2023
MNDI
Kritik
AFF › AT Rhetoric of Poverty
Olsen, 2010 - Professor of Socio-Economics, Social Statistics at University of Manchester [Wendy “Poverty as a Malaise of Development: A Discourse Analysis in its Global Context”, https://www.escholar.manchester.ac.uk/api/datastream?publicationPid=uk-ac-man-scw:29857&datastreamId=SUPPLEMENTARY-1.PDF ZR]
Structuralists argue that structures are more than 11 metaphors because they have real effects of two kinds: one, their effect upon the elements in the structures, e.g. being a worker in a job affects the worker. Two, their emergent properties go beyond the nature of the different parts of the structure. For example,. class relations evolve as people migrate from villages to cities, but the nature of class relations is not simply the sum of the proportions of people in different types of job, in each place. It also involves larger properties of the whole society, such as inequality and hence the emergence of real poverty. Thus structures have real effects. Structures are also durable. Their enduring – but not permanent – nature makes us tend to call them ‘structures’ rather than simply norms or instutions. Authors who have set out this ontology include Gimenez (1999), Sayer (2005), and Elder-Vass (2007). The main structures in capitalist societies in the 20th and 21st centuries include ethnic groups, social classes and gender relations. These structures themselves have causal powers so there are powerful mechanisms operating upon both rich and poor people ‘from outside themselves’. These causes are not determining, though; there are also some countervailing causes. One’s tendency to stay uneducated can be fought by borrowing money to pay for an education. But then one must pay interest on the loan and perhaps do bonded labour to repay it. One may have to drop out of education to repay the loan. So the worker returns to the state of low formal education, even though they have learned some interesting lessons. The worker’s agency is exercised to try to fight toward a different position in the class society. Agency is not always successful. Even when it succeeds, it may only move the worker around but not change the class structure itself (Sayer, 1992, chapters 1-3).
2023
MNDI
Kritik
AFF › AT Rhetoric of Poverty
Olsen, 2010 - Professor of Socio-Economics, Social Statistics at University of Manchester [Wendy “Poverty as a Malaise of Development: A Discourse Analysis in its Global Context”, https://www.escholar.manchester.ac.uk/api/datastream?publicationPid=uk-ac-man-scw:29857&datastreamId=SUPPLEMENTARY-1.PDF ZR]
It would be dangerous to attribute too much explanatory power to discourses. Green’s paper, which I cited at the start, seems to suggest that discourses create poverty. Does she mean that discourses of poverty create poverty where before there was none? Her view is probably that the history of poverty is, in part, the history of poverty discourses. But my question about causality may seem a bit confused. There is an underlying philosophical question – does poverty exist prior to its description, when it is encapsulated into a narrative within a discourse? If we answer yes, we presume too much. (This begs the question and essentialises poverty.) If we answer no, then we will inevitably have trouble studying the causes of poverty, because by taking an anti-essentialist position (which feminists call anti-foundationalist) we are making it impossible to study the thing that people are trying to describe. Through long years of field visits in both UK and India, and close study of texts from anthropology and economics as well as sociology, I have concluded that suffering exists, and that this statement is a better starting point than ‘poverty exists’ (Amato, 2001). However we can use words about ‘poverty’ to describe the sources of suffering, since poverty – by its nature, or by what we mean to pin down when we say ‘poverty’ – implies some suffering. I take a realist view of poverty (Olsen, 2007). That makes me think that discourses of poverty nobly try to get at the problem, and sometimes fail, yet in the meantime are interesting in themselves. There are many other discourses of poverty – one might for example mention the participation discourse, in which participation in development is thought to potentially reduce poverty; the human needs discourse, which in the 1970s had been called Basic 9 Needs, and so on. I have just described three because I thought that the reader could relate more easily to these. The next section will discuss two problems that arise in relation to the three poverty discourses the contradictions they imply for the user of the discourse; and their explanatory weaknesses.
2023
MNDI
Kritik
AFF › AT Rhetoric of Poverty
Stephens, 2006 – School of Government at Victoria University of Wellington [Robert, 7/26/2006, Ministry of Social Development, “Poverty by Ruth Lister, Polity Press, 2004, The Poverty Wars by Peter Saunders, UNSW Press, 2005” https://www.msd.govt.nz/about-msd-and-our-work/publications-resources/journals-and-magazines/social-policy-journal/spj28/28-poverty-by-ruth-lister-polity-press-2004-the-poverty-wars-by-peter-saunders-unsw-press-2005-p197-199.html, - MZ]
The approaches taken by the authors reflect the current state of the debate on poverty within their respective countries. In Australia, Peter Saunders’s namesake and nemesis at the neoliberal Centre for Independent Studies (CIS) seems to have captured the media and political debate, disputing that the existence of poverty is anything other than a failure by the poor themselves, abetted by overgenerous welfare state programmes. This approach seems reminiscent of New Zealand during the 1990s. In the United Kingdom, poverty and its alleviation are centre stage for the Blair government, and while there may be debates over causes and cures, the acceptance of the concept of poverty allows Lister time to explore its deeper meanings and implications rather than ensuring poverty remains on the political agenda. She has the luxury of being able to explore the debates as to whether poverty is caused by individual traits or better explained by societal/ structuralist concepts of class, gender, race, geography and disability. Her discussion on discourses such as othering (“the labelling and stigmatizing of marginalized social groups”) and social exclusion (which underpins the causes of social dynamics) provide the antidote to the CIS-based Peter Saunders and, when combined with discussion on human rights and citizenship, shows the need “to embed anti-poverty policies within wider policy debates” of a general social inclusion strategy. When the academic Peter Saunders changes tack from an advocate to a researcher, his coverage of topics overlaps with those of Lister, though at the more intuitive level suitable for the intended audience of those in the front line of anti-poverty policy development and implementation. Lister’s book is far more academic, but essential reading for those in government departments dealing with issues of social development and exclusion, and also for notions of integrated and coordinated policy formulation. Both authors argue that for poverty research to be creditable it has to be grounded in the experiences of the poor, and commensurate with community values and norms, and both draw on the qualitative experiences of the poor to support their claims. However, measurement of the extent and severity of poverty is the first element in the development of anti-poverty policies, requiring the setting of a poverty standard. Here it is a pity that neither author drew on the work of the New Zealand Poverty Measurement Project (Stephens et al. 1995, Waldegrave et al. 1996), because their use of focus groups provided a method for integrating household experience of surviving on low incomes with a quantitative poverty standard.
2023
MNDI
Kritik
Extend - Framework
Lister, 2004 - Professor of Social Policy at Loughborough University [Ruth, “Poverty”, Ch: Discourses of Poverty: From Othering to Respect, p. 100-103]
The notion of ‘the poor’ as Other is used here to signify the many ways in which ‘the poor’ are treated as different from the rest of society. The capital ‘O’ denotes its symbolic weight. The notion of ‘Othering’ conveys how this is not an inherent state but an ongoing process animated by the ‘non-poor’. It is a dualistic process of differentiation and demarcation, by which the line is drawn between ‘us’ and ‘them’ – between the more and the less powerful – and through which social distance is established and maintained (Beresford and Croft, 1995; Riggins, 1997). It is not a neutral line, for it is imbued with negative value judgements that construct ‘the poor’ variously as a source of moral contamination, a threat, an ‘undeserving’ economic burden, an object of pity or even as an exotic species. It is a process that takes place at different levels and in different fora: from everyday social relations through interaction with welfare officials and professionals to research, the media the legal system and policy-making (Schram, 1997). Valerie Polakow, for example, describes how, in the US, schools, teacher training institutions and research institutes are all ‘implicated in the framing of poor children as other, and in institutionalizing the legitimacy of their otherness status’ (1993: 150, emphasis in original). Othering is closely associated with, and reinforced by, a number of related social processes such as stereotyping, stigmatization and the more neutral categorization. Stereotyping is a discriminatory form of labeling, which attains a taken-for-granted quality and serves to portray particular social groups as homogenous. It is a discursive strategy that magnifies and distorts difference (Riggins, 1997). Michael Pickering writes that ‘stereotypes operate as socially exorcistic rituals in maintaining the boundaries of normality and legitimacy’ (2001: 45). He suggests that normally ‘stereotyping attempts to translate cultural difference into Otherness, in the interests of order, power and control’ (2001: 204). In contrast, in the case of ‘the poor’. Stereotyping functions to create cultural difference and thereby the Other. At the same time, as we saw in chapter 3, those groups who are more likely to be poor – women, racialized minorities and disabled people – are themselves groups that are frequently Othered. Processes of classification and categorization effected by governmental and legal institutions, the media and social scientists, although analytically distinct from stereotyping, can draw on stereotypes and thereby reinforce them. These processes can have implications for how ‘the poor’ are treated by fellow citizens as well as by powerful classificatory institutions (Edelman, 1977). As we shall see, the bifurcation of ‘the poor’ into ‘deserving’ and ‘undeserving’, each with their associated stereotypes, has had a profound impact on their treatment by the welfare state and its antecedents. The label of ‘undeserving’ poor has been negatively charged by the process of stigmatization, which, historically and today, has had implications for how society sees ‘the poor’, how they see themselves and how they are treated by welfare institutions. Erving Goffman’s classic text referred to stigma as ‘an attribute that is deeply discrediting’ and to the belief that ‘the person with stigma is not quite human’ (1968: 13, 15). In this way, stigma contributes to the dehumanization involved in Othering (Oliver, 2001). Othering and associated processes such as stigmatization have various effects on ‘us’ and ‘them’ and the relations between the two. With regard to ‘us’, Othering helps to define the self and to affirm identity (Sibley, 1995). In contrast, it divests ‘them’ of ‘their social and cultural identities by diminishing them to their stereotyped characteristics’ and by casting them as silent objects (Pickering, 2001: 73; Oliver, 2001). In doing so, it denies them their complex humanity and subjectivity. Othering operates as ‘a strategy of symbolic exclusion’, which makes it easier for people to blame the Other for their own and society’s problems (Pickering, 2001: 48). The Othering of ‘the poor’ also acts as a warning to others; poverty thereby represents a ‘spectre – a socially constituted object of wholesome horror’ (Dean with Melrose, 1999: 48). As regards the relationship between ‘us’ and ‘them’, Othering legitimates ‘our’ privilege – rooted in superiority – and ‘their’ exploitation and oppression – rooted in inferiority – together with the socio-economic inequalities that underlie poverty (Riggins, 1997; Young, 1999). This underlines the ways in which power relationships are inscribed in the process of Othering. It suggests that Othering may be most marked where inequality is sharpest. An additional effect of Othering is that it denies the Other the 'right to name and define themselves' (Pickering, 2001: 73). The power 'to name one's Self' has been described as 'a fundamental human right' (Riggins, 1997: 8) and as a key 'political resource' (Silver, 1996: 135). Naming 'the poor' is an exercise in power, for 'we' invariably name 'them', even when sympathetically (Polakow, 1993). Naming or labelling of the Other has symbolic, cultural, psychological and material effects. 'How we name things affects how we behave towards them. The name, or label, carries with it expectations' (Clarke and Cochrane, 1998: 26). Likewise 'we' create images of 'them - the poor', which have a similarly powerful effect on attitudes and actions. 'The politics of representation' is therefore a crucial element in the politics of poverty (hooks, 1994: 169). As we shall see, it has taken on greater salience today as some groups of people in poverty, following the disabled people's movement, are resisting the ways they are represented by the wider society, in recognition of the power of language and images. It is through language and images that the discourses that frame how we perceive and act in the social world are articulated. Othering can thus be understood as a discursive practice, which shapes how the 'non-poor' think and talk about and act towards 'the poor' at both an interpersonal and an institutional level. Although it does not represent the only available poverty discourse, its impact on policy and the practice of officials and professionals has been profound in some countries, notably the UK and US. Moreover, welfare policy and administration can themselves be understood as a discursive and symbolic practice, which constructs 'the poor' and the nature of the problem of poverty in various ways (Schram, 1995; Saraceno, 2002). A focus on discourse thus helps to illuminate the relationship between the material and relational/symbolic dimensions of poverty and the ways in which the fibres of power are interwoven through them.
2023
MNDI
Kritik
Extend Alternative – New Definition of Poverty
Lister, 2005 – Professor of Social Policy Loughborough University [Ruth Jan 2005, “Poverty and Social Justice: recognition and respect” , EH]
I am conscious that I have been talking about poverty without defining my terms. The figures I have given you are based on the measure used by government that is most frequently cited: 60 per cent of median income, after housing costs. This is sometimes erroneously called a definition of poverty, but it is no such thing. It is simply a measure and measures are technical devices that are constrained by limitations of methodology and by the available data. A definition should distinguish the state of poverty from that of non-poverty, for instance in terms of low living standards and/or inability to participate fully in society because of lack of material resources. Such a definition is reflected in some of the ways that people in poverty themselves talk about poverty, for instance: ‘Sleeping in a bed that used to be someone’s else’s, wearing cast-off clothes, and being expected to be grateful’; or ‘Dreading every Christmas and birthday because of the disappointment in the children’s eyes’ (ATD u.d.). But listening to people in poverty also reveals other meanings – words like ‘humiliating’, ‘indignity’, ‘denial of human rights’ (UKCAP, 1997). People tall about feeling judged and looked down on; ‘never feeling good enough’ (ATD u.d.). This suggests that as well as measures and definitions, we need a broader conceptualisation of poverty if we are to understand its meanings, particularly for those experiencing it. A broader conceptualisation of poverty enables us to take on board its non-material aspects. These largely stem from people in poverty’s everyday interactions with the wider society and from the way they are talked about and treated by politicians, officials, professionals, the media. Poverty has to be understood not just as a disadvantaged and insecure economic condition but also as a shameful and corrosive social relation. This perspective has been illuminated in particular by participatory research in the Southern hemisphere. This has highlighted non-material aspects of poverty such as: lack of voice, disrespect, humiliation and an assault on dignity and self-esteem, shame and stigma; powerlessness; denial of rights and diminished citizenship. I will elaborate on some of these in a moment.
2023
MNDI
Kritik
Extend Alternative – New Definition of Poverty
Lister 2004 - Professor of Social Policy, Loughborough University [Ruth Poverty and Social Justice: recognition and respect EV]
What do we mean by poverty? I am conscious that I have been talking about poverty without defining my terms. The figures I have given you are based on the measure used by government that is most frequently cited: 60 per cent of median income, after housing costs. This is sometimes erroneously called a definition of poverty, but it is no such thing. It is simply a measure and measures are technical devices that are constrained by limitations of methodology and by the available data. A definition should distinguish the state of poverty from that of non-poverty, for instance in terms of low living standards and/or inability to participate fully in society because of lack of material resources. Such a definition is reflected in some of the ways that people in poverty themselves talk about poverty, for instance: ‘Sleeping in a bed that used to be someone’s else’s, wearing cast-off clothes, and being expected to be grateful’; or ‘Dreading every Christmas and birthday because of the disappointment in the children’s eyes’ (ATD u.d.). But listening to people in poverty also reveals other meanings – words like ‘humiliating’, ‘indignity’, ‘denial of human rights’ (UKCAP, 1997). People talk about feeling judged and looked down on; ‘never feeling good enough’ (ATD u.d.). 8 This suggests that as well as measures and definitions, we need a broader conceptualisation of poverty if we are to understand its meanings, particularly for those experiencing it. A broader conceptualisation of poverty enables us to take on board its non-material aspects. These largely stem from people in poverty’s everyday interactions with the wider society and from the way they are talked about and treated by politicians, officials, professionals, the media. Poverty has to be understood not just as a disadvantaged and insecure economic condition but also as a shameful and corrosive social relation. This perspective has been illuminated in particular by participatory research in the Southern hemisphere. This has highlighted non-material aspects of poverty such as: lack of voice, disrespect, humiliation and an assault on dignity and self-esteem, shame and stigma; powerlessness; denial of rights and diminished citizenship. I will elaborate on some of these in a moment. Poverty has to be understood as a shameful and corrosive social relation.
2023
MNDI
Kritik
Extend Alternative – Social Justice
Lister, 2005 – Professor of Social Policy Loughborough University [Ruth Jan 2005, “Poverty and Social Justice: recognition and respect” , EH]
A social justice perspective on poverty means considering it in relation to the overall distribution of income and wealth.
As one writer on social justice put it, ‘we are discussing how the good and bad things in life should be distributed among the members of a human society’ (Miller, 1999: 1). Or, in the immortal words of R. H. Tawney, ‘what thoughtful rich people call the problem of poverty thoughtful poor people call with equal justice the problem of riches’ (1913). For much of the twentieth century the trend was towards a more equitable distribution of material resources. The trend halted after 1979 and went into reverse; the share of income (both before and after tax) received by the top 1 per cent has returned to broadly similar levels to those when Nye Bevan was a government minister in the 1940s (Atkinson, 2003). According to the Institute for Fiscal Studies, the present government has not been able to bring inequality down to earlier levels but its more redistributive measures have at least helped to stem the rate of the upwards trend. A social justice perspective on poverty means considering it in relation to the overall distribution of income and wealth. While my focus is on poverty and social justice in Britain, Bevan’s internationalism, reflected in the ethos of the Foundation, means that we must not forget global inequality. Although global trends are the subject of some dispute, many argue that an intensification of poverty in some countries is associated with growing global inequality, the level of which has been described by the United Nations Development Programme as ‘grotesque’ (2003: 39). Throughout the world, poverty intersects with social divisions of gender, ‘race’ and disability and also with position in the life-course (with childhood and old age particularly vulnerable stages in many countries). Thus, it can reflect not just class-related inequalities but also discriminatory processes that disadvantage women, black and minority ethnic (BME) groups and disabled people. In the UK, it has been estimated that women are five per cent more likely than men to be in poverty (Bradshaw et al., 2003). But the statistics do not tell us the full extent of female poverty because they assume that resources are shared fairly within the family, an assumption questioned by a number of studies. Moreover, as an Oxfam GB study in Merthyr Tydfil demonstrated, a gender analysis deepens our understanding of the different ways that men and women experience poverty (Buhaenko et al., 2003). The presence of a disabled adult or child increases the risk of poverty by seven to eight percentage points. Black and minority ethnic groups are more likely overall to be in poverty than white groups. There is, however, considerable diversity between minority ethnic groups. The greatest deprivation is among Pakistanis and Bangladeshis, seven out of ten of whom are in poverty. Although they are not picked up by the statistics, some of the worst poverty is to be found among asylum-seekers. The work of the Refugee Council suggests that the operation of section 55 has left some asylum-seekers destitute, reliant on the support of voluntary organisations and refugee communities.
2023
MNDI
Kritik
Extend Alternative – Social Justice
Lister 2004 - Professor of Social Policy, Loughborough University [Ruth Poverty and Social Justice: recognition and respect https://www.bevanfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/12/Ruth-Lister-2004.pdf EV]
Human rights and citizenship This reflects a more general unwillingness to listen to what people in poverty have to say and to treat them as subjects of their own lives rather than as the objects of professional judgement, research and policy. As Moraene Roberts complained at the CAP poverty hearing: ‘No-one asks our views…But we are the real experts of our own hopes and aspirations…We can contribute if you are prepared to give up a little power to allow us to participate as partners in our own future, and in the future of the country’ (Russell, 1996). This is beginning to change thanks to pressure from organisations involving people in poverty themselves. These organisations are frequently framing their demands using a language of human rights, citizenship, voice and power. The UN has helped to promote a human rights discourse. According to the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, a human rights conceptualisation of poverty: leads to more adequate responses to the many facets of poverty…It gives due attention to the critical vulnerability and subjective daily assaults on human dignity that accompany poverty. Importantly, it looks not just at resources but also at the capabilities, choices, security and power needed for enjoyment of an adequate standard of living and other fundamental, civil, cultural, political and social rights’ (www.unhcr.ch/development/pov-02.html). Two key tenets underpin this statement. First is respect for the dignity of all human beings. It can be the everyday indignities that make poverty so difficult to bear. For instance, poverty activist Willie Baptist tells how the main concern of a group of homeless people in the US was the indignity of having to line up daily to receive a ration of five pieces of toilet paper. ‘That infuriated them’, he writes, ‘it took them beneath any level of dignity they might have’ and it was around that indignity, rather than the wider issue of homelessness, that they were prepared to organise. Similarly, a low paid worker, involved in a Living Wage Campaign in London, challenged a shareholders’ meeting at the head office of the bank where he cleans: ‘I am asking you for a living wage so that I and my colleagues can have the same dignity as ordinary people’. 12
2023
MNDI
Kritik
Extend Alternative – Social Justice
Lister 2004 - Professor of Social Policy, Loughborough University [Ruth Poverty and Social Justice: recognition and respect https://www.bevanfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/12/Ruth-Lister-2004.pdf EV]
A social justice perspective on poverty means considering it in relation to the overall distribution of income and wealth. As one writer on social justice put it, ‘we are discussing how the good and bad things in life should be distributed among the members of a human society’ (Miller, 1999: 1). Or, in the immortal words of R. H. Tawney, ‘what thoughtful rich people call the problem of poverty thoughtful poor people call with equal justice the problem of riches’ (1913). For much of the twentieth century the trend was towards a more equitable distribution of material resources. The trend halted after 1979 and went into reverse; the share of income (both before and after tax) received by the top 1 per cent has returned to broadly similar levels to those when Nye Bevan was a government minister in the 1940s (Atkinson, 2003). According to the Institute for Fiscal Studies, the present government has not been able to bring inequality down to earlier levels but its more redistributive measures have at least helped to stem the rate of the upwards trend. A social justice perspective on poverty means considering it in relation to the overall distribution of income and wealth. While my focus is on poverty and social justice in Britain, Bevan’s internationalism, reflected in the ethos of the Foundation, means that we must not forget global inequality. Although global trends are the subject of some dispute, many argue that an intensification of poverty in some countries is associated with growing global inequality, the level of which has been described by the United Nations Development Programme as ‘grotesque’ (2003: 39). 7 Throughout the world, poverty intersects with social divisions of gender, ‘race’ and disability and also with position in the life-course (with childhood and old age particularly vulnerable stages in many countries). Thus, it can reflect not just class-related inequalities but also discriminatory processes that disadvantage women, black and minority ethnic (BME) groups and disabled people. In the UK, it has been estimated that women are five per cent more likely than men to be in poverty (Bradshaw et al., 2003). But the statistics do not tell us the full extent of female poverty because they assume that resources are shared fairly within the family, an assumption questioned by a number of studies. Moreover, as an Oxfam GB study in Merthyr Tydfil demonstrated, a gender analysis deepens our understanding of the different ways that men and women experience poverty (Buhaenko et al., 2003). The presence of a disabled adult or child increases the risk of poverty by seven to eight percentage points. Black and minority ethnic groups are more likely overall to be in poverty than white groups. There is, however, considerable diversity between minority ethnic groups. The greatest deprivation is among Pakistanis and Bangladeshis, seven out of ten of whom are in poverty. Although they are not picked up by the statistics, some of the worst poverty is to be found among asylum-seekers. The work of the Refugee Council suggests that the operation of section 55 has left some asylum-seekers destitute, reliant on the support of voluntary organisations and refugee communities.
2023
MNDI
Kritik
Extend Alternative – Structural Poverty
Bhattacharya 2019 - director of programs and strategy at the Insight Center for Community Economic Development [Jhumpa “Exploring Guaranteed Income through a Racial and Gendered Justice Lens” . . Accessed 23 June 2023 EO]
There is still more to be learned and documented about how to design the best guaranteed income policy in order to advance greater racial and gender equity. Current pilot programs in Stockton, California, and Jackson, Mississippi, will help us answer many design questions (SEED n.d.; Springboard to Opportunities n.d.). In addition to the evidence that will be collected from these pilots, direct input from the communities that this is targeted towards must be incorporated in order for any policy implemented to be as effective as possible. For example, questions around an annual lump-sum payment versus monthly payments must be discussed with individual communities, so that policymakers have a sense of what option would best achieve the ultimate goals of the policy. It’s possible that in these conversations, the recommendation is made to allow recipients to choose what payment breakdown they would prefer. In addition to direct community input for the design of a guaranteed income, it is important to understand that a guaranteed income is ultimately an income policy solution, and income is only part of the equation when thinking about wealth.
2023
MNDI
Kritik
Extend Alternative – Structural Poverty
Ross, 1991 Prof. of Law at the University of Pittsburgh [Thomas, June Georgetown Law Review “The Rhetoric of Poverty: Their Immorality, Our Helplessness”, , MZ]
V. CONCLUSION The question posed by this article is where will we choose to stand on the rhetorical field. As readers and critics within the legal community, we have an ethical obligation to ponder and choose our perspective. The Court's rhetoric of poverty has provided a ready viewing point on the legal issues of poverty. It is a relatively comfortable niche-either a place beyond choice or a seat of judgment from which we see the poor and judge their moral strength, winnowing out the undeserving from the deserving poor. There are other viewing points we might choose, however. We might choose to acknowledge the inherent element of our own choice in these matters and our responsibility for that choice. We might choose to struggle to see their suffering as ours. We might choose to question our own moral strengths and weaknesses. From these other, less comfortable, viewing points we may still see the Court's choices as right. But to do so we would have to accept that suffering which might have been alleviated was not, not because we were beyond choice in the matter, but rather because we made the hardest choice that life puts to us-the choice that suffering we might relieve ought nonetheless continue. The rhetoric of poverty shelters us from our choices. The rhetoric allows us to imagine that the suffering of the poor is just or that we are helpless to end it. But our legal history is replete with the most elegant rhetorical facades built around the most horrific of legal choices.212 And we must wonder whether our legal choices about poverty will bring upon us and our chil- dren the tragedy and shame that historically have attended those who take the shelter of rhetoric in a storm of human suffering.
2023
MNDI
Kritik
Extend Alternative – Structural Poverty
Hirschl et al, 2003 - Professor of Global Development at Cornell University [Thomas with Mark R. Rank and Hong-Sik Yoon December, The Journal of Sociology & Social Welfare “American poverty as a structural failing: evidence and arguments” ZR]
Empirical research on American poverty has largely focused on individual characteristics to explain the occurrence and patterns of poverty. The argument in this article is that such an emphasis is misplaced. By focusing upon individual attributes as the cause of poverty, social scientists have largely missed the underlying dynamic of American impoverishment. Poverty researchers have in effect focused on who loses out at the economic game, rather than addressing the fact that the game produces losers in the first place. We provide three lines of evidence to suggest that U.S. poverty is ultimately the result of structural failings at the economic, political, and social levels. These include an analysis into the lack of sufficient jobs in the economy to raise families out of poverty or near poverty; a comparative examination into the high rates of U.S. poverty as a result of the ineffectiveness of the social safety net; and the systemic nature of poverty as indicated by the life course risk of impoverishment experienced by a majority of Americans. We then briefly outline a framework for reinterpreting American poverty. This perspective incorporates the prior research findings that have focused on individual characteristics as important factors in who loses out at the economic game, with the structural nature of American poverty that ensures the existence of economic losers in the first place.
2023
MNDI
Kritik
Extend Alternative – Structural Poverty
Three lines of evidence are detailed in order to illustrate the structural nature of poverty--1) the inability of the U.S. labor market to provide enough decent paying jobs for all families to avoid poverty or near poverty; 2) the ineffectiveness of American social policy to reduce levels of poverty through governmental social safety net programs; and 3) the fact that the majority of the population will experience poverty during their adult lifetimes, indicative of the systemic nature of U.S. poverty. Each of these lines of evidence are intended to empirically illustrate that American poverty is by and large the result of structural failures and processes. The Inability of the Labor Market to Support All Families Several of the pioneering large scale studies of poverty conducted at the end of the 19'th and beginning of the 20'th century focused heavily on the importance of labor market failings to explain poverty. The work of Charles Booth (1892-1897), Seebohm Rowntree (1901), Hull House (1895), Robert Hunter (1904), and W. E. B. DuBois (1899) all emphasized the importance of inadequate wages, lack of jobs, and unstable working conditions as a primary cause of poverty. For example, Rowntree (1901) estimated that approximately 57 percent of individuals in poverty were there as a direct result of labor market failures (low wages, unemployment, irregularity of work). Yet by the 1960's the emphasis had shifted from a critique of the economic structure as a primary cause of poverty, to an analysis of individual deficiencies (e.g., the lack of human capital) as the underlying reason for poverty. As Timothy Bartik (2001) notes, U.S. antipoverty policy has focused heavily on labor supply policies (e.g. increasing individual's human capital or incentives to work through welfare reform) rather than labor demand policies (increasing the number and quality of jobs). As mentioned earlier, social scientific research has reinforced this policy approach by focusing on individual deficiencies to explain individual poverty. Yet it can be demonstrated that irrespective of the specific characteristics that Americans possess, there simply are not enough decent paying jobs to support all of those (and their families) who are looking for work. During the past 25 years the American economy has increasingly produced larger numbers of low paying jobs, jobs that are part-time, and jobs that are lacking in benefits (Seccombe, 2000). For example, the Census Bureau estimated that the median hourly earning of workers who were paid hourly wages in 2000 was $9.91, while at the same time approximately three million Americans were working part-time as a result of the lack of sufficient full-time work being available (U.S. Census Bureau, 2001). In addition, 43.6 million Americans were lacking in health insurance, largely because their employer did not provide such benefits (U.S. Census Bureau, 2003b).
Poverty is not the result of individual choices – social structures determine inequality.
Pineda, 2021 - Managing Consultant at Esploro Company [Mathew, September 19, Profolus, “Theories of Poverty”, ZR]
In his book, political science professor David Brady argues that poverty is not simply a result of the inability of an individual. Poverty tends to be prevalent in vulnerable demographic environments and troubled labor market circumstances. Hence, the greater the number of people living under these circumstances, the higher the prevalence of poverty. Brady specifically explains that poverty results from the failure of the society to collectively take responsibility for promoting the economic security of its citizens through the instrument of the welfare state. Hence, welfare programs are collectively the best tool for reducing poverty. Sociology professor Edward Royce also argues that in the United States, despite being a rich country, poverty remains rampant not because of the individual failings of the poor but because of the failings of the American social system, especially of its political economy. Royce specifically noted that poverty represents structural inequality. In societies with incidents of poverty, people have unequal status as demonstrated in unequal relations in roles, functions, decisions, rights, and opportunities.
2023
MNDI
Kritik
Extend Impacts – Ethical Implications
De Schutter, 2022 - Special Rapporteur on extreme poverty and human rights for the United Nations Human Rights Office of the High Commissioner [Oliver October 28, “Ban ‘povertyism’ in the same way as racism and sexism: UN expert”, https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2022/10/ban-povertyism-same-way-racism-and-sexism-un-expert, UN Office of the High Commissioner]
NEW YORK (28 October 2022) – “Povertyism” – negative attitudes and behaviours towards people living in poverty – is as pervasive, toxic and harmful as racism, sexism and other forms of discrimination and should be treated as such, according to a published by the UN expert on poverty. “People are stereotyped and discriminated against purely because they are poor. This is frankly sickening and a stain on our society,” UN Special Rapporteur on extreme poverty and human rights, Olivier De Schutter, told the UN General Assembly as it met for its 77th session in New York. “As the global rise in energy and food prices throws millions more into poverty, they must be protected not just from the horrors of poverty, but also from the humiliation and exclusion caused by the scourge of povertyism,” De Schutter said. The Special Rapporteur called on governments to urgently review their anti-discrimination laws, as well as consider “pro-poor” affirmative action, to ensure povertyism is wiped out. “The dangerously misplaced belief that people living in poverty are to blame for their condition, and therefore somehow socially inferior, has a firm grip on society and will not disappear on its own,” De Schutter said. “It is high time the law intervened to ban discrimination on grounds of socio-economic status, as many countries have already done with race, sex, age or disability. The report finds that povertyism has become firmly entrenched in public and private institutions, largely because decision-making positions tend to be held by those from higher-income backgrounds, skewing the system against people in poverty. It details cases where children from low-income families have been refused access to certain schools, employers have judged CVs more harshly when the address suggests the person lives in poverty, and landlords have refused to rent apartments to tenants receiving social benefits. Even judges have been found to hand out harsher sentences based on anti-poor stereotypes.
2023
MNDI
Kritik
Extend Impacts – Ethical Implications
Ross, 1991 Prof. of Law at the University of Pittsburgh [Thomas, June Georgetown Law Review “The Rhetoric of Poverty: Their Immorality, Our Helplessness”, , MZ]
IV. THE POWER OF RHETORIC-THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE READER The contemporary Court, in a range of cases dealing with the rights and interests of the poor, has adopted a non-interventionist approach. The Court has left the law's treatment of people in poverty largely to the political processes, acknowledging only the narrowest constitutional grounds for addressing their interests. The Justices have put forth opinions abundant with both explicit and, more often, implicit assumptions of the difference and moral weakness of the poor. Repeatedly, the Justices have stressed their own helplessness to correct the problems of poverty. This pattern of choice and rhetoric provides a structure for understanding the power of rhetoric. Out of an understanding of the nature of the rhetoric of poverty emerges a responsibility, an ethic, incumbent on the reader. As we read the Court's opinions embodying the rhetoric of poverty we are engaged in an activity with moral connotations. Once we have read the opinions, there is no morally neutral position available-we must act as critics. Here, even silence is a morally charged position. We, as readers, have a responsibility to resist the rhetorician's magic and to see the subject of our inquiry as clearly and fully as possible. The essential points of this part of the article have relevance beyond the bounds of the poverty cases. Each case we read, whatever its subject, represents a choice imposed on other people backed by the threat or actuality of violence.1 92 It may be a choice to terminate a woman's relationship with her son, to send a man to death or to a cage for the rest of his life, or to allow the carnage of an undeclared war to continue. Whatever the subject of the case, we cannot escape our responsibility as readers. The Court's jurisprudence of poverty is nevertheless a sensible place to begin for two reasons. First, there is so much at stake in this area. Critical inquiry into the constitutional status of poverty is needed from as many thoughtful and responsible vantage points as possible. These cases are about our obligation to those members of our society who lack the very means of subsistence. Second, the rhetoric of poverty is an especially illuminating example of the complex and indirect power of rhetoric. These cases provide a great lesson in reading. A. THE POWER OF RHETORIC The analysis of judicial rhetoric is an exploration of the human activity of reading. This activity is at once both simple to describe and difficult to understand. 1 93 How the reader derives meaning from text is hard to say, and how that meaning influences the reader in her understanding of the constitutional issues of poverty is unclear. Surely, many who read the judicial rhetoric of poverty are influenced by it. Although rhetoric rarely changes the reader's mind, it often subtly influences people by either creating doubt or strengthening resolve. When the Justices repeat the argument of judicial helplessness in case after case, the reader may begin to wonder whether there truly is any choice in the matter. When the reader is repeatedly confronted with the conceptual segregation of the poor, she is more likely to accept some version of the us/them idea embedded in this rhetoric. Our own experiences of reading judicial rhetoric tell us that these sorts of effects do occur. What we need to understand is how this happens to us.
2023
MNDI
Kritik
Extend Impacts – Ethical Implications
Ross, 1991 Prof. of Law at the University of Pittsburgh [Thomas, June Georgetown Law Review “The Rhetoric of Poverty: Their Immorality, Our Helplessness”, , MZ]
1. Conceptual Segregation and Moral Weakness The Court's rhetoric of poverty has conceptually segregated the poor in various ways. When Justice Stewart, in Dandridge, demanded an "equitable balance" between the "families on welfare and those supported by an employed breadwinner," he conceptually separated those families in poverty and receiving public assistance from other families. In his validation of the Texas AFDC scheme in Jefferson, Justice Rehnquist separated AFDC recipients into the undeserving, able-bodied poor, and the deserving, disabled and aged poor. Running through the cases analyzed in Part III, particularly those dealing with disability benefits and food stamps, is the specter of fraud, which in turn depends on the segregation of recipients of public assistance into a group especially likely to deceive. The very act of conceptual segregation has rhetorical power. When the members of the segregated group are defined by their difference from those in a dominant position in society, the very act of segregation suggests not simply difference but also deviance. 197 The norm is defined by the dominant group; the segregated group is defined by deviance from that norm. The power of this segregation is vividly revealed in the rhetoric of poverty. The rhetoric of poverty reiterates this label of deviance through the varitural ous expressions of the moral weakness of the poor. For example, when Justice Blackmun portrayed the AFDC mother in Wyman as the likely perpetrator of child neglect and abuse, the reader is willing to accept this characterization partly because of the conceptual segregation of the AFDC mother. 98 The segregation of the poor and the assertion of their moral deviance are intertwined. Accepting the us/them construct makes the assertion of moral deviance easier to accept, and, reciprocally, the acceptance of the construct of moral deviance reinforces the idea of difference. If we had no conception of difference--if AFDC mothers were not thought of as a category distinct from mothers in general-the assertion of moral deviance would be disturbing because it would be an assertion about us and our families. While we cannot think of ourselves as so prone to child abuse that home visits by government agents are appropriate in the absence of probable cause, we can think of others in that way. Thus, the two rhetorical themes work together, iterating and reiterating the essential message that the poor are different and deviant. In its assertion or suggestion of the difference and deviance of the poor, the rhetoric of poverty is both revealing and obscuring. The rhetoric reveals the reality of criminal and immoral behavior among the poor. The rich are not the only ones who defraud the government and abuse their children. At the same time, the rhetoric of poverty obscures the aspects of poverty that reflect our own lives. The lives of the poor have always mirrored the lives of the rest of society. Many of us struggle to raise children and to find and do work. We all feel humiliation and have aspirations. We all face desperate moral choices of one sort or another; we all succumb to temptation or despair at one time or another; we all, at the end, have good reason to question the strength of our individual will.
2023
MNDI
Kritik
Extend Impacts – Ethical Implications
Ross, 1991 Prof. of Law at the University of Pittsburgh [Thomas, June Georgetown Law Review “The Rhetoric of Poverty: Their Immorality, Our Helplessness”, , MZ]
Part II of this article is an exploration of the historical and cultural standing of these rhetorical themes. Part III is a demonstration of the presence and persistence of this rhetoric in the contemporary Court's opinions. Part IV is a consideration of the power of this rhetoric and the resulting responsibility of the reader. In a world in which silence is sometimes the most powerful moral statement one can make, no one can read the opinions that constitute our contemporary constitutional jurisprudence of poverty and thereafter find a morally neutral position. To the extent we are influenced by the Court's rhetoric, we need to understand the process by which we are influenced. We need to realize that how we talk and argue about poverty reveals what we believe about ourselves and others. II. THE RHETORIC OF POVERTY Rhetoric is built from the cultural assumptions and attitudes available to its creator.7 The contemporary legal rhetoric of poverty is built on premises that have both a validity in the contemporary culture and a history of their own. The premise of the moral weakness of the poor has been around in various forms throughout our history. Likewise, the argument that we are all helpless to change the harsh reality of the poor has a long lineage in American public discourse. And the particular argument of judicial helplessness has served as the rhetorical linchpin for important legal issues throughout our history.8 To understand the nature and power of the contemporary legal rhetoric of poverty requires some understanding of the history and cultural standing of its basic premises. A. THE IMMORALITY OF THE POOR The separation and stigmatization of people in poverty is not new. In vari- ous manifestations, it has been a constant feature of our culture.9 In fact, the cultural separation and stigmatization of the poor has been a feature of most Western cultures throughout modem history.10 In one fashion or another the poor have always been separated by class distinctions and labels. They have been labeled "paupers," "peasants," and "strangers." They have been cast as different, deviant, and morally weak. 1 These assumptions make coherent the physical separation of the poor from the affluent. Just as the separation and stigmatization of the poor is a recurring cultural assumption, the intensified suffering of those in poverty in times of natural or man-made disaster has been a recurring societal reality. During the great plagues of Europe, for example, the poor were left in what became ghettos of disease and death while the affluent left for enclaves outside the cities. 12 As a result, the plagues took the lives of a much larger percentage of the poor. Famine, wars, and natural disasters have followed a similar pattern, with the burdens falling disproportionately on the poor.1 3 The cultural assumptions and the societal realities cannot be disconnected. The assumptions make the disproportionate suffering coherent.
2023
MNDI
Kritik
Extend Impacts - Stigmatization
Lister, 2005 – Professor of Social Policy Loughborough University [Ruth Jan 2005, “Poverty and Social Justice: recognition and respect” , EH]
Nevertheless, research also shows how resilient many living in poverty are in their struggle to get by – particularly women who are typically the main managers of poverty and who act as shock-absorbers of poverty as they try to protect their children from its worst effects, often to the detriment of their own physical and mental health. Generally the picture painted is one of constant restrictions; doing without; running out of money at the end of the week; limited choice; no room for spontaneity; damaged family relationships; isolation from the wider society. ‘Existing not living’ is a recurrent phrase used by people in poverty to describe its material impact. Bringing up children in poverty is particularly tough. The inability to meet children’s needs and demands makes parents feel guilty and a failure and can lead to family tensions. Research shows that both parents and children place great emphasis on ‘participation’: the right of every child to share in the activities, experiences and lifestyle of the community in which s/he is brought up. Both also fear its negative corollary: exclusion. In a materialistic world the ability for an individual child to participate largely depends on access to goods, services and activities, most of which have a financial cost.A more recent study talked to children themselves. It found that children in poverty often don’t ‘fit in’, particularly with regards to the ‘right’ clothing. The ‘wrong’ clothing can mean bullying and general exclusion. They often can’t ‘join in’ shared social activities with their peers because of the cost. The children spoke of ‘their fears of social difference and stigma’ (Ridge, 2002) In the words of a child in a separate study carried out by Save the Children Wales with children in deprived communities: ‘People think you’re different and treat you different if you’re poor (Crowley and Vulliamy, u.d. p15). Othering ‘the poor’ This brings us to the psychological impact of the way people in poverty are often treated. In a study I was involved in, ‘poverty was associated with loss of self esteem, feelings of powerlessness, anger, depression, anxiety and boredom’ (Beresford et al., 1999). In another report, one woman put it graphically: ‘You’re like an onion and gradually every skin is peeled off of you and there’s nothing left. All your self esteem and how you feel about yourself is gone – you’re left feeling like nothing and then your family feels like that’(UKCAP, 1997). Stigma, lack of respect and denial of dignity are constant refrains when people in poverty talk about how they are treated by the wider society; the most recent example can be found in the Report of the Child Poverty Task Group (2004) published this week by the Welsh Assembly Government. Two contributions at a national poverty hearing held by Church Action on Poverty (CAP) are typical: ‘The worst blow of all is the contempt of your fellow citizens. I and many families live in that contempt’ and ‘I just feel very angry sometimes that people are ignorant to the fact that we are humans as well and we do need to be respected’ (Russell, 1996). The Commission on Poverty, Participation and Power, of which I was a member and half of whose members had direct experience of poverty, reported ‘the lack of respect for people living in poverty was one of the clearest and most heartfelt messages which came across to us as a Commission’ (CoPPP, 2000). Participants in the South Wales Oxfam GB study spoke of their dislike of the stigma they felt attached to their estate. Stigma, lack of respect and denial of dignity are constant refrains what people in poverty are reacting to is a process of what we might call ‘othering’ i.e. they are treated and talked about as people who are ‘other’ to the rest of us. It is a process of differentiation and demarcation, by which the line is drawn between ‘us’ and ‘them’ and through which social distance is established and maintained. The line is imbued with negative value judgements that construct ‘the poor’ variously as a source of moral contamination, a threat, an ‘undeserving’ economic burden, an object of pity or even as an exotic species. Language is an important part of the process by and large, the language and labels used to describe ‘the poor’ have been articulated by the more powerful ‘non-poor’ – the media, politicians, academics. It is a language that is rooted in history with its division of the poor into ‘deserving’ and ‘undeserving’ groups. The more obviously demeaning examples today are 'underclass' and ‘welfare dependant’ – and the American terms ‘white’ or ‘trailer trash’. But the less value-laden word ‘poor’ is itself problematic. It is an adjective that we ‘apply’ to ‘them’ but people in poverty themselves are often reluctant to wear what they perceive to be a stigmatising label, with its connotations of inferior as in ‘poor quality’. Typically they are not asked how they want to be described.
2023
MNDI
Kritik
Extend Impacts - Dehumanization
Ross, 1991 Prof. of Law at the University of Pittsburgh [Thomas, June Georgetown Law Review “The Rhetoric of Poverty: Their Immorality, Our Helplessness”, , MZ]
This description does not capture every reader's experience, nor does it capture fully any individual reader's experience. Some readers will resist the vision of poverty suggested by the rhetoric, and no individual reader will follow exactly the path suggested above. The assumptions and experiences of the individual, the purpose and context of the reading, and other variables will affect the nature of any particular reading of these opinions.202 Still, for all readers drawn from a culture that teaches the difference and deviance of the poor, the assertion or suggestion of those cultural themes is not simply and easily ignored. Thus, the judicial rhetoric of poverty draws power from the explicit and implicit depiction of poverty. In the hands of the most skillful of the Court's rhetoricians, it is used to craft a picture that, if accepted, leaves the reader with no other choice but the Court's. The rhetoric of poverty also works in a more general way to influence our understanding of the poor. The experience of reading this rhetoric may diminish the possibility for empathy. So long as we think of those in poverty as "them" and not "us," we are less likely to share in their pain and humiliation. 203 We can imagine that they do not suffer as we would, or that their suffering, unlike ours, is inevitable or even deserved. Our inability to imagine the poor as strong, successful, ambitious, and responsible people who win the battles of life prevents us from feeling empathy for them. The persistent idea of the "passive poor" in the "underclass" keeps blocking our imagination. Yet, the story of people in poverty in this country has been a story of strength and success. Against all odds, facing social stigma and working through maddening systems of public assistance, the poor have survived. 2° 4 Many poor women and men have kept their families together and maintained safe and decent lives in the midst of conditions that would seem to make family disintegration inescapable. The rhetoric of poverty highlights only the stories of failure and obscures the stories of success.
2023
MNDI
Kritik
Extend Impacts – Turns Case
Sarangi 2023 - professor at the department of political science at University of Hyderabad [Prakash January 12 “Welfare discourses in India”, India Review, ZR]
Broadly, there are three characteristics of responsive welfare policy. First, a direct link between political representation and welfare policy emerged. Governments responded directly to the expectations of a class of citizens whose votes matter for remaining in power. The beneficiaries started to ask for better delivery of services, rather than simply accepting a patronage. The participatory upsurge by the marginalized gave them a new status and power. Major political parties became sensitive to this new environment and tweaked their mobilization strategy accordingly. Second, there was a paradigm shift in the working of the Indian state. The moral obligation of the state as the major provider of welfare was reaffirmed, in spite of the involvement of non-state actors in the monitoring of these policies at the grassroots level. Governance and accountability were given top priority. Ruparelia writes, “the move to provide socioeconomic entitlements through novel civic rights and governance reforms is an innovative state-building project that aims to curb the danger of authoritarian high modernism by allowing India’s citizenry to ‘see the state.’” Third, the emphasis on social citizenship accelerated the process of empowerment of the poor and the marginalized. The language of “rights” brought the welfare policy at the center stage of political discourse. These new entitlements show that “the underprivileged majority is not completely marginalized in this elitist political system.” As Williams, et al, suggest, “such initiatives have reconfigured not only the material interactions between the state and India’s marginalized, but also the imagined spaces within which marginal groups renegotiate their relationships with the state.” (emphasis is in the original)