2023
GDI
Affirmative
Case – advantages › Squo fails – general
Bivens, chief economist at the Economic Policy Institute and Banerjee, economic analyst for Economic Policy Institute, 2022
[Josh, Asha, “Inequality’s drag on aggregate demand,” Economic Policy Institute, May 24, 2022, https://www.epi.org/publication/inequalitys-drag-on-aggregate-demand/, accessed July 13, GDI-TM]
Fiscal policy has been even less effective than monetary policy in reining in inequality and alleviating demand constraints. The federal tax and transfer system can impact inequality by spending more on safety net and social insurance programs (transfer programs) that benefit households at the bottom, and taxing more at the top. One way we can estimate the efficacy of the tax and transfer system is by calculating the transfer rate, which is tax credits and deductions and transfers a household receives as a share of its pre-tax-and-transfer income. The transfer rate differs among households at different points in the income distribution just as tax rates do. Figure G shows the net transfer rate (the transfer rate minus the federal tax rate), to depict how much pre-fiscal incomes for each income group have been buoyed or reduced by the effect of taxes and transfers since 1979. In this period, the net effect of taxes and transfers has always boosted incomes for the bottom 40%, and since the early 1990s has even boosted incomes for the middle fifth of the income distribution. The fact that the transfer rate for the bottom fifth of households exceeds 40% confirms that our progressive tax system is working at least somewhat as designed: the lowest-income households don’t have to pay large amount of taxes and they receive government benefits to help them meet their needs (though the U.S. social safety net is weaker than in other countries).4
2023
GDI
Affirmative
Case – advantages › Inequality debate › Income and wealth inequality increasing
Siripurapu, Council on Foreign Relations, 2022
[Anshu, “The U.S. Inequality Debate”, Council on Foreign Relations, 4/20/22, https://www.cfr.org/backgrounder/us-inequality-debate, 7/11/23 GDI- SC]
Moreover, inequality in the United States outpaces that of other rich nations. This is captured by the steady rise in the U.S. Gini coefficient, a measure of a country’s economic inequality that ranges from zero (completely equal) to one hundred (completely unequal). The United States’ Gini coefficient was forty in 2019—the same as Bulgaria’s and Turkey’s, and significantly higher than that of Canada, France, and Germany—according to the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), a group of advanced economies.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
Case – advantages › Inequality debate › Income and wealth inequality increasing
Siripurapu, Council on Foreign Relations, 2022
[Anshu, “The U.S. Inequality Debate”, Council on Foreign Relations, 4/20/22, https://www.cfr.org/backgrounder/us-inequality-debate, 7/11/23 GDI- SC]
* Figure omitted
2023
GDI
Affirmative
UBI + 1AC › The Advantage: › Solvency
Pinto, Universidade do Minho, ‘20
[Jorge, “Environmentalism, Ecologism, and Basic Income”, Basic Income Studies Vol 15.1 https://doi.org/10.1515/bis-2019-0026accessed 7-11-2023 GDI-FLC]
The compatibility between a BI and ecological sustainability is not, however, obvious (Andersson, 2010). One question immediately comes to mind: if one of the causes of the current ecological crisis is the productivist model of the economy, based on the ever-increasing extraction of natural resources, over-consumption, and the search for permanent economic growth, will not an extra income contribute even further to the promotion of such a system? Questioning the existence of an environmental justification for the BI, Van Parijs presents two possible reasons why the Greens would support the implementation of a BI, concluding that there is a fundamental, albeit indirect, relationship between BI and ecological issues.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
UBI + 1AC › The Advantage: › Solvency
Hasdell et al., Postdoctoral Research Fellow with the Stanford Basic Income Lab, 2021
[Rebecca, Juliana Bidadanure, Sarah Berger Gonzalez, Healthy Communities and Universal Basic Income: A Conceptual Framework and Evidence Review,” Stanford Basic Income Lab, January 2021, https://basicincome.stanford.edu/uploads/healthy-communities_ubi-paper_final.pdf, accessed May 7, 2023, GDI-TM]
In the absence of a truly universal and unconditional program delivered at scale, policies and programs that share some features with a UBI are used to draw conclusions about the policy’s likely impacts. The outcomes from these UBI-type programs on individual outcomes across contexts has been summarized at length in several systematic reviews of the literature.1 Findings from an umbrella synthesis of existing reviews and reports of the UBI literature are generally positive that UBI-type programs help alleviate poverty and increase economic security through savings, investment and production with minimal impacts on labor market participation. Positive impacts have also been observed for educational attainment and health status (Hasdell 2020). A wider range of social determinants have been pursued by researchers, but evidence is more limited for these outcomes, especially because the geographic scope of the evidence base is narrow. Owusu-Addo, Renzaho and Smith (2018), for example, find evidence for the impact of conditional and unconditional cash transfers on material and psychosocial circumstances, sexual risk behaviors, adolescent empowerment and utilization of health services in sub-Saharan Africa, but they note that cash transfer pathways or mechanisms to improving individual health remain largely unexamined.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
UBI + 1AC › The Advantage: › Solvency
The Undercommons, 2017
[The Undercommons is a freedom school in Los Angeles that was started at UCLA. It works to provide oppressed peoples' social movements with the resources housed at universities, “No Racial Justice Without Basic Income” Boston Review May 3, 2017 accessed 6.23.23 GDI-TM]
The criminal justice system in the United States largely functions to insulate the politically powerful from the risks of their decisions, at both the literal and figurative expense of working-class communities of color.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
UBI + 1AC › The Advantage: › Solvency
Pinto, Universidade do Minho, ‘20
[Jorge, “Environmentalism, Ecologism, and Basic Income”, Basic Income Studies Vol 15.1 https://doi.org/10.1515/bis-2019-0026accessed 7-11-2023 GDI-FLC]
It is not surprising that ecologists look to this approach reluctantly. Even if technological solutions to com- pensate for the environmental impact of human activities are created and the separation between economic growth and consumption is achieved, should this happen after the loss of biodiversity (including the extinc- tion of animals and plants) or after passing the planetary boundaries beyond the point of no return – that is, the critical point after which the consequences for the planet are unpredictable – then it may be too late. Instead of taking a defeatist attitude toward the possibility of changing the economic system, advocates of ecologism will, in a proactive way, try to promote these changes, defending a model of prosperity that does not depend on economic growth (Jackson, 2017). For the sake of clarity, it is this vision of ecologism I subscribe to.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
UBI + 1AC › The Advantage:
Lawhon, Assistant Professor of Geography and Environmental Sustainability at the University of Oklahoma, and McCreary, Assistant Professor at the Department of Geography at Florida State University, 2020
[Mary and Tyler, “Beyond Jobs vs Environment: On the Potential of Universal Basic Income to Reconfigure Environmental Politics” Antipode, 28 January 2020, https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/anti.12604, Accessed 7/13/2023 GDI-HB]
Political conflicts between jobs and the environment remain trenchant as sociotechnical and environmental change exacerbate concerns about both disemployment and ecological collapse. Of course, at the global scale and in the long run, sustainability and livelihoods are not at odds: viable livelihoods are predicated on a sustainable earth. For specific individuals and job sectors in particular locations, however, environmental protection often conflicts with established ways of making a living. We argue therefore that the “jobs vs the environment” problematique is best understood through a geographical lens as a specific, located conflict. Various strategies have been put forward to mitigate this conflict, ranging from job training and relocation to support for local economies and worker ownership, yet these strategies remain constrained by the entanglement of income, labour, and local development.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
UBI + 1AC › The Advantage:
Lawhon, Assistant Professor of Geography and Environmental Sustainability at the University of Oklahoma, and McCreary, Assistant Professor at the Department of Geography at Florida State University, 2020
[Mary and Tyler, “Beyond Jobs vs Environment: On the Potential of Universal Basic Income to Reconfigure Environmental Politics” Antipode, 28 January 2020, https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/anti.12604, Accessed 7/13/2023 GDI-HB]
Environmental politics has and continues to be shaped by a fundamentally uneven distribution of the benefits of the global economy and the costs of production. As we argued above, this includes social and spatial variance in job losses which will be likely with any radical socioecological change. Our argument is that a UBI enables a more just distribution of these costs and benefits, and that this is particularly important for enabling support for sustainability during times of rapid change. First, it reduces the vested interest of communities in maintaining specific sectors of employment. While many may still prefer to retain their jobs, a UBI would mitigate the direct and indirect impacts of job losses in resource extractive industries. Second, UBI provides additional leverage to workers and local communities in negotiations with extractive capital. The threat of relocation or closures still exists, but proximate residents, workers and their dependents, and local governments can demand environmental protections from stronger negotiating positions. Third, it effectively subsidises the non-capitalist economy, enabling people to build alternative community economies that reduce the overall dependence on the circulation of extractive capital. It can expand the economic horizons of resource-dependent communities by reducing community dependency on resource extraction and enabling people to share the economic benefits produced from the wider economy.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
UBI + 1AC › The Advantage:
Moranta et al, Senior researcher at the Ecosystem Oceanography Group, 2021
[Joan, “Transcending capitalism growth strategies for biodiversity conservation” Conservation Biology, 18 August 2021, https://conbio.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/cobi.13821#cobi13821-bib-0060 Accessed 7/15/2023 GDI-HB]
We suggest conservationists liaise with political ecologists and ecological economists to underline the problems and contradictions in the relationship between growth and biodiversity. We argue here that capitalism's metabolism is not compatible with an economy that respects the limits of the biosphere. The negative impact of economic growth on biodiversity is evident in the literature, and environmental and biodiversity conservation programs grounded in economic growth are ineffective. To ensure growth, continuous extraction of value from and commodification of nature is required to safeguard the capital, which in itself constitutes one of the most critical contradictions of capitalism. A capitalist economy not only exhausts the material basis for its reproduction, but also deteriorates the biophysical conditions that enable life on Earth (Foster et al., 2010; Harvey, 2014; Moore, 2015). Capitalism's commodification of nature and its derived conservation policies, such as payments for ecosystem services and biodiversity offsets, will result in perpetuating the growth-based status quo.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
UBI + 1AC › The Advantage:
Pinto, Universidade do Minho, ‘20
[Jorge, “Environmentalism, Ecologism, and Basic Income”, Basic Income Studies Vol 15.1 https://doi.org/10.1515/bis-2019-0026accessed 7-11-2023 GDI-FLC]
The enduring social and global climate crises are challenging society to look for alternatives to existing economic models. Nevertheless, in order to move away from the existing situation of unsustainability (Barry, 2012) we face, old solutions will hardly be enough, as the Anthropocene is characterised by countries already living above their limits.1 This is strongly suggested by indicators such as the ecological footprint and the planetary boundaries. With the ecological footprint we conclude that according to the goods and services we use, human- ity currently needs the regenerative capacity of 1.6 Earths (WWF, 2016). The concept of planetary boundaries is particularly interesting. It consists of the definition of boundaries for nine Earth system processes that should not be passed in order for the planet to remain within “safe operating space”, with four of those systems having already passed beyond the limit (Rockström et al., 2009; Steffen et al., 2015).
2023
GDI
Affirmative
UBI + 1AC › The Advantage:
Taiwo Associate Professor of Philosophy at Georgetown University 2021
[Olufemi, “Universal Basic Income, Racial Justice, Climate Justice” LPE Project 02/15/21 7/11/23 CB]
Basic income can inoculate us as well from the worst aspects of economic crisis – the kind that the COVID-19 crisis proved are powerfully linked to the natural world. Our system’s current failures to distribute vaccines, then, are a bad omen of what’s to come.But whether or not basic income plays this role comes down to the second of our two distinctions. Some (especially on the political right) treat basic income as a replacement for other aspects of our social system that currently work to secure people, like unemployment assistance and food stamps. This approach tries to (or pretends to) treat all forms of protection as interchangeable through the medium of currency would likely on net work out to only further precarize marginalized people. But Black, Indigenous, disabled, and trans people, particularly those who are women or gender nonconforming, are not a check away from solving all of the problems of insecure housing, safety in their homes and personal lives, and environmental risk that our institutions must address specifically and by means more broad than what can be accomplished via cash transfer. This basic income-as-substitution approach, UBI-, doesn’t live up to the promise of collaborative security. But basic income could be tethered to a larger body of transformative political moves, rather than a replacement for them. Dorian Warren of the Economic Security Project, who also helped develop the Movement for Black Lives’ section on basic income, wrote about one possibility in this vein. He is in good company in African-American political history, noting that “both Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. and the Black Panther Party to argue for full employment and a ‘guaranteed income’ for African Americans specifically and all Americans more than fifty years ago.” His version is “identical to most UBI proposals”, save for the inclusion of “a pro-rated, additional amount for black Americans over a specified period of time.” This would safeguard universal economic security through a strategy of “targeted universalism” that both responds to the history of racial slavery and injustice in and by the United States and anticipates the effect of future, persisting racial injustice on African-Americans’ life chances. The time for this kind of broad based, collaborative security is now. As the climate crisis accelerates, we risk our social system warping around its old and longstanding inequalities. By century’s end we may face persistent forms of climate apartheid and climate colonialism, in which inequalities within and across countries are increasingly tied to the extent to which families, communities, and whole nations can pay to deal with the consequences of a warming planet. Our current trajectory risks genocidal realities – perhaps most dramatically if our governments continue to respond to movement across borders with border militarization and warehousing, and to social upheaval within them by means of increasingly violent and exploitative policing and caging. The pandemic should serve as a grave wake up call. The virus, after all, was just one part of the deeper political problem: how our society distributes risk, vulnerability, and security. Since our global society is built on racial capitalism, distributes these in a deeply stratified way, where different tiers of society experience markedly different levels of risk of exposure to environmental, financial, and interpersonal harm and violence. Responding to such a system must involve more than challenging this or that political leader or installing a few solar panels. It calls for us to find a way of protecting ourselves beyond the cannibalistic, violent model Provided by the history of racial capitalism that built so much of today’s world – to find a way to protect ourselves by protecting each other. Basic income is one way forward.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
UBI + 1AC › The Advantage:
Iannuzzi & Oishi, Assistant and Professor of Phycology, 21
(Jazmin Brown Iannuzzi, assistant professor at the University of Virginia, Shigehiro Oishi, professor of psychology at the University of Virginia, Racial Inequality at the Brink: How Economic Inequality Exacerbates Racial Prejudice and the Potential Alleviating Role of a Universal Basic Income”, https://www.russellsage.org/sites/default/files/racialprej_LOI_example.pdf-grh)
In the U.S., both economic inequality and racial economic inequality – or the unequal distribution of financial resources across racial groups – is large and growing. From 1983 to 2016, the median White family went from approximately 8 times to 13 times more wealth than the median Black family (Pew, 2016). More recently, the pandemic has left Black families more vulnerable to death by COVID-19 and its economic shocks (Hardy & Logan, 2020; Wrigley-Field, 2020). Making matters worse, data suggest that income inequality precedes rises in White-on-Black racial prejudice (Connor et al., 2019; see also Hovland & Sears, 1940). Unfortunately, little empirical data investigates how inequality impacts individuals’ psychological processing and, in turn, increases prejudice. And, almost no work investigates the impact of inequality on racial minorities (Bianchi, 2020). Critically, inequality could also exacerbate prejudice between low-social power groups, stifling coalition building across these groups. The global pandemic’s widening of economic inequality makes now a crucial moment for understanding how inequality may exacerbate prejudice and for developing effective strategies to mitigate this process’s dire outcomes. The current application (1) puts forth a new hypothesis: inequality group-competition hypothesis, and (2) examines whether a policy, such as universal basic income, could mitigate the impact of inequality on prejudice (see Figure 1). We hypothesize that higher inequality triggers beliefs that people are in competition for limited resources because people tend to think the economy is zero-sum, meaning that one person’s higher earnings implies others’ lower earnings (Friedman & Friedman, 1990; related work see Buttrick & Oishi, 2017; Sommet et al., 2017). Perceiving others as competitors for scarce resources increases individuals’ concerns about their individual position and their groups’ position within society (Elliot, 2006; Esses et al., 2001). Status concerns activate both the desire to gain more resources for the self and group, as well as fear of losing relative position in the socioeconomic hierarchy (e.g., Davidai & Ongis, 2019; Sommet et al., 2017). Further, because inequality fosters the mindset of living in an intensely competitive environment, residents may be particularly attuned to group membership cues, such as race, as a way to determine whether someone has the potential to be economically beneficial (because they are ingroup member) or harmful (because they are an outgroup member). Providing for basic needs via a universal basic income may mitigate the impact of higher inequality on increasing prejudice by assuaging people’s zero-sum biases and their fears that others are competing for limited resources. However, to whom basic income is provided must be carefully considered to mitigate resentment toward a specific income and racial group.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
UBI + 1AC › The Advantage:
Siripurapu, Council on Foreign Relations, 2022
[Anshu, “The U.S. Inequality Debate”, Council on Foreign Relations, 4/20/22, https://www.cfr.org/backgrounder/us-inequality-debate, 7/11/23 GDI- SC]
* Figure omitted
2023
GDI
Affirmative
UBI + 1AC › The Advantage:
Siripurapu, Council on Foreign Relations, 2022
[Anshu, “The U.S. Inequality Debate”, Council on Foreign Relations, 4/20/22, https://www.cfr.org/backgrounder/us-inequality-debate, 7/11/23 GDI- SC]
Income and wealth inequality in the United States is substantially higher than in almost any other developed nation, and it is on the rise, sparking an intensifying national debate. The 2008 global financial crisis, the slow and uneven recovery, and the economic shock caused by the COVID-19 pandemic have deepened these trends and challenged policymakers to respond.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
AFF Answers - Fism DA › AT: Impact › States Can’t solve Climate
Blundell, School of Economic Sciences at Washington State University, Assistant Professor, et al. 21[Wesley, Mary F. Evans, Jerrine and Thomas Mitchell ‘66 Professor of Environmental Economics and George R. Roberts Fellow in the Robert Day School of Economics and Finance at Claremont McKenna College, Sarah L. Stafford, Ph.D. in Economics, Chancellor Professor of Economics and Department Chair, July 2021, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, Volume 108, “Regulating hazardous wastes under U.S. environmental federalism: The role of state resources”, , ccm]
We also find evidence that budget-constrained states decrease the number of resource-intensive on-site inspections at large RCRA facilities while increasing the number of lower-cost off-site inspections. Many of the off-site inspections are records reviews, which determine whether the facility has met the regulatory requirements for financial or other types of record keeping. Such inspections may be less effective in detecting regulatory violations that would have a direct impact on human health and the environment than on-site compliance evaluations. If so, then a potential worrisome consequence of this substitution is poorer environmental outcomes in states with shrinking environmental budgets.
Due to data limitations on monitoring and enforcement efforts at small quantity generators and other “non-large” RCRA facilities, we are unable to examine the impacts of decreases in state budgets at those facilities. However, given that there is no formal guidance, minimum standards, or oversight on monitoring at these facilities, it seems likely that decreases in state budgets would have similar, if not greater, impacts on agency efforts towards them. While one might be tempted to dismiss such impacts at these “non-large” facilities as being inconsequential, given the large number of such facilities (over 300,000 across the U.S.) the aggregate effect on environmental quality could be substantial.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
AFF Answers - Fism DA › AT: Impact › Fed K2 Solve Climate
Ricketts, Center for American Progress, senior fellow for Energy and Environment, et al., 20
(Sam, Rita Cliffton, manager for State and Local Government Affairs at the Center, Lola Oduyeru, manager for State and Local Government Affairs at the Center, Bill Holland, senior director for State Advocacy and Policy at the League of Conservation Voters, 4-30-20, Center for American Progress, “States Are Laying a Road Map for Climate Leadership”, , ccm]
And while states’ actions are lighting the way for federal lawmakers, there are limits in what they can do. States are restrained in their powers of investment by state constitutional requirements for balanced budgets, for example, and they lack the federal government’s power of the purse. This is especially important to note in light of the current pandemic-driven economic crisis. States lack the power to provide the large-scale national economic stimulus that is necessary to mitigate impacts related to the pandemic, making federal leadership critical. As Congress looks to invest in economic recovery, it should provide resources that sustain and expand state-driven clean energy, infrastructure, and conservation successes.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
AFF Answers - Fism DA › AT: Internal Links › State Courts Fail
Hays, Professor of Law, Columbia University School of Law, 1954
[Paul R., Jun. 1954, University of Pennsylvania Law Review, “Federalism and Labor Relations in the United States,” https://www.jstor.org/stable/3309892, Accessed 07/09/2023, BS]
Other efforts to induce the Court to return "to the due process philosophy that has been deliberately discarded" have been largely unsuccessful." The power of the Court over regulation of the right to organize and the right to strike have been confined to very narrow limits.'2 The Court, however, has decided certain cases involving racial discrimination in such a way as to suggest the possibility of its playing a role of great importance in the regulation of the whole field of col- lective bargaining.'3 Faced with this possibility in a recent case which did not present the element of racial discrimination, the Court, while denying recovery and somewhat limiting the implications of its prior decisions, did not indicate clearly a disposition to forego regulation of collective bargaining.14 But some of the lower federal courts have shown decided reluctance to accept further regulatory power.'5
2023
GDI
Counterplan
AFF Answers - Fism DA › AT: Internal Links › No IL- Fed Courts Key
Parmet, Northeastern University's Center for Health Policy and Law, Co-Director, 22
(Wendy E., 11-19-22, Scientific American, “Fights between U.S. States and the National Government Are Endangering Public Health”, , Accessed 7-8-23, ED)
These inefficiencies have been amplified by more than two decades of Supreme Court decisions that, in the name of states’ rights, have handcuffed the federal government’s ability to protect the public’s health. For example, in 1997, the Supreme Court ruled that the federal government could not command state officials to conduct background checks before gun sales. That decision explains why the federal government could not require the states to open or close schools during the pandemic, or require states to impose vaccination requirements. While the federal government can use its spending powers to induce states to comply with its policy goals, states can reject the money and refuse to cooperate.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
AFF Answers - Fism DA › AT: Internal Links › No IL – Congress Key
Hays, Professor of Law, Columbia University School of Law, 1954
[Paul R., Jun. 1954, University of Pennsylvania Law Review, “Federalism and Labor Relations in the United States,” https://www.jstor.org/stable/3309892, Accessed 07/09/2023, BS]
A federal constitution may carefully define the spheres in which the Federal Government or the constituent states shall operate to the exclusion of the other, or it may leave the allocation of functions to future determination. In the United States the allocation of control over labor relations under the constitutional power of Congress "to regulate commerce with foreign nations, and among the several states" ' may be looked upon as a continuing process of adjustment of the Fed- eral relation. The power to regulate may be left to the states, pro- hibited to the states, taken over by the Federal Government or given or returned to the states from time to time as occasion for change arises. Until 1937 the Supreme Court assumed the power to allocate con- trol of labor relations between states and Federal Government. By means of a generally restrictive, though somewhat flexible, definition of "commerce," the Court gave extensive powers to the states to the exclusion of the Federal Government. However, influenced by the trend toward national integration, particularly notable in the increase in size of operating economic units which was greatly accelerated by economic depression, and recognizing the inadequacy of judicial ma- chinery and doctrinaire solutions for meeting the growing complexity of economic problems, the Court, by broadening its definition of "com- merce," finally relinquished to Congress the power to allocate control over labor relations.