2022
Georgetown
Disadvantage
Conventional causes Russia Baltics escalation
Kühn, 18 – nonresident scholar at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, and the head of the arms control and emerging technologies program at the Institute for Peace Research and Security Policy at the University of Hamburg. (Ulrich Kühn, “NATO’s Options – Preventing Escalation in the Baltics,” 3-28-2018, Accessed 06-28-2022, https://carnegieendowment.org/2018/03/28/nato-s-options-pub-75883)//ILake-NoC
DETERRENCE BY DENIAL
2022
Georgetown
Disadvantage
Not zero sum – NATO will just increase total resources invested because cyber defense is a priority.
DOD, '18 (U.S. Department of Defense; "News Conference by Secretary Mattis at NATO Headquarters, Brussels, Belgium"; ; https://www.defense.gov/News/Transcripts/Transcript/Article/1654419/news-conference-by-secretary-mattis-at-nato-headquarters-brussels-belgium/; 10-4-2018, Accessed 6-24-2022)//ILake-NoC
Amid many competing priorities, American lawmakers did not reduce funding for the European Deterrence Initiative by a single cent, instead maintaining the highest levels of commitment since the 1989 fall of the Berlin Wall. We have maintained the number of U.S. troops currently assigned to Europe while adding additional capability.
2022
Georgetown
Disadvantage
NATO cyber resources are limited – we must pick and choose.
Waterman, '22 – journalist and communicator who has worked for the BBC, United Press International and POLITICO, and an expert on cybersecurity and counterterrorism (Shaun Waterman; "Cyber Troops Stretched Thin in Ukraine Response as NATO Builds Common Air Picture"; Air Force Magazine; https://www.airforcemag.com/cyber-troops-stretched-thin-ukraine-response-nato-common-air-picture/; 3-14-2022, Accessed 6-24-2022)//ILake-NoC
The war in Ukraine has provided a wake-up call for U.S. military cyber defenders, who are facing hard choices about how to deploy limited resources, said Air Force Brig. Gen. Chad D. Raduege, the chief information officer of U.S. European Command.
2022
Georgetown
Disadvantage
OCOs would be integrated by the CYOC.
Maigre, '22 – Non-resident Senior Fellow with CEPA's Transatlantic Leadership Program and CEPA's Digital Innovation Initiative, as well as the Senior Cyber Security Expert at Estonia’s e-Governance Academy, a non-profit that helps governments go digital. (Merle Maigre; "NATO’s Role in Global Cyber Security"; GMFUS; https://www.gmfus.org/news/natos-role-global-cyber-security; 4-6-2022, Accessed 6-24-2022)//ILake-NoC
CyOC is the first cyber-dedicated entity within the Command Structure. The “eyes and ears” of the respective commanders in cyberspace, CyOC aims at enhancing situational awareness in cyberspace and helping integrate cyber into NATO’s planning and operations at all levels. While CyOC operates within the existing NATO frameworks, its main aim is to equip the Supreme Allied Commander Europe with any necessary tools to operate in cyberspace. As CyOC moves toward initial then final operating capacity, it will be critical that it is staffed with sufficient—and sufficiently expert—personnel.2222NATO, NATO's Role in Cyberspace, February 19, 2019.
2022
Georgetown
Disadvantage
Even lower increments make nuclear war inevitable in every region
Dr. Michael T. Klare 20, Five Colleges Professor of Peace and World Security Studies at Hampshire College, Ph.D. from the Graduate School of the Union Institute, BA and MA from Columbia University, Member of the Board of Director at the Arms Control Association, Defense Correspondent for The Nation, “How Rising Temperatures Increase the Likelihood of Nuclear War”, The Nation, 1/13/2020, https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/nuclear-defense-climate-change/
Climbing world temperatures and rising sea levels will diminish the supply of food and water in many resource-deprived areas, increasing the risk of widespread starvation, social unrest, and human flight. Global corn production, for example, is projected to fall by as much as 14 percent in a 2°C warmer world, according to research cited in a 2018 special report by the UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). Food scarcity and crop failures risk pushing hundreds of millions of people into overcrowded cities, where the likelihood of pandemics, ethnic strife, and severe storm damage is bound to increase. All of this will impose an immense burden on human institutions. Some states may collapse or break up into a collection of warring chiefdoms—all fighting over sources of water and other vital resources.
2022
Georgetown
Disadvantage
Runaway warming causes extinction
Nathan Alexander Sears 21, PhD Candidate in Political Science at The University of Toronto, Former Professor of International Relations at the Universidad de Las Américas, Trudeau Fellow in Peace, Conflict and Justice at the Munk School of Global Affairs, “Great Powers, Polarity, and Existential Threats to Humanity: An Analysis of the Distribution of the Forces of Total Destruction in International Security”, Conference Paper: International Studies Association, 2021 Annual Conference, March/April 2021, https://tinyurl.com/bfbfspzx
Climate Change
2022
Georgetown
Disadvantage
Climate change is an existential risk and a threat multiplier. Integrating it with NATO risk assessment is vital to avoid extinction.
Amar Causevic 17, researcher at Global Economic Dynamics and the Biosphere program at the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences, “Facing an Unpredictable Threat: Is NATO Ideally Placed to Manage Climate Change as a Non-Traditional Threat Multiplier?,” Connections: The Quarterly Journal, Vol. 16, Iss. 2, 2017, http://connections-qj.org/article/facing-unpredictable-threat-nato-ideally-placed-manage-climate-change-non-traditional-threat
Climate Change as a Non-Traditional Threat Multiplier
2022
Georgetown
Disadvantage
NATO climate security requires tradeoffs and resource allocation.
Lipert, '16 – Policy Analyst, Lawyer, and Data Scientist (Tyler H. Lippert; "NATO, Climate Change, and International Security: A Risk Governance Approach"; RAND; https://www.rand.org/pubs/rgs_dissertations/RGSD387.html; 10-2016, Accessed 6-24-2022)//ILake-NoC
NATO finds itself in a complicated and crowded institutional environment in the context of climate security risk. A variety of international organizations—as well as NGO and member state agencies—share responsibility for the potentially adverse and wide ranging impact of a changing climate. Yet, NATO has the resources and relationships to allow it to play a role in shaping, guiding, and implementing actions on the climate-security nexus.
2022
Georgetown
Disadvantage
The aff clouds NATO’s focus – info-sharing makes the organization a glorified clearinghouse that trades off with NATO security initiatives.
Moller, '20 – Assistant Professor at the School of Diplomacy and International Relations (Sara Bjerg Moller; "It Will Take More Than a Biden Victory to Solve NATO’s Strategic Malaise"; War on the Rocks; https://warontherocks.com/2020/09/it-will-take-more-than-a-biden-victory-to-solve-natos-strategic-malaise/; 9-25-2020, Accessed 6-24-2022)//ILake-NoC
If and when the Biden team embarks on its grand European tour, it seems virtually certain that, beyond the expressions of gratitude for America’s “return” that will surely follow them wherever they go, the delegation can expect to be met with a lengthy list of items requiring their immediate attention. Moreover, appeals for Washington’s assistance are likely to differ from capital to capital, with each NATO ally arguing that their particular issue or concern represents the most pressing challenge and therefore requires the most attention and resources. In Warsaw and the capitals of the Baltic states, the U.S. delegation will hear that, despite a new U.S. rotational troop deployment, a revanchist Russia necessitates additional NATO (but especially U.S.) military commitments along the Eastern flank of the alliance. In Rome, Athens, and Madrid, U.S. policymakers will learn that the Mediterranean countries represent the “soft underbelly” of NATO and that the alliance must do more to project stability along its southern arc of instability. In Ankara, the message will be one of anger directed at what the Erdogan government perceives as NATO’s collective failure to support Turkish actions in Syria and elsewhere. In Paris, the message for the U.S. delegation will be that the alliance must strengthen its counter-terrorism efforts in the Middle East and North Africa, while in Berlin the focus will be on reforming NATO’s nuclear posture and salvaging expiring arms-control agreements. Meanwhile, securing the Arctic and halting the effects of climate change will be at the top of the agenda in Copenhagen and Oslo.
2022
Georgetown
Disadvantage
Climate remains high priority post-Ukraine.
Kirton & Warren, 3/22 – professor of political science and the director and co-founder of the G7 Research Group, co-director and founder of the G20 Research Group (John Kirton and Brittaney Warre; "Will the War in Ukraine Crowd Out G7 Climate Action in 2022?"; G7 Information Center; http://www.g7.utoronto.ca/evaluations/2022elmau/kirton-warren-ukraine-crowd-out.html; 3-22-2022, Accessed 6-24-2022)//ILake-NoC
G7 Performance on Security and Sustainability on March 10 and 11
2022
Georgetown
Disadvantage
Climate change will be a top priority in the upcoming Madrid summit – focus is key.
NATO, '22 (North Atlantic Treaty Organization; "NATO continues to adapt to rapid environmental changes"; NATO; https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/news_195079.htm; 5-5-2022, Accessed 6-25-2022)//ILake-NoC
Rapid environmental changes resulting from climate change have a direct impact on our shared security and call for innovative technological solutions. NATO has started a new project using Big Earth Datacube Analytics for transnational security and environmental protection. Today (5 May 2022) marked its kick-off, at an event hosted at NATO Headquarters in Brussels by the NATO Science for Peace and Security (SPS) Programme, featuring the participation of project stakeholders and experts from Denmark, Germany, Israel and Switzerland.
2022
Georgetown
Disadvantage
Climate is a priority, but resources are strapped – NATO defense initiatives directly trade off.
Kochis, '21 – senior policy analyst in European affairs in the Margaret Thatcher Center for Freedom (Daniel Kochis; "Biden Wants NATO To Focus on Climate Change. What About Russia?"; Heritage Foundation; https://www.heritage.org/global-politics/commentary/biden-wants-nato-focus-climate-change-what-about-russia; 8-13-2021, Accessed 6-24-2022)//ILake-NoC
The recent NATO summit in Brussels was, by and large, a big disappointment. Its big “achievement” was the misguided adoption of a climate change agenda. At best, that agenda is a distraction from the critical security challenges facing the alliance. At worst, it will actively undermine the alliance’s ability to defend its member states.
2022
Georgetown
Disadvantage
Collective defense k2 russia
Kochis et al., '22 – Senior Policy Analyst in European Affairs, Margaret Thatcher Center for Freedom (Daniel Kochis; "The Russian Threat: Bolstering NATO Deterrence at a Critical Time"; Heritage Foundation; https://www.heritage.org/defense/report/the-russian-threat-bolstering-nato-deterrence-critical-time; 3-14-2022, Accessed 6-26-2022)//ILake-NoC
The security and prosperity of the transatlantic community, including the United States, rests on the foundation of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO). Russia’s ongoing war of naked aggression against Ukraine, a NATO non-member state, should put to rest any lingering questions about the modern utility of the Alliance and about which threat should be the focus of NATO’s upcoming strategic concept.
2022
Georgetown
Disadvantage
Baltic info-sharing is sufficient to deter Russian covert activities now BUT vulnerabilities remain in their military readiness.
Radin, '15 – political scientist at the RAND Corporation. His research interests include European security, NATO, and Russia's foreign and security policy; state building and security sector reform; and peace operations (Andrew Radin; "Hybrid Warfare in the Baltics"; RAND corporation; https://www.rand.org/content/dam/rand/pubs/research_reports/RR1500/RR1577/RAND_RR1577.pdf; 2015, Accessed 6-28-2022)//ILake-NoC
Like Crimea and eastern Ukraine, the eastern portions of Estonia and Latvia are proximate to Russia and do have a significant Russian-speaking population that might make them similarly vulnerable to Russian covert action. In general, however, the Baltic countries appear to be a less fertile ground for covert subversion than Ukraine. While Russia was able to seize and maintain control over Crimea, where its conventional forces maintained dominance, the success of covert actions in eastern Ukraine was ultimately less successful, as discussed above. The Baltic countries are better positioned than Ukraine to defend against and deter Russian covert action. They have greater control over their own territory, through the development of their internal security forces, as outlined below. Furthermore, they are members of NATO, and so benefit from assistance from other NATO countries, including under Article 5. Unlike Ukraine, where NATO support to Ukraine was limited to nonlethal equipment after Russia used conventional forces to support the separatists, NATO member countries are committed to respond to an attack on any of the Baltic states as if it were an attack on themselves.
2022
Georgetown
Disadvantage
Cyber-security investments sap diplomatic energy crucial to doubling down on territorial defense.
Peter van Ham, '08 – senior research fellow at the Netherlands Institute of International Relations Clingendael in The Hague (About The; "NATO Review"; NATO Review; https://www.nato.int/docu/review/articles/2008/03/18/nato-and-the-madonna-curve-why-a-new-strategic-concept-is-vital/index.html; 3-18-2008, Accessed 6-24-2022)//ILake-NoC
That is why NATO needs policy entrepreneurs who are willing to give the Alliance a new lease of life and a new focus.
2022
Georgetown
Disadvantage
Peripheral commitments like cybersecurity spread NATO too thin – obfuscates a focus on the operational capabilities that sustain collective defense.
Peter van Ham, '08 – senior research fellow at the Netherlands Institute of International Relations Clingendael in The Hague (About The; "NATO Review"; NATO Review; https://www.nato.int/docu/review/articles/2008/03/18/nato-and-the-madonna-curve-why-a-new-strategic-concept-is-vital/index.html; 3-18-2008, Accessed 6-24-2022)//ILake-NoC
If NATO aspires to deal with terrorism and WMD proliferation, the timing and legitimacy of military force will be a key issue on which the allies have to see eye to eye. But as a look at some core strategic documents shows, this is not the case today. The EU Security Strategy of 2003 opens with the sanguine observation that “Europe has never been so prosperous, so secure, nor so free”, whereas the US Security Strategy of 2006 starts with the ominous statement that “America is at war.” This testifies to the potential of infecting the Alliance with a level of strategic schizophrenia [irrationality] that is unhealthy and untenable.,
2022
Georgetown
Disadvantage
NATO must prioritize military defense against Russia – non-traditional threats blur strategic focus.
Coffey, '20 – Director of the Allison Center for Foreign Policy Studies at The Heritage Foundation (Luke Coffey; "NATO needs to remain focused on Russia"; SAUDI RESEARCH & PUBLISHING COMPANY; https://www.arabnews.com/node/1772621; 12-05-20, Accessed 6-24-2022)//ILake-NoC
This week, foreign ministers from NATO’s 30 member nations gathered for a virtual meeting during which they were presented with a lengthy report on the future of the alliance.
2022
Georgetown
Disadvantage
NATO is shifting priorities towards Baltic conventional defense now, but that requires massive resource re-allocation.
Foy, 6/27 – FT's European Diplomatic Correspondent, based in Brussels. He reports on the EU's foreign policy, relations between Brussels and other world powers, and the diplomatic intrigues between member states. Previously he was Moscow Bureau Chief, where he interviewed president Vladimir Putin and charted his regime's descent into repression (Henry Foy; "NATO to increase forces on high alert to 300,000 "; Financial Times; https://www.ft.com/content/39caeff3-38cf-44e2-9270-835ab28f13c8; xx-06-27-2022, Accessed 6-28-2022)//ILake-NoC
Nato is to increase its forces on high alert by more than sevenfold to 300,000 in response to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine as part of a sweeping overhaul to better protect its eastern flank.
2022
Georgetown
Disadvantage
Stimpson, '15 – (Maj R.T. Stimpson; ""; No Publication; https://www.cfc.forces.gc.ca/259/290/317/305/stimpson.pdf; xx-xx-xxxx, Accessed 6-27-2022)//ILake-NoC
Cyberweapons have been hyped as an attractive alternative to conventional weapons due
to their affordability. Amy Chang a research associate in the technology and national security
2022
Georgetown
Disadvantage
Conventional war outweighs cyberwar – cyberattacks are de-escalatory and replace more violent means.
Libicki, '14 – American scholar and Professor at the Frederick S. Pardee RAND Graduate School in Santa Monica, California (Martin Libicki; "Is Cyberwar Good for Peace? [par Martin Libicki]"; FIC; https://incyber.org/en/is-cyberwar-good-for-peace-par-martin-libicki/; 01-2014, Accessed 6-27-2022)//ILake-NoC
Imagine two universes. In the first one, information systems are impervious to manipulation from the outside. No unauthorized person one can change the instructions that systems run and systems react to all input as they are supposed to (that is, consistent with the common understanding of designers and users). This is a world in which the potential effects of cyberwar are, at most, weak and largely irrelevant to the conduct of violent (i.e., kinetic) conflict. In the second universe, cyberwar is potentially consequence; it where we live today.