This set of deeply intertwined issues underscores the need for converting the U.S. military to civilian purposes and control. This section turns to the specific options and opportunities for a just transition of the U.S. military.
This transition requires nothing less than a complete dismantling and restructuring of this institution of war, firmly rooted under civilian control, toward the goal of creating an equitable and ecological society. There are three broad strategies to pursue as part of this just transition: spending reductions and reallocation; economic conversion to a peace economy; and assistance, retraining, and civilian repurposing for workers and veterans (D’Agostino and Rynn, 2019). Spending Reductions and Reallocation Demilitarization and just transition require decreases in military spending and a green fiscal shift toward meeting urgent social and environmental needs. Often it is a budget reduction that catalyzes deeper, more abiding conversions, yet such a curtailment must be combined with targeted reinvestments (Pemberton and Hartung, 2020). Military spending creates many fewer jobs than if those same funds were spent on healthcare, education, and clean energy and infrastructure, and jobs in these other sectors are on average equally well or better compensated (Peltier, 2019; Pollin and Garrett-Peltier, 2011). Shifting military spending to green manufacturing can support a just transition for regions of the U.S. experiencing declines in manufacturing, while scaling up lower-carbon energy infrastructure and public transportation, better preparing communities for impacts of climate change, and improving and expanding jobs in care work (Steichen and Koshgarian, 2020). A growing consensus is emerging around proposals to cut military spending. For example, a Defense Spending Reduction Caucus has been formed in the U.S. Congress, while an amendment was further introduced in 2020 to cut the Pentagon budget by 10% (Lee, 2020). This reduction is especially urgent in view of the need for and popularity of Covid-19 economic relief payments, and changes in rules to allow significant cuts to the DoD independently of non-defense spending. Even at just 10%, this reinvestment could achieve significant benefits across any number of priorities: housing half a million people, dramatically expanding coronavirus testing, bridging the funding deficit for majority non-white school districts, providing renewable energy to nearly every U.S. household, transitioning nearly every worker in conventional coal, oil, and gas sectors, hiring close to a million public school elementary educators, and so on (Steichen and Koshgarian, 2020). At a global level, the opportunities for shifting funding become even greater, given $2 trillion annually in global expenditures (half from the U.S.) on war and war preparations. Small percentages of this amount could end starvation or provide drinking water worldwide, reducing unrest, and improving well-being (World Beyond War, 2020). Economic Conversion In coordination with these shifts in budgetary priorities, a just transition requires converting from a military to a peace economy, including especially industrial planning and restructuring. Economic conversion refers to “political, economic and technical measures for ensuring the orderly transformation of labor, machinery and other economic resources now being used for military purposes to alternative civilian uses” (Melman and Dumas, 1990). Such efforts have been proposed and tested for decades, emphasizing the use of sector- and community-based planning for workers and communities dependent on defense and defense industries (D’Agostino and Rynn, 2019). Beginning with moves toward nuclear disarmament and the end of the Cold War in the 1980s and 90s, advocates and organizers seriously examined the necessary elements of conversion to a peace economy (Melman and Dumas, 1990; Pemberton and Hartung, 2020). In addition to spending reductions and reinvestment, successful economic conversion depends upon several key conditions. These conditions include availability of technical and financial assistance to firms, workers, and communities; supportive civil society measures including research, education, and legislation; and well-designed industrial policies and planning. Many examples of successful conversion can be traced at the level of firms, communities, bases, laboratories, and sectors since the end of the second world war. However, the size and complexity of the network of militarism in the U.S. now require a largescale industrial policy to achieve full disarmament and demilitarization (Pemberton and Hartung, 2020). Much has already been learned about scaling up economic conversions. Especially since the end of the Cold War, the work of Seymour Melman and colleagues, along with efforts of labor and trade unions, has provided a foundation for this comprehensive approach to economic conversion and industrial planning. These lessons reflect the fact that for decades, military priorities have served as the de facto plan for the U.S. economy, and markets are incapable of making the needed shift to peaceful economies (Eisenscher, 2014; Melman and Dumas, 1990). Supportive legislation nearly passed as early as 1963, while legislation such as the Defense Economic Adjustment Act has been introduced in various forms since the early 1990s (Swanson, 2010). More recently, Miriam Pemberton and others have put forward comprehensive strategies for defense transition that operate at all levels and are federally funded and resourced, and state- and locally coordinated and implemented (Pemberton, 2018). The scale and pace of change needed now demand new models for economic conversion. Demilitarization and conversion to a peace economy will require explicit industrial planning in public and private sectors, a challenge in the U.S. context to say the least. Nevertheless, several tools may provide a starting point if applied to the purpose of a just transition. One obvious measure is to implement new rounds of base closures through the Base Realignment and Closure process, especially including closures of overseas bases, and to shift the savings to just transition and civilian priorities. Closed bases and installations could serve as new sites for restored ecosystems and alternative energy generation (Crawford, 2019). Another measure would be to shift the focus of the Defense Production Act, which provides presidential authority to expedite and expand materials and services from U.S. industries, toward emergency preparedness. A specific focus would be to minimize hazards and impacts of climate change and protect and restore critical infrastructure—both built and natural—as needed for a just transition. In the context of climate emergency, a more direct approach to large-scale industrial planning could effectively reverse the function of the War Production Board, which was active during the wartime period. This mode of planning would instead convert factories from manufacture of weapons and military equipment to peacetime industries under public control, while conserving high-priority materials and limiting waste and luxury items. It is important to emphasize in the context of emergency preparedness and climate resilience, the point is not to extend military control but rather to unequivocally transfer resources and responsibility of the existing military apparatus to civilian control (Barber and Bennis, 2020). For example, civilian organizations such as the U.S. Public Health Service or the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention would assume responsibility for medical staff, equipment, and facilities. All these methods and more will need to be integrated over time within a broad strategy of demilitarized industrial planning for conversion to a peace economy. Assistance, Retraining, and Civilian Repurposing The third general strategy for a just transition of the U.S. military centers on the contribution of the workers and their communities toward minimizing ecological catastrophe and providing for basic needs. This strategy therefore involves coordinating targeted assistance, retraining, and transitioning current military service members and contractors toward peace economy sectors, industries, and services. Ensuring social assistance and retraining provides the baseline for a demilitarized just transition. Here again, experience offers many examples, including the various GI Bills, Vocational Rehabilitation and Employment Assistance, the Veterans Retraining Assistance Program and Transition Assistance Program, and so on. Often under the charge of the Department of Veterans Affairs, these programs have demonstrated their ability to make a meaningful difference to people transitioning from military to civilian life by providing assistance and benefits for education, housing, business support, counseling, jobs training, and monthly subsistence payments. Funds could be reallocated from the DoD to the VA including the Office of Transition and Economic Development to dramatically scale up financial and logistical support for these transitions. This process must also involve redirecting economic activity and livelihoods. This would involve retraining public employees displaced by the phase out of military programs and offering them meaningful work in other federal, state, or local agencies, as engineers and mechanics, electricians, public health workers, accountants, and so on (D’Agostino and Rynn, 2019). Many of these programs, historically and presently, emphasize private sector employment in anticipation that the market can supply the needed work. Here again, the present context requires a more targeted system of transition that aims to rectify existing social inequities and minimize ecological catastrophe. This means providing high-quality jobs to build and repair public infrastructure, construct public water and wastewater systems, clean up toxic and nuclear waste sites, restore ecological habitats, provide national and international disaster preparedness and relief, and build new and retrofit existing housing, libraries, and schools. Alongside these priorities, a just transition also calls for creating new opportunities for local manufacturing and production and worker-owned businesses and cooperatives, and providing technical and administrative assistance to communities facing these converging crises (D’Agostino and Rynn, 2019; Melman and Dumas, 1990). An especially relevant opportunity follows from the growing calls for a re-envisioned and permanent Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC), or a Civilian Climate Corps as proposed in the first days of the Biden Administration. The original CCC, sometimes known as Roosevelt’s Tree Army, operated from 1933 to 1942 as a New Deal public work relief program. The CCC was highly popular, employing millions, and completing a vast number of projects including planting trees, building parks and trails, fighting fires, and protecting soils. The CCC helped influence environmental programs and attitudes that continue to this day. Yet this program did not provide long-term, high-quality jobs, reinforced racial and gender inequities, and became militarized and subsumed under the war effort (Alexander, 2018; Heller, 2009; Maher, 2008). The just transition needed now would function differently. A reimagined CCC would create high-value work especially in ecological restoration and climate resilience, rectify inequities, and set a clear path for workers and communities to demilitarize in a way that is responsive to present and future needs (Aronoff et al., 2019). Boosted by funds reallocated from the military budget, a new Civilian Climate Corps could provide transitioning workers with well-paid union jobs as “conservation and resilience workers” who restore lands and waters, build green infrastructure, install solar panels and wind towers, sequester carbon in soils, protect biodiversity, clean up toxic waste, and much more (The White House, 2021). To align this initiative more closely with principles for a just transition, the program must center on the needs and priorities among Black, Indigenous, and People of Color (BIPOC), while providing skills needed for lifelong work in a demilitarized, post-fossil-fuel economy (Collier, 2021). Just as the military now serves as the nation’s largest federal employer, this repurposed program could further serve as a key element of a federal public jobs guarantee program, thus ensuring a viable transition for military workers, families, and communities.