Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Social Security › M4A

M4A is a hail marry in hopes of preserving for-profit healthcare – M4A and all its contemporaries are little more than Neoliberal philanthropy.

Sculos, 19, (Bryant William Sculos 2019 "It's Capitalism, Stupid!: The Theoretical and Political Limitations of the Concept of Neoliberalism," ) #Gay Frog

That neoliberalism, at its most conceptually-valuable, is a matter of degree can be understood by looking at the on-going debate over health care in the US (though the logic can be applied in any context). There are three policies, which are each, to varying degrees, part of a neoliberalization process. This is where neoliberalism can connect to the problematic discussions and categorizations of someone like Barack Obama. We have the Affordable Care Act, or “Obamacare,” wherein the government mandates that individual citizens buy health care from private companies. This individual mandate leaves the roots of the American healthcare system in the market, and even forces citizens into that market to the benefit of private insurance companies. On the other hand, the ACA also expanded the government’s role in providing health insurance by offering citizens subsidies and offering states increased funding to expand Medicaid coverage. Thus, the ACA contains elements that contribute to neoliberalization and others that hedge against full-scale neoliberalism. Compare the ACA to the Ryan-Trump plan that was eventually withdrawn from a planned floor vote in the House of Representatives.21 This bill was a more aggressive form of neoliberalization than the ACA in that it removed the individual mandate (the penalty for violation being paid to the federal government) and replaced it with a rule allowing private insurers to charge up to 30% more for people who lacked health insurance for more than 63 days in the previous calendar year. There is still a government-allowed penalty for failing to buy insurance, but in the case of the Ryan-Trump plan the penalty money is paid directly to private companies. Additionally, while the plan retained subsidies, they were substantially more regressive than with the ACA. Another alternative bill proposed by the so-called “Freedom Caucus” of the House GOP, called for the complete repeal (without replacement) of the ACA. No subsidies to help people buy insurance. No individual mandate in any form. Insurance companies would be able to charge more or less whatever they wanted to anyone. They could discriminate based on age, gender, and pre- existing conditions. This bill is much closer to — if not fully representing — neoliberalism in its ideal form. Privatization can take many forms, but when we think about the drift towards neoliberalism, it is fundamentally a matter of degree, with few policies ever likely to fully meet the ideal-typical definition of neoliberalism sketched out above. This is where the concept of neoliberalism has value; it allows us to understand how policies as diverse as the ACA and the Freedom Caucus proposal each embody neoliberal values in distinct ways and why all degrees of neoliberalization need to be resisted. One can also put the ACA against various proposed versions of Medicare-for-All. In his earliest comments on Medicare-for-All, Bernie Sanders, considered the political father of this proposal in the popular imaginary, simply stated that Medicare-for-All means dropping the age limitation from the existing Medicare statute. However, while the existing Medicare statute is an example of a kind of single-payer (though still with co-pays and premiums, depending on the plan and the procedure), it is primarily processed through private, for-profit insurance companies, which the ability to profit off of is increasingly difficult for the public to find information about (but obviously happens or these for-profit companies wouldn’t provide Medicare plans at all). If Medicare-for-All were to proceed under the current conditions of Medicare, it would be a regression of neoliberalism and neoliberalization, without removing us from the overall structure of a capitalist political economy. If the prescription drugs are still produced and distributed within a for-profit model, if medical devices are still produced and distributed within a for-profit model, if nurses and doctors and medical workers of all kinds still produce surplus-value for for-profit health care companies, Medicare-for-All is still progress, but it does not represent moving outside of neoliberalism or neoliberalization, at least not completely, but it is certainly moving in the right direction. In other words, Medicare-for-All, in its various interactions, is a challenge to neoliberalism as neoliberalization, but it is not automatically a fundamental challenge to capitalism. Certainly, if one views Medicare-for-All as a last-ditch effort to maintain the legitimacy of for-profit health care, even through its single-payer model, it fits contradictorily within the ideological and structural-historical parameters of capitalism—and may even serve some of the forces of neoliberalization, even as it is obviously less neoliberal than the Freedom Caucus plan or the ACA. Conversely, there are other versions of Medicare-for-All that are more aggressively progressive and anti-neoliberal (though still not necessarily anti-capitalist). Sanders’ newest (2019) iteration of his Medicare-for-All plan represents the strongest left position on offer at the moment, but even this improved proposal fails to address some important aspects of the broader systemic context.22 If Medicare-for-All was provided through a publicly-controlled and managed system, without using private insurers as middlemen, and if Medicare-for-All includes negotiated prices for tests, treatments, prescription drugs, and devices, under more fully-democratic political conditions, this would appropriately be considered outside of neoliberalism and neoliberalization. It would be a complete rejection of privatization, and even some of the fundamental aspects of capitalism; health care would be less commodified and provided based on need—and while surplus-value extraction would still be a systemic component of even this expansive version of Medicare-for-All, surplus-value would be more equitably redistributed based on need and not profit-seeking. While Sanders’ new approach meets many of these criteria, it would need to be accomplished without compromise, and would likely demand deeper structural transformation in regard to how democracy works in the US (including in relation to the rest of the planet’s population). This speaks to the importance of critical engagement with campaigns such as Sanders’ in the US, and other more socialistic ones around the world, without sowing confusion or delusions in the ability of capitalism to be substantially reformed or that we can merely turn back the clock on the neoliberalization occurring within the global capitalist system without opposing capitalism (and thus neoliberalization) wholesale. These distinctions can be observed in other single-payer health care systems around the world and their distinct funding methods and degrees of privatization for different aspects of their respective health care systems.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Social Security › M4A

Medicare puts a bandaid on the underlying capitalist structure – fails to challenge the root cause and instead reinforces a capitalist form of cruel optimism

Sculos 19 – [Bryant Sculos, Worcester State University, “It’s Capitalism, Stupid!: The Theoretical and Political Limitations of the Concept of Neoliberalism,” Class, Race and Corporate Power, Vol. 7 : Iss. 2, Article 7, 2019, ] /jsam

One can also put the ACA against various proposed versions of Medicare-for-All. In his earliest comments on Medicare-for-All, Bernie Sanders, considered the political father of this proposal in the popular imaginary, simply stated that Medicare-for-All means dropping the age limitation from the existing Medicare statute. However, while the existing Medicare statute is an example of a kind of single-payer (though still with co-pays and premiums, depending on the plan and the procedure), it is primarily processed through private, for-profit insurance companies, which the ability to profit off of is increasingly difficult for the public to find information about (but obviously happens or these for-profit companies wouldn’t provide Medicare plans at all). If Medicare-for-All were to proceed under the current conditions of Medicare, it would be a regression of neoliberalism and neoliberalization, without removing us from the overall structure of a capitalist political economy. If the prescription drugs are still produced and distributed within a for-profit model, if medical devices are still produced and distributed within a for-profit model, if nurses and doctors and medical workers of all kinds still produce surplus-value for for-profit health care companies, Medicare-for-All is still progress, but it does not represent moving outside of neoliberalism or neoliberalization, at least not completely, but it is certainly moving in the right direction. In other words, Medicare-for-All, in its various interactions, is a challenge to neoliberalism as neoliberalization, but it is not automatically a fundamental challenge to capitalism. Certainly, if one views Medicare-for-All as a last-ditch effort to maintain the legitimacy of for-profit health care, even through its single-payer model, it fits contradictorily within the ideological and structural-historical parameters of capitalism—and may even serve some of the forces of neoliberalization, even as it is obviously less neoliberal than the Freedom Caucus plan or the ACA.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Social Security › SS – Generic

Social Security operates within a capitalist framework and was aimed to subtly eliminate working class struggles.

Jenkins & Brents ’89 [J. Craig Jenkins, Ph.D., State University of New York at Stony Brook; professor, chair of sociology, and faculty associate of the Mershon Center for International Security at The Ohio State University. Barbara G. Brents, Ph.D., Associate Professor of Sociology and Faculty Affiliate in Women's Studies at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas. 1989. “Social Protest, Hegemonic Competition, and Social Reform: A Political Struggle Interpretation of the Origins of the American Welfare State.” American Sociological Review, 54(6), p. 891–909. https://doi.org/10.2307/2095714; JFan]

Neo-Marxists and state-centric theorists have recently offered interpretations of the formulation and passage of the Social Security Act of 1935. Quadagno's (1984, 1985) neo-Marxian interpretation sees the Social Security Act as a compromise between monopoly and competitive sector capitalists that "incorporated working class demands into legislation on capitalist terms" (1984, p. 646). The American state was "relatively autonomous" in that political leaders constructed this compromise, reconciling the economic and political interests of these two class fractions "operating at different levels within a hierarchical state structure" (1984, p. 646). Yet, contrary to most neo-Marxian interpretations, she concludes that the working class played "almost no role," pressures coming. instead from the middle-class Townsend movement. In contrast, state-centric theorists have advanced an institutional/ political process interpretation that emphasizes the interests of political leaders and the constraints of past policies. The initiative for Social Security came from a coalition for "bureaucratic autonomy" composed of progressivist political officials, policy intellectuals, middle-class political activists and a "handful" of liberal capitalists who responded to a general "democratic upsurge" and worked against the concerted opposition of "virtually all politically active business leaders and organizations" (Skocpol and Amenta 1985, p. 572; see also Skocpol and Ikenberry 1983; Orloff and Skocpol 1984; Amenta, Clemens, Olsen, Parikh, and Skocpol 1988; Orloff 1988).

These analyses have moved beyond earlier interpretations by framing specific hypotheses in terms of explicit theories of the state. ' However, by misspecifying the autonomy of the state, these analyses have failed to distinguish policy formulation from policy- making, underestimated social protest as a force in placing social welfare proposals on the political agenda, and misanalyzed the sources and significance of intracapitalist conflicts over the passage of the Social Security Act and related "Second New Deal" reforms .2

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Social Security › SS – Generic

Social Security was made to be a way to maintain capitalism’s vitality, without addressing the root cause

Social Security Administration, No Date ("Social Security History," No Publication, ) #Gay Frog

If America was to avoid the siren songs of the "radical calls to action," responsible political leaders would need to offer some persuasive alternatives. As the Depression grew, three general approaches emerged: do nothing; rely on voluntary charity; and expand welfare benefits for those hardest hit by the Depression. It seemed to many politicians and leading public figures that the Depression was just another dip in the economic cycle and that it would right itself soon enough. These voices counseled a restrained response, or no response at all. In the early aftermath of the stock market crash such views were especially common. This view that nothing very much was wrong and nothing very much needed to be done, began to fade quickly as the Depression deepened. Even so, it held considerable sway in the early years after The Crash. President Hoover had a distinguished career before becoming president. He made a name for himself in international relief efforts before and after World War I. He helped feed millions of starving people, through the efforts of voluntary partnerships of government, business and private giving. He knew this kind of "volunteerism" worked, on a massive scale, and he saw no reason why it should not work to solve the problems of the Depression. So although he engaged in some limited federal relief efforts, his main response to the Depression was to advocate voluntary efforts, which never materialized. The main problem with this strategy was that America was able to help rebuild Europe in the aftermath of World War I because America's economy was basically sound. In the Depression the total wealth of the nation was cut in half during the first three years after The Crash. This made voluntary charity a difficult ideal to achieve. Even before the Depression hit, the States had been forced to deal with the problems of economic security in a wage-based, industrial economy. Workers Compensation programs were established at the state level before Social Security, and there were state welfare programs for the elderly in place before Social Security. Prior to Social Security, the main strategy for providing economic security to the elderly, in the face of the demographic changes discussed above, was to provide various forms of old-age "pensions." These were welfare programs, eligibility for which was based on proof of financial need. By 1934, most states had such "pension" plans. Even at the state level, however, these plans were inadequate. Some had restrictive eligibility criteria which resulted in many of the elderly being unable to qualify. The most generous plan paid a maximum of $1 per day. In the Congress, the consensus of conventional wisdom was for more old-age assistance like that available in the states. With the coming to office of President Roosevelt in 1932, and the introduction of his economic security proposal based on social insurance rather than welfare assistance, the debate changed. It was no longer a choice between radical changes and old approaches that no longer seemed to work. The "new" idea of social insurance, which was already widespread in Europe, would become an innovative alternative. Social insurance, as conceived by President Roosevelt, would address the permanent problem of economic security for the elderly by creating a work-related, contributory system in which workers would provide for their own future economic security through taxes paid while employed. Thus it was an alternative both to reliance on welfare and to radical changes in our capitalist system. In the context of its time, it can be seen as a moderately conservative, yet activist, response to the challenges of the Depression.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Social Security › SS – Generic

Social Security expansion is empirically used to further industry goals and prevent class conflict and full redistribution through concessions

Gonzalez and Wen 14 (Franciso, PhD in Economics from Boston University, Jean Francois, PhD at Queen’s University, The Economic Journal, “A THEORY OF TOP INCOME TAXATION AND SOCIAL INSURANCE”, - SH)

The Social Security Act of 1935 marks the birth of the welfare state in the US. It provided federal benefits to retirees and grants to states for the unemployed, old-age assistance, aid to dependent children, vocational rehabilitation, maternal and child welfare, and public health work.16 The New Deal programmes were legislated as social insurance to combat economic insecurity, with an emphasis on the fact that ‘funds for the payment of insurance benefits should not come from the proceeds of general taxation’ (President Roosevelt’s message to Congress on Social Security, January 17, 1935). However, they were accompanied by sharp rises in tax progressivity.17 Our interpretation is that the need for redistribution as an accompaniment to social insurance to avert social conflict was recognised at the time. Thus, while advocating the introduction of an inheritance tax, President Roosevelt stated: ‘Social unrest and a deepening sense of unfairness are dangers to our national life which we must minimize by vigorous methods’ (message to Congress on Tax Revision, June 19, 1935). He noted further that ‘The movement toward progressive taxation of wealth and of income has accompanied the growing diversification and interrelation of effort which marks our industrial society’. These comments point to the use of progressive taxation for securing industrial co-operation during the Great Depression. Domhoff (1990, 1996) discusses the identity of the power elite and the channels through which they exert their power, while Dal Bo et al. (2009) provide evidence of the remarkable persistence of political dynasties in the US.18 The important role of elites in the adoption of the 1935 Act has been stressed by Domhoff and also by Quadagno (1984, p. 645), who remarks that ‘[I]t is also important to explain why a piece of legislation with such a high level of ‘class content’, that is, a social-welfare measure, was implemented with almost no working-class input’.19 Alston and Ferrie (1993) observe that Southern large plantation owners formed a major segment of the US governing group for a century preceding 1970, operating through overwhelming Congressional committee control by the Democrats. The rural elite’s political objectives were to maintain low wages and to secure federal agricultural subsidies for large plantations. The Southern landowners ensured that the unemployment insurance component of the 1935 Act excluded farm workers and that public assistance programmes were administered by the states rather than the federal government. Alston and Ferrie also note that farm mechanisation in the 1950s significantly reduced the need for plantation workers and that it was increasingly in the interest of Southern landowners to promote the out-migration of blacks to Northern states. Thus, commenting on the Economic Opportunity Act, which was the centrepiece of the Johnson Administration’s War on Poverty, they argue that ‘it is extremely unlikely that the welfare state programmes of the 1960’s could have emerged from Congress without the countenance of Southern Congressmen’. The development of the welfare state since the Great Depression has been one of enlargement of insurable events and gradual extensions of eligibility to include more groups of individuals. The original Social Security Act excluded numerous job categories encompassing about half the working population. Coverage was added for various workers in subsequent decades. The 1950 Social Security amendments extended the old-age and survivors insurance programmes to about 10 million more persons. Self-employed farmers, homeworkers, and some self-employed professionals were added in 1954. The inclusion of disability benefits into the Social Security Act in 1956 is an example of an increase in transfers resulting from an enlargement of insurable events. The 1960 Social Security amendments increased federal grants to states to provide medical care for aged people receiving social assistance. Medicare and Medicaid were established in 1965. Old Age Insurance paid benefits to 16% of the aged in 1950, but to 92% by 1978 (Lampman, 1984).20 The total tax burden imposed by federal taxation has been approximately constant as a proportion of GDP from 1953 onwards but the composition has changed substantially.21 Social insurance contributions have risen steadily since 1950 while corporation income taxes have fallen by a similar magnitude beginning in 1953 (see Table 2.3 in the Budget of the United States, 2005). As payroll taxes are regressive and the corporation income tax is progressive, the replacement of corporate taxes with payroll taxes in federal receipts contributed to the decline in tax progressivity. Piketty and Saez (2007) find that the average federal tax rate, including individual, corporate, payroll and estate taxes, for the top 0.01% of the income distribution declined from 71.4% in 1960 to 59.3% in 1980, whereas corresponding rates faced by income groups between the 40th and the 95th percentiles were higher in 1980 than they were in 1960. Our interpretation of this decline in top income taxation is that a gradual lifting of supply-side constraints enabled more comprehensive social insurance coverage and, consequently, reduced the need for redistribution. Learning-by-doing and technical improvements in the administration of programmes and taxes played an important role in expanding coverage and lowering the cost of tax compliance. The payroll tax in the Social Security Act, for example, was a precursor to the general withholding tax on wages introduced in 1943. Quoting from US Senate Hearings, (1942, p. 136): ‘All of the employers have had 7 years’ experience [and] they will be in a much better position to do this job than they were to do the social security job back in 1936 when it first went into effect’.22 Furthermore, advances in record-keeping technology, especially automated data processing that originated during the Second World War are likely to have facilitated the extensions of social insurance programmes in the US in the 1960s and the 1970s.23

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Social Security › SS – Generic

Expansion of social insurance exploits efficiency to reduce the burden of the wealthy and prevent uprising from the working class

Gonzalez and Wen 14 (Franciso, PhD in Economics from Boston University, Jean Francois, PhD at Queen’s University, The Economic Journal, “A THEORY OF TOP INCOME TAXATION AND SOCIAL INSURANCE”, - SH)

5. Conclusions The advice given to the Prince of Salina in The Leopard — Giuseppe di Lampedusa’s famous portrayal of sociopolitical upheaval in nineteenth-century Italy — is: ‘If we want things to stay as they are, things will have to change’. In the same spirit, we have argued that, in the US, UK and Sweden, the wealthy responded to the threat of unrest brought about by the Great Depression by bearing a remarkable increase in top income taxation in the period 1930–60. But as new social insurance programmes and extensions of existing programmes targeted heterogeneous risks more finely over time, less redistribution through the tax system was required to avert social unrest. By 1990, programmes covered the major categories of risk faced by most households and transfers stabilised. Our main conclusion is that the development of the welfare state reflected the gradual substitution of social insurance for top income taxation as an efficient means of averting social conflict. We have abstracted from the roles commonly assigned to economic development and negative incentive effects in explaining the sources and the limits of the welfare state. We have shut down these effects to focus on the supply of social insurance and the role of economic risks. This reflects an important contrast between our view and one that equates a larger welfare state with larger efficiency losses. Instead, we see the growth in the number and complexity of transfer programmes as reflecting the exploitation of further efficiency gains. Our analysis has taken as given the pre-tax income distribution to focus on social policy. Conversely, analyses of the dynamics of the income distribution, particularly the top incomes, usually take social policy as given. We think that there are important insights to be gained from a better understanding of the joint evolution of the income distribution and social policy.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Social Security › SS – Generic

Social insurance is a way of preventing class conflict and makes real redistribution impossible, reinforcing existing class structures while avoiding conflict

Gonzalez and Wen 14 (Franciso, PhD in Economics from Boston University, Jean Francois, PhD at Queen’s University, The Economic Journal, “A THEORY OF TOP INCOME TAXATION AND SOCIAL INSURANCE”, - SH)

The development of the welfare state in the Western economies between 1930 and 1990 coincided with a puzzling pattern in the taxation of top incomes. Effective tax rates at the top increased sharply during the 1930s and 1940s, but then gradually decreased, even as social transfers continued rising. We propose a new theory of the development of the welfare state to explain these facts. Our main insight is that social insurance and top income taxation are substitutes for averting social conflict. Our detailed arguments build on the policy histories of the US, UK and Sweden. Social transfers grew spectacularly in the Western economies between 1930 and 1990. Meanwhile, tax rates on the top 1% of the income distribution increased sharply in the 1930s and 1940s but then decreased gradually between 1960 and 1990. This pattern of top income taxation is particularly striking in the US and the UK but it is qualitatively similar in other countries.1 Why was there so little change in social transfers until the Great Depression? If the state taxes the wealthy to supply transfers to others, why did top income taxes decline after 1960? We propose a new theory of the development of the welfare state to address these questions. A risk-neutral elite, or governing group, is presumed to have control over policy but it requires the cooperation of a risk-averse non-governing group to be able to produce. The interests of the governing group are aligned with the economic interests of the top of the income distribution.2 We characterise public policy as the outcome of Pareto efficient equilibria of a repeated game where in every period the governing group designs income transfers and the non-governing group makes a participation choice. The threat of conflict – non-participation in production – enables the non-governing group to obtain a part of the surplus from cooperation. Since the non-governing group is exposed to risks that private insurance markets fail to cover, the governing group has an incentive to provide redistribution in the form of state-contingent transfers, that is, social insurance. This allows it to secure social peace with smaller average transfers compared to providing pure redistribution. Our main insight is that insurance and top income taxation are substitutes for averting social conflict. This can explain the pattern of top income taxes and social transfers. Future incomes were perceived as riskier in the aftermath of the Great Depression, making social conflict more attractive. As social insurance coverage was initially inadequate for counteracting risk, an increase in redistribution financed by top income taxes was required to avoid conflict. We argue that constraints in revenue collection, record-keeping and programme administration necessitated, historically, an incremental approach to social insurance coverage. Consequently, the increase in top income taxation was reversed gradually as social insurance programmes matured to provide better coverage and conflict was made increasingly less attractive. Through the lens of our theory, the expansion of the welfare state can be understood as a process of exploitation of efficiency gains made possible by learning by-doing and technical improvements in public administration. This mechanism could not have operated before the taxation innovations resulting from the Second World War, nor after the 1980s, at which time all major social insurance programmes were in place and public administration records were fully computerised in the Western economies. Our view complements other explanations of the development of the welfare state, which are discussed in Section 1. In the 1951 annual report of the National Bureau of Economic Research, Arthur Burns described the unprecedented decline in the top income shares between 1930 and 1950 as ‘a transformation that has been carried out peacefully and gradually, but which may already be counted as one of the great social revolutions of history’ (Burns, 1951, p. 3).3 From our perspective, it is precisely the supply of social insurance by power elites who are not the main beneficiaries of the programmes, and the increased taxation of the top incomes, that underlaid this peaceful transformation in the distribution of national income. It is commonly argued that the increase in top income taxes in the period 1930–50 was a key factor preventing the top income shares from recovering after the Second World War, and also that the tax cuts after the 1960s precipitated the increases in the income shares of the very top of the distribution in several countries after 1980.4 These arguments, however, take as given the evolution of taxation, without addressing its causes. Our view is that the period of declining top tax rates was the concomitant of a more efficient supply of social insurance.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Link – UBI › Link – Working Class

UBI destroys working class – dismantles social programs, destroys jobs and industries, and hides the structural issue of capitalism (good w class analysis alt)

Booth 17 – [Adam Booth, "Universal basic income: utopian dream or libertarian nightmare?," In Defence of Marxism, 02/10/2017, ] /jsam

It is this context of a broken economic engine that we see the emergence of the demand for a “universal basic income”, or UBI: a uniform payment given to all in society, regardless of wealth or needs. The idea behind the UBI, in theory, is that it would break the link between work and pay, providing – on the one hand – workers who have been made redundant by robots a safety net that prevents them from getting stuck in low-paid, precarious jobs, whilst also allowing them to transition from obsolete industries into new, more productive sectors. And – on the other hand – enabling the capitalists to invest in automation and new technology without the moral anxiety (or, more importantly, the practical concern) of adding to society’s legion of the unemployed. Et voilà! The wheels of capitalism are well and truly greased: investment goes up; productivity increases; the economy grows – and meanwhile workers are able to smoothly move from one job to another for the rest of their lives. Would that it were so simple. The reality is that productive investment today is at an all-time low, not because of any principled apprehension about the fate of sacked workers, but because of the enormous levels of overproduction – or “excess capacity” as the bourgeois like to euphemistically describe it – that hang like an albatross around the neck of the global economy. The capitalists invest, not to provide jobs, meet needs, or develop the productive forces, but to make profits. If goods cannot be sold because ordinary families do not have the money to buy them, then industry will be mothballed. And if the bosses can get more profit out of ten exploited workers than from one shiny new machine, then the workers will stay in place and productivity will remain sluggish. Indeed, the relationship between work and pay has already been broken – but not in any positive sense. In all countries – both in the advanced capitalist countries and the so-called “emerging” economies – the share of wealth going to labour has decreased, with real wages remaining stagnant despite an increase in GDP. The working week grows longer, and yet take-home pay stays the same. Despite being raised on the basis of fundamentally false premises, the call for a UBI has nevertheless found an echo in this epoch of eye-watering inequality. Already, social and economic experiments involving UBIs are underway in a variety of countries, including Canada, Finland, and Holland. In Switzerland, a proposal for a SFr30,000 per annum (around £24,000 per year) UBI was rejected by 77% to 23% in a referendum on 5th June 2016. In Britain, meanwhile, the demand for a UBI has been raised by the leaderships of both the Labour Party and the Green Party. For those on the Left, the UBI is proposed as a progressive demand: a reinforced safety net, beyond the sticking plaster of the current welfare state, funded through increased taxation on big business and the rich. Raised in such a manner, it is clearly a demand – like any genuine reform – that should be supported and fought for. UBI, however, is not an inherently left-wing or progressive measure. The idea of a universal payment, in fact, has many advocates on the libertarian right. Indeed, even prominent bourgeois economists such as Milton Friedman have made similar proposals in the past, with his idea for a “negative income tax”. For these respectable ladies and gentlemen, the concept of a UBI has great appeal as an extremely streamlined version of – or, worse still, replacement for – the welfare state. In one fell swoop, these small government zealots suggest, one could “simplify” (read: slash) vast swathes of the taxation and benefits system, “eliminating bureaucracy” and “reducing market interference”. At the same time, one can clearly see the attraction of the UBI to the Schumpeterian liberals who preach the virtues of the invisible hand and the powerful transformative forces of “creative destruction”. Provide a primitive safety net, eradicate “barriers” to job creation such as the minimum wage, and give the anarchy of the market a free hand to destroy industries and jobs, without any planning or provision of education and retraining. It’s a libertarian’s dream – and a nightmare for the working class. Some free-market fanatics, meanwhile, have even advocated the idea of a relatively large UBI payment, but (and here’s the catch) only on the proviso that pesky public services – such as healthcare and education – are scrapped, i.e. privatised, and opened up to profit. Far from strengthening the conquests made by previous generations, therefore, one can see how the demand for a UBI can equally be raised by those looking to roll back and destroy such gains. Rather than increasing the welfare state in a progressive way by redistributing society’s colossal wealth, a UBI could instead become a deeply regressive fig leaf for a wholesale attack on – and privatisation of – public services, bolstering the capitalist market instead of weakening it. Marxists will fight for any reform that genuinely improves the living standards of workers and the poor. But in order to ascertain whether we can support this-or-that demand, we must first ask: is it really a reform that is being proposed, or – in fact – a counter-reform? In this respect, the call for a UBI in the abstract is meaningless. The devil is in the detail. Above all, it is necessary to analyse the question from a class point of view and look at who is raising the demand, and – most importantly – in whose (class) interest.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Link – UBI › Link – Working Class

Basic Income is a distraction to steer the working class away from the root cause of inequality

Esteban 18 – [Esteban Mercatante, economist, Left Voice, “Universal Basic Income: A Capitalist Fix to the Evils of Capitalism?” 08/07/2018, ] /jsam

Tens years after the Great Recession, some have proclaimed that the world has turned a corner, even if the turbulence of more the last couple years discredits such claims. The capitalist class is preparing new attacks on the living standards of the working class, which it must do in order to increase accumulation. A key part of this are the labor and pension (counter)-reforms being imposed around the world (from France to Brazil and Argentina). But UBI also has its part to play. The proposal for a UBI shifts debate from the terrain of class conflict to that of public policy and citizenry. This could be of great service to the capitalist class as it continues its attacks on the working class. After all, a dispute about the primary distribution of income always entails the danger that the exploited will question who controls social production and begin to organize. But if the debate is shifted to UBI, it becomes a question of secondary distribution, of income management and social security expenses. Some on the left defend UBI because it will supposedly “empower” the working class in its confrontation with capital. The logic is that an income that can cover the basic cost of living would give the working class greater bargaining power, since all workers would have a credible “exit” strategy. This position is defended by, for example, David Calnitsky in Catalyst. 7 However, this argument has some major weaknesses. All efforts by capital in recent decades have aimed at creating job insecurity, flexibility and fragmentation of the workforce. Calnitsky is right that working class power is today at a historic low. So, can we really expect the government to come up with a proposal for UBI that gets any closer to a livable income? Doing so would be naïve. Then, what we need to focus on is not a policy proposal that shifts the attention away from class struggle, but the task of organizing at workplaces, in the unions, for the working class to become again a force that needs to be reckoned with. Of course, the argument of those who propose a “dignified” basic income is not that it will come from state generosity, but that it must be achieved through struggle. However, as Alex Gourevitch and Lucas Stanczyk argue in Catalyst, There is consequently no prospect of the hoped for policy coming to pass until there is a working-class constituency that is organized and powerful enough to be able to extract it, in spite of the predictable resistance of superbly organized capital.8 Accepting the “end of work” and fighting for remuneration outside of employment does not bode well for a working class that aspires to become such a powerful social force. If anything, it can facilitate the new attacks of the ruling class. The “progressive” proponents of UBI are thus caught in a vicious circle. UBI is not a shortcut to the independent organization of the working class that its progressive proponents imagine. In contrast to these illusions, there is only one response to either neoliberal austerity or miserable handouts: the struggle to reduce the workweek to six hours a day, five days a week, and the redistribution of working hours among all those available to work. Around the world, the workload for those who have a job is increasing, while unemployment and underemployment grow alongside it. Data from the US show that, even though labor productivity has tripled from 1957 to today, the eight-hour day remains unchanged and businesses have found multiple ways to impose even longer hours. In the last decades, the time dedicated to work has increased. The same goes for Europe, and even more so for many dependent countries that have joined the networks of transnational production. Far from being “natural,” this is determined by capital’s need to increase its appropriation of surplus value at the expense of labor. Therefore we must raise the demand for the reduction of the working day by distributing the available work among all those who can work, without any loss in salary, thus guaranteeing all employed people an income based on the cost of living. This proposal seeks to question the seemingly “natural” character of the industrial reserve army. The conditions have been created for everyone to work fewer hours. But while capital is in power, some must continue working as many hours as workers did many decades ago while a growing part of the population is transformed into a “relative surplus population.” Thus, we have to question the private monopoly of the means of production. The IG Metall strike in Germany last year, in which hundreds of thousands of workers fought for the reduction of the working day,9 showed that this is an idea that can resonate deeply in important sectors of the working class (even if in this case the strike was called off by the union bureaucracy after it imposed a salary cut in exchange for a shorter working day). What stands in the way of distributing all available work among all those who want to work, decreasing everyone’s working day? Why should some of us have exhausting working days while others are condemned to unemployment and underemployment (with or without a UBI)? Why can’t we use technological advances to reduce the working day to everyone? Why do the workers who produce all the social wealth have to settle for crumbs from the capitalist state, while eight billionaires own the same wealth as 3.5 billion people? Capitalism has created the conditions for reducing the time required to produce all socially necessary goods. But for the vast majority of the world population to benefit from this enhanced productive capacity, we need to question the mechanisms of exploitation that sustain the current mode of production. Then the only “realistic” thing to do is to fight to abolish the capitalist system. We must clear the path for a mode of production that is no longer based on private profit but rather on meeting the social needs of everyone.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Link – UBI › Link – Commodification

UBI re entrenches logics of domination through expansion of the commodity form – defers the possibility of meaningful qualitative transformation

Harris ’23 (Neal Harris, Senior Lecturer in Sociology specialising in Critical Theory, 3-10-2023, "Critical Theory and Universal Basic Income," Sage Journals, -- MG

Taken together, the arguments above appear to present a powerful progressive case for introducing a UBI. In this section, I subject them to critique, drawing on the concepts of reification and real abstraction. I contend that while the quantitative advantages are undeniable, the qualitative changes UBI could bring are illusory as the implementation of UBI could in fact serve to reinforce the dominant modalities of thought and desire which exist within capitalist society. The adoption of the critical theoretical perspective is particularly valuable here, insofar as it enables a discussion of epistemic and depth-psychological concerns, which are often absent within traditional positivistic social research (see Delanty, 2020). Reification. Adorno and Horkheimer (1997) united insights from Weber and Marx, and crucially, from Lukács, in their seminal work on reification. For Lukács (1972), reification chiefly refers to the artificial distanciation between the subject and their external world which is induced by capitalism. The capitalist subject views the world in a disengaged manner, abstracted from their surroundings, 10 Critical Sociology 00(0) viewing others people, and their wider environment, as mere ‘things’, as ‘dead matter’ (Horkheimer, 1993: 81). For Lukács (1972), reification derives from ‘the fetish character of commodities’ and is ‘the subjective stance corresponding to it’ (p. 84). In a world which is governed by the exchange of commodities, a pathological form of consciousness comes to dominate. Reification is furthered by the market’s dependence on logics of false equivalence, what Lukács (1972) calls a ‘phantom objectivity’ (p. 6). The capitalist subject is encouraged to reduce their external world to exchangeable, purposeless matter which can be swapped for equivalent capital. The exchange value of a human liver is now commensurate with the exchange value of a certain weight of turnips, or of plutonium. The qualitative difference between the aforementioned objects is ‘written off as literature’ by the reifying logics of the market (Adorno and Horkheimer, 1997: 7). For critical theorists, the hegemony of such reified consciousness is a crucial obstacle to progressive transformation as it prevents the development of critical reason. A fundamental concern for critical theorists, when assessing UBI, therefore, is will it help ameliorate reified consciousness? In this regard, the answer is a resounding negative. Rather than furthering a co-operative approach to all social relations, ever more domains of social life will become controlled by the market. As Van Parijs and Vanderborght (2017: 12) argue, it is ‘fundamental to the concept of a basic income . . . that it is paid in cash’. We would then see an attendant expansion of the commodity form, because we will see an attendant expansion of market actors. The capital relation will now become more, rather than less dominant, as more actors become ‘consumers’, regardless of how their capital is ‘earned’. While the ‘hidden abodes’ of capitalism (Fraser, 2014) were undeniably irrational and inequitable in past social formations, they remained substantially immune from the reifying power of the market. For example, love, esteem and respect can be earned in a manner not mediated by wage-labour (Honneth, 1995). The introduction of a UBI would see ‘recognition’ taking the universal form of capital. Recall that for Van der Veen and Van Parijs (1986) UBI could displace the socialist stage of production in the route to communism as it would enable the development of a community who are socially conditioned to more readily embrace communistic values. However, when viewed through a critical theoretical lens, UBI serves to further entrench and embed reification and false equivalence. By expanding the field of consumers, and reaffirming capital as the fundamental method of affirming social recognition, UBI serves to reinforce a reified atomistic consciousness, rather than serving to enable the transition to a more communistic form of thought and sociality. Critical theory thus offers a warning against the implementation of a UBI: by expanding the market-mediated domains of the social world, the deeply pathological reified form of consciousness associated with capitalistic societies would further proliferate, rather than recede (see Delanty, 2020). This would serve to retard [ruin] prospects for qualitative socialistic transition as the reified form of thought associated with commodification and the capitalistic relation will be further enshrined, rather than challenged. Money and Real Abstraction. While the discussion of reification may seem abstruse in the applied context of the discussion of UBI, Alfred Sohn-Rethel’s (1978) increasingly popular work focusses explicitly on the relationship between money and cognition. In summary, the argument presented by Sohn-Rethel is that a society which is organised around money will inevitably reproduce logics of domination and bondage because money is at core a manifestation of petrified, abstracted labour time (Sohn-Rethel, 1978). While Adorno and Horkheimer’s work focussed on the market and its relationship to instrumental rationality, Sohn-Rethel’s insights enable us to focus explicitly on the relationship between money and impeded cognition. This is of real value to a critical theoretical investigation of UBI, which, as Van Parijs and Vanderborght (2017: 12) argue, must be paid in the form of money. Harris 11 For Sohn-Rethel (1978: 18–23), there is a fundamental pathology embedded within the logics of exchange which are connected to the transfer and holding of money. Importantly, this is not solely a psychological pathology, but a social pathology (see Harris, 2022). As Sohn-Rethel (1978: 20) argues the ‘economic conception of value is a real one’; while it lives only in the ‘human mind . . . it does not spring from it’. Rather, our actions, such as the everyday buying of selling of commodities with money represents a very real ‘social formation’ which induces a particular social synthetic form of cognition (Sohn-Rethel, 1978: 2). The ‘conceptual foundations of the cognitive faculty’ (Sohn-Rethel, 1978: 5) are shaped by the concrete forms of activity we take part in through our quotidian behaviour, such as buying bread or paying for petrol, whenever we hand over a note, or type in our pin. Crucially, the moulding of our cognition to that which is ‘socially necessary’ for capitalism occurs without subjects even ‘being aware of it’ (Sohn-Rethel, 1978: 20). Our use of money naturalises reductive ways of thinking and being, which are fundamentally in keeping with the structurally necessary logics of capitalism (SohnRethel, 1978). Expressed more formally, this means that money (the means through which UBI is to be administered) pathologically shapes the ‘dimensions of private consciousness’ (1978: 26) in a manner that denigrates the individual’s critical-epistemic and phenomenological capacities (see Thompson, 2022). As Sohn-Rethel (1978: 59) words it, ‘[a]nyone who carries coins in his pocket and understands their functions . . . bears in his mind, whether or not he is aware of it, ideas which, no matter how hazily, reflect the postulates of the exchange abstraction’. When we live in a society based on exchange we are forced to acquiesce unknowingly to forms of thought which reinscribe the abstract value of expropriated labour as the base equivalence of all social life. This occurs through cognitive processes that are connected to quotidian material acts, inescapable when living within a money-based economy. Such ‘real abstractions’ not merely serve to naturalise the capitalist system, but serve to impede efforts to disclose its contradictions. UBI is definitionally based around money; having real, accessible money in liquid form. It cannot be operationalised in any form other than through money, and it cannot be presented through extended services, or progressive tax rates. There thus seems no way around Sohn-Rethel’s position; progressive advocates of UBI are forced to either find grounds to reject his claim, relativise it or accept a foundational weakness to the UBI approach. There is no way for UBI to be implemented without recourse to money. Indeed, advocates of UBI have claimed it is a positive that more people are awarded more money; feminists in particular have expressed support that care labour could be rewarded by money through UBI (see Flanigan, 2018). As such, through the implementation of UBI, a dominating and oppressive feature of capitalistic society, money, would not merely be reinforced, but its domain would be expanded (see Martinelli, 2017). Indeed, this expansion itself is heralded as a cause for celebration by some feminist advocates of UBI (see Flanigan, 2018). When viewed through the lens of ‘real abstraction’, the dependence of UBI on money can be seen to further a form of domination which supports the capitalistic ‘social synthesis’ at the cost of the subject’s capacity to truly comprehend their relation to the external world (Sohn and Rethel, 1978: 60). The capitalist subject’s relationship to nature, to the Other, is hidden behind the veil of false equivalences, deeply connected to the money form. In short, UBI would further enforce an impeded cognitive capacity, which would defer the possibility of meaningful qualitative transformation.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Link – UBI › Link – Ruling Class

Universal Basic Income is nothing more than a naïve farce that assumes the ruling class will simply hand over the wealth they have horded for years.

Adam Booth, 10 February 2017, (“Universal basic income: utopian dream or libertarian nightmare?”, https://www.marxist.com/universal-basic-income-utopian-dream-or-libertarian-nightmare.htm)

The system is broken It is this context of a broken economic engine that we see the emergence of the demand for a “universal basic income”, or UBI: a uniform payment given to all in society, regardless of wealth or needs. The idea behind the UBI, in theory, is that it would break the link between work and pay, providing – on the one hand – workers who have been made redundant by robots a safety net that prevents them from getting stuck in low-paid, precarious jobs, whilst also allowing them to transition from obsolete industries into new, more productive sectors. And – on the other hand – enabling the capitalists to invest in automation and new technology without the moral anxiety (or, more importantly, the practical concern) of adding to society’s legion of the unemployed. Et voilà! The wheels of capitalism are well and truly greased: investment goes up; productivity increases; the economy grows – and meanwhile workers are able to smoothly move from one job to another for the rest of their lives. Would that it were so simple. The reality is that productive investment today is at an all-time low, not because of any principled apprehension about the fate of sacked workers, but because of the enormous levels of overproduction – or “excess capacity” as the bourgeois like to euphemistically describe it – that hang like an albatross around the neck of the global economy. The capitalists invest, not to provide jobs, meet needs, or develop the productive forces, but to make profits. If goods cannot be sold because ordinary families do not have the money to buy them, then industry will be mothballed. And if the bosses can get more profit out of ten exploited workers than from one shiny new machine, then the workers will stay in place and productivity will remain sluggish. Indeed, the relationship between work and pay has already been broken – but not in any positive sense. In all countries – both in the advanced capitalist countries and the so-called “emerging” economies – the share of wealth going to labour has decreased, with real wages remaining stagnant despite an increase in GDP. The working week grows longer, and yet take-home pay stays the same. Despite being raised on the basis of fundamentally false premises, the call for a UBI has nevertheless found an echo in this epoch of eye-watering inequality. Already, social and economic experiments involving UBIs are underway in a variety of countries, including Canada, Finland, and Holland. In Switzerland, a proposal for a SFr30,000 per annum (around £24,000 per year) UBI was rejected by 77% to 23% in a referendum on 5th June 2016. In Britain, meanwhile, the demand for a UBI has been raised by the leaderships of both the Labour Party and the Green Party. For those on the Left, the UBI is proposed as a progressive demand: a reinforced safety net, beyond the sticking plaster of the current welfare state, funded through increased taxation on big business and the rich. Raised in such a manner, it is clearly a demand – like any genuine reform – that should be supported and fought for. UBI, however, is not an inherently left-wing or progressive measure. The idea of a universal payment, in fact, has many advocates on the libertarian right. Indeed, even prominent bourgeois economists such as Milton Friedman have made similar proposals in the past, with his idea for a “negative income tax”. For these respectable ladies and gentlemen, the concept of a UBI has great appeal as an extremely streamlined version of – or, worse still, replacement for – the welfare state. In one fell swoop, these small government zealots suggest, one could “simplify” (read: slash) vast swathes of the taxation and benefits system, “eliminating bureaucracy” and “reducing market interference”. At the same time, one can clearly see the attraction of the UBI to the Schumpeterian liberals who preach the virtues of the invisible hand and the powerful transformative forces of “creative destruction”. Provide a primitive safety net, eradicate “barriers” to job creation such as the minimum wage, and give the anarchy of the market a free hand to destroy industries and jobs, without any planning or provision of education and retraining. It’s a libertarian’s dream – and a nightmare for the working class. Some free-market fanatics, meanwhile, have even advocated the idea of a relatively large UBI payment, but (and here’s the catch) only on the proviso that pesky public services – such as healthcare and education – are scrapped, i.e. privatised, and opened up to profit. Far from strengthening the conquests made by previous generations, therefore, one can see how the demand for a UBI can equally be raised by those looking to roll back and destroy such gains. Rather than increasing the welfare state in a progressive way by redistributing society’s colossal wealth, a UBI could instead become a deeply regressive fig leaf for a wholesale attack on – and privatisation of – public services, bolstering the capitalist market instead of weakening it. Marxists will fight for any reform that genuinely improves the living standards of workers and the poor. But in order to ascertain whether we can support this-or-that demand, we must first ask: is it really a reform that is being proposed, or – in fact – a counter-reform? In this respect, the call for a UBI in the abstract is meaningless. The devil is in the detail. Above all, it is necessary to analyse the question from a class point of view and look at who is raising the demand, and – most importantly – in whose (class) interest. As with all such reforms, the most pertinent question is: who pays? Where, one must ask, would the money come from? Indeed, it is this key point that right-wing opponents to UBI highlight. In the case of the Swiss referendum last year, the government came out against the £24,000 per year that was being proposed on the grounds of this amount being unaffordable (to put the proposed level in perspective, however, bear in mind that the cost of living in Switzerland is painfully high, and average salaries are around twice this suggested UBI amount). In places such as Finland, the “more reasonable” UBI suggested is the miserable sum of approximately £5,700 per year – a value that would be small change to the millionaires receiving it (don’t forget, it is an unconditional universal payment, after all), but that would actually leave the poorest who currently rely on the provision of means-tested benefits worse off. In order to provide a UBI payment better than what is currently on offer through the welfare state, some fairly significant tax increases would be required, as the Economist highlights with some hypothetical estimates: “Setting up a basic income would be no easy matter. To pay every adult and child an income of about $10,000 per year, a country as rich as America would need to raise the share of GDP collected in tax by nearly 10 percentage points and cannibalise most non-health social-spending programmes. More generous programmes would require bigger tax increases still.” Before continuing, let us make one thing crystal clear: the money clearly does exist to provide a decent UBI payment to all – and at levels far beyond $10,000. As has already been noted, according to the recent Oxfam report on global inequality, just eight billionaires own as much wealth as the poorest half of the world’s population. Meanwhile, big business in the USA sits on an idle cash pile of around $1.9 trillion dollars. The problem, however, is not economic, but political. To implement a genuinely progressive UBI would constitute the most ambitious and radical shake up of the redistributive taxation system since the cradle-to-grave welfare state was introduced in the post-war period. And yet, at a time when all these gains of the past are under attack from austerity, we see various well-meaning left-wingers calling for the UBI and proposing a titanic challenge to capital, with huge tax increases on the rich and corporations. Everywhere we look, social democracy and reformism is in retreat as a result of the crisis of capitalism. Elected “left” governments, such as Syriza in Greece and Hollande’s “Socialists” in France, far from carrying out progressive programmes of tax-and-spend, have been forced by the dictatorship of the banks to implement cuts and counter-reforms. But never mind all that: double or nothing! In this respect, the demand for a UBI is only the latest utopian proposal from a naïve layer of the left who imagine that austerity is ideological, and that we can – somehow, surely – persuade the rich and wealthy to kindly and quietly pass over the money for the good of society. This, at root, is what the advocates of UBI are relying on and hoping for: the benevolence and philanthropy of the capitalists and the establishment politicians who represent them. Whilst the occasional multi-billionaire such as Bill Gates might well part with a small portion of their vast fortune voluntarily for charitable causes (and even then, often only as a cynical PR stunt), the capitalist class as a whole – in the final analysis – are in business to make a profit. And they do not – and never have – appreciated having their private wealth forcibly taken from them to fund the rest of society; hence the almost farcical tax-dodging schemes that the world’s biggest businesses are scandalously embroiled in. As Warren Buffett, the renowned billionaire investor, stated emphatically after pointing out that he pays less tax than his receptionist: “there’s class warfare, all right – but it’s my class, the rich class, that’s making war, and we’re winning!” Again, we should stress that the wealth is most definitely there in society to fund a genuinely progressive UBI system. But the only way such a reform would ever actually be introduced in any meaningful way is if the capitalists felt threatened to the point that they feared losing everything; that is, if the class struggle reached such intense and heightened levels that the ruling elites offered reforms from above to prevent revolution from below. And even then, in such a situation, the demand would have to be not for UBI, but for socialist revolution! If the demand for UBI is to be posed and fought for by the Left, then it cannot be done so in a manner divorced from the question of class struggle. We cannot rely on the altruism of the rich and the compassion of the capitalist state, the essence of which – as Engels explained and Lenin underlined – consists of “special bodies of armed men” in defence of the property and interests of the ruling class. Particularly at a time when governments everywhere are prostrating themselves before the “invisible hand” of the market, therefore, it is pure utopianism to suggest that the capitalists will happily and calmly agree to hand over their wealth to fund a decent UBI, or that the bourgeois state would ever be willing to begin on undertaking such a task.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Link – UBI › Link – Ruling Class

UBI depends on the “benevolent” capitalists and cedes the current struggle against capitalism. Only a class-based revolution solves.

Booth ’17 [Adam, “Universal basic income: utopian dream or libertarian nightmare?”; 2-10-2017, In Defence of Marxism, https://www.bolshevik.info/universal-basic-income-utopian-dream-or-libertarian-nightmare.htm; JFan]

In this respect, the demand for a UBI is only the latest utopian proposal from a naïve layer of the left who imagine that austerity is ideological, and that we can – somehow, surely – persuade the rich and wealthy to kindly and quietly pass over the money for the good of society. This, at root, is what the advocates of UBI are relying on and hoping for: the benevolence and philanthropy of the capitalists and the establishment politicians who represent them.

Whilst the occasional multi-billionaire such as Bill Gates might well part with a small portion of their vast fortune voluntarily for charitable causes (and even then, often only as a cynical PR stunt), the capitalist class as a whole – in the final analysis – are in business to make a profit. And they do not – and never have – appreciated having their private wealth forcibly taken from them to fund the rest of society; hence the almost farcical tax-dodging schemes that the world’s biggest businesses are scandalously embroiled in. As Warren Buffett, the renowned billionaire investor, stated emphatically after pointing out that he pays less tax than his receptionist: “there’s class warfare, all right – but it’s my class, the rich class, that’s making war, and we’re winning!”

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Link – UBI › Link – Authoritarianism

UBI will not only perpetuate current capitalism but deepens the effect towards authoritarianism.

Frost 6-8 [David, “Universal basic income would put us on the road to authoritarianism”; 6-8-2023, Telegraph, https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/06/08/marxism-winning-as-welfare-for-all-becomes-mainstream/; JFan]

The latest twist on this idea comes from Silicon Valley. People like Elon Musk and Sir Tim Berners-Lee claim that soon AI will be so capable that it will be able to do virtually everyone’s job. They seem to take Marx’s original view, that capitalism will in the end leave a few people holding all the wealth and the workers will be immiserated – and so believe that only a UBI will give people the income they need in this new world of leisure. Of course it never works out like that. People have always said this about technological advances and they have always been wrong. New technology generates new jobs rather than kills them. But the UBI advocates will turn any argument to their cause. Left-wingers always think clever people can remodel society and that we are all just one new idea away from nirvana. As we know, that never works out well either. It doesn’t stop them trying. So now we have a plan for a trial scheme from Autonomy, an “independent, progressive research organisation”, for 30 people to be paid £1,600 a month for two years, with their lives monitored and compared with 30 people who must work for a living. (In fact it’s not the first trial: as so often with bad ideas, the Welsh “Government” got there first, with its own plan beginning next month.) The Autonomy trial is obviously laughable. Giving 30 people money for nothing for two years is hardly going to tell you anything useful. But it keeps the issue in the public eye. Bit by bit the Overton window, the range of politically possible ideas, is moving to accommodate it. UBI was always a marginal idea until recently. But unfortunately Covid collectivism and “sustainability” lifestyle lecturing have made all too many of us prey to the economic snake oil advocates. UBI is gradually moving from the fringe to the mainstream of Left-wing politics, at least if we assume that mainstream includes Andy Burnham, who has said he’d like to try it out in Manchester. So we need to rubbish it while we still can. The clearest argument against a UBI is that it makes no economic sense. Pay the income in the Autonomy trial to everyone of working age in Britain and it would cost about £700 billion a year. For comparison, last year all existing taxes and other receipts raised just over £900  billion, and the Government spent £1,040 billion. So, if nothing else changed, a UBI at this low level would nearly double the tax burden, and the government would spend something like three quarters of all the money in the country. That way madness lies. Taxes at that level would comfortably be the highest in the world and anyone who could leave would do so. Output would fall dramatically. Many would choose not to work more than they had to, relying on their UBI instead, so we would probably have to introduce some sort of compulsion to work. At that point we would be a super-corporatist, authoritarian quasi-fascist society – a country where private companies formally existed but everyone’s aims and aspirations would be subordinated to the government’s need, somehow, to keep the show on the road. Anyone who thinks such a society would not have social conflict or that people would be happier in it must be totally self-deluding.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Link – UBI › Link – Masking

UBI further masks the capitalist structure through the “management” of poverty and a reserve army of labor to keep the employed working class further down

Esteban 18 – [Esteban Mercatante, economist, Left Voice, “Universal Basic Income: A Capitalist Fix to the Evils of Capitalism?” 08/07/2018, ] /jsam

Money here and now, because there is no time to wait for great social transformations – that is the slogan of UBI proponents. They want to give every person a sufficient income to acquire the essentials, whether or not they have a job, whether or not they want to work, with no strings attached. Such a decoupling of the income of citizens from the obligation to work seems to some to be the only viable alternative in a world where the system of production throws growing numbers of workers to the side of the road. A basic level of economic and social rights would be universally guaranteed – without the need to expropriate the means of production or storm the Winter Palace. Since the capitalist state already outlays considerable sums, which in some cases are universal, such as the cash transfers offered to families with children by many states in Latin America, what major roadblocks could stand in the way of taking one more step, however great, down the same path? UBI proponents are certain that it is within reach, and this feeling is reinforced by the growing number of experiments by public agencies and NGOs to test the effects of implementing a basic income. This has occurred even though there is a great abyss separating “progressive” proposals, meant to ensure a “dignified” income, and state practices that aim only to manage poverty without eliminating it. It is no surprise, then, that Rutger Bregman gave his book about UBI the title Utopia for Realists. 5 This book summarizes the experiences from different times and places and also examines the arguments for and against UBI. One of the main objectives of Bregman’s book is to disprove the claim that handing out money for nothing leads to laziness. The author presents the conclusions of a pilot scheme implemented in 2009 in London by the Broadway Cares organization, which delivered 3,000 pounds to 13 homeless people. According to this study, in each case the aid “empowered” the beneficiaries. Utopia also presents the results of a study by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology on the performance of the NGO Give Directly, which collects money from donations and delivers it to beneficiaries in poor countries with no strings attached. This study shows a lasting increase in income (on average 38% higher than before the transfer) and an increase in assets and property, including homes (up 58%), as well as a 42% reduction in the number of days that children go hungry. Other examples abound. According to Bregman, there are different programs based on cash transfers that reach 110 million families in 45 countries (“from Brazil to India, from Mexico to South Africa”), the overwhelming majority of which have been implemented in the last 20 years. Focusing on the poorest sectors of society is of course not the same as implementing a UBI sufficient to lift everyone above the poverty line, regardless of their employment status, income and wealth. Bregman does refer to one experiment that took place from 1974 to 1978 in the Canadian town of Dauphin with 13,000 inhabitants. This program secured a basic income for the entire population and ensured that no one fell below the poverty line. Thirty percent of the population (one family in four) received monthly payments that in today’s currency amounted to $19,000 a year. With the arrival of a fiscally zealous new government, the program was canceled without any investigation of the results. Thirty years later, a study analyzed the program’s impacts on health statistics compared with similar populations that did not receive this benefit, and it showed that it was a success. There are currently trials that have been advertised as first steps toward a UBI in Canada, Holland, Scotland, Kenya and India. A “citizen’s wage” is even included in the program of the government coalition formed by the Italian Movimento 5 Stelle (M5S – Five Star Movement) and the xenophobic Lega Nord (LN – Northern League), part of a program that also calls for large company tax reductions. In their current stage, these proposals focus on the poor and the unemployed, just like many of the experiments that Bregman refers to. They also continue to run into similar difficulties over time. Finland announced a few months ago that its two-year program, in which 2,000 unemployed people between 25 and 28 years old received 560 euros a month tax-free, was ending on December 31, 2018. This decision was motivated by fiscal austerity as a result of a slowing economic growth, and has nothing to do with the program’s results, which, according to its organizers, can be assessed only after six years. Still, the amount of money provided was less than half of the 1,200 euros needed to avoid poverty in Finland. This fact shows that the proposals discussed by different nation-states are a long way from the paradise of free time without poverty that some leftists like to imagine. This basic income thus aims to be nothing more than a palliative measure. In the United States, for example, there is the SNAP program (“food stamps”) to provide food to people who cannot afford it. Payments such as this ameliorate the situation of the poorest sectors, but they do nothing to reduce income inequality between capitalists and workers, which has particularly exploded in the US since the 1980s. This type of program just allows this unequal income distribution to continue but with a bit less tension. Such a basic income that comes “from above” as a public social security policy will hardly be universal. Capitalist production is dependent on not only an active labor force, but also a pool of unemployed and underemployed that are ready to take up any vacancy. This “reserve army of labor” exerts a constant downward pressure on wages and has a disciplining effect on the employed sector of the working class. A government-provided allowance that enables workers to fully withdraw themselves from the labor market would dismantle this key mechanism of any capitalist system. For this reason, it will be focused only on very low-income sectors and will not even amount to a basic income, but be set at levels below the poverty line. This is the only way that a basic income can be compatible with the continued exploitation of labor in the conditions that modern capitalism in decline requires, especially in backward and dependent countries, but also in the richest imperialist economies. Basic income is a long way from being a progressive reform that ensures a decent income for all citizens. Public policies are caught between the demand for fiscal austerity and the need to contain discontent and make capitalism’s continued social degradation somehow bearable. As Michel Husson states, “Progressive partisans of an income of 1,000 euros per month may well serve as ‘useful idiots’ for the establishment of a universal income of 400 euros, for a final settlement that also advantageously reduces the operating costs of the welfare state.” 6

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Link – UBI › Link – Racial Cap

UBI’s inherent nature of extraction constructs the base for racial capitalism.

Zatz ’21 [Noah, Professor of Law at UCLA School of Law, 2-16-2021. “Basic Income and the Freedom to Refuse.” LPE Project. https://lpeproject.org/blog/basic-income-and-the-freedom-to-refuse/; JFan]

Criminal legal debt provides a revealing lens through which to examine universal basic income (UBI). It highlights a path to potential failure: fetishizing labor markets as the engine of economic inequality ignores how today’s criminal legal system carries forward racial capitalism’s techniques of targeted extraction. Yet recognizing this also opens a door to more robust visions of UBI that join together the powers of work refusal and debt refusal.

UBI’s radical appeal has been staked to its potential to enable in practice and convey in principle a refusal of the labor market. As Kathi Weeks explains in theorizing a “post-work imaginary,” this does not require an absence of work but rather its decentering as an organizing institutional and cultural principle. And UBI would simultaneously shift power relations within waged work (as well as between waged and unwaged workers in families & communities), the centerpiece of Erik Olin Wright’s embrace of UBI as “eroding capitalism” over time.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Link – UBI › Link – Generic

Fiscal Redistribution including basic income under the current system fails to address inequality effectively and leads to hyper-capitalism

Jackson & Victor 21 – [Tim Jackson, Centre for the Understanding of Sustainable Prosperity, University of Surrey, and Peter Victor, Faculty of Environmental Studies, York University, "Confronting inequality in the “new normal”: Hyper‐capitalism, proto‐socialism, and post‐pandemic recovery," PubMed Central, 05-04-2021, ] /jsam

The two key structural factors, which determine the evolution of inequality under a declining growth rate, are (1) the savings rate and (2) the elasticity of substitution between labor and capital. Depending on the configuration of these factors, two radically different futures may emerge. Under one future, which we have described here as “hyper‐capitalism” (Scenario 1), a constant savings rate and high substitutability between capital and labor lead to accelerating inequality, even under a progressive combination of redistributive measures. Under another kind of future, which we describe as proto‐socialism (Scenario 2), a declining savings rate and low substitutability between capital and labor, lead to declining inequality, which in combination with progressive redistributive policies, have the potential to eliminate inequality almost completely. Turning next to redistributive policies, the most striking finding from our model is that even relatively progressive policies, which impose a combination of higher differential tax rates, taxes on capital and a basic income (funded from returns to capital) remain ineffective in the long run in bringing down structural inequality under the hyper‐capitalism described in Scenario 1. Higher capital to income rates, constant savings rates, and the rigorous protection of rates of return on investment lead inevitably to the “explosive” inequality highlighted by Piketty, and the best efforts of progressive fiscal policies are unlikely to be able to halt this rise. Even the much vaunted “solution” of a basic income fails to curb the inevitable rise in inequality under such conditions (Scenario 1). In the “proto‐socialism” of Scenario 2, on the other hand, this same combination of measures is strikingly effective. By the end of the run (Figure ​(Figure7),7), inequality between capitalists and workers is almost entirely eliminated. Hyper‐capitalism is likely to emerge in a world where labor is increasingly (and easily) substituted with capital and the interests of the owners of capital are privileged over the rights of workers. These privileges encourage capitalists to continue to save even as the growth rate declines, leading to a rising capital to output ratio and an escalating inequality. Such a scenario could, for example, accompany a world in which an aggressive drive towards automation or the implementation of artificial intelligence (AI) by monopolistic companies removes the need for wage labor across large swathes of the economy. Failure to protect the livelihoods of the immiserated work force facilitates continued savings and investment by asset owners. By the same token, it concentrates incomes (and wealth) increasingly in a minority of the population, leading to the kinds of dystopian trends in inequality illustrated in Scenario 1. 13

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Link – UBI › Link – Generic

UBI doesn’t address the root cause of poverty and inequality – only the alt can provide the necessary class analysis in order to improve material socio-economic conditions

Cope ’19 (Dylan Cope, , 8-15-2019, "Universal Basic Income," ) -- MG

But whilst a UBI could in theory provide a safety net for the most vulnerable, the fact remains that the proposal is still only a mild form of redistribution. At root, it does nothing to challenge the unchecked power, property, and profits of the billionaire class. Any UBI money handed out, after all, would simply end up flowing upwards into the pockets of the parasites and profiteers. In the final analysis, a UBI system would ultimately maintain the broken status quo of the profit motive and the anarchy of the market, doing nothing to stop the chaotic crises of capitalism that have caused unemployment and cuts to social services in the first place. Right-wing support Indeed, UBI is not an idea unique to the left. In fact, many conservative and libertarian thinkers see UBI as a golden opportunity. One of the earliest proponents of a similar proposal, for example, was none other than Milton Friedman, a key economic advisor to Thatcher. The right-wing argument is that if everyone has a guaranteed income, there would be no need for public services that are free at the point of use, such as the NHS. This individualist outlook would mean people could opt into the services they wanted and not have to pay for services they didn’t use. For example, why should they pay for children’s education if they don’t have a child? Why should they financially support cancer treatments if they do not have cancer? In short, the aim of these right-wingers is to use UBI to get rid of the welfare state and unleash the market into every sphere of human life. This is at a time when even the UN have recently produced a report stating that: “much of the glue that has held British society together since the Second World War has been deliberately removed and replaced with a harsh and uncaring ethos.” UBI is also attractive to big business owners as yet another way for the state to subsidise the low wages currently offered by the bosses; as another method by which the capitalists can continue suppressing workers’ wages and boosting profits, all the while offloading the social burden onto the rest of society. Get to the roots This again shows how UBI does not challenge the fundamental problem at the heart of the matter: the question of economic ownership. Inequality is only the symptom – capitalism is the disease. It is the capitalists’ private ownership over the economy that causes such massive inequality within society, with an accumulation of profits at the top, and an accumulation of poverty amongst the rest. It is therefore wrong to call UBI a ‘radical change’. Marx said that to be radical is to grasp the root of the matter. And the root of poverty, inequality, and all social ills is precisely the capitalist system, based on private ownership, competition, and production for profit. By merely tinkering with how society’s wealth is distributed, UBI does nothing to get to the actual cause of the problem. As any gardener will attest, if you do not tackle the root then the weeds will continue to return!

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Link – UBI › Link – Generic

UBI lacks a concrete solution, with various people supporting or opposing the implementation.

Hogg ’23 [David James, “‘The Left will find that it has bought a Trojan Horse’: The dialectics of universal basic income”; February 2023, Sage Journals, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/02610183221092151; JFan]

On the surface, basic income does indeed appear radical, suggesting that its appeal ‘seems to lie partly in its very transgressiveness’ (Sloman, 2018: 638). But there are also dangers posed by its implementation, which is evident from the bourgeois support for UBI both historically and today.

A ‘shape-shifting social policy’

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Link – UBI › Link – Generic

Basic income is a policy for the capitalist. It only worsens existing wealth inequalities between the capitalists and working class. We need a reorganization of our labor system to truly address these inequities.

Esteban Mercatante ‘18 {Esteban is an economist from Buenos Aires and a member of the PTS.} - ("Universal Basic Income: A Capitalist Fix to the Evils of Capitalism?," Left Voice, published 8-7-2018, accessed 7-11-2023, https://www.leftvoice.org/universal-basic-income-a-capitalist-solution-to-the-evils-of-capitalism/)//marlborough-am/

This basic income thus aims to be nothing more than a palliative measure. In the United States, for example, there is the SNAP program (“food stamps”) to provide food to people who cannot afford it. Payments such as this ameliorate the situation of the poorest sectors, but they do nothing to reduce income inequality between capitalists and workers, which has particularly exploded in the US since the 1980s. This type of program just allows this unequal income distribution to continue but with a bit less tension. Such a basic income that comes “from above” as a public social security policy will hardly be universal. Capitalist production is dependent on not only an active labor force, but also a pool of unemployed and underemployed that are ready to take up any vacancy. This “reserve army of labor” exerts a constant downward pressure on wages and has a disciplining effect on the employed sector of the working class. A government-provided allowance that enables workers to fully withdraw themselves from the labor market would dismantle this key mechanism of any capitalist system. For this reason, it will be focused only on very low-income sectors and will not even amount to a basic income, but be set at levels below the poverty line. This is the only way that a basic income can be compatible with the continued exploitation of labor in the conditions that modern capitalism in decline requires, especially in backward and dependent countries, but also in the richest imperialist economies. Basic income is a long way from being a progressive reform that ensures a decent income for all citizens. Public policies are caught between the demand for fiscal austerity and the need to contain discontent and make capitalism’s continued social degradation somehow bearable. As Michel Husson states, “Progressive partisans of an income of 1,000 euros per month may well serve as ‘useful idiots’ for the establishment of a universal income of 400 euros, for a final settlement that also advantageously reduces the operating costs of the welfare state.” 6 UBI or the Redistribution of Working Hours?Tens years after the Great Recession, some have proclaimed that the world has turned a corner, even if the turbulence of more the last couple years discredits such claims. The capitalist class is preparing new attacks on the living standards of the working class, which it must do in order to increase accumulation. A key part of this are the labor and pension (counter)-reforms being imposed around the world (from France to Brazil and Argentina). But UBI also has its part to play. The proposal for a UBI shifts debate from the terrain of class conflict to that of public policy and citizenry. This could be of great service to the capitalist class as it continues its attacks on the working class. After all, a dispute about the primary distribution of income always entails the danger that the exploited will question who controls social production and begin to organize. But if the debate is shifted to UBI, it becomes a question of secondary distribution, of income management and social security expenses. Some on the left defend UBI because it will supposedly “empower” the working class in its confrontation with capital. The logic is that an income that can cover the basic cost of living would give the working class greater bargaining power, since all workers would have a credible “exit” strategy. This position is defended by, for example, David Calnitsky in Catalyst. 7 However, this argument has some major weaknesses. All efforts by capital in recent decades have aimed at creating job insecurity, flexibility and fragmentation of the workforce. Calnitsky is right that working class power is today at a historic low. So, can we really expect the government to come up with a proposal for UBI that gets any closer to a livable income? Doing so would be naïve. Then, what we need to focus on is not a policy proposal that shifts the attention away from class struggle, but the task of organizing at workplaces, in the unions, for the working class to become again a force that needs to be reckoned with. Of course, the argument of those who propose a “dignified” basic income is not that it will come from state generosity, but that it must be achieved through struggle. However, as Alex Gourevitch and Lucas Stanczyk argue in Catalyst,

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Link – UBI › Link – Generic

A Universal Basic Income sustains the neoliberal order while increasing child, pension, and worker poverty and rolling back social programs

O’Boyle 21 – [Brian O'Boyle, lecturer at St. Angela’s College, "A Socialist Case Against Universal Basic Income," REBEL, 7-5-2021, ] /jsam

The Left Case Against Basic Income The most striking feature of the UBI literature is the gap between its abstract promise of social improvement and the amount of money typically proposed as a payment. To allow people to avoid unsafe and degrading work a progressive UBI would presumably have to ensure a living wage. According to the Low Pay Commission in Ireland, this would mean €12.30 per hour or €460 for an average working week. With 3.5 million adults in the country this would cost €83 billion annually or more than the total amount of public spending in a normal year. To put this in context, the social protection budget for 2021 was just €25 billion meaning at least a threefold increase that would have to be paid for by taxing the rich. A progressive UBI would also have to protect the current level of service provision, meaning at least a doubling of public spending overall. Even if the rate was reduced dramatically to €1,000 per month for every citizen, it would cost €42 billion annually – far more than the current system could sustain without an enormous transformation in power relations. Faced with these realities, progressives typically capitulate to neoliberal common sense, arguing for a UBI set at a fraction of these figures. In his report to the British Labour Party for example, Professor Standing references several potential models, each of which would give people a tiny fraction of what they require to live with dignity – between £50 – £100 per week. He also references a pilot scheme advocated by the think-tank, Compass, which would give people £292 per month and simultaneously take away their existing entitlements. Even the authors of the Compass Report admit that, set at such a low level, UBI would be catastrophic, with child poverty estimated to increase by 10%, pension poverty by 4% and poverty among the working poor by 3%. When contrasted with these proposals, Social Justice Ireland’s seems more appealing, proposing a UBI of €650 per month. This would cost €40 billion annually, however, requiring a universal flat income tax rate of 40% and the loss of all core social welfare payments, except illness and disability benefits. Once again, the idea of living with dignity would be replaced with the dystopian reality of less money for welfare recipients and regressive taxes on the rest of us. Despite coming from progressive sources, each of these schemes inadvertently reproduces Milton Friedman’s vision of a UBI, replacing hard won social gains with a minimal weekly payment. Far from supporting a progressive challenge to neoliberalism, this would be a capitulation to it for two interrelated reasons. Firstly, it would be a step towards a purer form of market society as the cash nexus becomes more prominent and privatisation becomes more likely. Over the last 40 years neoliberals have attempted to wedge the market ever further into our lives, while dismantling key parts of the public sector. Once a UBI became generally acceptable, it is likely that a neoliberal state would put major pressure on the provision of public services, in favour of opening up spaces for capital to profit. In a society that has already commodified much of the housing stock it would potentially be a trojan horse for the private sector in healthcare and education. Thus, rather than de-commodifying our lives, this would extend the logic of capitalism instead of reducing it. Secondly, it would encourage employers to reduce their wage bill, safe in the knowledge that workers already had a minimal payment and no alternative welfare to fall back on. Viewed in this light, a UBI could very well represent a transfer from workers to unscrupulous employers who already have a track record of paying low wages topped up by the welfare state.