Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Disadvantage

2ac --- China Great Power War

The risk of great power war is high – it could cause nuclear escalation

Brands, 18 – Henry Kissinger Distinguished Professor at Johns Hopkins University's School of Advanced International Studies and a senior fellow at the Center for Strategic and Budgetary Assessments (Hal, “Great-Power Rivalry Is Back. The U.S. Is Playing Poorly.” Bloomberg View, 2/28,

Having reconstituted its military power, Russia has been reasserting its dominance along its Central Asian and Eastern European peripheries, challenging NATO and undermining the European Union, and projecting its military power deep into the Middle East -- all in addition to seeking to weaken and divide the U.S. through information warfare and other means.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage

2ac/1ar --- AT: China Tech Inevitable

China tech is not inevitable--- regulations killed the industry.

James Cooper and Kashyap Kompella [James Cooper is professor of law and director of International Legal Studies at California Western School of Law in San Diego and a research fellow at Singapore University of Social Sciences Kashyap Kompella, a technology industry analyst, is CEO of RPA2AI, a global artificial intelligence advisory firm, The Hill, “No, China is not winning the AI race,” https://thehill.com/opinion/technology/592270-no-china-is-not-winning-the-ai-race///ZW]

The global competition between the United States and China continues apace. Technology is rightly seen as providing unique leverage to win this geopolitical race. The U.S. long has been the global technology powerhouse, but not surprisingly, we have heard much about the Chinese government’s ambition to dominate high-tech industries such as 5G telecommunications, autonomous vehicles, blockchain, and semiconductor chips. In this light, as a horizontal technology that can be applied across all sectors, artificial intelligence (AI) has become a strategic priority and the Chinese focus on superiority in this field is touted as something about which the U.S. should be concerned. Some have gone so far as to conclude that the West has already lost the AI race. Don’t believe the hype. To be sure, the availability of large amounts of data is at the heart of AI success. It is tempting to think that less-democratic regimes that amass huge amounts of data about their citizens and have scant regard for privacy can develop better AI systems using that data. However, all other things being equal, better and higher quality AI systems emerge from countries with strong data privacy and data protection regulations because AI systems must undergo greater scrutiny during their development and deployment. An example of this can be seen in the United States regarding fair lending practices and consumer protection from credit bureaus. Further, the market for AI is global, and such high-quality AI systems find buyers in other countries as well. Around the globe, Big Tech’s rising power has resulted in calls for more oversight. In a drastic move that stunned the industry and analysts alike, the Chinese government recently rewrote the rulebook for the country’s technology industry. In effect, China is vacating entire swaths of digital and creative industries, arenas that serve as training grounds and talent factories for other industries. This more restrictive approach may not bode well for China’s AI industry in the long term. China may find itself constrained on the extent of automation and AI in its manufacturing sector — labor-intensive manufacturing remains China’s main strength, and a high degree of automation can result in job losses, labor unrest, and instability. Meanwhile, there is bipartisan support for AI in the United States. Former President Trump proposed increasing funding for AI development through the National Science Foundation. The National AI Initiative Act of 2020 signaled a sense of urgency and suggested that several federal agencies create a national strategy on artificial intelligence. The Biden administration has formed the Artificial Intelligence Research Resource Task Force to develop a roadmap to foment AI research and spark innovation nationwide. There is draft legislation, at both the state and federal level, to promote responsible use of AI and prevent its misuse. Strong objections to the use of facial recognition and other AI systems by law enforcement in the U.S., raised by civil liberties advocates, have led some local authorities, such as the City of San Francisco, to ban such systems. To use a Silicon Valley phrase, these debates are “not a bug, but a feature.” They shine a light on the limitations of AI systems and help to set the “rules of the road” for proper use of AI. This will establish the U.S. as a global leader in AI regulation, once lawmakers and regulators do their work. China, meanwhile, has faced strong global criticism for using facial recognition software to monitor and surveil Uyghurs in its Xinjiang region. China has outlined a set of AI ethics principles, but the jury is still out on enforcement and how they function in practice. The increasing number of AI research papers and patents by Chinese researchers is often cited as proof that China has caught up with the United States in this field. The increased focus is good for the Chinese AI ecosystem, and it will help them solve China-specific problems. But dominance in this emerging strategic industry is not guaranteed. The U.S. has several strategic advantages, including: the strengths of its higher education and research institutes, which attract the best STEM talent from across the world; the largest venture capital ecosystem; and the largest number of technology unicorns (start-ups with private valuations greater than $1 billion). China is not overtaking the U.S. in artificial intelligence. The current evidence and trajectory paint a clear picture: The conditions for AI to flourish, such as incentives to experiment, freedom to pursue opportunities without restrictions, and the coming guardrails to prevent misuse, favor U.S. leadership. This is still the United States’s game to lose — though maybe both countries could win through collaboration. To solve planet-scale problems such as climate change, we are going to need AI solutions from both competitors.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage

2ac/1ar --- AT: AI Impact

They’ve got it backwards--- AI singularity solves threats.

Rick Hayes-Roth 10-02-2006 [Rick Hayes-Roth is a professor in the Information Sciences Dept. at the Naval Postgraduate School in Monterey, California, Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, “Puppetry vs. Creationism: Why AI Must Cross the Chasm,” https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/abstract/document/1705420/authors#authors//ZW]

Most of the visions for self-modifying and self-improving AI have been a bit scary or a bit shallow. Much discussion has occurred around the concept of the singularity, first explained by Vernor Vinge2 and now a theme popularized by Ray Kurzweil,3 among others (for example, see www.aleph. so/Trans/Global/Singularity). Roughly, the singularity is a point in history when technology accelerates beyond human capacity to master it. With regard to AI, this could mean that computers learn and communicate with one another faster than they can with humans. At that point, they might not be willing to slow down or engage further. In such a case, the machines would reach a kind of escape velocity, enabling them to leave human culture behind. I'm suggesting that we should actively seek to create the capabilities underlying such a possibility, because the potential gains are exponentially greater than what traditional puppetry can produce. But this surely entails risks, as readily suggested in most of the scary movies about rogue AI and robots gone haywire. We obviously have limited insight into both the positive and negative capabilities of self-improving AI systems. Although the road will be somewhat long, we ought to consider ways to identify and mitigate the risks before they afflict us. Fortunately, many people interested in the singularity and future visions of robots have given these issues serious consideration. We'll want to incorporate their ideas and related technologies into the new creationism agenda. This will help prevent predictable problems and provide additional insurance against the unforeseen. Although I consider these risks serious, I think we can de-emphasize or defer them a bit. To get out of the puppetry business will require a major shift in investment, orientation, and technology. By focusing mostly on the required new capacities for model-based learning and improvements in operational contexts, we put first things first. Like the master puppet makers of the classic folktales, AI engineers have built some marvelous machines. These machines are surely valuable, but our puppetry won't cross the chasm separating us from a world of artificially intelligent creatures. To get there, we need a singularity of artificial creationism, where we launch artificial beings that can adapt, learn, and evolve. We need to emphasize the development of continuously self-improving systems that interact with and perform tasks in the physical world. Creation of those systems will mark a singularity in the punctuated evolution of artificial intelligence.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage

2ac/1ar --- China Regs Don’t Work

China’s regulations for AI aren’t feasible.

Makenzie Holland 03-17-2022 [News writer covering big tech and federal regulation, Tech Target, “China’s AI regulations face technical challenge,” https://www.techtarget.com/searchenterpriseai/news/252514781/Chinas-AI-regulations-face-technical-challenge//ZW]

China is one of the first countries to regulate AI algorithms -- a regulation that may prove technically difficult for businesses to adhere to. China's AI algorithm regulations took effect March 1, requiring businesses to provide explainable AI algorithms and be transparent about their purpose, such as for recommending products or services. The new regulations also prohibit businesses reliant on AI algorithms from offering different prices to different people based on personal data collected. Technical feasibility will be one of the most challenging aspects facing the new regulations, said Russell Wald, director of policy for Stanford University's Institute for Human-Centered Artificial Intelligence (HAI). Explainable AI has proven to be difficult for businesses to offer up. In this Q&A, Wald talks about the AI regulations' impact on businesses, as well as how they're unlikely to affect the Chinese government's own use of AI when it comes to surveilling its citizens. What do you think about China taking this step? Wald: What I find most interesting is China has done this first. We can see and watch in real time what happens to some of these businesses now being regulated for the first time. Questions remain about the technical feasibility of this. The question is, are we seeing regulation in theory or regulation in practice? One key part is a continuing need for human-centered AI. How do you define human-centered AI? Wald: AI that is inspired by the human brain and comes from what you've seen in human development. AI that doesn't replace humans but augments human capability. And the third part of that is AI that doesn't harm but rather benefits humanity … technology fostering instead of eroding democratic aspects. That's the key part. It's a recognition of the rights of everyone to be able to go in and look at these technologies and have fair access to them and the rights to challenge their governments when they're in use. How will requiring AI algorithmic accountability and transparency impact businesses? Wald: There is the technical issue here of whether that's feasible. That's one layer that has a big question mark hanging over it. Then there's the aspect of following regulation where you could and being in compliance with that. To that end, whether or not those companies will be able to do it, I think they'll have to. I don't think they have a choice. The larger question is not whether Chinese businesses are able to comply with this, it is whether other international companies will now be affected by this. If you're selling into the Chinese market, you are going to have to work on that. That's where a unique tension is going to come through. What if China says, 'It is technically feasible'? Then there will be other countries that say 'No, it's actually not, we've had these problems.' Will these regulations apply to the Chinese government's use of AI? Wald: The government will not cede, from my view at least, its surveillance of its citizens. Because of that, I think it'll always have access to that technology. It's too tempting. It even remains tempting for local law enforcement in the U.S. But here, at least in the United States, we're having a debate about an AI bill of rights. We're debating about facial recognition use by police, by the federal government at the border. There is this open debate. That debate is not happening in this case of the [Chinese] government's use of it. Do you think there needs to be more debate before moving forward with AI regulations? Wald: The EU or U.S. system of open debate around this is ultimately driving us in the right space. Not fast enough, but still a better pathway forward. What I do have concerns about in the U.S. is we are woefully behind. You're starting to see an increase in legislation. You're starting to see a Federal Trade Commission that's trying to lean a little more forward on some of this. But I think the best way to have these dialogues and national debate is through legislation where all the interest groups, all the advocacy organizations, everyone comes to the table and hashes it out. Are there aspects of the Chinese legislation you'll be paying attention to, like how they handle consumer complaints about potential harms caused by AI algorithms? Wald: I mentioned that technical feasibility part, that's really important. I'm more curious about what the petition process will be. I'd like to watch that space more than anything. Is it significant, is it public, are a lot of people openly complaining? I would be curious to see the registration of these complaints. That would be important for when Europe or the U.S. starts to get into this model. What's the mechanism for them to be able to do this? If we all had a contact at the FTC or the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, they'd be flooded and overwhelmed and unable to manage that process appropriately. The logistics of managing that has huge application towards ultimate effectiveness. Editor's note: Responses have been edited for brevity and clarity.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage

2ac/1ar --- AT: China Heg Inevitable

Studies exaggerate--- even if China takes the lead it means nothing for hegemony.

Ian Verrender 03-15-2022 [ABC Business Editor, Australian Broadcasting Corporation, “Why China is unlikely to overtake the United States to become the biggest economy in the world,” https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-03-15/china-faces-significant-hurdles-to-become-biggest-global-economy/100912398//ZW]

For decades, it has been one of the great truisms of global foreign policy; the "inexorable rise of China". Never a question of if but only when, the betting amongst academics, politicians and diplomats has concentrated on how long it would take for China to overtake the United States as the world's biggest economy. Its sheer size, both in terms of land mass and population, made it seemingly inevitable as the economy developed and living standards soared in one of history's fastest transitions from a Third World agrarian nation to a highly urbanised society. But the path to becoming the biggest is becoming increasingly hazardous. China is experiencing serious growing pains. The easy gains have been extracted and many pundits are winding back those ambitious straight-line extrapolations of continuous growth. Even then, there are various ways to measure size. Time to scale back the growth prospects A new study by Lowy Institute researchers Roland Rajah and Alyssa Leng casts doubt upon the speed with which China can achieve the dubious honour of claiming the crown and questions whether it will ever become the most powerful. "China would overtake the United States to become the world's largest economy in nominal US dollar terms by about 2030," the report's authors conclude. "But it would never establish a meaningful lead ... and would remain far less prosperous and productive per person than America, even by mid-century." Most research concludes that China will be able to motor along with around 5 per cent annual economic growth until 2050. If it did, it would be the world's biggest economy by a country mile, with the capacity to be its own bloc. It is those kinds of projections that have created fear and angst among many Western nations, including Australia, on how best to deal with a global economic powerhouse of such magnitude that does not adhere to democratic norms. This new study paints a vastly different picture of the future. Rather than 5 per cent growth, it forecasts growth of around 2 to 3 per cent a year, which has significant ramifications for the balance of global power and a major impact on China's internal politics. "With slower growth, China's progress in catching up to rich country average living standards and productivity levels would remain significantly incomplete, even by mid-century," the study says. "On the one hand, the average person in China would be 2 to 3 times richer by 2050 compared to today and 2.5 to 3.5 times more productive. "Nonetheless, China would still be much poorer and less productive than the United States, based on current expectations of future US growth at around 1.6 per cent a year on average." By 2050, the authors calculate the average person in China would be only 40 per cent as rich as the average American and about half as productive. More than just teething problems The early gains were easy. From an economy largely run by the state, allowing individuals to own and operate their own businesses sent growth soaring. Global capital poured in, providing cheap investment and employment. But those easy gains no longer are available. And the ongoing fracturing in relations between the West and an inward looking Beijing, accelerated by Russia's invasion of Ukraine, will likely continue to see a slowing and perhaps withdrawal of foreign investment. In recent years, it has faced a series of crises fuelled by mounting debts which have seen a sharp uptick in defaults within private and government owned businesses, most recently concentrated within the property sector and companies such as Evergrande. Putting aside poor productivity, debt and overinvestment in infrastructure, the Lowy Institute report cites another issue as the biggest overall impediment to China's future; its ageing population and the legacy of its draconian past one child policy. "China's working age population has been shrinking since the middle of last decade," it says. "The fertility rate has fallen rapidly over the past decade to just 1.3 births per woman in 2020 — well below the replacement rate of 2.1." By 2050, China's working age population will have shrunk by around 220 million, which is around a fifth of its current level, with those aged over 65 making up about a quarter of the population. The authors conclude that you can never completely rule out the prospect China could rule the world, the chances of such are nowhere near as likely as most studies would indicate. "But it would require an enormous degree of success with productivity enhancing reforms well beyond China's track record to date," they argue. "It should not be the baseline expectation."

2022 Michigan Disadvantage

2ac --- US Heg Good

Heg solves global nuclear war

Zalmay Khalilzad 16, former U.S. ambassador to the United Nations, counselor at the CSIS, 3/23/16, “4 Lessons about America's Role in the World,” http://nationalinterest.org/feature/4-lessons-about-americas-role-the-world-15574?page=show

Ultimately, however, we concluded that the United States has a strong interest in precluding the emergence of another bipolar world—as in the Cold War—or a world of many great powers, as existed before the two world wars. Multipolarity led to two world wars and bipolarity resulted in a protracted worldwide struggle with the risk of nuclear annihilation. To avoid a return such circumstances, Secretary of Defense Dick Cheney ultimately agreed that our objective must be to prevent a hostile power to dominate a “critical region,” which would give it the resources, industrial capabilities and population to pose a global challenge. This insight has guided U.S. defense policy throughout the post–Cold War era.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Baudrillard vs. Fem IR › Links

The affirmative has unknowingly stumbled into the paradox of art and life itself – if everything is art then nothing is, if everything is beautiful then nothing is – we lose all determinants and meaning as boundaries, borders, and limits are eviscerated

Fernando, 12 [Jeremy, Jean Baudrillard Fellow at the European Graduate School, “Writing Death,”] //Don Markos

And it is not as if doing so comes without a price: once something is completely calculable, it is also completely exchangeable, completely transparent. Here, we might momentarily tune in to Jean Baudrillard and attend to his warning that total transparency is the point where "every individual category is subject to contamination, substitution is possible between any sphere and any other: there is total confusion of types:' Thus, "each category is generalised to the greatest possible extent, so that it eventually loses all specificity and is reabsorbed by all the other categories. When everything is political, nothing is political anymore, the word itself is meaningless. When everything is sexual, nothing is sexual anymore, and sex loses its determinants. When everything is aesthetic, nothing is beautiful or ugly anymore, and art itself disappears. This paradoxical state of affairs ... is simultaneously the complete actualisation of an idea, the perfect realisation of the whole tendency of modernity, and the negation of the idea and that tendency, their annihilation by virtue of their very success, by virtue of their extension beyond their own bounds ... :' In order for any response to be possible, there have to be boundaries, borders, limits. For, without the separation, the space, one would not be able to even begin communicating with another; everything would just be the same. In other words, what has to be maintained is an exteriority, a finitude to all gestures of knowing. This also means that all responding, all response, is always already finite. If this were so, a question remains with us: what of the situation in which the call was made? The trouble is: if one can never be sure what the call even is, when, or even where, it came from-if one is blind to both the source and the object of the call-one is attempting to respond to a complete unknown, an absolute unknowability. However, even though there is no possibility of verification, one is still responding-this suggests that there is still a measure of exchange that is taking place. Whether this exchange can be measured is yet another question; one that perhaps can never be addressed. And since there is an exchange that takes place in spite of the fact that the exchange may be impossible, this suggests that the exchange is a symbolic exchange ritualistic, formal, nothing more-and nothing less-than a form; where the form of the exchange is everything-and in which each individual component is meaningless except for its role within the ritual itself.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Baudrillard vs. Fem IR › Links

The 1ac is not art, it’s an advertisement – their attempt to trade aesthetics for the ballot colludes with the project of commercialization that values artwork insofar as it has productive potential – this process of commodification renders existence banal and sterilized as we’re plunged into a sea of indifference

Baudrillard, 93 [Jean, “The Transparency of Evil: Essays on Extreme Phenomena,” pg. 14-5,] //Don Markos

We see Art proliferating wherever we turn; talk about Art is increasing even more rapidly. But the soul of Art - Art as adventure, Art with its power of illusion, its capacity for negating reality, for setting up an 'other scene' in opposition to reality, where things obey a higher set of rules, a transcendent figure in which beings, like line and colour on a canvas, are apt to lose their meaning, to extend themselves beyond their own raison d'etre, and, in an urgent process of seduction, to rediscover their ideal form (even though this form may be that of their own destruction) - in this sense, Art is gone. Art has disappeared as a symbolic pact, as something thus clearly distinct from that pure and simple production of aesthetic values, that proliferation of signs ad infinitum, that recycling of past and present forms, which we call 'culture'. There are no more fundamental rules, no more criteria of judgement or of pleasure. In the aesthetic realm of today there is no longer any God to recognize his own. Or, to use a different metaphor, there is no gold standard of aesthetic judgement or pleasure. The situation resembles that of a currency which may not be exchanged : it can only float, its only reference itself, impossible to convert into real value or wealth. Art, too, must circulate at top speed, and is impossible to exchange. 'Works' of art are indeed no longer exchanged, whether for each other or against a referential value. They no longer have that secret collusiveness which is the strength of a culture. We no longer read such works - we merely decode them according to ever more contradictory criteria. Nothing in this sphere conflicts with anything else. Neo-Geometrism, Neo-Expressionism, New Abstraction, New Representationalism - all coexist with a marvellous facility amid general indifference. It is only because none of these tendencies has any soul of its own that they can all inhabit the same cultural space; only because they arouse nothing but profound indifference in us that we can accept them all simultaneously. The art world presents a curious aspect. It is as though art and artistic inspiration had entered a kind of stasis - as though everything which had developed magnificently over several centuries had suddenly been immobilized, paralysed by its own image and its own riches. Behind the whole convulsive movement of modern art lies a kind of inertia, something that can no longer transcend itself and has therefore turned in upon itself, merely repeating itself at a faster and faster rate. On the one hand, then, a stasis of the living form of art, and at the same time a proliferative tendency, wild hyperbole, and endless variations on all earlier forms (the life, moving of itself, of that which is dead) All this is logical enough: where there is stasis, there is metastasis. When a living form becomes disordered, when (as in cancer) a genetically determined set of rules ceases to function, the cells begin to proliferate chaotically . Just as some biological disorders indicate a break in the genetic code, so the present disorder in art may be interpreted as a fundamental break in the secret code of aesthetics. By its liberation of form, line, colour, and aesthetic notions - as by its mixing up of all cultures, all styles - our society has given rise to a general aestheticization: all forms of culture - not excluding anti-cultural ones - are promoted and all models of representation and anti-representation are taken on board. Whereas art was once essentially a utopia - that is to say, ultimately unrealizable - today this utopia has been realized : thanks to the media, computer science and video technology, everyone is now potentially a creator. Even antiart, the most radical of artistic utopias, was realized once Duchamp had mounted his bottle-dryer and Andy Warhol had wished he was a machine . All the industrial machinery in the world has acquired an aesthetic dimension; all the world's insignificance has been transfigured by the aestheticizing process. It is often said that the West's great undertaking is the commercialization of the whole world, the hitching of the fate of everything to the fate of the commodity. That great undertaking will turn out rather to have been the aestheticization of the whole world - its cosmopolitan spectacularization, its transformation into images, its semiological organization. What we are witnessing, beyond the materialist rule of the commodity, is a semio-orgy of everything by means of advertising, the media, or images. No matter how marginal, or banal, or even obscene it may be, everything is subject to aestheticization, culturalization, museumification. Everything is said, everything is exposed, everything acquires the force, or the manner, of a sign. The system runs less on the surplus-value of the commodity than on the aesthetic surplus-value of the sign.

2022 Michigan Kritik
AfroPess vs. Fem IR Aff › Link – Fem / Intersectionality

Intersectional feminist logic delegitimates the effect of ontological blackness as opposed to “epistemological masculinity.” Vulnerability is thus weaponized towards the creation of black-as-vessel, existent only for its cultural production Sirma Bilge 20 [Department of Sociology, The fungibility of intersectionality: an Afropessimist reading, https://www-tandfonline-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/doi/full/10.1080/01419870.2020.1740289, March 23 2020, Accessed 7/5/22, https://doi-org.proxy.lib.umich.edu/10.1080/01419870.2020.1740289, -ekh-]

Given the centrality of the concept of fungibility in my argument and its close ties to Afropessimism, it is worth starting by a succinct exposé of the latter’s central tenets. First things first, Afropessimism under consideration here is the US-version of Afropessimism, which was developed several decades after its original elaboration in Africa (with a different meaning) and largely obscured this prior conceptualization.

A foundational premise of (US-made) Afropessimism is the claim that humanity was “made legible through the irreconcilable distinction between humans and blackness” (Douglass, Terrefe, and Wilderson , 1). The advent of “human” as category was achieved through the violent negation of humanity to the Black, classified as non-human. This founding relationality in which the Black non-human is the constitutive outside of the Human means that Blackness eludes and exceeds the humanist modes of thinking and world-making. This premise is buttressed by the Afropessimist conceptualization of Blackness as “a paradigmatic position, rather than an ensemble of cultural, social, and sexual orientations” (1), as a “structural position of noncommunicability in the face of all other positions” (Wilderson , 58), which is coupled with a methodological refusal – that of any analogizing/comparison between the regimes of violence that discipline non-Black subalterns (dominated but human) and the one that evicts the Black from humanity. For Afropessimists, any analogizing between Black non-being and subjugated being (whether non-Black migrant, woman, queer, disabled) is misguided, as fungible object is incomparable to subordinated subject, and “the structure of the entire world’s semantic field – regardless of cultural and national discrepancies – […] is sutured by anti-Black solidarity” (58). One can hardly miss the divergence between this Afropessimist precept of incommensurable ontological (anti)Blackness, which foregrounds one true antagonism, the one between Black non-human and non-Black human, while it views “other repressive relations like class and gender” as taking place “on the level of conflict – they can be resolved, hence they are not ontological” (Wilderson .), and the intersectional relational schema which, without treating differences as equivalent and interchangeable, conceives them within a matrix of domination where there is no superordinate antagonism. Thus, Afropessimist relational schema is hardly compatible with intersectional relational schema. While the former builds on the premise of only one true antagonism – that between humans and Blacks which is the core of ontological anti-Blackness – relegating the others to the realm of conflicts, because, it argues, they are not ontological, the latter eschews the idea of a single determination (be it race, class or gender) and focuses on theorizing their context-specific mutual constitution and articulations.

From an Afropessimist perspective, Blackness doesn’t belong to the domain of subjectivity, identity, agency and epistemology, but to that of ontology, accumulation and fungibility, as determined by slavery and its afterlife (Hartman ). What ensue are structural incommensurability and incommunicability of Blackness vis-à-vis all other subaltern positions, “predicated on modalities of accumulation and fungibility, not [Marxian] exploitation and alienation” (Wilderson , 58) – for slave is an object, not an exploited labourer-subject (Patterson ). They produce the “the absolute non-individuality and interchangeability” (Warren , 397) of Blackness. Here, the concept of fungibility is of paramount importance, as the predicate upon which the enslaved Black is evicted from humanity and turned into ontologically (ac)cumulable and exchangeable commodity. Hartman () argues:

2022 Michigan Kritik
AfroPess vs. Fem IR Aff › Link – Hegemonic Masculinity

Their invocation of the feminine/masculine dichotomy confines black women into the archive of gender founded upon humanist categories that renders the black gender silent

Mukasa Mubirumusoke 2022 [Assistant Professor in the Intercollegiate Department of Africana Studies at Claremont McKenna College “Black Hospitality A Theoretical Framework for Black Ethical Life” https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-95255-6]//sheima

When regarding the functioning of the spectacular, it also cannot go unmentioned that black cisgender men have garnered the most attention and although the considerations here will avoid focusing on any event in too much detail, it should be noted this group is not exclusively subject to such violence. Patrice D. Douglass gives a very nuanced reading of gender and afropessimism as it follows in the wake of Spillers’ invocation of (un)gendering and the fashion in which femininity and masculinity are misnamed and misrecognized under white supremacy. Douglass explains: Juxtaposing the hyper-visibility of the death of Black men against the invisibility and silencing of the death of Black women opens a litany of trap doors. Placing the lens on how Black women die is not to demand that visual images of their deaths are repeated on social media networks and the nightly news at the behest of the pleasure of viewing Black suffering. In fact, the issue of Black gender is more complex than the dichotomization of death. Furthermore, to bifurcate Black gender, Black women up against Black men, achieves nothing more than reifying gender stratifcations that historically and experientially have never been made available to Black people. By shifting perspective, we might ask, how Black feminist politics account for the dead and dying inclusive of all genders? (Douglass 2018, 108) ¶ This concluding call, asked of and inspired by black feminism, thus demands, not the dismissal of gendered violence, but rethinking the juxtaposition and ossifcation of such identities that are never afforded through proper terms of gender, since they are only created through a violence to separate these black identities from the political ontology of the human. Black (un)gendering thus exposes with greater depth the ways in which black vulnerability exceeds all principles and categories of the human. To refer to Douglass one more time at length she elaborates: ¶ The archive of gender is structurally anti-black. Its assumptive logic, whether explicit in its presentation or not, maintains that all women have the same gender. This orientation of thought does more than render Black gender invisible or silent. It makes it conceptually impossible to think of gender violence as orienting more than the realm of gender. Rather than engaging a politic fixated on what binds women together in life, I want to draw focus to what separates Black women in death. What creates the conditions of (im)possibility for Black women to die? (Douglass 2018, 115)¶ Humans die; meanwhile, black women are hailed into existence by a violence that only permits their perishing. This reality needs to be kept in mind when we are thinking of the phenomenon of police violence. Violence against black women should not be ignored, but an increased media presence does not bring about human recognition; their absence is part and parcel of an anti-black violence that imposes gender differently, though for a similar end, that is, social (and real) death. Wilderson falls in line with much of what Douglass explicates and suggests that the media focus on the carceral violence received by black men only serves the purpose of reifying spectacular violence and offering a false sense of agency through assuming the human categories of gender. Gender for black people is not essential, it is a ‘borrowed institutionality” instrumentalized in strategic ways. In the end, the actions of police brutality, inclusive of all genders, are not simply spontaneous or isolated acts of individual anger; they serve the ends of white civil society inasmuch as its constituents, while recognizing a certain horror in police brutality, feel safe from the fears and dread of its reality in the space where it belongs, namely in the black community. Moreover, there is also pleasure derived in the negrophilic dalliance of a weekend warrior protestor where their confrontation with police actually can be dignifying. These spectacular images show to many that the police are doing their job, which explains the ex post facto justifcations of these black people as criminals even though the criminal records that these victims might possess actually points to the criminalization of their livelihood, that is, the banality of white supremacy. Again, the spectacles obscure all of this and serve to provide a “vital cultural labor” (Sexton and Martinot 2003, 176) Or as Sexton and Martinot state explicitly:¶ White supremacy is not reconstructed simply for its own sake but for the sake of the social paranoia, the ethic of impunity, and the violent spectacles of racialization that it calls the “maintenance of order,” all of which constitute its essential dimensions. The cold, gray institutions of this society – courts, schools, prisons, police, army, law, religion, the two-party system – become the arenas of this brutality, its excess and spectacle, which they then normalize throughout the social field. (Sexton and Martinot 2003, 180)

2022 Michigan Kritik
AfroPess vs. Fem IR Aff › Link – Vulnerability

The weaponization of Black vulnerability for the political agendas of junior partners sustains a bottomless well of antiblack violence

Mukasa Mubirumusoke 2022 [Assistant Professor in the Intercollegiate Department of Africana Studies at Claremont McKenna College “Black Hospitality A Theoretical Framework for Black Ethical Life” https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-95255-6]//sheima

This is not to imply that there is not class difference among black people. The black people listed at the beginning of the chapter as so-called beacons of progress do indeed live a much different life than the poor and working-class victims of violence that were named soon after (although a few of the former did not always live with money and may not continue in the future. There are real consequences for these class distinctions; for example, Skip Gates ultimately had a beer summit with the first black president after his confrontation with a police officer; meanwhile, Brionna Taylor did not even get a knock at the door before her demise. These different class experiences cannot be conflated and the black poor and working classes experience life differently, but that experience does attend to the ontological. The few black Americans that owned slaves, for instance, were not whitened; they had more money. Nevertheless, they were always vulnerable in a way that was not the same as even the poorest white people who may indeed perish from the consequences of their poverty. The qualitative distinction between white and black exceeds calculations and again only an appeal to the general economy of white supremacy can make sense of this distinction. The vulnerability of any proletariat can be overcome through hard work (some harder than others), but black vulnerability at the ontological level—which includes sudden death for no reason at all except the fact that one is black—cannot be ultimately mitigated by labor regardless of the neighborhood. Therefore, while it may not be the literal case that black people can be purchased as chattel slaves in 2020 (although the conditions in Libya may challenge even this contention), the nonrelation of blackness as vulnerable to anyone was set by a diremption between black and non-black centuries ago and this antagonism is constituted by the extra-ordinary, that is, illegible, accumulative, fungible, abject, objectifcation, and the open vulnerability that follows from it. From a materialist perspective, it is often argued that racism and sexism are used to obscure true class relations and create inessential hierarchies and intraclass confict. A Marxist or class critique may indeed allow one to see the exploitation at work behind the hypnotic light of our computer screens, but will that unmask the ‘ugliness’ of the affective economy and larger ethical dilemma of white supremacy? Let’s hear Wilderson explain in his own words: Anti-black violence is vital to the psychic well-being of White (and nonBlack) people everywhere. Violence against black people provides a sanctuary for White people, a guaranteed matrix of safety, security, and respite—respite from the otherwise unbearable hydraulics of their own family lives, and from the unbearable hydraulics of an ugly world that they have created and which they know, in the collective unconscious, to be ugly, though they can’t bring themselves to admit it is beyond redemption. (Wilderson III 2015, 148) Antiblack violence is vital in maintaining the hierarchy of the antiblack world, but as the parenthetical term intimates, the human also extends to those non-blacks, which Wilderson identifes as the ‘junior members’ of white civil society (Wilderson III 2007, 26) and who may also attend to the bottomless well of anti-blackness for their own constitution. These junior members are the familiar marginal political groupings, whether they be other people of color, other categories of identity regarding gender, sexual orientation, or even the  previously discussed political economic positions, such as the worker. It is hard not to recognize that this sort of malleability in terms of self-fortifcation is once again an attribute of the excessive economy of white supremacy as the gift that keeps on giving. In contemporary times we see the proliferation of identities that make claim to their marginal status over against the status quo and their legibility is not just symbolic differentiation. This may indeed mark their legibility as a given ‘exceptional’ categorical possibility, but the vitality of their stature is enriched or stabilized by comparing and distinguishing from blackness. All these junior members participate in the fortification of white civil society, only marginally, but still by way of anti-blackness. This is indeed a polemical contention, but it need not be so reductively interpreted as a ranking. Rather, the constitutive primacy of antiblackness serves as a tracing of the conceptual landscape, whereby it becomes clear where the ever so replenishing life force of what we recognize as the human or civil society springs from. Wilderson provides a number of examples of how such parasitic anti-blackness arises in everyday life from junior members. For instance, in the previously cited “Prison Slave” essay he cites the sort of anti-black subjection that Assata Shakur describes in her biography via a white woman in the abolitionist movement, concluding, “The verisimilitude between Assata’s well known police encounters and her experience in civil society’s most nurturing nook, the radical coalition, raises disturbing questions about political desire, black positionality, and hegemony as a mode of struggle” (Wilderson III 2007, 24). One question may be: what are the limits of non-black prison abolitionists when it comes to sacrificing for the greater good? Carceral punishment for even the most heinous crimes appears to be one thing that must go with the abolition movement, but even then, antiblackness cannot help itself from flourishing even in the most radical places. Also, in another example of the ever-expanding list of who finds respite in antiblackness, one may turn back to the essay “Afro-Pessimism and the End of Redemption,” where Wilderson recalls a conversation with a Palestinian friend whose cousin had died constructing a bomb. The friend then confded, in a moment of unfiltered grief, that the humiliation of the full body searches conducted by Israeli soldiers was worse when it was an Ethiopian Jew. Wilderson goes on to explain: I was faced with the realization that, in the collective unconscious, the Palestinian insurgent has more in common with Israeli state and civil society than s/he does with Black people. What they share is a largely unconscious consensus that Blackness is a locus of abjection to be instrumentalized on a whim. At one moment Blackness is a disfigured and disfiguring phobic phenomenon; at another moment Blackness is a sentient implement to be joyously deployed for reasons and agendas that have little to do with Black liberation … My friend’s and his country’s women’s and men’s negrophobogensis, is the bedrock, the concrete slabs upon which any edifice of human articulation (whether love or war) is built. (Wilderson III 2016) Antiblackness necessarily shades even the ‘micro-aggressions’ in the examples of Assata and Wilderson’s friend above. The white prison abolitionist and the Palestinian insurgent can sense the absolute abjection of blackness, and they gesture toward it to give themselves a glimpse at their own humanity, however much degraded by the violence they are subjected to via contingent violation as opposed to the gratuitous violence that black people may meet at a whim. Black vulnerability is of the same quality as theirs. While black people and the junior members share the category of occurrent, it is not pathogenic in the way of undermining autonomy or exacerbating any sense of powerlessness through particular actions that circumscribe their subjection. Instead, it is a vulnerability that is abject, that is discursively illegible or without origin, objectifying, psychically replenishing, and fortified by the dominant and marginal constituents of civil society, gratuitously, that is, without reason or dialectical reconciliation. Black vulnerability marks the parameters of human or subjective capacity through a broad coalition of policing the contours of the human and hardly human in a collective unconscious of antiblackness.

2022 Michigan Kritik
AfroPess vs. Fem IR Aff › Link – Vulnerability

The aff’s insistence that we should all “embrace vulnerability” overcodes the way black vulnerability is manifest constantly as abjection––it relies on antiblack grammars of relationality centered around the Human

Mukasa Mubirumusoke 2022 [Assistant Professor in the Intercollegiate Department of Africana Studies at Claremont McKenna College “Black Hospitality A Theoretical Framework for Black Ethical Life” https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-95255-6]//sheima

We all share in vulnerability argues Butler, even on this global geopolitical scale and it’s rooted in a ‘social vulnerability.’ Against Butler’s idea of a shared ‘social vulnerability’, this chapter argues human vulnerability in its various guises and comparable quantifications is not of the same quality as black vulnerability. Black vulnerability is of a different kind then even the extreme vulnerability Butler identifies as imposed by the war on terror. Black vulnerability has an abject quality because of its non-relationality that expels the experience of black people from the realm of the human by means of an objectifying violence. The extralegal policies issued by the United States state department seemingly defy all modern legal precedence domestically and internationally, culminating in the practice of indefinite detention at Guantanamo Bay—which still holds thirty-nine people as of January 2022. And yet, these conditions still discursively refer to a human subject insomuch as these persons retain some form of cultural historical integrity and a political ontology that can identify and punish transgressions of its normative orders, even if these transgressions are generally seen as acceptable by a broader human coalition. Undeniably a shared vulnerability of the human gets manipulated and contorted to produce an intensification of vulnerability for the brown, deceitful, ‘terrorist’, both abroad and in the United States. The profound degradation of the Middle Eastern person, however, is not the same as the abject black object and this distinction must be considered beyond the discourses of colorblindness, protest size, or even the unfathomable unconstitutional practices of the US government toward an entire religion and region post 9/11.¶ “This chapter began by recounting black experience at the beginning of the twenty-first century not merely because it describes a black vulnerability that overlaps temporally with the hostility toward Middle Easterners, which is the signature of the never-ending war on terror that framed Butler’s reflections of vulnerability. Indeed, these two historical examples are worthy of comparison for their temporal overlap and conceptual distinction, but also a look at the beginning of the twenty-first century and the right ‘now’ for black people also calls attention to an eerie repetition of the same, whereby the spectacular horror of violence that is attached to the names Trayvon, Tamir; Taylor, Floyd, seem all too familiar and even now more than ever seem almost necessary for the functioning of the political order of America, even if it is not clear why. In describing the peculiarity of black (political) vulnerability this chapter will also need to address what appears to be this compulsion of antiblack violence and the spectacle that obscures it. Butler’s reimagination of subjectivity through vulnerability is an attempt to reform the ethico-political presumptions that encourage individualism, nationalism, and dichotomous self-constructions, suggesting American aggression and Middle Eastern resentment are notes in the same chord. The concept of vulnerability supposedly can unveil the harmony of humanity even when its violent hypocrisies are loudest. Yet the hostility toward blacks and their vulnerability resonates in a different key; the interminable ‘war on terror’ is different from the positionality of the slave that must be reaffirmed regardless of, and illegible to, more prominent narratives in American political discourse and political economy.Through the lens of afropessimism, Frank Wilderson III and Jared Sexton—along with others—allow us to conceptualize the uniqueness of black vulnerability, or rather its illegibility and objectifying nature, over and against the spectrum of shared political vulnerability described by Butler and others. The key to understanding black vulnerability and its extraordinary character is a notion of social death—which will be recategorized as political death in the next chapter—that positions black people not merely at the edge but on the outside and antagonistic to a political community that is structured by antiblack white supremacy. Wilderson provides the most comprehensive conception of black social death working primarily from, with modification, Orlando Patterson’s definition in the seminal work Slavery and Social Death, in addition to inspiration from Frantz Fanon, Saidiya Hartman, and Hortense Spillers. Through social death, black people occupy a positionality—not a subjective identity—that refuses legibility as human. This is accomplished under the parameters of dishonor, natal alienation, and gratuitous violence. The black positionality is unique in its’ non-relation to all other positionalities inasmuch as its degradation is an absolute abjection, in other words modern political ontology denies all relationality to black people. It is not contingently maintained through possible transgressions, but structurally constitutive through negation in the formation of proper political subjectivity, from the most valued to the least valued political subjects. Social death as abjection is necessary to maintain the world of the human. Jared Sexton offers the helpful description of a general economy to conceptualize the excess and need for repetition as a non-rational affective investment in the abjection of black people. From these perspectives emerges a concept of black vulnerability that goes beyond Butler’s homogenized conceptualization of a collective ontological vulnerability. Through a loss of what was never there, a loss that is gratuitously reified through repetition, we can better understand what is specific to antiblack violence. David Marriott employs the term abjection to signify a loss that was never present (Marriott 2007, 123).¶ Gratuity compliments abjection, as it explains the excessive repetition of antiblack violence, since there are no legible norms to be transgressed in a loss that was never present and thus no ultimate rationality or foundation to rest on except bare assertion. As Wilderson describes in the first chapter of Red, White, and Black: “This (gratuitous ) violence which turns a body into flesh, ripped apart literally and imaginatively, destroys the possibility of ontology because it positions the Black in an infinite and indeterminately horrifying open vulnerability, an object made available (which is to say fungible) for any subject. (Wilderson III 2010, 38; my emphasis) In describing black vulnerability as ‘infinite’, ‘indeterminate’, and ‘horrifyingly open’, Wilderson provides a conceptual framing and analytic undoing that demands rethinking who may belong to the spectrum of human vulnerability and what does not. This chapter next turns to an explication of the excessive ‘extra-ordinary’ nature of the illegible, fungible, accumulative, and abject object of blackness that characterizes black vulnerability.”¶ II. The General Economy of White Supremacy and Extra-ordinary Black Vulnerability Following in the spirit of Butler’s innovative refguring of subjectivity via vulnerability, Catriona Mackenzie, Wendy Rogers, and Susan Dodds, in the introduction to their 2014 reader titled Vulnerability: New Essays in Ethics and Feminist Philosophy, also call for the displacement of the traditional role of rationality for describing the essence of humanity, proclaiming “Human life is conditioned by vulnerability” (Mackenzie et al. 2014, 1). While vulnerability may have universal applicability for human life, they argue it does not come in one standard universal form. They make a welcomed contribution to Butler’s intervention by breaking down vulnerability into a helpful taxonomy that situates the different ways it manifests itself through our materiality as needy bodies, through the social and affective nature of our being open to others through grief, humiliation, or through our socio-political nature as open to exploitation and oppression. Also, vulnerability can emerge from a different variety of sources, that is, inherent, situational, or pathogenic, as well as exist in different states, that is, dispositional or occurrent. These distinctions are constructive and yet limited when it comes to black people. Under this rubric, the experience of black vulnerability would fall under an occurrent state, meaning that it is not a matter of dispositional possibility of becoming vulnerable, for example, some physical disabilities, but rather black vulnerability is manifest constantly. Furthermore, its source would be pathogenic entailing a systematic oppression that is not simply inherited by means of being human or strictly situational. Makenzie, Rogers, and Dodds explain, “a key feature of pathogenic vulnerability is the way that it undermines autonomy or exacerbates the sense of powerlessness engendered by vulnerability in general” (Mackenzie et al. 2014, 9). At first glance their taxonomy appears more than sufficient to account for black vulnerability. Black vulnerability would be one among many forms of occurrent and pathogenic conditions that plague a plethora of identities that fall short of the generally accepted zero-sum position of white cisgender heterosexual ablebodied bourgeois men. However, there is a marked difference for the experience of black people: their autonomy and ‘sense of power’, at least as traditional subjects, is not undermined but illegible because of an original lack of political ontological stature. Singularly, the pathology that characterize black vulnerability is abjection, whereby black people are banished from the metrics of humanity that would render their suffering, and therefore their vulnerability, irrational, that is beyond sublation, and non-relational. Perhaps the most insidious component of black vulnerability from a philosophical perspective follows from the fact that antiblackness elides any appeal to an ultimate justification or rationality. When confronted with the machinations of antiblackness in everyday life, for example, with hate crimes, police brutality, disproportionate wages, and so on, these manifestations at first appear as if they can make sense in some larger context or rationale. As if there is some identifiable reason why black people deserve repercussion, as if they had transgressed some cultural normative arrangement or even economic preserving ideology. These racist ‘events’ appear in a taxonomy of violence that point toward antiblackness, but what if the underlying justification beyond their expression from a restricted perspective escapes any ultimate justification or rationality beyond the bare assertion of black abjection? We may say that Michael Brown would be alive if he had not stolen from that convenient store (if indeed that was the case), if he were not poor (although this too of course plays a role), if he had not charged like ‘the Hulk’, if he were not jay walking, but those ancillary reasons only obscure the reality that his violation ultimately needs no reason. It was not simply a ‘sense of powerlessness’ or lack of autonomy, but instead abject inhumanness, his non-relationality, that brought him to the alter for sacrifice in the name of white supremacy. His blackness made him vulnerable beyond belief—or, to be more specific, only on the grounds of belief—because it was his blackness that brought Darren Wilson to that neighborhood, as with many other officers, and it was his blackness that turned the 18-year-old into the Hulk, it was blackness that turned 12-year-old Tamir Rice into an armed and dangerous adult, it was blackness that turned Rodney King’s shielding forearms into aggressive pursuit and falling pants into sexual assault. Jared Sexton articulates the structure of a ‘libidinal economy of white supremacy’ using the insightful heuristic of the general economy. The libidinal economy refers to the affective and subconscious desires and investments that informs one’s self-identifications. For ‘white supremacy’ these are the arrangement and distribution of desires and affects, positive or negative, that support the formation of any identity over against blackness. Now, a general economy challenges the logic of traditional economic models that are considered essentially rationalized laws of exchange, since its grounding principle is instead exuberant expenditure, without any ultimate reason. Sexton describes white supremacy as a general economy in the 2003 essay co-authored with Steve Martinot titled “The Avant-Garde of White Supremacy,” but he explores the concept with greater depth and by name in his 2008 book Amalgamation Schemes: Antiblackness and the Critique of Multiracialism. While in the former essay he uses the term ‘hyper economy’, in the latter he uses the term general economy explicitly, citing Arkady Plotnitski’s Reconfgurations as his source. For this discussion, however, it is worth considering the more familiar, and the inspiration of Plotniski’s analysis in his book, twentieth-century French theorist and eroticist Georges Bataille.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Cap K vs. Fem IR Aff › Cap Impact

Sustained global capitalism ensures nuclear escalation, magnifies local conflicts, and intensifies inequalities

Hrubec and Uhde 18- The research of guest editors of this thematic issue was made in the framework of the research programme “Global Conflicts and Local Interactions”, Strategy AV21, The Czech Academy of Sciences. https://sci-hub.se/https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0896920518798880?journalCode=crsb

The contemporary changes make global conflicts and local interactions increasingly interconnected. The local problem can spread rapidly globally, and global problems can interfere in many local communities. Diverse global conflicts have a strong influence on local social dynamics; at the same time, local processes, especially in hegemonic geopolitical macro-regions, shape the global political and economic order. Today’s problems have crystallized as a result of various technological, economic, political, social, cultural and other global interactions over the long history of human civilization which have not been sufficiently processed and integrated into the systemic framework of local, regional and national structures and the global civilizational system, nor into theoretical research analyses. While colonial history lies deep in the roots of many contemporary problems, today the main power behind the perpetuation of systemic and structural causes of inequalities and injustice is global capitalism, with the related processes of the exploitation and marginalization of various world macro-regions and hegemonic war conflicts. Critical research into global conflicts and local interactions brings to the fore mutual relations between diverse issues such as military escalation, wars, transnational migration, poverty, exploitation, displacement and social expulsion, transnational corporations, gender and racial inequalities, etc., and opens up horizons for the normative issues of struggling for global justice and peace, reshaping democracy and citizenship in a post-national constellation and new economic paradigms compatible with civilizational and ecological developments. The challenge faced by social research into global conflicts is that analyses need to be directed not only at security studies, but also and principally at the complex sources and causes of wars and other contemporary problems, mainly in the form of the subtle economic, political, and cultural practices of global capitalism which lie behind armed conflicts. These analyses are also the first step towards resolving conflicts. In other words, we can say that analyses of “hard power” should be supplemented and redefined by analyses focused on “soft power”, that is, on the economic, political and other forces which condition the first kind of force. The subject of global conflicts in relation to their local interactions has not been researched systematically much yet, although global conflicts, on the one hand, and various related local economic, political, and cultural processes, on the other, have received separate attention from numerous researchers. It is important to start with the premise that global conflicts and their local interactions constitute fundamental challenges for social research and also future possibilities of positive social interactions. This premise transforms the perspective from which individual issues and territorial analyses are approached. Existing studies have shown that, while territorial integration processes have lasted on our planet for millennia, and globalizing processes have continued since the expansion of Europeans into the Americas 500 years ago, a majority of authors associate the notion of global interactions primarily with accelerated globalization since the end of the 1980s. Challenges faced by social research into global interactions place new demands on analyses of conflictual transnationalization in late modern societies and on cosmopolitan claims in a transdisciplinary approach (Fine, 2007; Jaggar, 2014; Beck, 2016). A precondition for these analyses is consideration of the current crisis tendencies of global capitalism which could prove deeper in the long run than the structural crisis of 2008 (Robinson, 2014). The deeper characteristics of these crisis tendencies indicate trends which may lead not only to structural crisis, but also to a crisis of the whole system. The past structural crises of the world system seriously polarized relations between social groups and classes, damaged the economic basis, and weakened or delegitimized state authority, with consequences for the restructuring of the capitalist system. Such restructuring made possible the revitalization of the collapsed economy, politics, and society within the system. The main cause of the current crisis is over-accumulation because global production and trade heavily increased accumulation in the past few decades. Current problematic trends are defined by environmental limits, global social and economic inequalities, social control and militarized tendencies, the territorial limits to the expansion of the contemporary order, the population creating surplus labor, and political contradictions between the nation states and transnational arrangements in the era of global capitalism (Harris, 2016; Sklair, 2016). The thematic symposium in this issue follows research and its international cooperation within a new transdisciplinary research programme “Global Conflicts and Local Interactions” at the Czech Academy of Sciences in Prague. The research team focuses not only on armed conflicts, but also on economic, political, social, and cultural conflicts and their local interlinks with regard to particularism and universalism and also with regard to interactions between global, macro-regional, national and local orders. It contributes to critical analyses of the contemporary society and the complex thematic issue of glocal interactions (Fasenfest, 2010; Hrubec, 2012). Nevertheless, this special thematic symposium cannot analyze all the relevant topics within the thematic area of global conflicts and local interactions. It addresses three important aspects in particular: first, militarized escalation leading to the global police state and threat of nuclear war; second, the complex intertwinement of transnational societal challenges anchored in contradictions of the current global system; third, problematic issues and the positive potential of civil society in Western countries and in sub-Saharan Africa. Militarized Escalation, Transnationalization, and Civil Developments First, militarized escalation by means of current global repressive tendencies is linked to the transformation of the police and war. While the global order as a whole develops step by step in specific local and national conditions, at the same time the militarization of local and national places is Hrubec and Uhde 3 closely interlinked to macro-regional involvement in the webs of transnational and global war conflicts (Robinson, 2018). A locally created problem in the main global superpower, the USA, can easily spread globally. Even if the USA is declining power, its leading economic and political groups, in collaboration with other transnational capital groups, have still played a leading role in the domination of the world via militarily channels on the global level. The militarization of the economy and society is rooted particularly in the events of 11 September 2001, and has led to global interactions that connect the military and security complex with industrial and political trends in a specific dangerous way (Hristov, 2014; Paley, 2014). These repressive tendencies have led to the establishment of a global police state. Because of the new political and economic trends in the USA and their intense conflictual integration within global capitalism, there are high risks of military escalation, with dangerous lethal consequences for societies (Hrubec, 2016). The current impulses for the nuclear threat and related problems are formulated in new strategic documents of the US administration, particularly in the National Security Strategy and the Nuclear Posture Review. Political statements based on these and other documents open up the possibility of the real use of nuclear weapons in a limited nuclear war. Highly advanced electronic systems, containing transnational communication with big data, developed high-precise weapon systems and other tools, also allow for the application of nuclear weapons on a very specific territorial scale. On the basis of new technologies, political and economic actors have revitalized the possibility of nuclear war, and the establishment of Donald Trump in the White House has opened a real threat of “thinking the unthinkable”, i.e. a real nuclear conflict. Even if the hypothesis for nuclear war cannot be proven before the war breaks out, the highly dangerous military, economic, and political tendencies potentially leading to this kind of war are sufficient reason to pay attention to this serious problem. In the long history of human civilization, people have always misused the most developed technological innovations in wars. There is a serious probability that we are not at the end of history, when the people would stop doing that. This is why it is important to help to contain this kind of threat by analyzing it (Lodgaard, 2010). Second, the thematic area of global conflicts and local interactions places a spotlight on the transnationalization of social and other processes and relations. While these intertwined aspects of the contradictions of global capitalism are often examined separately, their analyses require research into complex interconnections and the common causes of local and global problems, which is also a necessary first step in articulating potential remedies and normative requirements for global justice. The analytical lens of global interactions also sheds light on the changing role of the nation state, and problematizes the commonly accepted premise equating society with the political unit of a nation state. The gap between the global interconnectedness of social processes, on the one hand, and efforts to address arising social conflicts at the level of nation states and internationally organized political institutions, on the other hand, is prevalent not only in real politics, but also in the current social sciences (Beck, 2016). Asking fundamental contemporary questions thus calls for a different methodological approach, which is linked to transnational inquiry. The main focuses are on the transnational intertwinement of social and environmental contradictions that are manifested in various conjunctions in global crises, risks, and conflicts, and on transnational migration, which is an exemplary case of interdependent problems, be they economic, social, political, cultural, or environmental. The profit-oriented global system creates social and environmental risks that are unequally distributed. Nevertheless, they pose a challenge for everybody on the planet. While from a short-term perspective the transnational ruling groups benefit from the planetary plundering of natural resources, labor precarisation, exploitation and expulsion, and sharpening social and economic inequalities, their adaptation to these social conflicts and crises induces the further multiplication and cumulation of destructive consequences to a point that) poses a threat to the current system and even to the sustainability of human life on the planet (Sassen, 2014). These are the fundamental limits of the current system

2022 Michigan Kritik
Cap K vs. Fem IR Aff › Cap Links – Identity Politics

The AFF’s identity politics only serve as a distraction from challenging capitalism—and even worse, the distraction does nothing to solve for structural inequalities at all.

Pook 18 (Zooey Sophia, “QUEER IS THE NEW CAPITALISM: NEOLIBERAL TECHNOLOGIES AND A BLUEPRINT FOR THE LEFT BEYOND IDENTITY POLITICS,” Dissertation for a PhD in Philosophy, New Mexico State University)

Identity politics have altered the way we speak about politics and in what ways. Neoliberalism does not employ the exclusionary tactics of the disciplinary age, but embraces diversity and inclusion as a means to neutralize hostis and to flatten 94 identity into a singular postfordist way of being. Discipline today is an interpersonal tool of neoliberal culture, in which individuals may take up the baton of political correctness and become an honorary member of the p.c. police, challenging inflammatory and discriminatory language, while also serving the goals of neoliberal order. Dean (2009) writes, quoting Zizek, The true victory (the true ‘negation of the negation’) occurs when the enemy talks your language. In this sense, a true victory is a victory in defeat. It occurs when one’s specific message is accepted as a universal ground, even by the enemy, (p. 7) The true victory of the post-1968 Left is the instatement of a universal language of neoliberal multiculturalism. Is this not what presents itself in all facets of culture today? A superficial respect of difference is afforded and policed omnipotently. A TV host makes a racist or sexist comment and he is fired. A store clerk tells a transgender woman she can’t use a restroom and the store is boycotted and put out of business. A movie does not promote women in the right way and it’s written about in a well-read blog and it flops in theaters. Meanwhile, the institutional injustices suffered by queer, black, and female bodies remain untouched. Identity politics serve neoliberalism because they orient us towards pacifism, and a focus on interpersonal abuses, reducing politics to speech, and directing us away from the functions of economics and politics. What identity politics have effectively served to create is an impotent language of multiculturalism that privileges victimhood and orients the disenfranchised toward superficial battles rather than towards direct action, subversion, and violence. Dean (2009) explains, 95 The position of victim (rather than victor) grows out of a prominent strain of contemporary American politics, namely, the rights discourse associated with movements for civil rights, women’s rights, and the rights of sexual minorities.7 Although often linked to left political correctness, speaking as a victim is at odds with the long history of the labor movement as well as with the politics of the new left. One need but recall a whole series of claims to power: ‘Black power,’ ‘Sisterhood is powerful,’ ‘We’re here; we’re queer; get used to it,’ ‘Power to the people.’ Reducing political speech to testimony to the suffering of victims inverts these claims to power and subverts the movements’ activist spirit, (p. 5) The discourse of victimhood does not produce institutional change. It produces social milieus. Today’s identity politics are vacuous. They have been reduced by neoliberal technologies to a microcosm of what they once were. Today’s “social justice warriors” are self-aggrandizing, going through the motions, and their digital protests are in direct symmetry with the emptiness of academic social critique. Frances Lee’s widely circulated (2017) blog article, “Kin Aesthetics: Excommunicate Me From the Church of Social Justice” mirrors LaTour’s (2004) critique of cultural studies, evidencing that identity politics movements today have become a divisive lifestyle which uncritically promote elitist and superficial language/analysis and attachment to “sacred texts” that fail to meaningfully challenge capitalist logics. When once Stokely Carmichael (1967) called for direct action and violence, citing the ways that civil rights movements become coopted, today #BlackLivesMatter is a savvy political brand aimed at shaping the modem platform of the Democratic Party, unconcerned with neoliberal imperialism (Dixon, 2015). When transgender women once threw bricks at the Stonewall Inn and physically defended themselves against police bmtality, today the LGBT+ movement musters its collective force to fail movies that 96 don’t adequately address the perception of their history (Smith, 2015). Identity politics have become problematic, as social justice warriors might say. Neoliberal technologies are particularly good at orienting us towards digital milieus. Identity politics have become hashtags and Facebook arguments. They have become circulation; more information capital lost in the flow on neoliberal networks. Jodi Dean (2009) explains her notion of circulation, Any particular contribution remains secondary to the fact of circulation. The value of any particular contribution is likewise inversely proportionate to the openness, inclusiveness, or extent of a circulating data stream: the more opinions or comments that are out there, the less of an impact any given one might make (and the more shocking, spectacular, and new a contribution must be in order to register or have an impact). In sum, communication functions symptomatically to produce its own negation, (p. 26) Today, issues of social justice and culture are taken up in endless ways on the internet by ever fracturing groups of individuals, constantly reimagining their space, positionality, and identity. Social media, blogs, group pages, and more direct lines of communication swell with hashtags, petitions, and arguments lined with a language of social justice ripe with lingo and abbreviation specific to the causes of internet activists. They remain detached from means of power and economics, and are instead easily swept into the currents of network, producing ever more information capital for the system they wish to challenge. The internet is a cozy and comfortable place for the disenfranchised to dump their proclivities for change. The Invisible Committee (2007) writes of activists organizations as “empty structures, which, in spite of their grand origins, can never be filled. In all their affairs, at every level, these organizations are concerned above all with their own survival as organizations, and 97 little else,” but “Far more dreadful are social milieus, with their supple texture, their gossip, and their informal hierarchies. Flee all milieus. Each and every milieu is oriented towards the neutralization of some truth” (p. 100). Digital milieus are no different: they form a language, a culture, sublimate a revolutionary message, and finally, punish and attack anyone who fails to perform their message the way they have deemed to be fashionable. These milieus and fractioned identity politics groups fail to convert any particulars into a universal cause or coherent Left capable of challenging neoliberal power. They are divisive and often simply serve as a vehicle to dump one’s rightful fears and anger about social injustices, producing a hard sardony, as their digital contributions are appropriated and exchanged as information capital. Dean (2009) writes, Contestations today rarely employ common terms, points of reference, or demarcated frontiers. In our highly mediated communications environments we confront instead a multiplication of resistances and assertions so extensive as to hinder the formation of strong counterhegemonies. The proliferation, distribution, acceleration, and intensification of communicative access and opportunity result in a deadlocked democracy incapable of serving as a form for political change. I refer to this democracy that talks without responding as communicative capitalism, (p. 22) The digital milieus of identity politics cannot serve us. They fracture, rather than connect, and convert useful resentment against the system into circulation. They squander revolutionary potential. Digital milieus are the internet equivalent of activist organizations and thus exacerbate the already existent problems of management, exclusivity, and production, through the reach, scope, and capture of neoliberal technologies. 98 Identity politics and digital milieus converge with neoliberal technologies to orient us to nonviolence, toward issues of culture rather than institutional awareness, and toward matters of the interpersonal, because this is what is achievable via the method of digital milieus and the internet, such as through petitions, social media, etc. Identity politics are particularly attuned and skilled in making it known that a particularly movie might be racist or even that an act of police brutality has occurred, but not in highlighting or addressing the ways in which systems function. Digital milieus, in short, orient us to matters of subjective, rather than objective violence. Slavoj Zizek (2008) explains the difference, as The catch is that subjective and objective violence cannot be perceived from the same standpoint: subjective violence is experienced as such against the background of a non-violent zero level. It is seen as a perturbation of the ‘normal,’ peaceful state of things. However, objective violence is precisely the violence inherent to this ‘normal’ state of things. Objective violence is invisible since it sustains the very zero-level standard against which we perceive something as subjectively violent. Systemic violence is thus something like the notorious ‘dark matter’ of physics, the counterpart to an all-too-visible subjective violence. It may be invisible, but it has to be taken into account if one is to make sense of what otherwise seem to be ‘irrational’ explosions of subjective violence, (p. 2) Digital identity politics address egregious shows of force that emerge and appear on top of the regular functions of economics, politics, and our daily routines, which disappear in mundanity. We can stop a bill from passing that would victimize transgender women, or get a cop put on trial for killing an unarmed black man, but identity politics cannot address the imperial and domestic violence of capitalism; it cannot impede the rhythm of empire. Politics are thus reduced to subjectivized dilemma, and often reduced further to the smallest microcosm of interpersonal 99 interaction since internet technologies allow even the most ordinary civilian to hold a lens at all places and times in the public sphere. Identity politics becomes lost in the exchange of all things that the neoliberal shift from capital as wage relation to social relation produced. Digital milieus cannot challenge the flows of information and capital in network because it is contributing to them through the conversion of their revolutionary anger to circulation. However, I would like to consider what form resistance might take to disturb and counteract the flows of empire. In the following section I will examine what kind of force might make way against the objective violence and processes of desubjectivation through which neoliberalism sustains itself. I will attempt to offer solutions.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Cap K vs. Fem IR Aff › Cap Links – Identity Politics

Neoliberalism must be addressed before the aff’s identity politics—their performance only gets coopted by the capitalist system otherwise

Pook 18 (Zooey Sophia, “QUEER IS THE NEW CAPITALISM: NEOLIBERAL TECHNOLOGIES AND A BLUEPRINT FOR THE LEFT BEYOND IDENTITY POLITICS,” Dissertation for a PhD in Philosophy, New Mexico State University)

Although Butler and company have made it clear that they do not wish to put the burden of social change on the backs of the least off, instead, carefully relegating their actions as potential strategies for academics, there does at least seem to be a kind of sensationalism that appears, at the very least, as an effect of such inquiries. Similarly, it is important to note efforts taken by Butler to delegitimize the flimsy perceptions of agency drawn from Gender Trouble that were addressed, most notably, in Bodies That Matter, and through the addition of her concept of precarity, which I will specifically address in the following chapter. In Bodies that Matter, Butler reiterates and strengthens her claim that performativity is not a matter of personal choice but of a subject already decided through the repetition/regularization of cultural norms (p. x). In Dispossession, performativity is compounded by the notion of precarity and the ways different bodies are specifically dispossessed in relation to neoliberal power. But even with these updates and nuances, the central tenants and problems of performativity and performative transgression remain, as does the impact of Gender Trouble, whether read thoughtfully or otherwise. This is the reason that I took the time to offer evidence of the specificities of the kinds of performative being done- so a reasonable analysis could be made about the ethics and effectiveness of performativity and identity-based politics when considering the situations of queer bodies. For the majority of women and gender studies students privileged and 62 educated enough to make sense of these works, reading about poor transgender inmates and impoverished queer people of color, for example, written by presumably safe and comfortable academics, lends itself to a kind of utopian thinking where the revolution is to come from a distressed and magical “other” at the deepest and darkest margins of our culture. And this is obvious enough if you’ve spent any time in a cultural studies department or in an LGBT center on most college campuses in the United States, as much excitement is generated from the possibilities of queer bodies serving as resistance tools. One should not underplay the excitement they had the first time reading Judith Butler as an undergrad, after all. In response, I think it is fair to say that queer theorists engaged in these projects would echo something not unlike Patricia Hill Collin’s (2004) defense of feminist standpoint theory- that it is more about the social conditions that a group faces than individual experiences (p. 247), but it is hard not to see how the damage is done. This is why Uma Naryan (2004) warns theorists of acquiring a kind of “double vision” where we transfer some kind of magical notions of truth and revolutionary knowledge to those who are most oppressed by the social forces and institutions we pit ourselves against (p. 233). This is an ironic twist because it seems not unlike the high theory equivalent of figures like “the magical negro” and others who have been well noted by cultural theorists as minority figures in works of popular culture who exist solely to advance the white narrative of a film, often completely devoid and separate from the logic of the film (Glenn, 2009). These are important points to consider because of the condition of LGBT+ people in the United States and in the world, as transgender people, 63 specifically, face enormous wealth disparities and are the target of murder on a quite disproportionate level (Longo, 2017). The challenges and institutional hardships of LGBT+ people are, of course, also exacerbated for LGBT+ people of color and for women, especially non-cisgender women. What should be raised at this point, are serious questions of ethics- both of the researcher in engaging such populations for political and strategic purposes and for readers and activists interested in drawing tactical conclusions from, or in tandem, with the group of inquiry. If we compare the previous works mentioned to similar works in Sociology, for examples, such as Unspeakable Love: Gay and Lesbian Life in the Middle East or Kristen Schilt and Laurel Westbrook’s “Doing Gender, Doing Heteronormativity: ‘Gender Normal’s,’ Transgender People and the Social Maintenance of Heteroesexuality,” we see much more careful attempts to make light of sensitive issues such as gay and lesbian experience in the middle east, violence towards transgender women, and the experience of transgender men in the workplace, followed by pragmatic examination of policy and law and their possibilities. This is far removed from the kind of sensationalizing or drawing undo political consequence or importance from the other’s body or experiences, despite being analysis bom of the same kind of inquiry and concern. Beyond what Hill-Collins proclaims about examining the shared social conditions of a group, it is more worthwhile to turn to the conditions of power themselves, as doing so will reveal a shift in the forms and distributions of neoliberal power, and more importantly, the changing technologies through which our lives are mediated. At such a time, identity politics will really be beside the point, and 64 performativity will need to be reassessed as a process of digital appropriation. Queer theorists have long been engaged in a kind of project to flesh out Foucault’s Discipline and Punish, acknowledging that while all bodies are disciplined by institutions and social formations of the state, they aren’t done so equally. Here, each scholar takes a turn yelling out a different minority group to which the specific particularities of oppression will be examined, along with the possibilities of resistance that coincide. It is probably long past time to turn back and diagnose power again; things have changed. Ironically, Foucault did this in very meaningful ways in his later work, arguing powerfully against self-identification and distinctions of gender and sexual identity he saw as problematically developing in the aftermath of ’68 (1978). It is, after all, one of Foucault’s major accomplishments, from his very earliest works, to illuminate the connection between the emergence of positive knowledge of human bodies and the corresponding institutional techniques that would follow to manage them (Behrent, 2013, p. 77). Now, it is neoliberalism in full bloom, and its technologies of appropriation that we must address against identity-based political resistances. The kind of compelled disclosure that Foucault draws a history of in the confessional and in medicine is now a relation of culture; it is decentralized and surrounds us, comprising our activity on the internet and between each other. The expectation of offering or being asked for a preferred pronoun in the transgender community is a serious example of this. Such an expectation transcends trust and autonomy thus reproducing the demands of information capital, rather than allowing identity to emerge or to not emerge on one’s own terms. Shannon Winnubst’s (2012) 65 work, for example, which utilizes the work of Foucault from this period to draw critique of the new ontological condition that neoliberalism produces is a useful and important work linking identity studies to postfordist being is particularly necessary in cultural studies, as is transcends the gap between technology, micro and macro political concerns, and locates neoliberal power via their connection

2022 Michigan Kritik
Cap K vs. Fem IR Aff › Cap Links - PoMo Fem

The affs engagement in post-structural feminism culminates in the reification of enlightenment thinking and capitalist hierarchies.

Willey 14- Marilynn is a passionate supporter of Wellesley and its mission to prepare students to make meaningful contributions to the world through disciplined thinking and engagement with diverse perspectives. She is thrilled to support the Freedom Project's efforts to be a beacon of tolerance and pluralism both on campus and beyond file:///Users/ethancooper/Downloads/WCTC_2014_WilleyMarilynn_ACritiqueofPostmoder.pdf

In attempting to expound upon the thinking behind poststructuralist feminism, Alcoff explains, “The mechanism of power referred to here is the construction of the subject by a discourse that weaves knowledge and power into a coercive structure…on this view, essentialist formulations of womanhood, even when made by feminists, ‘tie’ the individual to her identity as a woman and thus cannot represent a solution to sexism.” 94 The problem with this view, when it is applied to social and political movements, is that it places the individual’s ability and desire to subjectively create and design their own identity and purpose as the highest moral good - there is not higher order or meaning beyond what the individual creates as part of their autonomous and non-essential identity. As Alcoff explains, “The political struggle can have only a ‘negative function:’ rejecting ‘everything finite, definite, structured, loaded with meaning, in the existing state of society.’”95 Such a view might be helpful when addressing individual psychological or social difficulties, but it is a problematic way to lead a social movement and a destructive way to lead people in understanding their role in a social, humane world. Alcoff’s criticism is rooted in the philosophically challenging aspect of such a view: “Applied to the concept of woman the poststructuralist’s view !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 93 Ibid, 8. 94 Ibid. 95 Ibid, 11. 48 results in what I shall call nominalism: the idea that the category of ‘woman’ is a fiction and that feminist efforts must be directed toward dismantling this fiction.”96 Alcoff explains that the appeal of post-structuralism to feminist thinkers is twofold: “First, it seems to hold out the promise of an increased freedom for women, the ‘free play’ of a plurality of differences unhampered by any predetermined gender identity as formulated by either patriarchy or cultural feminism. Second, it moves decisively beyond cultural feminism and liberal feminism in further theorizing what they leave untouched: the construction of subjectivity.”97 Interestingly, Alcoff notes the extent to which poststructuralist feminism is a direct descendent of classical liberal views on the individual: “Despite rumblings from the Continent, Anglo-American thought is still wedded to the ideal of a universalizable, apolitical methodology and set of transhistorical basic truths unfettered by associations with particular genders, races, classes, or cultures.” 98 Alcoff sees the generic human idea, promoted in Enlightenment thinking, as closely related to post-structuralism’s designation of “individual particularities such as subjective experience as a social construct,” and claims that “post-structuralism’s negation of the authority of the subject coincides nicely with the classical liberal’s view that human particularities are irrelevant. (For the liberal, race, class, and gender are ultimately irrelevant to questions of justice and truth because ‘underneath we are all the same.’)” Perhaps Alcoff’s most relevant and pressing question is the one that points to the primary problem facing any proponent of poststructuralist feminism: “A feminist !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 96 Ibid. 97 Ibid. 98 Ibid, 13. 49 adoption of nominalism will be confronted with the same problem theories of ideology have, that is, Why is a right-wing woman’s consciousness constructed via social discourse but a feminist’s consciousness is not?”99 It has been recognized by many feminists in academia that disagreements among feminists are cause for concern, especially those who wish to see feminist ideas of any form succeed. The editors of Conflicts in Feminism note in their introduction that, While feminists have in principle tended to agree that difference is a more productive theoretical and political category than either universalizing consensus or divisive oppositions, in practice, actual differences within feminist discourse have tended to erupt into separate camps. At this moment in time, some of these conflicts have proven so divisive that they seem to foreclose rather than stimulate debate, even at times appearing to threaten the very viability of contemporary feminism as a political and theoretical venture.100 The problems that result from such a stifling intellectual climate are apparent not only to those dealing with feminism in theory, but also among those putting it into practice in the classroom or in the public sphere. The editors of Conflicts in Feminism also echo Alcoff’s observation that “A common divide keeps forming in both feminist thought and action between the need to build the identity ‘woman’ and give it solid political meaning and the need to tear down the very category ‘woman’ and dismantle its all-too-solid history.”101 They recognize that neither approach is without fault: social construction does not seem plausible to the average person, and “to assert that the body has no enduring, natural language often !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 99 Ibid, 12. 100 Marianne Hirsch and Evelyn Fox Keller, “Introduction,” Conflicts in Feminism, (New York: Routledge, 1990), 4. 101 Ann Snitow, “A Gender Diary,” in Conflicts in Feminism, 9. 50 seems like a rejection of common sense.”102 Not only is it a tough sell to a mainstream audience, but also the poststructuralist approach is logically problematic, in that “By definition social construction theory cannot offer a securely bounded area for the study of gender; instead it initiates an inspiring collapse of gender verities.”103 Alcoff offers a similar sentiment, asking, “If gender is simply a social construct, the need and even the possibility of a feminist politics becomes immediately problematic. What can we demand in the name of women if ‘women’ do not exist and demands in their name simply reinforce the myth that they do?”104 Such an approach eventually leads to an almost nihilistic nothingness - a void in which there is no need for women’s liberation because women do not exist. The editors also touch on an important dichotomy in feminist thought, somewhat analogous to Alcoff’s cultural feminism and poststructuralist feminism: Equality and difference are broad ideas and have included a rrange of definitions and political expressions. Equality, for example, can mean anything from the mildest liberal reform to the most radical reduction of gender to insignificance. Difference can mean anything from Mary Daly’s belief in the natural superiority of women to psychoanalytic theories of how women are inevitably cast as “the Other” because they lack penises.105 Clearly, even within two polarized categories - equality and difference feminism - there are still more opportunities for polarization and disagreement. !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 102 Ibid. 103 Ibid. 104 Linda Alcoff, “Cultural Feminism Versus Post-Structuralism: The Identity Crisis in Feminist Theory,” 13. 105 Ann Snitow, “A Gender Diary,” in Conflicts in Feminism, 26. 51 It is clear from Alcoff’s essay and from the essays in Conflicts in Feminism that this issue is deeply troubling for feminists who are committed to an academic and logically sound feminism that is rooted in reality: A subjectivity that is fundamentally shaped by gender appears to lead irrevocably to essentialism, the posing of a male/female opposition as universal and ahistorical. A subjectivity that is not fundamentally shaped by gender appears to lead to the conception of a generic human subject, as if we could peel away our ‘cultural’ layers and get to the real root of human nature, which turns out to be genderless. Are these really our only choices?106 I argue that they are not the only choices, and that both cultural feminism and poststructuralist feminism adhere to and even depend fundamentally on an underlying and flawed liberation from essence view. The problem with the liberation from essence view, as it is found in both cultural feminism and poststructuralist feminism, is that, in dealing with issues of broader social and political relevance, it ultimately places the individual’s autonomy and subjectivity as the highest moral good. Whether it follows the cultural feminist line of thinking, which views women’s interests and men’s interests in opposition to each other and does not presuppose or allow for any mutual interests or synergy beyond the individual woman or man’s happiness, or the poststructuralist feminist’s view of denying the category of “woman” in the first place, neither view takes larger societal goods into consideration. Neither view considers a purpose outside of the individual’s own identity, self-definition in relation to community or tradition, and subjective experience in the world. !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 106 Linda Alcoff, “Cultural Feminism Versus Post-Structuralism: The Identity Crisis in Feminist Theory,” 16. 52 While such views may have value in a therapeutic or psychological setting, they are destructive ways to view social interactions and to interpret one’s role in society and relationships and duties to others. Cultural feminism sees masculinity and femininity as “at war,” and can be traced to the type of matriarchal feminism promoted by Charlotte Perkins Gilman, while poststructuralist feminism faces serious logical inconsistencies that threaten to eliminate the notion of women in the first place. Hoff Sommers’ offers a more classical liberal and moderate feminism centered on freedom and individual liberties. Thus, we have three primary schools of feminist thought to consider. There are the two that are accepted on the left: poststructuralist feminism and cultural (matriarchal) feminism. Then there is the more right leaning blend of freedom and maternal feminism promoted by Hoff Sommers. This chapter has identified the difficulties that contemporary feminists face in attempting to develop an underlying philosophical impetus for the movement; next I will consider how they are addressing feminism as an academic discipline with a role in educational institutions.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Cap K vs. Fem IR Aff › Cap Links – Gender

Capitalism is the sole antagonism standing in the way of liberation. A singular focus on gender eschews a wider class based struggle cannot produce effective change. Only a unified and decisive blow to capitalism can rupture the patriarchy.

Previato 02- In Defence of Marxism – launched in 1998 – has become one of the world's foremost sources of Marxist theory, analysis on current events and the history of the revolutionary workers’ movement. https://www.marxist.com/marxism-feminism-womens-day101002.htm

In 1808, in his Theory of four movements, Fourier explained that "social progress is measured by the progress of the woman towards freedom". Later, Marx and Engels analysed the development of human society in detail, not only from the economic viewpoint but also culturally and in the relationship between the sexes. Marxism analysed the origin of women's oppression and laid the theoretical basis for overcoming it. In particular Engels, in The Origins of the Family, Private Property and the State (1884), starting from the scientific and anthropological knowledge of that time, showed the dynamic nature of social structures and how these structures are linked to the level of development of the productive forces. "The increase of production in all branches - cattle-raising, agriculture, domestic handicrafts - gave human labour-power the capacity to produce a larger product than was necessary for its maintenance. (…) As to how and when the herds passed out of the common possession of the tribe or the gens into the ownership of individual heads of families, we know nothing at present. But in the main it must have occurred during this stage. With the herds and the other new riches, a revolution came over the family. To procure the necessities of life had always been the business of the man; he produced and owned the means of doing so. The herds were the new means of producing these necessities; the taming of the animals in the first instance and their later tending were the man's work. To him, therefore, belonged the cattle, and to him the commodities and the slaves received in exchange for cattle. All the surplus which the acquisition of the necessities of life now yielded fell to the man; the woman shared in its enjoyment, but had no part in its ownership. The "savage" warrior and hunter had been content to take second place in the house, after the woman; the "gentler" shepherd, in the arrogance of his wealth, pushed himself forward into the first place and the woman down into the second. And she could not complain. (…) "The man now being actually supreme in the house, the last barrier to his absolute supremacy had fallen. This autocracy was confirmed and perpetuated by the overthrow of mother-right, the introduction of father-right, and the gradual transition of the pairing marriage into monogamy. But this tore a breach in the old gentile order; the single family became a power, and its rise was a menace to the gens.(1) (Fredrick Engels, Origins of the Family, Private Property, and the State, Chapter IX: Barbarism and Civilization.) Since these ancient origins, women have been looked on as inferior beings. A contemporary of Marx in Italy, the abbot Rosmini, inspired the upbringing of many “young ladies” from good families and appealed to nature to emphasise their age-old subjection to men: "It is for the husband, according to the convenience of nature, to be lord and master; it is for the woman, and so it should be, to be almost an appendage, a complement to the husband, entirely consecrated to him and dominated by his name”(2). These theories may cause some amusement and sound out of date, but they formed the basis for family law in Italy right up until 1975, when it was finally reformed after very hard struggles. While struggles and debates have arisen around this question in many moments in history, the rise of capitalism marked a decisive transition which radically changed the relations between individuals. Liberation outside the walls of the home As Engels explains, the oppression of the woman within the household was the result of change outside it. To the degree in which the labour of the man, linked to herding and agriculture, began to produce the wealth of those societies by producing a surplus over and above family needs, which was "sold", domestic labour ceased to be the fundamental wealth. It was of a private nature, could not be exchanged for other goods on the market and thus lost its value. The labour of the man, whose products were exchanged for gain, became productive, while that of the woman, whose product was not for sale, became unproductive. This change outside the family marked an overturning of the balance of forces within it. To quote Engels again: "We can already see from this that to emancipate woman and make her the equal of the man is and remains an impossibility so long as the woman is shut out from social productive labor and restricted to private domestic labor. The emancipation of woman will only be possible when woman can take part in production on a large, social scale, and domestic work no longer claims anything but an insignificant amount of her time. And only now has that become possible through modern large-scale industry, which does not merely permit of the employment of female labor over a wide range, but positively demands it, while it also tends towards ending private domestic labor by changing it more and more into a public industry."(3) (Fredrick Engels, Origins of the Family, Private Property, and the State, Chapter IX: Barbarism and Civilization.) The development of the capitalist mode of production actually had important repercussions on all women, from those of the upper classes to proletarian women. It was precisely the processes explained by Engels which pushed bourgeois women, and even some from the nobility, to demand more rights, and, as we shall attempt to clarify here by describing some of the struggles at the turn of the 19th-20th centuries, to shake up consciousness and the social system. The class struggle and the struggle against patriarchal society However, the capitalist mode of production marked an irreconcilable break between the interests of the exploited and the exploiters. The capitalist system pushes the individual to find a role in social production. Thus not only did bourgeois women come out of their "gilded prisons" to demand a seat in Parliament or a place in male professions, but also millions of peasant women and housewives were thrust by want into large-scale production: the factory, the mill, the mine, the office and the call center have become the place of a further form of oppression: class oppression. This second burden, however, brings them out of the solitude of the four walls, gives them the chance to find other female and male comrades in the fight against their exploited position, become protagonists in their own lives, break their subjection to men and strike a blow against patriarchal society. The whole experience of women workers' struggles teaches just this: the struggle in the workplace is always accompanied by a crisis in the family, with men looking suspiciously on the new female protagonism while women, gaining confidence in their abilities, no longer put up with abuse and ridicule by fathers, husbands and brothers. Entry into the world of labour, the earning of a wage and, ultimately, the class conflict, do not automatically lead to the liberation of the woman, but communists who set themselves this aim must understand the connection between these two aspects; it is the class conflict that most clearly reveals to women in general the reactionary nature of the family as a place where individuals, and especially women and children, suffer oppression. Communists must take advantage of this objective condition to put forward a different idea of how human beings can live together, based on the socialisation of economic resources, of household tasks, of the care and upbringing of children. But above all they must make it clear that the cause of the tensions and violence that are part of daily family life lies in the private nature of the responsibilities that capitalism necessarily unloads onto the shoulders of the family and of women in particular. So breaking women’s oppression, breaking down this private character, means making the struggle for women's liberation part of the struggle against capitalism. Taking up the women's question is not just an extra, but a decisive issue which brings the struggle against capitalism onto more advanced ground. Communists do not fight this system only because it forces three quarters of the world into the most inhuman poverty, but also because it is a brake on the development of culture, science and human resources, and from a simple brake it is transforming itself more and more into a system leading to barbarism in human relationships even in the advanced capitalist countries. Thus the battle is also an ideological one. The nature of feminism Up to now we have avoided using the term feminism in relation to the struggle of the women's movement and we believe that a few clarifications are needed concerning this term. It was Fourier who first spoke of feminism, giving the term a positive value as it meant the struggle of women against their oppression. However, historically the term has been taken over basically by movements with a bourgeois or petty bourgeois leadership, often coming into conflict with the labour movement and its organisations. The feminist movement, particularly after the Second World War, produced ideas and analyses which were unquestionably valid, and in some cases adopted revolutionary Marxist ideas. However, the fact remains that overall it remained a prisoner of a reductionist view of the women's question, which saw it as a central battle with all women being lumped together regardless of their social background and separately from all other struggles (wages, social conditions, etc.). While it is true that the denial of rights affects women of different social classes, there is an enormous gap between the conditions of women, according to the class they belong to, and this distance is inevitably reproduced in the aims they set themselves. First of all there is the question of property. Bourgeois women have to look after their own and their family’s and acquaintances’ property. Proletarian women, with their class demands, together with their demands as women, are a constant threat to bourgeois property, which is challenged not only by the programme of the labour movement (which may be more or less advanced) but particularly by the methods of struggle (strikes, occupations, etc.) and the mass character of these struggles. Secondly there is the problem of the goals of the struggle. Historically the feminist movement has had many different expressions which we will analyse later in this text. Here we will try to summarise these objectives: the central theme for bourgeois women in the feminist movement is the cultural battle. At the beginning of the 20th century this was expressed in the extension of democratic rights, such as the right to vote, the right to study and access to the "male" professions (lawyers, doctors etc.), but it later found its demands in female protagonism and against a Catholic culture which saw the woman as the "angel of the hearth" (divorce, abortion rights). This cultural battle was often accompanied by a strong verbal radicalism and also by "exemplary" actions aimed at showing the revolutionary and universal character of those demands. Basically, however, although democratic rights for women are universal, in other words they involve everyone, posing the cultural struggle separately from the economic system gives this battle a partial character. It may have striking effects but does not undermine the system. Hence the eternal debate as to whether we should demand women's emancipation or liberation. The most moderate sections of the movement naturally limited themselves to demanding a few adjustments to women's conditions, campaigning for a more or less slow emancipation process. Other sections, which were more radical but often more confused, demanded a genuine liberation, but did not understand that to achieve this they had to go beyond the narrow limits of feminism and take part in a broad struggle against capitalism, putting forward a more radical, revolutionary programme within the workers' movement. Working women and patriarchal ideology On the other hand, for women workers, their oppression within the home is interwoven with social conditions. For women workers this is represented by the suffocation of housework and child-minding. Unlike bourgeois women they cannot unload these chores onto wage labour (baby-sitters, maids, etc). Over the last few decades in the advanced countries there has been a certain involvement of men in looking after the children and in housework, but the ultimate responsibility continues to rest on the shoulders of the woman. In the poorer layers and the working class this responsibility is even greater, as capitalist society has no interest in socializing it. This situation changes the role of the woman, and particularly the woman worker, in society; time is dedicated to the house, the children, running the house in general at the expense of study, union activity, politics, improvement of working conditions etc. However, as opposed to bourgeois women, working class women, although they are also oppressed by their men, are forced to take a more tortuous and laborious path to free themselves. The men of their social class do not have a nice, well-paid profession for them to envy or compete for. Although men workers on average are better paid than women workers, it is still wage labour. What remains is a couple and family life which is unsustainable from a human and economic viewpoint, and inevitably goes into crisis. And here too we see the greatest difficulties affecting women workers; for them the prospect of divorce means having to face life as a single person, probably with children (who in 98% of cases go to the mother), on a starvation wage and with an extra rent to pay. Capitalism imposes on the women the double burden of work outside and inside the home. When this burden is unbearable no solution is offered except more loneliness and a disrupted social life. About half of households in Italy are no longer of the traditional type (father, mother, child/children); in most cases they are women desperately looking for a way to emancipation from family oppression, but while they may escape from their obligations towards a husband, they cannot escape the women’s role that capitalism in any case thrusts upon them. The care of the children remains, discrimination in the workplace remains, economic need remains and even increases, as does the need for human solidarity, but here the division of roles by sex is once more reproduced. Women workers, unlike middle class women, can react to this loneliness of oppression suffered in private by taking up a role in struggles in their workplace. The class struggle is a collective struggle and demonstrates the power of women workers, increasing their confidence in their abilities and helping to make broad layers of the female working class aware of their oppressed condition as women in society, showing how collective action can combat the oppression of women too. In order for this to be expressed in a conscious struggle for their own liberation, a revolutionary analysis and programme are needed. But the reformist organizations of the labour movement have gone from a sometimes openly hostile attitude (consider the Italian socialists who opposed the vote for women) to posing the problem in an exclusively economic manner (equal pay, conditions, hours etc.), without taking up the revolutionary implications of the struggle against women’s oppression and even claiming that the problem was something concerning exclusively middle class women. Subsequently, in the absence of an independent class analysis, the reformist leaders capitulated completely to feminist conceptions, adopting the ideas and demands of the most moderate sections. To this it should be added that the feminist movement has always looked on women workers as “second-class sisters”, partly because they were less open to its arguments and partly because they were looked on as practically irretrievable victims of male domination of the workers’ organizations. This attitude of self-sufficiency is shown by the almost complete absence of writings about the struggles of working class women, compared with a far greater number of publications about the strictly feminist movement, not to mention the deafening silence surrounding women’s conquests in the Soviet Union thanks to the October Revolution. Feminism and the workers’ movement Having said this, we must seek a correct relationship between feminism and the labour movement and between the conflict between the sexes and the class struggle. While the women’s question must be taken up by communists, as explained above, we must oppose a partial approach which places the cultural battle at the centre of our campaigns, independently of class origin. This approach causes a lowering of the consciousness with which women approach their condition, where women can see only a description of their oppression without being offered the means to overcome it. As we have explained, women’s oppression did not originate with capitalism, but the existence of capitalism represents the decisive obstacle to overcoming it. This system is obliged to base its rule on the oppression of the working class and so has to encourage all possible divisions within it. The patriarchal ideology is fundamental to guarantee a wide layer of female labour where it can impose inferior wages and conditions, and who can enter and leave the labour market as needed, acting as a constant downward pressure on the wages and conditions of the whole working class. In exactly the same way, racism is used to divide the working class on race lines. Thus, although capitalism thrusts women into social production, along with immigrants from the more backward areas of the world, it must at the same time promote the idea that a woman’s duty is to stay at home to look after her children and family. Thus capitalism, along with its church ideologues, has become the fundamental instigator of women’s oppression. For anyone dealing with the women’s question, it is an inescapable task to expose this link, showing how the patriarchal culture is used and promoted by capitalism to maintain its rule. Any struggle that does not take this into account is not only doomed to defeat, but will be incapable of orienting women workers and those middle class women who do not just want to adjust their conditions but aspire to genuine liberation. Finally we must deal with the reasons why the class struggle has a central place in comparison with the struggle between the sexes. Firstly, from what we have said so far, it is clear that liberating the woman, or at least creating a basis for her liberation, means first of all liberating the economic resources to enable the socialization of housework and child-minding, chores which tie women to their responsibilities and to their role as women in society. Freeing these resources means coming into conflict with private ownership of the means of production, with the ruling class. It means posing the need for a revolutionary process towards socialism, with the taking of power by the working class; the nationalisation of the multinationals and of the commanding heights of the economy with the planning of these resources under the control of the masses who are exploited today. Only in such a context, in a socialist society, could they be used for the benefit of the masses themselves. The central position of the working class in this process is determined by its role in social production, by the fact that the workers, as a class of wage labourers, enable capitalism to function and exist, even though they may not be aware of this power in normal times. Their involvement is therefore decisive so that their strength can become a conscious force, able to challenge the established order. This central position has recently been disputed in the left, by those who argue that there are other equally important conflicts, such as precisely the conflict between the sexes, or over the environment. Here we are not questioning the importance of these issues. What we are stressing is what is the central contradiction round which all the other contradictions turn. The women’s question, like the environment, cannot be solved independently from the abolition of capitalism, a system which is now incapable of guaranteeing a harmonious development for women and for humankind in general. In addition it is not possible to conduct a cultural battle without posing the central question of breaking the motor force of this culture and overthrowing the ruling class which expresses its interests through that culture. Thus it falls on the shoulders of the working class, which has the potential, as explained above, and the responsibility to carry out these tasks which the capitalist system cannot guarantee, starting now also an ideological campaign, first of all among women workers themselves and then, once power has been conquered, implementing our proposals for liberation. The brief notes which follow are of a mainly historical nature and aim to illustrate the ideas set out above. As we have already stated, we are interested in pointing out both the validity and the limitations of the middle class movements internationally, among the most important of which was the British suffragettes movement, but for reasons of space we will be concentrating on the Italian experience.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Case Neg vs. Fem IR Aff › Turns Solvency

Politicized identity relies on a negation of an ostensible universalism –dooms their project into recreating the impacts of the aff

Brown, 1995. (Wendy, Professor of Political Science and Rhetoric at UC-Berkeley, States of Injury: Power and Freedom in Late Modernity, published by Princeton UP, p. 64-65; spp)

Contemporary politicized identity in the United States contests the termsof liberal discourse insofar as it challenges liberalism's universal "we" as astrategic fiction of historically hegemonic groups and asserts liberalism's"I" as social-both relational and constructed by power-rather thancontingent, private, or autarkic. Yet it reiterates the terms of liberal discourse¶ insofar as it posits a sovereign and unified "I" that is disenfranchised by an exclusive "we." Indeed, I have suggested that politicized identity emerges and obtains its unifying coherence through the politicization ofexclusion from an ostensible universal, as a protest against exclusion: a protest premised on the fiction of an inclusive/ universalcommunity, a protest that thus reinstalls the humanist ideal-and a specific white,¶ middle-class, masculinist expression of this ideal-insofar as it premises itself upon exclusion from it. Put the other way around, politicized identities¶ generated out of liberal, disciplinary societies, insofar as they are premised on exclusion from a universal ideal, require that ideal, as their exclusion from it, for their own continuing existence as identities.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Case Neg vs. Fem IR Aff › Turn – Reinstates Domination

Their attempt to order politics around women’s freedom requires the specter of patriarchal unfreedom – this locks in the power dynamic they criticize

Brown, 1995. (Wendy, Professor of Political Science and Rhetoric at UC-Berkeley, States of Injury: Power and Freedom in Late Modernity, published by Princeton UP, p. 8-9; spp)

Invoking Marx recalls a second dimension of this paradox in which¶ freedom responds to a particular practice of domination whose terms are¶ then often reinstalled in its practice. When institutionalized, freedompremised upon an already vanquished enemy keeps alive, in the manner¶ of a melancholic logic, a threat that works as domination in the form of¶ an absorbing ghostly battle with the past. 7 Institutionalized, freedom arrayed¶ against a particular image of unfreedom sustains that image, whichdominates political life with its specter long after it has been vanquished¶ and preempts appreciation of new dangers to freedom posed by institutions¶ designed to hold the past in check. Yet the very institutions that areerected to vanquish the historical threat also recuperate it as a form ofpolitical anxiety; so, for example, functions the "state of nature" or the¶ "arbitrary sovereign" in the liberal political imagination.¶ It may be the extent to which freedom institutionalized transmogrifies¶ into its opposite that led Foucault to insist upon understanding liberty as¶ a practice rather than a state, as that which can "never [be] assured¶ by ... institutions and laws" but "must be exercised. "B Sheldon Wolin¶ presses a similar point in his provocation that "a constitution, in setting¶ limits to politics, set limits as well to democracy .... Democracy thusseems destined to be a moment rather than a form. "9 In Jean-Luc¶ Nancy's account, "freedom ... is the very thing that prevents itselffrom being founded. '' And a similar concern can be discerned in¶ Hannah Arendt's insistence on the perniciousness of equating freedom¶ with sovereignty, along with her counterproposition that freedom as "virtuosity" is defined by the contingency of action, as the place where¶ "the I-will and the I-can coincide" as power.11¶ Recognition of the tension, if not the antinomy, between freedom and¶ institutionalization compounds the difficulties of formulating a politics of¶ freedom in the late twentieth century, the age of institutions. Not only¶ do we require a historically and institutionally specific reading of contemporary¶ modes of domination, but freedom’s "actualization" wouldappear to be a frustratingly indeterminate matter of ethos, of bearingtoward institutions, of the style of political practices, rather than a matterof policies, laws, procedures, or organization of political orders. This is¶ not to say that freedom becomes aesthetic, but rather that it depends¶ upon a formulation of the political that is richer, more complicated, and¶ also perhaps more fragile than that circumscribed by institutions, procedures, and political representation.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Case Neg vs. Fem IR Aff › Turn – Reinstates Domination

Their performance of an ideal world mirrors a reversal of suffering without addressing subject constitution – this reinstates the structure of oppression which they attempt to fight

Brown, 1995. (Wendy, Professor of Political Science and Rhetoric at UC-Berkeley, States of Injury: Power and Freedom in Late Modernity, published by Princeton UP, p. 7; spp)

But this opens rather than settles the problem of how to formulate a discourse¶ of freedom appropriate to contesting contemporary antidemocraticconfigurations of power. One of the ironies of what Nietzsche boldly¶ termed the "instinct for freedom" lies in its inceptive self-cancellation, its¶ crossing of itself in its very first impulse. Initial figurations of freedomare inevitably reactionary in the sense of emerging reaction to perceivedinjuries or constraints of a regime from within its own terms. Ideals of freedom ordinarily emerge to vanquish their imagined immediate enemies, but in this move they frequently recycle and reinstate¶ rather than transform the terms of domination that generated them. Consider¶ exploited workers who dream of a world in which work has beenabolished, blacks who imagine a world without whites, feminists whoconjure a world either without men or without sex, or teenagers who, fantasizea world without parents. Such images of freedom perform mirror reversals of suffering without transforming the organization of the activity¶ through which the suffering is produced and without addressing the subject¶ constitution that domination effects, that is, the constitution of the social categories, “workers,” “blacks,” “women,” or “teenagers.”¶ It would thus appear that it is freedom’s relationship to identity-its¶ promise to address a social injury or marking that is itself constitutive of¶ identity – that yields the paradox in which the first imaginings of freedomare always constrained by and potentially even require the verystructure of oppression that freedom emerges to oppose.