Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Kritik
Bronze Night Aff › Ks › AT: Tech=Violent

Tech collectives have radical potential.

Toupin 21 (sophie, doctoral student in the Department of Art History and Communication Studies at McGill University, “More widespread than we think”) //ansel

During the anti-globalization movement of the early 2000s, tech collectives such as  and  came into existence to provide autonomous, non-corporate communication tools and “How-Tos” for social movements to organize safely and securely with emerging new media. In South Africa, the  campaign was initiated in 2010 in response to the Protection of State Information Bill, which aimed at weakening the rights of journalists and whistleblowers to access information. As part of their work, R2K has published  to protect themselves digitally.

To heighten my own digital defense practice, I recently took a virtual workshop offered by the New York-based . This collective provides technology education for radical organizers and revolutionary communities with special attention to underserved groups. These groups, which design tools and training for activists, are not a new occurrence. They have an interesting history across varying political cultures dating back, at the very least, to the national liberation struggles of the 20th century. Let’s take two of these, both armed struggles.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Bronze Night Aff › Ks › AT: Settler Colonialism

The development of imperial technology explains the mechanisms of dispossession better.

Harris, 4—Department of Geography, University of British Columbia (Cole, “How Did Colonialism Dispossess? Comments from an Edge of Empire,” Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 94:1, 165-182, dml)

The emphasis on culture in studies of colonialism tends to obscure other forms of colonial power while making it impossible to contextualize the cultural argument and assess its salience. Rather than focusing on texts, systems of signification, and procedures of knowledge generation, as the colonial discourse literature is wont to do, a fuller understanding of colonial powers is achieved by explaining colonialism’s basic geographical dispossessions of the colonized. In so doing, the issue of power is not prejudged and the particular roles of different modes and theories of colonial power come into focus. I explore these propositions by considering the powers underlying the reserve (reservation) system in British Columbia, a system that, by allocating a tiny fraction of the land to native people and opening the rest for development, facilitated the geographical reorganization of the province. My conclusions are these: the initial ability to dispossess rested primarily on physical power and the supporting infrastructure of the state; the momentum to dispossess derived from the interest of capital in profit and of settlers in forging new livelihoods; the legitimation of and moral justification for dispossession lay in a cultural discourse that located civilization and savagery and identified the land uses associated with each; and the management of dispossession rested with a set of disciplinary technologies of which maps, numbers, law, and the geography of resettlement itself were the most important. Although no one body of theory explains colonial power, several theoretical perspectives yield crucial insights. Key Words: colonialism, colonial discourse theory, deterritorialization, colonial land policies, governmentality, reservations, British Columbia.

Influenced by Michel Foucault’s analysis of the relationships of power and knowledge (1972), by Edward Said’s examination of Orientalism (1978), by textual theory harnessed to colonial discourse analysis, and by many studies of the values and ideologies enmeshed in particular colonial encounters, most postcolonial scholars now identify culture and associated procedures of knowledge generation as the dominant power relations associated with colonialism. Whereas Frantz Fanon (1963) emphasized violence—the power of the gun—and Marx, to the extent that he wrote on colonialism, the aggressive reach of capital, postcolonial research and writing situates the momentum of colonialism in the culture of imperialists and colonists. A central goal, therefore, of colonial discourse theory is to identify the assumptions and representations inherent in colonial culture—in the binary of civilization/savagery, in the erasures of Aboriginal knowledge of time and space, in assumptions about race and gender, in the concept of the land as empty (terra nullius), and so on—and then, insofar as possible, to expose their contemporary manifestations. This work has focused much scholarly energy and has yielded important theoretical and practical results, but it is less clear that it has revealed the principal momentum and power relations inherent in colonialism.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Bronze Night Aff › Ks › AT: Ivory Tower

Stacks are as material as you can get.

Mohorčich 17(Jospeh, Ph.D., Johns Hopkins University, “POWER PRAGMATISM”, CS)

A sensible plan for radical transformation, therefore, will start with a plan for taking care of basic human needs: an alternative technology stack for keeping human beings alive so that they don’t die when the standard systems of feeding and caring for them fail or are removed. Gupta argues that “you don’t [convert to a new life-support stack] by pulling the old one down. You [convert] by building a new one, prototyping it, bootstrapping it from the resources of the old, proving that it works, and then pulling the population across.”403 As Bratton points out, stacks are “intrinsically modular,” so each is “also a platform, and an interface even, for the redesign and replacement of the Stack-we-have with a Stack-we-want.”404 To think about radical transformation—up to and including revolution—without thinking about infrastructure is to neglect that engineering and politics are embedded in each other. Because any plan for political transformation must start with some kind of life-support plan, it makes sense to start working on these types of plans and to bring this work explicitly into the political-theory fold. Working to diagram and assemble alternative life-support stacks has the potential to convert cycles of radical action from self-defeating to self-reinforcing. As activists and thinkers are increasingly existing stacks, and to not get enmeshed in questions about who’s going to call in sick to work or argue with Comcast this week, they are able to think, agitate, and act in a more engaged manner, which opens space for further political-material-technical moves that strengthen alternative stacks, which engenders further agitation and thought, which restarts the cycle. For example, Bitcoin’s role as a functional component of an alternative financial stack (i) demonstrates the technical viability of blockchain-based experiments to create alternative stacks for education, personal identification, energy markets, housing, carbon emission tracking, and so on, and (ii) pulls developers, users, and billions of dollars in wealth from existing financial stacks into alternative ones, which creates the material, technical, and social grist for further developments. To be sure, purchasing baby formula or pizza with a blockchain currency is not itself a shatteringly radical move, especially if the supply chains for what you have bought can still be traced through to structures of degradation, exploitation, and accumulation. This is why building alternative stacks for the production and transport of energy, food, heat, and information that interleave with alternative financial structures like blockchain currencies remains a critical and self-reinforcing task.406 Developing alternative life-support stacks opens up ways of rethinking radical separatism.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Bronze Night Aff › Ks › AT: Capitalism

Stacktivism socializes technology and reshapes the foundation of capitalist notions of value.

Dragona 15(Daphne, PhD from the Faculty of Communication & Media Studies of the University of Athens, “From Community Networks to Off-the-cloud toolkits: Art and DIY networking”, CS)

Firstly, all networks discussed follow a usercentered approach. The human and non human elements that a network involves are balanced by always allowing the users to have control of the nodes of the network; setting them up, controlling them and sustaining them. In the era of algorithmic automation and control, its important to remember what Munster and Lovink wrote, that the rise of networks should be made understood as an all too human behaviour [77]. Whereas as Medosch says ‘in ubiquitous computing, it is usually the devices which get smarter and the people who remain stupid’, in the cases of such initiatives a ‘new Internet of People’, following here Nold and van Kranenburg, and can emerge against the Internet of things [78, 79]. Secondly, the topologies of DIY networking are exposed and understood by a merging of the social and the technological. As a user is always behind a node and in control of a node, it is easier to realize the edges and nodes, the architecture and potentiality of the network. This idea of “becoming the machine” that Pasquinelli mentioned can be understood as becoming the node and gaining control of the network. Thirdly, all infrastructures of different scale are based on open software and hardware leaving open to the users the possibility for modifying and even repurposing them for their own needs; this way not only the DIY but also the DIWO ethos is encouraged embracing the logic of thinking, sharing, working together. This in a manifestation of what Hardt and Negri have stated when they argued that “being with” is no longer enough”; a “doing with” is necessary [80]. Alternatives based on collaboration and sociality are introduced to spread and teach people how not only to modify and use infrastructures but also to make decisions, possibly based on criteria which are qualitative and humanistic [81]. Staying out of the market of centralized systems and platforms, a new system and theory of value is embraced. Encouraging forms of exchange economy and providing tools and knowledge freely and openly, a significant effort is made for social value to outbalance market value, for sharing networks to surpass zones of property. Fourthly, and in continuation of the above arguments the infrastructures proposed can be seen as part of the new ‘Network Commons’ as Armin Medosch puts it. Although Medosch refers primarily to the community networks, this can greatly stand for the wider family of offline sharing networks as they are systems in terms of infrastructure and content that are meant to be constructed, possessed and managed by all. Through such platforms, users are invited “to speak and think, to become informed and to participate”, as Stavrides has put it for the necessity of the contemporary commons [82]. The making of the common in the case of infrastructures is therefore a process based on potentialities, skills and affects of the users and this can be approached as meaningful acts of commoning.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Bronze Night Aff › Ks › AT: Capitalism

Marxist theorizations of change fail to account for the ontological nature of modern capitalism – the aff’s approach is the only way to create individual value in the world of utility

Magrini 11 (James, Professor at the College of DuPage, “Working to Recover the Essence of Education for the Sake of Teaching and Teacher Education: Towards a Phenomenological Understanding of the Forgotten, Ontological Aspects of Learning” p. 4)NCF

It is evident that there is a serious problem with educational procedures emerging out of the “bureaucratic/rational choice model” that is two-fold in nature, a problem that is in fact antibiotic, as in a vicious sense of codependence. Instructors who are increasingly alienated from what might serve as legitimate, or authentic, curriculum for the preparation of teachers entering the field are slaves to institutions governed by pre-determined standards of achievement. These institutions are then filtering ill-prepared (alienated) teachers into a system that is governed in much the same way, namely, by standards and competencies established by bureaucratic agencies that are at a remove from authentic educational purposes and practices. Teachers are thus alienated in a duplicitous sense, both from the curriculum they are now forced to teach and the students who cannot relate to what is being taught. Bonnett (2001) echoes the sentiments expressed earlier when stating that the current “predisposition to regard outcomes of education as definable in advance of the process of education” engenders a deterministic system of education that obscures authentic subject-hood and we lose sight of the fact that humans are “individual centers of consciousness capable of relating to the world in ways that have personal meaning, for this is essential to human being against some sort of mechanized and depersonalized being” (p. 30). In short, there is a loss of ownership on the part of both educator and student, but beyond this, there is a loss of authentic subject-hood; ironically, by means of education, we are losing sight of what it means to be truly human. The alienation from the curriculum and authentic subject-hood of which I speak should not be conceived in terms of Marxist theory, which tends to focus on ideology and the critique of capitalism and its detrimental effects on schools. Rather, I conceive alienation and depersonalization in terms of what Heidegger (1979) calls the oblivion, or forgetting, of Being, which is grounded in the failure to ask about “the truth of being itself” and about “the way the essence of human being belongs to the truth of Being” (p. 246). This condition, which pervades the world of education, grows from the tradition in Western metaphysics and its subsequent influence on the rise of science and technology. In short, education is moving us farther away from essential issues of human dwelling as linked with our Being, and the ontological aspects of our existence. It is now to the potential recovery of this essential, forgotten ontological notion of authentic Beingin-the-world as related to education that I turn.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Bronze Night Aff › Ks › AT: Capitalism

Mastery DA: The notion of a universal dialectic is a neurotic projection of the will to mastery---it transforms the alt into genocidal party politics---only the affirmative’s rejection of static linearity solves

Berardi 15 (Franco Berardi, like Lenin but not depressed, AND: Phenomenology of the End, p. 90-95)

Desire for the Absolute is visible in the historical sphere as a will of total palingenesis, purification of the social community from the traces of the past. The reference to purity is transparent in the Russian conception of Revolution, particularly in the Leninist persuasion that the revolutionary political party is the “incarnation” of the pure idea coming down from German Philosophy, and must be embodied by a small organization of professional bearers of the Revolutionary Truth. The Russian exacerbation of the role of pure subjectivity entered the scene of the world history in 1917. The Soviet Revolution—that Lenin managed to unleash against the will of many prominent leaders of the Russian socialist movement, provoked a catastrophic polarization in the worldwide social conflict, and forced the worker’s movement to identify with a totalitarian experiment, based on the authoritarian statalization of class struggle. The Russian revolution provoked an irreversible rupture and a permanent laceration in the body of society whose effects persisted worldwide all along the century. Lenin forced the workers of the world to defend the Socialist State of the Soviets, and to enter a process of permanent war. This war lasted until 1989, but since the beginning the worker class was doomed to unavoidable defeat. The messianic utopianism, widespread in the Russian society of the nineteenth century merged with the hyper-voluntaristic project of the Bolsheviks, so the history of Communist revolution began as a tragedy in the context of the immolation culture, and since the beginning was destined to end as a tragedy. The violence and the authoritarianism that the Leninist experiment unleashed in the country and exported worldwide brutally changing the prospects of the international movement for worker’s emancipation, were inscribed in the Russian history of the previous centuries, and still prevail in the Russian political life, after the end of the Soviet dictatorship. Leninist communism may have ruined Russia, but certainly Russia has (forever?) ruined Communism as a possible alternative to Capitalism, as the Russian subjectivism and cult of purity have dragged the international movement of the workers into a vision of permanent military mobilization that was not part of the Marxian imprinting. The spontaneous goal of the workers movement is to expand the space of autonomy from capitalist exploitation. The idea that the movement is taken in a dialectical contradiction is an effect of the Hegelian interpretation of the social process: this idea becomes historical reality when the Russian palingenetic cult of pureness melts with the Hegelian tradition. The fusion of Marxism and Leninism is the origin of the workers defeat, in my opinion. Lenin brings into the worker’s political discourse an element of subjectivism and of purity that did not belong to the experience of autonomous social movements. The workers movement was aimed to emancipate spaces of life and of the territory from the capitalist domination, but the Leninist breakthrough transformed the movement into a project of absolute separation from the existing world, of radical demolition and of palingenetic purification. In the first part of the book, Lenin confirms Lassalle’s argument: the purification (epuration, cleansing) is strengthening the party. This idea of ideological cleansing (epuration) is the main thread of the history of the Soviet Communist Party, particularly in the Stalin age. According to the words of Lenin: “the worker class is only able to elaborate an economic unionist consciousness, but is unable to understand the radical opposition to the system.” (Lenin, What has to be done?) This impurity of the worker class has to be overcome, so that society can adapt to the purity of the communist ideal. Only a party which is the bearer of the pure Logos can be the bearer of the revolutionary project—not the aggregation of impure social bodies. In her biographical essay on Lenin, the French historian of Georgian origins Hélène Carrère d’Encausse speaks of two major episodes of clinical depression in the life of Lenin that are generally ignored by the hagiografic Leninist tradition. The book (Lenine, la Revolution et le pouvoir, 1979) is interesting especially because it is focusing on the affective life of the communist leader: the importance of the relation with the mother, the sister, and particularly of the wife, Nadeezda Krupskaja, who took care of him in the periods of acute psychic crisis. The book also speaks of Ines Armand, the lover who disturbingly entered the life of Lenin, and was later removed, neutralized, as a potential danger for the political integrity of the leader. Depression is the peculiar feature of the psychological description of Lenin, and depressive crises are coinciding with the most important political decisions of his life. The first major crisis, according to Hélène Carrère d’Encausse, occurred in the year 1902, and coincided with the decision of founding the Communist party and the draft of What has to be done? The second occurred in 1914, when Lenin takes the decision of breaking with the Second International before Zimmerwald Congress, and the Communist Schism at the European scale. The third occurred in Spring 1917 and coincided with the decision of launching the Soviet insurrection which actually took place in October. These decisions, that marked the emergence of the Communist identity, and forced a voluntary acceleration on the history of class struggle all over Europe and worldwide, can be linked in my opinion with the depressive cycle of Lenin. When intelligence is depressive, only will is the therapy that makes possible ignoring the abyss. The abyss is not removed, not resolved, not avoided or overcome. It is ignored, but still it is there, and the decades following the Revolution have actually exposed its persistence, so that the century sunk down into the abyss. More than in the political meaning of the decisions of Lenin, here I’m interested in the relation between Bolshevik voluntarism and the male inability to deal with depression. By the political point of view, the Bolshevik breach provoked a general precipitation of the confrontation between workers and capital in the world: workers were pushed everywhere towards a totalizing form of opposition, and actually towards civil war. The social autonomy was obliged to choose between revolutionary terror and capitulation. And where the communist parties succeeded in seizing political power, this was turned into violent dictatorship and submission of social life. This way the Leninist strategy prepared the worldwide catastrophe that at the end of the century has provoked the worst possible defeat whose effects we’ll be experiencing for decades. The project of a rebirth of the world beginning with the palingenetic violence of the revolution is a mythology that has no historical foundation. History has never known abolition, palingenesis or rebirth. History is always about stratification, negotiation, coevolution, autonomy or dependence, identification or extraneousness. Not about abolition. Leninism can be considered as an attempt to deny depression, as an assertion of the purity of will, as a refusal to accept the finiteness of human potency: male hysteria that was already at work in the Dostoevsky’s writings.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Bronze Night Aff › Ks › AT: Capitalism

Collective resubjectivization generates material liberation.

Hall, 20—Professor of Education and Technology, De Montfort University (Richard, “Platform Discontent against the University,” The digital age and its discontents: Critical reflections in education, Chapter 7, 130-132, dml)

The proletarianization of the University is predicated upon atomized competition, which utilizes new forces of production to reshape relations between people, in order to extract value. A critical element of this is enforced separation between individuals, and the ability for individual agency to be repurposed by structural requirements. However, in order to extract maximum value, capital requires individuals to work in concert, or to collaborate as producers, distributors and consumers. This gives opportunities for cooperative re-imagination. For Marx (1866), the cooperative movement was a transformational force where it understood its relationship to labour as the point of social production. Thus, he argued that producer cooperatives, as opposed to consumer cooperatives, are a manifestation of class antagonism that can point towards ‘the republican and beneficent system of the association of free and equal producers’ (ibid., emphasis in the original). This analysis of cooperation rests on forms of self-mediation by human beings of their material activities in society. In an idealized cooperative state, activities are no longer piecemeal or solitary, or governed by capital; rather, they are governed by alternative networks of solidarity and purpose: ‘This is not possible without the community. Only within the community has each individual the means of cultivating his gifts in all directions; hence personal freedom becomes possible only within the community’ (Marx & Engels 1998: 86).

A focus on the communal and associational characteristics of cooperation is critical to Marx’s praxis, because in them he sees the individual developing the capabilities of their species (Marx 2004). As a result, a refocusing upon cooperative values and principles, grounded in the conceptual framework of the self-in-association, acts as a moment of refusal of alienated socialization, in which the producers of society are estranged from both the means and conditions of production of that society. However, discontent at the present state of things does not coalesce into a single, counter-hegemonic position, predicated upon a unified collection of alternative governing principles for life. It therefore becomes important to think about alternative forms of knowledge production and an integration with alternative conceptions of mutuality, solidarity and cooperation, such as those emerging from indigenous or marginalized communities.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Bronze Night Aff › Ks › AT: Afropessimism

The aff is an internal link turn and the perm solves. Embracing both black use of technology as well as blackness as technology creates moments of sociality within ontological structures of fungible commodification---that places blackness, in this sense, as paraontological with respect to Wilderson

Brock, 20 - André Brock Jr., PhD, Associate Professor in the School of Literature, Media & Communication at the Georgia Institute of Technology; 2020(“Making a Way out of No Way Black Cyberculture and the Black Technocultural Matrix,” in Distributed Blackness African American Cybercultures, NYU Press, 2020, Accessed Online via Michigan Libraries, bam)

Throughout this book, I have framed Black online identity and Black digital practice as Black cyberculture, an awkwardly named construct incorporating cyberspace (itself a dated term) and technoculture. As mentioned earlier, technoculture can be understood as the relations between, and politics of, culture and technology. Dinerstein (2006) argues that “technology is the American mythos” (p. 570). When defined this way, however, technoculture often tricks upon the racial identity of whiteness, and white racial ideology and technological beliefs become the norm. That obviously won’t do! Black technology users are not white (even if they are Western), so it becomes necessary to interrogate how Black people make sense of their existence as users and as subjects within advanced technological artifacts, services, and platforms. This final chapter is that catechism, firmly placing Black folk at the center of information and communication technology use. I offer this interrogation not as a summary of the previous chapters but as a provocation for those who are interested in centering Blackness as digital practice.

Reorienting technoculture to incorporate Blackness invites an inquiry into the possibilities of Blackness as technology—not Black bodies (been there, done that) but Blackness as technology—in the same way that Blackness often stands in for the best of American entertainment and culture. I am not arguing for minstrelsy and blackface here, to be clear, even though those representations of Blackness are as American as apple pie. Nor am I suggesting that Blackness is a nonserious use of technology; indeed, technology use for Blacks often occurs from the margins of society, where survival, joy, and resistance intertwine uncomfortably in the everyday. Chun (2013) contends that race-as-technology “posits a comparative equality or substitutability—but not identity—between the two” (p. 8). Chun goes on to probe how whiteness incorporates science and technology to build technologies and institutions of race—a helpful formulation for antiblackness and technology but not as necessary here. Instead, I would like to begin from the introduction’s discussion of “technology as text” to build out from the possibilities of Black thought into a concept of Black technoculture. From there, I will discuss Afrofuturism as an analytic for Black technology use and time and Black technoculture. Finally, I close with a foray into a libidinal framework of Black technoculture.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Bronze Night Aff › Ks › AT: Afropessimism

The digitization of the carceral state disproves the historical continuity of anti-Black oppression—it takes different forms.

Jefferson, 20—associate professor of geography and geographic information science and O’Connell Scholar in the College of Liberal Arts and Sciences at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign (Brian, “Introduction: NextGen Nightmare,” Digitize and Punish: Racial Criminalization in the Digital Age, Introduction, pg 13-16, dml)

A point of emphasis in the book is that carceral power is silently spreading through infrastructures of cellular towers, datacenters, fiber-optic cables, smart sensors, and video cameras. Carceral functionality is becoming a key attribute of the smart city. This is not meant to say that the prison-industrial complex is being wholly supplanted or that it is bound to disintegrate. Even though incarceration rates have reached their lowest points in decades, the history of carceral management is not one of a linear development. Nor is it a history of a changeless institution. Carceral space has manifested in the form of extraordinary rendition sites, immigrant detention centers, and internment camps. This book traces an emergent form of carceral space that is characterized by machines that traverse human anatomy, public housing facilities, public schools, transportation systems, telecommunications systems, and street networks in U.S. cities. The book also emphasizes that the deeper telecommunications and IT firms entrench themselves in crime control policy, the more likely it is for these infrastructures to continue to expand.

The extension of carceral management through the Internet of Things (IoT), or networks of devices that communicate with each other, is greatly influenced by the movement of capital.42 On one hand, the carceral state’s circumscription of black and latinx communities was partly catalyzed by the flight of industry from cities, which rendered entire groups deskilled and unemployable. Decades of revelatory research demonstrates how cities turned to mass criminalization to manage the enormous economic, political, social, and medical problems arising from deindustrialization.43 On the other hand, in addition to outbound industrial capital, the carceral state’s digital architecture owes its existence to inbound information capital. The infrastructure sector has emerged as one of the most important sectors in finance, knowledge, and technology industries.44 IT companies have insinuated themselves in seemingly all facets of urban life, including government agencies, private businesses, social networks, transportation systems, workplaces, and infrastructure. These companies have also nestled their way into criminal justice administration, which is reshaping geographies of carceral governance.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Bronze Night Aff › Ks › AT: Academy Bad

Imaginaries change the world—the diffusion of cybernetics proves!

Atanasoski and Vora, 19 – Neda Atanasoski, Professor of Feminist Studies and Critical Race and Ethnic Studies at the University of California, Santa Cruz; Kalindi Vora, Associate Professor of Gender, Sexuality and Women's Studies at UC Davis; 2019( “Introduction: The Surrogate Human Effects of Technoliberalism,” Surrogate Humanity: Race, Robots, and the Politics of Technological Futures, Duke University Press, Accessed via Michigan Libraries, pg 23-24, bam)

Dissident Technologies and the Disruption of Technoliberal Enchantment: Our Itinerary

Dominant techno-utopic imaginaries direct funds and structure engineering research labs around the world, and therefore also impact the distribution of differential conditions of comfort versus misery in the present along vectors of race, gender, class, and other social hierarchies. The surrogate human effect explains how difference continues to inform what subjects become legible as human through technology design imaginaries that respond to market values by focusing on innovating and improving, rather than challenging, social and cultural structures and processes that are predicated by categories of gendered racial hierarchy. To this end, Denise da Silva offers the concept of “knowing (at) the limits of justice,” a practice that “unsettles what has become but offers no guidance for what has yet to become.”59 To insist on “knowing at the limits” of representational categories of difference, we must ask: If the predominant fantasies of systemic social change in mainstream Euro-American public discourse dwell upon the techno-utopics of a world in which all of those who are already human and already subjects ascend into the realm of those whose lives are supported by “human-free” or “unmanned” technological infrastructures of service (whether in factories, in the military, or in the nursing home), then how do we think about the relationship of new technologies to possible fields of political protest or action?

2022 Michigan Kritik
Bronze Night Aff › Ks › AT: Academy Bad

The aff’s cooperative re-imagination of communication and value can redefine the subjectivity of society. The academy is key—if we win a link, it proves that we’ve identified a crack in the system from which new relationalities can emerge.

Hall, 20—Professor of Education and Technology, De Montfort University (Richard, “Platform Discontent against the University,” The digital age and its discontents: Critical reflections in education, Chapter 7, 130-132, dml)

The proletarianization of the University is predicated upon atomized competition, which utilizes new forces of production to reshape relations between people, in order to extract value. A critical element of this is enforced separation between individuals, and the ability for individual agency to be repurposed by structural requirements. However, in order to extract maximum value, capital requires individuals to work in concert, or to collaborate as producers, distributors and consumers. This gives opportunities for cooperative re-imagination. For Marx (1866), the cooperative movement was a transformational force where it understood its relationship to labour as the point of social production. Thus, he argued that producer cooperatives, as opposed to consumer cooperatives, are a manifestation of class antagonism that can point towards ‘the republican and beneficent system of the association of free and equal producers’ (ibid., emphasis in the original). This analysis of cooperation rests on forms of self-mediation by human beings of their material activities in society. In an idealized cooperative state, activities are no longer piecemeal or solitary, or governed by capital; rather, they are governed by alternative networks of solidarity and purpose: ‘This is not possible without the community. Only within the community has each individual the means of cultivating his gifts in all directions; hence personal freedom becomes possible only within the community’ (Marx & Engels 1998: 86).

A focus on the communal and associational characteristics of cooperation is critical to Marx’s praxis, because in them he sees the individual developing the capabilities of their species (Marx 2004). As a result, a refocusing upon cooperative values and principles, grounded in the conceptual framework of the self-in-association, acts as a moment of refusal of alienated socialization, in which the producers of society are estranged from both the means and conditions of production of that society. However, discontent at the present state of things does not coalesce into a single, counter-hegemonic position, predicated upon a unified collection of alternative governing principles for life. It therefore becomes important to think about alternative forms of knowledge production and an integration with alternative conceptions of mutuality, solidarity and cooperation, such as those emerging from indigenous or marginalized communities.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Bronze Night Aff › Ks › Perm—Stacks—2AC

Perm: Stack the aff and the alt. Mutual exclusivity is counterproductive; in the cybernetic era, it’s more productive to assume partial interlinkages between movements and focus on layering them through stacktivist praxis. Not everyone has to be a stacktivist for the perm to solve!

Lovink, 20—founder of the Institute of Network Cultures at the Amsterdam University of Applied Sciences (Geert, “Principles of Stacktivism,” tripleC 18 (2): 716-724, 2020, dml) [emojis in original article…]

We can also read The Stack as a pedagogical framework within the Bauhaus tradition as a proposal for a general design principle, as John Thackara has recently done, updating the Bauhaus foundation course for the age of global warming[12]. As an abstract model describing the architecture of the Internet, the stack provides us with a useful spatial division of layers such as protocols, data, applications and user interfaces. Bratton’s notion of The Stack comes out of the US postmodern literary tradition of cognitive mapping (Jameson), which seeks to make intelligible (and containable) complex processes. Bratton combines this approach with decades long attempts to visualise the vertical integration of technologies drawn in 2D, with maps of networks that strive to capture relations between the different players. His aim is to produce a general network theory able to provide deeper insights in the dynamics of power: blowing up 2D tech engineering plans to a 3D dimension able to modulate planetary transformation.

Benjamin Bratton also invites us to think tech in relation to geo-politics and location. At the same time The Stack can be seen as method, a mechanism. However, the book is consciously vague about how material infrastructure and ideology relate. In the light of Trump, Putin and Xi Jinping, Bratton’s global engineer seems a tragic, retrograde figure. At best The Stack works well as a multi-disciplinary guideline of past globalist techno-social practices that, ironically, have become outdated since 2016, the year of its publication and the year of Brexit and Trump. For all its ambition to delineate the geo-political contours of techno-operations supposedly occurring on a planetary scale, the book settles with an oddly depoliticised aesthetic imaginary.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Bronze Night Aff › Ks › Governance Turn—2AC***

The alt’s totalizing anti-governance orientation discounts methods of repurposing the stack-layers of governance towards ungovernability in favor of fleeting viral moments of spontaneity.

Schneider, 22—assistant professor of media studies at the University of Colorado Boulder (Nathan, “Governable Stacks against Digital Colonialism,” tripleC 20 (1): 19-36, 2022, dml)

Theorists and practitioners of anticolonial resistance have persistently stressed the centrality of self-governance in everyday life as both the means and the end of their movements, alongside acts of outright insurrection. By self-governance I mean to evoke other terms like autonomy, autogestión, autogestió, community control, self-determination, self-management, self-organising, self-rule, sovereignty, swaraj, and more – together encompassing how groups of people become impervious and intolerable to those who want to govern them by governing themselves. The aspiration to be “ungovernable” has appeared among thinkers ranging from the philosophers Michel Foucault and Giorgio Agamben (Thaning, Gudmand-Høyer and Raffnsøe 2016) to former Black Panther Lorenzo Kom’boa Ervin (Anderson 2020), each seeking to assert the vital personhood of people caught in dehumanising systems. Such systems utilise “governmentality” to extend their power into subjects’ lives (Li 2007). Scholars of governance tend to regard it as something done to – or at best, for – most people, rather than something they do themselves (Levi-Faur 2012). Self-governance against colonialism is something else, something people do to govern while becoming ungovernable.

To become ungovernable under digital colonialism, how should we be learning to self-govern?

2022 Michigan Kritik
Bronze Night Aff › Framework › AT: Reflexivity/Skills

Their info reflexivity claims are a smokescreen for algorithmic control.

Tazzioli, 21—Lecturer in Politics and Technology, Goldsmiths University of London (Martina, “Technologies of Control and Infrastructures of Redistribution,” e-flux #123, December 2021, dml)

A well-known slogan that emerged from the disability movement during the 1990s goes: “Nothing about us without us.” It stresses that no policy should be adopted without fully involving those who are affected by that policy. Nowadays, it is a catchphrase used across different fields and institutional settings, signaling that “participation” has become a placeholder for inclusion, democracy, and horizontal decision-making processes. Yet, what does “participation” in a given system mean when the epistemic-political codes, the ability to maneuver, and the stakes of the participation are set in advance by the party in control? So-called “participatory programs,” like surveys and other forms of data acquisition, have been used extensively by humanitarian agencies since the 1990s, and more recently have shifted into systems for practicing what I instead call “participatory confinement.” In such systems, individuals are nudged and encouraged to actively participate in their own confinement and governmentality, “for their own good.” Christopher Kelty, a scholar of science studies and anthropology, rightly claims that this sort of “participation is more often a formatted procedure by which autonomous individuals attempt to reach calculated consensus.” Not only are the goals and forms of participation often preestablished and surreptitiously imposed, but individuals are also de facto pushed to corroborate, contribute to, and improve mechanisms of confinement and coercion. Here, I focus on refugee humanitarianism as a case study for coming to grips with modes of participatory confinement as a systematic political technology of governmentality.

Modes of participatory confinement in refugee humanitarianism are inflected by clear-cut asymmetric relations between asylum seekers on one side, and humanitarian actors on the other. This initial condition and its trend towards reform by way of inviting participation is reminiscent of the diagnosis of prison reform by Michel Foucault in a lecture he gave in 1976. Furnishing an anticipatory example of participatory confinement, he writes: “There is an attempt to make prisoners themselves participate in devising the very programmes for their punishment, through the prisoners’ councils and so on. This is the idea that the individual, singly or collectively, is meant to accept the punitive procedure.” Nowadays, participatory approaches are center stage on the agendas of international agencies and NGOs in the context of the so-called “refugee crisis” in Europe. They continue to operate with the same neoliberal logics of prior reforms to systems of punishment and control that performatively invite the exploited to frame the forms of that exploitation, while actually ceding no power to the “participant.”

2022 Michigan Kritik
Bronze Night Aff › Framework › AT: Iteration

Machine Learning DA: Mechanistically weighing the consequences of fiated plans over and over makes debate algorithmically violent at the level of form, which has material significance. They’ve created uniqueness for our offense because iteration is a process, so disrupting one instance jams the gears.

Amoore, 22—Professor of Human Geography in the Department of Geography, Durham University (Louise, “Machine learning political orders,” Review of International Studies, February 15, 2022, dml) [language modifications denoted by brackets]

Yet, what I propose here is that machine learning political orders reverse Deleuze’s dictum so that the political problem is constituted by the posited solution; or, the solution gets the problem it deserves. The retroactive logic of deep learning commonly begins with the identification of the target output from the model, actively using the output signals that diverge or converge on the target as an experimental space of modulation and adjustment. Though there are multiple possible functions or ‘solutions that will match the data’, a machine learning algorithm will use ‘two sources of information to select the best function: one is the dataset, and the other (the inductive bias) is the assumptions that bias the algorithm to prefer some functions over others’. 40 In order to change the output signal, the weights within the hidden layers of the neural network adjust and modify the signal that feeds forward to the next layer. Why does this computational process matter for how the political problem and the solution interact? The retroactive move from target solution to the weights in the model means that the parameters and dimensions of an intractably difficult political question – democracy, pandemic response, border security, stability in the economy – become configured as infinitely adjustable in relation to the solution. Where the concept of problematisation suggests a multiplicity of actions that could take place under the broad unifying conditions of the formulation of the problem – and, indeed a space for normative deliberation of possible actions – this retroactive paradigm forecloses the multiplicity of plural solutions to a single target, and reduces the framing of the political problem to the weighting of inputs. Every adjustment or modification of the parameters in the deep learning model is simultaneously an arrangement of the political problem.

To begin at the ‘end’, with a target output of the model, is thus to transform radically what a political claim can be in the world. For example, machine learning algorithms are increasingly being deployed in immigration and borders decisions. The introduction of machine learning in the sorting and classification of visa applications does not merely automate some aspects of a previously human centred bureaucratic process. More than this, the building of a model of the flows of immigration claims actively constitutes what a border can be and how it is understood as a political question. Moreover, the space to challenge the political formulation, such as for example to question the racialised criteria that are applied to the judgement on a person, is also closed out by the machine learning process. In contrast to the rules-based models that I described as engineering racialised assumptions into association rules (for example, in Rakesh Agrawal’s data mining models), machine learning learns and generates new racial formations from the data examples. With machine learning forms of classification, there are no criteria as such; there are only inputs, outputs, features, and functions. The model will also adjust with the volatilities and geopolitical disruptions of migration, shifting its thresholds so that the derived outputs are decoupled from the input data of a visa application.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Bronze Night Aff › Framework › Reasonability—2AC

Reasonability: You should choose to understand our interpretations as reasonable readings of the resolution. Cyberwar operates at the level of epistemology itself, which means competing interpretations is a regime of veridiction that furthers the militarization of the cybernetic episteme.

Joque, 18—PhD from the European Grad School, researches philosophy, technology and media and is the visualization librarian at the University of Michigan, go blue (Justin, “Spear Phishing: Nodal Subjects,” Deconstruction Machines: Writing in the Age of Cyberwar, Chapter 4, 157-165, dml)

Leaking information, anonymity, and privacy are not only issues of secrecy or its lack but are intimately tied to the subject’s relation to truth. Faced with the contingent and vulnerable nature of these networks and information, any political subject always exists in a complex relation to truth or, at the very least, the veracity of her information. Any political efficacy from leaking information and destroying institutional secrecy requires the production of truth or some sort of truth-effect in the network that would engender a political response. Given the risks that false information could be leaked for the purposes of deception, or produced for other ends, as we saw in the case of Sabu, it becomes difficult to determine the veracity of any individual bit of information. More fundamentally, cyberwar in its very functioning is an attack on truth and its material and epistemic underpinnings. Under the threat of cyberwar, and the possibility that any information may have already been compromised, epistemology and truth become not only philosophical concerns but military-strategic problems as well.

In this light, it becomes difficult to separate any truth from its political and military investment. Derrida in “Plato’s Pharmacy” suggests that “the opposition between the true and the untrue is entirely comprehended, inscribed, within this structure or this generalized writing. The true and the untrue are both species of repetition. And there is no repetition possible without the graphics of supplementarity.”18 Here, for Derrida, the true does not transcend the structure of writing in general. There is no unity but only a relation among units of inscription. The true and the untrue are movements of repetition within and between systems, a movement defined by text and network. Truth and its opposite become emergent effects of networks and texts rather than transcendental or global attributes of systems. Like certificate authorities for verifying identity on open networks, the guarantee of any information is merely deferred to a different level. Truth emerges as a result of the structure and folds of a given system.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Bronze Night Aff › Framework › C/I—USFG—2AC

The USFG is an assemblage. Did you not see Hamilton?

Aroney, 2—Professor of Constitutional Law at The University of Queensland (Nicholas, “Imagining a Federal Commonwealth: Australian Conceptions of Federalism, 1890-1901,” Federal Law Review, 30(2), 265, dml)

Putting these points together, Just apparently sought to show that it was necessary to have a strong federal government in which the will of the majority prevailed, but that such a government must first be formed with the consent of each of the several colonies as independent bodies politic. As the Herald had maintained, a federation comes into being by unanimous agreement of the constituent bodies politic, and they agree to confer limited functions on a central government that makes its decisions by majority rule, but the remainder of their constituent and governmental powers are retained.

Just also felt it important to draw the attention of his Australian readers to Hamilton's famous discussion of Montesquieu's classic definition of the 'Confederate Republic'. As reproduced by Just, Montesquieu had said:

2022 Michigan Kritik
Bronze Night Aff › Framework › C/I—NATO—2AC

NATO is an assemblage, “a number of disparate and heterogeneous elements convoked together into a single discernible formation.” That’s limited and predictable.

Handeland, 19—Master of Science candidate in International Relations, Department of International Environment and Development Studies, Norwegian University of Life Sciences (Lars, “Exploring the knowledge-politics nexus in global governance: A case study of the anti-chemical weapons assemblage in Syria (2013-2017),” , dml)

Originally developed as a concept by the philosopher Gilles Deleuze and his writing partner, the psychoanalyst Felix Guattari, defined assemblage in the following way: “An assemblage is a number of disparate and heterogeneous elements convoked together into a single discernible formation” (Deleuze & Guattari as cited Bueger, 2014c, p. 60). Importantly, the French word they use is agencement. Derived from the verb agencer, the noun agencement can roughly be translated into the ‘act of assembling’, and highlights the ongoing and neverending processes of shifts and transformations (Phillips, 2006). 8

The term ‘convoked’ implies that they are brought together towards a function or purpose. Indeed, “every assemblage is characterized by the process of constituting a "territory" that holds together distinct or heterogenous elements…”(Hayden, 1998, p. 96). The territory, then, comes to signify the identity of a given assemblage, which is derived from its purpose or function. Indeed, the assemblage is not “a random collection of things, since there is a sense that an assemblage is a whole of some sort that expresses some identity and claims a territory” (Wise, 2005, p. 77).

2022 Michigan Kritik
Bronze Night Aff › Framework › C/I—Cybersecurity—2AC

Cybersecurity is “the security of the environment formed by physical and non-physical components and characterised by the use of computers and other networked devices.” Debates about US-NATO security cooperation are more accurate when they theorize states as assemblages rather than unitary actors.

Collier, 18—Cyber Security DPhil Candidate based at the Department of Politics and International Relations, and the Centre for Doctoral Training in Cyber Security, University of Oxford, formerly worked at the NATO Cooperative Cyber Defence Centre of Excellence (Jamie, “Cyber Security Assemblages: A Framework for Understanding the Dynamic and Contested Nature of Security Provision,” Politics and Governance, Volume 6, Issue 2, July 2018, dml)

Refreshed thinking is required to better understand the provision of cyber security and the configuration of cyber security actors. Here, the term cyber security is defined as the security of the environment formed by physical and non-physical components and characterised by the use of computers and other networked devices. Cyber security actors, by definition, provide security in some capacity. Yet this does not mean that all actors strive to achieve a single, unitary concept of security. The prevalence of private actors means that cyber security is often provided by actors who prioritise other commercial objectives over security. Encryption disputes between the US government and technology firms show that different actors have altogether different motivations.

This makes the study of the different cyber security providers, and how they interact with one another essential. The concept of global cyber security assemblages provides a conceptual anchor that provides a means for further understanding these issues. The term provides a more appropriate concept for understanding contemporary cyber security contexts when compared to more traditional frameworks. The security assemblage term refers to new hybrid structures that are often simultaneously public and private, global and local. The use of the term is part of an emerging body of scholarship within IR literature that seeks to empirically assess complex structures where a range of different global and local, public and private security agents, interact, cooperate and compete to produce new institutions, practices and forms of security governance that cannot be captured neatly though the boundaries of nation states (Abrahamsen & Williams, 2011; Williams, 2016).

2022 Michigan Kritik
Bronze Night Aff › Alternative Methods/Theses › Borderless Cosmopolitanism

Tag 1 – RAID THE ARCHIVE

Tag 2 – The spectre of the non-western Other haunts the resolution, inducing an ethos of total control for the western subject through top-down risk management. NATO, at its core, a question of borders, as the west artificially cordons off those deemed worthy of being and those to be deprived. Vote aff to affirm borderless cosmopolitanism, a rupture in the crystallized western archive that embraces instability to render oneself ungovernable by the LIO’s sovereign authority. <This conceptual power hinges on the order and stability of its security state. The so-called neutrality of the closed system of debate through fairness, predictability, and stasis is not benign but rather a violent fidelity to the ordered security paradigm of territorialization.>

Mbembe 18 (Achille, research professor in history and politics at the Wits Institute for Social and Economy Research at the University of the Witwatersrand. “The idea of a borderless world”) //ansel

*modified for gendered language