Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 SDI Negative
*Human Germline Genetic Engineering* Negative › Advantage 1 - Ethics › A2 Precautionary principle

Precautionary principle is pragmatically insufficient and results in self-interested ignorance and neglect of opportunity costs and risk probability comparisons

Sunstein 02 (The Paralyzing Principle BY CASS R. SUNSTEIN University of Chicago Karl N. Llewellyn Distinguished Professor of Jurisprudence at the University of Chicago. Cato Institute Winter 2002-2003; http://object.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/serials/files/regulation/2002/12/v25n4-9.pdf)

PRECAUTIONS AND RATIONALITY But if the Precautionary Principle, taken in a strong form, is unhelpful, how can we account for its extraordinary influence, and indeed for the widespread belief that it can and should guide regulatory judgments? Undoubtedly, self-interested political actors invoke the principle strategically. For example, European farmers invoke the idea of precaution to stifle American competitors who are far more likely to rely on genetically modified crops. But apart from that point, I suggest that an understanding of human cognition provides some useful clues: Loss aversion People dislike losses far more than they like corresponding gains. The result is that out-of-pocket costs, or deteriorations from the status quo, seem much worse than opportunity costs, or benefits lost as a result of continuing the status quo. In the context of risks, people often tend to focus on the losses that are associated with some activity or hazard, and to disregard the gains that might be associated with that activity or hazard. A closely related point is that unfamiliar risks produce far more concern than familiar ones, even if the latter are sta tistically larger; the Precautionary Principle, in practice, is much affected by that fact. The myth of a benevolent nature Loss aversion is often accompanied by a mistaken belief that nature is essentially benign, leading people to think that safety and health are generally at risk only or mostly as a result of human intervention. A belief in the relative safety of nature and the relative risk of new technologies often informs the Precautionary Principle. Because natural processes are often dangerous and human interventions often promote safety, a commitment to nature can be life threatening. The availability heuristic It is well known that people focus on some risks simply because they are cognitive y “available,” whereas other risks are not. When the Precautionary Principle seems to require stringent controls on one risk, even though other risks are in the vicinity, the availability heuristic is a common reason. And when the availability heuristic is at work, certain hazards will stand out whether or not they are not statistically large. The hazards associated with heat waves, for example, receive little public attention, while the hazards associated with air travel are a significant source of public concern; one reason is that the latter hazards come readily to mind. That is a serious problem because the less salient risks, including those from heat waves and poor diet, can be the serious ones. Probability neglect People are sometimes prone to neglect the probability that a bad outcome will occur; they focus instead on the outcome itself. The Precautionary Principle often embodies a form of probability neglect. At least, that is the case when people invoke the principle to favor stringent controls on a low-probability risk and when the consequence of those very controls is to give rise to new risks of equal or greater probability. In the context of the sniper attacks in the Washington, D.C. area in October 2002, people were far more concerned, and took many more precautions, than the statistical realities warranted, in part because the high salience of the attacks led to a form of probability neglect. It is highly likely that some of those precautions, including those that involved extra driving, actually increased people’s risks. System neglect The Precautionary Principle often reflects a general neglect of the systemic effects of regulation. When a single problem is placed in view, it can be difficult to see the full consequences of legal interventions. Sometimes, the principle has the appearance of being workable only because a subset of the relevant effects is “on screen” — and hence there seems to be no need to take precautions against other possible adverse effects that do not register. I suggest that the Precautionary Principle seems appealing to many people in large part for the same reason.

2022 SDI Negative
*Human Germline Genetic Engineering* Negative › Advantage 1 - Ethics › Its ethical – A2 Eugenics

Germline gene editing enhances human dignity and isn’t eugenics – we have the capacity to resolve mass human suffering

Vera Lúcia Raposo 2019 Gene Editing, the Mystic Threat to Human Dignity Journal of Bioethical Inquiry Pty Ltd. 2019 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11673-019-09906-4

In light of this understanding, gene editing does not violate human dignity; on the contrary, it offers the individual more possibilities to assert his/her status as a human person and, therefore, to assert his/her dignity. The claim is unfounded that gene editing is a form of eugenics and therefore—ipso facto—repugnant. To be healthy, to live a life with less suffering, cannot be against human dignity. The accusation of eugenics has become commonplace—invoking the Nazi holocaust and the fear of gross violations of human rights. However, the fear of past mistakes cannot block genetic ameliorations that are able to relieve humanity from diseases that continue to kill so many people. Critics also invoke the immutability of the genetic code, as a kind of foundation of human dignity. Nevertheless, the preservation of humankind’s genetic pool cannot be more important than the other values and goals at stake here, such as eradicating the pathological features of people who are suffering. If the aim is to avoid human suffering in present and future generations, the hypothetical right to receive an unmodified genetic code (hypothetical because future generations do not have any rights) cannot prevail over the right to health. On the other hand, an immutable genome cannot be viewed as a condition sine qua non for the dignity of the person. Scientific reports have shown that a person’s genetic code changes throughout their existence, even if such changes are subtle and temporary. Certainly, these changes do not imply a diminution of an individual’s dignity. Another repeated argument pertains to the destruction of our intrinsic human nature. However, enhancement (becoming stronger and healthier) is natural to humanity; it is the defining note of the human species. Looking back in time, the story of humankind has been one of enhancement. We are always trying to supplant ourselves (Buchanan 2011). We cannot assume that human nature is something defined and fixed (Fenton 2006). On the contrary, we cannot avoid changing ourselves for the simple reason that we are human. Gene editing is just another way of being human.

2022 SDI Negative
*Human Germline Genetic Engineering* Negative › Advantage 1 - Ethics › Its ethical – A2 Eugenics

Human germline editing is not reminiscent of the type of eugenics we should be afraid of – potential for positivity and not harmful.

Vera Lúcia Raposo 2019 Gene Editing, the Mystic Threat to Human Dignity Journal of Bioethical Inquiry Pty Ltd. 2019 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11673-019-09906-4

Human enhancement, including enhancement for health-related purposes, is rejected by many under the accusation that it led to the Nazi horrors and to other procedures to eliminate the unfit. What these measures have in common is that they are all eugenic measures (Paor and Blanck 2016), but the mistake is to consider all eugenics as pernicious. The Nazi Holocaust and the sterilization of mentally impaired people represented the negative side of eugenics, characterized by discrimination, hierarchization of human life, and ultimately the killing of those perceived as weak in our species (Bachruch 2004; Finkelstein and Stuart 1996). Conversely, the kind of human enhancement that we pursue today by means of gene editing (and artificial reproductive treatments) aims to promote the well-being of the existing generations (somatic genetic interventions) and of future generations (germinal genetic interventions). The assimilation between these two scenarios, so different from each other, rest on a misunderstanding about eugenics as being necessarily harmful (Caplan et al. 1999). Eugenics has been vilified because of its abuses during the early 20th century, particularly Germany’s choice to murder people with perceived disabilities. But the origin of eugenics was simply a desire to increase the odds that a child would be born healthy. Today we consider such measures as prenatal care, eating sensibly during pregnancy, avoiding use of alcohol or other drugs, and choosing your partner carefully to be the minimum that the pregnant woman should do and that the healthcare system should offer. Yet these practices are the very basis of eugenics. (Root 2000, 873). It has become common to use eugenics as a kind of bogeyman and for every intervention with connotations of human improvement to be at risk of being banned. However, we should not be afraid of eugenics.

2022 SDI Negative
*Human Germline Genetic Engineering* Negative › Advantage 1 - Ethics › Its ethical – A2 Human Dignity

Unaltered genetic heritage is not the only way to preserve human dignity

Vera Lúcia Raposo 2019 Gene Editing, the Mystic Threat to Human Dignity Journal of Bioethical Inquiry Pty Ltd. 2019 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11673-019-09906-4

The right to an unaltered genetic heritage cannot be taken as an absolute goal; the genetic code isn’t something divine and immutable. Even though detrimental traits are part of human heritage, there is no reason to keep them unmodified. Genetic immutability is not the only guide for genetic decisions or even the more beneficial to humankind. If this were so, we would be prevented from defending ourselves against the caprices of nature and biology based on a supposed duty to respect nature or BGod-given gifts.^ Surgical interventions, vaccinations, or even something as simple as taking an aspirin would be banned.

2022 SDI Negative
*Human Germline Genetic Engineering* Negative › Advantage 1 - Ethics › Its ethical – A2 Human Dignity

Genetic engineering does not take away humanness

RUSSELL POWELL Boston University, Boston, Massachusetts 2015 In Genes We Trust: Germline Engineering, Eugenics, and the Future of the Human Genome, USA Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 40 (6):669-695 (2015)

I will not take a stand here as to whether our given biological nature has intrinsic value or, if it does, how weighty that value might be. Indeed, there are serious problems with drawing any substantive bioethical conclusions from a conception of human nature (see Buchanan, 2009). Furthermore, authors will disagree over just how much of a departure from human biological nature is necessary to bring about the loss of intrinsic value associated with remaining “fundamentally human.” One might contend, for example, that much of human biological nature (as defined earlier) can be altered without altering fundamentally human characteristics. Attempting to distinguish putatively fundamental human characteristics from less fundamental ones raises a spate of philosophical difficulties that I will not address here. I will simply argue that if there is intrinsic value in retaining human biological nature or central features of “humanness,” then this gives us further reasons—conservative reasons—to actively promote human germline modification technologies, or at the very least to oppose prohibitions of germline intervention that are insensitive to risk-benefit analyses and which block the gathering of information necessary to make proper risk-benefit assessments.

2022 SDI Negative
*Human Germline Genetic Engineering* Negative › Advantage 1 - Ethics › Its ethical – A2 Human Dignity

Human dignity is not based on a certain genetic code.

Vera Lúcia Raposo 2019 Gene Editing, the Mystic Threat to Human Dignity Journal of Bioethical Inquiry Pty Ltd. 2019 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11673-019-09906-4

To conclude that the existence of a non-manipulated genetic code is linked to human dignity, we would have to assume that human dignity is based on a certain genetic code, not any human genetic code but the one every person is born with. If that were true, any change to that code would carry a diminution of dignity. This conclusion is problematic because our genetic code changes during our lifetime. For instance, after a baby is born some fetal cells may be left behind in its mother’s body. They can travel to different organs and be absorbed into the mother’s tissues, changing her genetic composition,3 but no one would say that the mother is less worthy of dignity. In the case of blood transfusions, depending on the amount of white blood cells (the only ones that contain nuclear DNA), some DNA is transferred from the donor to the recipient, even in small amounts, and it can survive for days in his or her body,4 but this does not make the recipient less dignified during that transitory period. Furthermore, some diseases (such as cancer) can lead to acquired genetic mutations, creating the so-called genetic mosaics.5 In addition to being sick, do these people become undignified? The same happens in organ (Olszewski et al. 2005) and bone narrow donations.6 Both involve adding the donor’s DNA to extracts of tissues from the recipient, but none of these situations diminishes the recipient’s dignity. If the above thesis were true and if human dignity resided in a specific (human) genetic code, these examples would lead to the conclusion that some people lose their dignity during their lifetime due to changes (even if reduced and temporary) in their genomes, which obviously does not make any sense. Human dignity cannot be reduced to a certain genetic code, nor the human being reduced to genetic characteristics. This same idea is stated by article 2 of the UDHG: (a) Everyone has a right to respect for their dignity and for their rights regardless of their genetic characteristics. (b) That dignity makes it imperative not to reduce individuals to their genetic characteristics and to respect their uniqueness and diversity. If that is the case, there is no way that a change in the genetic features of a person will undermine his or her dignity.

Gene editing is ethical – does not clash with human dignity

2022 SDI Negative
*Human Germline Genetic Engineering* Negative › Advantage 1 - Ethics › Its ethical – A2 Human Dignity

Its ethical – germline editing isn’t contrary to dignity – modifying genomes happens in medical treatments and is consistent with international law.

Boggio and Yotova (2021). Gene editing of human embryos is not contrary to human rights law: A reply to Drabiak. Bioethics. doi:10.1111/bioe.12945 

The second rebuttal concerns the argument that clinical interventions based on gene editing of human embryos are contrary to human dignity. The argument takes different forms: gene editing is seen as an alleged violation of human dignity because it (a) leads to considering some human lives (of those carrying good genes) better than others (of those carrying bad genes); (b) violates a purported right to genetic identity; and (c) compromises the human genome, whose unmodified form is allegedly a requisite of human dignity. Drabiak embraces the second and third forms of the argument. Taken to an extreme, the idea of this dignity being grounded on genetic identity or genetic inviolability leads to an indefensible conclusion: persons who have undergone cancer or other serious treatment, which modifies their genome, would have lost, or have suffered a violation of, their human dignity in the process. This conclusion is hard to defend on its face. More moderate accounts are not new to us and have been discussed in Yotova's background paper. After a thorough review of all international and regional instruments applicable to gene editing that mention human dignity, she concludes that “there is a trend of acknowledging that while embryos and foetuses are not generally recognised as holders of human rights, they are becoming increasingly recognised as having human dignity.” 46 The dignity‐ based argument is complex, and a lengthy analysis of this issue exceeds the scope of this paper. Here we want to focus on some critical aspects. First, while embryos may possess human dignity, they are generally not recognized as rightsholders. As Yotova points out, “legally speaking … human rights are protected only after birth, which puts germline editing outside of their temporal scope of protection.” 47 This is the case under international law and also in the majority of domestic laws. The European Court of Human Rights also acknowledged the lack of consensus in Europe about the nature and status of the embryo, rejecting the argument that they are a “person” with “a right to life.” 48 Second, the ICESCR acknowledges human dignity. Nonetheless, it recognizes the right to access treatment to enjoy the highest attainable standard of physical and mental health and the right to access clinical applications as benefits of scientific progress compatible with human dignity. These two rights are recognized without reservations. As we have seen, their recognition is not absolute, leaving it up to State Parties to limit the two rights to access provided it is done according to the parameters set in Article 4 of the ICESCR. A State Party may consider the interest of embryos to deserve consideration that trumps the right to access clinical applications of gene editing of human embryos. However, this is a State Party's prerogative, not a duty under the Covenant. Third, the concept of human dignity was considered and discussed extensively during the negotiations of the UNESCO Declaration on the Human Genome but never as an argument against germline interventions. Instead, it was linked to very different legal principles.

2022 SDI Negative
*Human Germline Genetic Engineering* Negative › Advantage 1 - Ethics › Its ethical – A2 Gene Drive

Takes thousands of years to evaluate changes of genetic code – and can’t change human nature.

Vera Lúcia Raposo 2019 Gene Editing, the Mystic Threat to Human Dignity Journal of Bioethical Inquiry Pty Ltd. 2019 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11673-019-09906-4

Based on this understanding, Jurgen Habermas (2006) asserted that when people change their genetic code they are altering their human nature and turning themselves into instruments. According to Habermas, our genetic code is the basis of our human nature, as if changing it would make us less human. Kass (2002), for instance, referred to losing one part of being human. This argument can be divided into two sub-arguments: a) genetic homogeneity can become a threat to the survival of the human species; and b) an overall ecological balance should be maintained, which depends on the existence of diverse species. Notwithstanding these assertions, it would take thousands of years and generations for one change to have repercussions for the genetic makeup of humanity as a whole. As McConnell (2010, 420) puts it: [T]here are more than six billion humans on the planet. Absent some kind of magic wand, it is initially difficult to see how any given genetic intervention could change human nature.

2022 SDI Negative
*Human Germline Genetic Engineering* Negative › Advantage 1 - Ethics › Its ethical – A2 Gene Drive

Human germline editing is an ethical imperative to sustain genetic health

RUSSELL POWELL Boston University, Boston, Massachusetts 2015 In Genes We Trust: Germline Engineering, Eugenics, and the Future of the Human Genome, USA Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 40 (6):669-695 (2015)

In this article, I explore some of the evolutionary and social risks that attend the other side of the risk equation: namely, the undesirable consequences that are likely to flow from our failure to intervene in the human germline. I argue that even if we do not have moral reasons to genetically “enhance” our children relative to the current status quo of normality (for arguments that we do, see, e.g., Savulescu, 2001; Bostrom and Ord, 2006; Harris, 2007; Savulescu and Persson, 2008; Buchanan, 2011; Powell and Buchanan, 2011), germline intervention still emerges as a pro tanto moral imperative so long as we have good reason to sustain the levels of genetic health that we presently enjoy for future generations—a goal that should appeal to bioliberals, biomoderates, and bioconservatives alike. My aim is to show that merely preserving important genetic and phenotypic aspects of the human species—and perhaps even human dignity—will require that we overcome the remaining technical obstacles and make germline genetic therapies legal and widely available to healthcare consumers.

2022 SDI Negative
*Human Germline Genetic Engineering* Negative › Advantage 1 - Ethics › Its ethical – A2 Mosaicism & Autonomy

Genetic engineering necessary to preserve key aspects of our biology and is ethically justifiable

RUSSELL POWELL Boston University, Boston, Massachusetts 2015 In Genes We Trust: Germline Engineering, Eugenics, and the Future of the Human Genome, USA Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 40 (6):669-695 (2015)

Whereas most of the philosophical literature on the ethics of genetic engineering, both skeptical and optimistic, has focused on its ability to enhance human nature and valued biological capacities (see e.g., Savulescu and Bostrom, 2009), my contention is that genetic intervention will be necessary merely to preserve them. The dynamic evolutionary environment may counsel against taking genetic engineering off the table, lest the technology proves useful in tackling unforeseen challenges that arise in the future—but this does not imply that we will need to embark on a genome-wide enterprise of germline modification in order to maintain valued elements of the biological status quo, or to avoid foreseeable reductions in human wellbeing. In this section, I argue that a large-scale program of genetic intervention will be necessary to achieve these goals, regardless of whether the environment changes in the ways contemplated earlier.8

2022 SDI Negative
*Human Germline Genetic Engineering* Negative › Advantage 1 - Ethics › Its ethical – A2 Mosaicism & Autonomy

New studies prove can do editing without genetic instability

Yelena Biberman Dr. Biberman is an associate professor of political science at Skidmore College, a fellow at West Point’s Modern War Institute, and a nonresident senior fellow at the Atlantic Council’s South Asia Center The Technologies and International Politics of Genetic Warfare STRATEGIC STUDIES QUARTERLY FALL 2021 https://www.airuniversity.af.edu/Portals/10/SSQ/documents/Volume-15_Issue-3/Biberman.pdf

Gene editing and synthetic biology research are making strides in overcoming the problem of genetic instability. A study published in 2019 presented a new system, CRISPR-BEST. It created mutations in actinomycetes (bacteria that produce a wide variety of industrially and medically relevant compounds) without creating genetic instability and forcing them to rearrange and even delete large parts of their chromosomes.53 Synthetic biology is also increasingly embracing genetic instability rather than trying to suppress or compensate for it. With improved understanding, it is expected to design devices that incorporate genetic instability as a parameter.54 Such devices would be “a true frontier in biological engineering.”55

2022 SDI Negative
*Human Germline Genetic Engineering* Negative › Advantage 1 - Ethics › Its Ethical

Human germline gene editing would actually reduce the risk to a number of unwanted viable embryos.

Savulescu, et.al. 2015 The moral imperative to continue gene editing research on human embryos Julian Savulescu, Jonathan Pugh, Thomas Douglas, Christopher Gyngell Protein Cell 2015, 6(7):476–479 DOI 10.1007/s13238-015-0184-y

In fact, gene-editing technologies might ultimately lead to far fewer embryos being destroyed for reproductive purposes. Currently, if a carrier of a genetic disease wants to have a child that will not be affected by their parent’s condition, the carrier will often choose to undergo IVF and PGD in order to select a non-affected embryo. This practice often involves the creation, and eventual destruction of, a considerable number of surplus unwanted viable embryos. However, this practice would be rendered obsolete by the availability of safe and effective gene-editing technologies; if such technologies became available, carriers of genetic diseases would not have to produce large numbers of surplus embryos which would eventually be destroyed in order to ensure that they could have a child who was not affected by their parent’s genetic disease.

2022 SDI Negative
*Human Germline Genetic Engineering* Negative › Advantage 1 - Ethics › Its Ethical

No valid legal human rights restriction on germline editing – ethical because right to health and to benefit from science.

Boggio and Yotova (2021). Gene editing of human embryos is not contrary to human rights law: A reply to Drabiak. Bioethics. doi:10.1111/bioe.12945 

In a recent article in this journal, Katherine Drabiak argues that the genome editing of human embryos is contrary to fundamental human rights law.1 “Such practice,” Drabiak concludes, “would violate what we should recognize as a fundamental human right to inherit a genome without deliberate manipulation.” 2 Her argument is presented in the form of a critique of the analysis and conclusions reached by the Nuffield Council on Bioethics in its 2018 report Genome editing and human reproduction: Social and ethical issues3 and of the background paper, authored by Rumiana Yotova, on The regulation of genome editing and human reproduction under international law, EU law and comparative law. 4 Unfortunately, Drabiak's analysis mischaracterizes both the Nuffield Council's report and international human rights law that pertains to genome editing of human embryos. In this reply, we limit our critique to two main points. First, we challenge her methodological approach used to identify what constitutes “fundamental human rights law.” Her approach fails to include key human rights provisions in the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, which include the right to health and the right to benefit from science. Second, we challenge the substantive standard invoked by Drabiak (a right to genetic integrity of a future person) and the implications of the concept of human dignity for informing how genome editing of human embryos can be regulated. After further analyzing Drabiak's argument and specifying what her argument does not prove, we conclude by reiterating the position taken by the Nuffield Council in 2018 and Yotova's background paper that: international law does not prohibit genome editing of human embryos and does not recognize a right to genetic integrity for future persons let alone inviolability as clearly evidenced in the text and preparatory works of the 1997 UNESCO Declaration on the Human Genome and Human Rights.5

2022 SDI Negative
*Human Germline Genetic Engineering* Negative › Advantage 1 - Ethics › Its Ethical

Not unethical – all new technologies have unpredictable effects and we don’t ban them. Its key to advancement and innovation.

Savulescu, et.al. 2015 The moral imperative to continue gene editing research on human embryos Julian Savulescu, Jonathan Pugh, Thomas Douglas, Christopher Gyngell Protein Cell 2015, 6(7):476–479 DOI 10.1007/s13238-015-0184-y

However, some in the scientific community are calling a moratorium on gene editing research. Yet, they fail to give a sufficient justification for such a ban. In calling for a moratorium, Lanphier et al. (2015) state: In our view, genome editing in human embryos using current technologies could have unpredictable effects on future generations. This makes it dangerous and ethically unacceptable. Such research could be exploited for non-therapeutic modifications This reasoning is, however, inconsistent with widely accepted practices. Nearly all new technologies have unpredictable effects on future generations. Information technologies like the internet and mobile phones fundamentally change the way people interact and communicate with each other. Their effect on future generations is very hard to predict, and though they could be catastrophic (for example, through cyberterrorism), this does not mean on balance they should be banned. Their expected benefits outweigh their expected harms.

2022 SDI Negative
*Human Germline Genetic Engineering* Negative › Advantage 1 - Ethics › Its Ethical

Banning germline genetic editing is naïve and amounts to ‘biological nonsense’ – their ‘ethical concerns’ are unlikely to ever occur and mystify legitimate implementation benefits

Pinker 15 Pinker, Steven. Steven Pinker is professor of psychology at Harvard University and the author of 10 books, most recently "The Sense of Style: The Thinking Person's Guide to Writing in the 21st Century." “Experts Debate: Are We Playing with Fire When We Edit Human Genes?” STAT, 17 Nov. 2015, www.statnews.com/2015/11/17/gene-editing-embryo-crispr/#Mathews. Accessed 30 June 2022. //DRE

Germline editing should be treated like any other medical procedure, weighing benefits against harms. It should not be banned out of a nebulous terror about tampering with a sacrosanct entity called "the human germline" - a concept which is biological nonsense. We affect the genetic makeup of our offspring, and the species, every time we choose one sex partner over another. And each of us introduces dozens of mutations into our own germlines by exposing ourselves to everyday radiation and chemical mutagens. Genetic editing would be a droplet in the maelstrom of naturally churning genomes. What are the potential benefits? There are several scenarios in which germline editing could benefit parents who carry disease genes. It could be used when both parents are homozygous for the disease, when in vitro fertilization doesn't produce enough viable and unaffected embryos for preimplantation genetic diagnosis, or if future data shows that babies who undergo the procedure have compromised longevity or health. The principal harm of germline editing is the risk of producing a sick or deformed child. Frankly, I suspect that this risk will always be unacceptable, so most of this discussion is moot. But suppose safety could be ensured. Should we fear the prospect of parents genetically enhancing their babies, the outcome the prohibitionists dread? This is highly unlikely - a relic of the early 1990s, when people thought there was "a gene for" this or that talent. We now know that heritable psychological traits, such as intelligence and personality, are the product of hundreds or thousands of genes, each with a tiny effect. And many genes have multiple effects, some of them harmful, such as an increased risk of neurological disease or cancer. With each enhancement providing a trifling benefit and a non-negligible risk, and with the editing process itself imposing risks, it's unlikely that today's morbidly risk-averse helicopter parents will take a chance at enhancing a child. They won't even feed their babies genetically modified applesauce! Add these risks to the expense and tribulation of IVF compared to good old-fashioned sex, and one can conclude that widespread genetic enhancement is too unlikely a possibility to worry about.

2022 SDI Counterplan
AFF ANSWERS › 2AC › A2: AI Timeframe too slow

Russia autonomous weapons are hype – too many technical difficulties

Gregory C. Allen, 22, (Gregory C. Allen, Gregory C. Allen is the director of the Artificial Intelligence (AI) Governance Project and a senior fellow in the Strategic Technologies Program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington, D.C. Director, AI Governance Project and Senior Fellow, Strategic Technologies Program, 5-26-2022, No Publication, Russia Probably Has Not Used AI-Enabled Weapons in Ukraine, but That Could Change, https://www.csis.org/analysis/russia-probably-has-not-used-ai-enabled-weapons-ukraine-could-change, 6-27-2022) SCade

In March, WIRED ran a story with the headline “Russia's Killer Drone in Ukraine Raises Fears About AI in Warfare,” with the subtitle, “The maker of the lethal drone claims that it can identify targets using artificial intelligence.” The story focused on the KUB-BLA, a small kamikaze drone aircraft that smashes itself into enemy targets and detonates an onboard explosive. The KUB-BLA is made by ZALA Aero, a subsidiary of the Russian weapons manufacturer Kalashnikov (best known as the maker of the AK-47), which itself is partly owned by Rostec, a part of Russia’s government-owned defense-industrial complex. The WIRED story understandably attracted a lot of attention, but those who only read the sensational headline missed the article’s critical caveat: “It is unclear if the drone may have been operated in this [an AI-enabled autonomous] way in Ukraine.” Other outlets re-reported the WIRED story, but irresponsibly did so without the caveat. WIRED’s assessment that Kalashnikov claims the KUB-BLA “boasts the ability to identify targets using artificial intelligence” is based on two main pieces of evidence: a Kalashnikov press release about ZALA Aero’s “Artificial Intelligence Visual Identification (AIVI)” capabilities for its unmanned aircraft, and the original Kalashnikov press release announcing the KUB-BLA in 2019. However, these two pieces of evidence are less than they seem. The Russian-language AIVI press release never mentions the KUB-BLA or military applications. Instead, it describes a ZALA Aero machine-learning AI drone product line that is marketed to industrial and agricultural sectors. Incorporating modern machine-learning AI into military applications is significantly more difficult than in industrial or agricultural applications. Modern machine-learning AI using deep neural networks offers the opportunity for incredible gains in performance, but that performance depends on having lots of training data during development. Moreover, that training data needs to closely resemble operational conditions. In general, it is much easier to get such training data from commercial customers than from an enemy military, especially if friendly weapons systems and sensors do not often come within range of enemy ones. The most mature military AI applications are ones like satellite reconnaissance: even in peacetime, satellites get to take a lot of pictures of Russian and Chinese military forces, and those pictures can be digitally labeled by human experts to turn them into training data. Training data is what machine learning AI systems learn from. The combination of a learning algorithm and training data is how AI systems learn to recognize what is in the image. But training data is generally application-specific. Satellite image recognition training data only helps build satellite image recognition AI. One cannot magically use labeled satellite image data to train an AI for a robotic drone’s targeting computer (at least not with today’s technology). Getting enough of the right sort of training data to incorporate modern AI into, say, a robotic tank’s targeting computer, is a much tougher technical challenge. It is not impossible in principle, but in practice, there are far fewer opportunities to collect the right sort of training data.

2022 SDI Counterplan
AFF ANSWERS › 2AC › A2: NATO fails at AI

Standardization and new rules solves for any of NATO shortcomings – gets NATO back to innovating

Ben Wodecki, 22, (Ben Wodecki, 5-4-2022, AI Business, NATO at risk of losing AI innovation race to Russia, China, https://aibusiness.com/document.asp?doc_id=777260, 6-24-2022) SCade

The North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) should standardize and regulate AI to keep up with rivals, according to findings published by the U.S. think tank, Center for European Policy Analysis (CEPA). CEPA’s comments came as it published a series of AI-related recommendations for NATO amid growing geopolitical tensions with the likes of Russia, China and North Korea. Its recommendations include AI standardization, encouraging and improving AI literacy and spurring private sector innovation. Such undertakings would allow NATO allies to better scale and deploy AI – and keep pace with rivals. “These new capabilities will revolutionize NATO’s military and strategic affairs, thus strengthening NATO’s ability to fulfill its essential core tasks of collective defense, crisis management and cooperative security,” CEPA’s Nicholas Nelson and Nico Luzum wrote. The pair cited AI projects being undertaken by adversaries, including China’s attempts to develop purported mind-controllable drones and AI assistants for fighter pilots. But NATO allies have their own capabilities – including U.S.-developed autonomous tanks and British-made systems that provide ground troops with information on the surrounding terrain. The think tank’s study suggests that at present, NATO is leading the AI race – but risks losing its competitive advantage to peer competitors “competitors if allies fail to leverage the private sector, coordinate implementation and engage with the public.” CEPA suggests that NATO allies should accelerate AI adoption and actively encourage private sector innovation. “Ultimately, we hope that these recommendations enable NATO allies to better innovate, scale, deploy, and integrate AI and autonomy-based technologies to form agile, system-wide solutions.

2022 SDI Counterplan
AFF ANSWERS › 2AC › A2: NATO fails at AI

NATO initiatives prove they are successful at AI management

Colin Demarest, 22, (Colin Demarest, Colin Demarest is a reporter at C4ISRNET, where he covers military networks, cyber and IT. Colin previously covered the Department of Energy and its NNSA — namely Cold War cleanup and nuclear weapons development — for a daily newspaper in South Carolina. Colin is also an award-winning photographer!, 5-18-2022, Defense News, NATO launches AI initiative to ensure tech advantage, https://www.defensenews.com/artificial-intelligence/2022/05/18/nato-launches-ai-initiative-to-ensure-tech-advantage/, 6-24-2022) SCade

WASHINGTON — Two NATO agencies recently kicked off an artificial intelligence initiative to better understand the technology and its potential warfare applications. More than 80 AI experts, researchers and academics from the U.S. and other member countries are involved with the venture, known as a strategic “horizon scanning,” put together by the NATO Science and Technology Organization and the NATO Communications and Information Agency. An inaugural meeting and workshop was held this month in The Hague, Netherlands, where the NCI Agency’s data science and AI facilities are located. “AI is one of the key emerging and disruptive technologies identified by NATO as vital for the maintenance of its technological edge,” NATO Chief Scientist Bryan Wells said in a statement. “By working together, the STO and the NCI Agency are able to bring together global experts to ensure the very best scientific expertise is available to advise NATO and its allies and partners on the latest scientific trends in this area.” The NATO guarantee of a collective defense and the advantage of numbers, both on the battlefield and in the lab, has been much discussed amid Russia’s latest invasion of Ukraine and the subsequent membership applications made by Finland and Sweden. NATO ministers in October adopted the alliance’s first-ever AI strategy, which describes the capability as “changing the global defense and security environment” and offering “an unprecedented opportunity to strengthen our technological edge but will also escalate the speed of the threats we face.” The strategy emphasizes responsible use of AI for defense across six tenets: lawfulness; responsibility and accountability; explainability and traceability; reliability; governability; and bias mitigation. AI frameworks and other guidance drafted by the U.S. and its defense community take a similar approach. NATO allies in 2019 agreed to focus on seven emerging and disruptive technologies, data, computing and AI among them. Making sure there are shared standards, and that systems will work with systems, will be critical to success, officials said. “One of the big challenges when we go into this new phase of disruptive technologies is how do you keep all allies on the same hymn sheet when it comes down to communicating with each other, using the same technology, being interoperable,” David van Weel, NATO assistant secretary general for emerging security challenges, told Defense News in March 2021. “So that’s a big part [of the strategy] and a big role for NATO to play.”

2022 SDI Counterplan
AFF ANSWERS › 2AC › 2AC---US Failing at AI

The US is no longer demolishing China in the race – need full NATO cooperation to outpace China

Graham Allison and Eric Schmidt, 20, (Graham Allison Eric Schmidt, 8-1-2020, Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, Is China Beating the U.S. to AI Supremacy?, https://www.belfercenter.org/publication/china-beating-us-ai-supremacy, 6-27-2022) SCade

The US-China Race for Artificial Intelligence Combining decades of experience advancing frontier technologies, on the one hand, and analyzing national security decisionmaking, on the other, we have been collaborating over the past year in an effort to understand the national security implications of China’s great leap forward in artificial intelligence (AI). Our purpose in this essay is to sound an alarm over China’s rapid progress and the current prospect of it overtaking the United States in applying AI in the decade ahead; to explain why AI is for the autocracy led by the Chinese Communist Party (hereafter, the “Party”) an existential priority; to identify key unanswered questions about the dangers of an unconstrained AI arms race between the two digital superpowers; and to point to the reasons why we believe that this is a race the United States can and must win. We begin with four key points. First, most Americans believe that U.S. leadership in advanced technologies is so entrenched that it is unassailable. Likewise, many in the American national security community insist that in the AI arena China can never be more than a “near-peer competitor.” Both are wrong. In fact, China stands today as a full-spectrum peer competitor of the United States in commercial and national security applications of AI. Beijing is not just trying to master AI—it is succeeding. Because AI will have as transformative an impact on commerce and national security over the next two decades as semiconductors, computers and the web have had over the past quarter century, this should be recognized as a matter of grave national concern.1,2,3 Second, China’s zeal to master AI goes far beyond its recognition that this suite of technologies promises to be the biggest driver of economic advances in the next quarter century. For the Party, AI is mission critical. The command of 1.4 billion citizens by a Party-controlled authoritarian government is a herculean challenge. Since the fall of the Soviet Union, Americans have been confident that authoritarian governments are doomed to fail—eventually. But AI offers a realistic possibility of upending this proposition. AI could give the Party not just an escape hatch from the “end of history,”4 but a claim to advance a model of governance—a national operating system—superior to today’s dysfunctional democracies. As one former Democratic presidential candidate put it: “China is using technology to perfect dictatorship.”5 It’s a value proposition that resonates with many leaders around the world. As former Google ceo Eric Schmidt has argued: “if the Soviet Union had been able to leverage the kind of sophisticated data observation, collection and analytics employed by the leaders of Amazon today, it might well have won the Cold War.” Third, while we share the general enthusiasm about AI’s potential to make huge improvements in human wellbeing, the development of machines with intelligence vastly superior to humans will pose special, perhaps even unique risks. In 1946, Albert Einstein warned, “the unleashed power of the atom has changed everything save our modes of thinking, and thus we drift towards unparalleled catastrophe.” We believe the same could be said of AI. Henry Kissinger has identified these risks in what we call “Kissinger’s Specter.” In his words, AI threatens an unpredictable revolution in our consciousness and our thinking, and an “inevitable evolution in our understanding of truth and reality.”6 In response to Einstein’s insight, the technologists and strategists who had built and used the bomb to end World War II joined forces to find ways to prevent a nuclear World War III. Meeting the challenges posed by AI will require nothing less. Fourth, China’s advantages in size, data collection and national determination have allowed it over the past decade to close the gap with American leaders of this industry. It is currently on a trajectory to overtake the United States in the decade ahead. Nonetheless, if the United States will awake to the challenge and mobilize a national effort, we believe that it can develop and execute a winning strategy.

2022 SDI Counterplan
AFF ANSWERS › 2AC › 2AC---NATO Action Key – Montenegro

Other NATO states – like Montenegro – require US cyber help – the CP leaves NATO members defenseless

Pierluigi Paganini, 20, (Pierluigi Paganini, Pierluigi Paganini is member of the ENISA (European Union Agency for Network and Information Security) Threat Landscape Stakeholder Group and Cyber G7 Group, he is also a Security Evangelist, Security Analyst and Freelance Writer. Editor-in-Chief at "Cyber Defense Magazine", Pierluigi is a cyber security expert with over 20 years experience in the field, he is Certified Ethical Hacker at EC Council in London. The passion for writing and a strong belief that security is founded on sharing and awareness led Pierluigi to find the security blog "Security Affairs" recently named a Top National Security Resource for US. Pierluigi is a member of the "The Hacker News" team and he is a writer for some major publications in the field such as Cyber War Zone, ICTTF, Infosec Island, Infosec Institute, The Hacker News Magazine and for many other Security magazines. Author of the Books "The Deep Dark Web" and “Digital Virtual Currency and Bitcoin”., 1-20-2020, Security Affairs, Nato has sent an anti-hybrid war team to Montenegro, https://securityaffairs.co/wordpress/96627/cyber-warfare-2/montenegro-nato-hybrid-attacks.html, 6-27-2022) SCade

The Chairman of the NATO Military Committee announced that the alliance has sent a counter-hybrid team to Montenegro to face Russian hybrid attacks. Last week in Brussels, the Chairman of the NATO Military Committee (MC), Marshal Sir Stuart Peach, announced the effort of the Alliance in facing Russian hybrid attacks. The term “Hybrid warfare” refers to a military strategy which employs political warfare and blends conventional warfare, irregular warfare and cyberwarfare with other influencing methods, such as fake news, diplomacy, lawfare and foreign electoral intervention. Peach said that the NATO alliance had set up the first NATO counter-hybrid team in Montenegro. “The first NATO counter-hybrid team has been deployed to our ally state, Montenegro, with the aim of helping to strengthen Montenegro’s capacities and deterring hybrid challenges”, Peach said. Several countries, especially Russia, continue their aggressive operations against foreign states, and cyber warfare is becoming the main concern for almost any government. The official explained that since 2014 the defence spending to face hybrid threats has continued to increase, it has been estimated that by 2024 that amount will reach $ 400 billion. “NATO data shows a 4,6% increase in 2019. That is the fifth consecutive year of growth. By the end of this year, allies will have invested over $130 billion”, added Marshal Peach United States Army General Mark Milley, the highest military officer and military adviser to the President, Minister of Defence and U.S. National Security Council, accused the Russian Government of attempting to destabilize the members of the alliance and divide it. “it is evident that Russia has been trying to divide NATO and make it weaker”. General Milley said. “It would be their benefit. It would be detrimental to Europe and the US if NATO just collapsed and disintegrated.” Representatives of Montenegro’s Defence Ministry confirmed that NATO counter-hybrid team visited Montenegro in November. Experts fear that Russia could attempt to influence the forthcoming parliamentary elections that will take place in October 2020. “This visit was the first such engagement in one of the allies, and it was an important experience for Montenegro. Montenegro wants to enhance its capacities and the focus of NATO’s team was on strengthening legislative framework in this domain and its implementation”, said Ivica Ivanović, director general for defence policy. On June 5, 2017 Montenegro officially joined NATO alliance despite the strong opposition from the Russian Government that threatened to retaliate. Cybersecurity experts believe that a new wave of attacks from the cyberspace will hit the state. In February 2017, for the second time in a few months, Montenegro suffered massive and prolonged cyberattacks against government and media websites. Researchers at security firm FireEye who analyzed the attacks observed malware and exploits associated with the notorious Russia-linked APT group known as APT28 (aka Fancy Bear, Pawn Storm, Strontium, Sofacy, Sednit, and Tsar Team). Another massive attack hit the country’s institutions during October 2016 elections, amid speculation that the Russian Government was involved. Hackers targeted Montenegro with spear-phishing attacks, the malicious messages used weaponized documents pertaining to a NATO secretary meeting and a visit by a European army unit to Montenegro. At the time, the cyberspies delivered the GAMEFISH backdoor (aka Sednit, Seduploader, JHUHUGIT, and Sofacy), a malware that was used only by the APT28 group in past attacks.