will be no easier to cope with.” Then there would be the “shelter period” followed by the “recuperation period.” “Major changes should be anticipated in the societal structure as survivors attempt to adapt to a severe and desponding environment never before experienced,” the report states. “The loss of 100 million people, mostly in the larger cities, could raise a question on the advisability of rebuilding the cities ... The surviving population could seek to alter the social and geopolitical structure of the rebuilding nation in hopes of minimizing the effects of any future conflicts.”

2022 Michigan Evidence

RWG – AT: Ukraine

Ukraine guarantees HEMPs

Paul Bedard 22, 2-24-2022, "Russia threatens power grids if Biden moves in Ukraine," Washington Examiner, //barn

In a new alert, Peter Vincent Pry, the executive director of the EMP Task Force on National and Homeland Security, said concerns are growing that Russia, North Korea, and Iran are inching closer to testing an electromagnetic attack on the U.S. grid, or parts of it. He noted the current crisis in Ukraine could spark a Russian attack, and he cited state media making the threat in the past. “In April 2021, during the previous big crisis between Russia versus the U.S. and NATO over Ukraine, Moscow’s state-run TV broadcast to the world that: ‘War is inevitable…it will be a Cyber War,’” Pry said in his note, shown below. He said Florida has been threatened “to deter the U.S. from helping Ukraine.”

2022 Michigan Evidence

RWG – AT: HEMPs Ignore MAD

HEMPs ignore MAD

Broughel 22, 4-21-2022, James Broughel is a senior research fellow at the Mercatus Center "Cascading Risks: The U.S. Is Vulnerable To An Electromagnetic Pulse Attack," //barn-parks

Of further concern is that with EMP warfare, there is a strong incentive to attack first. Because the initial blow can be crippling, the first striker has a huge advantage. This makes EMP strategy more like cyber warfare than Cold War nuclear strategy. During the Cold War, the U.S. and U.S.S.R. relied on the principle of mutual assured destruction. Neither was reckless enough to launch a nuclear attack on the other because it would result in a devastating counterattack. This logic may not work with EMP attacks if the initial strike is sufficiently ruinous.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
democracy qpq cp – at: russia backlash › 2nc – at: russia backlash

Countering democratic backsliding within the alliance is a prerequisite to effective deterrence

Eisen & Kirchick 18 – Norman Eisen, senior fellow in governance studies at the Brookings Institution, J.D. cum laude from Harvard University, A.B. magna cum laude from Brown University; James Kirchick, visiting fellow in the Center on the United States and Europe Project on International Order and Strategy at the Brookings Institution, columnist for The Tablet (“Yes, Russia is a threat to NATO. So are the alliance’s anti-democratic members”, 7/14/2018, ) FGY

As Western leaders gather in Brussels this week for their annual NATO summit, the Atlantic alliance faces a daunting set of challenges: Middle East instability, an ongoing mission in Afghanistan and, above all, a resurgent Russia, which has overturned Europe’s security order in Ukraine, used chemical nerve agents on British soil, and continues to deploy instruments of hybrid warfare against the United States and other alliance members. President Trump’s repeated suggestions that NATO is “obsolete” and freeloading on American largesse risk damping public support for the alliance that rushed to America’s aid after 9/11. These threats are paramount. Often overlooked, however, is the threat from within: NATO member governments gradually undermining their own democratic institutions, unraveling the common tie between members of an alliance “founded on the principles of democracy, individual liberty and the rule of law,” and thereby undercutting it as an effective guarantor of the “freedom and security of all its members.”

Yes, NATO must continue to deter its external adversaries—principally Russia. But democratic regression among its own members makes that task more difficult.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
democracy qpq cp – at: russia backlash › 2nc – at: russia backlash

Aggression is broadly inevitable but the counterplan’s the best chance that NATO has at deterring Russia

Ackerman 22 – Sterling Professor of Law and Political Science at Yale, Leading Global Thinker by Foreign Policy magazine, Honorary Doctorate from the University of Trieste in Italy, LL.B. from Yale Law School, B.A. from Harvard University (“How to Reinvigorate NATO and Deter Putin’s Aggression”, 5/17/2022, ) FGY

As Vladimir Putin made clear in his recent Victory Day speech, the war in Ukraine will grind on for years. Even if Russia ultimately retreats, this won’t lead to a lasting peace. During the Cold War, Western Europe could confidently rely on American military power to deter Soviet aggression. This is no longer true. And Putin and his successors will continue to exploit this fact — unless and until NATO decisively reorganizes itself.

The United States and Europe are understandably wary of engaging in direct conflict with Russia, but they can still do more than provide short-term assistance to Ukraine. Now is the time to start taking steps to establish NATO as a credible force for the defense of Western democracy in the 21st century. Bold measures are required, including dramatically revising the NATO treaty, raising an army in Europe and even expelling countries who have betrayed their democratic commitments. But it’s the best way to deter the Kremlin and ultimately avoid more brutal wars in the future.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
The Digital Cyclops Affirmative --- BFHR › Kritiks › 2AC---AT: Silence

Even if they win we are loud politics, we still solve -- their author agrees

Kaura-aho 21 (Katariina Kaura-aho - doctoral candidate in the Faculty of Law at the University of Helsinki, “The aesthetics of political resistance: On silent politics”, Thesis Eleven 65, 2021, ,)//guyB

When politically marginalised refugees set out to resist their unequal position in a particular political context, they often organise their protests in a loud, vocal manner. By expressing their resistance through loud outcries of dissent, refugees attempt to make their political claims for equality heard as clearly and as widely as possible. These kinds of protests can sometimes be effective in gaining public attention. Occasionally, however, refugees organise protests without recourse to loud vocality. Sometimes egalitarian refugee protests emerge in a mode that can be characterised as silent action. In silent political action, refugees express their resistance in a non-verbal, embodied way. Refugee activists’ bodies communicate politically in silent acts of resistance. Silent politics often emerges in restricted, prisonlike conditions, such as detention centres where the persons confined within these places do not have access to public spaces where they could organise loud, vocal protests. Sometimes, however, refugees who succeed in entering a public space enact their protest in the silent mode.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
The Digital Cyclops Affirmative --- BFHR › Kritiks › 1AR---AT: Settler Colonialism

We explain the reasons behind settler colonialism better and anything that doesn’t affect the will to technology first fails

Chew 15 (May Chew - Assistant Professor at the Mel Hoppenheim School of Cinema and Department of Art History at Concordia University, “BECKONING BODIES, MAKING SUBJECTS: INTERACTIVE AND IMMERSIVE TECHNOLOGIES IN CANADIAN MUSEUMS, 1967-2014”, Queen’s University, 2015, , MG)

While the preceding section considered the ways in which technology shapes both external and internal landscapes, what follows is an attempt to examine more extensively the generative capacity of technology to (re)produce bodies within the folds of nation, and the role of technology in situating us in an historical narrative through rhetorics of seduction. Not only is technology interjected into our affective, imaginative relationships with nation, but it in fact plays a primary role in generating and conducting these relationships in the first place. Integral to this inquiry is an examination of how, emboldened by origin myths centering on the confrontation of nature with technological prowess, Canadians carry forth the embodiment and reproduction of the will to technology.

A few years before Chief Dan George's delivered his indictment of the colonial state during its one hundredth birthday, another George had already sounded his ominous "lament." George Grant's Lament for a Nation, published in 1965, centred on what the philosopher saw as the inevitable casualties strewn across the path towards unbridled technological advancement. In his famous treatise, Grant mourns the sundering of ties to the European tradition of contemplation inherited from the Greeks, and condemns what he observes to be the willing surrender of Canadian sovereignty and keen embroilment in America’s imperial injustices in Vietnam. The technological imperative, against which Grant warned, springs from the "crucible of pioneering of Protestant liberalism" that produced "those uncomptemplative, and unflinching wills" which in turn become the driving force of a technological society (Technology 25). The wellspring of the will to technology is the liberal faith in not merely the creative capacity but also necessity to conquer the landscape, overcome requisite obstacles, and create the world anew. Any excavation of such an imperative would be incomplete without an examination of the idealism that compels us towards this technological striving. Namely, Grant points to the relationship between our mastery of the human and non-human world and the perhaps paradoxical liberal discourse of "freedom" and "values" with which this mastery becomes inextricably entwined. Arguably, Grant begins to posit a significant affective dimension to the technological will in his explanation that "[w]hat makes the drive to technology so strong is that it is carried on by men who still identify what they are doing with the liberation of mankind" (Technology 27). He also maintains that it is Canadians' "belief in progress through technique" which is "the central cause of motion in their souls" (Technology 64). In other words, the drive towards technological mastery and imperial expansion is rarely articulated through the naked language of capitalist accumulation and power; rather, its efficacy and potency lies in its alignment with individual freedom and unrestrained human potential.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
The Digital Cyclops Affirmative --- BFHR › Kritiks › 2AC---AT: Settler Colonialism

The will to technology controls the root cause of settler colonialism

Chew 15 (May Chew - Assistant Professor at the Mel Hoppenheim School of Cinema and Department of Art History at Concordia University, “BECKONING BODIES, MAKING SUBJECTS: INTERACTIVE AND IMMERSIVE TECHNOLOGIES IN CANADIAN MUSEUMS, 1967-2014”, Queen’s University, 2015, , MG)

This account provides an affective analogue to Innis’s political economy. Grant’s passage, like much of his other writing, reads as a threnody that reveals a resoundingly solipsistic moral imperative expressed through a consolidating settler perspective. This is also a fascinating passage for the way in which it elegiacally construes the forging of North America as an alienating “break” from “the old and the settled” and a necessary estrangement with “the extremes of the new land.” Because the land did not—and could never—belong to the new settlers, their identity had to be moulded in wilful opposition to the land, which was subsequently seen as needing to be continually conquered by the will of man. This inhospitable land thus serves an important symbolic function in the national imaginary; its wildness is that which needs to be perpetually (re)established, in order that it can provide an embryonic “wild” against which the will to technology (the rational-scientific imperative to tame and subjugate) can be emphasized through juxtaposition.

The outer world was not the only terrain fundamentally altered by the will to technology. A notion that comes up repeatedly through much of these thinkers' works is that technology fundamentally structures our psyches and determines the way we think and relate to others. For Grant, technology is neither a neutral nor separate entity with which we are able to choose how we wish to interact—an external "playground" or "orchard where we can always pick variegated fruit;" instead, technology "moulds us in what we are, not only at the heart of our animality in the propagation and continuance of our species, but in our actions and thoughts and imaginings" (Technology 15). While Grant was perhaps the most pessimistic in his understanding of the colonizing potential of technology, other thinkers shared his idea that technology had the force to shape consciousness for better or worse.