Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Kritiks › AT: Baudrillard---Perm

Our postmodern simulation of life is a turn against the simulacrum, forcing it into its own mad proliferation that produces differentiation rather than sameness.

Song 12, University of California Riverside, (Mary, Cyborg Dreams in Asian American Transnationality: Transgression, Myth, Simulation, Coalition, University of California Riverside, ) //CHC-DS 🐱‍👤

If we contemplate how narrative-making is an art that simulates identity, we might better appreciate the field of literary scholarship ! especially if we better understand the products of simulating identity versus the consequences of representing identity. Jean Baudrillard observes that our culture of simulation has become wholly reliant on signifiers that have replaced “reality” with “hyperreality”. Massumi critiques Baudrillard’s notion of hyperreality as a perception that leaves us in a sea of endlessly floating signifiers where “[m]eaning has imploded” (Massumi, http://www.anu.edu.au). Massumi asks, “But do we really have no other choice than being a naïve realist or being a sponge?” (ibid) Instead, Massumi advocates Deleuze’s notion of simulacra as an alternative to “being a sponge”:

The thrust of the process is not to become an equivalent of the “model” but to turn against it and its world in order to open a new space for the simulacrum’s own mad proliferation. The simulacrum affirms its own difference. It is not an implosion, but a differentiation; it is an index not of absolute proximity, but of galactic distances. (ibid)

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Kritiks › AT: Anti-Blackness

Settlement, spatiality, and place must all be theorized as essential to the production of the “human” and the materialization of blackness as an ontological position—the process of settlement enables self-actualization by the Settler through the turning of blackness into a position of the settled-slave

King 13

[2013, Tiffany Jeannette King, “IN THE CLEARING: BLACK FEMALE BODIES, SPACE AND SETTLER COLONIAL LANDSCAPES”, PhD Dissertation]

This is not an appeal to expand the category of the settler, as I have argued before Black slaves and descendants of slaves are not settlers. However, the processes which make Black bodies fungible flesh, a form of terra nullius, and embed their bodies in the land as settled-slaves needs to be theorized as modalities of settlement. Settlement needs to be retheorized along the contours of the bodies that it renders materially and socially dead. Scholarship from Marxist geographies, cultural landscape studies, anthropology and the emerging field of settler colonial studies is useful for helping us think about space, however, it does not help us think about the ways that the process of settlement also materializes Blackness as an ontological position. Native studies and Black studies enable a discussion of how the production of Settler and Master or Settler-Master subjectivity comes about due to its parasitic relationship to Native death and Black fungibility/accumulation (social death). When we think about the Settler-Master as parasitic we can also begin to think about their process of settlement as one that also requires the making of ontological categories occupied by the dead. The process of settlement allows the Settler-Master to become a human with spatial coordinates because the Native dies and the Black becomes a non-being (a settled-slave).15 Settlement is more than transforming the land. It is more than the teleological process of weary white people making a home and Native people naturally disappearing over time. Settlement is an assemblage of technologies and processes of makings and unmakings. Its processes require the making and unmaking of bodies, subject positions, space, place and claims to various forms of autonomy, self actualization and transcendence. In Settler Colonialism: A Theoretical Overview, Lorenzo Veracini, a founding scholar of the emerging field of settler colonial studies describes the process of settlement as a process that enables the “unfettered mobility” of the settler.16 While abject others within settler colonial nations are “principally characterized by restrained mobility” the settler experiences the capacity for “unfettered mobility.” This description of the kind of state of existence that settlement allows the settler is instructive. While Veracini’s description moves us closer to a discussion of states of being, I want to reframe Veracini’s description and introduce a few more elements to the equation. Settlement as an intricate, dynamic and contradictory relationship to Native bodies, Black bodies and the land/nature. Settlement structures the Settler’s relationship to the Native, the Black and nature as a relation of negation. Settlement also creates complex ontological positions that are constituted by both states of stasis and flux. What I mean by this is that some bodies (Native and Black) are relegated to a permanent position of flux. Native bodies are always slipping into death, Black bodies are always sliding into states of fungibility and accumulation. The flux and instability of the Black and the Native enable the Settler to experience a self actualizing state of both libratory stability and transcendent autonomy. The ontological positions of the Native (slipping into death) and the Black (sliding into fungibility and accumulation) are positions of fixed-flux. As Wilderson argues these positions do not occupy the universal liberal orienting and humanizing frames of time and space. They are fixed and rooted in a place of elimination and expanding use for the settler’s unending pursuit of self actualization. By settling, or gaining an exclusive claim to time and space, the Settler is able to simultaneously become a stable, coherent and autonomous human subject who occupies space while they also experience hyper mobility, transcendence and self directed transformation. The Settler moves back and forth at will between states of rootedness and mobility, stability and postmodern (self determined) constructedness. The Settlers’ unfettered movement between these contradictory spaces and states is predicated on the “fixed-flux” of Native and Black bodies. Fixed-flux is the underside of the Settler’s unfettered mobility and self actualization. It is always being susceptible to having the world flipped upside down at the whim of another (the Settler). Settlement functions like a violent form of deconstruction. Settlement as a gratuitously violent project that kills the Native and accumulates the Black also reorganizes discourse. The relationship that exists between the signifier and signified for concepts like autochthony and indigeneity and words like clearing under conditions of settlement become shifting ground beneath our feet.17 The prior meanings held by the terms and words autochthonous, indigenous and clearing are destabilized and then completely evacuated due to the material and discursive muscle of settlement. At the site of the clearing, Settlers are able to become autochthonous and indigenous at the same time. Frank Wilderson helps us think about the kind of discursive and material violence that occurs within what he calls the “Settler/Master/Human’s grammatical structure.”18 Within this grammatical structure, Wilderson argues that there is a disavowal of the violence of genocide in the way the settler narrates the formation of the US. On one level, the disavowal occurs through the settler’s preferred part of speech. Clearing is only spoken of as a noun in the Settler/Master/Human’s grammatical structure. Clearing is never used as a verb in the human’s grammatical structure. Wilderson draws our attention to its use: “Clearing, in the Settler/Savage” relation, has two grammatical structures, one a noun and the other as a verb. But the Western only recognizes clearing as a noun. But prior to the clearing’s fragile infancy, that is before its cinematic legacy as a newborn place name, it labored not across the land as a noun but as a verb on the body of the “Savage,” speaking civil society’s essential status as an effect for genocide.”19 This discursive displacement represents an actual displacement. As the Settler/Master/Human renders the clearing a static place, void of settler violence and absent of indigenous bodies and relations to the land, the Settler also indigenizes themselves to this abstract space. The Settler is allowed to merge with the land as they root themselves. They become autochthonous people that “sprang up from the land.”20 Settlers are now the group of humans that establish a right/righteous relationship with the land. Settlers proclaim themselves the new indigenous population. The original indigenous peoples are stripped of their indigeneity and rendered dead. Within the process of settlement, the indigenous people become embedded in or are literally buried as the dead within the land. The Settler then assumes a new autochthonous identity and emerges from the earth anew. Even when the Settler indigenizes or roots themselves into the land; they do not become stuck there like Native peoples. In her book, Black Body: Women, Colonialism and Space, Radhika Mohanram spends time explaining how enlightenment notions of the Indigene and European binary operate.21 The body conceived as incarcerated by nature is partially achieved by the discursive construction of the native as a “person who is born and thus belongs to a certain place,” and is in fact over determined by that place.22 The European on the other hand can be of a place but is not incarcerated by it like the Native. Their settler “indigeneity” offers them “unfettered mobility” as well as unfettered self actualization. Native people do not acquire this through their indigenous status. Upon encountering the settler (who becomes indigenous) the Native experiences their indigeneity as non-existence and death. The clearing also shapes Blackness as it carves out the settlement-plantation. The clearing in its verb form certainly labored across the bodies of Native people. However, the clearing also worked on and transformed the bodies of Blacks. The Black body is turned into the Settled-slave. Nana and Elizabeth Peazant are Settled-slaves whose bodies evince the way that the process of settling “cleared” Blacks of all spatial coordinates that could make them human during this process of making the settlement/plantation. Blacks become mere ‘states of flux,” and the atomic potential for space. At the site of the clearing, both a spatial and ontological production, Black bodies are the raw material and precursor to space. While Black bodies are geographic and necessary to the production of space they are not geographic subjects that humanly inhabit space at the site of the clearing.23 As geographic—dark—matter and material under settlement they make space possible but cannot occupy it. Existing in a continual state of liminality and change Black femaleness is a place making unit but not in place. Place is where humanness resides. According to Tim Cresswell, place and its links to humanness, morality and identity are a part of a humanistic project.24 For the humanist undertaking geography, “ontological priority was given to the human immersion in place rather than the abstractions of geometric space.” The humanist concept of place is accompanied by the baggage of morality, identity, authenticity and exclusion. Within modern thought systems, there is a tendency to locate people with certain identities in certain places. There is also a tendency within this metaphysical framework to imagine “mobile people in wholly negative ways.”27 Bodies on the move or sentient beings in a state of “fixed-flux” who slip into death like the Native or slide and transform as fungible flesh have no place and are considered suspect within this worldview. Through humanist articulations and re-theorizations of place, the universal and abstract notion of space becomes humanized and exclusionary admitting only a select group of people. Making a place is also about making a home.28 Place (and space) as home was functioning within imperialist endeavors of the enlightenment far before human geographers of the 1970s named it as such. As a geographer, Tuan has focused a great deal of attention on the extent to which people have attempted to “create order and homeliness out of the apparent chaos of raw nature.”29 In fact “the concept of place is central to our understanding of how people turn nature into culture by making it their home.”30 What happens when this humanist endeavor of turning nature/chaos into culture/order/home meets up with the imperialist endeavor? Sylvia Wynter argues that both the Native and the Black are considered states of non-Reason and chaos within Enlightenment humanism. Under imperialism, both the bodies and the lands of Native and Black people were states of chaos that needed to be ordered. While Tuan’s configuration of place and the transformation of raw nature into a home for humankind does not have the violent and exclusionary form of the human in mind, my reconfiguration of the place of settlement does. The landscapes of settlement, when they appear to the eye as a tranquil pasture with a log cabin or people sun bathing on a beach conceal the violent processes hidden in the clearing. One way of revealing what is hidden is through rethinking what a landscape is and how it functions. Richard Schein presents an interpretation of landscape as a process. In fact, Schein argues that landscape is always in the “process of becoming.”31 Another aspect of Schein’s theorization of the landscape that is productive is that he construes the landscapes as having material and epistemological value. The epistemology of the landscape disciplines those who come into contact with it. The disciplinary element of landscape is embedded in the fact that the material aspect of the landscape is seen, and presents itself as linear and objective.32 The landscape is in fact not self evident but duplicitous.33 Likewise settlement as a process and what it achieves even in its materiality (clearing, settlement-plantation) is not self-evident but multivalent and at times counter intuitive. What is hidden is that settlement is not just the making of a physical location for the Settler; rather, what is concealed is the simultaneous process of the Settler rooting in order to launch. Settlement is the subjugation and sinking/fixing of others into a state of flux (death, fungibility) in order for the Settler to transcend into a state of humanness. As the ultimate self actualizing human, the Settler can actually overcome the particularity of place (body, gender, race, abject sexuality) and launch into universal and abstract space (humanness). To be human in Frank Wilderson’s terms is to have “cartographic capacity.”34 “Spatial and temporal capacity is so immanent on the field of Whiteness that the effects and permutations of its ensemble of questions and the kinds of White bodies that can mobilize this universe of combinations are seemingly infinite as well.”35 To be a Savage or to be Black is to exist in the realm of no time and space.36 An apt visual for what happens when the Settler (noun) settles (verb) both people and land is one of a propelling long jumper. A long jumper is a subject who plants in order to launch oneself into space. This process of disciplining bodies, land and the viewers’ eye is hard to always perceive.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Kritiks › AT: Anti-Blackness

The 1AC’s analytic frame is necessary—slavery and anti-blackness are inadequate to understand and must be theorized in conjunction with settler colonialism as structuring modernity and constituting blackness

King 13

[2013, Tiffany Jeannette King, “IN THE CLEARING: BLACK FEMALE BODIES, SPACE AND SETTLER COLONIAL LANDSCAPES”, PhD Dissertation]

We must consider that Settler colonialism shapes and constitutes Black life, specifically slavery and its afterlife in America. While slavery and anti-Black racism should be active and robust analytic frames that guide Black Studies and help us understand Black subjectivity in the Western Hemisphere, settler colonialism also structures Black life. The genocide of Native peoples, the perpetual making of Settler space and Settler subjectivity—as unfettered self actualization—do not immediately stop existing as forms of power when they run into Black bodies. The way that settler colonial power looks and manifests itself just changes; it does not stop. Settler colonialism, as a subjectless discourse, is a form of productive power that touches all that live in the US and Settler colonial nations.30 Though it touches and shapes everyone’s life it does so in very different ways. For the purposes of my own research I am arguing that settler colonialism’s normalizing power enacts genocide against Native peoples (disappears Native people) but it also shapes and structures antiBlack racism. The ontological positions that were created by slavery, specifically the Slave are still alive and well however, settler colonial power intersects with, works through and structures the repressive and productive power that makes the Black captive fungible and socially dead. Throughout, In the Clearing poses the question, in what ways does settler colonial power help structure slavery and anti-Black racism? This project ultimately argues that slavery and anti-Black racism are not adequate to fully understand the material and discursive processes that create Blackness in all of its embodied genres in North America. Slavery and anti-Black racism are also not the only repressive powers that make the Black body abject, fungible and situated at the outer limits of being-ness. Both slavery and settler colonialism structure modernity and need to be fully conceptualized as forms of power that help constitute Blackness. Conceptualizing the ways that settler colonialism and slavery co-constitute one another is an essential component of this dissertation.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Kritiks › AT: Anti-Blackness

Asian American critique of their own involvement in domestic settlerism can be the basis of conjoining global decolonization movements to domestic deimperialization—the creation of futures beyond settlerism requires the production of new knowledges that attack the stress points of global empire—

Fujikane 12

[3/7/12, Candace Fujikane, “Asian American critique and Moana Nui 2011: securing a future beyond empires, militarized capitalism and APEC”, Volume 13, Issue 2, 2012]

If one pushes even further to argue that there must be a dialectical process in any deimperialization movement, then what conditions need to be created in the United States to bring about an effective movement there? What would the concrete forms of such a movement be? What are the appropriate methodologies for making deimperialization a reality in the neoimperial center? (Kuan-Hsing Chen 2010) Our brother Attwood Makanani, a cultural practitioner and voyager, once told me, ‘You gotta haku’, and I didn't understand what he meant. ‘Haku’ is the term for braiding or composing something. And now I think I understand that Pacific peoples can take the most fragile fibers and weave them into powerful ropes to bind homes together, canoes together, and even move great objects through the forest. Let us braid our struggles together into an unbreakable cord that's much stronger than our individual parts. Let us make a net that's big enough and strong enough to restrain even the most powerful of these strange and dangerous fish that threaten to engulf us. (Kyle Kajihiro 2011) As essays in this volume of Inter-Asia Cultural Studies examine the implications of Asian American studies in Asia, I would like to open up this essay with a consideration of the fragile fictions of US imperialism in Asia and the Pacific. On October 11, 2011, US Secretary of State Hilary Clinton published an op-ed piece in Foreign Policy on the necessity of aggressive military and economic advances in the Asia-Pacific region. Entitled ‘America's Pacific Century’, Clinton's statement stakes a claim to the Pacific, opening with the conditions of war in Iraq and a repositioning of US military forces from Iraq and Afghanistan to Asia and the Pacific: As the war in Iraq winds down and America begins to withdraw its forces from Afghanistan, the United States stands at a pivot point. Over the last 10 years, we have allocated immense resources to those two theaters. In the next 10 years, we need to be smart and systematic about where we invest time and energy, so that we put ourselves in the best position to sustain our leadership, secure our interests, and advance our values. One of the most important tasks of American statecraft over the next decade will therefore be to lock in a substantially increased investment—diplomatic, economic, strategic, and otherwise—in the Asia-Pacific region. (Clinton 2011) Such a framing clearly articulates the militarized theater necessary for the performance of US economic policies. It is in the rhetoric of militarized capitalism that we see the nineteenth-century logic of US imperialism: gunboat diplomacy that forced open markets in Asia and the Pacific continues today as Aegis warships enforce free trade. In this way, Clinton's declaration prepared the ground for the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) forum of 21 nations in the Asia and Pacific regions hosted by the United States in Honolulu, Hawai‘i, in November 2011. APEC's ostensible mission is ‘championing free and open trade and investments’, but as critics like Walden Bello have argued, APEC is being used by the United States to pull itself out of financial crisis, particularly in furthering the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP), formed in reaction to the ASEAN-China Free Trade Area (ACFTA) that went into effect in 2010 (Bello 2011). The TPP countries include the United States, Australia, Brunei, Chile, Malaysia, New Zealand, Peru and Singapore with Japan, Indonesia, Russia and others as potential members. As Bello (2011) explains, the TPP is viewed as a ‘WTO-plus’ because it is even more stringent in its free trade rules than the World Trade Organization (WTO): The objective of the original agreement was to reduce all trade tariffs to zero by the year 2015. It now aims to be a comprehensive agreement covering all the main pillars of a free trade agreement, including trade in goods, rules of origin, trade remedies, sanitary and phytosanitary standards, technical barriers to trade, trade in services, intellectual property, government procurement, and competition policy. As critics agree, APEC's representation of transnational interests has led to the deregulation of Asian and Pacific economies that makes possible the exploitation of human and environmental resources with devastating effects for indigenous peoples, farming and fishing communities, workers, women and poverty-stricken people in Asia and the Pacific. As the APEC leaders met at the Hawai‘i Convention Center, an alternative conference was held by Pua Mohala i ka Pō and the International Forum on Globalization (IFG). The Moana Nui 2011 (Peoples of the Asia/Pacific vs. APEC/TPP) conference brought together activists from Hawai‘i, Rapanui, the Philippines, Guåhan/Guam, Okinawa, Aotearoa/New Zealand, the Marshall Islands, Palau, Tonga, Fiji, Micronesia, Australia, Sāmoa, Siberia, Vanuatu, Malaysia, South Korea, Japan and the United States. Invited speakers included Native economists, farming and fishing practitioners, advocates for political and economic sovereignty, globalization experts, experts on the global land grab, specialists in media, public education, environmental studies and law, and anti-bases movement activists. In their description of the event, the coordinators of Moana Nui sent out a call to the peoples of Asia and the Pacific to articulate their own self-determining visions of a sustainable economic and political future: Moana Nui is intended to provide a voice and possible direction for the economies of Pacific Islands in the era of powerful transnational corporations, global industrial expansion and global climate change. This conference will issue a challenge to Pacific Island nations and communities to look for cooperative ways to strengthen subsistence and to protect cultural properties and natural resources. The timing of this conference is intended to overlap the next meeting of the Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) in Honolulu and hopes to call public attention to the critical importance of maintaining sound and productive local economies in the Pacific Islands both for their own sake and food security in the world. (Moana Nui 2011a) Against the fictions of free trade, the most powerful note of consensus at the conference was that traditional cultural practices that sustained indigenous peoples for millennia are the most sustainable. These international gatherings enable us to protect and promote those practices by piecing together our local analyses for a clearer picture of the global operations of interlinking forms of imperialisms, colonialisms, corporate capitalisms and militarisms. As anti-APEC and Moana Nui organizing and demonstrations illustrated the fragile fictions of empires, it is the cumulative effect of these deimperializing moments that is restructuring a future beyond empires. The magnitude of this imperial, militarized capitalism is rendered as a global map of stress points that cannot bear its inhumane burdens. Interlinked popular movements and their production of knowledge, then, become like bursts of runaway voltage striking at these stress points. Visions of the future hinge upon the ideological wars over the production of knowledge, and these insights into the vulnerabilities of empires enable us to chart emergent formations and to map new directions for Asian American critical praxis. As I contend in this essay, the seemingly unassailable architecture of US empire is under erosion from both within and without. Although Asian American studies as a discipline was born out of the civil rights movement and criticisms of imperialist wars being fought in Asia, Africa and South America, Asian Americans later turned to delineating the institutional parameters of Asian American studies, focusing on domestic issues of racism in the United States and the ‘claiming of America’. It was in the 1990s that theorists in postcolonial studies and Third World feminist studies raised questions about the artificial boundaries that were being drawn in examinations of Asian American texts. Later work on the continuities between Asian American studies and the imperial and colonial contexts of Asia was inspired by writers who traversed international boundaries, including Chandra Mohanty (1988), Trinh T. Minh-Ha (1989), E. San Juan, Jr. (1991a, 1991b, 1991c), Oscar Campomanes (1992, 1995), Chungmoo Choi (1993), Lisa Lowe (1991, 1993), and Inderpal Grewal (1994). Most recently, texts such as Setsu Shigematsu and Keith Camacho's (2010) edited collection Militarized Currents: Toward a Decolonized Future in Asia and the Pacific have worked to connect the histories of Japanese and US empires across Asia and the Pacific. On another register, an emergent form of Asian American critique challenges the presence of the United States within its imagined borders. The etymological narrative that the United States is ‘home’ to Asian American studies is being critically re-examined in analyses of settler colonialism and the US settler state's assault on indigenous peoples, their land, and their state sovereignty. In the fall of 2000, Jonathan Okamura and I co-edited a special issue of UCLA's Amerasia Journal entitled ‘Whose vision? Asian settler colonialism in Hawai‘i’ (Fujikane and Okamura 2000), followed by an expanded collection, Asian Settler Colonialism: From Local Governance to the Habits of Everyday Life in Hawai‘i (Fujikane and Okamura 2008). Kanaka ‘Ōiwi scholars Haunani-Kay Trask, Mililani Trask, Momiala Kamahele, ku‘ualoha ho‘omanawanui, and Healani Sonoda foreground the genocidal operations of the US settler state and raise critical questions for Asian Americans about their status as settlers on indigenous lands.1 As a fourth-generation Japanese American settler in Hawai‘i and co-editor of the collection, I describe Asian settler colonialism as a constellation of the colonial ideologies and practices of Asian American settlers who are part of the broader structure of the US settler state (Fujikane 2008: 6).2 Asian settler colonialism refers to the present participation of all Asian Americans in Hawai‘i in US settler colonialism through different kinds of settler practices, ranging from colonial administration to the routines of everyday life. Asian American settler contributors to those volumes illuminate aspects of Asian settler colonialism from different fields and disciplines to illustrate its diverse operations and material impact on Kānaka ‘Ōiwi. As those of us who have critiqued Asian American settler colonialism have argued, an understanding of our positions as settlers in Hawai‘i and in the United States has become critical to reconceptualizing Asian American critique. As in poststructuralist work, the critique of Asian American settler colonialism asks us to enter into a more self-reflexive inquiry about our positions both in relation to the US settler state and to indigenous peoples. Far from an essentializing move, the critique of Asian American settler colonialism invites us to investigate the complex ways that Asian Americans are implicated in the settler colonial policies of the United States and to delineate the kind of anticolonial and anti-imperial work that must be done. The international workshop on ‘Asian American Studies in Asia’ became a critical site of inquiry for me in articulating the continuities between a critique of Asian American settler colonialism and deimperialization in Asia. In thinking about these questions, I was particularly struck by the kinds of critical analyses Kuan-Hsing Chen makes in his call for a deimperialization of both Asia and the United States. As Chen argues, the study of Asia as method alerts us to the possibilities of reorienting Asian American critique by using Asia as a reference point, moving beyond the imperial centers and imagining and engaging in post-imperial practices inspired by different geopolitical sites. As Chen writes, The implication of Asia as method is that using Asia as an imaginary anchoring point can allow societies in Asia to become one another's reference points, so that the understanding of the self can be transformed, and subjectivity rebuilt. Pushing the project one step further, it becomes possible to imagine that historical experiences and practices in Asia can be developed as an alternative horizon, perspective, or method for posing a different set of questions about world history. (Chen 2010: xv) In the quotation I take as my first epigraph, Chen also asks what methodologies can make deimperialization a reality in the neoimperial center. The question is derived from his concern that ‘the collapse of the empire does not mean the collapse of the former colonizing population's imperial consciousness’, and he cites Mutō Ichiyō's argument that critical intellectuals must assume the responsibilities for being accomplices to the crimes committed by the imperial state (Chen 2010: 206). Only in this way can deimperialization occur. I would argue that a critique of Asian American settler colonialism constitutes one such methodology that mobilizes a mode of self-reflexive inquiry in Asian American critique and conjoins it to a decolonizing and deimperializing movement in Asia and the United States. It is a methodology that calls upon us to re-examine the settler colonial underpinnings of Asian American narratives and praxis, underscoring the need for Asian American settlers to challenge settler colonialism in their own communities as well as in the larger US settler state. It is in tracing the production of settler colonial knowledges that we can expose the operations by which Asian American settlers have participated in obscuring the conditions of US occupation, colonialism, and imperialism. Only by achieving justice for Kānaka ‘Ōiwi and for American Indians can we as Asian American settlers liberate ourselves from our positions as agents in a settler colonial system of violence. It is in this work that I see a critique of Asian American settler colonialism broadening out in shared affinities with the project of deimperializing Asia. This now brings me to a key argument about Asian American studies in Asia: Asian American critique must engage in Asia and the Pacific as method, to borrow and extend Chen's argument, which means reorienting ourselves in more expansive ways toward Asia and the Pacific in order to work toward a decolonized, deimperialized future. This is not to say that we must abandon our own important local or national analyses of racism, heteropatriarchy, class struggle, or the relationships between indigenous peoples and settlers, or the transnational flows of people and resources among global sites. Instead, we can expand our work simultaneously in these different arenas and bring those critical analyses together

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Kritiks › AT: Anti-Blackness

Techno-Orientalism reduces Blackness to techno-primitivism, laboring exchange value, and unmodern irrationality. In the postmodern future, you should evaluate race through technocentric anxieties.

Roh et al. 15, David Roh is Professor of English at the University of Utah. He holds a BA in English from the University of California, Los Angeles, an Ed.M in Educational Technology from Harvard University, and an MA and Ph.D in English from the University of California, Santa Barbara. He is author of Minor Transpacific: Triangulating American, Japanese, and Korean Fictions (Stanford University Press, 2021), Illegal Literature (University of Minnesota Press, 2015), and coeditor of Techno-Orientalism (Rutgers University Press, 2015). His work has appeared in Law & Literature, MELUS, Journal of Narrative Theory, and Verge., (“Chapter 13: Palimpsestic Orientalisms and Antiblackness”, Techno-Orientalism: Imagining Asia in Speculative Fiction, History, and Media, Rutgers University Press) //CHC-DS 🐱‍👤

Framed by comparative and postcolonial approaches to Asian American studies, my approach to techno-Orientalism destabilizes the false universality of the “human,” that animating figure of speculative fiction. In “The Intimacies of Four Continents” (2006), Lisa Lowe locates the modern “human” subject’s nineteenth-century emergence, which normalized freedom, liberty, rights, and progress, within the material conditions produced through slavery, genocide, and indenture. Critical analyses that affirm liberal categories like freedom, rights, and progress forget that they arise from the exclusions, occlusions, and deathliness of race. Race thus temporally marks an ontological difference from the modern subject of liberal humanism; to be nonwhite is to be out of sync with modernity. Within this chronotopic definition of the “human,” the postmodern future of techno-Orientialism has left the “human” and its modern present of mercy and community behind to become a technocentric dystopia, while the decadent premodernity of past-turning Orientalism leads “humanity” astray from its modern values of discipline and order. Moreover, outside of these time zones of the “human” is the subjection of blackness. In Lisa Nakamura’s analysis, blackness in the digital age signifies techno-primitivism, primitive spirituality, and laboring exchange value. Reading depictions of technology in multiracial futures, Nakamura shows how white heroism takes on moral power through projections of Asianness and blackness: Asianness symbolizes a tool for white success, while blackness—stuck in an unmodern irrationality—legitimizes but never equals white valor (Digitizing Race, 109, 116, 127–128). These figurations of time racialize liberal humanism’s promise of freedom as whiteness; the category of the “human” and its appearance of universality disguise these structuring exclusions.

To be clear, I love Joss Whedon and his dedication to human rights, seen on-screen in the Whedonverse’s thematic preoccupations and off-screen in his support of international feminist organization Equality Now. However, as Mimi Thi Nguyen contends, the “human” of human rights structurally depends on the inhuman violence spread in delivering its promises of freedom. First, by naming race as this inhuman remainder, I intervene in the field of Whedon studies. The incredulous tone with which Eric Hung reviews this literature in “The Meaning of ‘World Music’ in Firefly” suggests how these acafan analyses forgive representational color-blindness, whitewashing, and racism beyond the screen to praise the auteur; the Dollhouse special issue of Slayage: The Journal of the Whedon Studies Association does not include race in its vocabulary. Focusing on race in the narratives of the Whedonverse introduces the inhumanity of the “human” as an unresolved problematic of minoritized groups’ struggle for representation. Second, I take up techno-Orientalism as a relationally racializing trope in speculative fiction to illustrate the nonequivalent co-construction of anti-Asian and antiblack racisms. These palimpsestic Orientalisms are not a fiction to be proven false, but characterize the twentyfirst-century anxieties of difference in the white supremacist culture from which Whedon writes; Asian American expression or presence alone cannot correct these interconnected racializations.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Framework › FW---Racializing Logics

The form of debate that calls us to “adhere to the rules” instates a subject that reproduces and rewards subjects who adhere to racializing logics built into the game.

Lu 21 (Melanie Lu, Writing Consultant at Vanderbilt's Writing Studio, Editor, Vanderbilt Lives, Undergraduate Creative Nonfiction Journal; April 27th, 2021, “Gendering the Techno-Orient: The Asian Woman in Speculative Fiction,” ; accessed 7/23/2022) ng

The possibilities are numerous, yet my interests here gravitate more specifically towards the emerging discourse on video games, the most lucrative entertainment industry in the world today. My previous analysis of films—especially Ghost in the Shell—has demonstrated the importance of taking into account the nature of visual form, in addition to narrative content, in shaping particular viewer interpretations. Paying attention to the creative medium itself becomes especially important when we enter the realm of video games, where interactivity is one of the defining characteristics of game experience. While any text, whether literary, visual, or otherwise, arguably “interacts” with an active reader/viewer in some way to produce meaning, video games offer unique challenges to how we think about interacting with texts. Not discounting the ongoing discussion regarding the role of narratology versus ludology in video games studies (Juul 16), I aim to briefly highlight here the medium’s high level of interactivity as a significant area in which racialization and gendering take place through mechanisms inherent to video games. I am therefore less interested in how fiction or storytelling in games can Otherize—they certainly do—but rather in how the underlying structures of video game mechanics do so, perhaps as part of a larger conversation on the ideological mapping of computer-mediated processes. For my purposes, I wish to call attention to the rule-based, outcome-oriented qualities that govern most video games; the fact that the player is encouraged, compelled, or simply allowed to perform certain actions in order to achieve certain outcomes is crucial to understanding how video games exert cultural influence and (re)produce ideology. Ian Bogost’s concept of procedural rhetoric is useful here: distinct from the verbal or visual rhetoric that accompanies more traditional forms of media, procedural rhetoric as often operating through digital systems designates the practice of using processes such as game mechanics persuasively, where “arguments are not made through the construction of words or images, but through the authorship of rules of behavior, the construction of dynamic models” (Bogost 29). Bogost contends that video games that effectively mount sophisticated procedural rhetoric can inform and challenge players to reflect on how processes in the material world do, can, or should work, thereby interrogating these material systems themselves (Bogost 57). But even as I accept Bogost’s fundamental premise that video games utilize argumentative procedure to great degree, I resist the suggestion that this procedure is necessarily rhetorical in nature: while players can indeed be persuaded to adopt certain views, it is also likely that the same procedures can manipulate or condition them into doing so. In other words, Bogost fails to adequately address the extent to which pre-existing ideologies may already naturalize, and thus reinforce, the very material processes video game procedures can literalize or seemingly call into question. Alexander Galloway has pointed out that procedures in video games—or what he calls “protocols”—can be viewed as allegories of control, where, through following and absorbing game rules that mirror the politics of the informatic age, players are “learning, internalizing, and becoming intimate with a massive, multipartite global algorithm” (Galloway 35). It is this more pernicious effect of video game procedure that I highlight as a reinstantiation of techno-Orientalism in new media. Let us briefly consider one example of a video game where this tension between procedure and allegory comes into play through racial Othering. While Lucas Pope’s 2013 independent game Papers, Please has garnered much critical attention for its procedural sophistication in interrogating the realities of immigration policy and authoritarian state violence, his most recent detective game Return of the Obra Dinn (2018) utilizes procedure in ways that are subtler and perhaps more troubling. On a general level, Obra Dinn employs procedural mechanics common to the detective genre’s idealization of objective, intelligible, and unmediated historical truths, such as by granting the detective means to traverse time and space when unravelling the Obra Dinn’s mystery; however, here it is important to elaborate on how racialization mechanisms are similarly woven into the structural pathways of the game. Set aboard a fictional East India Company trade ship from 1802, the game requires the player to investigate the fates of the Obra Dinn’s 60 crew members and passengers, who have all died or disappeared due to various natural and supernatural causes. The player navigates in first-person the complex layout of the monochromatic three-story ship with a magical pocket watch, which allows them to return to specific moments before each character’s death to explore relevant audio and visual clues. Using a roster and drawings of the crew, the player makes progress in the game whenever they correctly determine and input character fates into their inspector’s logbook; with every three cases solved, they are able to access more scenes and proceed further into the mystery. Even on a narrative level, the game Orientalizes by relying heavily on a mystical Formosan treasure chest as a central plot device: belonging to a group of royal Formosan passengers, this exotic object is revealed to have set in motion the endless tragedies on board, where, through some unfathomable Oriental magic, hordes of “terrible beasts” of the sea are lured in to attack the Obra Dinn. What calls for scrutiny is not just how the plot of the mystery unfolds, however, but more importantly the procedural strategies of deduction players have at their disposal when identifying characters and subsequently their fates. While more scrupulous or ambitious players may meticulously look for conclusive clues embedded solely within the narrative, such as by reconstructing timelines, analyzing character relationships through dialogue, or tracking specific character items at key locations, the game also offers a more freeform reasoning space in which external factors, such as profession or race, can be exploited for processes of elimination. At more difficult stages within the game where clues are scarce, one inevitably finds themselves noticing the simplistically rendered, but unmistakably present, racialized appearances of the characters, or the pronounced accents and linguistic variation of the dialogue recordings replayed at each death. Combined with the logbook’s convenient catalogue of all character origins, which include a variety of European and Asian nationalities, these normative racial markers make it possible for the player to guess character identities through trial and error, since the logbook automatically progresses once any three correct fates are reached. For instance, a player might assume a certain character to be Chinese based on their appearance and/or accent; then, with two identifications already entered into the logbook, the player could input all the Chinese names given until one of them triggers a third correct response. The way the game portrays individual racial appearance, accent, or culture—whether “accurately” or otherwise—is irrelevant here; what Bogostian procedure highlights are the rule-based structural pathways encoded in the game that permit racialization to work as a strategy in the first place. Obra Dinn thus motivates the player to make the kind of racial generalizations—accent as natural index of identity, ethnic features as justified means of racial and subsequently social categorization, etc.—that Bogost anticipates such a game to critique through procedure. Yet, instead of using rhetoric to expose the harm of racial Othering, the game cements their normative nature; since players are able to proceed in the game in this way and uncover the “truth” of the mystery, Obra Dinn actually rewards them for engaging in these ideological practices, thus further naturalizing the constructed logic of racialization. This implicitly encoded notion of reward is especially important when we reflect on Bogostian procedure in terms of its argumentative qualities. Unlike language that aims to persuade through direct instruction or explication, the procedures players are introduced to in video games like Obra Dinn are powerful tools by which ideology is learned, in the sense that players internalize—through interacting first-hand with rules of the game—processes that they themselves observe to be effective, often in high-stakes settings. In Obra Dinn’s online community forums, some players comment gleefully or in frustration about the fact that they can use “brute force” logic to clear the game, while others retort that this is not how the game is “supposed to be played.” But a singular or mandatory method for playing the game does not exist, just as a singular method to interpret a text does not exist, and it is precisely this possibility, this hidden logic, embedded in the game that becomes critical to its treatment of racial ideology as argument. For Obra Dinn does not offer a puzzle in which race does not exist or signify, nor does it explicitly satirize racialization as its own procedural vice, as was perhaps done with Papers, Please; instead, players encounter situations where racialization, seemingly irrelevant, ultimately proves to be highly effective once learned. Indeed, racialization is deliberately made a covert, intuitive, indeed algorithmic logic, much as how it operates in the real world, and herein lies the argumentative, or “persuasive,” power of digital procedure. Whether it is the earlier forms of explicit racism seen in yellow-peril propaganda, or the appropriation and depoliticization of race under the disguise of postmodern aesthetics, or the increasingly common narratives of post-racial dystopia featured in speculative fiction, reinstantiations of Orientalism and techno-Orientalism continue to define and surveille how Asians speak, act, and exist in both fictional and real worlds. Thinking back to Said’s early concerns with Orientalism’s amorphous, self-adapting nature over time, it is imperative that we pay close attention to the rapidly evolving expressions of global media and continue to identify, resist, and ultimately dismantle the various languages and spaces by which such oppressive systems of Othering exist. By examining the nuanced constructions of the subject-object binary as manifest in the Asian woman’s ornamental objecthood, this thesis has hopefully taken a step towards the critical discourse on reimagining gendered racial ontologies to promote more productive and subversive understandings of modern personhood.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Framework › FW---Gaming

The gamespace of debate is intertwined with late capitalism – assumptions of fair play and logistical mapping reinscribe the conditions that uphold the fantasy of perfecting space. Instead, our extreme Asian gaming disrupts capitalist time and blurs the boundaries between Occident and Orient.

Roh et al. 15, David Roh is Professor of English at the University of Utah. He holds a BA in English from the University of California, Los Angeles, an Ed.M in Educational Technology from Harvard University, and an MA and Ph.D in English from the University of California, Santa Barbara. He is author of Minor Transpacific: Triangulating American, Japanese, and Korean Fictions (Stanford University Press, 2021), Illegal Literature (University of Minnesota Press, 2015), and coeditor of Techno-Orientalism (Rutgers University Press, 2015). His work has appeared in Law & Literature, MELUS, Journal of Narrative Theory, and Verge., (“Chapter 8: Never Stop Playing”, Techno-Orientalism: Imagining Asia in Speculative Fiction, History, and Media, Rutgers University Press) //CHC-DS 🐱‍👤

In an essay called “Angels in Digital Armor: Technoculture and Terror Management” (2010), media scholar Marcel O’Gorman argues that notions of heroism in contemporary technoculture aim to satisfy two primary existential needs: the desire for recognition and the denial of death. Most video games interpellate players by reinforcing ideologies that underpin the sovereign subject, who believes herself to be immortal and master of the world represented on the computer screen. Gaming is one part of a broadly conceived digital technoculture for O’Gorman. Appropriating Bernard Stiegler’s thesis that the technologization of culture is linked to profound malaise and ontological indifference, O’Gorman argues that online heroism, constituted through attention garnered on Facebook, YouTube, and the news media, goes hand in hand with the disavowal of mortality and finitude. Toward this O’Gorman analyzes cases of gamer death in China and Korea, the Columbine High School shootings, and Cho Seung-Hui, the Virginia Tech shooter, as “explicitly technological, or even ‘cyber,’ because they involve the perpetrators’ use of media to rehearse or to promote their exploits in a desperate plea for recognition” (O’Gorman). He does not discuss race explicitly but implies that all users of digital media are somehow implicated.

While we agree with O’Gorman’s diagnosis of the culture of online celebrity and the proliferation of technically induced malaise, his analysis runs the danger of overgeneralization with the blanket term “technoculture.” We would like to attend to the specificity of video gaming and its Orientalist figuration by isolating a mechanic of StarCraft that is common to most video games: the acquisition of capital. More specifically, for the remainder of the essay we further interrogate the relationship between work and play. While drawing from McKenzie Wark’s Gamer Theory and key game play mechanics from StarCraft, we argue that extreme video gaming may be read to challenge the presuppositions that deem it “unproductive” labor. In doing so, we argue that extreme gaming upends notions of capitalist time, pointing to ontological aporias that blur the distinction between Occidental and Oriental.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Framework › FW---Fiat

Narrative constructions of the future materialize the way we invest in the present. Their seemingly objective predictions calculate subjects into knowability while simultaneously rendering data into fiction, unleashing abstract symbolic violence onto the world. Our uncertainty disrupts securitization and embraces the knowable as lived experience, creating a horizon of the not yet for non-White futurities.

Bahng 17, Aimee Bahng is an American academic. She is a professor of gender and women's studies at Pomona College in Claremont, California. Her previous denial of tenure at Dartmouth College sparked widespread protests about discrimination against racial minorities in academia., (Aimee, “Introduction: On Speculation Fiction, Finance, and Futurity” in Migrant Futures: Decolonizing Speculation in Financial Times, Duke University Press) //CHC-DS 🐱‍👤

This book puts into conversation speculative finance and speculative fiction as two forms of extrapolative figuration that participate in the cultural production of futurity. To put these two seemingly disparate arenas of narrative production into conversation, I largely use the methodologies of an emerging field that could be called critical finance studies in conjunction with a longer standing field called feminist science studies, which trained me to beware of the “god trick of seeing everything from nowhere” purveyed by the seemingly pure, objective vision of scientific and capitalist realism.6 It is indeed a god trick to get people to mistake prophecy for truth, notional figure for value, or futurity for the future. As a lifetime student of the power of narrative to alter reality, or at least perceptions of it, I have often been awed by fiction’s nearly magical actuarial potency. By approaching both speculative finance and speculative fiction as narrative productions, I emphasize the performativity of economics and therefore the potential power of the literary imagination to call forth new political economies, ways of living, and alternative relational structures; and different sorts of subjects into the world.

I use the term “futurity” to highlight the construction of the future and denaturalize its singularity, while maintaining an emphasis on how narrative constructions of the future play a significant role in materializing the present. “Extrapolation,” for example, is the name for the mathematical modeling practice economists use to predict future commodity prices and investment trends based on data compiled in databases such as the crb Commodity Yearbook, Wharton Research Data Services, as well as Global Financial Data Solutions. At the same time, science fiction studies might first associate extrapolation with the eponymous academic journal, which publishes scholarly essays on science fiction (also called extrapolative or speculative fiction). Migrant Futures investigates how we narrate futurity across various platforms, from speculative fiction to financial speculation. How do our stories of the future chart the ways we invest—financially, politically, ideologically, and intellectually—in the present? How do the logics of preemption break across the shores of financial securitization, military preparedness, and scientific projection? These are some of the questions taken up by anthropologists, sociologists, historians, cultural theorists, and other scholars contributing to an interdisciplinary examination of financialization.7

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Framework › FW---Cruel Optimism

You should embrace reparative reading practices that reject neoliberal futures while sustaining futures toward survival

Bahng 17 (Aimee Bahng is an American academic. She is a professor of gender and women's studies at Pomona College in Claremont, California. Her previous denial of tenure at Dartmouth College sparked widespread protests about discrimination against racial minorities in academia. 2017, “Migrant Futures: Decolonizing Speculation in Financial Times,” p132-145, accessed 7/24/2022) ng *figures omitted

Set in a dilapidated urban landscape, Malinky Robot revisits the primal scene of techno-Orientalist fantasy: Tokyo. However, by focusing on Tokyo’s day-laboring district of San’ya, which remains home to Tokyo’s dispossessed, Liew shifts the origin point of Japan’s economic success and underscores the vulnerability of those who were not folded into the prosperity of global capitalism.38 Like the denizens of Tokyo’s San’ya, Oliver and Atari “eke out a life” in a geopolitical context that works hard to eliminate them from the picture.39 Together they scrape together bits and pieces of culture, currency, and materials from the discarded matter of the city. “Eking out a life”—one of Liew’s favorite characterizations of Oliver and Atari’s mode of engaging with the world around them—resonates profoundly with Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick’s formulation of reparative practices, which illuminates “the many ways selves and communities succeed in extracting sustenance from the objects of a culture—even of a culture whose avowed desire has often been not to sustain them.”40 Sedgwick’s formulations of reparative versus paranoid modalities distinguish between ways of experiencing time—within and beyond narrative forms. Distinct from paranoid reading, which is motivated by an attempt to inure oneself to potentially horrible futures, reparative reading stays open and vulnerable to the radical possibilities of surprise.41 Though called sequential art, comics as a literary form have a propensity for bending time across the page, wherein the space between panels—“the gutter”—could represent a fleeting moment or eons of time passing, not necessarily in chronological order. Malinky Robot flexes the possibilities of its graphic form to capture play and adventure in slow time at a moment when blockbuster films profit from ever more accelerated pacing. With sparse, unspectacularized story lines that amount to “a robot walks home,” or “two kids borrow bikes to visit a friend,” Liew’s utopian visions—ephemeral and provisional—unfurl across the daily exploits and mundane, communal acts of these unlikely heroes of the future. Malinky Robot ruminates on forms of idleness that upend conceptions of wasted time, while simultaneously highlighting the waste of capitalist overproduction. Whereas the dystopian tenor of techno-Orientalist cyberpunk and the breakneck ambition of Future•Singapore both engender a paranoid relation to futurity by manifesting either foreboding about or securitization of it, Malinky Robot remains remarkably open to surprise and radical uncertainty. In this way, it articulates a reparative form of speculation—one that revels in the play of chance rather than the taming of it.42 Malinky Robot opens in 2024 atop a skyscraper (figure 4.3), where sunrise finds the protagonists on top of the world, not because they own or dominate it, but because they have made the rooftop their makeshift shelter. Atari and Oliver are homeless, making do with life in urban decay. Here, “mornings are . . . stinky!!” (11). This is the surprising pronouncement that begins “Stinky Fish Blues,” the first story in the collection. At dawn, Oliver encounters not the optimistic vista of sunlit horizons but the smell of a stagnant city, littered with signs of broken technological promises. Yet morning does bring surprising, if fleeting, moments of hope and unexpected opportunity. Oliver and Atari go fishing at the docks and discover rare life in the toxic waters—the nearly extinct Foetidus piscis (the stinky fish), which has persisted despite barrels of industrial sludge polluting its home. Their fortuitous catch fosters the hope of cashing it in for reward, but the fish ultimately falls prey to a friend’s more pressing need to eat it. The kids are disappointed but not dejected, as prospects of cashing in recede to make allowances for the sharing of life in this contingent community. The stinky fish, living beyond all probability in pernicious condtions, serves as a fitting compatriot for Oliver and Atari, who manage to do more than just survive in a hostile environment. They dare to have dreams, foster friendships, and have adventures that actively extend the possibilities of the living conditions allotted to them, even if their dreams remain decidedly out of reach. Likely destined to earn a living through tough, menial, and temporary work, Oliver and Atari might entertain brief moments of hope, but the fantasy to fly is not about ascendancy or mastery. The view from the top of Oliver’s transient skyscraper haven differs from what Michel de Certeau describes in “Walking in the City.” From the summit of the World Trade Center, de Certeau experiences being “lifted out of the city’s grasp. . . . When one goes up there, he leaves behind the mass. . . . His elevation transfigures him into a voyeur.”43 But Oliver’s prospects remain decidedly unchanged by this perspectival shift. He remains untransfigured, looking up like a homeless alien, not “looking down like a god.” This difference reverberates profoundly across the context of Atari’s and Oliver’s likely futures working in the construction sites that emblematize New Asia and its speculative building frenzy. Indeed, when the two look upon a construction site, they consider their curtailed set of opportunities, and even Oliver’s act of momentary ebullience (“I wanna fly a plane!”) (figure 4.4) seems squelched as the frame zooms out to capture the dwarfing effects of the world around him. The tops of skyscrapers yield only visions of unattainable aspirations and failed promises for Atari and Oliver, but they pursue adventure nonetheless and find in an arcade a virtual realization of Oliver’s hopes to pilot a plane. In this closing frame of the story (figure 4.5), Liew leaves us with a stunning display of reparative practice, of engaging in fleeting acts of pleasure to carve out alternative ways of looking forward. Together, Atari and Oliver explore alternative economies of exchange: they “borrow” bicycles that allow them to visit their friend Misha across town. Their mundane push toward collective ownership stands in stark contrast to the stealing-for-profit story Misha shares with them over lunch at “McDonnell’s” about Obiyashi Takamashuru, an unscrupulous man who stole the design for cantilevered gears on bikes from their mentor Mr. Bon Bon. This short vignette about bicycle thievery turns sideways when it’s revealed that bicycles themselves carry with them another story of stolen property. As we learn from Misha’s tale, the bicycle—as concept, design, and mode of transport—is always already stolen: the very mechanism that facilitates its locomotion turns out to be a lifted idea. Framed as the first in a series of comics within a comic, Misha’s Ingrown Nale reveals the history of the bicycle as property privatized and patented in the shadiest of circumstances, throwing the world of propriety into ethical question. Drawn in the heavily cross-grained and stridently scraggy pen-and-ink style of graphic mavericks such as Robert Crumb, Ingrown Nale (ostensibly produced from Misha’s hand but of course also a testament to Liew’s creative range) takes the reader into Obiyashi’s demented world of ruthless corporate competition, greed, and dishonesty. We follow Obiyashi to work on the day of his death and descent to a Dante-inspired hell, where he confesses how he stole the design of the cantilevered gear system. Though certainly incentivized to villainous action, Obiyashi turns out to be a dupe, trapped in the promise of a better future (figure 4.6). Before his fateful cardiac arrest, he reflects on his situation: “30 years! My life, a series of dwindling offices. I long for: the ocean, the trees, the breadth [sic] of my children as yet unborn. Today, though, will be a day different from days before” (45). We witness this corporate wonk’s perpetually fruitless drive toward upward mobility in several key details. Obiyashi’s namesake might ironically be Obayashi Global, the Japanese multinational construction corporation behind the building of Tokyo Sky Tree, the world’s tallest broadcasting tower. Obiyashi’s ascent in the corporate elevator leads him to a dead-end cube of an office. In his futile attempt to climb out of hell, he maniacally exclaims: “They gave me an office! They gave me a car! And a hat to wear for when it got windy!” (48). In these exclamations we hear the despair wrought by this subject’s investments in “aspirational normativity”:44 a perpetually upskilled life, heteronormative reproductive futurity, and a drive toward individualistic achievement. Obiyashi has spent years subjected to the “good life” logics of neoliberal capitalism—the logics that rationalize financial and social speculations privileging profit for the few over more disposable lives that don’t fit or aspire to the same narrative. The astonishing and inspiring element of the Malinky Robot stories is their commitment to disarming the seduction of neoliberal ascension and individualism in favor of cultivating extended practices of care and more inclusive notions of family and collective responsibility. In figure 4.7, we see Oliver’s comic strip embedded within the larger comic world of Malinky Robot. “Hi-Life” features two construction workers on their lunch break, sitting on a beam high up in a skyscraper, evocative of Charles Clyde Ebbets’s famous photograph, Lunch atop a Skyscraper, shot at New York City’s Rockefeller Center in 1932. In both examples, the drama revolves around the precariousness of high-rise construction work. Without harnesses, the workers seem alarmingly casual about their safety. Unlike the Depression-era photo, though, the display of risk in Oliver’s version has not been staged by corporate interest to promote the building of another Rockefeller skyscraper. Neither is the uncertainty of a person’s future contained by a narrative about the importance of saving. Liew opts, instead, to stay with the awkwardness of uncertainty, as one of the workers admits that he spends all his money on alcohol. In Malinky Robot, a post–financial crash story, putting money in a savings or interest-bearing retirement account might actually be more foolish than squandering one’s earnings on the pleasure of daily drinking. The snippet demonstrates Liew’s purposive undercutting of the “good life” promise—a promise of better futures that the act of building skyscrapers would seem to deliver. However, in Malinky Robot technological inventions, whether in the form of skyscrapers or cantilevered bike gears, fail to deliver on their promises. Oliver’s “Hi-Life” points to the irrelevance of whether these workers invest in the future or not; it recasts the tale of opportunity as a farce for those whom capitalism has deemed disposable, replaceable, and ultimately without a future. Liew sabotages reproductive futurity in a similar comic within a comic that plays on the popular children’s magazine activity of spotting the difference. Whereas a smiling child secures the happiness of the family portrait in the first panel, a tombstone supplants the child in the second and shatters the sunny disposition of reproductive futurity. Shattered also is the very exercise of spotting differences. These images make no pretense to similitude; with starkly contrasting color palettes—the first is in bright, mostly primary, colors, and the second is in macabre gray scale—spotting their differences hardly requires practiced sleuthing or careful discernment of the normal from the aberrant. Refusing to engage the familiar, normative apparatus, Liew puts pressure on Highlights’s slogan “fun with a purpose.”45 Oliver’s morbid rendering of spotting differences interrogates and dramatically halts the instrumentalization of fun. The critique of instrumentalized fun stands in direct contrast to Oliver’s preference for “irrational exuberance” over edutainment’s developmental games, designed to put kids on the dubious cutting edge of competitively tracked educational systems governed by quantitative evaluation and techno-positivist entrepreneurs. In this way, Oliver’s “Spot the Difference” comic registers a complaint against what Lee Edelman has termed “reproductive futurism,”46 a holding up of the figure of the child as the naturalized site of political incitement. The fraught case of imagining who shall inherit future Singapore, though, charts how capitalist development and ecological sustainability hold the question of reproduction and futurity in tension. Whereas a pronatalist movement in the 1980s led to a baby-bonus program with financial incentives for couples considering having second or third children, 1999 (on the heels of the financial crash of 1997–98) marked the launch of Singapore’s international head-hunting program to recruit students and professionals primarily from India and China.47 In 2001, the baby-bonus program was reinstated, awarding mothers $4,000 for each of the first two children born and $6,000 for the next two. More recently, at Singapore’s 2008 National Day, Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong dedicated more than 5,000 words of his speech to discussing the falling birth rate.48 Singapore’s concern over its low birth rate—among the lowest in the world—was perhaps most overtly broadcast when a 2012 Mentos ad went viral, calling for a National Night wherein Singaporeans would enact their “civic duty” to make babies.49 Set to a song in which a male vocalist raps: “It’s National Night and I want a baby, boo, I know you want it, so duz the sdu,” the commercial refers to the Social Development Unit (renamed the Social Development Network), a governmental body devoted to addressing the low birth rate and housed under the broader reaching Ministry of Social and Family Development. That state development includes such calls to reproduction as civic duty situates Singaporean futurity not in the figure of the child, but in actual children. The Mentos commercial, in its unapologetic overture to heterosexual baby making, makes clear the connections between reproductive futurity and other speculative futures. National Night, according to the video, also means getting aroused by the potential of buying a $900 stroller and taking a stroll through the Gardens by the Bay park—a billion-dollar, 103-acre public construction project that even looks like a giant bubble of speculative financing with all the aesthetic trappings of speculative futurity. It is against these financial forms of irrational exuberance that Atari and Oliver’s flights of fancy and moments of ebullience stand in contrast. Nevertheless, the exuberance Liew captures in his vibrant, dynamic, and wiggling lines also distinguishes itself from the imaginary of austerity and responsibility, marshaled by discourses of personal finance.50 In another sidebar comic within a comic, Atari’s imagined superhero Doctor Midnight (Mr. Bon Bon in disguise) administers punishment to his foes even as he spouts after-school specials’ canned statements about health and fitness. With each pow! krak! bif! blow to the thugs who have come to claim the stolen bicycles, the doctor administers “medicine”: “floss after every meal!” “always wear your seat-belt!” and “Maintain an active lifestyle!” (60). Doctor Midnight’s recitation of sound-bites about selfimprovement and healthy living as civic virtue is decidedly ironic. For all of modern science’s promises of its beneficial effects on the population, these pledged benefits have passed over Oliver and Atari, who seem wholly unmoved by overtures to longevity and prosperity. As the sworn defender of street urchins, Doctor Midnight interrogates for whom these logics of prolonging life are designed. After dispatching his adversaries, he rebukes the thin assurances of better tomorrows: “Who builds the cities? By whose sweat, by whose blood?? And in return to ask nothing but a roof over their heads. . . . Seeking merely to manage from day to day . . . in these times of unending change . . . and in the bitter end to shuffle into the darkness of this mortal coil that binds us all. What is it that awaits us beyond that final frontier? What indignities, what sorrows? What semblance of this hell that we have already tasted on this cruel earth?” (61). The city of the future does not provide a roof over the heads of those who built it. Oliver and Atari “manage from day to day” by squatting in makeshift shelters either on rooftops or in abandoned “McDonnell’s” sites, making do with the materials of dilapidated futurity. Doctor Midnight’s closing monologue alludes to the oscillatory quality of Hamlet’s considerations “to be or not to be.” The allusion helps illuminate the relationship between life and futurity— “perchance to dream”—and insists on the importance of thinking of the future as contested and critical terrain. If they were to buy into the aspirations of upward mobility and the gleaming promises of Asian futurity, Oliver and Atari would partake in what Lauren Berlant has called “cruel optimism.” Berlant investigates “what happens to fantasies of the good life when the ordinary becomes a landfill for overwhelming and impending crises of life-building and expectation whose sheer volume so threatens what it has meant to ‘have a life’ that adjustment seems like an accomplishment.”51 In many ways, Malinky Robot sketches out in haunting beauty the condition of “living in crisis,”52 wherein we encounter Atari and Oliver negotiating “the impasse” of everyday crisis in their temporary shelters and tender socialities.53 In Atari and Oliver’s daily exploits, we find a sustained rumination on the caring relationship between two truant geeks who aspire “toward and beyond survival,” but in ways that move “toward an opening that does not involve rehabituation, the invention of new normativities, or working through and beyond trauma.”54 Rather than eschewing Asian futurity in the face of techno-Orientalism, Malinky Robot follows Berlant’s injunction “to imagine better economies of intimacy and labor.”55 Launched from within a “McDonnell’s” where Atari and Oliver have scored a free lunch from their friend Misha, this series of embedded comics, which include Misha’s story of the theft of Mr. Bon Bon’s intellectual property, Oliver’s Sunday funnies about joblessness and curtailed futures, and Atari’s Doctor Midnight superhero comic, allows incredible artistry and imaginative storytelling to unfurl against the backdrop of Super size french fries and the multinational reach of corporations like McDonald’s. As the friends return to their neighborhood on their borrowed bicycles, they run into Mr. Bon Bon, whose backstory they’ve just learned over lunch. In the closing full-page panel of “Bicycles,” we see Bon Bon crouch to inspect the cantilevered gear, the sign of all that could have been. But, as the ordinary hero, Mr. Bon Bon simply asks if the kids are hungry and suggests a new noodle place where they can eat, “his treat.” In the cruel world of foreclosed opportunities, where Mr. Bon Bon works construction even though his invention could have gained him access to a life of financial security and relative comfort, Liew’s story bears witness to the startling willingness to cultivate tender ties in precarious times. Malinky Robot posits an alternative to cruel optimism—call it a queer exuberance—that persists not only in the queer kinships Misha, Atari, Oliver, and Mr. Bon Bon form amid conditions of contingency and precarity, but also in Liew’s ekphrastic exercise that restores texture to Asian futurity when techno-Orientalism works to smooth over the vicissitudes of neoliberalism. As Singapore relies increasingly on temporary migrant workers, its flexible accumulation trades on the cruelly optimistic drive toward a good life and the promise of an Asian futurity that will never arrive for the vast majority of the workers who sustain the wealth of the few. Malinky Robot imagines otherwise.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Framework › FW---Cruel Optimism

Rational political speculations produce cruel optimism, where progress narratives create empty promises that maximize productivity while leaving real people on the margins. Instead, we turn to the anomalies of discourse, where our strange futurity opens the aperture beyond frameworks of the knowable to open space for survivability.

Bahng 17, Aimee Bahng is an American academic. She is a professor of gender and women's studies at Pomona College in Claremont, California. Her previous denial of tenure at Dartmouth College sparked widespread protests about discrimination against racial minorities in academia., (Aimee, “Epilogue: Speculation as Discourse, Speculation as Exuberance” in Migrant Futures: Decolonizing Speculation in Financial Times, Duke University Press) //CHC-DS 🐱‍👤

In an essay titled “The Rhetoric of Sex / The Discourse of Desire,” Samuel Delany examines one possible etymology for “discourse” that stems from the Latin word for an ancient Roman oval racetrack, where spectators stood on the inside of the track, while the runners raced around the encircled spectators. These Roman discourses, Delany notes, “were places of much betting . . . , the touting up of odds, and the endless speculative conversation on the merits of the racers characteristic today of horseracing tracks were a part of daily life at the discourse.”1 Building on Michel Foucault’s theorizations of discourse in Archaeology of Knowledge, Delany understands discourse as a structuring mechanism that not only “tells us what is central and what is peripheral,” but that also controls the entry and exit points of that facility.

Delany identifies the Roman discourse as an archaeology of knowledge that is simultaneously a primal scene for speculation. Discourse in this example presents itself as a mostly closed system that facilitates gambling by providing the conditions of manageable uncertainty without throwing itself over to chaos. The runners ostensibly never leave the track. What would happen, though, if they did? Like Foucault, Delany takes more interest in the multiplicity of discourses, discursive practices, and their relationships to the anomaly—that which falls beyond the purview of the discourse. For him, paying attention to the “anomalous and nonserious” discards of discourse reveals the exclusionary structuring mechanisms of the discourse itself.2 Delany moves through these thoughts on discourse to arrive at his perhaps better known set of formulations on paraliterature, which includes speculative fiction and all sorts of other “anomalous and nonserious” forms of writing. And as Delany points out, “‘anomalous and nonserious’ is how the accomplishments of women, whether in the arts or in the world, were judged. And the writings of blacks in this country were, until very recently, considered even more of an accident.”

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Case › AT: Cap Good---Temporalities

Capitalism produces racialized temporalities in which Chinese labor is banished into abstractness, alienated from disguised social relations behind the products of human labor.

Day 16, Iyko Day is Associate Professor of English and Critical Social Thought at Mount Holyoke College and Faculty Member in the Five College Asian/Pacific/American Studies Program., (Iyko, “Sex, Time, and the Transcontinental Railroad: Abstract Labor and the Queer Temporalities of History 2” in Alien Capital: Asian Racialization and the Logic of Settler Colonial Capitalism, Duke University Press) //CHC-DS 🐱‍👤

By aligning Chinese bodies with abstract labor, their labor represents human labor in the abstract. It is this phantomlike objectivity of alien labor that establishes a commodity’s value. White bodies, on the other hand, are symbolically associated with concrete labor, which establishes a commodity’s quality.

Such a racial bifurcation of abstract and concrete labor is the work of the commodity fetish, which disguises the social relations behind the products of human labor. In terms of this book’s overarching claim, I argue that a key anchor of North American settler colonialism is an ideology of romantic anticapitalism that reifies a distinction between concrete and abstract social relations out of a misunderstanding of the dialectical nature of capitalism. Romantic anticapitalism hypostatizes the concrete, rooted, and pure, on one hand, and identifies capitalism solely with the abstract dimension of social relations, on the other. It glorifies what it sees as the concrete realm of social relations: white labor, the family, and the train itself—a machine whose concreteness is biologized as the “iron horse.” Alternatively, Chinese bodies are in nearly exclusive alignment with quasi-mechanized labor temporality, excluded from normative social and domestic temporalities. Once Chinese labor is no longer needed, romantic anticapitalism performs an aesthetic function by giving Chinese shape to the unrepresentable: giving bodily form to the abstract, temporal domination of capitalism. In this sense, Chinese labor allegorizes the commensurating function of abstract labor that propels capitalism forward. However, as Chakrabarty notes, for Marx the universal category of abstract labor serves two functions: “It is both a description and a critique of capital.”18 Following a Queer Marxist approach, this chapter will explore how abstract labor can pose such a critique.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Case › Advocacy---Virtuality

Racial discrimination has seeped into the incorporeal – only by blurring the lines between the virtual and the material can we adapt to and disrupt our representations.

Roh et al. 15, David Roh is Professor of English at the University of Utah. He holds a BA in English from the University of California, Los Angeles, an Ed.M in Educational Technology from Harvard University, and an MA and Ph.D in English from the University of California, Santa Barbara. He is author of Minor Transpacific: Triangulating American, Japanese, and Korean Fictions (Stanford University Press, 2021), Illegal Literature (University of Minnesota Press, 2015), and coeditor of Techno-Orientalism (Rutgers University Press, 2015). His work has appeared in Law & Literature, MELUS, Journal of Narrative Theory, and Verge., (“Chapter 10: Thinking about Bodies, Souls, and Race in Gibson’s Bridge Trilogy”, Techno-Orientalism: Imagining Asia in Speculative Fiction, History, and Media, Rutgers University Press) //CHC-DS 🐱‍👤

In the 1990s both popular culture and academic theorists promised freedom from the constraints of race, gender, sexual preference, and class via the Internet. This optimism was short-lived: in the twenty-first century, we know that bodies matter and that narratives about virtual disembodiment or equality often depend upon the very racial or gendered stereotypes that they purport to be eradicating.3 Technoculture studies scholar Lisa Nakamura sets up a key question about race and the Internet: “Can the Internet propagate genuinely new and nonracist (and nonsexist and nonclassist) ways of being,” or is “online discourse . . . woven of stereotypical cultural narratives that reinstall [the] conditions of gender, race, and class as conditions of social interaction?” (Digitizing Race xii). Gibson’s Bridge trilogy investigates this very problem, ultimately demonstrating that discourses of race, gender, and class are reliant on the binary opposition between physical and virtual, as well as interiority and exteriority. Gibson destabilizes these easy binary distinctions through the creation of an alternative space, Walled City, and a character, Rei Toei, who is both real and virtual.

In the future universe of Gibson’s trilogy, the Internet has become as highly regulated and policed as actual physical spaces. In reaction to this, radicals create a digital city located outside of the restrictions of the mainstream Internet: Walled City has “no laws . . . just agreements,” and therefore houses an eclectic population who have founded a new space outside of, and resistant to, the dominant digital culture (Idoru 209). As Masahiko puts it, it is “of the Net, but not on it.” Gibson’s “Walled City” much resembles the “City of Bits” described by the late William J. Mitchell, who was dean of the school of architecture at MIT and a prescient urban and media theorist: “This will be a city unrooted to any definite spot on the surface of the earth, shaped by connectivity and bandwidth constraints rather than by accessibility and land values, largely asynchronous in its operation, and inhabited by disembodied and fragmented subjects who exist as collections of aliases and agents. Its places will be constructed virtually by software instead of physically from stones and timbers, and they will be connected by logical linkages rather than by doors, passageways, and streets” (William J. Mitchell 24).4 The emphasis on virtual “logical linkages” over physical barriers like “doors and passageways” suggests that the virtual city does not share the same social inequities that are represented by the architectural enclosures of material cities, meant to keep locals in and invaders out. At the same time, it would be inaccurate to maintain that Gibson’s Walled City is “unrooted to any definite spot . . . on earth” because we learn that Walled City is a reproduction of the real city of Kowloon (also known as Kowloon Walled City). A largely ungoverned settlement in Hong Kong, when it was a British colony, Kowloon functioned as an autonomous zone that had been without laws or police because of a mistake in the possession agreement with China. As described in Gibson’s novel Idoru, it was a tiny space but extremely densely populated, which housed “drugs and whores and gambling. But people living, too. Factories, restaurants. A city. No laws” (221).

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Case › Advocacy---Virtuality

Narrative imaginations of identity at the edge of the virtual, seeping between the virtual and the real, are where affective potential is unlocked. Only by engaging the virtual can we understand emergence and utilize its triggerings of change.

Song 12, University of California Riverside, (Mary, Cyborg Dreams in Asian American Transnationality: Transgression, Myth, Simulation, Coalition, University of California Riverside, ) //CHC-DS 🐱‍👤

The connection between identity simulation and virtual narrative can be found in Hayles’s comment on literature as simulation in her text, My Mother Was a Computer: Digital Subjects and Literary Texts: “…literature functions more like simulations than do other discursive forms, because like computer simulations such as Karl Sims’s “Evolved Virtual Creatures”, literary texts create imaginary worlds populated by creatures that we can (mis)take for beings like ourselves. (Hayles 6) Likening literature with computer simulations, Hayles points out how narratives can create creatures that we mistake for ourselves – and is this not identity? Additionally, Massumi correlates the vital role that imagination plays in the world of virtuality when he states: “Imagination is the mode of thought most precisely suited to the differentiating vagueness of the virtual.” (Massumi 134) For Massumi, imagination is key because it sparks virtuality; virtuality is key because it triggers emergence: “Concepts of the virtual in itself are important only to the extent to which they contribute to a pragmatic understanding of emergence, to the extent to which they enable triggerings of change (induce the new). It is the edge of virtual, where it leaks into actual, that counts. For that seeping edge is where potential, actually, is found.” (Massumi 43) Massumi limns the boundary that lies between the virtual and the actual as the locus where emergence occurs. It is this locus where Choi’s narrative simulates identity. American Woman is a narrative wrought from the paradigm of actuality to create a virtual narrative that leaks into our personal consciousness as political awareness.

The affective power behind this sort of virtual narrative lies in our apprehension of what we already know and what we desire to discover. Choi clearly founds much of her narrative on the easily-recognized media coverage of the Patty Hearst case. But instead of narrating a non-fictional account that would replicate the U.S. media coverage of the privileged “American princess”, Choi rejects this paradigm for one that favors the barely known Asian American woman known to have accompanied Hearst in their final year in hiding, Wendy Yoshimura. Thus, despite her choice to use the Patty Hearst case as a platform for her narrative, Choi places her Japanese American protagonist, Jenny Shimada, center stage. In a way, Choi bait-and-switches her readers by packaging a story about an American princess – someone we visualize to be white and privileged – and instead offers us the unheard story of someone who is neither white nor privileged. Subsequently, Choi’s title to her novel patently points to her own bait-and-switch narrative tactic. What we are left to wonder is how much of this story is “true” and/or “authentic”?

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Case › Advocacy---Sinofuturism

Thus, we embrace Sinofuturism. In the cybernetic age, our criminal cyber-exoticism outlines a darkside cartography of the East that resituates our temporal imaginaries towards Asian knowledge in the face of Western anxiety. While they tie us to the past, we soar into the future.

De Seta 20, Gabriele de Seta is a digital anthropologist and sociologist specialising in everyday digital culture in the Chinese speaking world, and known for his contributions to digital ethnographic methodology. He works at the University of Bergen., (Gabriele, “Sinofuturism as Inverse Orientalism: China’s Future and the Denial of Coevalness”, SFRA Review, vol. 50, no. 2-3, ) //CHC-DS 🐱‍👤

The earliest documented use of the term is to be found in ‘Fei ch'ien rinse out: Sino-futurist under-currency’, an essay written in 2003 by musician and cultural theorist Steve Goodman. Drawing on the tactics of Afrofuturism, Goodman combines references to Chinese philosophical traditions, organized crime syndicates, and underground trading networks with the rise of cybernetics and computing technology, outlining “a darkside cartography of the turbulent rise of East Asia”. This sinofuturist imaginary emphasizes the deleuzoguattarian “co-stratification” of East and West (Goodman), which is epitomized by the convergence of communication technologies and global capital. Goodman orbited around the Cybernetic Culture Research Unit (CCRU), a Warwick-based collective experimenting at the nexus of underground cultures and philosophical speculation around the turn of the millennium, and inklings of sinofuturism can be found in writings by central members of this group. Most notably, Nick Land’s 1994 essay ‘Meltdown’ contains the ur-sinofuturist aphorism “Neo-China arrives from the future” (Land), and Sadie Plant’s book Zeros + Ones is steeped in Asia-futurist intuitions:

Five hundred years of modernity fades when the weaving of bamboo mats converges with the manufacture of computer games in the streets of Bangkok, Taipei, and Shanghai. The silicon links were already there. (253)

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Case › Advocacy---Sawayama

Our performativity hacks symbolic currencies that undergird gendered racial formations. In our overidentification with cybernetic being, we produce unintelligibility that scrambles binary racial and gendered codes and form new modes of sociality and self-empowerment.

Kouch and Wang 18, *June Kuoch is a queer and trans Southeast Asian American. They are a senior at the University of Minnesota majoring in Sociology with a focus in policy analysis and minoring in Asian American Studies, Gender Women and Sexuality Studies, and Comparative Race and Ethnicity in the United States. Kuoch is a local community organizer focusing on abolition through a queer and trans of color lens. Their work has been inspired the activist Yuri Kochiyama. Their current research focuses on haunting brought by United States empire building as it intersects with critical refugee studies, Asian American studies, critical archival studies, and queer of color critic. **Allegro Wang is a queer, trans Chinese-American and an undergraduate at the University of Minnesota. They are currently a sophomore in the U of MN’s College of Science and Engineering and double-majoring in Computer Sciences and Gender, Women’s, and Sexuality Studies. Allegro’s primary area of interest in research is in how technology emerges as a site of both subjugation and resistance in its intersection with whiteness, queerness, and transness., (June and Allegro, “Cyber Fantasies: Rina Sawayama, Asian Feminism, and TechnoOrientalism in the Age of Neoliberalism” in Sprinkle: An Undergraduate Journal of Feminist and Queer Studies, Vol. 11, ) //CHC-DS 🐱‍👤

Sawayama’s music videos, futuristic aesthetic, and lyricism deconstructs the West’s normalization of Asian women’s subservience. In “Cyber Stockholm Syndrome,” she sings about her personal relationship with technology as a site of solidarity and support, specifically singing, “Came here on my own / But I start to feel alone / Better late than never so I'll be alright / Happiest whenever I'm with you online” (Sawayama, 2017). Here, she also demonstrates how she found an escape from white supremacy through music and the cyber world. Specifically, this song was a project of catharsis to escape whiteness in a different world (Clarke, 2017; Myers, 2017). This production confronts how the cyber realm is traditionally encoded as a sphere of white men’s power as they control narratives of development, innovation, and technological “progress,” establishing technocratic, intangible spaces of dominance. Sawayama’s performativity thus becomes a means to subvert or “hack” the gendered racial formation forced upon Asian women. Hacking, here, “offers an eccentric mode of expression, a means to rupture[...]symbolic currencies and tendencies[...]which can be then decoded or scrambled” (Bui, 2014). Sawayama’s “hacking” of techno-Orientalism is a process of unintelligibility that creates new modes of sociality in that her performance deconstructs Western norms imposed on Asian women. This emerges as people are unable to auditorily grasp and categorize her music. Hacking is produced from her sense of hybridity. She hacks the dragon lady/lotus blossom binary imposed on Asian women. She hacks the West/East binary via the production of diaspora.

In A Cyborg Manifesto, Donna Haraway (1991) expands upon how technology can be utilized as a means of subversion writing, “coded texts through which we engage in the play of writing and reading the world” (p. 152). For Haraway, the cyborg exists in the liminal space between human and technology, which is similar to the configuration of Asians in a techno-Orientalist framework (Haraway, 1991; Roh et al, 2015). Here, the cyborg disturbs a Western understanding of what does/does not constitute the human self by disrupting normative forms of embodiment, subjectivity, and sociality (Haraway, 1991).

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Case › Advocacy---Identity Politics

Centering debates on the Asian American subjectivity breaks new imaginative grounds that are illegible in the US national discourse that systematically excludes the Asian identity.

Song 12, University of California Riverside, (Mary, Cyborg Dreams in Asian American Transnationality: Transgression, Myth, Simulation, Coalition, University of California Riverside, ) //CHC-DS 🐱‍👤

In Imagine Otherwise, Kandice Chuh recognizes the critical cogency for Asian American studies to consider postmodern insights about the limitations of representation: “Asian American studies may be seen as a formation of the critical landscape configured by a (poststructural) problematization of referentiality, which facilitates the (postmodern) jettisoning of the authority of the meta-narrative.” (Chuh 5)2 However, not only does Chuh suggest a need for a critical postmodern lens, she asserts that Asian American subjectivity is a particularly productive space to explore evolving notions of referentiality and multiplicity. She observes how Asian American subjects are racially-marked bodies that exceed the nation-state circumscriptions of the abstracted citizen through their ability to traverse boundaries both geographical and ideological:

I suggest that it is precisely because U.S. nationalism has constituted “Asian America” as a transnational identity that it has power as an analytic in exposing the failures of the U.S. nation-state’s promises of universal equality. …. In this manner, transnationalism might be seen as a discourse that advances investigations of the technologies of race and U.S. national identity formation, or perhaps more pointedly, the technology of race as a technology of U.S. national identity. (Chuh 60-1)

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Case › Advocacy---Feminist Post-Cyberpunk

We adopt feminist post-cyberpunk as a means to disrupt White male desire.

Roh et al. 15, David Roh is Professor of English at the University of Utah. He holds a BA in English from the University of California, Los Angeles, an Ed.M in Educational Technology from Harvard University, and an MA and Ph.D in English from the University of California, Santa Barbara. He is author of Minor Transpacific: Triangulating American, Japanese, and Korean Fictions (Stanford University Press, 2021), Illegal Literature (University of Minnesota Press, 2015), and coeditor of Techno-Orientalism (Rutgers University Press, 2015). His work has appeared in Law & Literature, MELUS, Journal of Narrative Theory, and Verge., (“Chapter 11: Reimagining Asian Women in Feminist Post-­Cyberpunk Science Fiction”, Techno-Orientalism: Imagining Asia in Speculative Fiction, History, and Media, Rutgers University Press) //CHC-DS 🐱‍👤

Much has been written about cyberpunk’s depiction of the gendered, sexualized, and, to a lesser extent, raced body. Wendy Hui Kyong Chun, in “Race and Software,” points out the use of “high-tech orientalism” in “foundational cyberpunk previsions, from William Gibson’s 1984 Neuromancer to Neal Stephenson’s 1993 Snow Crash, [that] use ‘Asian,’ ‘African,’ and ‘half-breed’ characters to create seductively dystopian near futures” (306). The “high-tech orientalism” of which Chun writes has often been located in female bodies. While the female characters in classic cyberpunk are imbued with high-tech gadgetry—like Neuromancer’s Molly’s mirror shades and nail blades—they are also “Orientalized,” rendered as “meat” and objects of white, Western male desire. Chun argues that, as a way to know and make the Other accessible and open to the user/reader, “high-tech orientalism offers the pleasure of exploring, the pleasure of being somewhat overwhelmed but ultimately ‘jackedin’” (306–307). In this chapter, I take up two feminist revisions of technoOrientalist cyberpunk tropes (the “pleasure” and real-world consequences of technological exploration) in Tricia Sullivan’s Maul (first published in 2003) and Larissa Lai’s Salt Fish Girl (first published in 2002).

Feminist Post-cyberpunk and the Raced Body

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Case › Advocacy---Diaspora

Thus, we engage the Asiatic Diaspora in a methodological praxis of refusal. Through diasporic melancholia, insurgent memories and counterknowledge, we find space for productive refusal against the Western hegemonic gaze that empowers transnational Asian solidarity.

Kouch and Wang 18, *June Kuoch is a queer and trans Southeast Asian American. They are a senior at the University of Minnesota majoring in Sociology with a focus in policy analysis and minoring in Asian American Studies, Gender Women and Sexuality Studies, and Comparative Race and Ethnicity in the United States. Kuoch is a local community organizer focusing on abolition through a queer and trans of color lens. Their work has been inspired the activist Yuri Kochiyama. Their current research focuses on haunting brought by United States empire building as it intersects with critical refugee studies, Asian American studies, critical archival studies, and queer of color critic. **Allegro Wang is a queer, trans Chinese-American and an undergraduate at the University of Minnesota. They are currently a sophomore in the U of MN’s College of Science and Engineering and double-majoring in Computer Sciences and Gender, Women’s, and Sexuality Studies. Allegro’s primary area of interest in research is in how technology emerges as a site of both subjugation and resistance in its intersection with whiteness, queerness, and transness., (June and Allegro, “Cyber Fantasies: Rina Sawayama, Asian Feminism, and TechnoOrientalism in the Age of Neoliberalism” in Sprinkle: An Undergraduate Journal of Feminist and Queer Studies, Vol. 11, ) //CHC-DS 🐱‍👤

Kim (2010) articulates a methodological praxis to challenge these systems of domination through her theorization of Asian American cultural production:

Asian American culture as also engaging in a politics of refusal. In refusing the seductive will to total knowledge or revelation of the “truth” of the “Asian American experience,” what it means to be Asian American, or what the United States “really did” in Asia during the Cold War, Asian American culture enact what in anthropological term has been called “ethnographic refusal” (Kim, 2010, p. 6)

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Case › Advocacy---Cyborg Politics

Thus, we endorse cyborg politics, the illegitimate offspring of militarism and capitalism that embraces illegibility in the metaphoric Asian American cyborg. By expressing the lived modes of racialized bodies, we reframe politics towards new affective connections that subvert systemic violence.

Song 12, University of California Riverside, (Mary, Cyborg Dreams in Asian American Transnationality: Transgression, Myth, Simulation, Coalition, University of California Riverside, ) //CHC-DS 🐱‍👤

A particularly salient feature of Haraway’s cyborg politics is its Althusserian ethos to recognize the mythology of identity from both sides of the ideological coin: myth-making on the part of the nation-state as grand narratives as well as myth-making on the part of the individual in how we desire to be hailed within those grand narratives. In her manifesto, she states: “The boundary is permeable between tool and myth, instrument and concept, historical systems of social relations and historical anatomies of possible bodies, including objects of knowledge. Indeed, myth and tool mutually constitute each other.” (Haraway 165) In order to deploy critical studies as the “tool” by which we seek sociopolitical equity, Haraway asserts that we are inseparable from the “historical systems of social relations” that we seek to recalibrate. Cyborg politics does not allow hegemonic constructs to be wholly responsible for the obstructions to a more just and equitable society. Rather, it demands that we fully acknowledge how all participate in the coalescing of power: “Innocence, and the corollary insistence on victimhood as the only ground for insight, has done enough damage.” (Haraway 158) Even the disenfranchised constitute the organization of hegemony ! if that were not so, centralized power could not exist. In other words, Asian American subjectivity is just as much constructed by Asian Americans in that we are also participating in the racialization of the Asian American body. If the nation-state has historically sought to corporealize the Asian American body in order to disenfranchise it from dominant white culture, striving to substantiate the racialized Asian American body does not mitigate the centralizing power of dominant white culture.

Kandice Chuh addresses the paradox of identity and ideology in that the Asian American body is just as effectively decorporealized in the name of the abstracted universal citizen as it is celebrated in national multiculturalism. Yet, she points out, the nation-state ultimately remains firmly invested in the ideology of a subject in that “As the uniquely authorized discourse of the nation, and in contrast to the postulation of the modern are that subjects (to monarchal power) have transformed into consensual citizens (of a nation-state), law requires subjection/ subjectification. [my emphases].” (Chuh 10) Subsequently, what Chuh proposes is an Asian American “subjectless” discourse. In line with Haraway’s idea of transgressing the boundary between myth and reality, Chuh proposes that we recognize the mythology that surrounds the Asian American subject as constructed by the U.S. nation-state. Moreover, Chuh aks us to recognize our own mythmaking participation in the construction of this Asian American subject: “Recognition of the subject as epistemological object cautions against failing endlessly to put into question both “Asian American” as the subject/ object of Asian Americanist discourse and of U.S. nationalist ideology, and Asian American studies as the subject/ object of dominant paradigms of the U.S. university. (Chuh 10)

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Case › Advocacy---Asian Gamer Death

The death of the Asian gamer ruptures Western fantasies of virtual escapism and challenges the sacredness of life and leisure in capitalism. Don’t deny death.

Roh et al. 15, David Roh is Professor of English at the University of Utah. He holds a BA in English from the University of California, Los Angeles, an Ed.M in Educational Technology from Harvard University, and an MA and Ph.D in English from the University of California, Santa Barbara. He is author of Minor Transpacific: Triangulating American, Japanese, and Korean Fictions (Stanford University Press, 2021), Illegal Literature (University of Minnesota Press, 2015), and coeditor of Techno-Orientalism (Rutgers University Press, 2015). His work has appeared in Law & Literature, MELUS, Journal of Narrative Theory, and Verge., (“Chapter 8: Never Stop Playing”, Techno-Orientalism: Imagining Asia in Speculative Fiction, History, and Media, Rutgers University Press) //CHC-DS 🐱‍👤

In this essay, we show how the Asian gamer may be understood within the discursive powers of techno-Orientalism that make the Asian Other knowable and controllable. This understanding reveals Western fantasies of virtual escapism, while the death of the Asian gamer ruptures precisely these fantasies—of never working while video gaming constantly, and of eternal life without death. In order to put forward this argument, we will look closely at the popular sci-fi RTS game StarCraft, released in 1998, and the cultural trends surrounding it. Our reading of StarCraft gestures toward attitudes around video gaming that do not celebrate playing without end, while challenging the sacredness of life and guaranteed leisure time in capitalism.

The first reported instance of online gamer death in Asia was in October 2002, when twenty-four-year-old Kim Kyung-jae played nonstop for eightysix hours until he collapsed and died in an Internet café in Kwangju, South Korea (Gluck). Just ten days later, Lien Wen-cheng died in a café in Fengyuan, Taiwan. The twenty-seven-year-old had been playing for thirty-two hours straight; he was found in the restroom bleeding from the nose and foaming at the mouth (Farrell). On August 5, 2005, Lee Seungseob went into cardiac arrest following a fifty-hour marathon session of StarCraft in Taegu, South Korea (Zimbardo). According to the psychiatrist at the hospital where Lee was taken, he had neglected to eat and sleep while playing. In 2005, Xinhua Online reported that a young woman, identified only as “Snowly,” died after playing World of Warcraft “for several continuous days during the national day holiday.” An online, in-game funeral was held in her memory by fellow gamers (“Death of Net Addict”). A twenty-six-year-old man identified only by his surname “Zhang” died in the Liaoning province of China on February 24, 2007. During the Spring Festival, Zhang had spent most of the seven-day holiday playing online computer games (Yong Wu). Also in 2007, a thirty-year-old man died of exhaustion after gaming for three days straight in Guangzhou, China (“Chinese Man Drops Dead”). On December 27, 2010, a nineteen-yearold college student, identified by his surname “Moon,” collapsed in a café in Ulsan, South Korea, after playing first-person shooter (FPS) games for twelve hours (Cho). A thirty-year-old man died in a cybercafé outside of Beijing, China, on February 22, 2011, after playing online games for three days (Goswami).