Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Cyborg Writing – BFHR 7wk › 2AC -- K › 2AC -- K -- Afropessimism

Their theorization of Black death is inapplicable to Black queer subjects -- Black queer subjectivity exists in a space of injury, marked by perpetual conditions of vulnerability and openness to violence rather than bound by non-existence – only including an analytic of queerness can account for the ways the afterlife of slavery uniquely demarcates Black queer life.

Avilez ’20 -- (GerShun Avilez, 2020, “Black Queer Freedom: Spaces of Injury and Paths of Desire,” Urbana: University of Illinois Press, accessed 7-23-2022) -- nikki

Black Queer Freedom: Spaces of Injury and Paths of Desire begins with a consideration of Big Freedia’s account of her life because her experiences can help us think through the boundaries of queer freedom and, specifically, the social threats that are directed toward the Black queer body. Simply moving through space—that is, walking down the street, going to work, traveling across state or national borders, or interacting with institutions—proves to be especially risky business for racial and sexual minorities. This book explains how attending to and challenging such threats constitutes the defining element in the work of Black queer cultural producers. Black Queer Freedom presents the argument that queerness, meaning same-sex desire and gender nonconformity, does introduce the threat of injury, but artists throughout the Black diaspora use queer desire to negotiate spaces of injury.3 I show how Black queer bodies are perceived as social threats, and this perception, in turn, results in threats (physical, psychological, socioeconomic) against these bodies. The Black queer body is immersed in a veritable threat feedback loop. With the spatial metaphor of the feedback loop, I describe the circular thinking that makes minority groups be perceived as perpetual threats. This loop characterizes a situation in which a majority group feels threatened by the presence of a minority group, and this feeling encourages material and symbolic violence against the perceived threat of the minority group, which ironically strengthens (through discriminatory logic) the social perception of the minority population as menacing and troublemaking. This threat loop— that minority bodies are assumed to be threatening whether or not they pose an actual threat—constitutes the space of injury and creates the conditions for Black queer vulnerability. This space of injury for the Black queer body is not necessarily about a particular architecture or location; it is more about the perception and engagement of that body. The space of injury is potentially any space that a queer body occupies or moves through. The point here is not to avoid precision in specifying the space of injury but, instead, to make clear how for many artists and thinkers, it is vital to recognize the possibility of injury in all locations and resist the desired belief that certain places may be assumed to be safe (such as, home, family, or places that claim to be queer friendly). The space of injury actually describes the Black queer body as it exists and moves through space. I do not seek to cast this body as having injury inhere to it; rather, I make the point that because of social norms and dominant ideologies, this body may always be on the verge of injury. Given this idea, I contend that Black queer individuals are injury-bound subjects. I develop this idea through Abdul JanMohamed’s conception of the death-bound-subject and theories of Black social death.4 JanMohamed defines this subject as one that is formed “by the imminent and ubiquitous threat of death” (2). It is a subject bound to and constantly directed toward death. His discussion is useful because it provides a framework for recognizing the social construction of vulnerability for the Black (male) subject in a hostile racial climate. I shift focus from death to injury because the threat of death does not fully capture the multiple kinds of threat (microaggressions, intimidation, humiliation, displacements, detention, defamation, medical abuses, and misgenderings) that racial and sexual minorities experience. One could argue that every physical threat implies the threat of death, but I think the overemphasis on death obscures the nuance and complexity of the multiple kinds of vulnerability minorities face. Freedia’s concern about getting a beatdown is first a fear of injury—physical, emotional, and social. An emphasis on different manifestations of injury illuminates how a broader array of interactions can create conditions of vulnerability, and this more capacious sense of social threat provides the opportunity to consider how gender and class dynamics inflect the threats posed by racism and homophobia.5 This book reflects my careful analysis about how threats of queer injury work assiduously along lines of sex and gender expressions. Throughout this book, the reader will find an explicit focus on the experiences of queer women and queer men with nonconventional gender expression. I work from the understanding that gender expression and identity are imbricated with same-sex desire and can deeply impact if and how one experiences social threat. This recurring attention to the role of gender in the experience of injury indicates the intersectional approach of the methodology as well as a recognition on the level of the argument that all queer bodies may face injury, but all of those bodies do not experience injury in the same manner or to the same extent. Injury, like queerness, is not one-dimensional.6 In a move toward thinking about injury and with a focus on queer bodies that might be injured but not killed, this volume builds on Darius Bost’s bold intervention into Afro-pessimism and the emergent discourses on Black social death.7 Bost insists, “In the context of slavery’s afterlife, asserting the presence of black gay bodies signals how contemporary theories of antiblackness replicate the historical processes of secondary marginalization experienced by blackness’s others” (15; emphasis added). What this critic points to is that which gets lost in the overemphasis on death and absence, especially when we talk about queer bodies, which are often already marginalized if not absent from the narratives and records of the past. My framework of injury emphasizes embodied presence rather than physical or epistemic absence. I take seriously material and epistemic violence but am mindful not to lose sight of the specific realities of queer embodiment within those paradigms.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Cyborg Writing – BFHR 7wk › 2AC -- K -- Capitalism › 2AC -- AT: Identity Politics

Class-analysis that attempts to eschew identity politics is just a ruse for white middle class men to feel included and lead the marginalized in the glory of the revolution. It is an invisible form of white paternal saviorism that pushes identity through the back door of anti-capitalist movements.

Ross 2000 [Marlon B., Professor, Department of English and Carter G. Woodson Institute for African-American and African Studies, “Commentary: Pleasuring Identity, or the Delicious Politics of Belonging,” New Literary History, Vol. 31, No. 4, pages 840-841]

Although in his contribution Eric Lott targets Professor Michaels's comments and his own recent feud with Timothy Brennan (who unfortunately is not included in this volume) rather than Ken's argument, what Eric says about “left and liberal fundamentalists” who “simply and somewhat penitently” urge us to “‘go back to class’” could also be directed at Ken's conclusion. Ken writes, “Crafting a political left that does not merely reflect existing racial divisions starts with the relatively mundane proposition that it is possible to make a persuasive appeal to the given interests of working and unemployed women and men, regardless of race, in support of a program for economic justice.” On this one, I side with Eric, rather than Tim and Ken. Standing on the left depends on whose left side we're talking about. My left might be your right and vice versa, because it depends on what direction we're facing, and what direction depends on which identities we're assuming and affirming. Eric adds, "Even in less dismissive [than Tim's] accounts of new social movements based not on class but on identities formed by histories of injustice, there is a striking a priori sense of voluntarism about the investment in this cause or that movement or the other issue—as though determining the most fundamental issue were a matter of the writer's strength of feeling rather than a studied or analytical sense of the ever-unstable balance of forces in a hegemonic bloc at a given moment." I agree, but I'll risk mangling what Eric says by putting it more crassly. Touting class or "economic justice" as the fundamental stance for left identity is just another way of telling everybody else to shut up so I can be heard above the fray. Because of the force of "identity politics," a leftist white person would be leery of claiming to lead Blacks toward the promised land, a leftist straight man leery of claiming to lead women or queers, but, for a number of complex rationalizations, we in the middle class (where all of us writing here currently reside) still have few qualms about volunteering to lead, at least theoretically, the working class toward "economic justice." What Eric calls here "left fundamentalism," I'd call, at the risk of sounding harsh, left paternalism. Of the big identity groups articulated through "identity politics," economic class remains the only identity where a straight white middle-class man can still feel comfortable claiming himself a leading political voice, and thus he may sometimes overcompensate by screaming that this is the only identity that really matters—which is the same as claiming that class is beyond identity. Partly this is because Marxist theory and Marx himself (a bourgeois intellectual creating the theoretical practice for the workers' revolution) stage the model for working-class identity as a sort of trans-identification, a magical identity that is transferable to those outside the group who commit themselves to it wholeheartedly enough. If we look back, we realize even this magical quality is not special to a history of class struggle, as whites during the New Negro movements of the early twentieth century felt that they were vanguard race leaders because they had putatively imbibed some essential qualities of Negroness by cross-identifying with the folk and their culture.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Cyborg Writing – BFHR 7wk › 2AC -- K -- Capitalism › 2AC -- Alt

4 -- Straight Time DA -- generates an “official time line” that glosses over the complexity of violence(s) our critique illuminates. The perm works to “tease” out good police practices from the “bad,” performatively demonstrating their refusal to examine structural interdependence. Their step in the “right direction” is a step in a “straight direction.”

Russell, 20 – Emma K. Russell is Lecturer in Crime, Justice and Legal Studies at La Trobe University, Australia. She researches in the fields of queer criminology and critical carceral studies. She is the co-author of Resisting Carceral Violence: Women's Imprisonment and the Politics of Abolition (Queer Histories and the Politics of Policing, “Afterword: police power, queer resistance,” Routledge, 2020, pg 154-155)//BL

As a queer criminological text, this book issues a broader challenge to the discipline of criminology. It is a call to question the production of ‘official time lines’ and simplistic dichotomies for the exclusions that they engender and the complexities that they gloss over. Rather than tease out the ‘good’ police practices and strategies from the ‘bad’, a critical and historical queer optic allows us to appreciate the mutual constitution and interdependence of these categories, the slippages and continuities between them in practice, and the powerful forces that reproduce and circulate them. Rather than view the uneven and coercive effects of policing as products of the actions of biased, deficient, or ill-equipped individual officers, we should broaden our analytical framework to account for the historical genesis of policing as a heteronormative and settler colonial project. This reminds us of the importance of preventing (and pursuing accountability for) the immediate harms of policing and punishment—whether as activists or scholars—without getting swept up in the administration of these systems and therefore invested in their continuity. Instead, we might consider strategies to demilitarise and disempower police (McDowell & Fernandez 2018), as well as dedicating more resources towards exploring community-based responses to harm (Kim 2018). As an emerging field of study seeking to distinguish itself from ‘mainstream’ criminology, queer criminology has much to benefit from engagement with abolitionist and anti-carceral feminist thinking (Carlton & Russell 2018; Stanley & Smith 2011; Thuma 2015). We must remain attuned to the violence that underpins the state’s promise of protection. Rather than accepting it at face value that the incorporation of previously excluded groups signifies historical progress and positive change, this book has sought to illustrate the exclusive and regulatory effects of the politics of recognition. My hope is that the narrative presented in this book sparks new questions about the relationship between sexual and gender politics and police power. The surface support for LGBT rights amongst police leaders might indicate success on some levels for LGBT activists who have long fought for queers to be seen as other than criminal and to have access to state protection when it is needed or desired. However, the adoption of LGBT rights language and symbols in by police public relations produces ambivalence and hostility towards police within LGBT movements (Russell 2019). Evolving LGBT-police relations prompt renewed discussion about the role and effects of policing in society, for queers and others. Queer Histories and the Politics of Policing has sought to make sense of contemporary strategies of governing sexuality and gender—the histories from which they emerge and the futures they foreclose—and the threads of resistance running through them.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Cyborg Writing – BFHR 7wk › 2AC -- K -- Capitalism › 2AC -- Alt

3 -- Conformity DA – communist organizing inevitably excludes and silences queer members by forcing them to conform to their ideal vision of the proletariat. Communist movements have historically been homophobic and claimed that being lesbian arises from unjustified hostilities to men and was an example of developing a lifestyle under capitalism. Don’t let them get away with just saying “not us”; multiple examples of communist movements being exclusionary, and their alt doesn’t do anything to actively include queer people.

Devrim 12 (Libri Derim writes about their experiences in the Revolutionary Communist Party. “Out of the Red Closet: Gay and lesbian experiences in the previous communist movement” Kasama, January, 2012. https://www.marxists.org/history/erol/ncm-8/kasama.pdf) alowenstein

Much has been written about the Revolutionary Communist Party and its ban on gay people within its ranks. Some of us are familiar with the specific anti-gay rationalizations the RCP promoted for thirty years – including its notorious argument that same-sex attrac- tions are a politically reactionary, personal-ideological choice. But what was going on within the RCP was not just a stubborn and arrogant “error of line”– it was also an actual practice that had an impact on real people and real struggle. That is what I want to write about, including what it was like to live “in the closet” inside a communist organization. I want to talk about what it was like to be attracted to the dream of revolution – and then be told that my lesbian feelings were ideologically part of a corrupt and oppressive world order, and that I force myself to have sexual relationships with men in an effort to develop the sexual feelings I was told I was supposed to have, as part of being a revolutionary. I want to talk about the way decent but incredibly ignorant communist com- rades were instructed to correct me, my feelings, and my behaviors. And how, within a movement hoping to carry out liberation, the awful arguments and pressures of anti-gay bigotry were reproduced and enforced. RCP cadre and leaders looked people like me in the eyes and told us to change, conform and be silent — or else get out. At the height of the AIDS crisis, they knowingly opened a horrible split between com- munist activists and those fighting rightwing attacks on gay people. They reproduced within revolutionary ranks (and using “communist” rhetoric) the prejudices, arguments and repressive practices of rightwing re- ligious nuts – and they tried to promote such views more broadly within the left. It seems that most queer revolutionaries were attracted to what the RCP was putting out. That they’d go take out the RCP’s newspaper, the Revolutionary Worker, get involved, and then someone would meet with them to have serious talk about “the Homosexual- ity Question,” and then they would disappear. In that respect, I was a bit different. I got involved before I came out. After meeting the revolutionaries of the RCP, I joined the Revolutionary Communist Youth Brigade (RCYB), really throwing myself into it. I was con- vinced that a possible revolutionary situation might be just around the corner (remember that slogan, “Revo- lution in the ‘80s – Go for it!”?). All my free time was spent building for the work this party was doing in my area: I was going to dem- onstrations, taking the paper out, talking to everyone about Marxism-Leninism-Maoism (MLM), postering a couple times a week, going to meetings. It was my whole life. Falling in love Then I started feeling attracted to another girl who was hanging around the RCYB. She was really funny and cute and smart. I thought she was great and I really respected her, especially the way she stood up for what she believed at school, how she would face off the cops at a demonstration without fear, the way she was al- ways ready to take the paper out even when the rest of us got discouraged by all the rejection. I wanted to be around her all the time and I thought about her con- stantly. Everyone else could see I had it bad, but I never noticed! She gave me her green kaffyah and I wore it all the time, even when I went to bed. I always wanted to ride in the same car with her when we went some- place. Her high school was across town from mine but I’d always try to find a reason to go to her side of town to take the paper out in the afternoons so that I could be with her. Finally, one of the other guys in the RCYB said something about me acting like I was in love with her. They were all teasing me about it. I realized that I had had feelings for girls for a while and I started to come to terms with the fact that I was a lesbian. A family’s anger... When I came out, everyone at home was upset. I was prepared for their reactions, I’d heard other stories from teenagers who had come out about how they were rejected or kicked out of the house, so I was ready to face that from my family. My family was upset and angry. They were disap- pointed in me and wanted me to just “get over” what- ever young adult phase I was going through that made me “think” I was gay. I was so depressed that they couldn’t accept me, their daughter, for who I was. But knowing my family’s conservative background, I had expected them to have a negative reaction so it didn’t surprise me. ...then the rejection by comrades What really shocked me was how leaders in the RCYB and the RCP reacted when I told them I was gay. I have to say that none of the other Youth Brigade members had a problem with it except one guy. He was a little immature and made a joke about how he didn’t mind if a girl was gay but there’s no way in hell he’d sleep in the same room with a guy who was gay. (We’d just stayed at a motel when we traveled to another city for an event and all of us had shared a room). But re- ally most young communists of my generation never thought that being gay was wrong – it was something that had to be imposed on us from without, and was done without ever really hearing or respecting our insights. But while the comrades in the Youth Brigade were fine with it I was really shocked by how hostile the RCYB leaders were. I was immediately separated from the rest of brigade – they stopped having me there for meetings and paper discussions, I wasn’t invited to take out the paper or go running in the mornings, and when I showed up at the bookstore for an event I was told to leave. Being educated I didn’t understand the reaction. Finally, after several months of being excluded from everything and with virtually no communication from Youth Brigade leaders, I received a phone call telling me to show up for a meeting at a coffee shop across town the next weekend. Several Youth Brigade leaders were there as well as two RCP leaders (one of whom had never spoken to me before but was clearly in charge). Everyone was very serious. I was pretty intimidat- ed and scared. They were there to explain to me what reality was, and what a communist view supposedly was: Why be- ing a lesbian arose from unjustified hostilities toward men as a whole, how it was like being a feminist-sepa- ratist, and how in the new society, men wouldn’t hurt women and so women would no longer respond to their oppression by becoming gay. Their argument was that lesbianism was a form of reformism – because it sought relief from oppression by developing a lifestyle within capitalism. They made a series of deductive arguments – very divorced from reality and my own situation – that les- bianism was an ideological choice that embodied a re- formist political program and that was therefore not compatible with being a communist revolutionary. Let me remind you that all of this was happening to me when I was a high school student – just barely starting to sort out life, love and sexuality. Looking back it seems clearer they had reproduced within revolutionary ranks (and using “communist” rhetoric) prejudices, arguments and repressive practic- es that were not far removed from rightwing religious nuts and homophobes. I was very young and pretty naïve I guess – I took what I was told at face value as the communist verdict on gay people, and on me. But at a gut level I couldn’t reconcile the idea that my feelings for other girls meant that I was being bour- geois. I still was attracted to other girls, even when I berated myself for feeling that way. I was told that I was viewing the girl in the RCYB that I liked as a sex object, that I was objectifying her because I had sexual thoughts about her. In one painful meeting (at a Burger King – I never wanted to eat there again after this!) I admitted tear- fully that, yes, I had imagined seeing her naked while masturbating. I felt really guilty. I was pushed into the closet as a price for being considered a revolutionary by those I respected. And this was doubly painful: I was forced to deny my own feelings in public self-criticism, and I was being trained to confront my continuing feelings as reactionary in the privacy of my own mind. Under watch Once I started being allowed back to Brigade ac- tivities I apologized to this girl for objectifying her; but she just laughed and gave me a hug and said not to worry about it. Local RCP leaders and the Youth Brigade coordi- nator kept me away from her though, and talked about sending me to live in a Brigade house in another city for the summer. That idea was dropped after I failed geometry and had to go to summer school, but for the next year or so, I was closely watched. However, I was spouting the party line, so I was “welcomed” back in the fold. But part of me wondered, what would happen if I didn’t accept what I had been told to believe. A few years later there was another change in the division of labor, I was sent to go work in another area with a new group of people. I had left high school and gotten my GED so I was anxious to start working full time and not having to depend on my family. When I was told to apply for a particular kind of job and live in a shared apartment with some other party folks, I complied. I didn’t really have any reason not to, even though I knew that living with people would be like being at the brigade house full-time; I would never be away from people who could scrutinize my actions and “tell on me” to my leadership. This whole time I had been repressing my feelings, trying to just pretend that they didn’t exist. My leadership brought up homosexuality during a paper discussion and I started defending a group of gay activists and one of their slogans. I was criticized by everyone but this time I didn’t back down, I kept on saying that I didn’t understand the RCP’s position on homosexuality. (Actually, I did understand, but I didn’t feel like I could say that I didn’t agree, it felt safer to just say I didn’t understand).

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Cyborg Writing – BFHR 7wk › 2AC -- K -- Capitalism › 2AC -- Alt

2 -- Futurism DA -- the alternative relies on a hetero-prophetic trajectory of progress that relapses into the universalizing institutional politics of cisheteronormativity – refuse the logic of programmatic future-making and instead turn inward to acts of micropolitical resistance.

Giffney 8 (Noreen Giffney, Proffessor at University College Dublin Ireland, “Queer Apocal(o)ptic/ism: The Death Drive and the Human,” Published in “Queering the Non/Human, 2008, pp 64)

Reproductive futurism imposes, according to Edelman, 'an ideological limit on political discourse as such, preserving in die process the absolute privilege of heteronormativity by rendering unthinkable, by casting outside the political domain, the possibility of a queer resistance to this organizing principle of communal relations' (2). Reproductive futurism absorbs all challenges and translates them into more of the same. It operates in a similar way to Monique Wittig's concept of the straight mind in that 'when thought of by the straight mind, homosexuality is nothing but heterosexuality' (1992,28). Reproductive futurism is a more specific term than heteronormativity in that it describes the process through which heterosexuality becomes heteronormative. Heteronormativity is thus a term to describe a conglomerate of effects while reproductive futurism signifies the process through which such effects are wrought. It is all-encompassing, operating at the level of ideology so that it sets limits on, not just what we think or do, but also on what and how we desire. Desire itself becomes reproductive futurism in its 'translation into a narrative', 'its teleological determination' through politics which 'conforms to the temporality of desire', 'the inevitable historicity of desire' (Edelman 2004, 9). Reproductive futurism is, what I call, 'heterocycloptic', bound up with the desiring gaze and the setting-out of a developmental trajectory of 'progress' moving endlessly towards a 'better' future, in the process imposing a panopticon ¬like self-surveillance: 'It's a machine in which everyone is caught, those who exercise power just as much as those over whom it is exercised' (Foucault 1980, 156). It is apocalyptic in the sense that desire itself becomes a trap, a disciplining device in which the norm becomes inextricable from the natural. This technology of power — a 'coercive universalization' (Edelman 2004, 11) operates at the level of fantasy and through the figure of the Child: 'the Child has come to embody for us the telos of the social order and come to be seen as the one for whom that order is held in perpetual trust' (11). In this, the Child becomes inextricably linked to the future and in turn to politics, and is thus reduced to a trope delimiting what will get to count as the future in advance. Reproductive futurism I believe exercises power contradictorily through a web, a net, a grid. It encourages, perhaps contradictorily, the proliferation of desires - a looking-out as opposed to a gazing-within - in the service of repressing any conscious self-awareness of the death drive. Reproductive futurism is therefore, what I term, 'hetero-prophetic' in that it tries to set out programmatically what will transpire in the future; a future 'endlessly postponed' (13), thus holding the present to ransom. If it is invested in eschatology, it is only as a veneer to discipline those into enslavement to its ideals.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Cyborg Writing – BFHR 7wk › 2AC -- K -- Capitalism › 2AC -- Alt

1 -- The aff solves it -- queer technological engagement infects the capitalist machine of commodification and consumerist desire and “collapses the grid” of neoliberalism

Blas 9 (Zach Blas is an artist and writer based in London. His work engages technology and politics and has been exhibited internationally at venues including IMA Brisbane; Museo Universitario Arte Contemporáneo, Mexico City; Whitechapel Gallery, London; and ZKM Center for Art and Media Karlsruhe. 2009, “GRID: Viral Contagions in Homosexuality and the Queer Aesthetics of Infection,” ; accessed 1/5/2022) ng

Queer Technologies proposes a queer grid. If the virus is life exploiting life, Queer Technologies’ formation of a grid calls for an exploitation of the queer self to manufacture difference, that is, to combat the dominant viral GRID of homosexuality, a queer grid must replicate and mutate the dominant never-being-thesameness to produce its own queer never-being-the sameness. Queer Technologies aligns with Alan Liu’s notion of “destructive creativity”—a creativity that goes “beyond the new picturesque of mutation and mixing to the ultimate form of such mutation and mixing: what may be called the new sublime of ‘destruction.’ [. . .] the critical inverse of the mainstream ideology of creative destruction [. . . a] viral aesthetics.”[14] This aesthetics becomes like a repetitive stream of disidentifications—disidentifying as queer cryptography, repetitively infecting the infections of mainstream ideology at the risk of obliterating one’s own “hygiene.” Queer Technologies locates the potential of such an aesthetic viral infection in queer affect. Queer affect as a type of cryptography--nonhygienic ways of being, living, experiencing-- generates a life-resistance that, in its contingencies, mutations, and infections with global capital, produces another queer, viral grid that is an “illegible and incalculable” artificial life to GRID, as it is always forming its life in relation/exploitation to this dominant GRID. A queer GRID is mapped through the potential of relationalities and affects generated in a Queer Technologies event, situated within the context of the encounter between the body in contact and the autonomy of the technological product. The affective encounter holds the potential to explode out into a queer collective force. To diagram this reveals the topological possibilities for queer world-making on and off GRID.: the queer grid is both visible and invisible. Queer Technologies identifies these material practices as queer capitalism. If, in viral capitalism, the commodity is the virus, Queer Technologies produces and manufactures its own line of commodities as political products to infect the desiring-product logic of GRID that constitutes the biosocialities of homosexuality. Queer Technologies refers to its products as gay bombs. Appropriating the mid-90s US Air Force proposal for the development of a biochemical weapon that would turn combatants of war gay, gay bombs, as queer political products circulating in GRID, explodes and infects GRID’s viral logic. Simply put, the circulation of Queer Technologies must exploit capital. Queer Technologies executes this through a variety of tactics: shop dropping, barcode manipulation, price based on cultural institute of dissemination, e-business scams, free giveaways at rallies, and fake tech support centers. Queer Technologies has commenced developing sets of maps and battle plans that are referred to as GRID. Queer Technologies uses the same name for its own queer grids as well as the dominant GRID to virally bind them linguistically and etymologically, in that Gay-Related Immune Deficiencty (G.R.I.D.) is always left as a trace (an infection) within the term “grid.” As Queer Technologies circulates within various cities and geographical areas, at sites such as Target, Best Buy, Circuit City, RadioShack, Wal-Mart, Borders, Barnes & Noble, Apple, and other places of technological consumption, Queer Technologies diagrams and situates these products--gay bombs--within a grided structure. These queer grids, once mapped out, are distributed all over the areas they correlate to: on billboards, sidewalks, signposts, websites, store fronts, etc. Akin to a Situationist dérive, these queer grids attempt to restructure the replications of homosexuality virally produced by GRID. Queer Technologies’ grid project fashions a new topology: these circulated diagrams and situated products in various consumer outlets work toward producing another type of virality that emerges from the fusion of map and territory--viral in that it uses the same logic of viral capitalism: the queer grid allows itself to constantly change and mutate with the dominant GRID to continuously infect capital; it is its own mutation engine that produces queer never-being-the-sameness. The queer grid will crash, succeed, re-chart, change always, replicate always. Its value lies within the fact that each node in the topology--as a gay bomb- -has the potential to explode into a queer relationality, encrypted by another grid, that can generate a whole new set of infections against GRID. Queer Technologies, through all its various tactics--broadly defined as viral aesthetics, infects GRID with another grid. Perhaps these escapings from GRID are momentary, fleeting, but they continue undoubtedly. Escaping the face, the representation, the image, the formation that infects the biosocialities of homosexuality generates the potential for a new viral logic of new queer biosocial formations, a new monstrosity of the homosexual flesh. Queer Technologies calls this flesh theSoftQueerBody—a social, artificial flesh, a materialism of everything, infected as queer.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Cyborg Writing – BFHR 7wk › 2AC -- K -- Capitalism › 2AC -- Perm

3 -- [EXTRA] Marxism should be theorized alongside queer theory

Liu 20 (Petrus Liu is Associate Professor of Humanities at Yale-NUS College and the author of Stateless Subjects: Chinese Martial Arts Literature and Postcolonial History. DECEMBER 01 2020, Social Text (2020) 38 (4 (145)): 25–47. ; accessed 1/7/2022) ng

Queer theory, even as elaborated by authors closely identified as arguing in favor of a radical linguistic constructivism, turns out to be a materialist theory of social structuration with affinities to Marxism. Queer theory does not argue that identity is fluid, mobile, definitionless, or freely chosen; rather, it shows that identity is produced by constraints, social norms, and other specters of the material beyond one’s knowledge and agency. Insofar as both queer theory and Marxism emphasize such primary ties to unknown Others as a source of human vulnerability as well as sociality, both are committed to a materialism even when the material remains unnamed, unidentified, or reduced to a spectral presence. The point of material analysis is not to reassert the priority of the economic but to show that questions of gender and sexuality are part of a matrix of social interdependence that connects the self to others beyond borders—geopolitical, ethnolinguistic, religious, or otherwise. These others may speak different languages, inhabit any kind of socioeconomic organization, and subscribe to a variety of cultural beliefs and customs. Hence, there is no reason to assume that a material analysis must begin with American capitalism, free wage labor, or class relations. Instead, a genuinely materialist analysis must look beyond the borders of the nation and provincialize US queer theory and Marxism as mere participants in a global conversation. While both queer theory and Marxism have largely relied on philosophical notions of ethical alterity to argue this point, philosophy can get us only so far. It is imperative for us as a field to move past philosophical questions of the Other in Kant, Hegel, or Levinas and begin seriously engaging the scholarship produced by the “actually existing others.” The kind of work that we read, produce, recognize, and disseminate as queer theory is all but one variant of a global discourse—there are many queer theories in the world that are generating valuable insights from different archives and social formations. Rather than asking whether queer theory is translatable or applicable to non-Western societies, we need to learn from their academic work and participate in international and translingual conversations. This move is logically demanded by the question of the material. My analysis of the material in queer theory and Marxism aims to show that the reduction of Marxism to an economic doctrine and the subsequent characterization of queer theory as its culturalist corrective reflect the provincialism of US multiculturalist politics. In the United States, the liberal-pluralist paradigm continues to be the primary language for progressive social policies, which has produced a deeply entrenched impression that the primary obstacle facing queer people is discrimination, mis- recognition, or other forms of mental judgment that impede parity in participation. Seeing the LGBTQIA+ “issue” as a battle against discriminatory attitudes and patterns of evaluation, critics believe that the proper remedy is the promotion of “diversity and inclusion” in the workplace or education. What the language of diversity and inclusion leaves out, of course, is the critique and analysis of the historical processes that authorized certain individuals to decide whom to include, tolerate, and accept in the first place. The implicit message to queer and other oppressed people is that, instead of questioning and demanding fundamental changes in the existing relations of power, they can rely on the good will of enlightened individuals in positions of power to bring about social change. The liberal-pluralist language of diversity and inclusion presents a reformist strategy to assimilate the disenfranchised into the national polity in accordance with mainstream views, instead of a transformative strategy that reconfigures relationships of power and expands the field of gender possibilities. A materialist methodology is a timely response at this critical juncture to counter the liberal-pluralist ideology that gender and sexual minorities only suffer from prejudices or invisibility. With materialist theories like Marxism and a rehabilitated queer theory, we can move past the fantasy that formal legal equality is all we need to eliminate oppression around the world. Though queer theory is haunted by the material, it has also necessitated a rethinking of the material.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Cyborg Writing – BFHR 7wk › 2AC -- K -- Capitalism › 2AC -- Perm

2 -- Queer Marxism DA – queer engagement with Marxist utopian imaginaries grounds their movement in embodied queer/trans histories that foreground capitalist accumulation, exploitation, and alienation – class analysis is inseparable from the reproduction of social identity.

Raha ’19 -- (Raha, Natalia, 9-2-2019, "Queer capital: Marxism in queer theory and post-1950 poetics,” Sussex Research Online, https://sro.sussex.ac.uk/id/eprint/86259/, accessed 7-23-2022) -- nikki

Queer theory engaging with Marxism has reinvigorated key Marxist concepts by grounding theories of sexuality and queer and trans histories, cultures and texts into histories and readings of capitalist social transformation and accumulation. This includes the Marxist concepts of the commodity, value, labour, the gendered and racial division of labour, totality, reification, surplus population, primitive accumulation, racial capitalism, crisis, history and capital. These concepts have been engaged with to varying degrees of detail and Marxist orthodoxy, by drawing from different eras in Marx’s (and Marxist) thought – at times from the optimistic Young Marx of the 1844 Philosophic and Economic Manuscripts (1959), from the revolutionary Marx and Engels of The German Ideology and The Communist Manifesto, from the Marx of Capital. Queer Marxists also draw strongly from twentieth century Marxist figures such as Georg Lukaçs, Walter Benjamin, Ernst Bloch and C.L.R. James. As I detail in Chapter 1, Gayatri Spivak’s reading of Marx’s labour theory of value (1988) has a profound influence on queer Marxism’s conception of value. Furthermore, while often not directly cited, the strong influence of Louis Althusser’s critique of ideology (1971) is evident in some contributions (Ferguson 2004, Liu 2015). The aforementioned Marxist concepts have been studied and applied to deepen important current subjects within queer theory, including the history of sexuality, utopia (of course also a subject of Marxism), affect, queer of colour critique and race, embodiment, gender, activism, and the political economy of sexuality more broadly. For instance, the influential work of Floyd (2009) and Hennessy (2000) connects the transformations of discourses of sexuality (of sexology and psychoanalysis) in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century with developments in capitalist production and consumption. Hennessy and Floyd deploy Georg Lukács’ theory of reification (1971), a touchstone for the development of Western Marxism in the interwar period, to theorise the reification of sexual subjectivity and sexual desire (I discuss this work at length in Chapter 1). The variation in Marxist orthodoxy has had a positive influence on the development of queer Marxism within queer theory, allowing for heterogeneity in critical and theoretical approaches in the uptake of Marxist concepts. Indeed, as Floyd writes, queer Marxism pushes Marxism “to speak to certain dimensions in social and historical reality powerfully illuminated in queer theory’s relatively brief history, dimensions that Marxism has little history of acknowledging, much less examining” (2009: 2, 4). The endeavour to challenge he epistemological limits of Marxism has been particularly fruitful in the development and uptake of queer of colour critique as a mode of analysis, as I discuss below. However, queer Marxisms have at times foregone structural critique that connects queer life and culture to political economy and the critique of capital. In addition, the muted engagement between queer Marxisms themselves seems to have had an adverse effect on the theoretical consistency of, and collaboration within, the discipline. For instance, addressing early work by Floyd (1996), Hennessy highlights the lack of “studies that examine the historical relationship between the formation of new sexual identities and the reifying cultural logic of an emergent commodity culture” (2000: 97). This is the key thesis of Floyd’s The Reification of Desire (2009), which undertakes a detailed queer reading of Lukács as I detail in Chapter 1. However, Floyd’s text only minimally attends to the important queer Marxist work of Hennessy (2000), Joseph (2002), Tinkcom (2002) and Ferguson (2004).16 Such a lack of engagement with other queer Marxist texts has undoubtedly affected the development of the field within queer theory. An example of the theoretical heterogeneity of queer Marxism is found in the roundtable discussion ‘Queer studies, materialism, and crisis’ in the GLQ special issue (Crosby et al. 2012). The discussion pays particular attention to queer Marxism’s “orientation to political-economic questions” (127), utopia and totality, racial capitalism and capital’s need to make certain bodies disposable in its pursuit of accumulation. The discussion brings together prominent contributors to queer Marxism and queer theorists addressing class and queer liberalism. Floyd explicitly historicises the uptake of certain concepts in queer theory, such as utopia in the work of Muñoz (2009) and Edelman (2004), as “symptomatic of a moment in which capital’s colonization of the future appears both unassailable, as a familiar neoliberal narrative would have it [… and] transparently violent in a way that may suggest the opposite: accumulation’s radical fragility” (Crosby et al. 2012: 128). On this point, he emphasises that Marxism and queer studies arrive at the same conclusions. Furthermore, building upon his reconsideration of totality in The Reification of Desire, Floyd asks “Can one ‘re-pos[e] the question of totality’ without implicating oneself in an imperial, American universalism?”, and while gesturing towards Marx’s value-form highlights the “problem of grasping the ways in which capitalism’s gendered, racialized and sexualized violence is inseparable from … capitalism’s simultaneous identity and nonidentity with itself” (138, emphasis added). Two contributors strongly emphasise the relationship between capitalism, racialization and queer studies’ address of marginalised figures and groups. Lisa Rofel emphasises the importance of a queer hermeneutics for understanding capitalism’s drive for universality across “Euro-American metropoles” which is “undone by the ‘difference’” of the history of the “postcolonies”, and for understanding the relation between the value form, bodies and the value of marginalised lives (129). On the subject of racial capitalism, Fred Moten emphasises, citing Cedric Robinson (1983), the centrality of “racism not as capitalism’s instrument but as its conditions of possibility”, alongside the role of “regulative desire” in the pursuit of capitalist accumulation (130). Robert McRuer emphasises queer theory’s interest in “provid[ing] some account of capitalist modernity, neoliberalism, or globalization” must necessarily address “the invalidated and unthinkable”, crip “figures that are sick, infected, deranged, addicted, scarred, wounded, or traumatized” (131). He notes that queer Marxism must remain invested in crip and Mad bodies and lives (as I consider in Chapter 4). Dean Spade’s contributions describe the pain of the NGO-industrial-complex’s “eclipse” of grassroots LGBT activism, which has transformed queer politics into “a site for building white power” (135) through carceral regimes and non-redistributive equality politics, and highlights the importance of a critical trans politics that cognises “the material conditions of existence and the distribution of life chances” (143). In contrast to these approaches that connect the structural forces of capitalism globally to contemporary narratives of development, the transformation of queer politics by capital, and the situation of marginal queer lives within these contexts, Heather Love details her interest in working-class queer writing, sometimes by writers of colour, which “focuses on the lived experience of structural inequality” (131). For Love, this work however decentres its focus on capital and “can seem to lack a revolutionary horizon” (131). She emphasises that “this refusal of the choice between revolution and capitulation is what makes this tradition queer”. 17 Love’s pessimism seems to miss the potential of reading or theorising such lived experience into materials and ammunition of queer Marxism.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Cyborg Writing – BFHR 7wk › 2AC -- K -- Capitalism › 2AC -- Perm

1 -- Relational deconstruction DA – the perm solves best – including methodologies of queer social deconstruction enables a reenvisioning of class struggle through the lens of capitalism as a subjective construction rather than a preexisting formation and reshapes collectivity through the embrace of difference – prerequisite to effective resistance.

Green ’06 -- Doctoral Student in Sociology at the University of British Columbia (Brian Green, 09-05-2006, “The currency of queer theory for class analysis: remarx on subjectivities, class struggle, and subversion,” Rethinking Marxism: A Journal of Economics, Culture & Society, 14:4, 139-144, accessed 7-23-2022) -- nikki

In the last decade, a powerful voice has emerged in social theory from its origins in cultural studies and discourse analysis. Loosely gathered under the label queer theory, this body of work has introduced substantial challenges not only to the heteronormativity of most social theory but also to the ways feminism, gay and lesbian studies, and analyses of inequality in general, have implicitly reproduced essentialist notions of identity and consciousness, thus constructed limits to their own subversive potential. Queer theory is less a homogeneous, coherent school of thought than a dialogue across disciplines that seeks to multiply the questions asked by social analysis. Emerging from more general trends toward deconstruction associated with poststructuralist thought, it takes as its starting point the social construction of apparently fixed identities, the reliance of such identities on presumed binary oppositions of difference which inhere in them, and the always unstable, always partial hegemonies of ‘the normal’ in real human life. In Seidman’s words “identities are always multiple or at best composites, with an infinite number of ways in which “identity components” . . . can intersect or combine. Any specific identity construction, moreover, is arbitrary, unstable, and exclusionary” (Seidman 1994, 173). Not only do constructions of identity always entail constructions of their opposite but, because those opposites are ideal-typical poles, they also produce unintended gaps on the continuum between them. And it is not so much in the recognition or affirmation of the ‘Other’ as here, on the multiple and shifting terrain between identities (i.e., the in-betweens of gender, race, and sexuality), that the potential lies for subverting essentialism altogether (Butler 1990; Seidman 1994, 173). This, then, is also where the importance of queer theory lies—not so much in the particulars of its diverse analyses of discourse, culture, theory, or law, but in its insistence upon the subversion of apparently dichotomous relationships rather than simply their inversion or recognition (Namaste 1994, 230). Such an analytic focus has significant implications for our understanding of, and political engagement with, relations of domination and resistance, including class relations. In fact, I would suggest that queer theory does for our understanding of identity struggle what Marx did for our understanding of economic struggle— historicizing its assumptions, identifying its subversions, articulating its alwaysalready existing potentials. And in doing these, it provides an opportunity to engage the relations of capital and class not as a set of immediately conquerable institutions but as a complex of ongoing relationships which is continually challenged, reconfigured and reinforced through the daily interactions of individuals and collectives (Namaste 1994, 224). How it does this, and the implications of that strategy for political class struggle, can be seen in the questions queer theory asks of more traditional approaches to gender inequality and heteronormativity, and the alternative political approaches those questions engender. Building on its roots in poststructuralism, queer theory interrogates not only the marginalized Others of social norms, but the dynamic and ever-shifting relationship between the poles; that is, rather than emphasizing the invisibility of women in patriarchy or of gays and lesbians in heteronormativity, the role those Others play is examined as always-already interior to the normal (Namaste 1994, 222). This is much more than a philosophical or discursive exercise, as too many Marxists are quick to assert—stressing the relational puts front and center the questions of interaction, of contestation, and of resistance. It implies that the binarisms upon which so much of identity is constructed cannot be preexisting, that neither pole in a dichotomy can be primary or natural, and that the formation, location, and interaction of such ‘opposites’ are the very substance of their continued reproduction. And if that is the case, resistance and alternatives become that much easier to locate as well, for three reasons: the recognition of identity as plural opens space for subversion, which can potentially include distinct and even apparently antagonistic groups; the emphasis on constructedness reveals that so-called normative identities (i.e., white, heterosexual, middle class) are no less unstable and partial than marginal ones, despite the significant privilege attached to them; and antagonism can never be rooted in immutable characteristics but must always and everywhere be located in existing relationships and the political strategies people employ to negotiate and renegotiate those relationships (Namaste 1994, 225). All this puts queer theory in marked contrast to more traditional approaches to social inequality, even those which sought radical political change. For example, previous theories of feminist and sexual liberation often tended to reproduce rather than subvert essentialism and binarism by opposing a unitary, victimized subject to a hegemonic norm, whether defined as male, heterosexual, or both. This can be seen in a wide range of politically motivated, even ‘revolutionary’ work, from radical feminism’s celebration of womanhood and privileging of lesbianism, and Dworkin and MacKinnon’s construction of an all-encompassing, inherently oppressive male sexuality, to Kristeva and Wittig’s searches for origins and even Wilkinson and Kitzinger’s arguments for political and identitarian unity in gay liberation struggles (Butler 1990; Bell 1994; Ingraham 1994, 213–5; Seidman 1994, 170; Wilkinson and Kitzinger 1994). In each case, patriarchy and heterosexuality remain constructed as universal and as intact; even where their naturally occurring status is called into question, they are seen as constructed upon real biological difference or imperative. Thus the hegemony of heterogender (Ingraham 1994, 204) is taken as a preexisting fact, rather than a recurrent tension, and the only possibilities for resistance are formal equality within existing parameters or inversion (but continued maintenance) of the hierarchy. By critiquing the tendency of much feminist and gay liberationist work to reproduce binarism, queer theory attempts to accomplish a rethinking akin to that brought about by postcolonial and black feminist thought in regard to assumed norms of whiteness—to promote a politically meaningful solidarity not on the basis of inherent sameness, but of constructed difference, not on the assumption of permanent, fixed identities but on fluid, partial, and contingent notions of selfhood and alliance which acknowledge multiple, intersecting relationships.1 Such a perspective may at first glance appear contradictory to the formation of political class solidarity in that it deemphasizes points of commonality, but on deeper examination, what appears is not a rejection of solidarity but a different conception of it. The point of commonality is not a universal sameness of oppression, not an unbesmirched essence buried beneath learned behavior, but the fact that we all share the experience of living with hierarchy-based identities, that we all experience only partial and unstable adjustment to identitarian regulations, albeit in different and even contradictory ways (see, for example, Wright 1997), and that all identities are at best incomplete, complex, and transitory. The resultant solidarity, then, is not one of a taken-for-granted unity or a presumed shared utopia, but rather a strategic solidarity which sees the sexual/ gender/race/class landscape itself, rather than any one, identifiable position on that landscape, as the common enemy. This, in turn, opens space for a plurality of resistances which can be seen not as competing but as mutually supporting, and provides for the possibility of alliance across sectoral divides. All this presupposes a very different approach to political struggle than we have been accustomed to. The broadly defined Left—be it feminist, Marxist, gay libera tionist, or nationalist—has tended to ground its political strategies and end goals in terms of an easily identifiable opponent: the class war rages between capitalists and workers; the feminist struggle between men and women; the sexual liberation struggle between straights and gays and lesbians; the antiracist struggle between racists and nonracists, as though real human relationships ever correspond neatly to such idealtypical poles. And while such oppositional organizing offered a means of establishing political community and articulating the value of alternative knowledges and alternative ways of living, in each case what was taken for the enemy was an embodied product of the system rather than the relational system itself.2 That is, the relation capital produces capitalists and workers, as though these were ahistoric, unchanging and easily identified categories; the gender system produces men and women, as though individuals were a necessarily wholly or permanently one or the other; the racialization process produces whites and blacks, as though these were somehow natural and timeless categories, rather than shorthand for a vast and ever growing range of miscegenations and racial and cultural identities. In each case, however, these presumed dichotomies are, in real human relationships, only-ever partial, can only be defined contextually, and are subject to constant redefinition. What needs to be analyzed and targeted politically, then, is not the individuals associated with various positions within such relational systems, but the systems themselves. Individuals are socially located not due to any essential characteristic which inheres to them, but due to their positioning within relationships and their roles in either reinforcing or subverting relations of domination. Rather than a retreat from conflict, then, the emphasis on relationships and systems helps to focus the object of struggle more clearly, to engage class, gender, heteronormativity, and racialization as processes of social reproduction rather than always-already existing states of being. What is more, it can accomplish these without either denying identity’s political relevance, as so many Marxists tend to do, or obscuring the play of structure, of material life, of laboring practices in seemingly ‘nonclass’ struggles, as is too often common in poststructuralist analyses. The emphasis on process and relationship is particularly well articulated by Judith Butler, for whom the starting point of analysis is a Nietzschean distinction between ‘doer’ and ‘deed’. This acknowledgement that identities and institutions are products of social interaction rather than preexisting states requires that we maintain an analytic and political focus on the ways that social relationships are produced and reproduced, on how they are constituted through their ongoing performance; “there need not be a ‘doer behind the deed’, but . . . the ‘doer’ is invariably constructed in and through the deed” (Butler 1990, 142). It is human action and interaction which is primary; thus, the political field is made more open to the subversion of normalcy and the multiplication of alternative potentials. Thus, while the political usefulness of Butler’s own work is limited by its focus on discursive production and individual interaction to the exclu sion of class struggles and laboring practices (Hennessy 1996, 225–8), her presentation of the problem has important implications for materialist, class-oriented analyses.3 Indeed, what are material institutions but the long-term and presumed-immutable outcomes of a previous relationships? What are ‘structural barriers’ but the concrete material implications of ‘doing’ or ‘performing’ social life according to culturally, politically, economically, militarily enforced rules of interaction? Thus it is here that we come to the concrete, political significance of queer theory for class struggles and for alternative ways of living: the queer theory approach provides an alternative set of questions which emphasize not only individuals in social relationships, but the production and reproduction of those relationships themselves, and the always existing gaps and breaks in social systems. When articulated with reference to concrete, material outcomes of relationships, queer theory emphasizes the production of alternative alliances and strategies which engage the reproduction of inequality as social process rather than as hegemonic entity, and provokes a political strategy in which liberation is not something ‘found’, but is achieved through ongoing processes of struggle, of solidarity in difference, and of relationship building. Queer theory, then, is not only or even primarily about understanding sexual diversity, but represents a significantly different approach to political analysis, and one which holds enormous potential for class analysts and class movements which seek an alternative to the legacy of Second and Third International Marxist-Leninist orthodoxies. It is an alternative way of thinking about social relationships which emphasizes process rather than product, subversive potential rather than end goal. Its implications for class analysis and political class struggle are to be found in the way it constructs domination and resistance as dynamic, as relational, as potential. Process and relationship become the central concerns not only of analysis, but of struggle as well, so that subversion is something to be uncovered and exploded, rather than implanted and left to fight a war of attrition for some always promised yet never attained state of bliss.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Cyborg Writing – BFHR 7wk › 2AC -- FW › 2AC -- FW -- AT: Predictable Limits

3 -- [EXTRA] The negative’s imposition of certainty is a technology of fascism that enables the exertion of interpersonal control as a proxy mechanism for dealing with the inherent unpredictability of the world – unpredictability is a radical delegitimation of state power.

Demir ’20 -- (Aylime Aslı Demir, 2020, “Unpredictable Activism in Times of Uncertainty,” Museum International, 72:3-4, 178-187, DOI: 10.1080/13500775.2020.1873515, accessed 7-23-2022) -- nikki

This article explores the political and artistic potential of ‘unpredictable’ forms of activism: ones specifically devised in response to attacks on the Turkish LGBTQI+ movement by right-wing populists within the AKP government led by President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, especially since 2015. Reflecting on the 2019 Conference in Marseilles at MUCEM—La Méditerranée du genre, de la résistance et des stratégies (The Mediterranean of Gender, Resistance and Strategies)—which spurred me to write the present article, it strikes me that at the time of that event, the world had not yet been tested with Covid-19. Although the growing spectre of the global climate crisis had already generated a significant sense of uncertainty and insecurity, we were still unfamiliar with the experience of our ‘safe’ realities and norms being swiftly swept away. We could not yet conceive of a reality in which we would not be able to hold the hand of our beloved at a funeral; or of the fact that our health insurance would not protect us amid hospitals full to capacity. Since the global pandemic swept the world, we have experienced the (co)dependency of our bodies with a sense of horror—representing, for the first time in modern history perhaps, such a globally reaching experience of radical uncertainty. Against all promises to the contrary, we are witnessing, in the time of Covid, how international bodies, states and institutions—no matter how ostensibly prepared they had been—cannot fulfil their responsibilities in protecting the public (or in certain cases prefer not to). At a moment when we are confronted with radical uncertainty, we are simultaneously facing the fact that we often have little choice but to act individually against collective risks. These individual actions include washing every surface or object you may touch with disinfectants, covering your face with masks even though public health authorities release contradictory and shifting statements around their protective capacities, or regretting your lack of good health insurance coverage and the precarious position it puts you in if you do get ill. From time to time, we become ‘good citizens’ who demand the harshest penalties for those who do not wear masks or disobey the rules of lockdown; or we establish a sense of personal ‘security’ by refusing access to our residential buildings for those who do not have the privileged position to stay at home, such as delivery people, service personnel and health workers—temporarily exerting a sense of control over our environment. In short, even for overprivileged individuals with excellent healthcare coverage, protected residences shielded from the outside world, and the ability to stay safe at home during a pandemic, all of us are confronted with radical unpredictability and incalculable risk in this age of Anthropocene. Moreover, with the challenges posed by neoliberalism—specifically the 2008 financial crisis and the Syrian War, which both sent reverberations around the world— right-wing populism has gained significant influence and political ground. As a way of doing politics, right-wing populism is noteworthy for its hybridity and adoption of uncertainty as a form of governing. It is hybrid because there is little consistency between the right-wing populist, charismatic leaders currently heading several countries around the globe—from Orbán to Bolsonaro and Trump—and the economic, political, judicial, scientific, philosophical, religious, moral and aesthetic ideologies and policies they represent and promote. For instance, while liberal values are adopted in some economic decisions, social rights might be accompanied by conservatism, pro-immigration policies by nationalism (and from time to time, even fascism). What is significant here is that while this ideological hybridity is not perceived as a negative trait by populist governments, which arguably thrive on inconsistency, it has an unpredictable power over citizens, because we do not know how such leaders will behave nor what they will do next. In The Anthropology of the State, Marc Abélès (2012) suggests that in order to legitimise political power under the law of reason, classical political philosophy differentiates between two conditions, natural and civic: On the one hand, there is a natural condition in which individuals are left to their own devices and this leads to an anarchical positioning. On the other hand, there is a civic condition emanating from the contract. In a literal sense, a political bond occurs only in the latter. Also, what conditions the existence and pérennité of the political bond is represented with its dual qualification in the forms of bringing together and empowerment. (p. 20) Thus, in order to remove the difficulties people face living in a lawless environment in which chaos dominates, the state will claim to bring fair, universal social solutions, which will determine the grounds of its legitimate power. Of course, this duality has been questioned in many instances and respects. For example, it can be said that the central objective of much research in political anthropology is to question this dichotomy established between the state and what supposedly existed prior to its formation. However, in the contemporary and neoliberal era, this duality has been blurred by the state itself, which instead opts for a mode of governing that fosters deep uncertainty. Even within the social sciences, the dualities generated by modern states, which are also legal entities, can be described in these terms: normal and abnormal, legal and illegal, permitted and unpermitted, public and private, etc. We witness how the lines between them change place arbitrarily, or become uncertain through government policy. Thus, when the distinction between what determines ‘normal’ and ‘outside of the norm’ suddenly become meaningless, not only are the laws of science that indicate the norm—which we can think of as something that repeats itself, or as rules—suspended, but so is the logic of law, on which states and governments are based. While the Enlightenment and its heritage has served as a common reference point for centuries, its notion of human rights is annihilated when the law itself is used as a tool for human rights violations.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Cyborg Writing – BFHR 7wk › 2AC -- FW › 2AC -- FW -- AT: Predictable Limits

1 -- The negative’s call to predictable activist strategies is a thinly veiled move to institutional cooption – unpredictable modes of symbiotic relationality are key to effective strategies of queer resistance.

Demir ’20 -- (Aylime Aslı Demir, 2020, “Unpredictable Activism in Times of Uncertainty,” Museum International, 72:3-4, 178-187, DOI: 10.1080/13500775.2020.1873515, accessed 7-23-2022) -- nikki

Following an attempted military coup in Turkey on 15 July, 2016, a country that was already being governed under a state of emergency witnessed, through decree laws, the closure of pro-democratic NGO publications, detentions, arrests, and the narrowing of permitted public spaces. Thousands of academics and tens of thousands of public employees were dismissed, while hundreds of association-based publications were shut down. The members of the association Academics for Peace were fired from their positions without first being prosecuted, and the presumption of their innocence was ignored. Meanwhile, courses and theses on critical theory, feminism, gender, LGBTQI+ and queer studies were suddenly removed from university syllabi. Most academic research on gender, LGBTQI+ and queer studies was disrupted, and with the dismissal of academics who served as a bridge between academy and activism, social movements’ sphere of influence shrank even more. After all these losses, it can be said that social opposition constituents were subjected to a collective trauma. Hundreds of people lost their lives, and thousands of opponents, journalists, human rights activists were denied their freedom, detained and arrested. Moreover, the ability to imagine a future democratic life was shattered. Ultimately, LGBTQI+ activities were indefinitely banned in Turkey in November 2017 so as to include the whole of Ankara and the Istanbul Beyoğlu district—which are also the heart of LGBTQI+ activities, actions, and life. The governorship listed ‘social sensitivities and sensibilities’, ‘public security’, the ‘protection of public health and morality’ and the ‘protection of others’ rights and liberties’ as motivations for the ban on LGBTI+ activities. In announcing its decision, the government released the following statements, republished in English on the Kaos GL website: We were informed through various social media and several printed and visual media organs that several movie, cinevision, theatre, panel, interview, exhibition etc. events including several social sensibilities and sensitivities will be organized in various locations of our city by various non-governmental organizations in the name LGBTT (Lesbian, gay, bisexual, transsexual, transvestite) and LGBTI (Lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, intersex). This situation was evaluated as that social media shares at stake may provoke one section of public with different social class, race, religion, sect and regional features to show hatred and animosity in the disadvantage of other section, therefore clear and imminent danger towards public safety may arise; also, considering that this may jeopardize public order, prevention of crime, protection of public health and morality, and protection of rights and liberties of others; as a result of several social sensibilities there may occur provocations and reactions by several sections towards groups and individuals who want to attend intended event. (Kaos GL 2017b) Just as Kaos GL Association had organised the Future Queer exhibition in order to launch a new public platform and space—one designed to create breathing room following the 2015 bombings—the organisation decided to stage innovative performance and unpredictable tactics in 2016, following the military coup attempt and after an ISIS plot to target the Kaos GL association’s offices was revealed. These new tactics had to be unpredictable, because the government was already aware of almost every tool of traditional activism. It had assimilated these tools and emptied all of the concepts that were meaningful for activists’ struggle. For instance, cases that were opened against those who encouraged attacks against LGBTQI+ people were dismissed by concluding that the perpetrators had exercised their right to freedom of speech, and that the state was obliged to protect the people’s right to freedom of speech, lest the police would be asked to respond to every call in which the word LGBTI was pronounced. Between 2017 and 2018, Kaos GL organised its second contemporary art exhibition, entitled Colony4 within the borders of the Fatih Municipality, in Sultan Ahmet Square. They chose it precisely because it is situated within one of the most conservative regions of Istanbul, and since there was no ban on LGBTQI+ events in the area. Without specifically naming the organiser or using terms such as ‘LGBTI’ in literature and without making any announcements in Kaos GL publications, Colony spread through word-of-mouth and earto-ear as much as silently, developing into a space of 4,000 square meters and an event that included some thousand voices (Fig. 4). In the age of the Anthropocene, in which humans themselves have been revealed as a geological force, and amid a climate of terrible uncertainty and fear which is created by unmanned air vehicles and suicide bombers, Colony set out to explore the possibilities of symbiosis, associations and interspecies relationships between humans and non-humans— even if the desire of bio-genetic studies is to create the ‘perfect’ human. The exhibition bulletin reads as follows: Fostered by the globally immediate socio-political juncture, artistic production, and academic discourse, Colony brings the definition of ‘human’ into question. Engaging critically with the means of making knowledge, science, technology, and politics, the exhibition questions that which privileges the human species by attributing a prioritised conception of existence to mankind. Through the agency of intimating a body and bodybeings, Colony gathers together artistic inquiries that reconsider constructed dichotomies such as human/nonhuman, nature/culture, and organic/ synthetic. Across moralism(s) and between female-male morphologies fixed in procreation, Colony explores the constitutive ways in which nature’s sanctions of normativity operate. Interfaced with discussions around language and gender, the exhibition probes for contemporary (collective) bearings that evade self-constituted, human-centered narratives derived from the alliance of culture-historysociety-power. Through the scope of post-human and queer critique kinship, colony embodies a range of perspectives that discuss these critical narratives.’ (Colony exhibition bulletin 2017) In the Turkish landscape, institutional support for artists is rare. Accordingly, following this exhibition, Kaos GL founded the Ankara Queer Art Programme, considering processes of artistic production in order to expand the limited opportunities for organising exhibitions and make such initiatives sustainable. The International Guest Artist House provides residencies for artists to work and live in Ankara for two months at a time, and supports their research and artistic projects. Today, while international travel remains risky due to the pandemic, the programme is continuing to offer financial support to artists and manages its consulting work online. Doing uncertain politics Over the past few years, we have witnessed countries that invented globalisation begin to adopt antiglobalisation policies, as right-wing, populist and nationalist politics gained momentum. But the walls that states have built up in order to protect themselves from immigration or free trade do not protect them against the climate crisis or from terror. When bombs started to arbitrarily explode in the streets of Ankara, the city was shocked by the knowledge that the victims were completely random, and shaken by the thought that anyone might become the victim of a terror act anytime, anyplace. Those in the crowds who wore thicker clothes than the seasonal norms, or those who ran away were not protected from the bombs; similarly, individual measures taken against the unpredictability that Covid-19 has created do not confer total protection from the disease. The state of not knowing what will happen no matter what one does has a horrific tendency to pacify individuals, who are paralysed with worry. Since the government knows by heart the current tools and probable moves of the resistance, we need to devise different tactics and exit the current ‘cat and mouse’ game. To respond to a government who desires to monopolise the power of creating uncertainty through governing that uncertainty, queer activism might represent a way of doing uncertain politics: one that offers the quickest and most effective responses against oppression. For instance, when officials told LGBTQI+ activists ‘you can’t gather in Istanbul’, we transformed numerous streets into spaces of action, effectively saying ‘Well then, we will spread out across the city’. When they said ‘You cannot walk beyond the barricade’ in İzmir, we responded by running back from the barricade. When they said ‘You cannot gather to protest in the streets’ we transformed the sea into a space of action and activism by taking a ferry. My sense is that we can find some inspiration in such a movement with regards to unpredictability. Traces of this form of activism can be observed in the work of one of the artists featured in the Colony exhibition (Abud Efendi Mansion, 2017-2018), Kerem Ozan Bayraktar. His video, entitled ‘Mimicry’, focuses on the ‘machineplant’ relationship (Fig. 5). The work, presenting footage from an orchid factory, reads the relationship between machines and plants as a symbiotic one. As in the biological evolutionary processes through which the cultivated orchids had been attracting bees in order to ensure their reproduction, within this contemporary factory setting, orchids ‘attract’ the machinery, namely the technological processes designed by human beings. This type of relationality negates the common assumption that the species that can sustain their existence through the evolutionary process are the fittest ones; since the orchids most capable of adapting to and cooperating with other species are constantly evolving and adapting enhance their survival capabilities through enabling the machines that are integral to their life cycles. Of course, the history of social movements can give us an idea of who our possible future alliances will be. However, if we see the basis of activism as affirmation of life, these alliances can change with every new situation encountered, like an orchid’s relationship to a machine. Else, the organic and inorganic world, as well as the history of activism, can seduce the survival strategies expected from our identities.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Cyborg Writing – BFHR 7wk › 2AC -- FW › 2AC -- FW -- AT: Fairness

3 -- Epistemic disobedience is good -- refusal to conform to the rules of the game calls into question the assumptions that sustain the normalization of queerphobic violence within debate.

Mignolo ’09 -- (Walter D. Mignolo, 2009, “Epistemic Disobedience, Independent Thought and Decolonial Freedom,” Theory, Culture & Society 26.7-8 (2009): 159–181, , accessed 7-3-2022) -- nikki

The introduction of geo-historical and bio-graphical configurations in processes of knowing and understanding allows for a radical re-framing (e.g. de-colonization) of the original formal apparatus of enunciation.2 I have been supporting in the past those who maintain that it is not enough to change the content of the conversation, that it is of the essence to change the terms of the conversation. Changing the terms of the conversation implies going beyond disciplinary or interdisciplinary controversies and the conflict of interpretations. As far as controversies and interpretations remain within the same rules of the game (terms of the conversation), the control of knowledge is not called into question. And in order to call into question the modern/colonial foundation of the control of knowledge, it is necessary to focus on the knower rather than on the known. It means to go to the very assumptions that sustain locus enunciations. In what follows I revisit the formal apparatus of enunciation from the perspective of geo- and bio-graphic politics of knowledge. My revisiting is epistemic rather than linguistic, although focusing on the enunciation is unavoidable if we aim at changing the terms and not only the content of the conversation. The basic assumption is that the knower is always implicated, geo- and body-politically, in the known, although modern epistemology (e.g. the hubris of the zero point) managed to conceal both and created the figure of the detached observer, a neutral seeker of truth and objectivity who at the same time controls the disciplinary rules and puts [themself] in a privileged position to evaluate and dictate. The argument is structured as follows. Sections I and II lay out the ground for the politics of knowledge geo-historically and bio-graphically, contesting the hegemony of zero point epistemology. In Section III, I explore three cases in which geo- and body-politics of knowledge comes forcefully to the fore: one from Africa, one from India and the third from New Zealand. These three cases are complemented by a fourth from Latin America: my argument is here. It is not the report of a detached observer but the intervention of a de-colonial project that ‘comes’ from South America, the Caribbean 4 Theory, Culture & Society 26(7–8) and Latinidad in the US. Understanding the argument implies that the reader will shift its geography of reasoning and of evaluating arguments. In Section IV, I come back to geo- and body-politics of knowledge and their epistemic, ethical and political consequences. In Section V, I attempt to pull the strings together and weave my argument with the three cases explored, hoping that what I say will not be taken as the report of a detached observed but as the intervention of a de-colonial thinker. In semiotics, a basic distinction has been made (Emile Benveniste) between the enunciation and the enunciated. The distinction was necessary, for Benveniste, to ground the floating sign central to Ferdinand de Saussure’s semiology and its development in French structuralism. Benveniste turned to the enunciation and, by doing so, to the subject producing and manipulating signs, rather than the structure of the sign itself (the enunciated). With this distinction in mind, I would venture to say that the interrelated spheres of the colonial matrix of power (economy, authority, gender and sexuality, and knowledge/subjectivity) operate at the level of the enunciated while patriarchy and racism are grounded in the enunciation. Let’s explore it in more detail (Benveniste, 1970; Todorov, 1970).

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Cyborg Writing – BFHR 7wk › 2AC -- FW › 2AC -- FW -- C/I

Queer temporality produces space and time for queer lives, enabling us to think gender and sexuality differently

Shafer 17 [Alexander Phillip. Queering Bodies: Aliens, Cyborgs, and Spacemen in Mexican and Argentine Science Fiction. Diss. UC Riverside, 2017. //gc

Cyborgs are not the only figures in science fiction that get us to question heteronormativity and other regulatory means; aliens, and other posthuman figures also abstract notions of the self and Other, the importance of the body, and queer relationships, particularly through the homosocial bonds these figures form with humans and non-humans alike. In this dissertation, the major questions I will address are: How does science fiction provide spaces and temporalities that allow us to relate to and understand diverse queer subjectivities? How does Latin American science fiction use colonial narratives of space travel to make evident the connection between gender, race, sexuality, and coloniality? How does the construction of non-human and quasi-human subjects in science fiction represent the intersection of categories of race, class, and sexual orientation? In order to understand these question, it is necessary to understand the study of Latin American science fiction, my use of queer theory to approach these questions, as well as the study of race, gender, and sexuality in science fiction criticism in general. I rely heavily on queer theorists’ work on space and time, and their connection to science fiction. One way to understand queer lives is in terms of “sexual orientation.” Sara Ahmed explores the spatial component to orientation, as the word orientation implies direction, the creation of space, and the relationship of people and objects in that space (1). In phenomenology, it involves “intentional consciousness,” the direction of attention 5 towards certain objects and away from others (27). Queer phenomenology, an idea I will return to in Chapter 1, offers one lens to see queer space and time; it seeks to view the way the world is oriented to privilege certain groups and exclude others. Sexual orientation affects the way we inhabit and experience a world already set before us, and thus understanding queer space can offer a glimpse of how to configure the world to be more inclusive. By analyzing queer spaces, we think outside the normative spaces created for and by gender and sexuality. Halberstam seeks to modify “postmodern geographies” to account for queer spaces and temporalities: Queer work on sexuality has to respond to canonical work on postmodern geography by Edward Soja, Frederic Jameson, and David Harvey and others that has actively excluded sexuality as a category for analysis precisely because desire has been cast by neo-Marxists as part of a ludic body politics that obstructs the ‘real’ work of activism (6).1 Halberstam makes queer lives central to questions about the creation of social space and class. Halberstam asks us to think beyond epistemologies that exclude gender and sexual orientation. By looking at these spaces, Halberstam and Ahmed construct a discourse that includes queer lives in ways that are sometimes overlooked. Doing so illuminates the presence of subjectivities often ignored in hegemonic discourse, such as rural queers or queer people of color. Opening up the category of queer to be that which goes against the norm in more general terms, Ahmed specifically allows us to think outside of the given spaces for things. In terms of queer phenomenology, this means carving a space in 6 phenomenology for queer lives as well as queering the way we think about inhabiting spaces already set before us. In other words, the world privileges certain groups by creating patterns and social and physical spaces that are more easily inhabited by some than others. Another dimension to understand queer lives is in terms of time. Queer temporality creates not only space but time for queer lives. Halberstam explains that there are “queer” subjectivities, such as HIV positive subjects or even the unemployed if we use the term queer more broadly, that go against heterosexual logics of reproductive and family time (6). These lives exist outside the “normal” capitalist schema of marriage, children, labor, and longevity, and acquire value based on other temporalities. Thus, time and space can be analyzed from a queer perspective. Queer includes that which goes against the norm, but also the sexual orientations associated with the word queer. As an inclusive not simply one but the other, looking at queer subjectivities rather than simply identities allows us to view queer lives from a multifaceted perspective within restricting what does or does not constitute the category such as a term like gay. Analysis of science fiction texts goes hand in hand with an analysis of queer space and time. Science fiction texts help us to get a better view of the structures of power that are frequently invisible; by creating new worlds, new alien races, and alternate histories, the familiar is rendered unfamiliar, and the unfamiliar becomes familiar. Darko Suvin theorizes that there is a relation between the world of the reader and the science fictional setting that is “estranged” to the reader in a process he calls “cognitive estrangement” (12). Borrowing from Bertolt Brecht’s examination of vanguard theatre, the idea is that 7 science fiction estranges the familiar world of the reader through a far-off time or place (or differing future or past). Science fiction, rather than estranging the world of the reader to the point of non-recognition, like surrealism, relies on tools of cognition to understand the unfamiliar. This frequently requires the reader to engage with scientific principles that render the story possible to the mind of the reader. 2 Science fiction then, through means of cognitive estrangement, forces us to reckon with the norms of society, such as gender, race, social hierarchies, and economic inequalities. Science fiction allows us to consider the reconstruction of gender as something one does rather than something one has; Like the ideas articulated by Ahmed and Halberstam, science fictional time and space is often queer time and space; alien bodies abstract notions of gender to the reader. The fictional space of science fiction allows writers to test the limits of the body and particularly gender.3 Judith Butler asks us in Undoing Gender to imagine a world beyond a gender binary: "fantasy is essential to an experience of one’s own body or that of another, as gendered” (15). Thus, gender itself is created in space and time, and in the imagination as much as being something one performs or does. Science fiction is a privileged site for imaginary worlds and spaces, and can be for the reconceptualization of gender and sexuality as well.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Cyborg Writing – BFHR 7wk › 2AC -- FW › 2AC -- FW -- C/I

4 -- Linear Education DA -- Modern day education functions along linear logic – the construction and formation of subjects in certain ways after time. Our argument is that these forms of linearity are exactly what is used to create “docility” from queer subjects, forcing them into discreet indentitarian formations through the process of chrononormativity.

Kim ’17 Kim, Jainey Jung Yeon, "Picturing Queer Death: Alternative Instantiations of Temporality within Process Art." Thesis, Georgia State University, 2017. KZaidi

What, then, is Time? I know well enough what it is, provided that nobody asks me; but if I am asked what it is and try to explain, I am baffled.7

In his series of lectures titled “Birth of Biopolitics,” Foucault formulates the idea that the delimitation between state and society marks the turn from liberalism into neoliberalism. Neoliberalism, as Foucault defines it, is a political rationality that merges the social sphere with the economic sphere as a means to reduce state services and shift the language of responsibility and morality onto the individual subject body. Within neoliberalism, there is a shift in governmentality and social regulation “in the sense that subjects are increasingly conceived and conceive themselves as entrepreneurs of the self, who attempt to maximize their human capital.”8 As Thomas Lemke goes on to explain:

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Cyborg Writing – BFHR 7wk › 2AC -- FW › 2AC -- FW -- C/I

3 -- Academic Politicization DA – debate as a political discipline is defined by the process of delineation between valorized and antagonized modes of knowledge production – resist the call of the negative to act as the procedural enforcer of counterinsurgency and embrace a queer interpretation of the resolution that calls into question the pervasion of state politics and its production of dominant ideological narratives.

Smith and Lee ’14 -- (Nicola J. Smith, Donna Lee, 1-20-2014, "What's Queer about Political Science?," Volume: 17 issue: 1, page(s): 49-63S, AGE Journals, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1111/1467-856X.12037, accessed 7-23-2022) -- nikki

As Laura Shepherd (2012) notes: ‘The idea of a discipline (noun), in the academic sense, clearly derives from the verb: both relate to establishing clear boundaries between what is right and good (behaviour/research) and what is wrong and bad (behaviour/research); both have ways to correct transgression when an uninitiated (or resistant) person strays [original emphasis]’. We would like to take this further and argue that it is through the very process of disciplining (verb) that an academic ‘discipline’ (noun) such as political science comes into being. That is, it is precisely through the construction, maintenance and policing of carefully-demarcated boundaries that political science becomes constituted as a discipline: the centre is not separate from the margins but is constituted in and through them (Doty 1997). Important here, then, is how political science has come to be defined as a field of study and, in particular, how ‘politics’ is seen to be the natural preserve of the state. Many of our students have undertaken A-levels in ‘Government and Politics’ and a number of political science departments in the UK and internationally currently feature ‘Government and Politics’ in the title.9 And one of the first—and most central—questions most first-year undergraduate students are asked to address is whether or not politics and government are synonymous (with the tacit message that, no, they are not the same but, yes, they do nevertheless ‘naturally’ go together, hence why the question is posed). A key problem regarding queer theory here is that it has not, as yet, had a great deal to say about the state (although see for instance Duggan 1994; Bernstein and Reimann 2001; Brandzel 2005). But it also reflects how states and bodies are nevertheless imagined to reside in different realms: the state is often seen as synonymous with the ‘public’ sphere of politics—a world of government, power and collectivity—whereas the body is frequently imagined to reside in the ‘private’ sphere—a world of intimacy, selfhood and individuality. Yet feminist scholarship has long sought to highlight how this supposedly straightforward division between states and bodies is, in fact, deeply gendered. Indeed, a central project for feminist theory has precisely been to reveal how the state itself is often coded as masculine: that is, it is associated with the public realm of political power and decision-making and, as such, with masculine influence and identity (Youngs 2000a). The body, in contrast, is frequently coded as feminine in its multiple associations with nature, emotions, sexuality, vulnerability, reproduction and the family (Hooper 2000). In so doing, feminists have sought to expose and challenge the complex ways in which ‘body politics’ become invisible, denied and erased (for a detailed discussion see Jenkins 2005). Charlotte Hooper (2000, 39), for instance, has explored how rational masculinity is organised around a series of gendered dualisms (including public/private, mind/body, and inside/outside) that include a ‘fantasy of disembodiment’ which ‘depends upon the apparent invisibility or absence of bodies in social discourse, so that masculine reason could be separate from and untainted from the body’. As such, feminists have sought to reveal the ‘problem of the missing body’ in social and political discourse in order to expose and challenge how this very invisibility is steeped in, and (re)productive of, power relations (Youngs 2000b, 1). In this way, feminists have also sought to show how bodies and politics are intertwined, for the body is: ... a place for political mobilization interconnected with other sites of resistance and political action ... bodies are not external to political processes but firmly enmeshed in them, even if they are not necessarily the defining site for action. The lived experience of the body, the identity and definitions attached to bodies, inform and are connected to all political struggles (Harcourt 2009, 23).10 Queer Theory and Political Science One of the most crucially important contributions of feminist political analysis, then, has precisely been to gender the state (for a review see Kantola 2006) but also, more fundamentally, to show how the personal is political and, consequently, to shift the focus from politics-as-government to politics-as-power. This latter notion is, of course, shared by many political scientists—indeed, to quote one of the aforementioned textbooks, Hay’s (2002, 168) Political Analysis states: ‘power specifies the sphere of the political: power is to political analysis what the economy is to economics [original emphases]’. What is interesting, though, is that although political science has a great deal to say about power, so too does queer theory. Queer theory is, in fact, centrally concerned with the (re)production of power relations; power is, in short, what queer theory is about. Although there is no one approach to power in queer studies—rather, power represents a key site of contestation within queer theorising—queer scholars frequently ask questions about power that ‘seek to expose the limitations, unstable foundations and power-laden assumptions of the “straight” political, psychological, cultural and economic discourses that govern us’ (Griffin 2011, 50). At the same time, while queer theory has much to say about power as it relates to sexuality, it can also denote ‘any form of research positioned within conceptual frameworks that highlight the instability of taken-for-granted meanings and resulting power relations’ (Browne and Nash 2010, 4).11 It is not (just) sexual norms but rather norms per se that a great deal of queer theory seeks to expose and destabilise. As Butler writes: ... power pervades the very conceptual apparatus that seeks to negotiate its terms, including the subject position of the critic; and ... this implication of the terms of criticism in the field of power is not the advent of a nihilistic relativism incapable of furnishing norms, but, rather, the very precondition of a politically engaged critique. To establish a set of norms that are beyond power or force is itself a powerful and forceful conceptual practice that sublimates, disguises and extends its own power play through recourse to tropes of normative universality (Butler 1994, 6–7). Rather than being (only) interested in what truths are, then, queer theory (also) asks us to consider what ‘truths’ do—that is, it asks: ‘What gets to be constituted as “truth” and what are the material effects of this?’ So, for example, rather than asking a question such as ‘What does it mean to be “human”?’ (or, put differently, ‘What is the essence or truth of “the human”?’), queer theorists might ask a rather different question: ‘What gets to be constituted as “human”, and what doesn’t? Who gets to be included in “the human”, and who is left out? And what are the material effects of this, in terms of the ability of the “less-than-human” to live a fully liveable life?’ (for a detailed discussion see Butler 2001). An important purpose of social and political theory is thus to critique how specific appeals to ‘truth’ become presented as universal and timeless rather than as contingent and contestable and how this can in turn legitimise violence and disadvantage within and across particular political, economic and cultural contexts. Indeed, this is a further reason why queer theory is written out of political science— because it seeks to destabilise rather than to discover foundational truths, it is dismissed as therefore being apolitical (and even downright unethical—see for instance Martha Nussbaum’s outright condemnation of Butler’s work in Nussbaum (1999)). Yet, as we’ve noted above, queer theory is fundamentally concerned with questions of power and—far from rejecting ethical enquiry—instead aims to uncover and critique how particular moral orders become naturalised, necessitated and thus positioned as being beyond ethical scrutiny.12 Equally, what queer theory does is to encourage reflection on what it means for something to be ‘political’. What gets to be constituted as ‘political’ and what doesn’t? What gets to become an object of ‘politics’ in academic enquiry and, indeed, public deliberation more broadly? What gets to be studied, discussed, contested, written about, cited, lectured on, and what doesn’t? In short: what’s in and what’s out? More than this, queer theory also insists that what gets to be counted as ‘political’ is itself political—it is a product of the exercise of power, with real material effects. In this sense, queer theory seeks to politicise ‘the political’ itself.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Cyborg Writing – BFHR 7wk › 2AC -- FW › 2AC -- FW -- C/I

2 -- Erasure DA -- their interpretation naturalizes a pedagogy of normativity that invisibilizes the queer body as a site of violent political contestation – you should question the utility of the skills they produce – prioritize the transgressive educational practice of our model.

Neto ’16 -- Senior Lecturer in Portuguese in the Department of Latin American and Iberian Cultures. Ph.D. in Hispanic and Luso-Brazilian Literatures and Languages from the Graduate Center, CUNY. He teaches Portuguese language, and courses on Brazilian and Lusophone culture. His research focuses on queer theory, queer pedagogy, Brazilian culture and visual media. (João Nemi Neto, 3-16-2018, "Queer pedagogy: Approaches to inclusive teaching," Columbia University, NY, SAGE Journals, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/1478210317751273, accessed 7-23-2022) -- nikki

Queer pedagogy and questions of gender identity and sexual orientation For many American researchers and activists, the concept of queerness seeks to incorporate bodies that lost visibility during the gay movement of the 1960s and 1970s. From this perspective, the gay and lesbian movement was normalized as it adopted heteronormative practices (like marriage and the adoption of children) to gain public acceptance. The term ‘queer,’ then, attempts to recover individuals erased by this normalization, such as feminine boys, transsexual people, transgender people, and non-binary or gender non-conforming people among others. Briefly retracing a possible historiography of queer theory, by the beginning of 1970s, gay literary studies began to flourish in the American academic world. As the gay movement started to seek out and create its own culture and identity, it began to look not only to the past but also to the future. In the 1980s, U.S. political activism, still maintaining its attention to the past, adopted the word ‘queer’ as a driver of the movement, a word that up until then, had been considered the most commonly used homophobic term in the country. In other words, the political movement reincorporated a term, previously carrying a negative connotation, trying, in this way, to deconstruct its pejorative meaning. Taken up by the academy, queer theory seeks to denounce the heteronormativity that influences even the gay movement. That is, the gay movement is accepted only to the extent that it conforms to certain social values pre-established by society, rejecting those who do not follow that norm.2 Teresa de Lauretis (1991) states that the term ‘queer’ should function as something that causes discomfort, juxtaposed to the words lesbian and gay in the subtitle to mark a certain critical distance from the vocabulary used in the past. For De Lauretis, queer is the ‘non-canonical,’ polyphonic, transgressive, and problematic. Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick (2008) too affirms that the term constitutes a moment, a movement, a continuous motive. Queer pedagogy, based in these ideas of a queer theory against normalization, seeks to contribute to practices of education, analyzing the fluidity and the mobility of society and affirming that educational institutions should not attach themselves to one set model, since these ideals end up alienating, even excluding, certain individuals. For Britzman (1998), queer theory transgresses seemingly stable representations and, in this sense, queer pedagogy works to question situations of apparent normality in the classroom and concerns itself with the social production of what is learned. Queer pedagogy does not seek the ‘correct’ method or the ‘right’ questions, but rather the possibility to question our practices or notions of equality and acceptance. Just as queer theory sought to distance itself from the markers of gender associated with gay and lesbian studies, queer pedagogy offers everyone involved in academic spaces, whether they be heterosexual, homosexual, bisexual, asexual, etc., the possibility of understanding issues of sexuality from a new angle. As Louro (2001) explains: “(…) a queer pedagogy and curriculum ‘speak’ to everyone and aren’t only directed at those who recognize themselves in this subject position, that is, as queer subjects.”3 (p. 256). Queer pedagogy offers a critical view of the practices of exclusion that are naturalized in the classroom by a banal heteronormativity4 that makes all those who don’t fit into a certain standard invisible. As Britzman (1998) demonstrates, queer theory recognizes the exorbitant normality in effect and the ways in which that normality ignores queer pleasures, practices, and bodies. Neither does said pedagogy seek merely to trade one norm for another, to simply leave a heterosexist binary for a heterosexual–homosexual modality. A queer lens for pedagogical practice would mean observing the varied possibilities of expression of sexuality without the necessity of labels or fixed identities. The recognition of different forms of expression would broaden an individual’s perspective, without that person having to necessarily adopt one of these fixed identities, allowing them to acknowledge these identities or even recognize themselves in said identities. It becomes necessary, then, to question and challenge dominant models in schools today so that socially favored groups are not the only ones visible, including as well other bodies that are still oppressed by different spheres of society. Queer pedagogy can help us in two ways. First, by problematizing the very school structure, the normalization of teaching per se and of the fixed and exclusionary content that is presented. Using a queer lens would involve, for example, discussing why terms like gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender do not find space in school vocabulary and why when they do, it is only through insults that should be silenced. More than prohibiting that students or even teachers use these words as insults, it is important to have a discussion of such use. To be gay or transgender is part of the identity of an individual and as such, should be included in the day-to-day just as ethnicity, religion, and many other aspects should be.5 As Britzman (2012) explains, queer pedagogy aims at ‘something different than a plea for inclusion or merely adding marginalized voices to an overpopulated curriculum.’ (p. 297). It is not the normalization of the ‘different’ that queer pedagogy proposes, is to ‘recognize difference outside the imperatives of normalcy.’ (p. 304).

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Cyborg Writing – BFHR 7wk › 2AC---Case › 2AC -- AT: IR Good

Reject their disciplinary scholarship – the potentiality of international theory exists in the liminality of politics, in the possibilities opened by embracing queer instability and failure.

Barkin and Sjoberg 21 (J. Samuel Barkin, PhD, Professor, Department of Conflict Resolution, Human Security, and Global Governance and Program Director of Global Governance and Human Security MA and PhD Programs; McCormack Graduate School; Laura Sjoberg is British Academy Global Professor of Politics and International Relations at Royal Holloway University of London. February 10, 2021, “The Queer Art of Failed IR?” ; accessed 7/23/2022) ng

If IR’s state-of-the-field debates are alternatively narrativized fairy tales, we have a replacement. We suggest that the fairy tales’ idealized end can be found not in success but in failure; not in agreement but in controversy; not in aggrandized claims but in careful thought; not in stability but in liminality.15 It is hitching our wagon to a failure of a discipline and acknowledging that failure that constitutes and creates the possibility of a happily ever after for IR theory. We see the answers to many of these questions bound up in a disciplinary IR that has racist, sexist, heterosexist, and cissexist intellectual orientations and remains silent about them and often the assumptions that prop them up. But even work which decenters or critiques these exclusions in IR, in our view, is positioned compared to or in opposition to the discipline’s existing structure. Rather than being disappointed that IR theories are exclusive, cannot be reduced to a single theory, cannot account for global politics as a whole, and cannot present grand narratives of their competitive advantages visa-vis other approaches, we suggest highlighting and inhabiting these failures. Questioning the terms of disciplinary success as lying in a tightly choreographed dance (peer review in elite journals) or a popularity contest (citation count), or even in the “science” of knowledge cumulation, we ask why empty signifiers continue to dictate value in a wide variety of channels in IR. But we do not think redefining success will “solve” this “problem,” no matter how well-intended or radical the redefinition is. Note that we are not denying the existence or importance of significant transgressive work within IR, work that rejects grand narrativizing, or other explicit or implicit attempts to embrace failure. We are under the impression that authors critiqued here might actually agree with our critiques, either placing themselves within them or taking exception to them. We are not looking to signal virtue or to exclude, simply to suggest an explicit alternative approach. Instead of looking for an alternative, emphasizing some of the “good” transgressions, finding another way to succeed, or recasting success, we look to deconstruct IR’s logics of success and failure, and, with them, its mimicry of reified standards and its fantasies of knowledge cumulation. We see rewards in embracing IR theory’s failure to live up to IR theorists’ expectations of it. With Halberstam, “perhaps most obviously, failure … disturbs the supposedly clean boundaries between…winners and losers” (Halberstam, 2011, p. 3). Declaring, and embracing, knowledge cumulation failure (and thus, IR’s intellectual failure) “allows us to escape the punishing norms that discipline behavior” (Halberstam, 2011, p. 3). The relevant norms in IR are the fetishization of science, the fetishization of progression and progress, and the establishment and reification of boundaries of what ideas matter to the field. In embracing failure and escaping those punishing norms that are as violent in their inclusion (e.g., Haritaworn et al., 2014) as they are in their exclusion, “queer studies offer us one method for imagining, not some fantasy of an elsewhere, but existing alternatives to hegemonic systems” (Halberstam, 2011, p. 89). It “can be a potent form of critique,… a refusal of the norm, an indifference to assimilation, and a route to other ways of being in the world” (Halberstam, 2012). Here, the alternative to the hegemonic system of claims of knowledge cumulation is the queer, understood as both liminal and anti-heteronormative, as a foundation for theorizing more nuanced understandings of knowledge than success or failure at cumulation. If scholars find their affirmation in (hollow) confirmations of their claims to knowledge cumulation, a queer politics of failure suggests a different direction. As Halberstam recommends, “rather than resisting endings and limits, let us instead revel in… all of our own inevitable fantastic failures” (Halberstam, 2011, p. 187). Reveling in fantastic failures, in terms of a queer critique of the fantasy of progressive knowledge cumulation, has two elements: celebrating research as failure and confronting the future given that embrace. Queer theory suggests guidelines for embracing failure; “failing is something queers do well”—not (only) in the self-deprecating sense of laughing at (one’s own) flaws, but also in the more fruitful sense of exposing the ridiculousness of norms by failing to live up to them. In this sense, queer failure is “a map of the path not taken” (Weber, 2014a, 2014b). As such, “queerness offers the promise of failure as a way of life,…but it is up to us whether we choose to make good on that promise in a way that makes a detour around the usual markers of accomplishment and satisfaction” (Halberstam, 2011, loc 3281). “Failing” to meet expectations and being fine repudiates the salvation narrative that accompanies the “right” rules and norms and lifts the often terrible consequences of falling outside “the norm” while removing the privileges of “belonging” to the category of success. The exposure and analysis of queer failure denaturalizes the coherence of knowledge-production performances to show the vapidity inside. We see the replacement of “all-encompassing global theories” with those “subjugated knowledges” which have been “buried or masked in functional coherences or formal systemization” as a key first step but insufficient by itself (Halberstam, 2011). Turning IR’s “losers” into its “winners” would both serve social justice and unsettle the binary itself, but rejecting the categories writ large would both upset the politics of exclusion in those categories and discourage the win-seeking behavior that makes state-of-the-field debates. Celebrating failure instead “provides the opportunity to use [failure’s] negative effects to poke holes in the toxic positivity of contemporary life” where “the negative thinker can use the experience of failure to confront the gross inequalities of everyday life” (Halberstam, 2011, p. 3, 4). The “toxic positivity” in IR theorizing is the attachment to the utility of grand theory that cumulates knowledge which makes the inequalities in the discipline appear to be organized by some sense of objective quality, where “success happens to good people” and good research while failure happens to bad work or bad people (Halberstam, 2011, p. 3). Instead, we see those inequalities as structural and standards of success in IR as political. IR’s happily ever after, then, if it is to have one, must be in the failure, in the mess, and in rejecting both inherited interpretations of success and of the normative relationship between success and failure. It must be not only in not meeting expectations of any given state-of-the-discipline proselytizing but also in instead realizing that IR cannot and should not approximate those expectations. It is not a progressive discipline with a singular end or an exercise in progressive knowledge cumulation. It is instead necessarily undisciplined—it must put aside the straightjackets of research standards, the ego-stroking of aggrandized claims, and the authorial voice of the telling of the discipline’s past, present, and future—to embrace liminality and the necessity (and beauty) of failure. The irony of this argument is not lost on us. Halberstam, making the queer theory case for celebrating failure, has become a very successful academic by many of the traditional disciplinary standards, and The Queer Art of Failure is a successful academic text. Many of the critics and supporters cited here have built on academic success by their engagement with the argument. We are bringing the case to IR, publishing it in a academic journal, through the traditional mechanism of peer review, from the comfort of secure and permanent academic employment. We poke holes where those holes can be seen by those who would police the boundaries between winners and losers. This article does not “practice” as it “preaches,” to itself upend the “winners” and “losers” in disciplinary IR—it is couched in both necessary and unnecessary hypocrisy. But positionally at the very least, our celebration of failure is itself a failure—implicated in our interest in and disciplinary IR’s promotion of success. We are not arguing that failure can be made pure or that it should be—only that it cannot and should not be escaped, especially for the glorification of success as its perceived opposite. As we fail at failure to demonstrate the fantasy of success, we envision a happily ever after of failing, un-discipline, and diversity rather than a faux idealism of synthesis, aggrandizement, “science,” and disciplining.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Cyborg Writing – BFHR 7wk › 2AC---Case › 2AC -- AT: IR Good

The paradigm of IR relies on the valorization of traditional research as a metric of “success” – voting negative imbricates debate in the echo chamber of normative political theory that accumulates rigid forms of knowledge while reproducing the exclusion of queerness.

Barkin and Sjoberg 21 (J. Samuel Barkin, PhD, Professor, Department of Conflict Resolution, Human Security, and Global Governance and Program Director of Global Governance and Human Security MA and PhD Programs; McCormack Graduate School; Laura Sjoberg is British Academy Global Professor of Politics and International Relations at Royal Holloway University of London. February 10, 2021, “The Queer Art of Failed IR?” ; accessed 7/23/2022) ng

We argue that knowledge cumulation in IR is a fantasy reified by paradigmatic clusters and the mimicry of research standards and practices in the natural sciences (e.g., Elman & Elman, 2001, 2003). The “evidence” of “knowledge cumulation” in IR comes as much from the ritualized practice of research behavior as it does from any “true” or genuine notion of knowledge cumulation. One has “succeeded” in the enterprise of IR by cumulating knowledge, and the work of “successful” scholars is by definition cumulated knowledge. Cumulation of knowledge as a standard of success is a condition of possibility for the desirability of success in the field. That ritualized practice at once is institutionalized as success and institutionalizes the need for research success, reified and reproduced by hiring, tenure, merit raise, and promotion standards. This ritualization is a signifier that what counts as knowledge in the field, in particular research programs and more generally, is performative (Barad, 2007; Butler, 1990; Weber, 1998)—where standards are set by their utterance and repetition rather than by some external “objective” standards of (narrowly) good science or (more broadly) good research (Baudrillard, 1991; Shepherd, 2008; Williams, 2003). Scholars iterate and reify standards of measurement of knowledge in each piece of scholarship which “succeeds” in the field, and these iterations make it a paradox for scholars to both occupy the methodological, epistemological, and political space that falls outside of inherited standards and succeed. Outside -the -mainstream work’s underrepresentation in the places understood to be publishing “success” is overdetermined, and the correlation between mimicry of traditional scholarship and “success” of critical scholars a given. We mean “performative” in the sense that Judith Butler uses it (Butler, 1990, 1993), particularly as she talks about it going hand in hand with a Foucauldian notion of disciplining,8 where “performativity cannot be understood outside of a process of iterability—a regularized and constrained repetition of norms” which resonate as “ritualized production” (Butler, 1993, p. 60). This frames performativity as a “specific modality of power as discourse” (Butler, 1993, p. 139) where the politics of the signification and the politics of the sign meet, an act of territoralization, of production, of installation—which does not have to be alone, singular, or unidirectional. Since performatives are their own referent (Butler, 1993, p. 159), they proliferate as manifestations of the power underlying them and interact relatively on the basis of that relative power. In this context, “performances” are actions and events, iterations and reifications, and context-specific, which “bring a subject into being” relationally.9 To escape the recursive, performative loop of “disciplinary success,” we argue that it is important to see the possibility that knowledge cumulation is not, and should not be, a given in IR research. Instead, we argue that the idea itself is an inherited empty signifier with unspoken content which governs the production of what we understand as disciplinary IR. Traditionally, the idea of knowledge cumulation is firmly grounded in a neopositivist understanding of social science, in which the role of theory is to collate observed empirical regularities across cases or what Waltz calls laws (Waltz, 1979). While this interpretation is critiqued in most critical IR, “cumulation,” in that work, becomes a term without clear conceptual content. The paradigmatization of IR theorizing distracts from a particular theory’s internal conditions of possibility by introducing incompatible conditions of possibility drawn from an inherited disciplinary sociology of what knowledge is and how it works. As such, any acknowledgment of the idea of cumulativity from within specific exercises in reflexive IR creates the grounds for necessary failure within those exercises. The simultaneous rejection of traditional “cumulation” and continued performance of acts of cumulation can be understood by seeing the ways that silence frames cumulation in critical IR. We learn from feminist theorists that the unspoken is as important as if not more important than what is spoken (Charlesworth, 1999; Kronsell, 2006), coming from attention to how IR’s others are omitted, excluded, kept out, and not mentioned (Agathangelou & Ling, 2004; Tickner, 1988). We argue that IR’s silences tell us more about the state of knowledge cumulation in the discipline than looking for standards that tell us what we do know. Accordingly, we ask on principle what any given research program does not take account of and how accounting for those omissions could changes analysis. We focus on both visible omissions (like the concepts that a research program fails to incorporate) and invisible omissions. Invisible omissions are those that are unhearable by a research program— normally left out or ignored by both the researchers that form the core of the research program and their critics (Butler, 2001; Edkins et al., 2012; Hansen, 2000). By “unhearable,” we mean either that the omitted content falls outside of the boundaries set for dialog or is assumed by all stakeholders to be by definition irrelevant (for deeper analyses see MacKinnon, 2006; Spivak, 1988). Unlike its visible omissions—variables that its scholars and their critics have added to, re-operationalized, expanded on, or suggested the inclusion of—invisible omissions are often not treated as omissions at all within particular scholarly boundaries.10 The discipline’s “collective” standards for knowledge production, then, can be understood as constituted by social performances of dominance rather than founded on some given or objective notions of what science should be. Rather than being objective judgments of quality, statements like “this is good science” and “these results are robust” are signs without referents used to discipline (Baudrillard, 1995). The invisible disciplining nature of the performative standards of knowledge cumulation is part of the story of Butler’s understanding of performativity. The other part is attention to who is excluded by claims to knowledge cumulation (generally as well as in specific paradigmatic situations), what is left out, and on what axes. These disciplinary standards (both in the conventional and Foucauldian sense) make invisible their own impossibility and their related necessary failure. For example, a submission to a traditional IR journal in the United States or Western Europe which makes an interesting argument, but is not in the format of, methodologically acceptable to, inclusive of the same forms of evidence traditionally used in, and good science to that journal’s traditional reviewers is unlikely to succeed in getting published.11 This will generally be justified with reference to the “quality” of the piece, and rarely if ever will questions of sex, race, gender, class, and other axes of exclusion be discussed as producers of the standards that then exclude on “quality” where “quality” has been set up in a way that excludes all performances of scholarship which are not mimicry of a particular Western, liberal model (Paolini, 1999).12 Even editors and reviewers who note the exclusionary effect of these standards will often mourn that and move on, imagining the only possible alternative being lacking standards, and seeing such a lack of standards as more insidious than the exclusionary effects of using certain sets of standards. “Knowledge cumulation” then becomes a set of reified and artificial standards rather than a journey for truth or interest. The answer to this quagmire is sometimes a liberal politics of inclusion (e.g., Nedal & Nexon, 2018)—how do “we” get more women, more minorities, and more people from underrepresented places in the world to be able to meet the standards of good scholarship in the field? That liberal politics of inclusion, while well-intended, can be read as a (subtle, perhaps accidental) expansion of the violence it (formally) seems to abate. It fails to question the utility of the existing standards of good scholarship and assumes that those currently excluded would be happy to change the form, shape, and/ or nature of their scholarship to fit within the (unquestioned/unquestionable) mold of good scholarship, either loosely or strictly understood. As Puar (2006) argues, liberal “inclusion” to absorb the other within can be as violent as if not more so than exclusion even as it appears progressive. That violence is the reproduction of naturalized, bounded identities when identities are liminal and messy when not policed (e.g., Agathangelou, 2013; Haritaworn et al., 2013; Scott, 2013). The bounded nature of IR inclusion excludes liminality, messiness, and outsideness (e.g., Malksoo, 2012 ¨ ). Expanding the boundaries of IR to include any given particular excluded work maintains an illusion of stability, hiding what is unstable; it maintains an illusion of certainty, hiding what is in doubt; it maintains an illusion of coherence, hiding the rebellious, the failed, and that which remains outside (e.g., Sjoberg, 2017). Queer theorizing of the liminality involved in unstable sex/gender identities shows that even that which is presumed to be the most primordial (sex identity) is really liminality hiding under supposed definition (e.g., Weber, 2016a). Translated to thinking about inhabitability, this theorizing suggests that the apparent safety of (constituting then occupying) inhabitable space hides liminality and uncertainty, and perhaps danger, under its supposed (empirical and normative) clarity (Haritaworn et al., 2014). Therefore, “all the repressive and reductive strategies of power systems are already present in the internal logic of the sign,” such “that violence is an inevitable byproduct of signification” (Baudrillard, 1981). In this way, not only do traditional standards of knowledge make invisible their own impossibility, they hide the violence of IR’s denials of failure and continued insistence on traveling failed paths despite the condemnation of failure and the privileging of success. IR’s continued recursive enactment of its settled “standards” despite their obvious failure and exclusiveness makes invisible the raced, classed, and sexed impacts of those standards and their apparent objectivity. Baudrillard’s work provides a path for navigating this disjuncture between signs (IR’s “standards”) and referents (the fantastic notion that “good scholarship” exists objectively) (Baudrillard, 1975). He argues that “only ambivalence, as a rupture of value… sustains a challenge to the legibility, the false transparency of the sign… questions the evidence of the use value of the sign (rational decoding) and of its exchange value (the discourse of communication).” This ambivalence, Baudrillard argues, “brings the political economy of the sign to a standstill; it dissolves the respective definitions of symbol and referent” (Baudrillard, 1981, p. 150). Endorsing the inclusion of nontraditional perspectives, classifying and categorizing them, and assuming inclusion’s possibility may all have violent impacts (for discussions of the violences of inclusion see Haritaworn et al., 2013, 2014; Mbembe, 2019). Moving of the signification “knowledge” from any referent to which it was originally tied makes method and research performances of scholarship, rather than (the illusive) scholarship itself. If “research” is a performance of scholarship, “standards” for research serve to disguise the fantastic nature of knowledge cumulation. As such, there is no space for liminality, uncertainty, change, inadequacy, and failure in structural rather than passing senses. Yet looking beyond the discourse of certainty, those pervade IR. A Baudrillardian ambivalence toward research programs and their truth statements can reveal the recursivity of IR’s standards of knowledge cumulation. This is because condemnation or rejection of any given research program and its truth statements endorses its assumptions about truth, as well as some of its assumptions about what the international arena is and how it works. As such, the idea that IR knowledge cumulation can be nothing but fantasy is straightforward. If the reification of standards of knowledge cumulation is a signification divorced from a referent, where the recovery of the referent is conceptually and practically impossible, then knowledge cumulation is and will always remain an empty signifier. The only question is how that empty signifier directs and is directed. We suggest that, in IR, more often than not, knowledge cumulation directs and is directed by discursive seduction. In Baudrillard’s words, seduction is “that which extracts meaning from discourse and detracts it from its truth” (Baudrillard, 1991[1979], p. 54). What makes a discourse of knowledge, of science, and of progress seductive “is its very appearance: the aleatory, meaningless, or ritualistic and meticulous circulation of signs on the surface, its inflections and its nuances. All of this effaces the content value of meaning, and this is seductive” (Baudrillard, 1991[1979], p. 54). Therefore, if there could be an interpretive discourse of knowledge cumulation that reached truth value, that truth value would be selfdefeating, since “the meaning of an interpretive discourse, by contrast, has never seduced anyone.” This is the fundamental contradiction, in Baudrillard’s terms, that makes standards for knowledge cumulation in IR internally impossible. He explains that “every interpretive discourse wants to get beyond appearances; this is its illusion and fraud. But getting beyond appearances is appearance, and is hence subject to the stakes imposed by seduction, and consequently to its own failure as discourse” (Baudrillard, 1991[1979], p. 54). As such, what is left in/of the failed discourse can only be the fantastic, and pretensions to success hollow.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Cyborg Writing – BFHR 7wk › 2AC---Case › 2AC -- AT: IR Good

IR theory is an intrinsically failed politics – the methodological landscape of IR is a repetitive fantasy of discipline that seeks coherence through the imposition of totalizing rules-based theories – embracing the queer indeterminacy and incomprehensibility solves.

Barkin and Sjoberg 21 (J. Samuel Barkin, PhD, Professor, Department of Conflict Resolution, Human Security, and Global Governance and Program Director of Global Governance and Human Security MA and PhD Programs; McCormack Graduate School; Laura Sjoberg is British Academy Global Professor of Politics and International Relations at Royal Holloway University of London. February 10, 2021, “The Queer Art of Failed IR?” ; accessed 7/23/2022) ng

In the wake of the enduring popularity of the argument that there might be an “end of IR theory” (Dunne et al., 2013), we see a world in which IR theorizing is alive, even if only in repetitive fantasy, and key to disciplinary identification for whatever “IR” is. Some of the responses to the “end of IR theory” argue for a retreat from grand theory to middle-level theory (e.g., Lake, 2013); others warn of a “cacophony” that needs categorization to be comprehensible (Jackson & Nexon, 2013, p. 543); still others call for either re-terming schools of IR (Michelson, 2020) or combining analytic approaches (Grieco, 2019). While we see theory’s continued importance even in scholars’ confusion about its appropriate role, we recognize, with those who declare theory’s end in the discipline, that something has changed in the structure and function of theorizing among scholars interested in global politics. That something, we argue, is the simultaneous recognition of and denial of the failure of IR theorizing. We contend that IR theorizing is both failing and necessarily failed, but that does not make it over. Instead, we argue, drawing on queer theory, that failure in/of grand IR theory is something to be celebrated and actively participated in. With many queer theorists (e.g., Halberstam, 2011), we argue that failure, rather than a normative bad, can be a necessary corrective to the intellectual and disciplinary stagnation implied by and implicated in practiced and accepted standards of success. We argue that overwrought debates about the state of IR theorizing could learn from queer methodology (e.g., Weber, 2014a) and queer theorizing (e.g., Weber, 2016a) not only about global politics but also about the nature of knowledge and disciplinary politics. Queer IR has asked how cultural ideas about gender and sexuality shape global politics, and how heteronormative, homonormative, and cisnormative frameworks have shaped the ways the world works (Richter-Montpetit, 2018). It has also turned its lenses inward, asking why queer scholarship has had as little influence on IR theorizing as it has (Weber, 2016b), and how queering IR could change IR’s methodological (Weber, 2014a) and theoretical (Weber, 2014b) landscapes. This article looks at a small but in our view important piece of that puzzle—how taking queer work seriously might provide insight about the (sometimes endless) state-of-the-field debates. We see these state-of-the-field assertions, arguments, and debates as first and foremost recursive. Sometimes they are romances, explaining the breaking developments that provide hopeful next steps for a blooming field (e.g., Acharya, 2014; Berenskotter, 2017). Sometimes they are tragedies, spelling gloom and doom for IR as an enterprise (if not academia as a whole) or even global politics itself (e.g., Aistrope & Fishel, 2020; Stevens & Michelsen, 2020). Other times, they are dramas with various players and various arguments taking various starring roles in sparring matches (e.g., Jackson & Nexon, 2009; Parashar, 2013). Sometimes they are histories, tracing the past into the present or the present into the past (Alekseyeva, 2016; Schmidt & Guilhot, 2019). Sometimes they are sociologies, explaining how this and that theory relates to this and that other theory (Aris, 2020; Barkin & Sjoberg, 2019). Sometimes they are serials, explaining how particular approaches ebb and flow or evolve (e.g., Epstein, 2013; Guzzini, 2013). Sometimes they are sports reports, talking about which side wins what when (e.g., Acharya, 2005; Legro & Moravcsik, 1999). Most state-of-the-field evaluations make the various protagonists and antagonists (theories or theorists) seem so at odds, so different, and the stakes of the debates so dire. We argue that, with few exceptions, these stories, despite their different forms, different characters, and different plotlines, are all the same. They are more often than not the product of gender, sex, race, sexuality, national origin, education, and employment privilege that produce a narrow view of what is and what should be, based on the practices that have provided the success from which the privileged writer writes. As Weber (2014b, p. 29) argues, “disciplinary IR’s commitments and standards are as much the performative result of the so-called ‘mainstream’ agendas of learned societies, universities, independent funding agencies, and governments … as they are the performative outcome of so-called ‘dissident’ practices” (citing Ashley & Walker, 1990; Soreanu, 2010). In fact, Weber suggests that the radical critical edge of IR and its mainstream “foes” are really “intricately intertwined positions” which “produce a disciplinary IR that claims to speak for the whole of the discipline” out of power rather than legitimacy (Weber, 2014b, p. 29). In concrete terms, we argue that the current “state” of state-of-the-field stories and debates is intimately and necessarily tied not only to heteronormative, traditionalized rules and norms of scholarly practice but also to heteronormative, traditionalized understandings of success, failure, and their value. In this article, we argue that the things that the state-of-the-field literature agrees on betray a narrow and problematic approach to what knowledge is, how it works, who has it, and how it can be. We suggest that IR on these terms is always and already a failed enterprise, no matter what spin the stateof-the-field literature puts on it. IR fails to reach any expected or desired end of the enterprise of IR theorizing. It fails to achieve coherence or fails to approximate some measure (citations, downloads, and publisher quality) socially understood as failure’s opposite. It fails to find clarity or directions. It fails because it must—its idealized goals are unachievable and require it to be something that it cannot be, and remain its seductive unquestioned/unquestionable ends, despite an obvious need for reevaluation and, possibly, the embrace of failure (Baudrillard, 1991 [1979]; Halberstam, 2011). Rather than arguing that IR’s success and failure need to be redefined, we contend that IR’s success and failure need to be normatively reinterpreted. We argue that seeing IR as a failure, and embracing its failings, provides a realistic and intellectually grounded path for IR’s “futures,” putting to rest the state-of-the-field fairy tales and encyclopedias once and for all.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Cyborg Writing – BFHR 7wk › 1AC › 1AC

Debate is a site of social formation – we retool the pedagogical processes of this space in service of reparative queer kinship that forms enduring bonds of solidarity and care within an environment of paranoid antagonism.

Ensor 17 (Sarah Ensor, English Language and Literature, Ecocriticism, gender and sexuality, JUNE 01 2017, “Relative Strangers: Contracting Kinship in the Queer Ecology Classroom,” ; accessed 1/5/2022) ng

If this model of contracting kinship requires acknowledging our corporeal vulnerability, then it seems necessary to acknowledge, too, that this year in particular (2016) has made us viscerally aware of bodies at risk. Among the many sources of exposure that we continue to face is the changing climate of higher education, whose current condition makes it easy to believe that optimism in (or, indeed, about) academia is naive at best and actively harmful at worst. But within an environment that fosters paranoia, pedagogical kinship may not only become legible through a reparative reading practice but also may be a powerfully reparative social formation. For such a model enables a form of care that is embodied and improvisational, responsive to and inspired by the way in which vulnerability and community, contingency and possibility (for teachers and students, as for matsutake21) so often are intertwined. Although administrations increasingly hope that teachers’ and students’ relationships to the university—and to each other—will be contractual, the fact remains that our contracting takes place not only in the legal but also in the bodily sense. As opposed to being a means of institutionalization—of the standardization of relationships, the reproduction of existing values (and forms of privilege),22 and the kind of conservative resemblance among past, present, and future that often characterizes both kinship structures and higher education—this model of pedagogy is characterized by provisionality, surprise, and spread. The classroom exceeds the increasingly corporatized institution at the same time that it is housed within (and inseparable from) it, calling to mind the subtly spatial logic of reparative reading. Pedagogical modes of kinship thus come to resemble the “plethora of only loosely related weak theories,” brimming with “tenderness, wit, inventive reading, obiter dicta, and writerly panache,” that, in Sedgwick’s (2003, 136, my emphasis) account, are “invited to shelter” within the strong paranoid theory of a book like D. A. Miller’s The Novel and the Police. Indeed, as Sedgwick repeatedly insists, the reparative posture (with its forms of care) is structurally inseparable both from paranoia itself and from the Kleinian depressive position—and thus is responsive to, not avoidant of, fear and harm. But “its fear, a realistic one, is that the culture surrounding it is inadequate or inimical to its nurture”; as a result, “it wants to assemble and confer plenitude to an object that will then have resources to offer to an inchoate self” (149, my emphasis). The ethical possibility of caring for others “is founded on and coextensive with the . . . very often fragile concern to provide the self with pleasure and nourishment in an environment that is perceived as not particularly offering them” (137). Perhaps an institution such as mine is precisely the proper site for such an experiment in care. Unlike on traditional campuses, where students more often than not are following an expected trajectory (high school to college to employment), my students already have considerable experience with the “deroutinized temporality” (and openness to surprise) that Sedgwick (148) deems foundational to the reparative gesture. And unlike on traditional campuses, where students in any given classroom find themselves already sharing considerable common ground—from age range to family background, from spirit for the school’s football team to fraternity affiliation—my students are strangers to each other in a much more fundamental way. They are veterans of Desert Storm, Iraq, and Afghanistan, who sit facing the door to preclude being startled and who miss class for appointments at the VA Hospital. They are parents and grandparents who put younger generations through school before deciding to return themselves. They are twenty- and thirty-somethings who are being priced out of their hometown, for whom our city’s rapid gentrification and booming housing market are not fodder for abstract debate but rather embodied realities lived on a daily basis. They are adults who have had entire careers as reporters, social workers, and administrative assistants, who have found themselves on our campus after losing their jobs or deciding to change course. For those who are closer to traditional college age, my institution is hardly ever their first stop. Graduates of community colleges or students whose initial foray into higher education ended in abandonment of one form or another, they have found their way to our campus in the wake of other experiences of learning, often ones that did not lead where they planned. Like Sedgwick, they have long been “attune[d] . . . to a heartbeat of contingency” (147). Like Tsing’s subjects, they inhabit “salvage rhythms” (2015, 132). As with my pedagogy, their paths have already gone astray. Ultimately, their status as college students does not indicate any kind of elite escapism from the world’s patterns of circulation but rather a different mode of participating in—and being affected by—them.23 When such students (and I) become kin, then, the result is neither flat likeness nor any kind of codified bond. The aim is not for those who find themselves in my class to choose each other as lifelong friends (although sometimes they do) or for our kinship to be an institution that rivals (or even provides an alternative to) the broader university that houses us. Instead, we respond to the ongoing damage of the past and the emerging damage of the present with immanent gestures of community that help us move together, uncertainly, toward uncertain futures. Our kinship—like the reparative posture—fosters a “position from which it is possible . . . to use one’s own resources to assemble or ‘repair’ the murderous part-objects into something like a whole—though . . . not necessarily like any preexisting whole” (Sedgwick 2003, 128). Invested in hope without naïveté, in a mode of repairing that is not the same as healing or absolving, such practices evince care precisely in the absence of durability and optimism precisely in the absence of guarantees. In improvisational, unpredictable, and steadfastly material ways, through our own local practices and “nonce taxonomies” (145), we seek to make things better not only for each other but also for the community that accrues at the thresholds of our urban university’s porous bounds. We reckon with the ways in which higher education has abandoned us without ourselves abandoning it. Eventually, however, we do walk away from the classroom, a fact that might foreground the interplay of provisionality and endurance in this model of care. For the resulting marks—the imprint—may be permanent even if the relationships themselves are not enacted again in the future (and perhaps cannot be replicated outside the social milieu of the classroom). As the texts on our syllabus reminded us, fleeting interactions can have enduring effects. For instance, Dean, writing about the forms of consanguineous kinship developed via (voluntary) infection with HIV, insists that the encounters responsible for transmission queerly resemble marriage, insofar as they involve a lifelong commitment (to one’s own body, if not to the often-multiply anonymous body that infects one). These encounters, then, are “as far from casual . . . as one can get” (Dean 2009, 85); consequence endures even if relationality does not. In direct contrast to the line from a fictional song that comprises the title of Kazuo Ishiguro’s novel, I must always let my students go. And in letting them go, I trust that in some way, shape, or form our kinship will persist, that the material we shared (both in the sense of our readings and discussions, and in the sense of our resultant consubstantiality) will continue to matter. As in Weston’s (2001, 161) analysis of Youngblood’s transfusions, “These are not solidarities that endure but solidarities that allow people to endure.” My students and I—like all good kin—help each other to endure, in the sense of “to undergo without succumbing.”24 As with any emergent ecology, our kinship—“fugitive” (Tsing 2015, 255), “elusive” (282), “effervescen[t]” (255), “ephemeral” (255)—does not itself solve the problems that have brought us to this point, nor does it offer us a predictable program to follow in the face of the future’s uncertainties. (Needless to say, “kinship” is not now listed among the learning outcomes I am required to include on my syllabus.) However, like the “tiny actions” that, in Kirksey’s (Kirksey, Shapiro, and Brodine 2014, 49) account, have “the potential . . . to make the world a more livable place,” like Berrigan’s (2014, 169) experiment in contagion, which is “genuine in its reach toward empathy and self-care” even if its “intervention is inevitably deficient,” and like the interspecies assemblages that remind Tsing (2015, 282) that while it is “not easy to know how to make a life [within the ruin], much less avert planetary destruction,” “luckily there is still company, human and nonhuman,” this social formation limns the extant presence of alternatives both within the sanitized, corporatized university and to the habits of thought that so often keep us from reading higher education otherwise. By attending to such relational possibilities within the troubled ecology of higher education, we might catch “the scent of the latent commons” (282)—one thing, it seems, that reparative queer pedagogy can pleasurably and ethically track.