Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 MNDI Kritik
Extend Impacts – Turns Case

The kritik turns solvency – stigmatizing the poor deters them from using the social services.

De Schutter, 2022 - Special Rapporteur on extreme poverty and human rights for the United Nations Human Rights Office of the High Commissioner [Oliver October 28, “Ban ‘povertyism’ in the same way as racism and sexism: UN expert”, https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2022/10/ban-povertyism-same-way-racism-and-sexism-un-expert, UN Office of the High Commissioner]

Negative stereotyping against those on low incomes is also rife in social services, where people applying for social benefits have reported being treated with suspicion and disdain. Millions of dollars in benefits are going unclaimed as a result, with potential beneficiaries preferring to avoid the humiliation of applying. This is a major reason for the non-take-up of rights which is severely weakening the world’s social protection programmes, the report said. “Poverty will never be eradicated while povertyism is allowed to fester, restricting access to education, housing, employment and social benefits to those who need them the most,” De Schutter said. “The world is finally waking up to the injustices of racism, sexism and other forms of discrimination, and putting laws in place to stop them from destroying people’s lives,” the UN expert said. “Povertyism is an affront to human rights, has no place in this world and must be treated just as seriously.”

2023 MNDI Kritik
Extend Impacts – Turns Case

The affirmative focuses on the wrong causes of poverty – they see it as an individual failing – this misperception prevents solutions to poverty

Hirschl et al, 2003 - Professor of Global Development at Cornell University [Thomas with Mark R. Rank and Hong-Sik Yoon December, The Journal of Sociology & Social Welfare “American poverty as a structural failing: evidence and arguments” ZR]

In recent times these debates have often been divided into two ideological camps. On one hand, poverty has been viewed as the result of individual failings. From this perspective, specific attributes of the impoverished individual have brought about their poverty. These include a wide set of characteristics, ranging from the lack of an industrious work ethic or virtuous morality, to low levels of education or competitive labor market skills. On the other hand, poverty has periodically been interpreted as the result of failings at the structural level, such as the inability of the economy to produce enough decent paying jobs. Within the United States, the dominant perspective has been that of poverty as an individual failing. From Ben Franklin's Poor Richard's Almanac to the recent welfare reform changes, poverty has been conceptualized primarily as a consequence of individual failings and deficiencies. Indeed, social surveys asking about the causes of poverty have consistently found that Americans tend to rank individual reasons (such as laziness, lack of effort, and low ability) as the most important factors related to poverty, while structural reasons such as unemployment or discrimination are viewed as significantly less important (Feagin, 1975; Gilens, 1999; Kluegel and Smith, 1986). This emphasis on individual attributes as the primary cause of poverty has also been reinforced by social scientists engaged in poverty research (O'Connor, 2001). As the social survey has become the dominant methodological approach during the past 50 years, and with multivariate modeling becoming the principal statistical technique, the research emphasis has increasingly fallen on understanding poverty and welfare dependency in terms of individual attributes. The unit of analysis in these studies is by definition the individual rather than the wider social or economic structures, resulting in statistical models of individual characteristics predicting individual behavior. Consequently, the long standing tension between structural versus individual approaches to explaining poverty has largely been tilted within the empirical poverty research community towards that of the individual. As Alice O'Connor writes, That this tension has more often been resolved in favor of the individualist interpretation can be seen in several oft-noted features in poverty research. One is the virtual absence of class as an analytic category, at least as compared with more individualized measures of status such as family background and human capital. A similar individualizing tendency can be seen in the reduction of race and gender to little more than demographic, rather than structurally constituted, categories (2001: 9). The argument in this article is that such an emphasis is misplaced and misdirected. By focusing on individual attributes as the cause of poverty, social scientists have largely missed the underlying dynamic of American impoverishment. Poverty researchers have in effect focused on who loses out at the economic game, rather than addressing the fact that the game produces losers in the first place. An analysis into this underlying dynamic is critical to advancing our state of knowledge regarding American poverty.

2023 MNDI Kritik
Links – Private Charities

Advocacies of private charities reinforce the rhetoric of poverty – they depersonalize and fetishize poor people.

Olsen, 2010 - Professor of Socio-Economics, Social Statistics at University of Manchester [Wendy “Poverty as a Malaise of Development: A Discourse Analysis in its Global Context”, https://www.escholar.manchester.ac.uk/api/datastream?publicationPid=uk-ac-man-scw:29857&datastreamId=SUPPLEMENTARY-1.PDF ZR]

Some people say that the charity discourse tends to commodify the people on whose behalf the organisations work (Wright, 2004). Wright’s closely argued paper on Café Direct advertisements, for example, reminds us that the people in advertisement cannot speak to/about us, nor can they see us; whereas we can see and talk about them. They remain anonymous. This is known as objectifying the person. Wright argues that it actually fetishises them, following up on Marx’s critique of capitalism. Marx’s notion of commodity fetishism refers to the perception of goods in terms of our relation with the goods or their prices, rather than our relation with the producers of the goods. Human relations (which are class relations), he says, are reduced to the relations between the consumer and the thing [the product]. – When Marx wrote, in the period 1860 to 1880, this was a vastly innovative thing to say. Even today, it appears in sociology texts but is not widely recognised in popular society. The ‘glamour’ and fashion industries rest firmly upon a denial of the fetishisation of the person. Perhaps you can see how, in charity discourse, even if the images show a happy healthy child, the poor person is still objectified and depersonalised. They are also not the agent of action! In charity discourse, the important agents are the donors and the intermediaries. A third agent is the media person or advertising expert. But all the agency aspects are subdued, and the moral aspect is primary. One is supposed to feel obligated to donate to mitigate the harm seen in the photos.

2023 MNDI Kritik
Links – Lazy Poor

The Affirmative treats persons in poverty differently – this undermines the respect and recognition that they deserve

Lister, 2005 – Professor of Social Policy Loughborough University [Ruth Jan 2005, “Poverty and Social Justice: recognition and respect” , EH]

The ‘politics of recognition’ is typically linked with the assertion of group difference and identity – by women, lesbians and gays, BME groups, disabled people. People in poverty do not want to be treated as different – indeed that’s the last thing they want. Instead their struggle is for recognition of their common humanity and citizenship and the equal worth that flows from that. But as we have seen, nonrecognition and disrespect are all too often the experience of people in poverty. Their struggle for voice is very much a politics of recognition. But, in order to reflect the language used by people in poverty themselves, I have called it a ‘politics of recognition and respect’. The philosophy behind it is summed up beautifully in an article in the Bevan Foundation Review by one of your trustees, Kevin Fitzpatrick: Equality of treatment, equality of outcome, depends crucially on everyone respecting everyone else just because they are human. This respect has to be recognised publicly and must be demonstrated by our institutions and the way they behave…To be treated as a human being is to be given the respect and dignity everyone deserves just because they are human (2003: 7). Fraser contends that the struggle for social justice requires the integration of a politics of redistribution and recognition. My own analysis of poverty leads to the same conclusion. Policy reform has to be directed towards tackling the material manifestations of poverty and ultimately its eradication. But so long as there are people living in poverty it must also address their lack of voice and the way in which they are treated by public institutions. In other words it must be informed by principles of equal citizenship.

2023 MNDI Kritik
Links – Lazy Poor

The assumption that poor people have poor work habits perpetuates a factually incorrect stigma – most of the poor work very hard.

Normington, 2018 – [Mark, 4-26-2018, "‘They’re poor because they’re lazy’," Medium, EV]

A common attitude nowadays is that people are rich because they work hard and deserve to be wealthy, whereas people are poor because they are lazy, feckless and incapable. Does this idea hold up? Many people living in developing countries actually work far harder than their counterparts in the developed world. For example, Mexico and Costa Rica have the longest average weekly working hours of the OECD countries at 42.9 and 42.6 hours respectively. Compare this with the average working week in the United States of 34.4 hours, and in the UK of . People living in poverty aren’t in that position because they’re too lazy to earn a decent wage. They’re in that position because their national economies aren’t very productive. For example, poor soil quality and a lack of mechanisation in agriculture mean that many farmers in developing countries have to spend many hours performing back-breaking work just to produce enough food to feed themselves and their families, let alone produce a surplus to sell. Many people living in the world’s poorest countries have no option but to send their children out to do manual labour, just to earn enough money to eat. The idea that these parents are so heartless that they would put their own children through this misery just out of their own laziness is not only offensive but downright ludicrous. We tend to lose sight of the role that luck plays in our lives. The lottery of birth is still an extraordinarily powerful determinant of how someone’s life will turn out. Those of us living in rich countries such as the UK benefit from centuries of history and economic development which we had absolutely no part in. It is because of this history that we have effective public institutions, democracy, high quality education and healthcare, comparatively high-paying jobs, etc. A person born in a rich country has a far greater chance of having a good standard of living than if that exact same person had been born in a developing country. The concept of natural economic justice — that people are rich or poor purely as a result of their own individual talent and effort — is both dangerous and demonstrably false. The world is full of examples of lazy, untalented rich people who are wealthy because of who their parents were; and intelligent, talented, hard-working poor people who, because of circumstances beyond their control, haven’t had the opportunity to improve their lot in life. The successful American investor Warren Buffett put it well when he expressed humility at the extent to which his own personal talent was responsible for his success: I personally think that society is responsible for a very significant percentage of what I’ve earned. If you stick me down in the middle of Bangladesh or Peru or someplace, you’ll find out how much this talent is going to produce in the wrong kind of soil. I will be struggling thirty years later. I work in a market system that happens to reward what I do very well — disproportionately . It’s important to recognise that how our life turns out is not only a result of our individual skill and effort, but are in large part down to luck. Donating to international development charities and supporting foreign aid to help those living in poverty overseas is, in part, recognition that if the lottery of birth had turned out differently, we could so easily have been in their position ourselves.

2023 MNDI Kritik
Links – Impossible to Solve Poverty

The rhetoric of helplessness obscures the fact that the existence of poverty is a Political Choice, not an inevitability of personal responsibility or vague social forces. Poverty exists because we Choose to all it.

Ross, 1991 Prof. of Law at the University of Pittsburgh [Thomas, June Georgetown Law Review “The Rhetoric of Poverty: Their Immorality, Our Helplessness”, , MZ]

2. Helplessness The contemporary Court's rhetoric of helplessness seeks to move the reader to a position beyond choice. The problem of poverty is presented either as a matter of personal transformation for which we cannot be responsible, or as a matter of such daunting complexity that we cannot solve it. The argument for judicial helplessness is expressed in the oft-repeated litany from Dandidge, the problem of poverty is "not the business of this Court."205 This profession of helplessness in the rhetoric of poverty is both revealing and obscuring. The "personal transformation" argument reveals the problem of individual responsibility in the matter of poverty. Some people do remain poor, in part, because they lack the will to change. The "too many forces" argument reveals the power of history and tradition. When generations of Americans have grown up with poverty as an enduring feature of the cultural landscape, the assumption that poverty is built into our society becomes difficult to change. In the process of revealing these features of poverty, however, the helplessness argument obscures another view of poverty. When Americans talk about poverty, some things remain unsaid. Mainstream discourse about poverty, whether liberal or conservative, largely stays silent about politics, power, and equality. But poverty, after all, is about distribution; it results because some people receive a great deal less than others. Descriptions of the demography, behavior, or beliefs of subpopulations cannot explain the patterned inequalities evident in every era of American history. These result from styles of dominance, the way power is exercised, and the politics of distribution. Poverty no longer is natural; it is a social product. As nations emerge from the tyranny of subsistence, gain control over the production of wealth, develop the ability to feed their citizens and generate surpluses, poverty becomes not the product of scarcity, but of political economy. Yet with few exceptions (such as some of the discussions during the Great Depression of the 1930s or the internal colonialism debate of the 1960s), this is not the way Americans have talked and written about poverty.2°6 This view of poverty reveals the fact that the existence of poverty involves an element of choice on our part.

2023 MNDI Kritik
Links – Exaggerated Welfare Spending

Their rhetoric exaggerates American spending on welfare – the US actually barely spends anything on social programs. This exaggeration is fearmongering which targets the poor.

Hirschl et al, 2003 - Professor of Global Development at Cornell University [Thomas with Mark R. Rank and Hong-Sik Yoon December, The Journal of Sociology & Social Welfare “American poverty as a structural failing: evidence and arguments” ZR]

The Ineffectiveness of the Social Safety Net to Prevent Poverty A second major structural failure is found at the political level. Contrary to the popular rhetoric of vast amounts of tax dollars being spent on public assistance, the American welfare state, and particularly its social safety net, can be more accurately described in minimalist terms (Esping-Andersen, 1990). Compared to other Western industrialized countries, the United States devotes far fewer resources to programs aimed at assisting the economically vulnerable (Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, 1999). As Charles Noble writes, "The U .S. welfare state is striking precisely because it is so limited in scope and ambition" (1997: 3). On the other hand, most European countries provide a wide range of social and insurance programs that largely prevent families from falling into poverty. These include substantial family or children's allowances, designed to transfer cash assistance to families with children. Unemployment assistance is far more generous in these countries than in the United States, often providing support for more than a year following the loss of a job. Furthermore, universal health coverage is routinely provided, along with considerable support for child care. The result of these social policy differences is that they substantially reduce the extent of poverty in Europe and Canada, while U.S. social policy has had only a small impact upon poverty reduction. As Rebecca Blank notes, "the national choice in the United States to provide relatively less generous transfers to low-income families has meant higher relative poverty rates in the country. While low-income families in the United States work more than in many other countries, they are not able to make up for lower governmental income support relative to their European counterparts" (Blank, 1997: 141-142). This effect can be clearly seen in Table 3. The data in this table are based upon an analysis of the Luxembourg Income Study (LIS) conducted by Veli-Matti Ritakallio (2001). Initiated in the 1980s, the LIS contains income and demographic information on households in over 25 different nations from 1967 to the present. Variables have been standardized across 70 data sets, allowing researchers to conduct cross-national analyses regarding poverty and the effectiveness of governmental programs in alleviating such poverty (for further detail regarding the LIS, see Luxembourg Income Study, 2000). Poverty in this analysis is defined as being in a household in which its disposable income is less than one half of the median annual income. Table 3 compares eight European countries and Canada with the United States in terms of their pre-transfer and post-transfer rates of poverty. The pre-transfer rates (column one) indicate what the level of poverty would be in each country in the absence of any governmental income transfers such as welfare payments, unemployment compensation, or social security payments. The post-transfer rates (column two) represent the level of poverty after governmental transfers are included (which is how poverty is officially measured in the United States and many other countries). In-kind benefits such as medical insurance are not included in the analysis. Comparing these two levels of poverty (column three) reveals how effective (or ineffective) governmental policy is in reducing the overall extent of poverty in a country. Looking first at the rates of pre-transfer poverty, we can see that the United States is on the lower end of the scale. Norway's pre-transfer poverty rate is 27 percent, followed by the United States, Canada, and Germany at 29 percent. The Netherlands pre-transfer rate is 30 percent, Finland stands at 33 percent, Sweden is at 36 percent, the United Kingdom rate is 38 percent, and finally, France possesses the highest level of pre-transfer poverty at 39 percent. When we examine the post-transfer rates of poverty found in column two, a dramatic reversal takes place in terms of where the United States stands vis-a-vis the comparison countries. The average post-transfer poverty rate for the eight comparison countries in Table 3 is 7 percent, whereas the United States' post-transfer poverty rate stands at 18 percent. As a result of their more active social policies, Canada and the European countries are able to significantly cut their overall rates of poverty. For example, Sweden is able to reduce the number of people that would be poor (in the absence of any governmental help) by 92 percent as a result of social policies. The overall average reduction factor for the eight countries is 79 percent. In contrast, the United States poverty reduction factor is only 38 percent (with much of this being the result of Social Security). Table 3 clearly illustrates a second major structural failing leading to the high rates of U.S. poverty. It is a failure at the political and policy level. Specifically, social and economic programs directed to the economically vulnerable populations in the United States are minimal in their ability to raise families out of poverty. While America has always been a "reluctant welfare state," the past 25 years have witnessed several critical retrenchments and reductions in the social safety net. These reductions have included scaling back both the amount of benefits being transferred, as well as a tightening of program eligibility (Noble, 1997; Patterson, 2000). In addition, the United States has failed to offer the type of universal coverage for child care, medical insurance, or child allowances that most other developed countries routinely provide. As a result, the overall U.S. poverty rates remain at extremely high levels. Once again, this failure has virtually nothing to do with the individual. Rather it is emblematic of a failure at the structural level. By focusing on individual characteristics, we lose sight of the fact that governments can and do exert a sizeable impact on reducing the extent of poverty within their jurisdictions. In the analysis presented here, Canada and Europe are able to lift a significant percentage of their economically vulnerable above the threshold of poverty through governmental transfer and assistance policies. In contrast, the United States provides substantially less support through its social safety net, resulting in poverty rates that are currently the highest in the industrialized world.

2023 MNDI Kritik
Links – Poverty Causes Crime

Poverty is not related to crime when you include white collar and corporate crime in the statistics.

eLearning Support Initiative, 2010 [Social Problems: Continuity and Change Acc 6/22/23 EH]

Social Class Findings on social class differences in crime are less clear than they are for gender or age differences. Arrests statistics and much research indicate that poor people are much more likely than wealthier people to commit street crime. However, some scholars attribute the greater arrests of poor people to social class bias against them. Despite this possibility, most criminologists would probably agree that social class differences in criminal offending are “unmistakable” (Harris & Shaw, 2000, p. 138). Reflecting this conclusion, one sociologist has even noted, with tongue only partly in cheek, that social scientists know they should not “stroll the streets at night in certain parts of town or even to park there” and that areas of cities that frighten them are “not upper-income neighborhoods” (Stark, 1987, p. 894). Thus social class does seem to be associated with street crime, with poor individuals doing more than their fair share. Social Class Explanations of this relationship center on the effects of poverty, which, as the next section will discuss further, is said to produce anger, frustration, and economic need and to be associated with a need for respect and with poor parenting skills and other problems that make children more likely to commit antisocial behavior when they reach adolescence and beyond. These effects combine to lead poor people to be more likely than wealthier people to commit street crime, even if it is true that most poor people do not commit street crime at all. Although the poor are more likely than the wealthy to commit street crime, it is also true that the wealthy are much more likely than the poor to commit white-collar crime, which, as argued earlier, can be much more harmful than street crime. If we consider both street crime and white-collar crime, then there does not appear to be a social class-crime relationship, since the poor have higher rates of the former and the wealthy have higher rates of the latter.

2023 MNDI Kritik
Links - Inevitability

Arguing that poverty is inevitable or impossible to solve because “it has always been there” is the rhetoric of helplessness – it is a self fulfilling prophecy because it hides the fact that we have Always had the ability to solve poverty – we Choose not to.

Ross, 1991 Prof. of Law at the University of Pittsburgh [Thomas, June Georgetown Law Review “The Rhetoric of Poverty: Their Immorality, Our Helplessness”, , MZ]

B. OUR HELPLESSNESS The other central theme of the rhetoric of poverty is helplessness. This theme is expressed in two related ways. First, poverty is said to be an inescapable societal tragedy that we are helpless to remedy.3 2 Second, in the legal rhetoric of poverty, judges profess to be helpless in their judicial role. Their helplessness places the particular legal problems related to poverty beyond the perimeters of their power and jurisdiction. Using this rhetoric of helplessness, judges sometimes concede that the problem of poverty may be capable of solution, and then assert that they, however, are not empowered to solve it. They identify someone else, typically the legislature, as the body empowered to address the problem. In cases dealing with poverty, the rhetoric of judicial helplessness sometimes incorporates the idea that poverty is an intractable, if not inevitable, social problem. In this sense of helplessness, the judges are helpless both as individuals (poverty is a complex and intractable problem) and as judges (in any event, we are without the power to deal with this particular issue relating to poverty).33 This sense of helplessness of both judges and the public in the face of poverty has a history that accounts in part for its contemporary presence and rhetorical power. 1. The Helplessness of Those Not in Poverty The idea that poverty in America is inherent or practically irremediable is commonly held today. Expressions like "there have always been poor peo- ple; there always will be poor people" are abundant in our discourse. 34 We bemoan the complex and intractable nature of the problem. Observers often interweave the premise of moral weakness with the argument for the intractable nature of poverty. 35 After all, if poverty is essentially a problem of moral weakness, if poor people must undergo a personal transformation, what can we do to affect such a change? Historically, we have often encouraged such a change on the part of the poor by making the conditions of poverty so appalling that we imagine poor people will do whatever it takes to avoid them.36 We are disappointed when so many poor people seem to insist on not mending their ways and, to our surprise, seem willing to go on living in the horrific conditions of poverty. This disappointment feeds the argument of helplessness. If poor people are unwilling to change their behavior and values in response to the strongest of incentives, the horror of life in poverty, what else can we do? Another version of the argument for helplessness is the characterization of poverty as a product of a mix of abstract forces and ideas, beyond our practical control. Poverty is built into the basic structure of our society, it is a product of our history, traditions, philosophies, political structures, and economic structures.37 Observers who espouse this view of the origins of poverty either see no realistic solution or else see a solution that entails the loss of our most basic social structures.38 This particular profession of helplessness is problematic because poverty arises out of the "politics of distribution.139 Poverty is not a matter of scarcity. We have more than enough to meet the basic needs of everyone in our society, yet we continue to speak about poverty as though it were a problem beyond the reach of our material resources. Perhaps the persistence of poverty leads to the idea that it is inherent in the structure of our society. But all that has ever been required to eliminate poverty is a redistribution of wealth. 4° Although the complex mix of history, traditions, and political structures may help to explain why Americans have chosen not to abolish poverty, it does not explain how that choice is a product of helplessness.

2023 MNDI Kritik
Links - Economics

Neoliberal economic discourse is a false poverty discourse – it patronizes, excludes, and blames poor people while ignoring social structures.

Olsen, 2010 - Professor of Socio-Economics, Social Statistics at University of Manchester [Wendy “Poverty as a Malaise of Development: A Discourse Analysis in its Global Context”, https://www.escholar.manchester.ac.uk/api/datastream?publicationPid=uk-ac-man-scw:29857&datastreamId=SUPPLEMENTARY-1.PDF ZR]

In brief: The charity discourse portrays us – the well-off – as able to ameliorate some poverty without intervening in any fundamental way to change the structure of social relations between poor and non-poor people. The social exclusion discourse portrays us – the well-intentioned government agencies – as able to target the poor for inclusion, without allowing people to engage freely in the discussion about how society should change. (Defining ‘freely’ in this claim is contestable; see Habermas for the argument that an immigrant or ‘outsider’ is not free to engage in the debate because the debate automatically excludes them; Habermas, 1998). Example of authors who challenge capitalism on grounds that it makes workers unfree to discuss poverty alleviation include Harriss-White (2006), and Fine (2001). Fine is particularly condemning of the social inclusion discourse. Finally, turning to the economists’ orthodox discourse, it portrays workers as choosing their own level of poverty. For this discourse everything is ‘chosen’. Agency is all. There is no role for structure. In recent years newspapers and governments have begun encouraging workers to make themselves more ‘employable’. This goes beyond formal education, as in the human capital model (which was hopeless enough for the poor). Now we have to make our c.v. lengthy, acquire office skills such as discipline and time-keeping, and document our new skills in ways recognized by employers, such as getting 12 National Vocational Qualifications no matter how tedious it is to produce the various portfolios and to welcome the inspectors. Inspectors and portfolios, as well as the audit culture of visiting to check files and poke noses, are now commonly found among self-employed, child care experts and health & safety, accreditation workers. All this arises from, and is consistent with, the employability theme in neoliberal thinking. Make yourself worthy of a job! Some underlying western ontological assumptions help to bolster the three false discourses. These discourses bely the possibility of real positive change. The assumptions include individualistic reductionism, oversimplification of the role of government, and nationalistic policy making.

2023 MNDI Kritik
Links - Underclass

The term “Underclass” reinforces the themes of the undeserving poor, of moral weakness, and the division between us and them.

Ross, 1991 Prof. of Law at the University of Pittsburgh [Thomas, June Georgetown Law Review “The Rhetoric of Poverty: Their Immorality, Our Helplessness”, , MZ]

Societal line drawing and moral censure took a brief detour in the 1960s. The "War on Poverty" was the product of a period of unrelenting growth in the gross national product and unbounded optimism about society's ability to abolish poverty without any real sacrifice. 24 During this time, people spoke of the cruel error of assuming a correlation between poverty and moral weakness. 25 As more Americans focused on the eradication of poverty, there was less interest in separating and stigmatizing the poor. Yet, as the "War on Poverty" came unraveled in the wash of blood, here and in Southeast Asia, and as people came to see the actual sacrifice entailed in eliminating poverty, the public discourse soon drifted back to the theme of moral weakness. 26 The rhetoric of poverty in the 1980s was exemplified by the myth of the welfare mother with a Cadillac and by the rise of yet another category of the poor, the "underclass."' 27 This new category of the poor included: (a) the passive poor, usually long-term welfare recipients; (b) the hostile street criminals who terrorize most cities, and who are often school dropouts and drug addicts; (c) the hustlers, who, like street criminals, may not be poor and who earn their livelihood in an underground economy, but rarely commit violent crimes; (d) the traumatized drunks, drifters, homeless shopping-bag ladies and released mental patients who frequently roam or collapse on city streets. 28 Membership in the underclass was determined by behavior which was either patently immoral or socially deviant. The concept of the underclass etched deeper the division between us and them. It also connected perfectly with the rhetorical theme of moral weakness. Except for some examples of the "traumatized" members of the underclass, the behavior that characterized the underclass was criminal, deviant, or that of a person without hope or dignity. The idea of the "passive" poor, people beyond hope and without any sense of initiative, expressed the pervasive notion that poor people were unwilling to pull themselves up by their bootstraps and were instead happy to feed at the public trough.29 The "underclass" thus was a late twentieth century form of the historically persistent category, the undeserving poor. And like its historical antecedents, the idea of the "underclass", seemed to be driven more by ideology than by any attempt accurately to generalize about the circumstances and nature of poverty in America. Michael Katz contrasted the idea of the underclass and the reality: [A]s a metaphor, the underclass obscures more than it reveals. It glosses over differences in condition that require varied forms of help, and it passes lightly over two salient features of poverty and welfare in America: their widespread and transient character. In the Michigan study, which followed a large sample of American families for 10 years.... [b]oth poverty and welfare use .. .lasted relatively briefly, and children whose parents relied on welfare were no more likely to need public assistance as adults than were others in the sample. What the study shows, in short, is that poverty is more accurately perceived now, as before in American history, as a point on a continuum rather than a sharp, clearly demarcated category of social experience. In truth, the forces that push individuals and families into poverty originate in the structure of America's political economy. Some of us are lucky, not different. 30 As a metaphor, the underclass is the perfect expression of the rhetorical themes of difference and deviance. Perhaps because it so perfectly expresses these persistent historical themes, it has remained as part of the public discourse on poverty notwithstanding its metaphoric and distorting quality.

2023 MNDI Kritik
Links – Means Testing

Identifying “the Poor” as a class focuses on their differences, which becomes deviances. This difference is used to label, stereotype, and stigmatize the poor.

Ross, 1991 Prof. of Law at the University of Pittsburgh [Thomas, June Georgetown Law Review “The Rhetoric of Poverty: Their Immorality, Our Helplessness”, , MZ]

Poor people are different from us. Most of them are morally weak and undeserving. And, in any event, we are helpless to solve the complex and daunting problem of poverty. This is the rhetoric of poverty. The United States Supreme Court has addressed the constitutional claims of poor people in a range of contemporary cases.' The rhetoric of poverty runs through these opinions. Poor people, it is said or implied, are unwilling to work and especially likely to commit fraud or child abuse, or to violate other legal and moral norms. They have bad attitudes and are the cause of their own poverty. At the same time, the problem of poverty is, in the Court's rhetoric, a problem of daunting complexity that is virtually beyond solution. Hard choices, suffering, even "Kafkaesque" results are simply unavoidable. The purposes of this article are to reveal the presence of these rhetorical themes in the Supreme Court's opinions and to argue that the Court's choices are disturbing. These themes, seen in the context of the individual cases, are either shamefully inapt or, at the very least, problematic. When we see that the Court's decisions are shored up by this rhetorical structure, we have good reason to question those decisions. The first rhetorical step, the creation of the abstraction the "poor," is an easily overlooked yet powerful part of the rhetoric of poverty. We are so used to speaking of the poor as a distinct class that we overlook the rhetorical significance of speaking this way. By focusing on the single variable of economic wealth and then drawing a line on the wealth continuum, we create a class of people who are them, not us. Creating this abstraction is, in one sense, merely a way of speaking. We do this because to speak of the world in sensible ways we must resort to categories and abstractions. There are meaningful differences between the circumstances of people below the poverty line and the circumstances of middle class people, and to ignore these real differences can lead to injustice.2 Thus, to speak of the "poor" is a sensible way to talk. In the rhetorical context, however, it is also much more. The creation of the category of the "poor", also makes possible the assertion of their moral weakness. To assert their moral weakness, "they" must exist as a conceptually distinct group. There is a long history of speaking of the poor as morally weak, or even degenerate.3 Thus, when we hear legal rhetoric about the poor, we often hear an underlying message of deviance: we are normal, they are deviant. Our feelings about their deviance range from empathy to violent hatred. Still, even in the most benevolent view, they are not normal. Their deviance is a product of a single aspect of their lives, their relative wealth position. All other aspects of their lives are either distorted by the label of deviance or ignored. By creating this class of people, we are able at once to distinguish us from them and to appropriate normalcy to our lives and circumstances. The rhetorical assertion of judicial helplessness is also connected to widely shared and long-standing cultural assumptions about the nature of poverty. This rhetoric depends on the assumption that poverty is somehow built into the basic structure of our society and system of law. We assume that the eradication of poverty, even if possible in theory, would require the radical transformation of our society. The causes of poverty, we assume, are a product of a complex set of factors tied to politics, culture, history, psychology, and philosophy. Thus, only in a radically different world might poverty cease to exist. And, whatever the extent of the powers of the Court, radically remaking the world is not one of them.4

2023 MNDI Kritik
Links – Poverty Statistics

Economists descriptions of the causes of poverty focus on why the poor are Different, and entrench the authority of major companies.

Olsen, 2010 - Professor of Socio-Economics, Social Statistics at University of Manchester [Wendy “Poverty as a Malaise of Development: A Discourse Analysis in its Global Context”, https://www.escholar.manchester.ac.uk/api/datastream?publicationPid=uk-ac-man-scw:29857&datastreamId=SUPPLEMENTARY-1.PDF ZR]

The Economic Discourse of Poverty The third poverty discourse is the one economists often use. The economics of poverty are seen as lying in causal explanations of why people and households are poor, and what it is about the non-poor that makes them different. Numerous famous economists can be cited – Dollar (2001), Dollar and Kraay (2001), Dollar and Gatti (1999), Rama (2003), Ravallion (1996), Ravallion and Datt (1996), for example. These economists hold certain types of theory dear. Firstly, there is the theory that people maximise their utility and try to better themselves, whilst also trading off paid work against more desirable leisure activities. Secondly, we have the theory of human capital. In this theory people’s earnings reflect their education and acquired skills. Investment in education is seen as rational individual choice, and if wages are low for a group (e.g. for women) then they may not invest in schooling because it won’t repay the investment l. The higher-response group, e.g. men, may get more investment because it is rational to prefer to invest where returns are higher rather than where returns are stagnant. Thus a mental model of a capital market is used to envision how decisions are made in the schooling market and labour market. Thirdly, the economists usually focus on firms as an important locus of decisionmaking. Firms pay wages, and the tradeoff here is that if they hire more people on lower wages, then poverty may go down, compared with hiring just a few people, in more capital-intensive work, on higher wages. Some economists advocate labour-intensive growth as a way to alleviate poverty. This approach accepts that low-wage work will predominate for the poor. It accepts high levels of economic inequality, while acknowledging that those who lack any paid work at all will suffer from poverty in modern industrialised societies. All the discourses share a sense that people will be better off if they can be enabled to earn a living and to make themselves better off. Thus at some anodyne level these discourses of poverty converge.

2023 MNDI Kritik
Links – Poverty Statistics

Focusing on poverty statistics distracts policymakers from seeing the poor as people – focusing on deeper structures is necessary to address exclusion.

Stephens, 2006 – School of Government at Victoria University of Wellington [Robert, 7/26/2006, Ministry of Social Development, “Poverty by Ruth Lister, Polity Press, 2004, The Poverty Wars by Peter Saunders, UNSW Press, 2005” https://www.msd.govt.nz/about-msd-and-our-work/publications-resources/journals-and-magazines/social-policy-journal/spj28/28-poverty-by-ruth-lister-polity-press-2004-the-poverty-wars-by-peter-saunders-unsw-press-2005-p197-199.html, - MZ]

Although this approach takes away the strictures both authors make about the arbitrary nature of most statistical poverty work, their warnings that poverty research must not be confined to ascertaining which groups in society will have a higher incidence of poverty are well made. Statistical measurement concentrates attention on lack of income as the cause of poverty, rather than asking what factors in society lead some individuals or groups to have a lack of income. Debate tends to focus on the level of the poverty standard rather than the factors required for individuals to function in society and achieve their capabilities, and measurement means that the dynamic, multi-dimensional and interactive nature of poverty is overlooked. Both authors want to move the poverty debate forward from income poverty into the analysis of deprivation (along the lines of the Ministry of Social Development’s Living Standards Survey – see Jensen et al. 2003); capability, functioning and social exclusion (see Salmond and Crampton 2001 for a New Zealand forerunner); and poverty dynamics (Ballantyne et al. 2004 provide a New Zealand foretaste). This wider perspective on poverty permits a better analysis of the causes and consequences of poverty and exclusion. Although Saunders is concerned with direct effects such as local labour market failings, or trigger events such as sick children or disability, Lister looks behind those issues in search of even deeper meanings, such as societal structures, denial of participation, infringement of human and citizens rights, and lack of voice and power. She places poverty in the context of socio-economic inequality and social class, and while social exclusion is separate from poverty, it provides a useful lens through which poverty can be analysed. The variables Saunders considers are more amenable to policy than those of Lister, and thus have greater potential for alleviation and amelioration of poverty. However, unless a longer-term strategy is taken to address the concerns that Lister raises, poverty will always be with us. And although local poverty research is moving from statistical measurement and concentration on income poverty into this deeper understanding, New Zealand is still vulnerable to a return to the 1990s when poverty (then known as “the P word”) could not be mentioned in official circles. Poverty became a political issue when the implications for health care outcomes and educational attainment were shown: neither book really spends sufficient space to demonstrate how the issue of poverty can be maintained on the political agenda, especially through the analysis of the consequences of poverty. Instead, Saunders concludes with a request for both a set of inter-related poverty indicators and a European Union commitment to address poverty. In her book, Lister remains above that requirement, knowing that the United Kingdom’s well-respected Child Poverty Action Group will be at the forefront of political advocacy. Instead, she makes us confront our own views and notions of the concepts of poverty, its definitions, measures and causes, so that ultimately the understanding of poverty can lead to the correct explanations and policy prescriptions.

2023 MNDI Kritik
Links - Speaking for The Poor

Poverty discourse presupposes the position of the speaker – “we” are not “them.” This social inclusion discourse creates social divisions, and patronizes, marginalizes and blames poor people.

Olsen, 2010 - Professor of Socio-Economics, Social Statistics at University of Manchester [Wendy “Poverty as a Malaise of Development: A Discourse Analysis in its Global Context”, https://www.escholar.manchester.ac.uk/api/datastream?publicationPid=uk-ac-man-scw:29857&datastreamId=SUPPLEMENTARY-1.PDF ZR]

Firstly, the speaker who uses the social exclusion/inclusion discourse engages in a contradictory moment, called a ‘performative contradiction’, by excluding the poor from autonomous action. Just by labelling them poor and making ‘them’ a them, and ‘us’ (the experts or the government) an us, the speaker creates a social division that tends to be patronising and disempowering for really poor people. Having a performative contradiction makes it impossible for policies drawn up under this discourse to attack the nerve centres of poverty creation. Instead, the policies are mainly ameliorative. I would go further and argue that ameliorative reforms in capitalism actually help to reproduce poverty and elitism. But this comes from my own position (see conclusion of paper) – instead let’s look more closely at an example to illustrate the performative contradiction. Milcher and Ivanov, 2008, define and discuss social inclusion as follows: Social inclusion is a relatively new concept promoted especially by the European Union (EU). The EU defines social inclusion as “a process which ensures that those at risk of poverty and social exclusion gain the opportunities and resources necessary to participate fully in economic, social and cultural life and to enjoy a standard of living and well-being that is considered normal in the society in which they live”. Thus, social inclusion is understood as both a relative concept where exclusion can only be judged by comparing the circumstances of some individuals (or groups or communities) relative to others . . . and as a normative concept which places emphasis on the individual’s right of “having a life associated with being a member of a community”. In order to achieve these rights, inclusion policies have to address institutional inefficiencies, which derive from exclusionary acts by agents based on power and social attitudes and result in multiple disadvantages based on gender, age, ethnicity, location, economic, education, health status or disability, etc.” (page 1; Milcher and Ivanov did not cite any reference for their quoted phrases) A stronger and more concerted rejection of structuralism in favour of individualistic reductionism is hard to imagine. Yet the rejection is subtly framed, taking the form of a positive statement in favour of human rights and against inefficiency. Who could disagree? The net result is that the discourse tends to leave poor people to blame for their position, and responsible for their own rescue. After all, it is they, not the state that create the inefficiency. They are not in the state that is so inefficient. The essence of the argument is that they are outside of the state. The tone of such writings is patronising and state-ist yet, ironically, (and confusingly) at the same time, liberal in the soft, ‘small,l’ sense of being socially progressive. Whilst progressive, such liberal views do not enable the “poor” to get into policy processes. Instead, they patronise poor people and keeps them separate from the well-educated, technocratic classes.

2023 MNDI Kritik
Links - Speaking for The Poor

Excluding the poor undermines their voice in democracy, reinforcing their powerlessness. This perpetuates the structure of poverty

Lister, 2005 – Professor of Social Policy Loughborough University [Ruth Jan 2005, “Poverty and Social Justice: recognition and respect” , EH]

A key element of participation from a citizenship perspective is political participation. A number of political theorists have posited the idea of a basic ‘right of participation in decision-making in social, economic, cultural and political life’ (Gould, 1988). Draft UN guidelines declare that ‘a human rights approach to poverty reduction…requires active and informed participation by the poor in the formulation, implementation and monitoring of poverty reduction strategies’. This goes to the heart of the voicelessness and powerlessness frequently identified as critical to their situation by people in poverty in both Northern and Southern hemispheres. Oxfam conceptualises poverty as ‘a state of powerlessness in which people are unable to exercise their basic human rights or control virtually any aspect of their lives’ (Hocking, 2003). Lack of voice is both a symptom of the political powerlessness of people in poverty and a cause of their often expressed feelings of powerlessness. As Nye Bevan observed, ‘silent pain evokes no response. The social reforms of the twentieth century are a consequence of the democratic power of the masses and not of increased enlightenment…Political democracy brings the welfare of ordinary men and women on to the agenda of political discussion and demands its consideration’ (1961, pp24-5).But in today’s democracy, even though we have a government committed to the eradication of child and pensioner poverty, the welfare of people in poverty is not very high on the ‘agenda of political discussion’ particularly at general election time. And excluded groups do not always feel that their views and interests are adequately represented through representative democratic institutions. Hence the growing calls for the voices of the marginalised to be heard in policy-making and campaigning. At a local consultation in Wales someone said: ‘We are not inferior – we are not deficient – but we are made to feel that way. You have the power to change things – listen to our voice!’ (CoPPP, 2000, p. 3). And a strong message from the consultation with children and young people carried out by the Child Poverty Task Group was that they should be listened to.

2023 MNDI Kritik
Links - Speaking for The Poor

Talking About the poor is method of constructing the poor as an “Other” – they are discussed, but never have their own voice.

Olsen, 2010 - Professor of Socio-Economics, Social Statistics at University of Manchester [Wendy “Poverty as a Malaise of Development: A Discourse Analysis in its Global Context”, https://www.escholar.manchester.ac.uk/api/datastream?publicationPid=uk-ac-man-scw:29857&datastreamId=SUPPLEMENTARY-1.PDF ZR]

However, social stigma and political exclusion are likely to follow from the degradation that is often (but not always) associated with economic poverty. Ironic, isn’t it then, that economic poverty continues to be very difficult to ask about in interviews in 2004? Part of the explanation is that economically poor people are usually construed as the other. In English phrasings, statements about ‘the poor’ typically imply that the speaker is automatically designated as non-poor. It is rare indeed for ‘poor’ people to talk about other poor people as such. Indeed one could argue that many people do not want to have a debate about either the poor or poverty. For instance, the UK government under ‘new Labour’ did not want to have a discussion about poverty as such, but rather about wealth creation. Another buzz phrase in use is ‘social protection’. ‘Indices of multiple deprivation’ were constructed. Deprivation would be construed as a failure to properly target and protect these areas. Social protection policies would include benefits and social support as well as pensions. In other words, by framing the scene a certain way, a positive light can be cast upon it, and especially upon the speaker or author. In this way, poverty disappears and something more pleasant – such as meaningfully targetted action - miraculously appears. Iyengar (1990) explains that the framing of poverty affects the politics of poverty. Yapa (1996) presents issues of subjectivity and reality with regard to poverty, helping to clarify how poverty discourses work. The ‘subjective’ realm is the one mainly set up using mental and linguistic constructs. 2 The way poverty is construed is itself a process of social construction. Poor people are construed (often air-brushed) out of existence. Yet poor people do exist, and many of us have personally experienced poverty at given points in life and understand something of what such a life is like. Poverty is a reality for poor people. Many poor people live in Salford. But it’s possible for them and others to collude in hiding the realities of their lives. Not only is the label hidden, but also the real day-to-day difficulties, the hard choices and suffering. In our study, we heard about the use of food stamps, of taking up free school meals, of ostracism and racism during our interviews. Yet always the stories were about ‘other’ people, ‘those’ people. Not us. The social construction of poverty was described by Maia Green as having a long history (2006). Green traces the historical predominance and usage of ‘poverty’ through a variety of schools of thought. These include anthropology in its early decades, the big international institutions as they construe poverty, and more recent normative statements from 1990 onward by global actors. For example, in the context of a debate over supply-side economics and structural adjustment, the ‘poor’ are those whose talents are wasted through bad government. To better use these talents, market forces need to be liberalised, some say, and government corruption and waste would need to be reduced (e.g. Berg Report, 1981). This came to be known as the Washington Consensus on market-oriented development. This Consensus underpinned the Structural Adjustment programmes aimed at restructuring the economies of lessdeveloped, poorer, countries and setting them on the path of market - led growth. Now we have the post-Washington Consensus; this new ‘consensus’ is a widely-held view that government itself is sometimes not the most efficient way to deliver services, but that the government can help where the services are in any case not delivered by markets. The post-Washington Consensus idea that you intervene “where there is market failure”, also has radical critics (Fine, 2001). This new consensus again has its own particular way of slotting ‘poverty’ and the ‘poor’ into the discourse. Fine explains that to say that the poor lack social capital is to avoid discussing deeper structural class problems. Green argues that there is nothing essential to be seeking, in poverty, but only these twists and turns of social construction of poverty (Green, 2006. As an anthropologist, her view is that poverty is simply socially constructed; my view is that poverty is partly socially constructed but also partly real . Elsewhere, Green offers important advice to those who run goverments, or international institutions.(Green, 2002).. Her advice is to focus on real social differentiation and to avoid glib overview statements when framing policy. This is good advice but does not do justice to the need for a radical overhaul of dominant conceptions of poverty. In fact it seems rather mildly reformist.

2023 MNDI Kritik
Links – Social Security

The comparison to taxes proves the moral assumptions about recipients of welfare – both are wealth transfers, but we assume that people will pay their taxes, and we assume that the poor will cheat on welfare.

Ross, 1991 Prof. of Law at the University of Pittsburgh [Thomas, June Georgetown Law Review “The Rhetoric of Poverty: Their Immorality, Our Helplessness”, , MZ]

One way to see the premise of moral weakness in the rhetoric of poverty is to compare the basic structure and assumptions of the welfare system and the federal income tax system. The welfare system transfers wealth from taxpayers to people on welfare. The tax system also transfers wealth through progressive tax rates and the rules that determine the calculation of taxable income. We usually think of the tax system as merely a wealth-taking and not a wealth-transferring system. Yet, when Congress chooses the structure of our tax system it is in effect making some people wealthier than others. This view of the tax system makes it akin to the welfare system-a government choice to make some people more or less wealthy. The ways in which we implement the tax and welfare systems are radically different, however. The tax system generally depends on voluntary compliance coupled with the threat of audits. 1 91 Although we acknowledge the existence of tax fraud, we do not see it as so systemic or substantial that it necessitates restructuring the way we implement and monitor our tax system. In contrast, Congress assumes that the welfare system must be implemented and monitored based on the assumption of substantial fraud. The difference might be understood as the assumption that most of us don't cheat, but most of them do.

2023 MNDI Kritik
Links – Job Training

Focusing on job skills is social inclusion discourse, which otherizes poor people by blaming them for not being employable.

Olsen, 2010 - Professor of Socio-Economics, Social Statistics at University of Manchester [Wendy “Poverty as a Malaise of Development: A Discourse Analysis in its Global Context”, https://www.escholar.manchester.ac.uk/api/datastream?publicationPid=uk-ac-man-scw:29857&datastreamId=SUPPLEMENTARY-1.PDF ZR]

The social inclusion discourse (as found in Britain, both in domestic policy and in international development policy) argues that the poor people have responsibility to act in proper ways, to work hard and train themselves, and that in exchange for these decent behaviours, compliant citizens can participate fully in society. An underlying argument is that no matter how low your income, e.g. the minimum wage, you are still an accepted member of society. The ‘society’ here is the nation-state. Government is an important actor in this discourse. In the EU, this discourse is linked up with the assertion of basic human rights (Milcher and Ivanov, 2008). Ironically, it has been turned into quite an individualistic type of discourse in recent years. The worker’s supply of labour is seen as crucial; they must not be lazy or they will become excluded. The latest phrase in the social inclusion discourse is employability. The worker must make themselves highly employable, in which case a labour market will successfully integrate them. All else will follow – decent housing, medical care and pension – if only workers will earn enough money for themselves. This has moved a long way from the original sense of social solidarity that is found in core states of Europe. In this sense the UK, New Labour discourse has become somewhat neoliberal (individualistic and commercially minded) while other Europeans still hold out for some fundamental unconditional rights and do not blame workers for their own unemployment. In New Labour’s social inclusion discourse, the poor are partly to blame for their own poverty, and are agents of their own empowerment. If they persist in being lazy, e.g. In ‘the workless household’ where both parents get unemployment benefits, then they are beyond help.

2023 MNDI Kritik
Links – Jobs Guarantee

Focusing on work for the poor reinforces the difference between the Deserving and Undeserving poor – this becomes an assumption of moral weakness

Ross, 1991 Prof. of Law at the University of Pittsburgh [Thomas, June Georgetown Law Review “The Rhetoric of Poverty: Their Immorality, Our Helplessness”, , - MZ]

The dual themes of moral deviance and judicial helplessness at first seem to be inconsistent. The premise of moral weakness suggests that the problem is really quite simple. If poor people simply chose to "straighten up and fly right," all would be well. If they would accept and commit to the moral norms of those of us not in poverty, they would cease to be poor, albeit only after a long time and much hard work. In this vision of poverty, the problem is uni-dimensional and is intractable only to the extent that poor people resist the personal, individual reform of their moral lives. The judicial helplessness theme depends, on the other hand, on the complexity of the problem and on the existence of multiple, intertwined causes. Despite this apparent inconsistency, the Justices-rhetoricians use both themes, often in tandem, throughout their opinions. This apparent inconsistency in the Court's rhetoric of poverty may be related to yet another enduring cultural assumption, the division of the poor into classes of the deserving and the undeserving poor.6 These classes have been drawn somewhat differently throughout history. The contemporary division of the poor distinguishes between able-bodied adults and the children, the aged, and the disabled. This distinction is premised on the ability of the former class to perform work. For this able-bodied class, the moral weakness rhetoric is especially potent-I work, they don't, they could. This argument does not fit members of the second group because we assume that work is not readily available to them. For this class, the judicial helplessness plea is the perfect response. The rhetoric of helplessness allows the expression of sympathy for the deserving poor while avoiding the burden of intervention. The dual rhetoric of moral weakness and judicial helplessness fits the needs of a Court that has chosen to minimize the constitutional basis for intervention on behalf of the poor. Under this rhetoric, either the poor do not deserve our intervention or, if they do have a claim to our sense of justice, we are functionally helpless to do justice.